Qnstc
—|-»
from Australia to France
COGEMA
Executive
summary
Thefirstmaritimeshipmentofresearchreactorspent fuelfromAustraliato Franceinitiatesanew partnership betweenthe Australian NuclearScienceand TechnologyOrganisation,ANSTO,andtheFrenchCompagnie Généraledes I\/latieresNucléaires,COGEl\/IA.
Thespent fuel elementsthat will betransferred
to
Francearisefrom theHIFAR researchreactor,operated by ANSTO.HlFARisat the heartof
Australia's nuclearscienceandtechnology program,whichencompassesthefieldsof nuclearmedicine, servingdomestic andforeignmarkets,materials and environmentalresearch.Spentfuelfromnuclearresearch reactorsmaybemanagedunder three main strategies: long-termstorage, direct disposal oroverseasreprocessing.Given the particular natureofANSTO’sfuel,Australia haschosen theoverseas reprocessingpathduetothewidelyrecognisedadvantages
of
this proven industrialsolution.Toimplementthis strategy,ANSTO hascontractedwithCOGEIVIA,theWorld leaderin nuclearfuel reprocessing,with morethanthree decadesofsuccessful
andsafeindustrial operation. .
Thereprocessingoperationsaswellasthe associated transportswillbecarried outunderverystringentQualityAssurance/Quality Control policies andvvill be infullcompliancewithall relevantinternationalandnational regulations, particularly those relatedtosafety.
Content
Nuclear activities in Australia o_W ow page4
ANSTO’s spent fuel management _____o pageg
COGEMA, a
<1d
§- I‘ M soun an
reliable partners
so o_o so sus
sopage12
.0
Reprocessing,
-a durable
and dependable solution __o-__ ____ **
o_page15
COGEMA and the environment _u_7_ page 19
Transport of spent fuel
from Australia to France uwo_u__ Y___ page 22
At a glance
u-
V u sopage 27
1?;
'1‘~'\1\;§\»:r
The Lucas Heights Science and Technology Centre,
site of Austra|ia’s nuclear research activities
Flustralia was
oneofthefirst countries
tobuild
anuclear
researchreactor. TheHighFlux/Ziustalian Reactor(HIF/ZiR). theonlyfunctioning
nuclearreactor
inthecountry.
isoperated by/Zii\lSTOat
theLucas HeightsScienceand
Technology Centre site. someforty
kilometerssouthof
Sydney.Itis
at
theheartofalmost all
/ZiNSTO'sresearchactivities and supports
thoseofseueral
otherorganisations
ontheLucas Heightssite.Nuclear activities
in Australia
J
a
What
is anuclear research
and mayholdiso
tonnesoituel,
whereasHlFARreactor?
nominalmaximum poweroutputisl0
megawatts,withatotal fuel loadofonly7 kilograms.
Researchreactors playavital roleinimportant Research reactorsaresmallerthannuclearpower
reactorsUsedtogenerateelectrlclm mtermsof medical,environmental, agricultural,scientic sizeandpoweroutput. Forinstance, commercial
power reactors ottenexceed3,000megawatts
HIFARresearchreactorsteelcontainmentbuilding
and industrialapplications.
l—llFAR, a l<ey
tool in Australian nuclear expertise
HIFAR has operated at Lucas Heights since
i958.
Today, HIFAR irradiates materials and generatesneutron beamsforvariouspurposes
atLucas Heights.
page4
inthe elds ofmedicine andhealth, scientific research,theenvironmentandindustry.
Bytheendof 2005, aftermorethan47yearsof operation, l—llFARwill beshutdownand replaced bya newresearchreactorthat willbeconstructed
I Medical applications:
HIFARgeneratesarangeofradioactive elements called radioisotopes.They are selected for their
Anexpertusingaradioisotope
I Industrial applications:
diffractionor scattering techniques.
Thesestudies permit the development ofstronger, lighter, more
resistant anddetectingequipment to check materialsfor theintegrityofapipeline ind Ustry more usefulchemicalsandadvanced pharmaceuticals.
HIFAR irradiates silicon crystals, transmuting silicon atoms into phosphorus to suit the HNSTO producesalmost Specic
90% ofAustralia’: nuclear
medicine requirements Characterlsncs appropriatefordia- gnostic ortherapeutic applicationssuchas muscularskeletalinjuries, pain palliation, heart disease,andthe detectionandtreatmentofcancer.
itsbiggest customersarethe nuclear medicine departmentsofhospitals and clinicsinAustralia andtheAsian region.
ijuclearmedicineisoneofthefastest growing T
needs
of
electronic components manufacturersfrom
Japan andother
countries.The silicon irradiated
in HIFAR is
fieldsinmodern medicine. Irradiated silicon produced-
--
returnedto
Oncurrentprojections, nearlyeveryAustralian inHIFARisusedextensively silicon suppliers canexpecttohavea nuclearmedicineprocedure 5"the
ele°"°"i”‘ i"d“$">'
vvhere it is slicedintheirlifetime.
into vvafers andsupplied to electronics companies.
I Sdentlc aPPll¢atl°n53
It is subsequently used in Charge Coupled Withmorethan 7,000 hoursin neutronbeam Devices (CCDs) in video cameras and fax ma- time providedeach year, HIFARis a major chines, in high povver transistors, diodes, researchtoolforscientistsandstudentsfrom thyristors and Silicon Controlled Rectifiers Australiaand overseas. (SCRs)for
povver transmission and air Studiesofthe
chemicalstructuresand magneticconditioning
control units, and in computer propertiesofmaterialsaremade using neutron DRAM (Dynamic Random Access Memory).lilllllflilllllll lllllillllllill
llll lllllllll lllllllllll llllli Ill lllli llllll
llllllllllliilllllll
Ill
ll@l'I|llllllill
page5
Qpe[(1tQ[ Q1 l:llEZlRl
—the United Nations’ International Atomic EnergyAgency (UN-IAEA) and,
—the Organisation for EconomicCooperation and Development's Nuclear EnergyAgency (OECD-NEA).
vtooperate largenuclearscienceand technology basedfacilitiesin Australiaand overseasforthe benefitofindustryandthe Australian research and development community.
Thefacilities operated byANSTO include particularlythe research reactor HIFAR, the Na- tional Medical Cyclotron (NMC) and the TheLucasHeightsScienceand Technology Centre site Australian National Tandem Acceleratorfor
Applied Research (ANTARES).
