åo'ì.QB
Population Change in Adelaide's Peri-urban Region:
Patterns, Causes and ImPlications
by Tania
X'ordA
thesissubmitted in fulfilment
of therequirements
of the Degree ofMaster of Arts, Department of
GeograPhYUniversity
ofAdelaide
April1998
ERRATA
p.66,
line
6 should read 'the last'p.67,line
7from bottom
delete'a'
p.73,Table4'l,lastcolumn,secondfrombottomshouldrcad'-O'45' p.95,line10frombottomdelete,9824'andreplacewith.503T'
p.99,
line
6from
bottom replace '70 andover' with '75
and over'line4frombottomreplace,|o-z4years'with.|5-24years,
p.101,
line
5 replace'0-10' with '5-14' p.105 L
=locality
(200-999 population)Beneath
title
of table should read. ..(see Figure 4.23fot
locations)p.lll,line6frombottomreplace'l}-z4years'with'15-24years'
p.1 16,
line
1 1 footnote to sentence: This figure, based on census count datadiffers from theestimatesquotedearlier(Tables4'2and4.3)whichwerebasedonvitalstatistics
line
9from
bottom, replace second'region' with 'SLA'
p.l23,line I
should read...Manyperi-urbanSlAs
are growing notonly
as aresult"
'p.l24,bottom right
corner of table replace'19'0' with '1'9'
p.183,
line 1'travelled'
p.202,1ine 3, second paragraph should read...approximately one quarter of the established
populationwasbornintheAsD,overseasandotherrurallocationsfespectively'
ll
TABLE OF CONTENTS TITLE PAGE
TABLE OF CONTENTS LIST OF TABLES LIST OF FIGURES LIST OF PLATES ABSTRACT DECLARATION
ACKNO\ryLEDGMBNTS ABBREVIATIONS
CHAPTER 1 INTRODUCTION 1.1
Introduction1.2
Themes in the Literature1.3 Aims
and Objectives of the Study1.4 Defining
the Peri-urban Region1.5
Adelaide's Peri-urban Region1.6
Adelaide's Peri-urban Region in Context1.6.1
The Fleurieu Peninsula1.6.2
TheMount Lofty
Ranges1.6.3
The BarossaValley L6.4
TheMurray
Lands1.6.5
TheLower Mid
North1.6.6
The Adelaide Plains1.7
Outlineof
StudyCHAPTER 2TIJE. LITERATURE AND APPROACHES TO EXPLANATION
2.1
Introduction2.2
The Population Turnaround2.3
The International Experience2.4
The Australian Experience2.5
Peri-urban Population Growth2.6
Approaches to an Explanation of the Population Turnaround2.7
Gaps in the Literature2.8
ConclusionCHAPTER 3 DEMOGRAPHIC GROWTH
PROCESSESIN THE PERI.URBAN REGION
3.1
Introduction3.2
Demographic Growth Processes3.2.1
Suburbanisation3
.2.2
Counterurbanisation3.2.3
Population Retention3.2.4
CentripetalMigration
3.3
Conceptual Framework of Peri-urban Growth3.4
The Data and Methodology3.4.1
Secondary Data SourcesPage
I ii
vii
X
xi xii xiii iv
1 1 1 õJ
4 7
I2 t4 I6 t]
18
l9
20 22
24 24 24 26 30 32 34 JI 40
42 42 42 42 45 48 49 50 56 56
3.4.1.1
The Australian Censusof
Population and Housing3.4.I.2
Other Secondary Sources3.4.2
Primary Data Collection3.4.2.1
Selection of Case Study Areas3.4.2.2
Survey Methodology3.4.3
Spatial Unitsof
Analysis3.5
ConclusionCHAPTER 4 POPULATION CHANGE IN THE PEII,I.URBAN REGION 4.1
Introduction4.2
Population Growth in South Australia4.3
Macro-Scale Factors Influencing Peri-urban Growth4.4
Population Changein
South Australia and Adelaide's Peri-urban Region, 1961 to19964.4.1
Population Change,196l-ll
4.4.2
Population Change, 1971-814.4.3
Population Change, 1981-914.4.4
Popnlation Change,199I-96 4.5
Components of Population Change4.5.1
Peri-urbanGrowth,
1966-19964.5.2 Migration
at theSLA
Level4.5.3
The Age Profile ofMigration 4.6
The Settlement Pattern4.7
Projected Population Change4.8
ConclusionCHAPTER 5 GROWTH
PROCESSESIN THE PERI.URBAN REGION 5.1
Introduction5.2 Definition of
Growth Processes5.3 Differentiation of
Growth Processes at theSLA
Level5.3.1 Origin
of Migrants5.3.2
