NGHIEN euru TinrC TRANG SUf DUNG PHlTflfNG PHAP BANH GIA KET QUA HOC T A P M O N L t LUAN CHG SINH VIEN
TRlTtfNG BAI HOC THE DUC THE THAO B A C NINH
ThS. NgaySn Thj Xuyin
-ii^lB"
^ T^tAt:
Trorg cdng tic kiem tra dirti qa\cit(\i^\nQCtipcac m&n ly thjy^t n6i dunq 6 trudng P ^ hpc TPTT BAc !«** <!»8i kK cdn maig tir*i kp d$t dtva phu htyp. Do v^y. r^itn oiu Xhfc tr^nq aJ 4*i6 \;^anq phap darh 0i k^t Cfj& hpc t$p mdn |y b|ki cho erh viftn, Sii djinq df^
qui trrti MS&n tra dim bAo si/ cdr^ b ^ v^ khach ^luan hon trory o^ trVh d^y hpc c i c mdn hpc khic rtiai
/tftract:
h the cxartiation avi assessment, ^eartwv^ outcomes h generd theoretic^ sibjecte a t Bac hWi Sport M/ereity somcttnss a ^ s e t avi not appropriate. Therefore, researdn the actual situation used methods of e/skjation study reedx. of thccrctic£i sibipcts for students, uerig to hdp the testing process t o enstrc farness and objectivity n the ptx:ess of teachfcig
tifferentsJpjpcte.
DAT VAN o i
Tir thyc t^ trong cdng tic kifm tra vi dinh gii ket qui hpc If p cic mdn ly thuyet ndi chung d Tnidng Dai hpc TDTT BN hifn nay mang tinb ip dit. chua phii hpp: Mdn niy thi trie nghifm;
Mdn kia thi ty lu|n va mdn khic Ifi thi vin dap vv.. Nhu v^y vifc t i ^ hinh phucmg phap thi khic nhau thi kft qui cd khic nhau khdng li vin dc dupc dit ra. Do viy chung tdi nghifn cuu thyc trfng sir dyng phuong phip dinh gia kft qui hpc t$p mft mdn Ly lufn cho sinh vifn tnrdng Dfi hpc TDTT Bic Ninh. Lam tdt dieu niy si giiip qui trinh kifm tra dinh gii dam bao sy cdng bing vi khich quan hem trong qui trinh dfy hpc cho eric mdn hpc khac nhau, timg budc ning cao chit lupng dio tfo cua nhi tnrdng len timg budc.
PHUONG P H A P N G H I E N CUTU
Qua trinh nghifn cuu sir dyng cac phuomg phip:
- Phuong phip tham khio tai lifu - Phuong phip phdng vin
• Phucme phip toin hpc thong kc
K^T QUA NGHIEN CCTU VA B A N L U A N
Bing vifc sir dyng cac phucmg phip nghifn cAu phd hpp trfn ddi tupng li ket qua kifm tra mft sA ly lufn thufe bp mdn L> lufn
TDTT dam nhifm ddi vdi sinh vien cic khda 41.
42. 43 va 44 ttirdng Dfi hpc TDTT Bic Ninh (ket qua thi lin 1). Budc diu de tii ed ket qui nghien ciiu sau:
I. So sanh ket qui giira hai phuong phip thi ty lufn \a trie nghifm mdn hpc Ly lufn vi phucmg phap Thf dye thf thao eiia khda DH 43
va44Hai khda DH 43 va 44 cd eie dieu kifn giang dfy va hpc t|p nhu nhau vi eiing mft chuong trinh hpc, nhung dupe t i ^ hinh theo hai phutmg phap thi mdn hpc Ly lufn vi phuang phap Thf dye the thao khac nhau: Khda DH 42 thi ty lufn cdn khda DH 43 thi trie nghifm; ket qua dup*c thf hifn d bing 2.1 vi 2.2
Khda DH 43 cd kft qui dft khi gidi c h i ^ 14.94° 0; difm yeu kfm li 48.92 % ttong khi dd khda DH 44 dft tdi 28.3%; di^m y^u kfm li
18.95''o.
