• Tidak ada hasil yang ditemukan

CONCLUSION INDONESIAN MANAGED FUNDS PERFORMANCE EVALUATION AFTER GLOBAL ECONOMIC RECOVERY BY USING DATA ENVELOPMENT ANALYSIS WITH NEW RISK MEASURES (2011 – MID 2015).

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2017

Membagikan "CONCLUSION INDONESIAN MANAGED FUNDS PERFORMANCE EVALUATION AFTER GLOBAL ECONOMIC RECOVERY BY USING DATA ENVELOPMENT ANALYSIS WITH NEW RISK MEASURES (2011 – MID 2015)."

Copied!
28
0
0

Teks penuh

(1)

CHAPTER V

CONCLUSION

5.1. Conclusions

The objectives of this research are to assess the attractiveness and efficiency of Indonesian managed funds and to underline outperformed and underperformed Indonesian managed funds after global economic recovery where markets and investments have already passed the “redemption era” after the global economic crisis. Thus, based on the previous chapter’s data collection and analysis, we can draw following statements of conclusion:

1. Indonesian managed funds averagely performed below than their weighted benchmark return as seen by their lower average of expected return. However, selecting best performers of these funds can be still profitable, even compared to the weighted benchmark return where the top 10 performers based on the covariance can generate 9.16%.annually. Among the top best performers, Kresna Flexima shines by generating 15.3% annually after the global economic recovery. Table 4.4. also presents the importance of syariah managed funds that generate 6.3% of return, compared to 4.45% of conservative managed funds, even though conservative managed funds’ covariance is better.

(2)

Dana Kombinasi stand out from others by significantly improve their covariance from such predicament and they are even among top 10 performers of Indonesian managed funds.

3. Equity Prima, Aberdeen Dana Handal, BNP Paribas Equitra, Cipta Dinamika, and Schroder Dana Kombinasi are those which are the closest to zero (random) influence from the systematic risk with all respective values less than 0.09. Overall, from only 2 among 50 funds which have invalid βj, we can see that Indonesian managed funds are positively influenced by the market. However, the market influence is still inelastic to the managed funds. Thus, this signifies that Indonesian managed funds are safely composed without exaggerating effect from the financial market.

4. There are only 16 Indonesian managed funds that are able to overcome the weighted benchmark return, risk-free rate asset, total risk, systematick risk, or the CAPM betha at the same time with 9.62% annualized expected return and the top performers based on merely covariance cannot measure this. Even more, 3 of them are syariah managed funds. Thus, the 16 managed funds from Table 4.9. are important, even though their covariances are not the best.

(3)

6. VaR and CVaR are among the sophisticated evaluation tool that take the skewness and kurtosis into account for investors to realize the maximum possible loss that can be suffered in a period of time that is realistically affect investors’ emotion as emphasized by Chen and Lin (2006). With different angle of perspective, Indonesian managed funds investors have to be ready for maximum possible loss up to 1.2% (VaR) and 9.5% (CVaR).

(4)

5.2. Research Limitations and Suggestions

This research has limitations due to several predicaments. Thus, several suggestions are also given for future research:

1. The inavailability of Indonesian managed funds’ transaction cost. As suggested by Chen and Lin (2006), providing transaction cost information is necessary to describe more variables that directly affect investors’ choice of investment. Subsciption and redemption costs are some examples of transaction costs that are going to so meaningful to be applied in DEA model.

2. STABLE program software. The expensive STABLE program software is also suggested by Chen and Lin (2006) to conduct the DEA fully. There are three advantages of having the STABLE program: (1) Standardizing the VaR and CVaR variables to include the number of skewness and kurtosis directly, (2) Conduct the DEA at weighted-standardized more than 1 runs, applicable to the types of variables, and (3) Overcoming the negative outputs in models by applying Translation Invariance Property.

3. For future researches, the author suggests several things concerning the topics that are:

(5)

combine them at the same time. Compared to OSDEA-GUI’s ability, well known international journals are still about CCR and BCC approach.

(6)

References

Ang, J., & Chua, J. (1979). Composite Measures for The Evaluation of Investment Performance. Journal of Financial Quantitative Analysis, 14, 361-384. Artzner, P., Delbaen, F., Eber, J., & Heath, D. (1999). Coherent Measures of Risk.

Journal of Mathematical Finance, 9, 203-228.

Asness, C. S., Israelov, R., & Liew, J. M. (2010). International Diversification Works. Social Science Research Network , 1-23.

Backhouse, R. E. (1991). Applied UK Macroeconomics. Oxford: Basil Blackwell. Baker, M., Lang, W., Southern, J., Blanks, A., Blandin, D. M., Meyer, C. L., et al.

(2008). The Basics of Saving and Investing: Investor Education 2020. Investor Protection Community.

Bank Indonesia, B. (2014). Financial Stability Review. Jakarta, Indonesia: Bank Indonesia.

Banker, R. D., Cooper, W. W., Seiford, L. M., & Zhu, J. (2004). Returns to Scale in DEA. Dalam R. D. Banker, L. M. Seiford, & J. Zhu, Handbook on Data Envelopment Analysis (hal. 41-70). Springer.

