$1$/,6,6'$<$+$6,//$7(.6'$1+(5,7$%,/,7$6.$5$.7(5
.8$17,7$7,)'$5,%(%(5$3$*(127,3(.$5(733
/DWH[<LHOG3RWHQWLDO$QDO\VLVDQG+HULWDELOLW\RI4XDQWLWDWLYH&KDUDFWHUVRI 6RPH5XEEHU*HQRW\SHV33 6$<85$1', 'HVWD:,51$6 GDQ6HNDU:2(/$1 %DODL3HQHOLWLDQ6XQJHL3XWLK3XVDW3HQHOLWLDQ.DUHW 32%R[0HGDQ6XPDWHUD8WDUD (PDLOVD\XUDQGLBVS#\DKRRFRP 3URJUDP6WXGL$JURQRPLGDQ+RUWLNXOWXUD)DNXOWDV3HUWDQLDQ,QVWLWXW3HUWDQLDQ%RJRU -DODQ0HUDQWL1R.DPSXV,3%'UDPDJD%RJRU-DZD%DUDW 3XVDW3HQHOLWLDQ.DUHW -DODQ6DODN1RPRU%RJRU-DZD%DUDW 'LWHULPD$SULO'LUHYLVL-XQL'LVHWXMXL$JXVWXV $EVWUDFW 7KHREMHFWLYHVRIWKHUHVHDUFKZHUHWR VWXG\ JURZWK FKDUDFWHUV ODWH[ \LHOG DQG KHULWDELOLW\RITXDQWLWDWLYHFKDUDFWHUVRIVRPH UXEEHU JHQRW\SHV 33 $ERXW ILIWHHQ UXEEHUJHQRW\SHVDQGWZRFRQWUROFORQHV RI 3% DQG 55,& ZHUH WHVWHG LQ WKLV UHVHDUFK7KHJHQRW\SHVWULDOZDVFRQGXFWHG LQDW([SHULPHQWDO*DUGHQ6XQJHL3XWLK 5HVHDUFK 6WDWLRQ ,QGRQHVLDQ 5XEEHU 5HVHDUFK,QVWLWXWHZKLFKLVLQ 'HOL6HUGDQJ 'LVWULFW 1RUWK 6XPDWHUD 3URYLQFH 7KH H[SHULPHQWDO GHVLJQ XVHG 5DQGRPL]HG &RPSOHWHO\ 'HVLJQ 5&' ZLWK WKUHH UHSOLFDWLRQV 7KH UHVHDUFK UHVXOWV VKRZHG WKDWWKHJHQRW\SHVKDGVLJQLILFDQWO\GLIIHUHQW LQ WZHOYH REVHUYHG FKDUDFWHUV QDPHG JLUWK EDUNWKLFNQHVVQXPEHURIODWH[YHVVHOULQJV GLDPHWHU RI ODWH[ YHVVHO FHOOV OHQJWK RI WDSSLQJSDQHOODWH[IORZUDWHSOXJJLQJLQGH[ DQRUJDQLF SKRVSKDWH FRQWHQW VXFURVH FRQWHQWWKLROFRQWHQWGU\UXEEHUFRQWHQWDQG ODWH[ \LHOG SRWHQWLDO %DVHG RQ JURZWK FKDUDFWHUVDQGODWH[\LHOGSRWHQWLDOLWVKRZHG WKDWJHQRW\SH+3KDGKLJKODWH[\LHOG ZKLOH JHQRW\SH +3 KDG KLJK ODWH[ \LHOG DQG YLJRURXV JURZWK 7KH WZHOYH FKDUDFWHUV ZKLFK ZHUH REVHUYHG KDG KLJK
KHULWDELOLW\ ZLWK K EV YDOXH EHWZHHQ ² ,WVKRZHGWKDWWKHFKDUDFWHUVZHUHPRUH LQIOXHQFHGE\JHQHWLFIDFWRU
.H\ZRUGV +HYHD EUDVLOLHQVLV ODWH[ \LHOG S R W H Q W L D O K H U L W D E L O L W \ TXDQWLWDWLYHFKDUDFWHUV
$EVWUDN
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
WLQJJLGHQJDQQLODLK EVDQWDUD² +DO LQL PHQXQMXNNDQ EDKZD NDUDNWHU NDUDNWHU WHUVHEXW OHELK GLSHQJDUXKL ROHK IDNWRUJHQHWLN
.DWD NXQFL+HYHD EUDVLOLHQVLV GD\D KDVLO ODWHNV KHULWDELOLWDV NDUDNWHU NXDQWLWDWLI
3(1'$+8/8$1
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
6DODK VDWX XSD\D \DQJ GDSDW GLODNXNDQXQWXNPHQFDSDLWDUJHWSURGXNVL QDVLRQDO DGDODK GHQJDQ PHQ\HEDUOXDVNDQ NORQNORQ NDUHW XQJJXO NH EHUEDJDL GDHUDK VHQWUDSHUNHEXQDQNDUHW.ORQNDUHWXQJJXO PHQMDGL VDODK VDWX NRPSRQHQ WHNQRORJL WHUSHQWLQJ XQWXN PHQGXNXQJ NLQHUMD GDQ NHVLQDPEXQJDQ LQGXVWUL SHUNDUHWDQ QDVLRQDO \DQJ HILVLHQ GDQ EHUGD\D VDLQJ WLQJJL3HQDQDPDQNORQXQJJXOGLEHUEDJDL SHUNHEXQDQ EHVDU VHFDUD Q\DWD WHODK PHQLQJNDWNDQ SURGXNWLYLWDV NHEXQ VHUWD HILVLHQVL XVDKD WDQL NDUHW $LGL'DVOLQ
6D\XUDQGL 3DVDULEX