E>ieu dd phan inh phuong phip thi ty lufn
ddi vdi sinh vifn khd dft difm cao hom thi trie
nghifm vi sd sinh vicn np ciing nhicu hon.
lAiiAflPimiac
Bing 1. Kit q u i o A m thi mdn Ly l u f n v i PP TDTT khda d f i hpc 43 n g i n h sir p h f m TD ( t y lufn)
Ldp BB BC BD BL BN BR BS CL CV DK QV TD VAT
VO TL T i n g
Xnit s i c Gidi
§6 lupng
4 1
t
6 1 1 1 1 4 ->
0
*>
1 (1 0 26
Ti If % 14.81 2.78 6.25 17.14
3.7 3.85 5.26 3.13 18.18 5.56
- 6.67 3.03
- - 6.27
Kfai
$6
hrpng 1 3 5 6
4 3
-1
1 3 0 1 ->
1 1 36
Tl If % 3.7 8.33 15.63 17.14 11.11 15.38 15.79 6.25 4.55 8.33
- 3.33 6.06 2.94 20 8.67
Trung binh
Sdlupng 13 10 14 16 13 13 -) 3 13 18 2 7 10 13 3 150
Tilf%
48.15 27.78 43.75 45.71 48.15 50 10.53
9.38 59.09
50 9.52 23.33
30.3 38.24
60 36.14
Yfu, kfm So
lupng 9 22
11 7 10
8 13 26 4 13 19 20 20 20 1 203
T i l f % 33.33 61.11 34.38 20 37.04 30.77 68.42 81.25 18.18 36.11 90.48 66.67 60.61 58.82 20 48.92
TAng
• > • *
36 32 35 27 26 19 32
t t
36 21 30 33 34 5 415 B i n g 2. K i t q u i diAm thi mdn Ly l u f n v i PP TDTT
khda d f i hpc 44 n g i n h su> p h f m TD (trAc nghifm)
Ldp
BB BC BD BL BN BR BS CL CV DK OV TD VAT
VO TL TAng
XuAt s i c . Gioi So
lupng 0 4 1 4 1
/ 8 9 9 0 9 4
J
0 66
Tilf "o - 10 5.88 13.79
3.13 20.59 25.93 34.78 42.86 21.43 - 23.08
16 9.09
- 16.46
Kha Sd lupng
• t
3 3 3 8 1 4 6 3 5 1 7 1 1 (1 4X
Ti If % 11.76
7.5 17.65 10.34 25 2.94 14.81 26.09 14.29 11.9 6.25 17.95
4 3.03
11.97
Trung binh
Solupng 9 22 10 18 17 19 9 7 5 25
8 20 14 22 6 211
Ti If % 52.94
55 58.82 62.07 53.13 55.88 33.33 30.43 23.81 59.52 50 51.28
56 66.67
100 52.62
Yeu, kfm So
lupng 6 11
3 4 6 7 7 2 4 3 7 3 6 7 0 76
Ti If % 35.29
27.5 17.65 13.79 1S.75 20.59 25.93 8.7 19.05
7.14 43.75
7.69 24 21.21
18.95
TAng
17 40 17 29 32 34 27 23 21 42 16 39 25 33 6 40142
Khda DH 43 dft difm qua lin Ichi d mire 67,50"4 : cdn difm yC-u kfm li 37.50 % ttxing khi dd khda DH 44 dft tdi 82.14"o; difm yeu kem la 17,76%.
Bing 3. Kit qui diAm thi mdn Ly lufn v i PP TDTT khda dfi hpc 43 nginh HLV (ty lufn) Kft epia dd cdn dupc phan inh rd net ddi vdi
sinh vifn nginh Huin luyfn vien va dupc thf hifn d bing 3. va 4.