The Journey toWork
5.3.3
Nature of Residential Development5.3.4 Amenity
Value of Destination Areas5.3.5
Accessibility5.4
Summaryof
Spatial Pattern of Growth Processes at theSLA
Level5.5 Differentiation of
Growth Processes at the Local Level5.5.1 Wakefield Plains
5.5.2 Mallala
5.5.3
Strathalbyn5.6
ConclusionCHAPTER 6 SOCIO.DEMOGRAPHIC CHARACTERISTICS OF THE MIGRATION FLOW
6.1
Introduction6.2
TheMigrant
Population6.3
Compositionof
theMigrant Flow:
The Literature6.4
Hypothesised Differences in theMigration Flow
lu
56 57 58 58 6s 68 69 7T 7T 7T 74 79 79 81 87 91 94 94 95 98 101 106 111
113 113 113 115 115
r28
136
r4r
t46
151 155 158 168
t77
186190 190 191 192 195
tv
6.5
The Socio-Demographic Characteristics of theMigrant
Households According to the SurveY Data6.5.1
Age-Sex Structure6.5.2 Family
TyPe6.5.3
Birthplace6.5.4
Labour Force Status6.5.5
Occupation6.5.6
Income6.5.7
Residential Location6.5.8
Natureof
Housing6.6
Recent Migrants and Established Residents6.t
The RecentMigrant
Population by Household Type6.8
ConclusionCHAPTER
7THE IMPACT OF POPULATION GROWTH IN THE PERI.URBAN REGION
7.1
Introduction7.2
Impactsof
Growth in the Peri-urban Region as a Whole7.3
Impactsof
Population Growth on the Local Hostcommunity:
The Literature7.3.1
Social Integration7.3.2
In-migrant Satisfaction andIdentification with
their NewLocality
7.3.3
Shopping Linkages7.3.4
Summary of Hypothesised Differences Between Recent Migrants and Established Residents7
.4
The Impact of Population Growth at the Local Level1.4.1
The Impact of Population Growth inMallala
7
.4.2
The Impact of Population Growthin
Strathalbyn1.4.3
The Impact of Population Growth in Wakefield Plains7.5
ConclusionCHAPTER 8 CONCLUSION 8.1
Introduction8.2
Key Findings of the StudY8.3
Research IssuesAPPENDICES
A
Deficiencies and Advantages of the Australian Census of Population and HousingB
The QuestionnaireC
TheFieldwork
D
Spatial Locationof
Survey RespondentsE
Classificationof
Case Study Areas by Location TypeF
Cadastral LandDivision,
Wakefield PlainsSLA G
Cadastral LandDivision,Lewiston (Mallala SLA)
H
Cadastral LandDivision,
StrathalbynSLA BIBLIOGRAPHY
220 220
22r
224 224 228 230 230 198r99 20r
202 204 206 207 2092t0 2t2
2142t9
234 234 239 244 247 252 252 252 258
261 263 271 213 276 279 280 281 282
LIST OF TABLES
3.I Definition
and Measurement of Demographic Growth Processes3.2
Variables Used to Classify Peri-urban SLAs3.3 Distribution of
Sample in Case Study A.reas4.I
Average Annual Population Growth, the State and Selected Regionsof S.A.,
1961to
19964.2
South Australia: Componentsof
Population Growth rn the State and Peri-urban Region, 1966-7 1to 199I-96
4.3
Componentsof
Population Growth,Periurban SLAs,
1986-914.4
Population Change by Settlement Category, SouthAustralia, I97I
tot99t
4.5
Growth of Peri-urban Population by Settlement Size, 1976-19964.6
Urban Centres/ Rural Localities Rankedby
settlementsize,
19964.7
Projected Population Growthof
Adelaide, the Peri-urban Region, Non-metropolitan S.A. and the Total State,199l-2011
5.1
NetMigration
by Peri-urbanSLA,
1986-915.2
Population Retaining Same Place of Residence, 1981-86 and 1986-915.3
Population Retaining Peri-urban Residence, 1981-86 and 1986-915.4
Rateof Out-Migration
of Total Populationfrom
Adelaide's Peri- urban Region, 1981-86to
1986-915.5
Rateof
CentripetalIn-Migration,
1986-915.6
Relative Contribution of the Four Growth Processes in Adelaide's Peri-urban Region Based onMigrant Origin
5.7
Population Employedwithin
Peri-urban Region, 1986 and 19915.8