Banker, R., Charnes, A., & Cooper, W. (1984). Some Models for Estimating Technical and Scale Efficiencies in Data Envelopment Analysis. Journal of Management Science, 30, 1078-1092.

Banker, R., Emrouznejad, A., Bal, H., Alp, I., & Cengiz, M. A. (2013). Data Envelopment Analysis and Performance Measurement. Proceedings of the 11th International Conference of DEA, (hal. 1-404). Samsun, Turkey. BAPEPAMLK. (2015, June 2). BAPEPAMLK. Quoted on June 2, 2015, from

BAPEPAMLK: Badan Pengawas Pasar Modal dan Lembaga Keuangan: http://aria.bapepam.go.id/reksadana/statistik.asp?page=komposisi-nab BAPEPAMLK. (2015). Reksadana BAPEPAMLK. Quoted on June 5, 2015, from

Badan Pengawas Pasar Modal dan Lembaga Keuangan (Capital and Financial Institution Supervisory Body):

http://aria.bapepam.go.id/reksadana/data.asp?page=reksadana&status=aktif& proc=ok

Basso, A., & Funari, S. (2001). A Data Development Analysis Approach to Measure The Mutual Funds Performance. European Journal of Operations Research, 135, 477-492.

Basso, A., & Funari, S. (2002, August 1). A Generalized Performance Attribution Technique for Mutual Funds. Working Paper .

Battacherjee, A. (2012). Social Science Research: Principles, Methods, and Practices. Tampa, Florida: Creative Commons Distributions-Non Commercial, University of South Florida.

Bowlin, W. F. (1998). Measuring Performance: An Introduction to Data ENvelopment Analysis. Working Paper , 1-27.

Brealey, R. A., & Myers, S. C. (2003). Principles of Corporate Finance (7th Edition ed.). Massachusett: The McGraw-Hill Companies.

British Library, B. (2015). British Library. Quoted on June 5, 2015, from British Librarary Web Site:

(7)

Bryk, A. S., & Raudenbush, S. W. (1988). Heterogeneity of Variance in Experimental Studies: A Challenge to Conventional Interpretations. Psychological Bulletin, 104 (3), 396-404.

Canadian Securities Administrators, C. (2012). Understanding Mutual Funds. Web document: CSA.

Charnes, A., Cooper, W., & Rhodes, E. (1978). Measuring The Efficiency of Decision Making Units. European Journal of Operations Research, 2, 429-444.

Chen, Z., & Lin, R. (2006). Mutual Fund Performance Evaluation Using Data Envelopment Analysis with New Risk Measures. OR Spectrum, 28, 375-398. Cooper, W. W., Seiford, L. M., & Zhu, J. (2011). Data Envelopment Analysis:

History, Models, and Interpretations. Book Section.

Cooper, W., Seiford, L., & Tone, K. (2000). Data Envelopment Analysis: A Comprehensive Text with Models, Applications, References, And DEA Solver Software.

Davis, J. H., Aliaga-Diaz, R., Cole, C. W., & Shanahan, J. (2010). Investing in Emerging Markets: Evaluating the Allure of Rapid Economic Growth. Valley Forge, PA: Vanguard Research.

De Santis, R. A., & Sarno, L. (2008). Assessing the Benefits of International Portfolio Diversification in Bonds and Stocks. Frankfurt, Germany: European Central Bank.

du Toit, P. (1979). Investment Basics. SA: ACIS.

Educated Investor. (2000). Educated Investor . Association for Investment Management and Research.

Elton, E. J., & Gruber, M. J. (1997). Modern Portfolio Theory, 1950 to Date. New York: Stern School of Business, New York University.

Farid, J. (2013, February 1). Calculating Conditional Value at Risk (CVaR) or Expected Shortfall – VaR and Beyond. Quoted on June 6, 2015, from Finance Training Course: ALM, Risk and Simulation Models - Training, Study Guides, Templates:

http://financetrainingcourse.com/education/2013/02/calculating-conditional-value-at-risk-cvar-or-expected-shortfall-var-and-beyond/

Farid, J. (2012, July 26). Calculating Value-at-Risk using Excel. Quoted on June 5, 2015, from Finance Training Course: Risks and Simulation Models - Training, Study Guides, Templates:

http://financetrainingcourse.com/education/2012/07/value-at-risk-var-case-study-explanation/

Ferreira, M. A., & Ramos, S. B. (2009). Mutual Fund Industry Competition and Concentration: International Evidence.

Ferson, W., & Schadt, R. (1996). Measuring Fund Strategy And Performance in Changing Economic Conditions. Journal of Finance, 51, 425-461.

Green Street Advisors, G. (2014). REIT Valuation: The NAV-based Pricing Model. Newport Beach: Green Street Advisors Inc.

Guillen, M. F. (2011). The Global Economic and Financial Crisis: A Timeline. University of Pennsylvania. The Lauder Institute.

(8)

Haslem, J. A., Baker, H. K., & Smith, D. M. (2008). Performance and Characteristics of Actively Managed Retail Mutual Funds with Diverse Expense Ratios. Financial Service Review, 17, 49-68.

