• Tidak ada hasil yang ditemukan

The International Journal o f Accounting and Business Society

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2018

Membagikan "The International Journal o f Accounting and Business Society"

Copied!
41
0
0

Teks penuh

(1)

20 H o w F a s t T o b a c c o C a n B e :

H o w F a s t T o b a c c o C a n B e:

T H E L O G I ST I C A L PRO C ESS A T RO T H M A N S O F PA L L M A L L IN D O N ESIA IN T H E 1997 IN D O N ESIA N EC O N O M IC C R ISIS

R .J .E . v a n d e r H e i j d e n Fo n t ys Un iv er si t y , Net h er lan d s

B .G . W a g n e r

Fo n t ys Un iv er si t y, Net h er lan d s

E . G . S u k o h a r s o n o Br a w i j a y a Un iv er sit y , In d o n esia

I n t r o d u c t i o n

Ev e r y year Ro t h m an s In t er n at io n al Gr o u p p u b lish es a g eo g r ap h ical b u siness rep ort . In t h is rep ort the d if f er en t A sian g eo g r ap h ical r eg io n s are co m p ar ed w it h one an o t h er co n cer n in g p r of it , cost s, sales et c. Bef o r e 1996, Ro t h m an s o f Pal l M a l l In d o n esia w as alw ays at t he l sl p lace co n cer n in g p rof it . T h is is b ecau se o f t he lo w cost s spent in In d o n esia. In 1996 p r of it s w er e d ecl in in g and t h eir p lace at t he hit list w as t ak en b y M al ay si a. T h is w ak en ed the m an ag em en t in Jak ar t a and M al an g . T h e Pr o f i t n um b er s w er e st ill d ecl in in g due t he h ig h er cost s t han ex p ect ed (sales m ain t ain co n st an t ). T h e cost s in cr eased in t he year o f 1996 w it h 1 0 % (u su all y b et w een

4%

and 6 %). Th o se 1 0 % t ot al f o r a RP 2,6 b ill io n : 1996. A cco r d in g t o t he m an ag em en t t h er e w er e t w o m ain causes f or t he 1996 y e a r ’ s h igh cost s :

1. H ig h co n t r ib u t ion s to t he p erso n n el o f t he In d o n esian g o ver n m en t 2. Pr o d u ct io n cost s w er e h ig h er t hen ex p ect ed at t he f act o r y in

M alan g .

T h e cau ses o f t he h ig h er p r od u ct ion cost s w er e : 1. Ex t r a lab o r cost s (ap p r o x . RP 1 b il l i o n ).

2. D u e t he m aj o r ch an g es o f m an ag er s in k ey p o sit io n s t he ef f ic i en cy o f t he r u n n in g o f t he f act o r y d eclin ed .

T h e ef f i ci en cy o f t he f act o r y had to be im p r o ved . T o get a clear p ict u r e on t he 1996 sit u at ion o f the p r od u ct io n p r ocess and t o get an idea ab ou t w h i ch m ach in es and d ep ar t m en t s had to be im p r o ved an d h o w t o im p r o ve t hem , Ro t h m an s o f Pal l M a l l In d o n esia w an t ed t o h ave an an alysi s w h at w as h ap p ened w i t h t he b u siness lo g ist ics in 1997.

(2)

Usi n g Y i n ’ s case st u d y m et hod (Y i n , 1989), t he o b j ect ive o f t h is p ap er is to in vest ig at e t he 1997 lo g ist ical syst em w h er e t h is is t he st art ed t u r m o il year o f the In d o n esian eco n o m y. Ro t h m an s In d o n esia w as w o r k in g w it h o ld - f ash ion ed m ach in es and in the past t h er e had b een m ad e ad- hoc im p r o vem en t s f o r t he p urp ose o f so lvin g b o t t len eck s and p r o b lem s in t he f act o r y . Th er ef o r e ex t r a p r o d u ct io n hours w er e used.

W h a t w a s h a p p e n e d

Th e t w o m aj o r p r o b lem s m en t io n ed b ef or e in d icat e t he areas o f the lo g ist ical p r ocess in w h i ch a d et ailed in vest ig at io n had been d one. Th e f ir st w as a b o t t len eck , f l o w an alysis and t im e st ud y o f the b u siness lo g ist ics, t he second w as ef f i ci en cy m easu r em en t o f t he d if f er en t p rocesses o f t he lo g ist ical process.

H o w s h o u l d it b e d o n e

Th e o ver h ead m et hod o f the in vest ig at io n w as based on t he b lack - b ox m od el o f In 't V e l d G. T h is w as b ecause o f t he co m p l ex it y and op en- endnes o f t he p r o b lem d escr ip t io n . Th e in vest ig at io n p r ocess had t o be co n d u ct ed bot t om up b ecau se o f t he lo cat io n o f t he resear ch er s and t h eir p lace w i t h in t he o r g an iz at io n . A s a p h ilo so p h y b ehin d t his bot t om - up r esear ch t he id eas o f Go ld r at t H w er e ad op t ed . Pr o b lem s w er e h ig h lig h t ed and f u r t h er in vest ig at ed . I f the cause o f the p r ob lem co u ld not be f oun d on t he o p er at ion al level o f the o r g an iz at io n , a st u d y w as m ad e o f t he t act ical and st r at eg ic levels. T h i s k in d o f st udy w as also lik e Het lam p m od el o f Po t g en si co n cer n in g t he st u d y o f the t act ical and st r at eg ic level.

%

T h e w h o le r esear ch w as com p let ed as f o llo w s:

1. A n o ver al l v i e w o f t he o r g an iz at io n w as est ab lish ed 2. A d et ailed visio n o f t he p r od u ct ion process w as m ad e

3. Tim e/ q u an t it y st ud ies ab out r esou r ces and o ccu p at io n levels w er e co m p let ed

4. In t er est in g part s o f t he p rocess w er e an alyz ed f u r t h er (b o t t len eck and in ef f icien t r eso u r ce)

5. Co n cl u sio n s w er e m ad e and solu t io n s w er e est ab lish ed

6. So lu t io n s w er e present ed and im p lem en t ed t hem int o t he o r g an iz at ion

E x p l a n a t i o n o f t h e r e p o r t c l a s s i f i c a t i o n s

Th e lim it s o f t he st u d y are d escrib ed . A sm all d escr ip t io n o f Ro t h m an s can be f o u n d (f o r a f u ll d escrip t ion : Ap p en d i x 1). Th e st u d y also d escrib es t he m et hod s o f t he in vest ig at io n , g i vin g a d et ailed v i e w o f t h e r esear ch m et hod s and 21 T h e I n t e r n a t i o n a l J o u r n a l o f A c c o u n t i n g a n d B u s i n e s s S o c i e t y

(3)

22 H o w F a s t T o b a c c o C a n B e :

t h eir o r ig in . Th e r esult s o f t he an alysis are d escrib ed . T h e co n clu sio n s and r eco m m en d at io n s w i l l be d iscussed . Fin al l y , in ch ap t er 6 t he im p lem en t at ion o f a new p lan n in g - syst em w i l l be an alyz ed .

In t he w h o le r ep ort sm all alp h ab et ic let t ers are used to l in k b ack to the t ab le o f au t h o r it ies. In t he t ab le o f au t h o r it ies are t he sam e let t ers used, w h i ch g ives t he ex act l y in f or m at io n ab out t he source. Th e sm all n u m b er s b ehind the w or d s r ef er to f oot not es.

A r em ar k is m ad e ab out the ex ch an g e rate o f the Ru p iah . In 1996 the RP w as at 6.0 00 to t he U S d o llar , Jan u ar y 1998 t he RP r each ed an u lt im o dept o f 9.000.

T a b l e o f t e r m

Th e f o l l o w i n g is an o v er vi ew o f t he sp ecif i c ab b r eviat io n s used b y PT Ro t h m an s o f Pal l M a l l in 1997 and t h eir m eanin g .

A b b r e v i a t i o n E x p l a n a t i o n

D I D u n h ill In t er n at io n al

D IM D u n h il l In t er n at io n al M en t h o l

D ii D u n h il l Lig h t

D K S D u n h ill K i n g Siz e D K SM Bl u e Rib b o n Su p er Siz e

B L R SS Kan sas Plain

K a n P Kan sas Kin g - siz e Fi l t er K a n K F - Kan sas M en t h o l

K a n L Kan sas Lig h t

K a n M L i Kan sas M en t h o l Lig h t W H R L S Wh i t e Ho r se Lo n g Siz e

M SB M ar s Br an d Sh ag

M B P M ar s Br an d Pap er

3 RH L 3 r o w box

2 RH L 2 r o w b ox

K O O P Custom er Order Detachment Point (planning vs customer- specific) Rot h m an s PT Ro t h m an s o f Pall M al l In d o n esia

(4)

23 T h e I n t e r n a t i o n a l J o u r n a l o f A c c o u n t i n g a n d B u s i n e s s S o c i e t y

A su r vey o f t he t erm s used b y Rot h m an s and t h eir m ean in g in t he 1997.