Relative Contribution of the Four Growth Processes in Adelaide's Peri-urban Region Based on the Journey toWork
5.9
Relative Contributionof
the Four Growth Processes in Adelaide's Peri-urban Region Based on Five Key Indicators5.10 Classification of
Migrant
Households by Growth Process5.1 1 Previous Place
of
Residence ofMigrant
Households, Wakefield Plains 5.12Distribution
of Recent Migrants by Previous Place of Residence inUrban and Rural Sectors, Wakefield Plains
5.13 Place
of
Previous Residence and Frequency of Travel to Adelaideof
Recent Migrants, Wakefield Plains
5.14
Main
Reasonfor Moving
to Current Residence by Previous Placeof
Residence
of
Recent Migrants, V/akefield Plains5.15 Previous Place of Residence of
Migrant
Households,Mallala
5.16Main
Reasonfor Moving
to Current Residence of RecentMigrant
Households,
Mallala
5.17 Previous Place
of
Residence ofMigrant
Households, Strathalbyn 5.18Distribution
of Recent Migrants by Previous Place of Residence inUrban and Rural Sectors, Strathalbyn
5.19
Main
Reasonfor Moving
to Current Residence of RecentMigrant
Households, Strathalbyn94 96 55 59 67
73
t02
103 105
r07
tr7
t2I
t22 t24 t25 r28 r33
135
r54
r57 159161
t63 r64
170
r74
179 180 183
6.1
RecentMigrant
Households Classified by Typet92
VI
6.2
Summary of Hypothesised Characteristics ofMigrant
Households6.3
Recent Migrants and Established Households by Family Type6.4 Migrant
Households by Family Type6.5
RecentMigrants
and Established Residents by Birthplace6.6 Migrant
Households by Birthplace6.7
Labour Force Status by Household Type6.8 Migrant
Households by Labour Force Status6.9 Migrant
Households by Occupation6.10
Main
Sourceof
Income by RecentMigrant
and Established Resident Households6.11
Migrant
Households by Residential Location6.l2Migrant
Households by Nature of Housing6.13 Statistically Significant Differences Between Recent
Migrant
and Established Resident Households Based Upon Survey Findings 6.14 Statistically Significant Differences Between RecentMigrant
Household Types Based Upon Survey Findings
1.1
Hypothesised Differences Between Recent Migrants and Established Residents1.2
Hypothesised DifferencesV/ithin
theMigration Flow
According to the Four Growth Processes1
.3
Questions Asked of the Survey Respondentsin
Relation to Social Integration,Local
Identification/Satisfaction and Shopping Linkages1.4
Perceived Integration of RecentAnivals
intoLocal
Community by RecentMigrants
and Established Residents,Mallala
7.5 Lifestyle
Adjustment Involvedwith
Peri-urban Move byMigrant
Type,Mallala
7.6
Locationof
Area Most Usedfor
Shopping by Recent Migrants and Established Residents,Mallala
7.7
Perceived Acceptance by Local Community by Recent Migrants and Established Residents, S trathalbyn7.8
Perceived Acceptance by Local Community by Migrant Type, Strathalbyn7.9
Participation in Local Organisations by Recent Migrants and Established Residents, Strathalbyn7.IOLocation of
Area Most Usedfor
Shopping by Recent Migrants and Established Residents, Strathalbyn7.11 Perceived Integration of Recent
Arrivals
into Local Community by Recent Migrants and Established Residents, Wakefield Plains7.!2Degree of Lifestyle
Adjustment byMigrant
Type, Wakefield Plains 1.13 Locationof
Area Most Usedfor
Shopping by Recent Migrants andEstablished Residents, V/akefield Plains
l.I4Differentiation
Between Recent Migrants and Established Residents in the Three Case Study Areas Based Upon Survey Results198
201
202
202 203 204 206 206 2082t0
2tr
213 218
23t
232 234 235 237 239 240 240 242 243 245 246 247 248
LIST OF FIGURES
1.1
The Form of the Peri-urban RegionI.2