Ho, G., & Mauro, P. (2014). Rapid Growth in Emerging Markets and Developing Economies: Now and Forever? Massachusetts Avenue, NW: Peterson Institute for International Economics.

Hoskisson, R. E., Eden, L., Lau, C. M., & Wright, M. (2000). Strategy in Emerging Economies. Academy of Management Journal, 43 (3), 249-267. Jensen, M. (1968). The Performance of Mutual Funds In The Period 1945-1964.

Journal of Finance, 23, 389-416.

Kadomae, D. (2012). The Rise of Retail Financial Services in Indonesia. Nomura Journal Of Capital Markets , 1-22.

Kaminsky, G. L., Lyons, R. K., & Schmukler, S. L. (2001). Mutual Fund Investment in Emerging Markets: An Overview. World Bank. The World Bank Economic Review.

Kontan. (2015, June 5). Pusat Data Kontan. Quoted on June 5, 2015, from Kontan: htttp://pusatdata.kontan.co.id/reksadana/

Kuppuswamy, V., & Villalonga, B. (2010). Does Diversification Create Value in the Presence of External Financing Constraints? Evidence from the 2007– 2009 Financial Crisis. Working Paper, Harvard Business School, Department of Research.

Le, Q., & Volguard. (2014). Asia Region Funds Passport: A Study of Potential Economic Benefits and Costs. APEC Policy Support Unit. Singapore: Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation.

Mankiw, G. (2009). Principles of Economics. Singapore: South-Western, Cengage Learning.

Markowitz, H. (1952). Portfolio Selection. The Journal of Finance , 77-91. McMullen, P., & Strong, R. (1998). Selection of Mutual Fund Using Data

Envelopment Analysis. Journal of Business Economic Study, 4, 1-12. Morey, M., & Morey, M. (1999). Mutual Fund Performance Appraisals: A

Multi-Horizon Perspectice with Endogenous Benchmarking. Omega, 27, 241-258. Morgan, J. (1996). RiskMetrics (4th Edition ed.). New York: Morgan.

Murthi, B., Choi, Y., & Desai, P. (1997). Efficiency of Mutual Funds And

Portfolio Performance Measurement: A Non-parametric Approach. European Journal of Operations Research, 98, 408-418.

Norgren, C. (2010). The Causes of Financial Crisis and Their Implications for Supreme Audit Institutions. Stockholm: Swedish National Audit Office. Nouri, E. A. (2013). A Sudy about Research and Research Methods. UK: Arab

British Academy for Higher Education.

OECD. (2003, March 14). Glossary of Statistical Terms: Treasury Bills. Quoted on July 29, 2015, from OECD (Organization of Economic Cooperation and Development): https://stats.oecd.org/glossary/detail.asp?ID=2766

OSDEA, M. W. (2013, October 19). Starting with OSDEA-GUI. Quoted on June 5, 2015, from Open Source DEA:

http://www.opensourcedea.org/index.php?title=Starting_with_OSDEA-GUI Parmar, C. T. (2010). An Empirical Investigation on Performance of Mutual Fund

(9)

Pastor, J. (1996). Translation Invarriance in Data Envelopment Analysis: A Generalization. Journal of Operations Research, 66, 93-102.

Pendaraki, K. (2012). Mutual Fund Performance Evaluation Using Data Envelopment Analysis with Higher Moments. Journal of Applied Finance and Banking, 2 (5), 97-112.

Plantier, C., Steenstra, J., Reid, B., Collins, S., & Holden, S. (2013). 2013

Investment Compnay Factbook: A Review of Trends and Activities in the U.S. Investment Company Industry. Investment Company Institute. Washington, DC: ICI.

Plantier, L. C. (2014). Globalisation and the Global Growth of Long Term Mutual Fund. ICI Global Research Perspective 1, 1 (1), 1-43.

Rockafellar, R., & Uryasev, S. (2000). Optimization of Conditional Value-at-Risk. Journal of Risk Management, 2, 21-42.

Schneeweis, T., & Spurgin, R. (1998, Fall). Multifactor Analysis of Hedge Funds, Managed Futures, and Mutual Fund Return And Risk Characteristics. Journal of Alternative Investment , 1-24.

Sekaran, U., & Bougie, R. (2010). Research Methods for Business: A Skill Building Approach. UK: John Wiley & Sons.

Sercu, P. (2009). International Finance: Theory into Practice. USA: Princeton University Press.

Sharpe, W. (1966). Mutual Fund Performance. Journal of Business, 34, 119-138. Shefrin, H., & Statman, M. (2000). Behavioral Portfolio Theory. Journal of

Financial and Quantitative Analysis, 35 (2), 127-151.

Sherman, H., & Zhu, J. (2006). Service Productivity Management: Improving Service Performance Using Data ENvelopment Analysis. Boston: Springer Science.

Sortino, F., & Price, L. (1994, Fall). Performance Measurement In A Downside Risk Framework. Journal of Investment , 59-64.