Ban d r o l 1 ax lab el

Blen d M i x o f vario u s t o b acco ’ s w h ich m ak e sp ecif i c a brand

Cast in g Fl av o r

Flavo r Sau ce w it h t he b lend is m ix ed t o m ak e a sp ecif i c tast e

Pack ag in g D ep ar t m en t w h er e Ro t h m an s p ack ag e t he cig ar et t es int o b ox es, sleeves and car d b o ar d ’ s

Pr i m ar y D ep ar t m en t w h er e Ro t h m an s m ak e t he b lend o f t he t o b acco

St i ck Cig ar et t e

St ick - m ak in g D ep art m en t w h er e Rot h m an s p r od u ce t he cig ar et t e (w i t h the t o b acco , f ilt er and p ap er )

C r i t e r i a o f t h e i n v e s t i g a t i o n

Th e p r od u ct s t hat Ro t h m an s p r od u ces in 1997 w er e D u n h i l l and M ar s Br an d f or t he In t er n at io n al m ar k et and Kan sas Wh i t e Ho r se and Bl u e Rib b o n f o r the d o m est ic m ar k et . Th ese brands w er e av ail ab l e in d if f er en t sizes, f ilt er / n on - f ilt er , p ack ag es and m en t h o l ver sion s. T h i s t ot als t he n um b er o f b lend s at 9 and t he n um b er o f end p rod u ct s at 14. Th e t o t al an n u al r even u e o f Rot h m an s o f Pall M a l l In d o n esia w as ab out RP 100 b i lli o n w i t h ap p r o x im at ely 2 ,4 0 0 ,0 0 0 ,0 0 0 cig ar et t es p r o d u ct a year.

Th e head o f f ice o f Ro t h m an s o f Pal l M a l l In d o n esia w as sit uat ed in Jak ar t a. T h e p r o d u ct io n and st orage f o r , r a w m at er ials and f in ish ed good s in ven t o r y w as m ain t ain ed in t he f act o r y in M alan g . T h e d o m est ic t o b acco in 1997 w as 65 %. Th e rest m ai n ly im p ort ed f r om A m e r i ca and Br az i l but t h ey w er e b ought ar o u n d t he w o r ld b y Rot h m an s In t er n at io n al. Ev e r y brand had it's o wn b lend (m ix t u r e o f t o b acco ). A b lend w as m ad e f r om 15 t il l 32 t yp es o f t o b acco and f lavo r ed w i t h a cast ing . Ev e r y brand had its u n iq u e cast in g , w h ich w as im p o r t ed f r om Eu r o p e.

Fo r the p r o d u ct io n o f t he cigar et t es Ro t h m an s In d o n esia m ak es used o f 2 GLT - m ach in es, 3 b len d - m ach ines, 11 p r od u ct io n m ach in es, 11 p ack ag in g m ach in es and 60 w ar eh o u ses sp r ead in g o ver all t he In d o n esian ar ch ip elag o . Th e p eop le in the f act o r y w o r k 40 hours a w eek , f rom 7.00 t ill 16.00 w i t h a b r eak o f

1 hou r at noon.

It w as m en t io n ed that not all act ivit i es o f t he co m p an y t o ok p lace in M al an g , Jak ar t a w as t he h ead - of f ice o f Ro t h m an s. Th e Pr esid en t D ir ect o r ,

(5)

24 H o w F a s t T o b a c c o C a n B e :

M ar k et i n g D ir ect o r , Fin an cial D ir ect o r , Hu m an r eso u r ces D i r ect o r and t he co m p let e M ar k et i n g and Fin an cial d ep ar t m en t w er e in Jak ar t a. Fo r the in vest ig at io n , o n ly t he f act o r y in M alan g w as in vest ig at ed . T h e p lace o f the r esear ch er s in t he o rg an iz at ion w as d ir ect ed u n d er t h e Hu m an r eso u r ce m an ag er o f M alan g . In o rd er o f level it w as on t act ical level. Th e o r g an iz at ion ch ar t can de seen in f ig u r e 1. A l l f u n ct io n s w h ich w er e sit uat ed in M al an g w er e g r ay. Th e p o sit ion o f t he in vest ig at o r s w as sho w n in red.

Gm anf Managar Gen r* M alaga h Wvq Qp*»Hon GfOtf) 0«v*lapm «nt

Factory Um g ar

Human Raaourcas Manag* (M in g }

Engew w g lin u d c w ii Owictoi Sarvwaa Dvactaf

Eng St r wt f Pio d ct S«vc«s Duactor Manag*

F I G U R E 1: O RG A N IZ A T IO N C H A RT O F RO T H M A N S [So u r ce:,Own invest igat ion]

M al an g w as d ir ect ed b y t w o m an ag er s, t he G M M (Gen er al M an ag er M al an g ) and t he G M M O (Gen er al M an ag er M alan g Op er at io n s. T h e G M M w as r esp o n sib le f o r o r g an iz at io n al t ask w h er eas t he G M M O w as r esp o n sib le f o r the p r o d u ct io n p rocess.

T h e P r o d u c t i o n P r o c e s s

Th e m an u f act u r in g p r ocess o f the cig ar et t e w as easy. T h e r aw t o b acco leaves w er e h ar vest ed and pre dried . T h ey ar r ived at Ro t h m an s in 80 K G back s. Her e, t h ey w er e sh o r t ly st ored u nt il f u r t h er p r od u ct io n f o ll o w s. Th e f ir st part o f the p r od u ct ion w as the g r een- leaves t rashing. Her e t he leaves and t he n er ves w er e sep arat ed , w ash ed , st eam ed and d r ied , cu t and b ox ed f o r a lo n g t im e st orage. T o g ain q u alit y t he t ob acco w as n o w st ored, d ep en d in g on each brand unt il ' / 2 or 1 year .

A f t er t he lo n g t im e st orage the t o b acco w as st eam ed ag ain to m ak e sure t hat it w as not b r ok en . Th en the t o b acco w as cu t int o f in al size and m ix ed w it h t he cut n er ves and w o o d . T h is w as done b y var io u s t o b acco b r and s at t he sam e t im e in one m ach in e. Th e m ix t u r e o f t o b acco w as called a b lend . T h e b lend was cast ed w it h a f l av o r t o g ive it som e sp ecif ic tast e and d r ied . A f t er the d r yin g , the t o b acco goes f o r t ree d ays into a co ld st orage.

(6)

25 T h e I n t e r n a t i o n a l J o u r n a l o f A c c o u n t i n g a n d B u s i n e s s S o c i e t y

Th e b len d w as f ed int o t he st ick - m ak in g m ach in e at t he m ak in g d ep ar t m ent . Her e t he b lend w as r o lled int o a p ap er and a f i lt er w as g lu ed to it. Th e st ick s ag ain go int o a co ld st orage f o r t hree d ays.

Fi n al l y , the st ick s w er e p ack ed int o p ack s, sleeves and b ox es. A f t er that t he box es h ave to be st ored f o r 7 d ays f o r good q u alit y. A f t e r t hat t h ey w er e d ist r ib u t ed to the var io u s sales- point s.

Th e b asic o f t h is lo g ist ical p rocess o f the f act o r y in M al an g can also be seen in f ig u r e 2. K O O P and som e lo g ist ical co re d ef in it io n s are also present ed.

T h e L i m i t s o f T h e I n v e s t i g a t i o n

Th e in vest ig at io n f ocused on the p r im ar y p r o d u ct io n p r ocess at o p er at io n al and t act ical level (as also can be seen in f ig u r e 2 and 3 on page 13 / 14, lim it s o f the o r g an iz at ion : Th e area w it h in t he d ot t ed lin e is t he to be in vest ig at ed ar ea). T h e b asic cig ar et t e m ak in g p r ocess w as an alyz ed . H o w ever , one t h in g not t ak en int o acco u n t w as the long t im e st orage. T h is w as b ecause d ecisio n s f o r p u r ch asin g w er e m ad e b y an ex p ert gr ou p , co n sist in g o f f arm ers and g r o w in g sp ecialist s. Th e m ost im p or t an t here w as t he q u ali t y o f t he t o b acco , the ch ar act er ist ics o f a t o b acco h ar vest and long- t erm h ar vest plans. Th e in vest ig at o r s d id not k n o w ver y m u ch ab out t his t o g ive an o p in io n and leave t h er ef o r e t h is part o f the p rocess to t h eir co u n t erp ar t s in Wag en i n g en .

Becau se o f t his, t he p u r ch asin g o f r aw m at er ials w as t he lef t lim it at io n o f the in vest ig at io n .

Fu r t h er , b ecau se all st r at eg ically d ecisio n s w er e m ad e in Jak ar t a, the w o r k in M al an g co u ld o n ly span t act ical and o p er at io n al d ecisio n s. T h e r esear ch w as lim it ed to that . On som e p oint s, som e o p in io n s w er e g iven co n cer n in g the st r at eg ic level.

A t t he end o f t he process t he prod uct s w'ould be d ist r ib u t ed . So m e d eliver ies w er e g o in g d i r ect ly to 40 d ist r ib u t o r s, but m ost o f t he d eli ver i es are g oing to- a st op- point (w ar eh o u se). On ever y m aj o r islan d w as a st op- point . As ex am p le Su m at r a has 2 st op- point s. Th e islan d s Su m at r a, Ja v a , Ba l i and Lo m b o k p r o d u ct s are d eliver ed b y t ru ck . Fo r the o t h er islan d s t he p r o d u ct s are d eliver ed b y b oat f r om Su r ab aya. A l l t he d el iver i es are ar r an g ed f r om Jak ar t a and t h er ef o r e not co n d u ct ed in t his research.

(7)
(8)

To b acco Cig aret t es

[ S o u rc e : H e i j n s d i j k P j

26

H

o

w

F

a

s

t

T

o

b

a

c

c

o

C

a

n

B

e

(9)
(10)

^

-1

r<

~

i

28 H o w F a s t T o b a c c o C a n B e

M e t h o d o f I n v e s t i g a t i o n

T h e o ver al l m et hod o f research w as t he Bl a c k Bo x ap p r oach acco r d in g to In t V e Id G. T h is is b ecause o f t he co m p lex it y and open- end nes o f the p r ob lem d escr ip t io n . Becau se o f the locat ion o f the in vest ig at o r s (g eo g r ap h ical) and t h eir p lace w i t h i n t he o rg an iz at io n , t he in vest ig at io n had to be con d u ct ed ^ 0£ 0m, up A t 0 P ' d °w n ap p r oach m ay not be su ccessf u l b ecau se o f the d if f i cu lt ies o f o b t ain in g m at er ial f r om Jak ar t a (Jak ar t a- M alan g , 1200 K m ) and the secr ecy o f core- dat a. D u e to t he p h ilo so p h y b eh in d t h is bot t om - up resear ch the id eas o f Go l d r at t E w er e ad op t ed, co n cer n in g t h r ou g h p u t , in ven t o r y and op er at ion ex p enses. Th e t h r ou g h p u t w i l l r em ain const an t , t he in ven t o r y and o p er at io n ex p en ses w i l l be red uced .