.HJLDWDQ SHPXOLDDQ NDUHW GL ,QGRQHVLDWHODKPHQJKDVLONDQEHUEDJDLNORQ NDUHW XQJJXO GHQJDQ SRWHQVL SURGXNWLYLWDV NDUHW \DQJ GLKDVLONDQ PHQFDSDL OLPD NDOL OHELK WLQJJL GLEDQGLQJNDQ GHQJDQ WDQDPDQ NDUHW DVDO ELELW VHPDLDQ :RHODQ .ORQ NDUHW DQMXUDQ VNDOD NRPHUVLDO VHSHUWL 3%3%3%55,&%30 ,55 GDQ ,55 WHODK EDQ\DN
GLNHPEDQJNDQ GL EHUEDJDL SHUNHEXQDQ EHVDU GDQ UDN\DW GHQJDQ SURGXNWLYLWDV DNWXDOQ\D GDSDW PHQFDSDL NJ+DWK $LGL'DVOLQ HW DO $LGL 'DVOLQ
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
E D Q \ D N J H Q \ D Q J P D V L Q J P D V L Q J
PHPSXQ\DLSHQJDUXKNHFLOVHKLQJJDPXGDK GLSHQJDUXKL ROHK OLQJNXQJDQ .DUDNWHU NXDQWLWDWLI PHPLOLNL VHEDUDQ NRQWLQ\X GDQ GDSDW GLXNXU .DMLDQ WHUKDGDS NDUDNWHU NXDQWLWDWLI VDQJDW EHUPDQIDDW XQWXN PHQ\HOHNVL NORQ NDUHW XQJJXO KDUDSDQ WHUXWDPD SDGD NDUDNWHUNDUDNWHU \DQJ PHPLOLNL QLODL KHULWDELOLWDV WLQJJL 6\XNXU 6XMLSULKDWL <XQLDQWL3HQHOLWLDQLQL EHUWXMXDQ XQWXN PHPSHODMDUL NDUDNWHU SHUWXPEXKDQKDVLOODWHNVGDQKHULWDELOLWDV EHEHUDSD NDUDNWHU NXDQWLWDWLI SDGD EHEHUDSDJHQRWLSHNDUHW33
%$+$1'$10(72'(
3HQJXMLDQ SORW SURPRVL GDUL OLPD EHODVJHQRWLSHNDUHWKDUDSDQGDQGXDNORQ SHPEDQGLQJ3%GDQ55,&GLEDQJXQ GL.HEXQ3HUFREDDQ%DODL3HQHOLWLDQ6XQJHL 3XWLK 3XVDW 3HQHOLWLDQ .DUHW SDGD WDKXQ .DEXSDWHQ 'HOL 6HUGDQJ 3URYLQVL 6XPDWHUD 8WDUD \DQJ WHUOHWDN SDGD NHWLQJJLDQ P GL DWDV SHUPXNDDQ ODXW
R
GSO GDQ EHUDGD SDGD SRVLVL DUDK XWDUD NKDWXOLVWLZD .ODVLILNDVL MHQLV WDQDK GLJRORQJNDQNHGDODPWDQDKXOWLVRO-XPODK UDWDUDWD FXUDKKXMDQSDGDVHSXOXKWDKXQ WHUDNKLU DGDODK PP 3HQHOLWLDQ GLODNVDQDNDQ SDGD EXODQ $JXVWXV ² 'HVHPEHU 0DWHUL JHQHWLN \DQJ GLJXQDNDQ SDGD SHQJXMLDQ SORW SURPRVL 33WHUGLUL GDULJHQRWLSHKDUDSDQ \DLWX +3+3+3 +3 +3 +3 +3 +3+3+3 +3 +3 +3 +3 +3 GDQ GXD NORQ SHPEDQGLQJ \DLWX NORQ 3% GDQ 55,& 3 H Q H O L W L D Q G L V X V X Q G H Q J D Q PHQJJXQDNDQ 5DQFDQJDQ $FDN /HQJNDS 5$/ GHQJDQ WLJD XODQJDQ 0DVLQJPDVLQJ JHQRWLSH WHUGLUL GDUL HQDP SXOXK WDQDPDQ \DQJGLEDJLPHQMDGLWLJDVDWXDQSHUFREDDQ GDQVHWLDSVDWXDQSHUFREDDQWHUGLULGDULGXD SXOXK WDQDPDQ -DUDN WDQDP \DQJ GLJXQDNDQ\DLWXP[P 3DUDPHWHU \DQJ GLDPDWL SDGD VDDW WDQDPDQ PHQJKDVLONDQ 70 EHUXPXU WDKXQ PHOLSXWL OLOLW EDWDQJ WDQDPDQ WHEDO NXOLW MXPODK FLQFLQ SHPEXOXK ODWHNV GLDPHWHU VHO SHPEXOXK ODWHNV SDQMDQJ DOXU VDGDS NHFHSDWDQ DOLUDQ ODWHNV LQGHNV SHQ\XPEDWDQ NDGDU IRVIDWDQRUJDQLNNDGDUVXNURVDNDGDU
WKLRO NDGDU NDUHW NHULQJ GDQ KDVLO ODWHNV6LVWHPVDGDS\DQJGLJXQDNDQ\DLWX VLVWHP VDGDS 6 G 'DODP SHQHOLWLDQ LQL GLODNXNDQDQDOLVLVGDWDKDVLOODWHNVGDUL70 VDPSDL GHQJDQ 70 'DWD LQL GLSHUROHK GDUL SHQJDPDWDQ \DQJ WHODK GLODNXNDQ VHEHOXPQ\D
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