Srinivas, P. (2006). Unlocking Indonesia's Domestic Financial Resources: The Role of Non-Bank Financial Institutions. World Bank, Poverty Reduction and Economic Management Finance & Private Sector Development, Indonesia Country Management Unit. Jakarta: World Bank Office Jakarta.

Steering Committee for the Review of Commonwealth/State Service Provision, S. (1997). Data ENvelopment Analysis: A Technique for Measuring the

Efficiency of Government Service Delivery. Canberra: AGPS.

Stephens, A., & Proffitt, D. (1991). Performance Measurement When Return Distributions Are Nonsymmetric. Quantitative Journal of Business Economics , 23-39.

Swinkels, L., & Rzezniczak, P. (2009). Performance Evaluation of Polish Mutual Fund Managers. International Journal of Emerging Markets, 4 (1), 26-42. Thompson, J. (2011). Non-bank Finance: Measure Plus Indonesia. USAID.

Pennsylvania Avenue, NW: Weidemann Associates.

Treynor, J. (1965). How to Rate Management of Investment Funds. Harvard Business Review, 43, 63-75.

Tsay, R. S. (2005). Analysis of Financial Time Series (2nd Edition ed.). Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons Inc.

(10)

Walia, N. (2009). Portfolio Diversification andFinancial Performance of Mutual Fund in India. Interdisciplinary Journal of Contemporary Research in Business, 1 (5), 69-86.

(11)
(12)

91

!"

#$ %& #$ '% ( )(

#$"* & # %& **

+ ,- . / 0123 / 345145 / 2 4! / ! 245 14

' 6 7 .8 / 5!431 / 24 4355 / 53 4114 / 504 4 1

2 9, . / 4 305 / 311 !2 / 5522240! / 05!55045

0 7 : . / 5 531 / 412144 / 5021253 / ! 4!5254

! ;& : / 0513!0 / 4 !0!!1 / ! 51 !04 / 0 !52!0

5 ' 6 '- 6 ; : / 0 35 2 / 3 0 10 / ! 3 !2 / 441 5

1 ' . , < . / 0 3 00 / 35112 4 / 03 33 / 1 1

3 % 7 .8 / 244303 / 3124 5 / 0!1!025! / 41!5 3 3

4 -8 = % : / 2 !0!5 / 54 3553 / 0!55 4 1 / 1541 2

' '- 6 ; .8 / 000 3 / 0!1 ! / 0213 24 / 323 4

7 .8 / 25 2 / 3240000 / 02 25 / 332!2 !

8 > : / 2 35 / !033041 / 0 / !50 4041

2 ' , / 054105 / 5 5 / 0 1 0 5 / 05 1402

0 , ', , ; : / 242 / !4 5 1! / 0 232 4 / !3240!05

! 7 , / 2 121 / 141 053 / 243 32 ! / 110230 4

5 & : / 22212 / 3231315 / 2413125! / 3 02 030

1 ; 8 + , / 0 033 / 25 4150 / 2401 444 / 20151 2

3 , . ; .8 / 055214 / 0535! / 23240441 / 214500

4 ' 6 / 2! !0! / 4!42 !2 / 2550! ! / 3!111 22

; : / 34 / 3 5!03 / 2!30!05! / 1 !02 !4

% '- 6 ; .8 / 223522 / 403 35 / 2!1 4515 / 3 5 524

: ? ', 8 : ; .8 / !0 1 / !20!1 0 / 33! 5 / 2152 223

(13)

0 ' 6 % 9 / 0145 / 11044 / 11 !45 / ! 0 1!

! . 6 '- 6 / 342! / 54 0 2 / 100 0 4 / 05 0!5

5 9, '- 6 ; : / 204 3 / 315 5 3 / 53 520! / !12 254

1 , ', , ' / 45 10 / 5!31 / 5150!41 / 1 552!1

3 : ? .9 / 34 21 / 12 145 / !4 5243 / 05 04! 1

4 8 ; : = @,6 / 440 / 4 4334! / 2 12 2 / ! !!52

2 ; , . / 15 4 / 3 03! / 2! 451 / !!!25!20

2 ; 8 , / 12 / 44 3!40 / 42 00! / !2 5 !

2 , , ? / 33201 / 35 31 / 3 1310 / 0!4!5!35

22 > . . / 0 402 / 0 1!15 / 302 4 / !3134413

20 : ? % .8 6 ; .8 / 31115 / 4 0405 / 2!! 5! / 0!3 1241

2! , = ' , 4/33514 ! / ! 3 3 / 42!! 4 / 0 2154

25 ' ; .8 / 3!5 3 / 51 01 / 124 3! / 0! 4 545

21 ; 8 '9 , / 40 / 40! 003 / 254 345 / 2 !134!

23 / 0! / 3502531 / 2 053 4 / 142322

24 , = : !/5!!00 ! / !! 4 / 5!0 / 2144 1!