The p r ocess st eps w er e in the f o llo w in g order: 1. Est ab lish in g a g lo b al v i e w o f the f act o r y

. Sp eci al iz ed v i e w ab ou t t he p r od u ct io n process

. Sp ecializ ed v i e w ab ou t t he o ccu p at ion level o f m ach in es and t he ef f i ci en cy o f t he use o f r eso u r ces

4. A n al y si s o f t he p r o b lem part s 5. So lu t io n s to the prob lem parts.

Sp ecial at t en t ion w as paid to the an alysis o f t he o ccu p at io n level o f m ach in es and m easu r em en t o f the ef f ic i en cy o f t he r esou r ces b ecau se t his is the st ar t ing p o in t f o r f ar t h er research. Gr ap h i cal l y t he in vest ig at io n can be seen in

(11)

2 9 T h e I n t e r n a t i o n a l J o u r n a l o f A c c o u n t i n g a n d B u s i n e s s S o c i e t y

f ig u r e 4: O v e r v i e w o f o u t lin e and m et hod.

Lo w e r p r o d u ct io n cost o f t he f act o r y

1f

O v e r v i e w o f the

r

Pr o d u ct io n processes

Pr o d u ct i vit y an alysis

M easu r em en t o f r esou r ces

Cap aci t y an alysis M M O

• In t er vi ew s w it h em p lo yees • Plan t tours

Bo t t len eck an alysis

• A n al y z i n g h ist o r ical d at a

• In t er vi ew s w it h em p lo yees • M M O

FIG U R E 4: O V ER V I EW O F O U T L IN E A N D M ET H O D [Sou rce Own i n v e s t i g a t e ]

Th e m et hod s o f r esear ch f o r the steps 1,2,3 and 4 w i l l be disgust .

(12)

G l o b a l V i e w o f T h e F a c t o r y

A g eneral im p r essio n o f t h e co m p an y w as est ab lish ed b y r ead in g d o cu m en t s, in t er vi ew s w i t h m an ag er s and v i ew i n g t h e f act o r y. A s a b asis f or t h is r esear ch t he "p r o cesco n t in g en t ieb en ad r ein g " acco r d in g t o Heij n sd ij k p w as used. T h e co m p let e r ep o rt o f t h is can be f o u n d in A p p en d i x 2 : K i n d o f o r g an iz at ion acco r d in g to Heij n sd ij k p Ro t h m an s is d ef in ed as a b u r eau cr at ic o r g an iz at ion in all its f u lln ess.

G l o b a l V i e w o f T h e L o g i s t i c a l / P r o d u c t i o n F u n c t i o n

T o f o cu s t he p r o d u ct io n process, a q u est io n n air e w as m ad e b ased on t he m o d el o f "We r k e n m et Lo g is t iek ", acco r d in g t o V i ss e r / V . Go o r K, co ver in g 7 m aj o r part s o f b u siness lo g ist ics. Th is q u est io n n air e d ealt w i t h t h e f o ll o w i n g head ing s:

1. Pr o d u ct io n , p lan n in g and co n t r o llin g 2. Pu r ch asin g

3. In ven t o r y m an ag em en t 4. M at er ial s h an d lin g

5. In ven t o r y co n t r o l o f f in ish ed goods 6. Dep o t s and in ven t o r y

7. Tr an sp o r t at io n d ecisio n s

Based on t he in f or m at io n ob t ained b y t he ab o ve q u est ion s, the f o l l o w i n g part s w er e co nst ru ct ed : A d et ailed f lo w - ch ar t (A p p en d ix 4 ). Th e m at er ial m o vem en t (A p p en d i x 5 ), an o v er v i ew o f t h e p lan n in g - syst em , an o v er v i ew o f depot s, m eans o f in t er n al and ex t er nal t r an sp o r t at io n , m at er ials h an d lin g and p u r ch asin g (A p p en d i x 3 ). So r r y, not f in ish ed ..

A n a l y s i s o f O c c u p a t i o n L e v e l s a n d E f f i c i e n c y o f T h e U s e o f R e s o u r c e s

T h e co r e p o in t o f in vest ig at io n co n sist ed o f t w o cl o sely co n n ect ed part s. On e w as t he b o t t len eck an alysis w h ich m easu r ed t he ef f i ci en cy o f each - st ep in t he p r od u ct io n p r ocess and the secon d w as t he p er f o r m an ce in d icat o r

w h i ch m easu r ed t he ef f i ci en cy o f all t he reco u r ses in t he p r ocess.

B o t t l e n e c k A n a l y s i s

T o g ive a st r uct u red o ver v i ew o f t he cap aci t y and t h e var io u s t ask s w it h in t he p r od u ct io n p r ocess, A ald er sA m o d el o f m ach in e use w as co p ied . Th e m o d el can be vi ew ed in f ig u r e 5.

30 H o w F a s t T o b a c c o C a n % e : ...

(13)

31 T h e I n t e r n a t i o n a l J o u r n a l o f A c c o u n t i n g a n d B u s i n e s s S o c i e t y

A v ai l ab l e p r o d u ct io n t im e, am o u n t o f p r o d u ct ion 1 0 0 %

Up t im e D o w n

t im e Real p r od u ct io n t im e Wai t i n g

t im e Usef u l p r o d u ct io n Sl ac k

t im e

FI G U R E 5: A N A L Y SI S O F BO T T L EN EC K [Sou r ce Aald er sA]

T h e q u an t it ies w h ich w er e in vest ig at ed w er e: Ho u r s a d ay f o r r ep air in g each m ach in e

Ho u r s a d ay o f w ai t in g , p r od u ct io n on r ed u ced speed o r er r or s in the

Ho u r s a d ay lost d ue to slack .

A lso , t he w ast e o f m at er ials w as m easu red w it h each o f t he ab o ve q u an t it ies.

Th ese q u an t it ies w er e m easured o ver 19 m aj o r st eps o f t he p r od u ct io n p rocess as ab st ract ed f r om the f lo w - ch ar t (A p p en d ix 4 ).

P r o d u c t i v i t y a n a l y s i s ( e f f i c i e n c y ) , t h e p e r f o r m a n c e o f t h e p r o c e s s

T h e g o al o f t h is an alysis w as to m easu re i f t he r eco u r ses f o r p r o d u ct io n w er e m in im iz ed to each step in the p r od u ct io n process. In f ig u r e 6 yo u w i l l see h o w t he r eso u r ces w er e in vo lved in the co m p o n en t s o f lo g ist ics m an ag em en t . p rocess

V o l . 12, N o . 1 Ju l y 2004 © Cen t r e f o r In d o n esian A cco u n t i n g and M an ag em en t Resear ch

(14)

32 H o w F a s t T o b a c c o C a n B e :

FIG U RE 6: C O M PO N EN T S OF [Source: Coun cil o f Log ist ics Managem ent B] L O G IST IC S M A N A G EM EN T

Per st ep o f t h e p r od u ct io n process, it w as m easu r ed h o w m an y p er cen t o f t he u sef u l p r o d u ct io n t im e w as lost due to h um an , cap it al (m ach i n e) o r nat ure (m at er ial).

T h e m ax im u m p o ssib le p r od u ct io n w as alm o st in all cases m ad e use o f the t ech n ical sp ecif icat io n s o f t he m ach in es in t hat st ep o f t he p r o d u ct io n . Th e co m p let e o v e r v i e w o f t he b o t t len eck an alysis an d t h e r esou r ces an alyses, acco r d in g t o A al d er sA , can be f o u n d in f ig u r e 7.

T h e u se o f m ach i n es

Availab le production time, amount o f production 1 0 0 %

Up time Down

time

Real production time

Wait in g time

Useful production time

Slack

Rep air Availab ilit y :

Capit al Resource Change

Sm all stops

Reduced speed Perf orm ance:

Hum an Resource Wait in g

Malf u n ct ion Starting/ Stop

- M k t f r ila f * , Resou r ce *

(15)

33 T h e I n t e r n a t i o n a l J o u r n a l o f A c c o u n t i n g a n d B u s i n e s s S o c i e t y

FIG U RE 7: A N A L Y SIS O F BO T T L EN EC K / RESO U RC ES [Sou rce Aald er sA] T h e w h o le b o t t len eck and p er f o r m an ce in vest ig at io n s are su m m ar iz ed in the ef f i ci en cy d iag r am (t h is w i l l be f u ll y ex p lain ed in ch ap t er 4 ).

E f f i c i e n c y d i a g r a m , t h e c o m b i n a t i o n o f b o t t l e n e c k a n d p r o d u c t i v i t y

a n a l y s i s

A s can be seen in f ig u r e 7. the b o t t len eck an alysis and t he p er f o r m an ce in d icat o r w er e the sam e in vest ig at io n . O n l y the n u m b er o f calcu lat io n w as d if f er en t . Th er ef o r e t hey w er e co m b in ed in the ef f ic i en cy m at r ix as sho w n b elo w in t ab le 1.

Nat ur e Nat u re Cap it al Ef f i ci en cy

Resou rces Resources Resources Sur p lus

Ef f i ci en cy Su r p lu s

Tot al Over all

Aver ag e Ef f i ci en cy

Def in e in ef f icien t resource

I A BL E 1: SU M M A RY OF EFFIC IEN C Y D IA G RA M [Source: Ow n Investigation!

