Peran Badan Pemeriksa Keuangan dalam Penegakkan Tata Kelola Pemerintah Daerah yang Baik pada Provinsi dan Kabupaten / Kota di Riau

(1)

! " # $ %& ! " # $ % " % & ' '( ) % & * + , -" . " " / 0 # 0/$ 0/ ,*1 2 3 . " 0/ " # '$ *' 4 - *' 5 2 #0$ . " 2 6 ' *1 * ( + ' *1 7 - 4 " 2 ' # ( ) * %%$ + + # # , " # * # * # # # - . * - /" . 0 1 ' * 223 " # * 1 4, ) * 5 # * # , # * # # *5 * 0 # . # * -- 6 5 * * / %%$4 $2 7 8 " 8 8 # 8 9 : # 0 8 . . 8 1 " , 9

(2)

: "* 0 '* # , . (; 6 / 2224 ' . 7 8 8 # 0 - " 0 0 , 0 8 # - 2 $$, 9 8 / # 4, 2 ; /'04 / 22 4 . * # *5 0 # &< $ /0" 4 , " * 22= 0" 0 3 /% 34 6 /$ &4 /< =4 ' 5 / %4 / 4 9 / 24 . * # 0 , 9 2 8 ; /'04 / 22=4 /0" 4 ; * # 5 * / 4, 0 # # *5 * ; 0" 22= * # 5 * , > 8 ; * 8 * # *5 # / 8 4 . , # * ; # * # * # # * # # * # # # * ; 8 8 8 # . # /2 8 ; 22=4 , * * . # # 5 # , > * " . * # . " . . * " # * ; > %3 * " , " # * " * / 4 " & # ?000 .

# # # ?000 " & & &@

* # . * ,

# " &8 " & " & " & @ > 1 #

0 ' * %3 * ; 1 < ' * 22& 1 ; 1 ' * 223 " " ' 5 # 1 , # * * * ; 9 . " 5 ; 1 ' * %<& " * + # ; 1 ' * 22=, : # " ; # , > ; + -" * * , A # * . " * # # " # # * " * * ' , # . . " " > " ' " * > * A " " # B , * * C * # * * # # B " , ' . " * + # " * * # # B ,

(3)

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

(4)

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

(5)

, ) ! ( ( # $ ) & # $ . . / %%< 7 24 > % G / - H 2 2 4 . 7 - - # # - I 2 &2 / ; ++ (( C %%&4 # , - J 2 &2 # # , . # . < -* ) ' & % ! # * * . # / 4 * , * . * <. /KH2 2 4, 62 7 # # , 6 7 # # , # # 62 7 # # # . / 4 I K /2 2 4, + & ! ! % # . * # * * * * * * # / 4 " /L4 * ' * /A4, " 7 A H M# L M , , " ) ! ! " ! " . * * = > .9 /): 4, . * . * / * 4, . 1 , " . * * # # , " . . ; , . # 6 , 6 # *5 * # * - , " . * . , - " ) .'% ! ! + * # # 7 627ρALH 2 7 ' " " ' * * # # B

(6)

6 7ρALN 2 7 ' " ' * * # # B . - . / 4; . , - . * # * # # # - , 6 * . ; # # . .. " ? - , * ' #

/ & 0 1 ! & ) ' & % ! % / & ! & & % 2 .& '& '"' '32 '3 !% #4$ % &'& % ( " # $ 1 1 " ,#₉ ,> 9 O # > -- + " 1 ; P , , / ; 4 &2 ,3<%2<& , 22$&$ = , 2 , 2 ;, 2% ,$ 3 , 2= &2 ,%= 2$ ,=<3<2&$ , % , % ;, 2 ,= 2 <% , , ' # 1 #, 8 + -% " 1 " ! #.$ 5 676- 8 % / !% / ! ' & " ! #.$ 9 676- 8 % % / !% / ! ' > * * * . 1 L * # 2 2 - / 4 * 2 2=, > * - # 2 2 , 6 # " # # , > * * * . 1 A * # 2 % - / 4 * 2 <% , > * - # 2 2 , 6 # ' * # # , ! & & ! ! " ! 6 * - * # # 7 / & * 1 ! & " ! 4 % ( .