0 ; 9 : ; : = @,6 1/5302 ! / 5 !2 ! / 1 0!1 2 / 31041 5

0 7 : < 1/2 012 ! / 55 0! / 5 !3! / 131 202

0 ', ; : 2/ 131 ! / 3!2 !34 / 230205 / 3 1

02 9, ; : 2/ 40 1 ! / 13 / 0 1 / 1142!2

00 '- 6 5/02 5 ! / 3 4 41 / 3 3! / !540053

0! 7 .8 5/ 1 2 ! / 12 !2 1 / 32 44 / 03 50!2

05 9 ; : / 012 / 202 2 / 30 ! / 5 2055

01 > , < . 4/ 2 ! / 21 / 02 041 / 45040

03 7 ; / 2 ! 34 / 23 014 / 3!5 04 / 142 15!

(14)

93

! > , , . @ 1/013!1 ! / 02 1 4 / 12 2 005 / 3 011

* 8 :-"

**A 6, : , B :- , < 00 6 , , .8 ? - - ? . < ? "

/ 4 1 ! 1

0/513 40 3!

/ 3 1!3!

5/3! ! 1414

!" # $! %! &'( ) * + &'( , )-

%.-+ ,- . / 0123 / 345145 / 2 4! !/ 245 1421

' 6 7 .8 / 5!431 / 24 4355 / 53 4114 5/04 4 122

2 9, . / 4 305 / 311 !2 / 5522240! 0/5!55045 0

0 7 : . / 5 531 / 412144 / 5021253 !/ 4!52534

! ;& : / 0513!0 / 4 !0!!1 / ! 51 !04 /0 !52!25

5 ' 6 '- 6 ; : / 0 35 2 / 3 0 10 / ! 3 !2 4/41 5 5!

1 ' . , < . / 0 3 00 / 35112 4 / 03 33 / 1 54

3 % 7 .8 / 244303 / 3124 5 / 0!1!025! 4/1!5 3 14

4 -8 = % : / 2 !0!5 / 54 3553 / 0!55 4 1 1/541 2 2

' '- 6 ; .8 / 000 3 / 0!1 ! / 0213 24 /323 33

4/ !5 4 4 3

!" /! # $! %! , )-

%.-> , , . @ / 1013!5! / 02 1 4 / 12 2 005 / 3 011

, : / 24 4! ! / 3 324 / 012 03 4 / 4!525 3

(15)

0 > , < . / 4 ! / 21 / 02 041 / 45040

! 9 ; : / 012 0 / 202 2 / 30 ! / 5 2055

5 7 .8 / 5 1 2 1 / 12 !2 1 / 32 44 / 03 50!2

1 '- 6 / 502 !4 / 3 4 41 / 3 3! / !540053

3 9, ; : / 2 40 1 / 11! ! 0 / 0 1 / 1142!2

4 ', ; : / 2 131 / 3!2 !34 / 230205 / 3 1

7 : < / 12 012 / 55 0! / 5 !3! / 131 202

/ 31404 1

) ::

< . . , / 5 531

. . , / 24 4!

< . . '% ( / 202 2

. . '% ( / 02 1 4

: 2 ? .

:- , / 2214!

: <9 , , C" !/1 0!344 !

< . . , C" /05 140 5

(16)

95

? '- 6 , !"

B'- 6D B #$ %& #$ '% ( )(

#$"*

& # %& **

! . 6 '- 6 / 342! / 54 0 2 / 100 0 4 / 05 0!5

5 9, '- 6 ; : / 204 3 / 315 5 3 / 53 520! / !12 254

00 '- 6 5/02 5 ! / 3 4 41 / 3 3! / !540053

' '- 6 ; .8 / 000 3 / 0!1 ! / 0213 24 / 323 4

5 ' 6 '- 6 ; : / 0 35 2 / 3 0 10 / ! 3 !2 / 441 5

% '- 6 ; .8 / 223522 / 403 35 / 2!1 4515 / 3 5 524

; : / 34 / 3 5!03 / 2!30!05! / 1 !02 !4

8 > : / 2 35 / !033041 / 0 / !50 4041

4 8 ; : = @,6 / 440 / 4 4334! / 2 12 2 / ! !!52

24 , = : !/5!!00 ! / !! 4 / 5!0 / 2144 1!

2 , ; .8 / !431 / 4 2 1 / 311 30 / 520 33 3

2 ; , . / 15 4 / 3 03! / 2! 451 / !!!25!20

2 ; 8 , / 12 / 44 3!40 / 42 00! / !2 5 !

1 ; 8 + , / 0 033 / 25 4150 / 2401 444 / 20151 2

21 ; 8 '9 , / 40 / 40! 003 / 254 345 / 2 !134!

0 ; 9 : ; : = @,6 1/5302 ! / 5 !2 ! / 1 0!1 2 / 31041 5

02 9, ; : 2/ 40 1 ! / 13 / 0 1 / 1142!2

2 9, . / 4 305 / 311 !2 / 5522240! / 05!55045

23 / 0! / 3502531 / 2 053 4 / 142322

+ ,- . / 0123 / 345145 / 2 4! / ! 245 14

0 , ', , ; : / 242 / !4 5 1! / 0 232 4 / !3240!05

1 , ', , ' / 45 10 / 5!31 / 5150!41 / 1 552!1

(17)

01 > , < . 4/ 2 ! / 21 / 02 041 / 45040

22 > . . / 0 402 / 0 1!15 / 302 4 / !3134413

2! , = ' , 4/33514 ! / ! 3 3 / 42!! 4 / 0 2154

0 7 : . / 5 531 / 412144 / 5021253 / ! 4!5254

03 7 ; / 2 ! 34 / 23 014 / 3!5 04 / 142 15!