7DEHO PHQXQMXNNDQ EDKZD JHQRWLSH +3 GDQ +3 PHPLOLNL SHUWXPEXKDQ OLOLW EDWDQJ SDOLQJ WLQJJL XPXUWDKXQ\DLWXPDVLQJPDVLQJ VHEHVDUFPGDQFPVHGDQJNDQ JHQRWLSH +3 GDQ +3 PHPLOLNL SHUWXPEXKDQ OLOLW EDWDQJ SDOLQJ UHQGDK\DLWXPDVLQJPDVLQJVHEHVDU FPGDQFP*HQRWLSHODLQQ\DPHPLOLNL XNXUDQOLOLWEDWDQJDQWDUD²FP GDQNORQSHPEDQGLQJ55,&GDQ3% PDVLQJPDVLQJVHEHVDUFPGDQ FP .DUDNWHU SHUWXPEXKDQ OLOLW EDWDQJ PHUXSDNDQ VDODK VDWX NDUDNWHU SHQWLQJ GDODPVHOHNVLNORQNDUHWXQJJXO.ORQNDUHW \ D Q J P H P L O L N L S H U W X P E X K D Q M D J X U GLKDUDSNDQ GDSDW PHPSHUSHQGHN PDVD WDQDPDQ EHOXP PHQJKDVLONDQ VHKLQJJD PHPSHUFHSDW SHQ\DGDSDQ 6LDJLDQ 6LUHJDU 0HQXUXW 1RYDOLQD
*HQRWLSH *HQRW\SHV /LOLWEDWDQJ *LUWK FP 7HEDONXOLW %DUN WKLFNQHVV PP -XPODK FLQFLQ SHPEXOXK ODWHNV 1XPEHURIODWH[ YHVVHO ULQJV 'LDPHWHUSHPEXOXK ODWHNV 'LDPHWHURIODWH[ YHVVHOFHOOV P +3 GH DE DE EF +3 FGH D DE IJ +3 DEF D DE FGHI +3 FGH D DE DE +3 EFGH D DE GHI +3 D E DE FG +3 DEFG D DE HIJ +3 FGH D E GHI +3 DE D DE D +3 EFGH D DE HIJ +3 GH D DE FGHI +3 FGH D DE J +3 FGH D DE HIJ +3 H D DE FGH +3 H D DE GHI 55,& DEFG D DE FGH 3% FGH D D EF
$QJND \DQJ GLLNXWL GHQJDQ KXUXI \DQJ VDPD SDGD VDWX NRORP PHQXQMXNNDQ WLGDN EHUEHGD Q\DWD
PHQXUXWXML+6'SDGDWDUDI
)LJXUHVIROORZHGE\WKHVDPHOHWWHULQWKHVDPHFROXPQDUHQRWVLJQLILFDQWO\GLIIHUHQWEDVHGRQ+6'WHVWDW OHYHO
NDUDNWHU OLOLW EDWDQJ PHPLOLNL KXEXQJDQ \DQJFXNXSNXDWWHUKDGDSKDVLOODWHNVVHEDE XNXUDQ OLOLW EDWDQJ DNDQ PHPSHQJDUXKL SDQMDQJQ\DDOXUVDGDS\DQJPHQJHOXDUNDQ ODWHNVSDGDSRKRQNDUHW
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
3DVDULEXVHOHNVLSDGDNDUDNWHUWHEDO 7DEHO3HUWXPEXKDQOLOLWEDWDQJGDQDQDWRPLNXOLWJHQRWLSHNDUHWKDUDSDQ33
SDGDXPXUWDKXQ
7DEOH*LUWKJURZWKDQGEDUNDQDWRP\RIUXEEHUSURPLVLQJJHQRW\SHV33DW\HDUV ROG
NXOLW DGDODK XQWXN PHQGDSDWNDQ JHQRWLSH
GHQJDQXNXUDQNXOLWFXNXSWHEDO0HQXUXW $LGL'DVOLQ NHWHEDODQ NXOLW PXUQL EHUSHQJDUXK WHUKDGDS NHPXGDKDQ XQWXN PHQ\DGDS SRKRQ NDUHW VHUWD SRWHQVL KDVLO ODWHNV
%HUGDVDUNDQ SDUDPHWHU MXPODK FLQFLQ SHPEXOXK ODWHNV PHQXQMXNNDQ EDKZD NORQ SHPEDQGLQJ 3% PHPLOLNL MXPODKFLQFLQSHPEXOXKODWHNVSDOLQJWLQJJL SHPEXOXKVHGDQJNDQSDOLQJUHQGDK WHUGDSDW SDGD JHQRWLSH +3 SHPEXOXK *HQRWLSH ODLQQ\D PHPLOLNL MXPODKFLQFLQSHPEXOXKODWHNVDQWDUD ²SHPEXOXK%HUGDVDUNDQSDUDPHWHU GLDPHWHUVHOSHPEXOXKODWHNVPHQXQMXNNDQ EDKZD JHQRWLSH +3 PHPLOLNL GLDPHWHU VHO SHPEXOXK ODWHNV SDOLQJ OHEDU \DLWX VHEHVDU P VHGDQJNDQ SDOLQJ VHPSLW WHUGDSDW SDGD JHQRWLSH +3 P
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
SHPEHQWXNDQ ODWHNV GLDQWDUDQ\D DGDODK NDQGXQJDQ VXNURVD IRVIDW DQRUJDQLN GDQ NDGDU WKLRO 1RYDOLQD HW DO +HUOLQDZDWL .XVZDQKDGL:RHODQHW DO +DVLO DQDOLVLV XML EHGD UDWDDQ PHQXQMXNNDQ EDKZD NDUDNWHU ILVLRORJL ODWHNV JHQRWLSH 33 EHUEHGD Q\DWD SDGD VHWLDS NDUDNWHU \DQJ GLDPDWL VHSHUWL \DQJGLVDMLNDQSDGD7DEHO