T o co m p let e t his ef f i cien cy d iag r am , var io u s m easu r em en t s and calcu lat io n s w er e und ert ak en to g at her the co r r ect dat a. Th e d at a f or the ef f i cien cy d iag r am w as f or a great deal ob t ained f r om a M M O (m u lt i m om en t o p n ain e), acco r d in g to Tipp et t ,. D u r in g a t w o w eek t im e st u d y (n o r m al p r od u ct io n w eek ) w e m ad e 6650 m easu r em en t s w h i ch spread o ver 19 p rocess steps (3 5 0 m easu r em en t s per st ep). Th e o ver all o ccu p at io n level w as calcu lat ed at 3 0 %. T h e st and ard d eviat io n w as 2 .5 %. Wi t h a r eli ab il it y o f 9 5 % w e can say that tlu? true o ccu p at io n level w as b et w een 2 5 %- 3 5 %.

T h e m ax im u m avail ab le p r o d u ct ion t im es per st ep o f t he p r o d u ct ion w er e o b t ain ed b y in t er view s w it h k ey- em p lo yees at each st ep and b y lo o k in g at t ech n ical m ach in e data. Th e w ast e o f p r od u ct ion t im e d ue t o m ach in e, m at er ial and hum an u n p r o d u ct ivit y w er e sub t ract ed f r om that and t he o ccu p at io n level w as the r em ain in g .

V o l . 12, No . 1 Ju l y 2004 © Cen t r e f o r In d o n esian Acco u n t in g and M an ag em en t Resear ch Post g r ad u at e Pr o g r am , Br a w i j a y a Un iv er si t y

Task 1 % Nat ur e % Hum an % Cap it al Ef f i ci en cy

(16)

34 H o w F a s t T o b a c c o C a n B e :

A n a l y s i s o f t h e p r o b l e m s

In t er est in g result s f r o m t he ef f i ci en cy d iag r am w er e:

• Pack ag i n g d ep ar t m ent (b o t t len eck ) • Hu m an r esou rce (least ef f icien t r esou r ce) • (H i g h st o ck l evels)

Fu r t h er an alysis o f t hose t hree "p r o b lem s" w as ag ain based on in t er view s w it h em p lo yees and som e sm aller "t im e- st u d ies".

R e s u l t s o f T h e A n a l y s i s

Becau se o f t he d u al it y o f the in vest ig at io n t his ch ap t er is d ivi d ed into t w o part s. Par t one d escr ib es t he b o t t len eck an alysis, its cr it i cal p o int s and result s. Par t t w o is t he ef f ic i en cy an alysis.

T h e b o t t l e n e c k

A f t e r the co n st r u ct io n o f the ef f i ci en cy d iag r am , t h e p ack ag in g d ep ar t m en t co u ld be d ist illed (o ccu p at io n level o f 6 4 % ) as b o t t len eck . In t he

p ack ag in g d ep ar t m en t w er e 1 3 m ach in es r u n n in g f o r 9 p r od u ct s. In Ap p en d ix 7

the r esu lt o f t he w h o le f act o r y an alysis can be seen. A f t er t h is an alysis w e m ad e t he sam e k in d o f b o t t len eck in vest ig at io n lik e t he p r evio u s o n e o n l y t h is t im e is sp ecializ ed (z o o m in ) on t he p ack ag in g d ep art m ent .

In t he p ack ag in g d ep ar t m en t w as one m ach in e t he m ain - b o t t len eck . It had an o ccu p at io n level o f 1 0 2 % , it m eans t hat t he d ail y d em an d w as im p o ssib le to p r od u ce w i t h i n t he n or m al 8 h ours w o r k - t im e. T h i s m ach in e p ack ag e t he D I and D IM .

Th e o t h er m ach in es in the p ack ag in g d ep ar t m en t had an o ccu p at ion level less t han 7 0 % . S o t he d ai l y d em an d co u ld be m an ag ed t h eo r et ically. Th e r esu lt o f t h is zoom an alysis can be seen in Ap p en d i x 8.

M o n e y t a lk s

185 em p lo yees w er e i n vo l ved d ir ect l y in t he p r o d u ct io n p r ocess in M alan g , 106 em p lo yees in d ir ect ly in clu d in g t he m an ag er s on t he w o r k f lo o r . 7 2 em p lo yees w er e part o f t he st af f or w o r k i n g on high level as m an ag er s.

(17)

• T h e m in im u m w ag e in In d o n esia w er e ap p r o x im at ely FI. 800,- each year . ( R P?)

• T h e aver ag e w ag e o f em p lo yees at t he M alan g f act o r y w as FI. 2825,-each year .

• T h e aver ag e o f 1 n or m al lab or- hour cost s Ro t h m an s FI. 1,36 each person.

• T h e aver ag e o f I ex t r a lab or- hour (o ver - w o r k ) cost s Ro t h m an s FI. 3,82 each person.

In 1997 t h er e w er e 65.406 ex t ra lab o r hours. Co m b in ed w it h 260 w o r k i n g d ays a year , t hat m eans Ro t h m an s had an aver ag e o f 251 h ours a d ay ex t ra lab o r hours. Th er ef o r e all em p lo yees (d ir ect ly and in d ir ect ly i n vo l ved ) w er e w o r k in g n in e hours a day.

T h e g en er al m easu r ed out p ut in st ick s had an aver ag e o f 9 m il li o n per w o r k in g d ay (8 h o u r s). Th e aver ag e sales vo lu m e o f Ro t h m an s w as 10 m iil io n st ick s a d ay. Th er ef o r e one ex t ra lab or h ou r w as used ever y d ay t o m ak e the m issin g 1 m il li o n st ick s.

A cco r d i n g to t he in vest ig at io n cap aci t y o f t he var io u s steps in the p r o d u ct io n process, t hese cost s w er e not n ecessar y. T h er e w as o n ly one m ach in e in the w h o le f act o r y, w h ich co u ld not m at ch w it h t he d ail y d em an d , the aver ag e o f 10 m il li o n st ick s. T h e p ack ag in g m ach in e. A t t h is m ach in e t here w er e 6 em p lo yees w o r k in g . T h ey had to w o r k t h eo r et ically 1 h o u r each d ay

ex t r a to m at ch w i t h t he d ai l y d em and .

Ef f i c i e n c y

A lo o k at t he ef f i cien cy d iag r am sh o w ed yo u t hat the h um an r eco u r se w as t he least ef f icien t . See t ab le 2.

35 T h e I n t e r n a t i o n a l J o u r n a l o f A c c o u n t i n g a n d B u s i n e s s S o c i e t y

Cau se % T im e

Red u ced speed 2 4 ,8 % 2h.

Wai t i n g 2 3 ,9 % 1 h 5 5 m in.

M alf u n ct i o n o f Pr ocess

1 ,0 % 5 m in.

St art in g / St o p p in g 3 , 1 % 14 m in

To t al 5 2 ,8 % 4h 1 5 m in.

T A B L E 2: I N EF F I C I EN C Y O F H U M A N R ESO U R C ES [Source: Ow n research]

(18)

36 H o w F a s t T o b a c c o C a n B e :

Ro u g h l y 4 h ours a d ay em p lo yees w er e not i n vo l ved in act u al p r od u ct io n . A short v i e w ab ou t t he t w o m ain causes can be f o u n d b elo w (see Red u ced Sp eed and Wai t i n g T i m e)

R e d u c e d s p e e d

T h e Red u ced speed f ig u r e w as t he h ig h est w ast e p r od u cer (g o o d f or 2 hours a d ay) but had to be view ed w i t h cau t io n . Th is f ig u r e w as a co m b in at io n o f t he act u al m easu r ed n u m b er o f em p lo yees at a g iven t im e at the m ach in e and t h e speed o f p r od u ct io n . In m at h em at ical form :

100 (# p resen t em p lo yees) ^

N o r m al nr. O f em p lo yees at m ach in e * % Wo r k i n g

RS = ”

100

Esp eci al l y the w o r k i n g speed w as v er y in d icat ive. Ap ar t f r om t hat , i f the w o r k i n g speed w as view ed as a p r ob lem , one had to co n sid er the cu lt u r e o f In d o n esia, w h i ch w as not a hard w o r k i n g cu lt u r e, acco r d in g to N ai sb i t t H. T h is m ad e t he r ed u ced speed f act o r t hat w as not a m ain p o int o f int erest f o r f u r t h er in vest ig at io n . O n ly a r em ar k w as m ad e that t his f act o r co u ld be an in t er est in g p o int f or f u r t h er st ud y. A sp ecial p oint o f int erest co u ld be t he w ag e syst em o f Rot h m an s.

W a i t i n g t im e

H o li d ay at Ro t h m an s. Each w o r k i n g d ay 1 h and 55- min t he p r od u ct io n em p lo yees spend w it h w ait in g . Ro u g h l y 7 0 % o f t his t im e w as w ai t in g f or ord ers and 3 0 % f or m at er ials.

Th e w ait in g t im e f o r ord ers o ccu r r ed b ecau se the p lan n ing - syst em d id not m at ch w it h t he f act o r y d em an d (o t h er w ise t here w o u ld be no w ai t in g f o r ord ers or m at er ials, w o u ld t h er e?). T h e w ai t i n g t im e f o r m at er ials, in d icat ed p r ob lem s w it h the m at er ials h an d ling .

A n al y si s o f t he p r od u ct io n p lan n in g result ed in t he in sig h t t hat the p lan n in g - syst em had a co r r ect n ess o f 2 7 % (st d . 3 3 %), see A p p en d ix 9, and that 's am az ing .