0 7 : < 1/2 012 ! / 55 0! / 5 !3! / 131 202

2 , , ? / 33201 / 35 31 / 3 1310 / 0!4!5!35

3 : ? .9 / 34 21 / 12 145 / !4 5243 / 05 04! 1

: ? ', 8 : ; .8 / !0 1 / !20!1 0 / 33! 5 / 2152 223

20 : ? % .8 6 ; .8 / 31115 / 4 0405 / 2!! 5! / 0!3 1241

4 -8 = % : / 2 !0!5 / 54 3553 / 0!55 4 1 / 1541 2

0! 7 .8 5/ 1 2 ! / 12 !2 1 / 32 44 / 03 50!2

! 7 , / 2 121 / 141 053 / 243 32 ! / 110230 4

7 .8 / 25 2 / 3240000 / 02 25 / 332!2 !

04 , : / 24 4! / 3 324 / 012 03 4 / 4!525 3

! ;& : / 0513!0 / 4 !0!!1 / ! 51 !04 / 0 !52!0

5 & : / 22212 / 3231315 / 2413125! / 3 02 030

3 , . ; .8 / 055214 / 0535! / 23240441 / 214500

05 9 ; : / 012 / 202 2 / 30 ! / 5 2055

25 ' ; .8 / 3!5 3 / 51 01 / 124 3! / 0! 4 545

' 6 7 .8 / 5!431 / 24 4355 / 53 4114 / 504 4 1

0 ' 6 % 9 / 0145 / 11044 / 11 !45 / ! 0 1!

4 ' 6 / 2! !0! / 4!42 !2 / 2550! ! / 3!111 22

1 ' . , < . / 0 3 00 / 35112 4 / 03 33 / 1 1

0 ', ; : 2/ 131 ! / 3!2 !34 / 230205 / 3 1

(18)

97

3 % 7 .8 / 244303 / 3124 5 / 0!1!025! / 41!5 3 3

? !"

#$ %& #$ 'E >( )(

#$" & # %&

+ ,- . / 0123 / 334302 / 25 10!1 / ! 245 14

' 6 7 .8 / 5!431 / 0 254! / 52 10504 / 504 4 1

2 9, . / 4 305 / 2 !22 / 5 ! 0343 / 05!55045

0 7 : . / 5 531 / 20!!1! / 5 !42 40 / ! 4!5254

! ;& : / 0513!0 / 4!!0 1 / 0345325! / 0 !52!0

5 ' 6 '- 6 ; : / 0 35 2 / 31430 / 0500 543 / 441 5

1 ' . , < . / 0 3 00 / 43 ! 40 / 0 5 10 / 1 1

3 8 > : / 2 35 / !! 22! / 0 4010!0 / !50 4041

4 7 .8 / 25 2 / 31 4 3 / 0 ! 401 / 332!2 !

' '- 6 ; .8 / 000 3 / 3!52 2 / 0 4 0! 3 / 323 4

-8 = % : / 2 !0!5 / 110420 / 0 1 1042 / 1541 2

% 7 .8 / 244303 / 4312 10 / 0 04324 / 41!5 3 3

2 , ', , ; : / 242 / 5 230 ! / 23431! 2 / !3240!05

0 ' , / 054105 / 02!31 / 2353 5 2 / 05 1402

! 7 , / 2 121 / 30 420 / 2110 00 / 110230 4

5 ; 8 + , / 0 033 / 2133 05 / 215 2 02 / 20151 2

1 & : / 22212 / 342505 / 212004 3 / 3 02 030

3 , . ; .8 / 055214 / 2 25!45 / 2!! 5 / 214500

4 ; : / 34 / 31!5 / 22 3 32 / 1 !02 !4

(19)

' 6 / 2! !0! / 100 1! / 2 1 45 / 3!111 22

, ; .8 / !431 / 41 31! / 5124 !4 / 520 33 3

2 : ? ', 8 : ; .8 / !0 1 / !3 5 / 5!5 145 / 2152 223

0 . 6 '- 6 / 342! / 12!3! 1 / !12 30 / 05 0!5

! 9, '- 6 ; : / 204 3 / 4 52323 / !52524 / !12 254

5 ' 6 % 9 / 0145 / 30 1215 / !! 3 4 / ! 0 1!

1 , ', , ' / 45 10 / 32 11 / ! 440 / 1 552!1

3 : ? .9 / 34 21 / 3 523!3 / 20!040 / 05 04! 1

4 > . . / 0 402 / 54!30 / ! 51! / !3134413

2 8 ; : = @,6 / 440 / 414 ! / 00 515 / ! !!52

2 ; , . / 15 4 / 4 01 / 221544 / !!!25!20

2 ; 8 , / 12 / 1 121 / 35 0 / !2 5 !

