Danh gia thUc trang
cong tac quan ly ru'ng tai Khu bao ton thien nhien Thu'Ong Tien, tinh Hoa Binh
HA TH! THANH THOY' Tdm tat , . .- Thdng qua phong vd'n cdc cd nhdn vd phong vdn nhdm, nghiin cffu dd ddnh gid ve cdc yeu id dnh hudng di'n cdng ldc qudn ly rffng tgl Khu bdo ton thien nhiin Thugng Tii'n thdi gian qua. Qua dd. di(a ra nhffng kho khdn, vitdng mdc, tff do de xudt cdc gidi phdp phu hdp de ndng cao chdt lugng qudn ly rffng lgi Khu bdo ton.
Tii khda: qudn ly rffng, Khu bdo tdn thien nhien Thugng Tie'n, chinh sdch bdo vi rffng
Summary
Through individual and group interviews, the study evaluates factors affecting forest managemeni in Thuong Tien Nature Reserve. After clarifying difficulties and obstacles, d propo.ses proper solutions to improve the quality of forest managemeni in Thuong Tien Nature Reserve.
Key words: forest management, Thuong Tien Nature Reserve, forest protection policy GIOI THIEU
Khu bao tdn thidn nhidn Thffdng Tie'n la mdt trong nhffng khu bao tdn dau lien dffdc thanh lap cua tinh Hda Binh cd long dien tich la 7.308ha, thudc dia gidi hanh chinh 3 xa la Thffdng Tie'n, Kim Tid'n cua huyen Kim Bdi va xa Quy Hda cua huydn Lac Sdn, tinh Hda Binh.
Khu bao ton thien nhidn Thffdng Tie'n nguydn la hd sinh thai rffng nhiet ddi thffdng xanh trdn nui tbS'p dae trffng cua vilng Tay Bac Viet Nam da bi tac ddng Iffdng dd'i manh. Ndi day cdn luU giff nhieu loai ddng thffc vat quy hie'm, cd tdn irong sdch dd Vidt Nam, sdch dd thd' gidi dffdc quan ly bao ve.
Vdi eac gid tri ve canh quan va da dang sinh hpc quan Irong nhff vay, viec nghien cffu cdng ldc quan ly rffng lai Khu bao tdn thien nhidn Thifdng Tie'n ed y nghia ea ve khoa hpc va thffc lien
CO S5 LY LUAN VA PHUONG PHAP NGHIEN COu Ctf sd ly luan
Mot sd khdi niem
Theo Luat Lam nghidp Viet Nam (2017), thi rffng la mdt hd sinh thai, bao gom: cac loai thffc vat rffng ddng vat rffng, nam, vi sinh vat, da'l rffng va cac yd'u to mdi trffdng khac. Trong dd, thanh phan chinh la mdt hoac mgt so loai eay than gd, ire, nffa, eay ho cau
•TS Trt/dng Dai hoc Tai nguyen va Moi trt/dng Ha Moi
Ngdy nhdn hdi: 18/10/2019; Ngdy phdn bien 12/11/2019; Ngdy du:.
cd chieu cao difdc xac dinh theo he thiXc vdt trdn mii da'l, nui dd, da't ngap nffdc, da't eai hoac hd thffc v0t dac trifng khde;
dien tich lidn vung tff 0,3ha ird len; dp tan che tff 0,1 trd ldn.
Mac du cho de'n nay chffa cd khdi nidm
"quan ly rffng", song cd ban cd the hieu, quan Iy rffng la tdng hdp cdc hoat ddng cua cac chu thl ed Ihlm quyen lidn quan ddn cong ldc to chffc diffc hien quy hoach, bao vd, bao tdn, phat trien va sff dung rffng.
Cdc ye'u to anh hffdng den qudn ly rffng tgi khu bao ton thien nhien
Vd cd ban, quan Iy rffng tai khu bao tdn thien nhien chiu anh hffdng bdi 03 nhdm yd'u to'sau:
(i) Nhdm ye'u td ve ca che. chlnh sdch cuu Nhd nudc: Cd chd', chinh sach phap luat cua Nha nifdc cd y nghTa quan trong, tae ddng Idn dd'n hidu qua ciia edng tdc quan ly rffng. Cd ehd', chinh sach ddng bd se tao cd che' thuan ldi cho ngu'di dan giam sir Id thudc vao rffng ddng thdi gia lang cac che' tai du manh dc ran de, ngan chan cdc hanh vi xam pham rffng.