(19)

37 T h e I n t e r n a t i o n a l J o u r n a l o f A c c o u n t i n g a n d B u s i n e s s S o c i e t y

Let 's t ak e a lo o k at t he f act o r y:

A d ep ar t m en t got its p r od u ct ion o rd ers ever y m o r n in g f rom t he boss. A s soon as t hey w an t ed to start p r o d u cin g , t h ey f in d out t hat input m at er ials w er e not avail ab le. T h ey called f o r the boss. Th e boss now' look ed in the var io u s depot 's and ch an g ed the p lan n in g ag ain. T h is ch an g e h o w ever w as not b r ief ed to t he ot her p r o d u ct io n chef s.

T h e lit t le st o r y in d icat ed t hree m aj o r p r o b lem s o f t he p lan n ing / co n t r o llin g syst em :

• T h e cen t raliz at io n o f the d ecision - au t h o r it y. • Th e f r eelan cin g o f t he vario u s d ecision - m ak er s. • A p lan n in g - syst em t hat can not co p e w i t h t his.

A ls o : Th e cu r ren t p lan n in g - syst em w as f o cu sed on p r o d u cin g to cu st o m er w ish es. Th e cu st o m er w as t ak en m u ch to f ar int o t he o rg an iz at io n . Becau se o f t he p r ed ict ab ili t y o f t he sales, an on in ven t o r y f o cu sed p lan n in g - syst em w o u ld be en o u g h f o r Ro t h m an s.

Th e ab o ve g ave t hree p o ssib le im p r o vem en t target s. Reo r g an iz in g t he d ecisio n au t h o rit y, r est r ict in g t he f r eelan cin g o f t he var io u s d ecision - m ak er s or m ak in g a p lan n in g syst em t hat co u ld h an d le t hose t w o sit uat ions.

T h e c e n t r a l i z a t i o n o f t h e d e c i s i o n a u t h o r it y7

D iscu ssio n s w it h Rot h m an s r esult ed in t he p o in t t hat it w as not w ish f u l to d ecen t r aliz e t he d ecision au t h o r it y. A l so b ecause Ro t h m an s w as a ver y b u r eau cr at ic o rg an iz at io n and t he cu lt u r e o f In d o n esia w h i ch w as not st ron g in m ak in g p erso n al d ecision s. A t t his t im e Ro t h m an s had 185 d ir ect p r od u ct io n w or k er s. 5 d ep ar t m en t m an ag er s m ad e the d ecisio n f o r t h eir d ep ar t m en t to ch an g e the p r od u ct io n p r ocess to an ot h er product . T h i s m ad e t he span o f co n t ro l on aver ag e 37 and t his f alse w it h in the span o f co n t r o l st at ed as n or m al by Heij n sd ij k p . T h er ef o r , t he d ecen t r aliz at io n o f t he d ecisio n au t h o r it y w as not r ej ect ed as p o in t o f im p r o vem en t .

T h e f r e e l a n c i n g o f t h e v a r i o u s d e c i s i o n - m a k e r s

(20)

Th e 5 m aj o r d ecision - m ak er s ch an g ed the p r o d u ct io n p lan n in g on a r eg u lar basis (al w ay s ). Th e causes t h er ef o r e w er e var io u s, st ar t in g w i t h u n avail ab i l i t y o f in p u t m at er ial, en d in g w i t h t he co m p an y p o l i cy o f m in im u m runs et c. Th e m o st h ear d ar g u m en t w as t hat t he d ep ar t m en t m an ag er s ch eck t he en d - in ven t o r y and upon t hat in f or m at io n t h ey r ear ran g ed t he p r od u ct io n process. Th e d ecision - m ak er s d id not p lan and p r od u ce syst em at ical. Th e co m m u n icat io n b et w een t he var io u s d ecisio n - m ak er s w as not o p t im al.

A p l a n n i n g - s y s t e m t h a t c a n n o t c o p e w i t h t h is

T h e cu r r en t p lan n in g - syst em w as f o cu sed on a m ar k et f o r ecast . It w as a k ind o f sim p l if i ed M RP- syst em . Ex am p le o f M R P co u ld be w r it t en in Gai t h er D. On p ap er t h is syst em w o r k ed w el l but p r ob lem s cam e aw ak e at t he d ai l y and m o n t h ly p lan n in g 's m eet ing s. T h e var io u s ch an g ed in t h e p lan n in g w er e d iscu ssed but t he f act t hat st orage t im es had t o be ar o u n d t h r ee d ays, co m p licat ed t he o v er v i ew o f t h is m eet ings. An o t h er p r o b lem w as t hat the p lan n in g - syst em w as based on a cu st o m er d em an d . T h e act u al p lan n in g at Ro t h m an s w as in t he f ir st in st an ce based on t he m ar k et in g f o recast but then m ix ed w i t h t he in ven t o r y levels. T h is o u t co m e w as t he act u al p r od u ct ion p lan n in g . Th er e w as a gap b et w een t he m ar k et in g p lan n in g (o r d er based, m ad e in Jak ar t a) and t he p r od u ct io n p lan n in g (st o ck level based, m ad e in M alan g ).

Fur t h er , ch an g es in t he p r o d u ct io n p r ocess shou ld also be ch an g ed in the p lan n in g syst em w h ic h w as m o st ly not done.

T h is in d icat ed t hat t he cu r ren t w ay o f p lan n in g d id not su p p o rt the w ay the f act o r y runs. In ef f ici en t co m m u n icat io n and a bad p lan n in g - syst em w er e the causes here f or.

C h a n g i n g t h e p l a n n i n g - s y s t e m

T o im p r o ve t he p lan n in g - syst em and im p r o ve t he co m m u n icat io n , t hree m aj o r ch o ices w er e open:

• Im p lem en t in g a co n sist en t cust om er- based p lan n in g syst em ( M R P). • Ch an g i n g to inven t o r y- b ased p r o d u ct io n .

• Im p r o vin g t he cl ar it y o f t he t ot al v i e w in t he p lan n in g 's m eet ing s.

A c u s t o m e r - b a s e d p l a n n i n g - s y s t e m ( M R P )

I f t he t rend o f t he h ead - of f ice in Jak ar t a w as f o llo w ed , it w as w ise to im p lem en t an all ord er- based p lann ing - syst em . H o w ever , t h is hacl som e m aj o r d r aw b ack s. Fir st o f all, a M R1 P syst em m eans t hat ever y cu st o m er w as not ed by 38 H o w F a s t T o b a c c o C a n B e : ...

(21)

it selves. T h i s m eans, or ver y short runs or g r ou p in g o f a lot o f or d er s on a huge p lann in g - b oard . A p ar t f r om t hat , one o f the ad van t ag es o f an M R P syst em w as t hat one ex act ly co u ld p r o d u ce w h at the m ar k et w an t ed at an y g iven t im e and t h er ef o r e al l o w i n g an in- st able m ar k et d em an d . H o w ever , t he m ar k et d em an d f o r Ro t h m an s w as ver y p r ed ict ab le and const ant . Fu r t h er t o t hat , I f on e p lan n ed p r od u ct ion to o rd ers, t he K O O P w o u ld be b ef or e p r o d u ct io n . A t Ro t h m an s the K O O P w as at t he end in ven t o r y. So all act ivit i es sh o u ld be based on p lan n in g . Fo r the ab o ve r easons, a M R I P k ind o f syst em w as rej ect ed .

I n v e n t o r y - b a s i-« l p r o d u c t i o n

In f avo r o f t he f act o r y at M al an g and the K O O P, one w o r k ed acco r d in g t o an in ven t o r y based p lan n in g . Th is w as a ver y f avo r ab le solu t io n . Sp e ci al l y , i f one t ook int o acco u n t the p o ssib ilit ies o f f ix ed p r od u ct io n runs.

I m p r o v i n g t h e c l a r i t y o f t h e t o t a l v i e w in t h e p l a n n i n g - m e e t i n g s

An o t h er p o ssib le so lu t io n w as im p r o vin g t he in f or m at io n m an ag em en t at t he p lan n in g 's m eet in g s. T h is solu t ion w as p r o b ab ly not t he m ost "b eau t i f u l" in b usiness en g in eer in g t erm s but the easiest one. It w as also t he least t im e and en er g y co n su m in g f o r Rot h m an s.

C o n c l u s i o n s

B o t t l e n e c k

Co n clu sio n s:

• Th e p r od u ct io n process at Rot h m an s had in g en er al a h igh cap acit y. O n l y 3 0 % o f t his w er e used in 1998.

• Occu p at io n levels o f the f act o ry co u ld not j u s t i f y ex t r a lab o r hours last year .

• Th e p ack ag in g d ep ar t m ent had the lo w est cap aci t y. T h er ef o r t his d ep ar t m en t w as the b ot t leneck .

• Th e D I and D IM p ack ag in g m ach in e had not en oug h cap aci t y to p ack t he d ail y d em an d in the nor m al 8 hours w o r k in g t im e. T h is m ach in e w as t h er ef o r e the m ain b o t t len eck . It had an o ccu p at io n level o f 1 0 2 %. • D esp it e ex p ect at ion s t he process sho w ed a r at h er lo w d o w n t im e and

slack f igu r e.

T h e H u m a n R e s o u r c e

A b et t er p lan n in g - syst em w o u ld r ed u ce the w ait in g t im e f o r the em p lo yees (n o w 2 hours a d ay). Th e r ed u ct io n s o f t he w ai t i n g t im e b y o n ly one 39 T h e I n t e r n a t i o n a l J o u r n a l o f A c c o u n t i n g a n d B u s i n e s s S o c i e t y

(22)

h o u r w o u l d r esu lt in a t o t al an n i h i l at i o n o f t he ex t r a lab o r co st s an d t h er ef o r e a co st r ed u ct i o n o f ap p . R I P 1 b i l l i o n a year .