22 , , ? / 33201 / 423 000 / 135! / 0!4!5!35

20 : ? % .8 6 ; .8 / 31115 / 513 2 / 30511 4 / 0!3 1241

2! , = ' , 4/33514 ! / !5103 2 / 10 2 / 0 2154

25 ' ; .8 / 3!5 3 / 0 4501 / 5 0 2 / 0! 4 545

21 ; 8 '9 , / 40 / 530 11 / 22 1 / 2 !134!

23 / 0! / 45402! / 3 02 / 142322

24 , = : !/5!!00 ! / 501 055 / 3124 0 / 2144 1!

0 ; 9 : ; : = @,6 1/5302 ! / 3 11 3 / 1 20!3 / 31041 5

0 7 : < 1/2 012 ! / 4!0055 / 5 1 4 / 131 202

0 ', ; : 2/ 131 ! / 4!03015 / 202210 / 3 1

02 9, ; : 2/ 40 1 ! / 3 5 5 3 / 24 2! ! / 1142!2

00 '- 6 5/02 5 ! / 34 !404 / 1 2 1 / !540053

0! 7 .8 5/ 1 2 ! / 144 3 / 1!43 1! / 03 50!2

(20)

99

01 7 ; / 2 ! 34 / ! ! 13 / !4404 / 142 15!

03 > , < . 4/ 2 ! / 2344 / 2 33 23 / 45040

04 , : / 24 4! / 355 / 0! 0320 / 4!525 3

! > , , . @ 1/013!1 ! / ! 22 2 / 03!32122 / 3 011

* 8 :-"

**A 6, : , B :- , < 00 6 , , .8 ? - - ? . <

? "

( ; ,6 ? !"

;F ( : ( : ,- :96 B !C" ,

+ ,- . / !3 22 5/! 12 4 ( : / !3 22

> . . / 5245!351 / 4!21 01 , ( : / 5245!351

2 8 > : / 5!5 35!3 / 0531 ( : / 5!5 35!3

0 ; 8 + , / 1 5 !03 / 1 1 3 ( : / 1 5 !03

! > , , . @ / 1105235 /040 5 , ( : / 1105235

5 9, . / 31! 32 3/3!0 ! 4 ( : / 31! 32

1 ' 6 7 .8 / 02 5/ 2 3 ( : / 02

3 , = ' , / 02 5!5! /05544 1 ( : / 02 5!5!

4 > , < . / 05! !531 / 15 2 ( : / 05! !531

7 : < / ! 51 0 3 / 301055 ( : / ! 51 0 3

7 .8 / 140 3!5 2/5 3 ! 5 ( : / 140 3!5

: ? ', 8 : ; .8 / 31 1 !5 2/ 34 3 ( : / 31 1 !5

2 , ', , ; : / 41 445! 2/ !4! ( : / 41 445!

0 9, ; : / 533 1 3 0/44 ! ( : / 533 1 3

(21)

5 , = : / 4 !3 021 /10! 3 0 ( : / 4 !3 021

1 ' 6 % 9 / 4023! !! /4 0 ( : / 4023! !!

3 . 6 '- 6 / 44 042 2 / ( : / 44 042 2

4 7 , /2 2 2 !/ 30! 2 ( : /2 2 2

' 6 '- 6 ; : /2 1 12 4 5/ 455 2 ( : /2 1 12 4

: ? .9 /2 ! 3 2/!413 1 ( : /2 ! 320

% 7 .8 /2 2! 411 5/1 42 ( : /2 2! 411

2 -8 = % : /22 41!541 3/ 5 ( : /22 41!541

0 % '- 6 ; .8 /22 !12! 0 /4 445 ( : /22 !12! 0

! ; : /225! 0 2! /450 0 ! ( : /225! 0 2!

5 , : /205 2 03 /130 4 ! ( : /205 2 015

1 '- 6 /255 54 3 /324! 3 ( : /255 54 3

3 7 : . /21 14! 32 5/! 3 4 2 ( : /21 14! 32

4 /2343 0!5 1/0!0 3 ( : /2343 0!5

2 , , ? /243 43 3 / 1 45 3 ( : /243 43 3

2 ' '- 6 ; .8 /0 524 2 /!3110 0 ( : /0 524 2

2 ' . , < . /0 4 5 151 0/53 42 ( : /0 4 5 151

22 & : /020 043 /44 !1 2 ( : /020 043

20

8 ; : = @,6

/00 25 2!1 /50 0 ( : /00 25 2!1

2! : ? % .8 6 ; .8 /001514515 /!1! 5 ( : /001514515

25 , ; .8 /00314000 /1045 ( : /00314000

21 7 .8 /0! 204 2! 0/10 01 ! ( : /0! 204 2!

23 9, '- 6 ; : /05! 3 0 0 /4 3!3 0 ( : /05! 3 0 0

24 ' , /03 2 !4 0/5 304 5 ( : /03 2 !4

0 ; , . /030 233 4/31 5 ( : /030 233 1

(22)

101

0 ; 8 '9 , /042521 1! / 5 !3 2 ( : /042521 1!

02 7 ; /045313415 3/5 4 1 ( : /045313415

00 ' ; .8 /! 3 0!! /! 5 1 ( : /! 3 0!!