Ldp BD BS DK VO Tong
Xuat sic, Gidi Sd
lupng 0 0 7 3 10
Ti If % - - 35
15 17.86
Khi Sd lupng
0 1 1 1 3
Tilf%
12.5 5 5 5.36
Tmng binh Sd
lupng 3 2 5 12 22
Ti If % 37.5
25 25 60 39.29
Yeu, kfm Sd lupng
5 5 7 4 21
Tl If % 62.5 62.5 35 20 37.5
TAng 8 8 20 20 56 Bing 4. KAt qui diAm thi mdn Ly lufn v i PP TDTT
Ldp BB BD BL CL CV DK OV VAT
\ ( ) long
khda dfl hpc 44 nginh HLV (1 Xuit sic, Gioi
So lupng
0 0 2 0 1 3 0 3 3 12
Ti If %
18.18 - 10 21.43
- 37.5
15 11.21
Khi So lupng
0 2 3 1
->1 I 1 3 14
Tl If % - 11.11 27.27 12.5
20 7.14 12.5 12.5 15 13.08
rAc nghii Trung binh Sd
lupng 7 8 6 6 6 9 4 4 12 62
Tilf%
70 44.44 54.55 75 60 64.29
50 50 60 57.94
)m)
Neu, So lupng
3 K 0
1 1 1 3 0 2 19
kfm Ti If %
30 44.44
12.5 10 7.14 37.5 10 17.76
TAng 10 18 11 8 10 14 8 8 20 107 Nhu viy ki-t qui hpc tfp ciia sinh vifn giira
2 phuang phip thi khic nhau cho ket qua difm khic nhau. Hinh thiic thi trie nghifm cd ket qua difm cao hom thi ty lufn.
2. So sinh kit qui diAm thi girii hai khda DH 41 v i 43 khi cung mft phiramg phip thi tif lufn mdn hpc ThA dgc thi thao tnrd>ng hpc
Kft qua dupc the hifn d bang 5 va 6 cho thiy: Mic dii hai khda khac nhau nhung cimg mft phuong phip thi ty lufn va cho ket qua difm d cic leifi khi gidi vi trung binh la tuong duemg nhau vi kft qua difm > eu kem eiing dien ra tuong ty.
3. So sinh kAt qui giira hai phirong phip thi hf l u ^ vi trie nghifm mdn hpc Phirang
phip huin luyfn thi thao hifn dfl cua khda DH 42 vi 43
Kft qua thft dang ngfc nhifn, binh thirc thi ty lufn doi vdi khda 42 nginh HLV khdng cd mpt sinh vifn nao np (0,0%), trong kho dd lofi difm gidi va xuit sic dft 83.54% (Dieu niy cd thf ly giii li do cdng tic eoi thi chua tot).
Nhung ket qua thi vin dip doi vdi khda 43 ty If
khdng dft yfu ciu chiem 50.00% va s6 sinh vifn
c6 ket qua difm gidi, xuit sic la 19,64% phananh sy trai ngupc vdi ket qua thi ty lufn cda
khda 42. Nhu vay kft qui giihi phuang phip thi
ty lufn va trie nghifm cd sy khic bift rd rft.
iAnAapiiAi»c
Bing 5. KAt qui diAm thi mdn ThA dvc thA thao Trvdmg hpc khda dfi hpc 41 nginh sir phfm TD (hf lufn)
Ldp
BB BC BD BL BN BR BS CL CV DK QV TD VAT
VO T i n g
Xuit s i c Gidi Sd
lupng 3.00 4.00 4.00 1.00 4.00 2.00 1.00 1.00 0.00 4.00 1.00 5.00 2.00 1.00 33.00
Tl If % 15.79 15.38
")•> T V
5.26 19.05
8.00 4.35 5.26
- 11.76 8.33 17.86 10.00 5.88 11.11
Kha Sd lupng
2.00 1.00 1.00 5.00 2.00 1.00 1.00 3.00 2.00 10.00
0.00 4.00 3.00 1.00 36.00
Ti If % 10.53
3.85 5.56 26.32
9.52 4.00 4.35 15.79 12.50 29.41
- 14.29 15.00 5.88 12.12
Trung binh Sd
lupng -.00 15.00 4.00 8.00 11.00 11.00 19.00 5.00 5.00 14.00
5.00 14.00
7.00 8.00 133.00
Ti If % 36.84 57.69 22.22 42.11 52.38 44.00 82.61 26.32 31.25 41.18 41.67 50.00 35.00 47.06 44.78
YAii,kfia Sd lupng
7.00 6.00 9.00 5.00 8.00 11.00
2.00 10.00