Established ih April 1987 to tepleee the 0to undertake research on specifictopicsto At,|5tra|iah
Atomic
Energy Commission, the advancethe understanding ofnuclear science Australian Nuclear Science and Technology and Theiieeleeilel
CYele-Qrganlgatlonl ANSTO, is at the eehtte
of
ANSTO operates in a numberof research areas.At_|5tra|]ah hueiear eXpett'|5e_» Among themare theapplication ofnuclear ThisAustralian Government agency occupiesa
70-hectaresiteseparatedfrom residences bya
l.6
l<m bufferzone ofpredominantly virgin l bushland.Withastaffofmorethan 800,ANSTOisoneof the largest employersinthe SutherlandShirelocal governmentareaand makesasignificant
economiccontibution to theShireandnearby areas.
TheLucasHeightsScience andTechnology Centre
isalso hometo partofthe Commonvvealth Scientificand IndustrialResearchOrganisation
andotherbusinessesinvolvedinscience and ANS_m,sSm” work technology. Togethervviththeuseofcontractors
andserviceprovidersfrom thelocalarea,some l9l’iY5le5i ad‘/eiieeel Ceiemlei the Pi°¢e55ln9 and 1,109 peepte ate employed atthe Site utilisation of radioactive materials, radioactive
waste management, bio-medicine and health, A[\l§T() pursue;Set/ete| ebjeetit/es; environmental sciences, research in crystal and
0toprovide expert scientificand technical advice meleeillei 5TiUCTUie5i and iedleplieimeeeetleel acrossthe nuclear fuel cycletogovernmentin 5Cleii<Ie5-
support ofnuclear policyissuesofstrategicnatio- 0toapply resulting technologies and otherrele- nal lI’iT€i’8ST andAustralia's international ob|iga- \/ant, UniqueQapabilitiegtofggugged research and
ilOI'iSlit ’EhiSarea developmentand otherscientific activitiesto
ANSTO provides notablythe technical basis for increasethecompetitivenessofAustralian industry AU5Tiella'5leeiilelpeileiilni and improve the qualityoflifeforallAustralians.
page6
F»
»<mr&~
\1 r.
&
é
The HIFAR research reactor.
The top has been removed for routine maintenance
Sincethe
beginning of
itsoperations
someforty
years ago. HIF/ZIRhas
accumulated
aninventory ofmore than
l.4OOspentfuel
elements.ANSTO.
with
theapproval oftheZlustralian
Government, hasselected the overseas reprocessingpath.
Toimplement
this strategy.ANSTO has
contracted with COGEMA
ANSTO’s
spentfuel
management
A
Houz does the reactoc i Qpe[ate7
lThe HIFAR core contains 25 fuel elements, COOlin9-
Comaining enriched uranium, which is Storing spent nuclear fuel elements
for
alloyed vvith aluminum. All l—llFAR elements several years under Water allows them to were manufactured in the Ul<, vvhile the lOS@muih
Of their activity.enriched Uranium W55 gupplied by bgth the \/VlW€l’l ’El’t€ l't€€iT has decreased sufficiently, UK and the USA. After the fuel is placed
llllellm
CW 5tOla9@ l5 made l5>O55lb|€‘-inside the reactor core, fission - the splitting of uranium atoms - occurs.
After some time, the nuclear fuel is no longer able
to
operate efficiently. Therefore everyfour
weeks, three orfour
used or spent fuel elements are removed from the reactor and replaced by nevv fuel elements.Annually, HIFAR uses around 37 fuel elements.
Once discharged from the reactor core, the
spent fuel elements are stored in pools
for
HIFARfuel element <15PreparedforShipmentpage8
m
Dependingonthe natureofthe fuel, thelong- maytherefore impairthe development ofthe di- termopt'ionsf
orresearchreactorspentfuelmana- rectdisposaloption for' ' researchreactorsPentfuel gementmayinclude extendedinterimstdirectdisposal and overseasreprocessing
Long-term interim storage
orage, formanyyears.
Reprocessing
Theoverseasreprocessingoptionis a reality,as Thelong-term interim storageofspent fuel does demonstrated bydecadesofexperienceinseveral not constitutea reliable solution. Indeed,some countries‘ ' aroundthevvorld. ln France, COGEl\/|A’s researchreactorsoperatorshaveencounteredcor- trackrecord in reprocessing encompassesmore rosionandmaterial' degradation problems' 'in than 30years,mainly' inthe largescaleLa Hague existingfacilities.Thisoption therefore cannotbe plant.
consideredasanacceptablesolution.
Separatingthe remaining enricheduraniumstill
Directdisposal
contained' 'inthe spent fuelfromthevvaste, makes theuranium availablefor furtheruse.Theisolation Thedirect disposalofresearch reactor spent fuel andconditioningofthe
ultimate\/vaste'intoah'ighly elementsoptionfaces severalunsolveddifficulties. stableform providesasafeandsoundsolutionfor Giventhe natureof aluminiumcladfuel, onehas transport,long-termstorage and final disposal.to
ensurethatthefuelanditsenriched
uranium l\/loreoveritsignificantl, yminim'isesthe ultimate‘contentvvill remainsafeandstable overalong volumeofthe waste disposedofwhen compared periodoftime. to the other options' generally availableforRTR Technicalandeconomical risksanduncertainties spentfuelmanagement.
RTR spent fu 1‘ eprocessing, main advantages:
I Recovery of valuable and reusable material
I Reduction of volume of ultimate waste
g I I High Safe conditioning stability of the for ultimate transport, long-term storage and residues final disposal
AN STO’s strategy
4» .A
9
i-if,'-If
».;
§~;-.f,_D___..._“.._M...__.___
holdmeSpentfuel element ,-m,e,,w,y oConditioning of thevvasteintoa dedicate
vfe.
.,'Ȥ
. "L -.
*5‘
7» . 3»
5
ryunderground storagefacilityatFINSTO used to
-L I 0': ' u0.|0.;'||'|
Thestrategyputin place by ANSTOandapproved bythe AustralianGovernmentinvolvesthe follovvingsuccessive steps:
0 Reprocessing ofspent fuel overseas,as no reprocessing facility has been established nor will be
established
inAustralia
dform
page9
(l<nownaslong-lived intermediate wasteform), 240 spentfuel elements were shipped to the US suitableforfinal storage. DepartmentofEnergy's Savannah River site, in
- 1998. NowasteswillbereturnedtoAustralia
0 Return of thewastetoAustralia.
fromtheseUS-origin fuel elements.