7DEHO PHQXQMXNNDQ JHQRWLSH EHUSHQJDUXK Q\DWD WHUKDGDS SDUDPHWHU NDGDUVXNURVD.DGDUVXNURVD SDOLQJWLQJJL WHUGDSDW SDGD JHQRWLSH +3 P0 VHGDQJNDQ \DQJ SDOLQJ UHQGDK WHUGDSDW SDGD JHQRWLSH +3 P0 *HQRWLSH ODLQQ\D PHPLOLNL NDGDU VXNURVDEHUNLVDU²P06XNURVD PHUXSDNDQ EHQWXN XWDPD VDNDULGD \DQJ EHUDGD GL GDODP VHO SHPEXOXK ODWHNV ODWLFLIHURXV FHOOV \DQJ GLKDVLONDQ PHODOXL SURVHV ELRVLQWHVLV \DQJ GLDZDOL GHQJDQ SHPHFDKDQ DVVLPLODW KDVLO IRWRVLQWHVLV 6HQ\DZD LQL PHUXSDNDQ SUHNXVRU XQWXN VLQWHVLVFLVSROLLVRSUHQD DWDX SDUWLNHO NDUHW 5DFKPDZDQ 6XPDUPDGML
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
+DVLO DQDOLVLV PHQXQMXNNDQ EDKZD JHQRWLSHEHUSHQJDUXKQ\DWDWHUKDGDSNDGDU IRVIDW DQRUJDQLN *HQRWLSH +3 PHPLOLNLNDGDUIRVIDWDQRUJDQLNSDOLQJWLQJJL P0VHGDQJNDQ\DQJSDOLQJUHQGDK WHUGDSDW SDGD JHQRWLSH +3 P0*HQRWLSHODLQQ\DPHPLOLNLNDGDUIRVIDW DQRUJDQLNEHUNLVDU²P0 .DGDU IRVIDW DQRUJDQLN WLQJJL PHQFHUPLQNDQ PHWDEROLVPH \DQJ DNWLI NDUHQD IRVIDW EHUIXQJVL VHEDJDL VHQ\DZD IRVIRULODVL GDQ
7DEHO .DUDNWHUILVLRORJLODWHNVJHQRWLSHNDUHWKDUDSDQ33XPXUWDKXQ 7DEOH /DWH[SK\VLRORJ\FKDUDFWHUVRIUXEEHUSURPLVLQJJHQRW\SHV33DW \HDUVROG *HQRWLSH *HQRW\SHV .DGDUVXNURVD 6XFURVHFRQWHQW P0 .DGDUIRVIDW DQRUJDQLN $QRUJDQLFSKRVSKDWH FRQWHQW P0 .DGDUWKLRO 7KLROFRQWHQW P0 +3 I DE EF +3 GHI DE E +3 EFGH DE D +3 D EFG EF +3 HI DEFG EF +3 FGHI EFG F +3 FGHI DEF EF +3 EF DEFG EF +3 HI D EF +3 HI EFG EF +3 HI DEFG EF +3 GHI EFG EF +3 E EFG EF +3 FGHI EFG F +3 EFG G EF 55,& FGHI FG EF 3% FGHI DEFG F
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² P0 VHKLQJJD DSDELOD WDQDPDQ PHPLOLNL NDGDU IRVIDW DQRUJDQLN P0 PDND PHWDEROLVPH WDQDPDQPHQMDGLNXUDQJDNWLI 7DEHO MXJD PHQXQMXNNDQ EDKZD JHQRWLSHEHUSHQJDUXKQ\DWDWHUKDGDSNDGDU WKLRO.DGDUWKLROSDOLQJWLQJJLWHUGDSDWSDGD JHQRWLSH+3P0VHGDQJNDQ \DQJ SDOLQJ UHQGDK WHUGDSDW SDGD JHQRWLSH +3P0+3P0 GDQ NORQ SHPEDQGLQJ 3% P0
*HQRWLSH ODLQQ\D PHPLOLNL NDGDU WKLRO EHUNLVDU ² P0 .DGDU WKLRO GL GDODPVHOSHPEXOXKODWHNVEHUIXQJVLVHEDJDL DNWLYDWRU HQ]LP GDQ EHUKXEXQJDQ GHQJDQ V W D E L O L W D V P H P E U D Q O X W R L G X Q W X N PHPSHUSDQMDQJ ODPD DOLUDQ ODWHNV 7KLRO PHPSXQ\DL NHPDPSXDQ PHOLQGXQJL RUJDQHOVXEVHOXOHUGDQPHQDQJNDSPROHNXO RNVLJHQ WRNVLN VHSHUWL 2 + 2 GDQ 2+ $WPLQLQJVLK 0HQXUXW 6XPDUPDGML GDQ 7LVWDPD NDQGXQJDQ WKLRO \DQJ R S W L P X P E H U N L V D U ² P 0 3HQLQJNDWDQ LQWHQVLWDV SHQ\DGDSDQ H[SORLWDWLRQ LQWHQVLW\ EHUSHQJDUXK SDGD SHQLQJNDWDQ NDGDU WKLRO QDPXQ MLND L Q W H Q V L W D V S H Q \ D G D S D Q E H U O H E L K D Q PHQ\HEDENDQ NDGDU WKLRO PHQMDGL UHQGDK NHPEDOL