9.00 6.00 6.00 5.00 8.00 7.00 95.00
Ti If % 36.84 23.07 50.00 26.32 19.04 44.00 8.69 52.63 56.25 17.65 50.00 17.86 40.00 41.18 31.99
TA«g
19.00 26.00 18.00 19.00 21.00 25.00 23.00 19.00 16.(X) 34.00 12.00 28.00 20.00 17.00 297.00 Bing 6. KAt qui diim thi mdn ThA dye thA thao Tnrfmg hpc khda dfi hpc 43nginh sir phfm TD (t^ lufn)
Ldp
BB BC BD BL BN BR BS CL CV DK QV TD VAT
\ o
Tong
Xuit s i c , Gidi Sd
lupng 2 0
• )
4
t
5
JS
5 5 6 0 3
t t
41
Ti If % 7.41
- 6.25 10.81
7.41 19.23 13.04 14.71 22.73 16.67 - 9.38 6.25 6.25 9.69
Khi Sd lupng
1 8 3 5 3 8 4 13
->
- 6 3 6 4 73
Ti If % 3.7
->-> •>->
9.38 13.51 11.11 30.77 17.39 38.24 9.09 19.44
">•) ->t
9.38 1H.75
12.5 17.26
T h i n g binh
s6
lupng 9 17 17 17 15 11 12 13 11 20 9 17 11 17 196
Ti If % 33.33 47.22 53.13 45.95 55.56 42.31 52.17 38.24 50 55.56 33.33 53.13 34.37 53.13 46.23
Yeu, Sd lupng
15 II 10 II
7 2 4 3 4 3 12 9 13 9 113
kfm
Ti If % 55.56 30.56 31.25 29.73 25.93 7.69 17.39
8.82 18.18
8.33 44.44 28.13 40.62 28.13 26.71
TAng
27 36 32 37 27 26 23 34 22 36 27 32 32 32 4 2 3 '
Bing 7. KAt qui AAm thi mdn hpc Phuong phip
huAn luyfn thA thao hifn dfi khda dfi hpc 42 nginh HLV (Ty lufn) Lirp
BB BD BL CL C\
DK VAT
VO
^TAng
XuAt sic, Gidi Sd
lupng 6 6 9 4 6 19
6 10 66
Tilf%
100 100 90 66.67 66.67 90.48 85.71 71.43 83.54
Khi Sd lupng
0 0 0 1 1 1 0 2 5
Tilf%
-
- 16.67 11.11 4.76
- 14.29
6.33
Tkung binh Sd
lupng 0 0 1 1 -»
1 1 2 8
Ti If % - - 10 16.67
• ) T -)")
4.76 14.29 14.29 10.13
Y^u, kfm Sd
lupng 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Ti If % - - - - - - - - -
TAng
6 6 10 6 9 21
7 14 79 Bing 8. KAt qui diAm thi mdn hpc Phirong phip
huin luyfn thA thao hifn dfi khda dfi hpc 43 nginh HLV (vAn dip)
Ldp
BD BS DK VO TAng
Xuit s i c Gidi
s6
lupng 1.00 1.00 5.00 4.00 11.00
Ti If % 11.11 11.11 29.41 19.05 19.64
Khi
s6
lupng 0.00
1.00 5.00 3.00 9.00
Ti If % - 11.11 29.41 14.29 16.07
Thing binh So
lupng 2.00 3.00 2.00 1.00 8.00
Ti If %
T> tt 33.33
11.76 4.76 14.29
\ i u , kfm Sd
lupng 6.00
• 4.00 5.00 13.00 28.00
Ti If % 66.67 44.44 29.41 61.90 50.00
TAng
9.00 9.00 17.00 21.00 56.00 KFTLUAN
- Cic phuong phip kifm tra thi danh gii ket qua hpc tfp cua sinh vien dAi \di cic mdn Ly lufn khic nhau thi cho ket qua khac nhau.
- Trong cae phuong phip kifm tta/thi danh gli kft qua hpc tfp ciia sinh vifn thi thi trie nghifm cd kft qua diem cao nhat va thap nhit li thi vin dip.
TAI U ( U THAM KHAO
I. Bp giio dye vi dio tfo, Vy dfi hpc (1995), Trie nghifm vd do ludng ca bdn trong gido due.
Hi Nfi
2 Trin Bi Hoinh (1991), Ddnh gid trong gido due, chuong trinh giio trinh dfi hpc.
Hi Npi
3. E)$ng \ u Hof t (1997), Mpt so van de kiem tra ddnh gid tri thuc hpc sinh, Nxb giio dye. Hi Npi.
4 Ding Bi Lim (1995), Cdc phuang phdp kiem tra ddnh gid trong gidng dpy dpi hpc, Nxb dfi hpc qude gia. Hi Npi.