(ii) Nhdm ye'u tdve ngudn ka pij^c vu I dng ldc qudn ly rffng: N\w}v cjc yd'u id'
16
ve ngudn Iffc phuc vu cdng lac quan ly rffng, bao gdm: tdi Iffc, nhan life, vat life.
Day la nhdm yd'u td cd anh hffdng trffc tie'p dd'n viec thffc Ihi quan IJ/ rffng.
(iii) Nhdm ye'u td ve nhdn thffc vd tap qudn sinh hogt, sdn xudt cua ngUcfi ddn:
Nhdn thffe ciia ngffdi dan ve tam quan trpng cua viec bao ve va phat tndn rifng cd y nghia quyet dinh dd'n thai dp, hanh vi cff xff cua hg ddi vdi rffng va cdng tdc quan Iy rij^g. Ddng flidi, sff Ihay doi nhan fliffc cung tac dgng ldn den viec thay ddi tap qudn, thdi quen sinh hoat, san xua't lac hau, le thudc va xam hai rffng eua edng dong dan cff sinh sd'ng d khu vffe vung ddm khu bao tdn. Ngffdi dan sinh sd'ng tai vung dem khu bao ton chinh la Iffc Iffdng quan trpng trong cdng tae quan ly va bao vd rffng.
Phifdng phap nghien cu'u Cac thdng tin sd ca'p dffdc tid'n hanh thu thap bang phffdng phap phdng va'n ca nhan va phong van nhdm. Hoat ddng phdng va'n dffdc tie'n hanh vao tuin thff 2 cua thang 1 va tuan 3 cua thdng 08/2019 tai Ban quan ly Khu bao tdn thien nhien Thffdng Tid'n, UBND xa Thffdng Tid'n, UBND xa Kim Tid'n.
Dd'i Iffdng phdng va'n dffdc lffa chon gdm 04 nhdra: (1) Cdn bd qudn ly Ban quan ly Khu bao ton thidn nhidn Thu'dng Tid'n; (2) Cdn bg phu trdch dia ban cua Ban quan Iy Khu bao ton thidn nhidn Thffdng Tien tai 2 xa Thifdng Tid'n va Kim Tie'n; (3) Cdn bd quan Iy nha nffdc tai 2 xa Thffdng Tie'n va Kim Tid'n; (4) Dai didn ngffdi dan dia phffdng cua loan bd 11 xdm thudc 2 xa Thffdng Tie'n va Kim Tie'n.
Ngoai ra, nghidn effu cdn sff dung phffdng phdp quan sal tai hidn trffdng dffdc de'n hanh vao tuan thff 2 ciia thdng I va tuanthff 3 eua thdng 08/2019 tai Khu bao tdn thien nhidn Thifdng Tid'n.
KETQUA NGHIEN CL/U Phan lich cdc yeu to' anh hffdng dd'n cdng tac quan Iy rffng tai Khu bao tdn thien nhien Thffdng Tie'n, huyen Kim Bdi, tinh Hda Binh eho tha'y:
Nhdm yeu to' ve cd che, chinh sdch cua Nhd nffdc
Cd chd', chinh sach phdp luat eua Nha nffdc cd y nghia quan irgng, ldc ddng Idn dd'n hieu qua cua cdng tde qudn ly rffng.
Theo ke'l qua phdng va'n eac dd'i tffdng la can bd xa va edn bd khu bao ton thien nhien Thu'dng Tid'n, 100% y kien deu ihd'ng nha'l cho rdng, cdc quy
dinh phdp luat ciia Nha nffdc ve cdng tac quan ly, bao ve^va phdt triin rffng hidn nay cd ban dam bdo tinh thdng nha't, tinh loan dien, tinh cu the, tinh kha thi.
Danh gia ve cd chd' chinh sdeh quan Iy, bao vd va phat hien riXng hien nay, 4/4 nhdm dd'i tu'dng difde phdng vd'n (bao gdm: can bp xa Thffdng Tid'n va xa Kim Tie'n, can bd ban quan Iy Khu bao tdn thien nhidn Thifdng Tid'n, can bd Ban quan Iy phu trdch dia ban xa Thffdng Tie'n va xa Kim Tien, irffdng cac xdm thuge xa Thifdng Tie'n va xa Kim Tie'n) deu eho rang, cd che' chinh sdch ve tai chinh hd trd cho cac boat ddng quan ly, bao ve va phdt trien rffng hidn nay cdn rat han che'. Mffc kinh phi ngan sach nha nffdc ho Ird cho boat dgng giao khodn bao vd rffng cdn qua flia'p, Nha nffdc chu'a cd'p kinh phi eho cdc boat dpng dieu tra, nghidn etJu khoa hpc phuc vu bao ton da dang sinh hgc. Kinh phi cho cdc ngudn chi nay phu thudc vao ngudn hd Ird cua cdc id chffc qud'c te", cac id chffc phi chinh phu, do vay khdng mang linh fliurdng xuyen.