40 H o w F a s t T o b a c c o C a n B e : ...

It we t ake a deeper look into the cult ure at Rot hm ans and In d o n esia in general, it was not lik ely that students or low level em p loyees g ave t heir op inio n about resp on sib ilit ies o f t heir superior. Th er ef o r e all the solutions g iven had to be im p lem en t ed by one o f the m anagers w h o had to be co n vin ced about the solution and its effect.

(23)

41 T h e I n t e r n a t i o n a l J o u r n a l o f A c c o u n t i n g a n d B u s i n e s s S o c i e t y

I m p l e m e n t a t i o n o f M o d e l

So let's t alk st ruct ured . Let 's im p r o ve the co n st r u ct io n o f t he p lan n in g at the Ro t h m an s f act o ry. Th e m ain p r o b lem s w er e caused b y t he m in im u m st orage t im e o f all st ock (3 d ay's). A f u r t h er p r o b lem w as the var io u s inp ut m at er ial (b an d r o l. f ilt er et c) and g et t ing t hem on t im e to the p r o d u ct io n .

T o st r uct u re t he m eet ing s an Ex cel sheet had been m ad e co ver in g one p r od u ct io n year. Th e m ar k et in g f ig u r es had to be insert ed int o t his. T h e lo g ist ic m an ag er t hen r eg r ou p ed t he ord ers to dat e and leavin g f ig u r es. T h en , the d ep ar t m ent m an ag er s had to g roup t he p r od u ct io n runs int o ef f icien t runs and level the seco n d ar y m at er ials to t his.

Th e w o r k i n g o f t h is sheet had been ex p lain ed to t he m an ag er s. T h ey w er e w i l l i n g to use it. I f a d ep art m ent co u ld not f u l f i l l t he p lan n in g , the p lan n in g - syst em w as ch an g ed acco r d in g to t his. A r em ar k w as m ad e t hat the st ock levels p r o b ab l y w o u ld rise, w h i ch w as t rue. Bu t it d id not m ak e an y d if f er en ce in f i n an ci al aspect s. Th e r aw m at er ials w er e lyin g f o r 1 year on st ock an yw ay.

A p oint o f r em ar k w as m ad e that t his o n l y co u ld be a t em p o r ar ily im p r o vem en t . T o sm o o t h in g the p r od u ct ion process even m ore, the w h o le p lan n in g - syst em had to be ch an g ed int o an on p lan n in g based in f or m at io n

syst em .

A long t im e im p r o vem en t w o u ld be an in ven t o r y o rien t ed p lan n ing - syst em . It w o u ld o p t im iz e its p r od u ct io n ef f ici en cy. Esp e c i a l l y w h en one t o ok int o acco u n t the p o ssib ilit y o f p r o d u cin g to a f ix ed w eek l y p r o d u ct io n sch ed u le. Th is w o u l d not o n ly im p r o ve ef f ic i en cy but also si g n if ican t ly clear t he p lan n in g and p r od u ct io n rout ine.

E v a l u a t i o n

Th e st rengt h o f t he in vest ig at io n w as the w ay t he m et hod s w er e used. Th e m et hod s f it t ed ex act ly in each ot her. Th at m ad e t he in vest ig at io n as a r eliab le in vest ig at io n . T h e r esult s o f the in vest ig at io n w er e also in co m m o n w it h t he p r o b lem d escr ip t io n .

Th e w eak n ess o f the in vest ig at io n w as t he m issin g o f a f in an cial secu r it y o f t he r eco m m en d at ion . O f co u r se Ro t h m an s lik ed to k n o w w h at the am o u n t o f cost r ed u ct io n w as i f t h ey f o l l o w the r eco m m en d at io n . In t he f irst p lace it w as hard to get t he o b j ect io n o f t he in vest ig at io n int o a q u an t it at ive

(24)

42 H o w F a s t T o b a c c o C a n B e :

num b er. A f t er the in vest ig at io n it w as d eclar ed , the r esult s o f the in vest ig at io n w er e m o re in d i cat ive t han ab solut e. T h is w as b ecau se o f t he w ay o f in vest ig at io n f o ll o w i n g Du t ch st udent s' levels.

It w as g o in g to be hard f o r Ro t h m an s to ad ap t on t he w ay the in vest ig at io n w as held and n at u r ally the result s o f t he in vest ig at io n . It w as not su it ab le w it h t he In d o n esian cu lt u r e. Th e p r ob lem lied on t he w ay h o w to ex p ress o n es cr it icism . N o r m al l y In d o n esian s d id not g ive d ir ect cr it i cism to each o t h er and m ost o f t hem f eel r eluct an t to g ive cr it icism .

Th e m o r al f o r Rot h m an s w as int erest ing. It w as t he f ir st t im e r esear ch er s o b ser ved the p r od u ct ion process. Th e k ey- em p lo yees had n ow an id ea o f h o w o u t sid er s look at t he process o f t he f act o r y in M alan g . T h ey co u ld learn f r om t h is p oin t o f vi ew .

So m e in t eiest in g lit erat u re: Ap p en d ix 11: Co p y o f n ew sp ap er m essage ab out in cr easin g t he p r ice o f cig ar et t es Ap p en d ix 12: Ho u se o f D u n h il l

R e f e r e n c e s :

A Aald er s Read er o f “ De afst udeersfase p r ak t ij k " (Pu t s) 1993

B Co u n cil o f logist ics

m anagem ent

St rat egic logist ics m anagem ent (Lam b er t s)

C Ed w ar d s St rat egic logist ics m anagem ent (Lam b er t s)

D Gait h er Pr od uct ion and operat ions m anagem ent

E Gold r at t Th e goal, the t heory o f const raint s

\ Heijn sd ij k "Vit ale organisat ies"

G In ’ t Veld "An alyse van or g an isat iep r ob lem en "

H Naisb it t Megat rend s Asia

1 Pot gens "Het lam p m od el"

J Tip p et t Read er o f Indust rial En g in eerin g (V . Vessem )

K Visser / V. Go o r "Wer k en met lo g ist iek "

(25)

T h e I n t e r n a t i o n a l J o u r n a l o f A c c o u n t i n g a n d B u s i n e s s S o c i e t y

I o.g jjjt? ioijn sf.ra .' p m c a &s s f Ra h m a n s o f P e l l Ms<! Ind or ,93,-3

Appendix 1: The Rothmans organization

P T Ro t h m a n s o f Pa l l M all In d o n e s i a is a p ar t c f t h e Pa c i H c Re g i o n o f o n e o f e w o r l d 's m aj o r i n t er n at i o n al t o b a o c o y r o .i p s o M h e Ro t h m a n s In t er n at i o n al Gr o u p . Ro t h m a n s In t e r n a t i o n a l G r o L p n as b e e n p r o d j c m g a n d se ll in g c i g a r e t t e s f o r o v e r 1 0 0 y e a r s a n d o v e r t h o s e p ast 10 0 year s, t o ? c o m p a n y h as g ra w n o u t t o b e a m u i t i n at io n a ' o r g a n i s a t i o n t h e 4 lh l ar g est t o b a c c o se ll er c l t h e w o rid T f eir p r o d u ct s a r e so :d in o v e r 2 0 0 c o u n t r i e s an d m v o lv e w o r l d w i d e p e r a n n u T salec. of Ap p iO'< im at e y 2Q0 b I io n c i g a r e t t e s . So m e 8 0 f act o* i< !S a r o u n d :h e g l o b e ar e c o n s t an t l y i n v o l v ed i ' p r o d u c i n g 'h i s d e m a n d

T h e Ro t h m a n s i n t er n a- io Ji al G r o u p p r o d u c e s m ai n l y w h it e, n o n - k r e t ec 7 c i g a r c t t e b u t it is al s o a l e a d i n g w o rid s u p p l i e r o f c i g ar s , f in e- cu t an d p ip e t o b a c c o s T h e m aj o r t r a d e m a r k s of (h e Ro t h m a n s i n t e r n a t i o n al Gr o u p a r e Ro t h m a n s . D u n hill a n d Pe t e r St j y v e s a n : , w h i c h a r e a m o n g t h e t o p 15 i n t er n a t io n al c i g a r e t t e t r a d e m a r k s o f h e w o r l d . A p a r t f r o m t h at t h e y p r o d u c e a b r o ad r a n g e of l o cal c i g a r e t t e s an d t o b a c c o b r an d s e x p e n d i n g o n e a c h g l o b a l M t d ! K ^

To c o m p e t e in t h e g l o b al m ar k et , Ro t h m a n s In t er n at i o n al G r o u o is o r g a n i z e d in g e o g r a p h i c a l r e g i o n s an d d if f er en t Ro t h m a n s H o l d in g s Lt d . Ro t h m a n s o f Pa l l M all A u s t r a l i a Lt d . is a p u b l ic c o m p a n y t h at is o w n e d f o r 5 0 % b y t h e Ro t h m a n s In t e r n a t i o n al Gr o u p It is r e s p o n s i b l e f o r t h e A s i a Pa c i f i c c i g ar e t t e r e g io n c o v e r i n g Au st r ali a, Fij i, In d o n e s i a , Pa p u a N e w G u i n e a . N e w Z e a l a n d a n d t h e Ph i l i p p i n e s Fi g u r e 6 s h o w s h o w ‘ h e A s i a Pa c i f i c r e g io n is o r g an iz ed .

n— :z=r

n w ' . i K h » U V L R V T F W O F R O T H M A N S ' i Sl A PA< .U* 1 C' fUCWtX1- ri^ri investigation]

P T R o t f i m a n s o f P a l l M a l l I n d o n e s i a

ir )9 3 1 N V T a b a c o t m a Bo l g i u n e s t a b l i s h e d a f act o r y in M a l a n g In M a r c h 1 9 8 6 t h e t a t f u r v w a s t r a n s f e r r e d t o Ro t h i r a n s o f Pa l l M a l l A u s t r a l ia Lt d T h e y r e n a m e d it t o Pt K c t h m a n s of Pa l l M a l l In d o n e s i a a n d w a s o f f icial ly r e o p e n e d u n d e* its n e w n a m e o n t h e

1 ~11' of Se p t e m b e r 1 9 8 7 .