Adelaide's Peri-urban Region1.3
South Australia: Net Population Increase, 1986-19911.4
Extent of Urban Development in the Adelaide Metropolitan Area and Surrounding Peri-urban SLAs1.5
South Australia: TheDirection
and Spreadof
Settlement upto
18681.6
South Australia: Density of VacantAgricultural
Land and RuralLiving
Properties1.7
Broad Physiographical Regionswithin
Adelaide's Peri-urban Area3.1
ConceptualModel
of Demographic Growth Processes atWork in
the Peri-urban Region3.2
Dendrogram Used to Classify Groups ofPeri-urbanSlAs
3.2
Locationof
Case Study Areas4.1
South Australia: PopulationDistribution
Between Metropolitan, Other Urban and Rural Areas, 1844-199I4.2
Growth of Population Aged 65+ Yearsin
south Australia and the Peri-urban Region, 197l-96
4.3
Increasein Motor
Vehicles(S.4.)
and Total Peri-urban Population,r97r-1996
4.4 Growth
in the Number of Telephones(S.4.)
and Total Peri-urban Population,I91I-1996
4.5
Increasein
Average V/eekly Earnings6.4.)
and Total Peri-urbanPopulation,
l97I-1996
4.6
Average House Prices(S.4.
and Adelaide) and Total Peri-urban Population,
1915-19964.7
Population Growthby SLA,
Non-MetropolitanS.4.,
1961-66 and 1966-7 t4.8
Population Growth bySLA,
Adelaide's Peri-urban Region, 196I-66 and 1966-714.9
Population Growthby
SLA, Non-Metropolitan5.4.,1971-76
andr9l6-8t
4.10 Population Growth by
SLA,
Adelaide's Peri-urban Region,l9ll-76
and 1976-81
4.11 Population Growth by
collection District,
Adelaide's Peri-urban Region,I97l-81
4.I2Location
of Peri-urban Centres and Localitiesand Major
Transport Routes4.13 Population Growth by
SLA,
Non-Metropolitan S.4.,1981-86 and 1986-914.14 Population Growth by
SLA,
Adelaide's Peri-urban Region, 1981-86 and 1986-914.15 Population Growth by
collection District,
Adelaide's Peri-urban Region, 1981-914.16 Population Growth
by
SLA, Non-Metropolitan S.A.,1991-964.17 Population Growth by
SLA,
Adelaide's Peri-urban Region,L99l-96
vll
11 12 6 8 9
13 15
5r
60 62t2
75 76 17 77 78 80 81
82 83
85
86 87
88
90
9l
92
viii
93 4.18 Population Growth by Collection
District,
Adelaide's Peri-urbanRegion,
199l-96
4.19 Net
Migration
and Distance From Metropolitan Adelaide, Adelaide's Peri-urban Region, 1986-9 14.20 Age-Sex Profile
of
Adelaide's Peri-urban Population, I 96I
and 19964.21 Age-Specific Net
Migration
Profile, Adelaide's Peri-urban Region,1966-71to
1986-914.22
Age-Specific NetMigration
Profiles, Mount Barker, Meningie, PortElliot/Goolwa
andVictor
Harbor, 1986-914.23 Peri-Urban Centres, 1 996
4.24Projected Population Growth,
SLA
in Non-MetropolitanS'A', l99L-2011
4.25 Projected Population
Growth,
SLAs in Adelaide's Peri-urban Region,l99r-200r
4.26Projected Population
Growth,
SLAs in Adelaide's Peri-urban Region,I99l-201r
5.1
Placeof
Previous Residenceof
Adelaide's Peri-urban Population bysLA,
1986-19915.2
Sourceof
In-Migrants to Adelaide's Peri-urbanSLAs,
1986-19915.3 In-migration
FromWithin
the Peri-urban Region as a Proportionof Total In-flow,
1986-915.4
Broad Pattern of Demographic Growth Processes in Adelaide's Peri- urban Region Based on theOrigin of
Migrants5.5
Journey toWork
Destination From Adelaide'sPeri-urbanSlAs,
19915.6
Journey toWork
Destination From Adelaide's Peri-urbanSLAs: Self- Containment, 19915.7
Broad Pattern of Demographic Growth Processes in Adelaide's Peri- urban Region Based on the Commuting Patterns of theWorkforce
5.8
Extent of Urban Settlement in Metropolitan Adelaide and Surrounding Peri-urban Region, 19915.9 Total 'suburban-like'
Development in Peri-urban SLAs SurroundingMetropolitan