Ngoai ra, tai Khu bao tdn cung chrfa dp dung chi tra dich vu mdi irffdng rffng (do dieu kidn ap dung tha'p) bdi vay kinh phi thffc hien cac boat ddng rat khd khan.
Ben eanh dd, hau hd't cdc y kie'n cua ede Irffdng xdm deu mong mud'n, Nha nu'dc ed cd che' chinh sdch tao vide lam cho ngffdi dan sinh sdng lai viing ddm khu bao ton de ngffdi dan dn dinh cudc sd'ng, thay ddi tap qudn sinh sd'ng truyen thd'ng Ie thudc vao rffng. Dong thdi, nhilu y kid'n cua nhdm dd'i tffdng nay phan dnh mong mud'n cua ngffdi dan trong viec dffdc cap bd sung kinh phi cho eac boat ddng van hda cdng ddng, nhff:
hdi hpp, giao luM van nghe nham nang cao linh doan ke't cdng ddng, qua dd Iriln khai hidu qua hdn cdng tac tuydn Iruyen, giao due ve bdo ve va phdt trien rffng.
Nhdm yea to nguon life phitc vu cong tdc qudn ly riing Nhdm cdc yd'u to ve ngudn life phue vu cdng tac quan ly rffng, bao gdm: lai life, nhan li^c, vat Iffc. Day la nhdm ye'u to cd anh hffdng trffc tie'p dd'n vide thffc thi quan ly rffng.
Theo ke't qua phdng va'n tff nhdm dd'i tffdng la cac trffdng xdm cua 2 xa Thffdng Tid'n va Kim Tie'n, loan bd cdc y kid'n deu cho rang:
Ve tdi lUc. hien nay mffc kinh phi tff ngudn ngan sach nha nffdc ca'p cho Ban quan Ij' Khu bao ton thien nhidn Thffdng Tid'n de thffc hidn cho eac hoat ddng quan ly rffng cdn ban che'. Ddn cff nhif mffc kinh phi khodn bao ve rifng tff nhidn cho cac ban quan Iy rffng thdn ban edn tha'p (40 tridu ddng/lhdn/nam). Mffe kinh phi nay dffdc cac thdn sff dung de xay dufng cd sd v^l chat, mua sam trang thie't bi phuc vu sinh hoat cdng ddng cua thdn ban.
Ve vdt Iffc, he thd'ng thong tin, nang li^e ffng dung cdng nghd thdng tin trong quan ly, theo ddi dien bid'n tai nguydn rffng, cap nhat tinh hinh bao vd rffng; hd Ihd'ng eanh bao chdy rffng, he thdng thdng dn lidn lac chi huy phdng chd'ng chay rffng edn nhieu han che'.
Trang thie't bi, phffdng lien lam vide cua can bd kiem lam cdn nhieu khd khan.
Hien nay, dieu kidn trang bi cho cac thanh vien tham gia id bao ve rffng d eac thdn ban edn rat thid'u thdn (khdng dffdc trang bi quan do, iing chuydn dung
17
dl man tra trong rffng, khdng dffdc trang hi edng cu bao vd, chii yd'u dung edng cu thd sd, nhff: dao. Hem) dieu nay khdng dam bao sff an toan, fliam chi gay nguy hilm khi tham gia luin tra cung nhff khi phat hien, dd'i mat vdi cdc dd'i tffdng vi pham, cd hdnh vi xam pham rffng,_khai thdc rffng trai phep.