+DVLO ODWHNV SDGD WDQDPDQ NDUHW VHODLQ GLSHQJDUXKL ROHK NDUDNWHU ILVLRORJL WHWDSL MXJD GLSHQJDUXKL ROHK VLIDW DOLUDQ ODWHNV\DQJGLDQWDUDQ\DDGDODKSDQMDQJDOXU VDGDS NHFHSDWDQ DOLUDQ ODWHNV LQGHNV SHQ\XPEDWDQ GDQ NDGDU NDUHW NHULQJ .HHPSDW SDUDPHWHU WHUVHEXW MXJD GDSDW
GLSHUWLPEDQJNDQ GDODP PHODNXNDQ VHOHNVL
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² FP 3DQMDQJ DOXU VDGDS PHPLOLNL SHQJDUXK SRVLWLI WHUKDGDS KDVLOODWHNVSDGDNORQNORQSHQJKDVLOODWHNV WLQJJL 1RYDOLQD PHQ\DWDNDQ EDKZD VHPDNLQ SDQMDQJ DOXU VDGDS PDND DNDQ PHQ\HEDENDQ SHPEXOXK ODWHNV \DQJ WHUSRWRQJ VHPDNLQ EDQ\DN VHKLQJJD DNDQ EHUSHQJDUXKWHUKDGDSKDVLOODWHNV
+DVLO DQDOLVLV PHQXQMXNNDQ EDKZD JHQRWLSH EHUSHQJDUXK Q\DWD WHUKDGDS NHFHSDWDQDOLUDQODWHNV*HQRWLSH+3 PHPLOLNL NHFHSDWDQ DOLUDQ ODWHNV SDOLQJ FHSDW POPHQLW VHGDQJNDQ \DQJ SDOLQJ ODPEDW WHUGDSDW SDGD JHQRWLSH +3 POPHQLW *HQRWLSH ODLQQ\D PHPLOLNL NHFHSDWDQ DOLUDQ ODWHNV EHUNLVDU
²POPHQLW:RHODQHWDO
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² ,QGHNVSHQ\XPEDWDQVDQJDWEHUNDLWDQHUDW GHQJDQ KDVLO ODWHNV NDUHQD PHQFHUPLQNDQ ODPD DOLUDQ ODWHNV ,QGHNV SHQ\XPEDWDQ WLQJJL PHQJDNLEDWNDQ DOLUDQ ODWHNV OHELK FHSDW EHUKHQWL 3URVHV NRDJXODVL ODWHNV GDODP MDULQJDQ VDOXUDQ SHPEXOXK ODWHNV DNDQPHPSHUFHSDWWHUKHQWLQ\DDOLUDQODWHNV VHEDOLNQ\D LQGHNV SHQ\XPEDWDQ \DQJ UHQGDKPHPLFX ODWHNVPHQJDOLUOHELKODPD VHKLQJJD ODWHNV \DQJ NHOXDU PHQMDGL OHELK EDQ\DN1RYDOLQD
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
+DVLO DQDOLVLV PHQXQMXNNDQ EDKZD JHQRWLSHEHUSHQJDUXKQ\DWDWHUKDGDSNDGDU NDUHW NHULQJ ... *HQRWLSH +3 PHPLOLNL ... SDOLQJ WLQJJL VHGDQJNDQ \DQJ SDOLQJ UHQGDK WHUGDSDW SDGD JHQRWLSH +3 *HQRWLSH ODLQQ\D PHPLOLNL ... EHUNLVDU ² 3DGD XPXPQ\D NORQ \DQJ PHPLOLNL ... WLQJJL PHPLOLNL LQGHNV SHQ\XPEDWDQ WLQJJL \DQJ PHQ\HEDENDQ DOLUDQODWHNVOHELKFHSDWEHUKHQWL:DODXSXQ GHPLNLDQ ODWHNV \DQJ PHPLOLNL ... WLQJJL GLKDUDSNDQ DNDQ PHQJKDVLONDQ NORQ EHUSURGXNWLYLWDV WLQJJL .DGDU NDUHW WLQJJL WHUXWDPDGLVHEDENDQROHKYLVNRVLWDVODWHNV W L Q J J L \ D Q J P H Q \ H E D E N D Q S U R V H V
SHQ\XPEDWDQ DOLUDQ ODWHNV EHUMDODQ OHELK FHSDW$WPLQLQJVLK
'D\D +DVLO /DWHNV %HEHUDSD *HQRWLSH 33
'DWD KDVLO SHQJDPDWDQ KDVLO ODWHNV GDODP EHQWXN JUDP SHU SRKRQ SHU VDGDS JSVVHODPDWDKXQGLVDMLNDQSDGD7DEHO %HUGDVDUNDQ KDVLO DQDOLVLV VWDWLVWLN PHQXQMXNNDQ EDKZD EHEHUDSD JHQRWLSH PHPLOLNL KDVLO ODWHNV \DQJ EHUEHGD Q\DWD GHQJDQNORQSHPEDQGLQJ3%
7DEHO PHQXQMXNNDQ EDKZD JHQRWLSH +3 GDQ +3 PHPLOLNL KDVLO ODWHNV JSV SDOLQJ WLQJJL VHODPD HQDP WDKXQ VDGDS \DLWX PDVLQJ PDVLQJVHEHVDU JGDQ J+DVLO ODWHNVGDULNHGXDNORQWHUVHEXWQ\DWDOHELK W L Q J J L G L E D Q G L Q J N D Q G H Q J D Q N O R Q SHPEDQGLQJ3%JGDQ55,& J *HQRWLSH +3 GDQ +3 PHUXSDNDQJHQRWLSH\DQJPHPLOLNL KDVLO ODWHNV SDOLQJ UHQGDK \DLWX PDVLQJ PDVLQJ VHEHVDU J GDQ J *HQRWLSH ODLQQ\D PHPLOLNL KDVLO ODWHNV EHUNLVDU²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