T h e c o m p a n y is o n e o f t h e l ar g est w h i t e c i g a r e t t e m a n u f a c t u r e r s m In d o n e s i a T h e c o m p a n y p r o d u c e s d o m e s t i c b r an d an d i n t er n at io n al b r an d s o f w h i t e c i g a r e t t e s . T h e p r o d u c t s t h at Ro t h m a n s o f Pa l l 'M a l l In d o n e s i a t r a d u c e s a r e D u n h i l l a n d M a r s Br a n d f or t h e In t e r n a t i o n a l m a r k e t a n d K a n s a s , W h i t e H o r s e a n d Gl u e Ri b b o n f or '.he d o m e s t i c n 'H 'V e t T h e s e b r a n d s a r e a v a i l a b :e in d if f er en t s i z e s p a c k a g e ?, an d m er .t h o l v e r s i o n s

T Ve n e a d o f f i c e of Ro t h m a n s o f Pa l l M all In d o n e s i a is si t u a t ed in Ja k a r t a . T h e p r o d u ct io n j n.n b t o r ag e f or r a w m a t e r i a l s a n d f in i s h e d g o o d s i n v en t o r y ar e m a i n l i n e d in t h e f act o r y

fi Wdiang

M c t e k c i g a r e t t e s c e r t a i n b 0 % t o b a c c o a n d & 3 °C k r M e k i h ^ f i l : c r o f t h e c i g a r e n e 'f . < ■* '■# « t : .n a g l c c o s e l a y e r

(26)

H o w F a s t T o b a c c o C a n B e :

Tim IvgKiiiciit pr'DCCSS Of Xpfhrnnn*. nf PaH MbIS ZnritTDiflS'd

Appendix 2: Kind o f organization according to HoijnsdijkF

T o g et a g o od im p r essio n o f Ro t h m an s an d to k n o w in w h at k in d o f d ir ect io n s t h e chancie- ac> i:ity t an g et s ar e going to be Ro t h m an s w a s ch ar act er i z ed acco r d in g t o

H eij n sd ij k

-Qu anti ties

Organization

As set s of Ro t h m an 5:

If w e t ak e a look at t h e f ix ed as s e t s of Ro t h m an s w e can s e e t h e f o llo w in g t r en d s.

• T h e f ix ed an d cu r r en t as s e t s ar e r esp ect ively d ivid ed int o 47% / 5 3 %. s e e A p p en d ix

1 0.

< T h e p ack ag in g an d st ick - m ak in g m ach in es ar e c a s e sen sit i ve. T h e o t h er m ach in es

can b e u sed f or all k in d s o f t o b acco .

• T h e d iv isron liab ilit ies t equ it y i3 1 4 % / 8 6 %. s e e also A p p en d ix ^ O.

Be c a u s e o f t h e hig h level of eq u it y Rothrr> ans c an in vest an d c h an g e r at h er f lex ib le T h e t ech n ical lay out o f t h e f act o r y al lo w s, ap ar t f rom p ack ag in g an d st ick - m ak ing , p r o d uct io n o f d if f er en t k in d s o f t o b acco .

OmanizaXianal culture

T h e o r g an iz at i o n is h ier ar ch ies, s e a t h e Ro t h m an s o r g an iz at io n ch ar t on p ag e 9.

» f h e t ask , r esp o n sib ilit ies «^nd al lo w an ces ar e s t n d l y d ivid ed h ier ar ch ical ly

« T h er e ar e no c ar e er o p p o r t u n t ies for t n c lo w er lev els

• T h e a v e r a g e ag e of a p r od uct io n w o r k er is 41

• T h e co r e- p h ilo so p h y of Ro t h m a r s is to m ak e of q u alit y o f cig ar et t es. TTiis p h il o so p h y

m ig h t n ot t o b e feH wit hin t h e f act or y.

« T h er e ar e b r o ad p lan n in g and cont rolling sy st em Po li ce o f f icer s ar e f o u n d to co n t r o l

t h e f act o r y.

Fr o m t h e ab o v e w e c a r co n cl u d e t h at t he cult u r e o f Ro t h m an s is f o r m al, st if f an d st ro ng . Ch a n g e s in t h e can '.p an y w I h- ?ve d iff icu lt ies to g ain f oo t hold . Ch an g e s h ave to be ■ nt roduced in a s r c n g . y h ier ar ch ical m an n er

8 0 0 e m p l o y e e s a^ e in vo lved in Ro t h m an s. 3 6 3 o f t h em at t h e f act o r y in M alan g . 4D in Ja k a r t a an d t h e r est so r ead all e v e r In d o n esia f o r k i n g at d ep o t s o f Ro t h m an s. Ir gr k - <1 r iver s e t c )

Persons

T h e r e is a g r eat d i f f er en ce b et w een t h e m an ag em en t an d t h e o t h er em p lo y ee s . T h e top- m an ag er s a r e m ain ly Eu r o p e an an d A u st r ali an p eo p le (sit u at ed in Jak ar t a), t h e m id d le m an ag er s ar e In d o n esian p eo p le g r ad u at in g f rom o v e r s e a s u n iver sit y an d t h e o p er at i o n level ar e lov/ ly- f iducat ed In d o n esian s.

• All t h e p r o b lem s ar e h rst ly d i scu ssed w it h t h e first We st e r n p er so n in t h e h ier ar c h ic al

line, n o t d ep en d i n g or. t h e f u n ct ion of t h e p er so n In d o n esian s h a v e d if f icu lt ies w it h t h is p o licy.

(27)
(28)

H o w F a s t T o b a c c o C a n B e :

_____________ ___________________________T)>l kwtefctil fiiucvsx <>i K ftr.'m w rtf >-*aiY Matt {tx}(W/°$i#

Ro d m a n s d o a s n l d eli ver t o all islan d s, {e q u al t o h er co m p et i t o r s) T h e co m p et it io n b e t w ee n t h e cig ar et t es- co m p an ies is fair an d o p en . Th e m o st im p o r t an t t h ing is t o d eal w it h t h e b est m ar k et in g - m ix in st r u m en t s.

D e s i g n v a r Ja b l & s

* T h e y h av e a st rict f un ct ion - d escr ip t ion. Ever y b o d y h as h is o w n jo b an d t ask s

* T h e o r g an i z at i o n h as a f u n ct ion al st ru ct u r e.

* Ro t h m a n s is st ro n g ly h o r iz o n t ally cen t raliz ed .

» T h er e a r c n o m an y t ask s d eleg at io n

St e e r v a r i a b l e s

* T h e r elat i o n s in Ro t h m an s ar e m o st of t h em f o r m al and ar e alm o st lik e in t h e

o o lo n ist 'p er io d . In p / incioal t h ey t ry t o st an d ar d iz e t h e j o b s an d t ask s, b u t t h e cr eat iv e so u l of t h e In d o n esian s h ave m ost of t h e t im e m o r e su ccessf u l.

* T h e r e ar e h ier ar c h ies an d h ig h - h and ed p ower- ship .

* T h e r e ar e f e w in t er n al ed u cat io n p r o g r am s.

* T h e p lan n in g an d co n t ro lling sy st em s a r e st ro n g ly h o r iz o n t ally cen t r aliz ed an d f o r m al.

* Ev e r y d e l e g a t e d t as k is f r o m t h e t o p t o t h e b o t t o m .

M a n a g e m e n t f ilt e r

T h e r e is o n ly o n e o o ssib ’ lity in t h e ^ c t o r y of M alan g to ad ap t to t h e c h a n g e s in t h e

su r r o u n d in g an d evei y t h m g t hat ’fi d eleg at ed . In Ja k a r t a t h ey h a v e al so p r o b lem s wit h

t his m at t er b e c a u s e t h ey h a v e to f o llow th e lin es an d r eg u lat io n s of Ro t h m an s

In t er n at io n al.

Su m m ar y.

* T h e st r at eg ic v ar i ab l e s ar e p oint ed out in tt>e m ar k et to co n vi n c e t h e q u alit y of t h e

p r o d u ct .

* T h e d esig n v a r i ab le s ar e cen t r aliz ed an d t h e f act o r y is ar r an g ed f u n ct io n ally

* T h e st eer v ar i ab le s ar e f o r m ally an d st an d ar d iz ed , w h ich ar e d el e g at e d f r om t h e t op

of t h e m an ag em er .t .

* T h e en vir o n m en t is st ab l e an d t r an sp ar en t

* T h e o r g an iz at io n is built t op - d own

* T h e in d ivid u als ar e lo w ly ed u cat ed , not c o n cer n ed t h e co m p an y tand doc/ lc.

* Be c a u s e o f h ier ar ch ical d if f icu lt ies (M alan g - Ja k a r t a - A u st r ali a) t h e m an ag em en t

fit t er is t hick .

So w e can co n cl u d e t h at Ro t h m an s acco r d in g to Heij n sd ij k f is mos t lik ely a b u r eau cr at i c

o r g an iz at io n

(29)

47 T h e I n t e r n a t i o n a l J o u r n a l o f A c c o u n t i n g a n d B u s i n e s s S o c i e t y

__________________ ___________________ _ _______The tog&ttcal )> t\ icvss at Rotbmaox Pv!> Mart fncku'Ptio

Appendix 3: Them oc te / o f *Werken met Logistiek'\ according io V fs s e r/ V.