Ve nhdn luc, theo kd't qua phdng van tff can bd Ban quan ly Khu bao ton thien nhidn Thrfdng Tien, deu nha'l tri cho rang, hien nay tbeo quy dinh ve bidn chd' eua Khu bao tdn, cong ldc tuin tra, bao vd rffng gap nhieu khd khan do so' Irfdng cdn bd qua mdng (long sd can bd bidn che' ciia Ban quan Iy hidn la 12 ngrfdi). Sd Iffdng kiem lam dia ban phan theo tffng xa la 1 can bg kiem ldm dia ban/xa. Life Irfdng luan tra, kie'm tra rffng chu ye'u phu thudc vao id bdo ve rffng cua xa vdi thanh vidn la cdn bg cdng an, dan phdng xa va trffdng cae xdm. Ve chat Iffdng nhan life, 100% edn bd cua Ban quan ly Khu bao tdn cd trinh dp chuyen mdn iff trung cap dd'n thac sy ve linh vrfc lam nghiep, thid'u nhan Iffc cd trinh do chuyen mdn v§ ITnh vffe da dang sinh hge.
Trinh do cde thanh vien tham gia to' bao vd rffng td'i thieu dat trinh dp td't nghidp phd' thdng cd sd (12/12), deu la nhffng ngffdi cd uy tin tai dia phffdng, nen ed nhffng thuan ldi nha't dinh cho cdng tac van ddng, tuyen truyen ve bao vd rffng dd'n ngrfdi dan. Bdn canh dd, Irffdng cdc xdm tham gia Id' bao vd rffng diu nam trong dp tudi tff 35-45 cd nhan thffc va nhiet huyd't vdi cdng tde bao vd rffng.
Tuynhien, ngoaicdctrffdngxdm, thi vide van ddng ngrfdi dan tham gia td bao ve rffng hidn nay gap nhieu khd khan, do ngffdi lao ddng ddia phffdng di lam an xa va khdng quan lam dd'n cac cdng vide mang linh eha'l edng ddng, xa hdi, hoac cd tam ly ngai va cham.
Nhdm ye'u td'vS nhgn thffc vd tgp qudn sinh hogt, sdn xudt cua ngffdi ddn
100% eac dd'i tffdng dffdc phong va'n deu eho rdng, nhan thffe cua ngffdi dan la ye'u id' cd mffc dp anh hffdng "Ra't quan irpng" dd'i vdi cdng tac bao ve va phat trien rffng. Trong dd, ngrfdi dan sinh sd'ng tai VLing ddm khu bao tdn ehinh la life Irfpng quan trpng nha'l trong edng tac quan iy va bao vd rffng.
Tuy nhien, trdn thffc Id', do khdng cd vide lam dn dinh, thu nhap tha'p, ndn mdt bd phan ngrfdi dan van duy trt vide thu hoach Iam san phu, nhff; mang, na'm, cdy thud'c, cui dd't.
Bdn canh dd, vide chan tha gia sue Iff do cd thl dffdc xem nhtf ia mdt trong cdc lac ddng dang gay anh hffdng nhieu nha'l de'n Khu bao ton. Vide chan flia trau bd trong Khu bao tdn gay ra cdc eanh tranh ve thffc an, ndi sd'ng dd'i vdi ddng vat rffng. Sff di chuyen thffdng xuydn cua sue vat nudi cung Iam fliay doi mdt each dang ke eanh quan va kd't ca'u iff nhien cua sinh canh rffng.
Hdn nffa, do phong luc va tap qudn, thdi quen cu, nen vdn cdn hien tffdng khai thdc gd lam san trdi phep lam dd hau sff, hien Iffdng dat bdy d l bat cdc con thu nhd, dilng sung san de bdn chim va cac loai thu trung binh song chu yd'u cdc vi pham tff ngffdi dan sinh sd'ng d khu vffe gidp ranh Khu bao ton, khdng ghi nhan thay
cae vi pham dang nay tff ngffdi^dan sinh sd'ng trong vimg ddm Khu bao ton.
DE XUAT MOT SO GIAI PHAP Thtf nha't, giai phap nang cao ti'nh hieu qua cua cd chd' chinh sach ve quan ly riifng
Dieu chinh chinh .sach khodn bao vd rffng
- Uu tidn khoan bao vd rffng va cdc boat ddng hen quan dd'i vdi ngffdi dan sd'ng Irong Khu bao tdn.
- Dieu ehinh lang mffe kinh phi khoan bao ve rffng phii hdp, sat vdi thffc te de dam bao ngffdi ddn cd thl dffde sd'ng dffdc nhd khodn rffng.
- Hoan thien edng tac khoan bao ve de'n tffng hd dan sd'ng trong vilng dem, thrfe hien md hinh "Dong quan ly " trong edng tac bao tdn, huy ddng cgng dong dan cff tham gia vao cdng tdc bao ton.