NDGDUNDUHWNHULQJJHQRWLSHNDUHWKDUDSDQ33XPXUWDKXQ
7DEOH /HQJWK RI WDSSLQJ SDQHO ODWH[ IORZ UDWH SOXJJLQJ LQGH[ DQG GU\ UXEEHU FRQWHQW FKDUDFWHUVRISURPLVLQJUXEEHUJHQRW\SHV33DW\HDUVROG *HQRWLSH *HQRW\SHV 3DQMDQJDOXU VDGDS /HQJWKRI WDSSLQJSDQHO FP .HFHSDWDQ DOLUDQODWHNV POPHQLW /DWH[IORZUDWH POPLQXWH ,QGHNV SHQ\XPEDWDQ 3OXJJLQJLQGH[ .DGDUNDUHWNHULQJ 'U\UXEEHUFRQWHQW
+3 EFG EFGH FGH DEF
+3 FG DEFGH FGH DEF
+3 DEFG DEFGH EFG DEF
+3 EFG DEFG EF DE
+3 DEF EFGH FGH DEF
+3 D DE D DE
+3 DEF EFGH FGH F
+3 DEFG EFGH FGH EF
+3 DE D DE DE
+3 DEFG DEF EFG DE
+3 FG FGH FGH DEF
+3 FG EFGH FGH DEF
+3 FG GH H DEF
+3 G H FGH DEF
+3 G GH GH D
55,& DEFG DEFGH EFG DE
3% DEFG FGH FGH D
$QJND \DQJ GLLNXWL GHQJDQ KXUXI \DQJ VDPD SDGD VDWX NRORP PHQXQMXNNDQ WLGDN EHUEHGD Q\DWD PHQXUXWXML+6'SDGDWDUDI
)LJXUHVIROORZHGE\WKHVDPHOHWWHULQWKHVDPHFROXPQDUHQRWVLJQLILFDQWO\GLIIHUHQWEDVHGRQ+6'WHVWDW OHYHO
KXEXQJDQDQWDUDSHUWXPEXKDQOLOLWEDWDQJ
WDQDPDQGDQKDVLOODWHNVEHEHUDSDJHQRWLSH NDUHW33
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
SHUWXPEXKDQ WDQDPDQ GDQ KDVLO ODWHNV GDSDW GLVLPSXONDQ EDKZD JHQRWLSH +3 PHPLOLNLSRWHQVLKDVLOODWHNVWLQJJL VHGDQJNDQ JHQRWLSH +3 PHPLOLNL SRWHQVLKDVLOODWHNVWLQJJLGDQSHUWXPEXKDQ MDJXU 3HQGXJDDQ 1LODL 5DJDP *HQHWLN GDQ +HULWDELOLWDV 1LODL SHQGXJDDQ NRPSRQHQ UDJDP KHULWDELOLWDV DUWL OXDV GDQ NRHILVLHQ NHUDJDPDQJHQHWLN..*EHEHUDSDNDUDNWHU NXDQWLWDWLI JHQRWLSH 33 GLVDMLNDQ SDGD7DEHO+DVLODQDOLVLVGDWDSDGD7DEHO PHQXQMXNNDQEDKZDQLODLUDJDPJHQRWLSH SDGD VHWLDS NDUDNWHU \DQJ GLDPDWL PHQXQMXNNDQ OHELK UHQGDK GLEDQGLQJNDQ GHQJDQ QLODL UDJDP IHQRWLSHQ\D +DO WHUVHEXW PHQXQMXNNDQ DGDQ\D SHQJDUXK OLQJNXQJDQWHUKDGDSNDUDNWHU\DQJGLDPDWL 3HQJDUXK OLQJNXQJDQ PHQ\HEDENDQ QLODL UDJDPIHQRWLSHPHQMDGLOHELKEHVDU
7DEHO PHQXQMXNNDQ EDKZD NDUDNWHU OLOLW EDWDQJ WHEDO NXOLW MXPODK FLQFLQ SHPEXOXK ODWHNV GLDPHWHU VHO SHPEXOXK ODWHNV SDQMDQJ DOXU VDGDS N H F H S D W D Q D O L U D Q O D W H N V L Q G H N V SHQ\XPEDWDQ NDGDU IRVIDW DQRUJDQLN
NDGDU VXNURVD NDGDU WKLRO NDGDU NDUHW NHULQJ GDQ KDVLO ODWHNV PHPLOLNL QLODL
KHULWDELOLWDVDUWLOXDVK EVWHUJRORQJWLQJJL 1LODL KHULWDELOLWDV \DQJ WLQJJL SDGD VHPXD NDUDNWHU\DQJGLDPDWLPHQXQMXNNDQEDKZD N D U D N W H U N D U D N W H U W H U V H E X W O H E L K G L S H Q J D U X K L R O H K I D N W R U J H Q H W L N GLEDQGLQJNDQ ROHK OLQJNXQJDQ 0HQXUXW 6\XNXU GDQ 6RELU NDUDNWHU \DQJ PHPLOLNL QLODL KHULWDELOLWDV VHGDQJ VDPSDL WLQJJL PDND NDUDNWHU WHUVHEXW OHELK G L N H Q G D O L N D Q R O H K I D N W R U J H Q H W L N GLEDQGLQJNDQ GHQJDQ OLQJNXQJDQ $SDELOD VXDWX NDUDNWHU PHPLOLNL QLODL KHULWDELOLWDV DUWL OXDV WLQJJL PDND NDUDNWHU WHUVHEXW SRWHQVLDO XQWXN GLZDULVNDQ NHSDGD NHWXUXQDQ +DVLO SHQHOLWLDQ PHQXQMXNNDQ EDKZD KHULWDELOLWDV NDUDNWHU \DQJ GLDPDWL PHPLOLNL NLVDUDQ QLODL DQWDUD ² 6XGDUPDGML 0DUGMRQR GDQ 6XGDUPRQR PHQ\DWDNDQ EDKZD KHULWDELOLWDV DGDODK SURSRUVL UDJDP IHQRWLSLN WRWDO \DQJ GLVHEDENDQROHKVHPXDWLSHHIHNJHQ1LODL KHULWDELOLWDV GLJRORQJNDQ PHQMDGL WLJD NULWHULD\DLWXQLODLKHULWDELOLWDVUHQGDKK KHULWDELOLWDVVHGDQJK GDQ KHULWDELOLWDVWLQJJLK 7Uì 7DEHO PHQXQMXNNDQ QLODL ..* SDGD PDVLQJPDVLQJ NDUDNWHU NXDQWLWDWLI 7DEHO 1LODLSHQGXJDDQNRPSRQHQUDJDPKHULWDELOLWDVGDQNRHILVLHQNHUDJDPDQJHQHWLN EHEHUDSDNDUDNWHUNXDQWLWDWLIJHQRWLSHNDUHWKDUDSDQ33
7DEOH (VWLPDWLQJ YDOXH RI YDULDQFH FRPSRQHQW KHULWDELOLW\ DQG FRHIILFLHQW RI JHQHWLF YDULDELOLW\RIVRPHTXDQWLWDWLYHFKDUDFWHUVRIUXEEHUSURPLVLQJJHQRW\SHV33 .DUDNWHU &KDUDFWHUV ÔS ÔJ ÔH KEV ..* /LOLWEDWDQJFP 7HEDONXOLWPP -XPODKFLQFLQSHPEXOXKODWHNV 'LDPHWHUVHOSHPEXOXKODWHNVP 3DQMDQJDOXUVDGDSPP .HFHSDWDQDOLUDQODWHNVPOPHQLW ,QGHNVSHQ\XPEDWDQ .DGDUIRVIDWDQRUJDQLNP0 .DGDUVXNURVDP0 .DGDUWKLROP0 .DGDUNDUHWNHULQJ +DVLOODWHNVJSV
.HWHUDQJDQ 5HPDNVÔS UDJDP IHQRWLSHSKHQRW\SLF YDULDQFHÔJ UDJDP JHQRWLSHJHQRW\SLF
YDULDQFHÔH UDJDPOLQJNXQJDQHQYLURQPHQWYDULDQFHK EV KHULWDELOLWDVDUWLOXDVKHULWDELOLW\
..* SDOLQJ WLQJJL WHUGDSDW SDGD NDUDNWHU
NDGDU VXNURVD VHGDQJNDQ \DQJ WHUHQGDKWHUGDSDWSDGDNDUDNWHUWHEDONXOLW .DUDNWHU ODLQQ\D PHPLOLNL ..* EHUNLVDUDQWDUD²$OQRSUL PHQ\DWDNDQEDKZDNHUDJDPDQJHQHWLN\DQJ WLQJJL PHQXQMXNNDQ DGDQ\D SHQJDUXK JHQHWLN \DQJ OHELK GRPLQDQ GDULSDGD S H Q J D U X K O L Q J N X Q J D Q V H E D O L N Q \ D N H U D J D P D Q J H Q H W L N \ D Q J U H Q G D K PHQXQMXNNDQDGDQ\DSHQJDUXKOLQJNXQJDQ \DQJNXDW%HUGDVDUNDQDQDOLVLVNRPSRQHQ UDJDP KHULWDELOLWDV GDQ NRHILVLHQ NHUDJDPDQ JHQHWLN GDSDW GLNHWDKXL EDKZD SHUZDULVDQ NDUDNWHU NXDQWLWDWLI \DQJ GLDPDWL OHELK FHQGHUXQJ GLSHQJDUXKL ROHK IDNWRU JHQHWLN GLEDQGLQJNDQ IDNWRU OLQJNXQJDQ
.(6,038/$1
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
QLODL K EV DQWDUD ²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
3RWHQVLNHXQJJXODQNORQNDUHW KDUDSDQ,55VHULGDULKDVLOVHOHNVL SRKRQ LQGXN-XUQDO 3HQHOLWLDQ .DUHW
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
'HSDUWHPHQ 3HUWDQLDQ /XDV DUHDO S U R G X N V L G D Q S U R G X N W L Y L W D V SHUNHEXQDQ GL ,QGRQHVLD WDKXQ 'LDNVHV GDUL ZZZSHUWDQLDQJRLG WDQJJDO0HL
'LUHNWRUDW -HQGHUDO 3HUNHEXQDQ
6WDWLVWLN3HUNHEXQDQ,QGRQHVLD -DNDUWD,QGRQHVLD'LUMHQEXQ *RPH] - 1DUD\DQDQ 5 &KHQ . 7
6RPH VWUXFWXUDO IDFWRUV DIIHFWLQJ WKH SURGXFWLYLW\ RI +HYHD EUDVLOLHQVLV0XHOO $UJ - 5XEE 5HV