'
L099-Term 5TOfa9eof
The eondltlened Wage Soonafter thislastshipment,the United Kingdom in a national intermediate level radioactive Govemmemdecided DounreayWOU|dnot enter Wage5T9fa9e laelll'W- into new fuelreprocessingcontracts.ThismeantthatANSTO hadtolooktoother commercial ThreeSlllpmemsofSpentfuel lled alreadybeen reprocessorstohandleitsnon-USorigin spent fuel.
sent overseaspriortotheANSTO-COGEIVIAagree- ment,
two
totheUnited Kingdom and onetothe UnitedStates.Previous shipments to the United Kingdom and the United States
Thefirst shipmentto theUK, in 1963, wasof 150elements,whilethe second,in 1996, was
of
114 elements.Thetwo
shipments were sentto the United KingdomAtomicEnergyAuthority's Dounreayplantin Scotland.HIFARhasalso used US-originfuel elements.The
UnitedStates has launcheda programto ANS]-0,5Staffeompletmgp,epa,at,O,efe, repatriatethe spent fuelOfUS-origin, and apreviousshipmentofspent fuel
J
A new PARTNERSHIP
ANSTOandCOGEIVIAcompletednegotiationsand (about1,3OOfuel elements) and hasprovisions
acontractwas signedinJanuary, 1999. Underthe forthe reprocessingofthe spent fuelfromthe termsofthiscontract,COGEIVIAwillassistANSTO FE-plaC€'men’£FGHCTOF
intheimplementation ofitsstrategyofdurable
andreliableback-end managementforthe The1,300 HIFARspent fuel elements willbe researchreactor gpent fuel, transportedinfourshipmentsfromtheendof The servicesthatCOGEIVIA shall performare, 199910 Z004-
briefly:
Transportofthe {LEI dementsin Theultiimateresiduessfhallbereturnedto dedicated casksonspecially equippedshipsfrom Ausllala’ asplovlded orbylheFrenchlaw’ and Australiato France. bytheterms
of
the commercial agreement. Both theFrenchandAustralian Governmentssupporto Reprocessing ofthe spent fuel elements at the the principleofthe retem COGEIVIA-La Hagueplant.
Thereturnshipmentsofresidues,whichwill be
9 COFTClltlOl’lll'lgOfll'l€ultimateWGSTQ ll'llO8St<'ilfJl€ encasedinSpecialCanistersContainedin dUa|_
form
purposecasks(fortransportand storage),shalloReturnof ultimateresiduesforstorage and final takeplace by 2015.Thequantityofresiduesto
disposal inAustralia bereturnedisestimatedtobe36 canisters having
Thecontractcoversall non-USHIFARspent fuel atotalvolumeofaround 6cubic meters.
page 10
The COGEMA Group is active throughout the world
in the nuclear fuel cycle
WW!
Uranium mining
Uranium enrichment
Uranium conversion
La Hague
reprocessing plant
Fuel
assembly manufacturing
Nuclear transport
COGEMA
asound
9
and reliable partner
France is one ofthe leading nuclear technology I
9 9 8
countries in the world
with
58 nuclear power plants in operation. Nuclear provides 76%of
French electricity output. Several companies and 34.4
research institutes are in charge of running the 30.5
"'7
31.5[4.8]
French nuclear technology program. Among them.
COGEM/Fl Group. established in
I976 specialises in the nuclearfuel cycle.
Its main share holders are the French State
consolidated
Salesrevenue
(8/.5%). the Total Fina-Elf Group
(/5%)
and an engineering group, Technip (3.5%).The COGEM/Zl Group is active throughout the
2&4 iii
Iljl
iI—i
II
[as]
[225]
[0.4/
_ 1.2
world in various fields from uranium mining and if
]
enrichment to spentfuel reprocessing and recycling as well as transport. Outside the nuclearfield. the COGEM/Z1 Group also provides engineering and services to several industries.
With a workforceof I8.700 highly skilled and well-trained persons and a consolidated sales re- i venue ofmore than
3/ billion
French Francsfor fiscal year /998. COGEA/IA ranks among the foremost French industrial groups.COGEM/Zl provides services to French and foreign customers: 40.5 %
of
the above cited figure was achieved abroad.COGEM/Zi has subsidiaries and affiliates mainly in the USA. Germany, Belgium, Spain, Ukraine.
japan, Republic of Korea, China. Taiwan and
Australia.
COGEMZl's activities contribute to the optimisation of the use ofenergy resources and the minimisation l of ultimate waste volume and toxicity in line
with
the objectives defined at the /992 Earth Summit regarding sustainable development.
page 12
‘\
0.45]
[DA
[D U1
LO CT!
LO
\J
ID
U
Contributions of
eachactivity to consolidated
sales revenueof the
COGEMAGroup in I998
Share
of
salesabroad in
consolidated
sales revenueCOGEMA
an |'n|.u;a||a|
0{III Ii’ '1 luq ' {'0
0nail '
COGEIVIA is the
world's
largest providerof
l\/lOFe specifically. the COGEl\/lA Group haS spent fuel reprocessing services,with
over gained SOunOl eXi>erienCe in RTR Spent fuel14,500 tonnes
of
Light Water Reactor management, includingtransportation,
(Power Reactor) spent fuel reprocessed by reprocessing,conditioning
and shipmentof
mid-1999.
the relatedultimate
waste.Controlroomat COGEMA-La Hague
COGEl\/IA has
many years of lh addition
t0
the contract With ANSTO, experience COGEIVIA has spent fuel management reprocessing RTR contractswith
the Belgian BR2 research spent fuelfrom
reactor and the international ILL research French research reactor in France.reactors.
The
hm Transportation of
RTRspent
reprocessing
fuel
plant in . . _.
operation in , T
France was l\/larcoule, which operated from l the
mid-1950's
to September 1997.The La Hague industrial complex, located in Normandy, started up in 1966 and has been reprocessing nuclear spent fuel from French and foreign
utility
customers since then.COGEl\/IA-La Hague has a nominal capacity of 1,700 tonnes per year and has contracts
to
reprocess nuclear spent fuelwith
about Shipmeneofkmspentfuel29 utilities from 6 countries (France, Japan, from“-reBe|gianBR2 COGEMA Germany, Switzerland, Belgium and
the
Ft-‘$¢‘1'¢h'¢'1¢f°"through
ltsiNetherlands). Subsldlafy .
TRANSNUCLEAIRE offers optimised services The WhO|e pram has reached a high degree covering the complete transport chain (cask
of
industrial performancetogether with
deslgn andmamlfactufer transport
outstanding quality, safety,flexibility
andpfepafatlon
andf°ll°W'thf°U9h' malnte'
environmental protection results. fiance)-La Hague plant evolution has always been TRANSNUCLEAIRE uses several types
of
casks characterised by the implementationof for
thetransport of
RTR spent fuel.state-of-the-art
equipment. New units are In 1999, TRANSNUCLEAlRE has introduced a less than 10 years old and will be operational new generationtransport
cask, called thefor
several decades into the next century. TN-|\/ITR. This cask has been speciallydesigned
for
easy handling,without
COGE|\/IA has set up a unique gathering of sophisticated equipment. it will be used for the most advanced technologies
to
minimise the transport Of ANSTO'S Spent fuel elements.and manage waste arising from nuclear RTR spent fuel
transportation
is routinelyspent fuel processing. made around the
world.
page 13
'0
l993i l6
5lllF>m@0Y5 Were Performed by vvastefor
storage and final disposal including TRANSNUCLE/\lREr TWOof
Which We"? from vitrified fission products and compactedThe Belgian BR2 f@5@aT¢h Teacloi structural pieces
that
arise from reprocessingReprocessing of spent fuel
UnloadingRTRspentfuel at LaHague
About13,000kg
of aluminide spent fuel arising from 21 research reactors and 5,900 l<g
of
heavy metal of other types ofRTR fuels vvere successfully reprocessed at
the
COGEl\/lA- UPl plant located at l\/larcoule.UPT vvas shut do\/vn
for
com- mercial reasons in 1997 afterforty
years of satisfactory operation. The knovv-hovv gainedthrough
this experience has been transferredto
theframework
of La Hagueplant activities.
Conditioning ofthevvaste
Glasspouringatthevitrification facilityat COCEMA-La Hague
For the
ultimate
disposed
of
in Australia, COGEl\/IA Wlll use the Universal Canister.
The Universal Canister can
every type of
operations.
As of
mid-i999,
6,600 vitrifed residues canisters have been safely produced at COGEl\/IA-La Hague in full compliance vvith customer requirements and the relevant na- tional regulations.Transportation of ultimate
residues
Previousreturnshipmentofvitrifiedresidues fromCOQEMA-La Haguetojapan
yesydtles to be The return
of
residues is a vvell-established procedure as 6 overseas transportsof
vitrified residues have already been safely conducted by sea, road and rail (4 to Japan and 2 to Germany).The
transport of
the conditionedultimate
residues as vvell as the reprocessing and conditioning steps abide by the mostaccommodate stringent
international and nationalregulations and standards.
page14
‘X
s ‘
'
»;:m=
$
‘WW'¢""
w
~,;y{g\ 143,.‘ \. H\»\“»\1;,~»\,-'@§;Z;;;\d \~~,»\\~ .‘M145‘ §cr;'~\ M‘,.\mH,, J,»» >4?M
‘ » v‘ ~ \‘\“ _ :4W‘‘A \~»~.\,\~ ‘ _ ‘»;w-\‘\‘»~~9‘cw» .\\\\9*~*». _<¢~¢$.‘<',\~.\'M\"\3:="\\~w \ \"'\".TX5Y.
‘"
W M“}\\\.;‘. - ¢;_';;j~;V; v\\ w,,\\r»n.‘“F451? »f¢;:*\.\"~" ‘ ‘
E 2A-in-‘V
. _<¢_.‘
< ¢..»,»:/;<~»» n ->‘_"'!':H . , .
1 ‘W:‘-an."~‘i'---/55> _ v. / » ~-‘1::'~,na='‘-.~:_V ..1 V 4.‘ - ‘I. ._ _ r --.321,-V. -/— ~I .,- .--.~w:~ > '..';.\‘-A\..
.
<_.1, 2/_»;’*.'Y»\;~‘<‘-~,'='_>-wu, . . ....»
' _‘ - 1 , ‘ '*
.-.<.~;,,»;
.,
»W -‘.-
<' ~ ..'. V .~»: .-:.:<;;é:.;=,'~::-~.--;:\’:5-“-L- ‘“-““‘§‘\“<T":"*i§’~,<;;_;€;/E;;_5-‘:.<;{;‘.\.»»,\.Wu~ :3/:§;;,,; ‘F ;_~U,,-,_~?_;;5f_ _,1 .“M7 »;:;<;{>0;,-‘= “inf.,\‘.~‘.(»,-.~-- ;,~~>..r_»,-~.\*,,"!
_ , ,-W </‘iiA \.._,,4,
.§,/
gg ‘ . 1 .\ \ ‘ ;;/~>‘ < ~ :<
/ . »‘ \‘ 1- <
\ ~ “* ‘\"-=~::<:<'' (5%? '-~Y
"
-‘ ;':‘~i;>@;1¢ - -.= ‘~) V).-5:3, , ,3 E‘ ‘ ~.‘=,»~ ._~, X’
w
*1‘m
\.‘
<5/.11‘, ‘‘Aq ‘‘ '~-$1‘1,,» -. L {$31 <\' a\ g\\‘
-.
* ’~ A ~‘ ~\ I1
V. .:-<_5‘k A ‘ , ;,?/‘ ' ‘ \\ \\1 @w ‘.',~‘;¥:‘.,;~$_:»:j\:<;<3»
3,» »‘VMa“.Iv»-;m<~}';.;:'<~'\ ‘\_\$\:.u;;3c;;r\§E,§~:‘v‘<‘ 3‘ S, , 4;; 9; ‘15»,
=‘=1 2.
\\
» aw
,":
. Q,x
W“..