Adelaide, 1950- 19965.10 Extent of Urban Development Surrounding Metropolitan Adelaide to
r996
5.1
I
Factors Associatedwith Amenity
Value in Adelaide's Peri-urban Region5.12
Amenity
Valuein
Adelaide's Peri-urban Region 5.13Accessibility
in Adelaide's Peri-urban Region.5.14
Amenity
andAccessibility in
Adelaide's Peri-urban Region5.15 Broad Pattern of Demographic Growth Processes in Adelaide's Peri- urban Region Based on Nature of Residential Development,
Amenity
andAccessibility of
the Peri-urban Destination5.16 Broad Pattem of Demographic Growth Processes in Adelaide's Peri- urban Region Based on the Five Key Indicators
5.I7
Location of Towns and Rural Settlements in Wakefield PlainsSLA
5.18
Distribution
of Recent Migrants by Previous Place of Residence,Wakefield
Plains97 98 100 101
r04
108
109
110
t17
119
t23 t26
130
r32 t34
136 138
1,39
t43 r44
r47t49
150 153 158
160
lx
5.19
Distribution
of Recent Migrants by Journey toWork
Destination,Wakefield
Plains5.20 Spatial
Distribution
of RecentMigrant
Household Types,Wakefield
Plains5.21 Broad Pattern of Demographic Growth Processes at the Local Level,
Wakefield
Plains5.22Location
of Towns and Rural Settlements inMallala SLA
5.23Distribution
of Recent Migrants by Previous Place of Residence,Mallala
5.24
Distribution
of Recent Migrants by Journey toWork
Destination,Mallala
5.25 Spatial
Distribution
of RecentMigrant
Household Types,Mallala 5.26Broad
Pattern of Demographic Growth Processes at theLocal
Level,Mallala
5.21 Location
of
Towns and Rural Settlementsin
StrathalbynSLA
5.28
Distribution
of Recent Migrants by Previous Place of Residence, Strathalbyn5.29
Distribution
of Recent Migrants by Journey toWork
Destination, Strathalbyn5.30 Journey to
Work
Destination of Migrants byOrigin,
Strathalbyn 5.31 SpatialDistribution of
RecentMigrant
Household Types, Strathalbyn 5.32 Broad Pattern of Demographic Growth Processes at the Local Level,Strathalbyn
6.1
Age-Sex Structureof
RecentMigrant
and Established Resident Populations6.2
Age-Sex Structure ofMigrant Flow
According to Household Type1
.l
Age-Sex Structure of the Peri-urban and South Australian Population,r996
7
.2 Model of
the Impact of Population Growth in the Peri-urban Regionr62 r66 t67 r69
17l r72 r75 t76 t78
180 181
r82
184 r85
r99
200222 225
x
LIST OF PLATES
7.1 Typical
Landscape ofMallala SLA
7.2 Typical
Landscape ofWakefield
PlainsSLA
7.3 Typical
Landscapeof
StrathalbynSLA
E1 E2 E3 E4
63 64 65 Well-Established Country Town: Balaklava (Wakefield Plains
SLA)
Suburbanlike
Development: Lewiston (MallalaSLA)
Small Rural Settlement: Langhorne Creek (Strathalbyn
SLA)
Hobby Farm:Dublin (Mallala SLA)
276 271 278 278
xl
ABSTRACT
Non-metropolitan growth has become
spatiaþ
concentratedin
the peri-urban regionsof cities throughout the
westernworld
andthe
signif,rcanceof this growth zone
isreflected in the large body of literature which has been
generated.Despite
this, significant gaps existwhich
impede a complete understandingof the
patterns, causes and implicationsof
peri-urbangrowth. This
study endeavoursto
bridge these gaps in the existing literature,with the
aimof
contributingtoward a
clearer understandingof
the nature
of
current patternsof
population changein
the peri-urban region. The peri- urban region is conceptualised as a setof
overlapping zonesof
net growth representingthe product of four
demographic processes (suburbanisation, counterurbanisation, population retention, centripetal migration). Previouswork
has failedto
identify these processeswhich, although quite different, are interlinked, producing