Dieu chinh ehinh sach dau tff, tin dung, tai chinh cho boat ddng quan ly, bao ve va phdt Irie'n rffng dde dung
Can ndi rdng ed che'chinh sdch nham da dang hda ngudn vd'n dau tff, tin dung, tai chinh cho boat ddng quan ly, bdo vd va phdt trien rffng dac dung dam bao nguon Irfc vd'n dap ffng drfdc vdi yeu cau thffc tidn.
Dieu chinh chinh sach su* dung tai nguyen rffng dac dung
- Trong phan khu phue hdi sinh thdi drfdc sff dung tdng hdp cac bidn phap ky thuat Iam sinh de dilu chinh mat dd, ca'u trtic, nang cao cha't Iffdng va thuc day nhanh qud trinh phue hoi rffng va hd sinh thai.
- Trong phdn khu dieh vu - hanh chinh dffdc tan thu, tan dung nhffng cay go da chd't, gly do va nhffng cay trong pham vi giai phdng mat bang de xay dffng cac edng trinh theo quy hoaeji; drfdc khai thdc cac loai lam san ngoai gd trff cae Ioai thrfe vat rffng, ddng vat rffng nguy ed'p, quy, hid'm quy dinh tai Nghi dinh sd 32/2006/
ND-CP, ngay 30/03/2006 cua Chinh phu.
- Can xay drfng ed chd' chia se ldi ich, chu trgng quyen ldi va sff tham gia eua ngffdi dan, dong vien moi lang Idp nhan dan, doan the xa hdi tham gia Lxing lac bao ve rffng. Cu the: rfu tidn ngu'di dan sinh sdng trong khu vrfc rffng dae dung, rffng phong hd dffdc chia se nhffng ldi ich tff rffng, nhrf: tham gia bao ve rffng va dffdc hrfdng cae ldi ich cua - l-,inh saeh bao ve va phat trien rffng, ed !ii\6n tid'p
18
can rffng, khai thac cac loai lam san ngoai g6, san phim irdng xen dffdi tan rffng..., nhffng khdng Iam anh hffdng de'n bao ton da dang sinh hgc rffng.
- Khuye'n khich phdt Iriln cac boat dgng dich vu mdi trffdng rffng, kinh doanh du Hch sinh thai trong rffng dac dung phu hdp vdi quy dinh cua phap luat, nham lao ngudn thu, bd sung ngudn kmh phi dffdc ca'p tff ngdn sdch nha nffde.
Thu' hai, giai phap cai thidn cae ngu6n lu'c phuc vu cong tac quan ly riifng
Ve ngudn vdn:
- Can da dang hda ngudn lai ehinh dau tff cho cdng tde quan Iy rffng: Ngoai ngudn tai chinh dau trf trf ngan sach nha nffdc chi cho boat dgng qudn Iy, bao vd va phdt triin rffng, cln huy ddng da dang cdc nguon tai chinh khac, nhrf: cac doanh nghidp sff dung dich vu mdi trffdng rffng;
cac doanh nghidp du lich tff boat dgng khai thdc dich vu du Iich sinh ihdi; cac td chffc qud'c te', cdc td chffc phi chinh pbii tff cac hoat ddng dilu tra, gidm sdl, nghien cffu khoa hgc ve bao ton da dang sinh hgc, bao tdn canh quan hen quan de'n rffng.
- Xem xel tang ede dieu kien ffu dai ve tin dung cho ngrfdi dan drfdc giao khodn bao vd rffng, cu the nhff tang thdi gian vay va dinh mffc tin dung dd'i vdi eae khoan vay khdng cd lai san dam bao.
Ddi vdl nguon vdt Iffc:
Tang cffdng he Ihd'ng thdng tin, nang eao nang Iffc, ffng dung cdng nghd thdng tin trong qudn ly, theo ddi diln bid'n tai nguyen rffng, thffdng xuydn cap nhal tinh hinh bao ve rffng.
- Tang cffdng trang thie't bi phuc vu can bd kiem lam va thanh vidn td bao vd rffng thrfe hien cdng tdc tuan tra, kiem tra rffng.
- Xdy dffng he thd'ng canh bdo chay rffng, he ihd'ng thdng tin lidn lac chi huy phdng cho'ng chdy rffng.
Ddi vdi nguon nhdn luc:
- Can cai thien sd' Iffdng, chat Iffdng dpi ngii cdn bd Ban quan Iy Khu bao tdn.