The COGEMA-La Hague plant
Thereprocessing
of
HIF/ZlRspentfuel elementswill
beperformed undertheroutine. well-established
industrial
processinuseat
COGE/\/l/Zl~LaHague. Reprocessingis a seriesofmechanical and chemical operations which
separatethevaluable and
reusablematerial still contained
in
nuclear
spentfuel (suchasenricheduranium) from final
wastesthat
havenofurther
useand cannot
berecycled.After having
beenseparated,thewastesareconditioned into
auerystableand compact form suitable for transport,
storageand final
disposal.\
Reprocessing,
Oa durable and
dependable solution
The PROCESS
‘IQ II‘ I’
Reprocessing involvesseveralsuccessive steps. In vvill becutintopiecesasnecessaryand dissolved addition,preliminaryoperationsarecarried out intoa nitricacid liquor.Theliquorarisingfrom before actual reprocessing begins. HIFARspent fueldissolutionvvillbeblendeddovvn
vvith liquorsfromdissolutionofcommercial
R€C€pTlOl’l and storage
li’l povverreactorspentfuel.spent fuel storage pool
ln the
further
process steps, uranium vvill be OnarrivalattheCOGEIVIA-LaHague reprocessing separatedfor
storage and subsequent plant,aftercheckingthe transportcasksandtheir recycling. Fission products, the very lovv contents,thefuelelementsvvill beremovedfromquantity
ofplutonium,
and structural pieces thetransportcasks, placed in baskets andstored vvill then be conditioned into a very stable undervvaterinadeactivation pool, enabling form suitablefor
transport, storage and final cooling,asnecessary,before thecommencement disposal.ofreprocessing.
Waste conditioning Spentfuel reprocessing
Theindustrialprocessappliedtotheconditioning Reprocessingvvill beginwiththe dissolution ofthesevarious categoriesofwastesvvillvary operation. Onceoutofthe pool, the spent fuel accordingtotheir nature.
pagel6
Fissionproducts andplutoniumvvill bevitrified, thenbeencased inastandardstainless steel thatis, incorporatedintoastableglassmatrix, packagereferredtoastheUniversal Canister.
while structural piecesvvill becompacted indiscs.
Afterbeingfilled, the canistersvvill behermetically Almostalltheradioactivityvvillbeencased inthe sealedandvvillundergoaseriesof thorough
glassmatrix. checks.
Boththeglassmatrix and compacteddiscsvvill
ENCAPSULATION
iv H
. [2
.Theconditioned ultimateresiduesthatvvill be Quality Control program (QA/QC)toguarantee returnedtoAustraliaareindustrially proven high thattheconditionedultimateresiduescomply technologyproducts, manufactured under strict withthe abovementioned specications.
Quality AssuranceandQuality Control systems.
l\/lore specifically,adedicatedQADepartmenthas
fe
'_"‘1i"An industrially pl'OV€i'i hlg
|’i been setupatl.aHague. ltguarantees thevvholecha';:"':l""ft'°5
°7; T€Cl'inology
pFOCl UCT. .. plant QualitySystemwhilemonitoring the qualitycanemguizsgs ofproducts delivered bynearly200 suppliers.
follows:
Theindustrialprocesses(vitrification,‘compaction Each year, i00,000 conditionedproductsare Height:L34
andconditioning instandard packaging)thatvvill checkedaccordingtothis framevvork.outside beusedtosafelyimmobilisethe various inaddition, on November 26,
i997,
the La Hague diameter: categoriesofresiduesremovedfromHIFARspent plantvvasgrantedtheISO9002certification,43cm fuelthrough reprocessingatLaHagueresultfrom followingathorough audit
ofthe
site.Thisproves thirtyyearsofextensive researchcarriedoutin the consistency and efficiencyofthe QAsystem in France. TheseR&Dactivitiesvvereaimedat placeatLa Hague.identifyingthemost stable solid form to immobi-
lisethe resulting long-lived intermediatelevel Ontop of that, foreignCOGEIVIAcustomershave
wastes. contracted the internationallyknovvn Bureau
Veritaswiththe responsibilityof controllingthe Alltheindustrial processes, vvhoseefficiencyhas operations,theindependent checkingoftheQA been internationallyrecognised,arealreadyorwill programs and theability tocertifycomplianceof
beshortlyimplementedon acommercialscaleat eachvitrifiedresiduescanistervvithagreed theCOGEIVIA-La Haguereprocessingplant.l\/lore specifications.
than 6,600 canistersofvitrified residues have beensafelyproducedasofSeptember i999.
...offering numerous ...manufactured undervery advantages
stringent Quality Assurance
and COmfQ| 5y5tem5
Thevitrificationandcompaction offinalvvastesas vvell astheuseofastandard packagingto condi- tiontheseultimate residuesprovideseverala . Alltheconditioned ultimateresiduestobe re- advantages,
' . turnedtoAustraliavvill bemanufactured incom-
pliancevvithspecifications meeting theIAEAcrite- ¢
High stability and safety of the ultimate
riaforlong-lived intermediatelevel vvastesand residues
TheUniversalcanlslef approvedbythe relevantcompetentauthoritiesin
Australia and France.COC-iEi\/|Avvillimplement Theindustrialtechnologies developedandimple- verystringentQuality Assurancesystemsand mented atCOGEl\/lA-l_a Hagueprovideforastable
page 17
and long-term immobilisation ofthe various (cementation)usedtoimmobilise structuralpieces vvastessorted
outthrough
reprocessing.Asforthe thatare novvcompacted.vitried residues,thehighstabilityofsucha glass matrixisillustrated byanalogywiththeglass obsidian,a natural mineralthatremainsfor thousandsofyearsvvithout alteration.
Theultimateresidues aretherefore stablefortrans- port, long-term storage and final disposal.