(7)

* * * - # # 2 $<& # 2 <%$ * * # " ' * 7 ₀Q H 2 <%$ M 2 $<& L, 6 # # *5 # " ' * 2 $<& 2 <%$, 6 # # " # ' * , ! & " ) ! ! " ! ! & ) ' & % ! ! 6 * . * " ' # &,

/ & + 1 ! & ) ' & % !

! "# $$ % & ! ' ( ) ! *+ , - . / 0 1 % $ / 1 . %. % > # * # *5 >* H 2 2% ; / 4 # 2 $= , > * * * . 1 -/ 4 * 2 $= # 2 2 , 6 . . # *5 # # , ! & ) ! ! / ! % ' !% ! % ! 6 . # # * * ' # 3, 2 + 2 2 2 *1 , 3 & *4, 3 " - . 1 $$ % 3 . 1 $$ % ! ) 5 6 0 7 ) 8 *9,

(8)

/ & , 1 ) % '! !% ! % ! :' & % ' ! " /L4 # RLA S * " /L4 8 8 -- + , / ; 4 1 # RLA 8 + -- + , / ! 4 1 ,222 &2 , 2 , 3& &2 , 2 , 3& &2 ,222 &2 / 1 . %. % 6 . * . # *5 * / * 4, 6 . * * L # / 4 - G, > * - L # 2 3& / -# * -# 2 2 # # 4, ! & " ) .'% ! ! 6 " * . - * ' # # 5 * 7 / & - 1 / & % ) " ! ! " ! > # . * / 4 H &2C * # # H # H $ # 3 %=, ' # * * . - * H 2 % I #H 3 %= # *5 ₀Q H 2 <%$ M 2 $<& L * - , * . - . * - * L A /AL4, * * # * AL # 2 =3$, ' * # # , " * , # " # *, - AL # * - / 4 # 2 3 2, 6 # # *5 3 2G ' * /A4 * * " , - " ' * . . * * ' # =,

/ & ; 1 ! & "( % " ' & ! 4 "

1 '* ' # /2 2 4 2+ 2+ + + + + 2 + + + / ! / 0 $ : $ : ; ! % 6 *1 , 3 7 & ! *4, ) 5 6 0 7 ) 8 8 ( ! 7 *9,

(9)

L A &2 2 $<& 2 =3$ 2 3 2 3 2 23$ 1 # . * / 4 H &2C . * # / 4 H C - - K H GC . # # / #4 H ; ; H &2; ; H $ * # 23$, " # . * # 3 2 # * # # # 23$, 9 # *5 62 # * - " * ' *, * # *5 * # # " * * , # " # * * # B , - O * - / 4 # 2 3 2, 6 # # *5 3 2 G * * * " , - " " ' * # . . , 1 # * # 23$ * # 3 2 # * # # # 23$, 9 # *5 62 # - " ' * # # B " , > * . " - . * / ">4 # B * # * # " , " * ; * - ;- * * * # ,

<

5 1 , 22<, 7 - @ <@ " . . ; " ' * =2 " , 5 * * -- 6 * %%$ 3 . 7 " A A 8 % 8 8 B '. . . , 222, A A 8 # 7 $ A 7 " # 0 , 0;" , " 0 22=, 4 . ++ ' , @ 2 3 ' ( ' , " ; " 5 , " # , RRRRRRR, 22=, 2 3 > , RRRRRRR, 22<, 4 . + ' C > 2 3 ' , " ; " 5 , " # , RRRRRRR, 22<, " " # 0 , 1),2 . 6 , , RRRRRRR, 22<, " " # 0 , 1), 2 ' * 22< D ;, ,

(10)

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

(11)

* -- # 0 22% 5 "