,QVWLWXWH0DOD\D
+HUOLQDZDWL ( .XVZDQKDGL $NWLILWDV PHWDEROLVPH EHEHUDSD NORQ NDUHW SDGD EHUEDJDL IUHNXHQVL VDGDS GDQVWLPXODVL-XUQDO3HQHOLWLDQ.DUHW
0LOIRUG*)-3DDUGHNRRSHU(& +R &9/DWH[YHVVHOSOXJJLQJ,WV LPSRUWDQFH WR \LHOG DQG FORQDO EHKDYLRU -5XEE5HVRI0DOD\D ²
0LUDEHOOR 0 - <DYLWW - % *DUFLD 0 +DUPV.(7XUQHU%/ :ULJKW 6 - 6RLO SKRVSKRUXV UHVSRQVHV WR FKURQLF QXWULHQW IHUWLOLVDWLRQDQGVHDVRQDOGURXJWKLQD KXPLG ORZODQG IRUHVW 3DQDPD- 6RLO 5 H V ' R L 65
1RYDOLQD -XVXI 0 :DWWLPHQD * $ 6XKDUVRQR 6XPDUPDGML $LGL ' D V O L Q . H U D J D D Q G D Q KXEXQJDQ EHUEDJDL NRPSRQHQ KDVLO WDQDPDQ NDUHW +HYHD EUDVLOLHQVLV 0XHOO $UJ SDGD GXD SRSXODVL KDVLO SHUVLODQJDQ3%GDQ31%XO$JURQ
1RYDOLQD'HWHNVLPDUNDJHQHWLN\DQJ WHUSDXW GHQJDQ NRPSRQHQ SURGXNVL ODWHNV SDGD WDQDPDQ NDUHW +HYHD EUDVLOLHQVLV 0XHOO $UJ PHODOXL SHPHWDDQ 47/ 'LVHUWDVL ,QVWLWXW 3HUWDQLDQ%RJRU,QGRQHVLD
2ERXD\HED66RXPDKLQ()2NRPD. 01JXHVVDQ$(%&RXOLEDO\/) .RIIL . ( /DFRWH 5 7HPSRUDO DQG VWUXFWXUDO UHODWLRQV ZLWKLQ EDUN DQG WUXQN LQ +HYHD EUDVLOLHQVLV -RXUQDO RI %LRVFLHQFHV
3XUZDQLQJUXP < 1DSLWXSXOX - $ 6LUHJDU7+6 +DQXP& +LVWRORJ\ DQG SK\VLRORJ\ RI %30 FORQHV ZLWK GLIIHUHQW H[SORLWDWLRQ V\VWHPV-%DV $SS5HV
5DFKPDZDQ $ 6XPDUPDGML .DMLDQNDUDNWHUILVLRORJLGDQVLIDWNDUHW NORQ 3% PHQMHODQJ EXND VDGDS
-XUQDO3HQHOLWLDQ.DUHW 6LDJLDQ 1 6LUHJDU 7 + 6
(YDOXDVLSURGXNWLYLWDVWDQDPDQNDUHW GHQJDQVLVWHPJDQGDSDGDVNDOD
NRPHUVLDO:DUWD3HUNDUHWDQ 6XGDUPDGML 0DUGMRQR 5 6XGDUPRQR
+9DULDVLJHQHWLNKHULWDELOLWDV GDQ NRUHODVL JHQRWLSLN VLIDWVLIDW SHQWLQJ WDQDPDQ ZLMHQ 6HVDPXP
LQGLFXP/-/LWWUL
6XPDUPDGML 7LVWDPD 5 'HVNULSVL NORQ NDUHW EHUGDVDUNDQ NDUDNWHU ILVLRORJL ODWHNV XQWXN PHQHWDSNDQ VLVWHP HNVSORLWDVL \DQJ VHVXDL-XUQDO3HQHOLWLDQ.DUHW 6\XNXU 0 6XMLSULKDWL 6 <XQLDQWL 5 7HNQLN 3HPXOLDDQ 7DQDPDQ -DNDUWD,QGRQHVLD3HQHEDU6ZDGD\D 6\XNXU 0 6RELU *HQHWLND 7DQDPDQ%RJRU,QGRQHVLD,3%3UHVV :RHODQ 6 6D\XUDQGL 3DVDULEX 6 $
.HUDJDDQ NORQNORQ ,55 VHUL GDQGLSHQJXMLDQSORWSURPRVL
:DUWD3HUNDUHWDQ
:RHODQ63HWDSDXWDQJHQHWLNGDQ DQDOLVLV 47/ WDQDPDQ NDUHW +HYHD EUDVLOLHQVLV 0XHOO $UJ SDGD SRSXODVL KDVLO SHUVLODQJDQ 55,0 GDQ 31 V H E D J D L G D V D U V W U D W H J L S H Q L Q J N D W D Q S U R G X N V L O D W H N V 'LVHUWDVL 8QLYHUVLWDV 6XPDWHUD 8WDUD,QGRQHVLD
:RHODQ 6 6D\XUDQGL 3DVDULEX 6 $ .DUDNWHU ILVLRORJL DQDWRPL SHUWXPEXKDQ GDQ KDVLO ODWHNV NORQ ,55 VHUL -XUQDO 3HQHOLWLDQ .DUHW
:RHODQ 6 6D\XUDQGL ,UZDQV\DK ( .HUDJDPDQ JHQHWLN WDQDPDQ NDUHW+HYHD EUDVLOLHQVLV 0XHOO $UJ GDUL KDVLO SHUVLODQJDQ LQWHUVSHVLILN
-XUQDO 3HQHOLWLDQ .DUHW
=DPEURVL)&%-XQLRU'0%RDUHWWR 504XDJJLR -$0XUDRND7 6\YHUWVHQ-3&RQWULEXWLRQRI SKRVSKRUXV 3 DEVRUSWLRQ DQG UHPRELOL]DWLRQ IRU FLWUXV JURZWK
-3ODQW 6RLO 'RL