0 Easy
handling and management of the ultimate residues for disposal
Thisadvantageresultsfrom theuseofastandard package, theUniversal Canister,toaccommodate alltypes
of
long-livedandintermediatelevel 0Volume reduction of ultimate residues
vvastes,regardlessoftheirform,
activity andfinalfor disposal
destination.TheRTRspent fuelmanagementpolicyasimple- Thefinalresiduesthatwill bemanufacturedat mentedatLa Hagueoffersanimportantvolume COGEMA-LaHaguevvill bedirectly suitablefor reductionfactorascomparedtotheotheroptions final disposal vvithoutanyfurther conditioning.
generally availableforRTRspent fuel manage- Theconditioning ofvvasteintouniversalcanisters ment. Inaddition,theimprovementovertheyears givesthe abilitytorationalisevvastemanagement
ofthe
techniquesusedatLaHagueallovvs an foronsitehandling,fortransportoperations, and optimisation ofthevvasteconditioning. Forin- forinterim storage and ultimategeological stance,thankstothecompactiontechnique, the disposal. Forthe returnshipment,theUniversal volumeofthe finalresidues has beendivided by4 Canistersvvill beloadedintodual-purpose storage comparedtothe previousconditioningprocess andtransportcasl<s.Spentfueldeactivation in storagepool
1
Dilution ofthe HIFFlRfueldissolution liquorinthemainflux resultingfrom commercial powerreactors spentfuel dissolution
Chemical
separation
’
Uranium
Plutonium
Structuralpieces
Compaction
page 18
Main steps
of reprocessing
UniversalCanisters ofvitrifiedand compactedresidues
aé
I
\% $
“*“
‘ii
*is‘;
an:'
Wt
. 53-‘_._ ‘...,,
I9 ,1." 5," ,L 1
V- ‘.-2:-. V f I
;:'
1 '—q''
Interimstorage
J
Peopletlyingatnormalcommercialiataircraft
i
COGE ‘
’":::.-
FA
"Wt
“ta
""Q W
.
-;,
if
’__§;3£§Wiaat
isradioactivitiy?
Radioactivityisthe propertyofcertain atomsto emitradiation.Theatomsconstitutingallmatter
Natural radioactivity nowadays originates mainly fromfoursources:
-cosmicraysfromthesunandthe outerspace, -radiation emitted bynumerous radioactive aremade upofanucleusaroundwhichelectrons elementssuchasuranium andthoriumnaturally gravitate.Thenucleiarethemselves made upof presentintheEarth'scrust,
two
kindsofparticles: protonsand neutrons.The -air,containingemanationsof
radon,aradioac- nuclei maybestableor unstable,thelatter change tivegasproducedbythedecayof uraniumand spontaneously andturn intonew atomsof thoriumcontainedinthe Earth's crust,differentchemical elements,whileemittingone or -naturalradioactivity contained infoodand moreradiation.They are saidtoberadioactive.
Theradiationconsistsofthe emissionof different kindsofparticles carryingmoreorlessenergy.
Where does radioactivity some from?
Radioactivityisanintegral partofthe lifeof the universe. Itispresent everywhere,even
without
anyhuman contribution.~ 65%oftheradiation dosereceived bymanis
natural.
AirTravel-1%'
drinlcs.
0 35 O/Oof the radiation dose received is man- made.Thisradioactivity comesfrom:
-medicalirradiation whichisthe greatest source
of
exposureowingtothedevelopmentofradio- therapy, nuclearmedicine andthermal cures (somemineralwatersarerich inradium andtho- rium),-technical and industrial activitiessuchasair travel, TV setsorcomputerscreensalsobringtheir contri- bution ona more daily basis.
How
isradioactivity measured?
altitude(8-l1kmi sustain increased exposurewith _ . . . .
doses betweeno.oo1~o.oosmiiiisievertper hour.
We-W
~ac oactT.eactivityismeasured in becquerelsRooks and Soil-20%
Allrocks and soilcontainradioactive material.Thiscontributestoexposure bothdirectlybygamma radiationand indirectlybybeingincorporatedinto the food andwater we consume.
Cosmic Rays-10%
Thedosefromcosmicradiation ishighlyvariable tromone
‘-'l'ieaveiagectcsetrori*'*etxzrr:1z:i.:ar
‘ Ai.:§iaiasaoot.r‘~ribe»etoe'a»as:rw.ear
1!]
l.)
ice number of disintegrations
of
nuclei;::-"
pg eachsecond ina sample.Theamount3"
é’&'gy
impartedtotissuesfromexposureto'2:
aton isreferredtoasabsorbeddose,theunit use: $T"€ gray(Gy)."
2" effectsof radiationonan exposed(
() ()
kt) f‘i
W
o"ca" 5"”. 'e"'e"ed toaseffective dose equivalent,
locationtoanotheranddepends --MRadmnmy inAn, 25% -
onaltitude.latitude.and.very ~ Fqgd and Drink.10» R G Hh- ' ff b k ‘- /'\-. A -'_ ,. - ,
occasionally,onsunspotactivity. Anumberofradmacmfe asdZgiiswrggioigyeegezayy '°':5 b M
:c
>.1':C " >i:
.: '
tSlS\), bUT‘lll'i€tl'lOUSGl"lCltl'l elémenisfe ¢°"YlW°U$l‘/ productswhich. wheninhaled.Pfvdwed"Yme im°$P"EF@ contributetointernalexposure.
by cosmic rayinteractions withmatterand are eventually incorporatedinto thefood chain.
ofa Siettert,I."€ miiislevert(mSv) iscurrently used.Amodern chestX-rayresultsinan approximatedoseof0.03 mSv.Throughoutthe world theannual average equivalent dose dueto Distributionofaverageannualradiationdose natUra|exposure15around2_4mgvl
page 19
R
?§'u‘\*:“"I li
“W7,
Re
Q 112 1.I
1u\iu\Qt x\‘\i
t\eh‘i§\Qi:,iiiii“\ii he
ҡҤ%%
Wu‘
“imsgEha ||-“ha.
H Q1
%;§‘k§"D\"\\
: .’
,'
c _\»..~vt§..:.ra.“£
gut. eta;
Vaw;-5;
ta.5-_€> F
4/
4r
"Wt
K
‘I3
._,,.
conforming withtheISO9000 standard.
TheQualityAssuranceandQuality Control programs areauditedbyanindependent thirdparty,the Fromtheverybeginningthe nuclear industryhas internationallyknovvn Bureau Veritas,makingsure been particularly carefultominimiseharmtothe thattheseprograms set-upbyCOGEl\/l/-\are environment.COGEl\AA'scarefortheenvironment appropriateand consistently applied.
isoneofthe mostimportant components ofits
generalpolicy. COGEl\/IA hasfora longtimebeen Tits;
asignatory
ofthe
"Companies charterforasustainabledevelopment”and hasmadeevery
effort tointegratethe spiritofthisCharterintoits -io assesstheehi/iiohmehtei iihheciOi:the ovvnstructureand intoitsdailymanagement activitiesperformed atLe Hague,COGEMA methods. Thishasbeendonebycontrollingthe eihhioysheimehehiiy24heohieehd 5Sheciaiized undesirable effectsofradiation andofby-products Vehieie5_
asWellastomakethe best possibleuseofravv materials and rehabilitationofsites.