Cu the, bd sung ve so Irfdng bidn chd' can bd Ban quan ly Khu bao tdn; Can
TAI LIEU THAM KHAO
cd ehinh sach rfu tien tuyen cdn bd cd Irinh do chuydn mdn ve bao tdn tdi nguyen thidn nhidn va da dang sinh hpc; Cln cd cd chd', chinh sdch thu hiit tuyen dimg ngffdi dan dia phrfdng vao lam viec lai Ban Quan ly Khu bdo tdn va cd chd'dd cff tuyen di dao tao chuydn mdn, nghiep vu; Can cd them chinh sach dai ngd ve tai chinh dd'i vdi can bd kiem lam dia ban, dac bidt la can bd nff.
-Cai thidn sd Irfdng, chat Iffdng dpi ngu thanh vien id bao vd rffng lai cac xa. Can thffdng xuydn md cdc ldp dao lao ngan han nhdm bdi dffdng kie'n thffc va nghiep yu bao vd rffng cho cde thanh vien id bao vd rffng; Cln bd sung kinh phi phuc vu cong lac hdi hpp, trrfc ban eua td bao ve rffng.
Thu" ba, giai phap nang cao nhan thtfc va thay d^i tap quan sinh hoat, san xua't cua ngifdi dSn
(i) Nang cao nhgn thffc ciia ngiM ddn ve trdch nhiem bdo ve, phdt trien riing vd bdo ton da dgng sinh hgc
- Thffdng xuyen td chffc tuyen truyen, phd bie'n sau rdng bang nhieu hinh thffc, phrfdng lidn, lam cho ngrfdi dan hid'u ro ve vai trd cua rffng; nhffng thiet hai dd'i vdi ddi sd'ng cua chinh ho trong hidn tai va the' he tffdng Iai nd'u d l xay ra ma't rffng, Iam ton hai rffng.
- Tuyen truyen, pho bid'n sdu rdng ve cdc gia in cua he sinh thdi rffng, vai trd cua bao tdn da dang sinh hpc, pho' bid'n cu thl dd'n ngffdi dan. Tang cffdng tuyen truyen, phd bie'n sau rdng de'n ngrfdi dan nhffng kid'n thffc cd bdn v l phdp ludl trong ITnh vffe bao ve, phat tnen rffng, da dang sinh hoc.
(ii) Giaiphap thay doi tgp qudn sinh hogt, sdn xud't cua ngffdi ddn
- Tuyen truyen, van ddng nhffng ngffdi cd uy tin trong thdn ban thay dd'i nhffng tap quan lac hau, lam xam hai dd'n rffng, dien hinh nhff tue sff dung than gd nguyen khd'i d l lo hau srf.
- Xff ly nghiem cac vi pham eua ngrfdi dan ve chan tha gia sue iff do trong Khu bao tdn; ve hanh vi sdn ban, bdy bdt ddng vat trong Khu bao tdn.
- C i n c d nhffng cd chd'ehinh sach thu hut cde doanh nghidp du lich ldn dau trf khai thdc cdc san pham du lich dac Irrfng cua Khu bdo ton, nhrf: du lieh sinh thai, du lich kd'l hdp nghien cffu, du lich hpc tap, du lich trai nghidm, du iich van hda, dujich cdng dong, qua dd tao cdng dn vide lam, thay doi sinh ke' cho ngffdi dan Khu bdo tdn.
- Can dieu chinh quy hoach, xae dinh lai ranh gidi viJng bao ve ciia Khu bao tdn d l dam bao quy da'l eho ngffdi dan san xua't, tranh vidc khdng cd da't eanh tac, ngffdi dan phai sd'ng phu thugc vao rffng.•
1. UBND xa Kim Tid'n (2018). Bdo cdo Tinh hinh thffc hien ke hogch phdt trien kinh te- xd hdi ndm 2018, Ki'hogch phdt trien kinh le - xd hgi ndm 2019
2. UBND xa Thffdng Tie'n (2018). Bdo cdo Tinh hinh phdt tnen kinh li' - xa hgi ndm 2018.
PhuOng hudng. nhiem vu phdt Irien kinh li'- xd hoi ndm 2019
3. Ban quan Iy Khu bao tdn thien nhien Thffdng Tid'n (2014-2018). Bdo cdo Tdng ket cong tdc qudn ly hdo vi rffng - bdo tdn thien nhien cdc ndm. Iff 2014 de'n 2018