G oorK

Th is m o d el c o v er s t h e 7 m ajo r p ar t s of b u sin ess logistrcs:

Production, planning and controlling

Purchasing

T h e m o st im po/ t anC r aw m at er ial s (t o b acco ) ar e m aij ily p u r c h ased b y Ro t h m a n s In t er n at io n al. Th e p u r ch asin g of p ap er , glue, filt er et c is ar r an g ed b y e m p lo y ees of t h e p u r ch asin g d ep ar t m en t in Malan g .

Inventory m anagem en t

T h e ar e a lot of in ven t o r i es in t h y p r od uct ion p r o cess. T h e level an d d u r at io n of t h e in ven t o ry ar e b as ed c n t h e q u alit y of t h e p rod uct . M easu r in g t h e q u alit y o f t h e t o b a c c o is o n Jy f o r so ec i al i s t s not for t his in vest ig at ion . Th is q u af it y m easu r em en t is esp eci all y

n t er cst in g for t h e long t im e st o r ag e. Th e t o b acco h as ;o b e st or ed t h er o for at least h alf a y e ar Thif> is an m cn ed ible bfcj in vest m en t

M aterials handling

T h e in t er n al t r an sp o r t at io n is m ain iy t r uck - d nvm g f rom an d t o t h e lon g t im e st o r ag e d ep o t s in t h e r est of t h e f act o r y ar e t h e d ep ar t m en t s c lo s e to e3 cJi o t h er T h a t m ean s

t h at t h e o ut p u t of o r e d ir ect ly t h e in ven t o r y o f t h e n e r i st ep . Fr o m t h e i w e n t o r y t o t h e

nex t st ep is m ain ly h u m an en er g y

inventory controf finished goods

t>i p in ven t o r y o f f in'&hed g o o d s rs also a cr i(j cal part o f (t ie in vest ig at io n . T h e cig ar et t es

h av e to b e st o r ed in t his h a'I for at laa&t 7 d ays, o t h er w ise t h e p r o d u ct s d o n o t h a v e g o o d q u alit y

Depots and inventory

li h e d ep o t s an d in ven t o r y o u t sid e t he f act o r y of M ala n g is o r g an iz ed b y t h e m an ag em en t in Jak ar t a.

Transportation decisions

The d el iv er ie s to t h e d ep o t s an d d ist r ib u t o r s ar e o r g an iz ed b y t h e m an ag e m e n t in

Jakarta.

V o l . 12, N o . 1 Ju l y 2004 © Cen t r e f or In d o n esian A cco u n t i n g an d M an ag em en t Resear ch

(30)

48 H o w F a s t T o b a c c o C a n B e :

. . . -AW- 'ictaw

J t \ e togmncsn p ric e s) RoUmuns o(Pul) Ma)> >n<*v,t?j0

Appendix 4: Material flow

Receiving,

En t r a n c e con t r o l

Gf<*en leaves

hashing

Fo r n icat i o n

Recf ry

Mix ing

Blen d

Cut t rng

Co o l st o r ag a

S tick-makrng

Co o l st o r ag e

Boxiog

Sl eevi n g

Ca r d b o ar d in g

St o r a g e

Or d er - p ick in g

D ist r ib u t ion

D o m est ic T o b ac co

in tern a­

t ional T o b acco

i I

Fl av o r Fi lt er Pa p e r ,

Gi u e.

Ink

Q

Fo il, Pa p e r La b e l s Tear - st r ip Film

(31)
(32)

H o w F a s t T o b a c c o C a n B e :

iixv-tcrg.'<:>„ .W r- 'niiuss Rorh'^.^'r o' F;n7 iW^m I'r x l o n ^

A p p e n d ix 6: L a y o u t o f th e fa c to r y / M a te ria l flo w

jL 3 l u i S « r

] Fr e e ir :c J 5TtllC«i« T C n : j f - n . * .

f r

i- 'nishea

is • -»> 1 prcoc;:ir

M i x i n i . ' t © r d l u g

: . t C < P f O d u u : i u I

j;hr>^G T

-t - r o O i r g i n -t o p a c i &l-t; » y i i ^ m ^ n i r c

H F

A St o r a g e □ I Pr a ce s- s ■ T r a n s p o r t

L o n g 1i n n ( t o r t A d

r t ?« n I r a t e s ■ . r f c f c' lin si

Panr- v

U IIOfAjiil? I re-

ti J O * .*

l r v e n t n r v hertora P I D d L C l i u

^torfcyt; before .i$<»7;e

(33)

T h e I n t e r n a t i o n a l J o u r n a l o f A c c o u n t i n g a n d B u s i n e s s S o c i e t y

A p p e n d ix e s I he lo g is tic a l p ro c e s s a t R o th m a n s o f P a ll M a lt In d o n e s ia

P a c k a g i n g M a c h i n e S s l e s v o l u m e i H u m e n { N a t u r e j C a p tu t E f f i c i e n c y su r plus 0 U n i t s R e p a i rC h a n g e S m i t l a t o p # R e d u c e d s p e e d W a f t i n g M a l f u n c t i o n o f p r o c e s s 0 S t a r t i n g / s t o p J t n g 0 R e m arks K l n g s i ; e H P 8 1 % 11 8 V J 1 1 % 2 2 8 % 6 4 3 % 8 .7su c h * . 1 6 0 , 1 t.

:

7 5 6 0 0 . 4 0 1 1 2 . 6 0 .1 7 3 2 7 r n * c h ir > e s S u p e « - t 'i C ! H P 1 2 % 0 o v , j 0 Z % | 3 6 % 1 0 2 , 3 % 1 1■t ic k s 0 3 0 0 3 9 0 0 0 1 .6 0 1 0 6 i m a c h i n e N o n fin**' SP 1 6 % 2 . 5 % 0 2*Vt j 2 9 3 % £ 8 . 0 % 2 4SOCKS 1 o 0.2 01 3 6 0 1 0 1 0 1 8 0 1 0.5 1 m a c h i n e S v j p e ' J i z e S T 7 % 2 1 5 % I 0.2V, i 1 6 6% 5 9 . 7 % 1 .1 SfiCKS 1 0 0 3 0.2 3 , 0 0 0 1 0 , 3 1 .6 0 . 6 1 0 5 1 ma c h in e K j n g & ./ o S P 2 % 3 5.8 %j 0 . 2 * I 4 5 . 1 % 1 8 9 % 1 ’s t i c k s ? 7 0 . 4 0 . 2 3 . 8 0 4 0 4 0 . 7 v e 0 8 1 0 . 5 1 m a c h i n e

To tal 1 0 0 % j 18 * 1 1 4 .3sf lc K * 4 0 2 0 1 1 511 m ac h in e?

A v e r a g e 11 7 % ! 1.811 I 22HV. 6 4 3 % 1.35 l'C k » 1 4 0 2 0.1 0 0 . 1 0 . 2 0 3 1

N a t u r e (m a t e r i a l ) R e s o u r c e *

C e p i t J l { m a c h i n e ) R e s o u r c e E f f i c i e n c y s u r p l u * A v e r a g e ( w i t h o u t s t o r a g e ) 0

O f* 1 s

Repair

C h a n g * S « n « f s t o p 0

Re d u c e o s p e ed

ty tu e n 't n u c tw r i p ^ o c r v d t > v ^ e p ro d u cti o n p r o c e ss

n t u m t d by the produciton o o c*

NyfT***- 0« 14TMI9

S o n M «rt»*

T im e m at « lo st to rvpairaiQ n tac* * "* *

m * <4 tod f ee to ca* o ( nq irt« tu •

Nvrrtoer o* umu to st to s m s I 5to e s (m eto u M n cH ) T im e tc* i to m fcjco d e d u c t i o n s p e e d Tkt>* k>«i d u e lo w i t n g f<n m p u i m e te n s t T « n * h u t u i »r>wk»rtctk» » p tfte p»oc* «*

S t a r t i n g / s t o p p i n g

p r v c v u (In th o u sa n d s)

(34)
(35)

Gambar

table o f  authorities. In the table o f  authorities are the sam e letters used, which  In the w hole report sm all alphabetic letters are used to link back to the gives the ex actly inform ation about the source
FIG U RE 1: O RG A N IZ A T IO N  C H A RT  OF RO T H M A N S
figure 4: O ver view  o f  outline and method.
FIG U RE 5: A N A L Y SIS O F BO T T LEN EC K
+3

Referensi

Dokumen terkait

Kedua, PR Politik melakukan tinjauan mengenai pengelolaan citra ( image management ). Di satu sisi, pengelolan citra ditujukan untuk citra pribadi politisi atau

Pengeringan yang dilakukan pada buah mahkota dewa bertujuan mengurangi kadar air dalam bahan, sehingga air yang tersisa tidak dapat digunakan sebagai media hidup

[r]

Saran yang dapat peneliti berikan berkaitan dengan tujuan penelitian ini adalah para preman tersebut sebaiknya terus meningkatkan pola komunikasi yang baik dengan remaja masjid

Of course, it’s trivial to create your own event aggregator in Backbone, and there are some key things that we need to keep in mind when using an event aggregator, to keep our

EVALUASI KEGAGALAN KOMPONEN PADA SISTEM VENTILASI ZONA RADIASI MENENGAH REAKTOR RSG-GAS.Peranan sistem ventilasi reaktor RSG-GAS selain untuk pendingin ruangan dan

Adapun tujuan dalam penelitian ini adalah untuk meningkatkan sikap ilmiah dan hasil belajar siswa dengan penerapan model pembelajaran kooperatif tipe Teams Game

Ekstrak etil asetat yang telah didapatkan kemudian dilakukan pemeriksaan fitokimia untuk golongan tepenoid dengan kromatografi lapis tipis menggunakan fase diam pelat KLT