Samplingisdone onthe atmosphere, rainwater, vvatertables,vvater used in homesorinagricul-
ture,seavvater,streams, plants,meat and milk
Monitoring
Intheimplementationofthis polic ,COGEl\AAV fromcattleraisedinthe surroundings, fish, theenvironment
ovvesagreatdealto the totalcommitment ofits ihoiiusesiCiiisiaceahs ehdeigee
employees.Thecareof environmentisplaced Eachyeah 25,000Saihhies areiakehiOhWhich underthe responsibilityofthe Direction
of
ihoie ihah80000
ehaiyses arecaiiiedout
Quality-Safety-Environment at headquarters,with
ateamofenvironmentaladvisersateach site. In 1997theimpactofCOGEl\/IA-La Hague releases
forthe
“criticalgroup”(i.e.the more Thiscommitment to environment protection has theoreticallyexposedpeople)vvas0.017mSvper led tosettingupanenvironmentalmanagement year,i.e. eighttimeslovverthantheimpactfrom system basedon theISO 14000 standard oneach the maximum authorized releasesset by decrees ofCOGEl\/lA’s sites.Thisinitiativeispartofaofthree
Ministries(0.l5mSv), andonehundredmuchwiderQualitymanagementprocessthathas timeslo\/verthanthe impactofnatural
M°"iif>Ti"8
the been setupinthemajorityofCOGEl\/lAplants radioactivityinthe region,vvhich is2.6 mSvpere"””°"me"t
andsites.Aboutthirty ofthesearecertifiedas personperyear.
page20
_
J
/
‘
__%\'
_‘\
T
HIF/Z1lRspentfuel elements
will
betransported
by seafrom
/Zlustralia to Franceinspecially
designedtransport
containers, orcasks, onboard
adedicated
uessel.
Thecasks
and
shipused, aswell
as theorganisation
o/‘thetransport
meetthe latest requirementsof
the enforceableinternational and national
regulations.Transport
ofspentfuel
from Australia
to France
TRANSPORTATION
Tl'l€
CllTT€l’€|’lTSTQDS o Loading ofthe casksonto a dedicated ship.TheshipmentofHIFARspent fuel elementsvvill ANSTO hascontractedanexperiencedtransport involveseveral successive steps. agenttoberesponsibleforalltransport
preparationandimplementation between the
0 Loading fuel elements atthe reactorsiteinto reactor andthe ship,including loadingofcasks
the dedicated casks. ontothevessel.
Thespentfuelelementsvvillbeloaded undervva- v Sea transportation from the Australian port to terintothetransportcasksatANSTO’s site,tol- theFrench portofCherbourg (l\/lanche).
lo\/vingestablishedandpractised procedures.The
casksvvillthenbedrained, vacuum dried and Thisseatransportationvvill becarriedoutona
hermeticallysealed. dedicated shipmeeting the requirementsofthe INF-2classificationsetdovvn bytheInternational
oTransfer ofthetransportcasks byroadfrom the l\/laritimeOrganisation(|l\/IO). TheINFcode Lucas Heightssitetoa port in New South Wales. appliestotheshipscarrying Irradiated Nuclear
Fuel. Suchships have beenoperated by Theloaded caskswill betieddovvn in specially TRANSNUCLEAIREsince 1995.
strengthened steelshipping ISOcontainersand COGEl\/lA is responsible
for
all transport transported by road to the port. preparation and implementation from the timepage 22
--r
thecasksare loaded onto the ship until their transportation.
arrivalatthe reprocessing site,and hassubcon- Theywillthenbetransported byroadtotheLa tractedall therelated transportservicesto Hague reprocessing plant where the shippingcon
TRANSNUCLEAIRE. tainersvvill beunloadedfromthetrailer.
Later,the spentfuelelementswillbeunloadedun-
0AtCherbourg transfer of the transport casks den/vaterfromthetransportcasks,placedin basket<
fromthevesseltotheCOGEIVIA-La Hague and stored unden/vaterinadeactivation pool.
c; z Specially
Q O \\
t
designed
‘z.
‘
Y‘ :. ,,,
tra nsport casks
“ " 33__“.£/"~12?”** S
. _/.
if
;; A
.5’
Lidsecurelybolted Special sealinlid
/
ANSTO'sspent fuel elementswillbe
Heavy steel
ThickleadShim transported inspecially
Fireand im act deslgned casks
Metalbasketscontaining_
/
fuel Trresistantans”nShffd°ask j Threesimilarsafetycharacteristics- - typesofcasks' vvith-s <1 <1 h' " *1 -
..... . ./C§§Qa,?,',,,s 'pp'“g; Wlllbeused.Thesecasks,
so named Ll-lRL 120,TN 7-2
f. we
'_ _. . . A andTN-l\/lTR,are cylindrica.. .. *
“A
is’
istructuresandWeigh‘ around 20 tonneseach.Th
$°"e'"““" °f
‘he LHRL' '20"""‘P°" "‘“"
l_l—lRl_-120vvasdesigned and builtpurposelyfor the carriageofHIFARspent fuel andhasreprocessing plant by roadtransport. performed previous shipmentsvvith anexemplary Oncearrivedatthe Cherbourg port,the shipping safetyrecord.
containersvvillbetransferred, byusinga harbour
crane, fromthevesseltoatrailervvitha maximum TheTN 7-2 and TN-l\/ITR casks have been grossvveightof40metrictonnes, meetingall designed by TRANSNUCLEAIREfor
domestic regulations regarding hazardous material accommodating differenttypesofRTRspent fuel,
i
§ i
i i .
LEAD /g »_-_.___ 2CONCENTRIC
COOUNG FINS
1"
= is-It-*==‘?a‘.’a-’..;., i 5
TIE-DOWN '
4-I;-'
STNNLESSmes r ‘~ _' Q5’-“i STEEL
i LEAD theirsecurityand reliabilityhave been
K L carefully tested.Theyhavebeenfully
ll E:
, t*= P"°TE¢“°" - licensedforthetransportof
RTRspent includingtheHIFARfuel elements.TRANSNUCLEAIRE hasdesigned more iv fl L;i -ts I thanonehundredshipping casksand
J '
\\
l SHOCK.. ’ “ii'1 requirements.