differences between andwithin
peri-urban StatisticalLocal
Areas(SLAs). This
study combines aggregate census datawith
survey data collectedin
three selected case studies. Threekey
aspectsof
peri-urbangrowth
dynamics are addressedin
the contextof
Adelaide's peri-urban region.Firstly,
spatial differentiationof
thefour
processes across the peri- urban region is undertaken at the macro-scale and linkedwith
local level case studies in orderto
provide afiner
levelof
spatial dissaggregation againstwhich to
examine theinteraction between migrant characteristics, behaviour, motivation and
space.Secondly, survey data arc utilised to
establishthe distinctive differences in
thecomposition of the migration flow
accordingto the four
processes.Thirdly,
the impactsof
population growth on the social structureof
the peri-urban host community are examined at the local level.xlr
DECLARATION
I
hereby declare that noneof
the material contained in this thesis has been acceptedfor
the awardof
any other degreeor
diplomain
anyinstitution
and that,to
the bestof
my knowledge and belief, the thesis contains no material previously publishedor
written, except where due reference has been madein the text of
the thesis.I
consentto
this thesisbeing made
availablefor photocopying and loan, if
applicable,and if it
isaccepted
for
the award of the degree.Tania Ford University
ofAdelaide
April
1998xlll
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
There are a number
of
peoplewithout
whom, the completionof this
studywould
not have been possible.Firstly
my supervisors,Mr
Peter Smailes andDr Martin Bell
haveprovided
countlesshours of expert
advice,insight and attention to detail, without which this
reseachcould not
have progressedto its current
state.I am
extremelygrateful
for
their constant encouragement and guidance throughout the durationof
this study. The unwaivering support and wisdomof
Professor GraemeHugo
over the past 10 years must also be acknowledged,who
has provided mewith
a solid background andworking
environmentwithin which to
undertake such a research task.I
am alsoextremely grateful
to
MsDi
Ruddfor
her friendship and encouragement over the years andto Mrs
MargaretYoung for
her support and vast computingskill
and expertise, upon which much of the analysisof
this thesis has relied.I
also owe a debtof
gratitudeto Mrs Sue Murray for her
patience,friendship and expert cartographic skills
in undertaking the enormous taskof
drawing manyof
the maps and figures included inthis
study.I
must also thankMr Neil
Coffeefor his
computer generated maps. Thefieldwork
undertakenfor this
study has reliedon the
co-operationof
many peoplescattered throughout the peri-urban region, but particularly Mr Steve Jonas of
V/akefîeld PlainsDistrict
Council,Mr
Colin Dunlopof
MallalaDistrict
Council andMr Gordon Stidson of Strathalbyn Council, who wero important sources of
localinformation and insight. I would also like to acknowledge all of the
survey respondents,without whom
muchof the
analysisin this
studywould not
have been possible.Finally to my family,
Julie andTim who
supported, encouraged and helped me through the duration of this research.X1V
ABS ASD CBD
CDDC
ERP GPOLTSR NI NM OASD SLA
SSD
ABBREVIATIONS
Australian Bureau
of
Statistics Adelaide StatisticalDivision
Central BusinessDistrict
CollectionDistrict District
CouncilEstimated Resident Population General Post
Office
Life
Table Survival Ratio Natural IncreaseNet
Migration
Outer Adelaide Statistical
Division
Statistical Local AreaStatistical Sub-Division