ABSORBER containersmeetingall regulatory
,//, \\
1S W°°°
“T”
~.}\ ‘K '_ The TN-l\/ITR cask,thelatestdesignedo@
vzmoninca = t
if TRANSNUCLEAIRE,incorporates state01 the art features, high capacity andeasy
handling.
l
.
mi VI
‘§_:<-._._A.-—__—_?..Y__,Y.*-...,
‘\
~'I-'-‘Z-‘J-“.--.-.,.----ea-»»~i..a.-.‘
1.
R-—V
ik
U“
_._.
V“.
___
t‘
l h mu mull‘
.1._.
1'
,
'°"""“°$ All casksvveredesigned and built to
"munmous .~.__~-. _— <
‘M
t ' ~ -....a.~. BASKETeon
l \ - \ 4
"=LE"e"*
.= ii'@1¢ 2
>
l
l
it-ff"
~. standardsforType B(U)Fpackagingsetbyinternationalexpertsrepresentingthe 127member countries
ofthe
lnternatio nalAtomicEnergyAgency(IAEA)and1 l fuelbytherelevantcompetent
'1’ authoritiesinAustraliaand France.
Schematic ofthe TN-MTR transport cask
page 23
D€CllCE3T€Cl V€SS€l equipmenton board, including the abilityto protect the casks by spraying water
A specificpurposevesselwill be usedtotransport 0 Duplicated electrical systems Al\lSTO’sspent fuel elementsfromAustraliato 0 Radiological monitoring equipment
France. 0 Modern communication and tracking system.
ThisEuropean registered shipis90 meterslong and 16meterswide and carriessufficientfuelto completeajourney
without
any port-call.lthasregularlybeen usedto transportradioactive materials between Europe,UnitedStatesandAsia.
Itmeetsthe international standardsand
requirementsoftheINF-2classificationsetdown bythe InternationalMaritimeOrganisation (IMO).
Accordingto theINF-2classification,theshipis
equipped with:
0 Lateral reinforcement tanksfor minimising A TR7lN5NUcl5/MR5 ‘Peel/ic P'"P°$e
""°'e‘"
damage and
for
safetyin caseof accident materialstransportvesselQ Additional fire detection and fire
fighting
The INF-2 classification requirementsalso include systems.The shipiscovered byafiredetection a radiation protectiontraining program forthe systemandhassophisticatedfireextinguishing crewand a specificshipboard emergencyplan.A
ll
TRANSPORTATION '1
. 0. 0 0.u '
. 0.
Thecasl<sandship used,aswellastheorganisa- Australia, these rules includethe Australian tion
ofthetransport
meetthe latest requirements Dangerous Goods code. In France, the current ofthe enforceable internationalandnational regu- regulationfor
road transport isbased onthelations. following European Union Directive:
thetransportofradioactive material.
0 Dangerous goodstransportation isregulated by
- the order relativetothe carriage of dangerous Theobjectiveofthe regulationsis
t0
protectthe goodsbyroad based onthe EuropeanAgreement public,transportworkersandpropertyfromboth concerning the international carriageofthe direct and indirect effectsofradiationduring Dangerous goodsby Road(orADR).
Seatransportationcomplieswiththeruleofthe
Inparticular, thetransportation ofresearchreactor International MaritimeDangerousGoods (lMDG) spent fuel complieswith
two
typesof stringent code,adopted bythe InternationalMaritime andwell-established regulations: dangerous goods Organization (IMO).Thiscodeoffers guidanceto andradioactive materials. personsinvolvedin handling andtransportofall
hazardousmaterialin portsand onboardships.
variousrulesdepending onthe modeof transport o In thecaseof radioactive material transporta- (road, railand sea)andthe countries involved. ln tion, the International Atomic EnergyAgency, a
page24
,__ - _
- I-
I - __,_t.
— l_-_-_-c .-_.___
,..-_--_'__,.--,. vvtv .'
:><v.-::-
3- - —~- - -— __"€Qu5:.O"5 C€' "‘€Y."’E€ 35C<5g "Q C5'.€§C'
:: 3'-
\.-
_ _ _ _ _ _ \design
criteria,tal<ingintoaccountthe
. . .OT‘\.‘v‘&I:"Oi 5
Ci’
CC L‘"-.
:E§7-
-'-_
-radioactivityaswellastheform
ofthe
material andatZOOmetersforattransported. .
the transportcasksmustcomplywith thehighly
Aftertheseteststhecaskmust remainleal<tight
‘
andretain enough
of
itsshieldingtoensurethatInor
erto
transportresearchreactorSpent we’ anyradiationdoseis\/vithin internationallyagreedi-
limits.
stringentIAEATypeB(U)FSpecications‘ A“Stof Compliancewithregulationsresultsin certifica-
verystringenttestsmustbeperformedtocheck . _
theresistanceandsafetyofthe package.
Thesetests include notably:
tionbytherelevantnuclear safetyautho"'._. *2 casksthatare usedfortheshipmentca.e :>e"
licensed bythe relevant Austra‘ac 2"
:
1-' '
authorities.
oTwo punishing droptests. Moreover, in
i993,
1"-3 ‘SC es".=_'-- '-
IIn one, thecask isdropped from a height ofone code,vvhich
'eco"r~e":s Mt:
--
-sr;
semeterontoasteel punch bar. safety
oftne
.esses:5" ' --
~' -t
2inanothertest,the caskis dropped nine meters coxer"g ice ce: gs
.:e:
‘ - - ~t
ontoan unyielding surface- asurfacemorelr~.flex‘-
co"ce'"e:
blethan anyfoundin
nature-to
stimulaterea'*e
esse': 2:
w e-:1“
s — ‘ _ —'
impactsfrom fargreater heights.
:a'.:*
OZ
ormal s l
Waterspray averin Drop from0.3to1.2 m ': Stacxin;511'55 :9-§¢-;3- '55- the nacxage we
;r'
». ~ . :a' 3-5.;
/> nr¢\|\I\;'II-¢ ‘UH-u -.-.--.4 -
-
Accident Q Y '
conditions
.s?
‘of transport
i “Drugsfrom9m Dropfrom1m Fire atBWC,30mn immersion under 5
heights(5) onapunch bar 15m
and 200m
l
'
On anunyielding surfaceMaintestsforTypeBpackages
m
Thesafetyarrangements—thespeciallydes