0! ', ; : /! 25 43 /230 4 ( : /! 25 43

05 ; 9 : ; : = @,6 /!2!10 502 2/! ( : /!2!10 502

01 , ', , ' /!0!25 53 2/14141 ( : /!0!25 53

03 , . ; .8 /5 1245 2 /4 0 0 ( : /5 1245 2

04 ' 6 /52204!333 / 1! 2 ( : /52204!333

! 9 ; : /521 5 !!4 / !532 4 ( : /521 5 !!4

( > 6 . , ? !"

' @ #$

7 ,

#$ % ', , ' @ " % ', , 7 , " ' @ ( : ,- 7 , ( :

,-. 6 '- 6 /!0!2511 ! 5/4113 3 3 1/2302 2522 5/4 43! 0! ' @ 7 ,

; : /!120 55 3/0 ! 5 1/150 2 !41 /22 05!1 ' @ 7 ,

2 8 > : / ! 5!553 2/2 15 31 / 244 54/4 3 45 ' @ 7 ,

0 8 ; : = @,6 /!!05 !2 4/ 405 4! 1 1/! 422! 2 0 /4211 01! ' @ 7 ,

! , = : /55 51!1 1/054!2424 /! 12!02 41/4!4 0011 ' @ 7 ,

5 , ; .8 /!!!4 34 3/ 0005114 1/! 12 2 3 2!/! ! 013 ' @ 7 ,

1 ; , . /14 ! !20 4/!54 4!5!0 /1 21521 00/0125503 ' @ 7 ,

3 ; 8 , /52 25 5 4/52!4010 3/!5 41141 00/4 !!152! ' @ 7 ,

4 ; 8 + , /1!!!00013 4/ 21 42 / 2 5 1 3/!! 024 ' @ 7 ,

; 8 '9 , / !!502 1! /02 212 !/5010324 52/304 0 ' @ 7 ,

; 9 : ; : = @,6 /055555 !2 /5 21 5 5/2 3534!3 ! /0! 04!01 ' @ 7 ,

(23)

2 9, . /2 52! 3!5 0/2 34 !! 0/ 320214 4 3/44532 5!1 ' @ 7 ,

0 9, '- 6 ; : /224 4 24 0/ !40214 0/!4 22 5 0 10/31 1035 ' @ 7 ,

! /3404454 4 4/ 014 20 ! / 32 !1 0 / 43!121 ' @ 7 ,

5 + ,- . / 0 22 4! 2 /325 /!0015 2! 313/4424!11 , ' @ 7 ,

1 , ', , ; : /5 551 ! 4/0 1 5! 3/03! 3 !! 3!!/1021224 ' @ 7 ,

3 , ', , ' /! 1!03 1! 1/303 1 25 1/ 02 25 ! 2 /3 !4 04 ' @ 7 ,

4 > , , . @ /! 150251 014/ 3 25 5/40 35 2! 2 0/ 133 5 ' @ 7 ,

> , < . /531! 2 22 / 24505 4/2 332113 !0/4 00 25 ' @ 7 ,

> . . /3 ! 230 /31!02 2 /324 00 2 20/!!12 2 ' @ 7 ,

, = ' , /4 5 2523 3/05215 ! 4 /!0 12! 25/43430 20 ' @ 7 ,

2 7 : . /1! 0 0004 5/1!43!10 / 1022! 2 42/ !051! ' @ 7 ,

0 7 ; /5 5 !!1 / 542!4 4 3/ 511 4!5! 5 /2443! 44 ' @ 7 ,

! 7 : < /12 00 43 4/05 20 4 4/4 1 41113 /021 0 3 ' @ 7 ,

5 , , ? /! 5! 145 1/!!1542 5 1/ 045!3523 2 /3!!1 4 ' @ 7 ,

1 : ? .9 /!011 5424 1/ 2 4332!0 1/0 !431 ! 1/ 344 1 ' @ 7 ,

3 : ? ', 8 : ; .8 / 44!5 54 5/1!41 5 50 0/ !5 1 420 !/0!2243 3 ' @ 7 ,

4 : ? % .8 6 ; .8 /1015 43 3/! 3053 2 / 1 !55 21/2 04 4 ' @ 7 ,

2 -8 = % : /3013!44!3 3/! 0 240 0 /03 13 21/ 52 ! ' @ 7 ,

2 7 .8 /!2 2134 4 1/!104 35! 1/ 3 250! 0 43/51 !43 ' @ 7 ,

2 7 , /230 40 1 /4!1 32!4 !/ 3 5 !2/3541 !2 ' @ 7 ,

22 7 .8 /0 1 ! !/5!0 2014 !/13020401 3!/553 03 ' @ 7 ,

20 , : /! 20 00! 1/42 4!435! 5/4! 5 3! 22/234! 5 2 ' @ 7 ,

2! ;& : /5 5 0 52 / 3 3 4 3/ 515 3 3 5 / ! 40402 ' @ 7 ,

25 & : /50 51 1 / !10 02 3/540 5!4 3 01/1134 11 ' @ 7 ,

21 '- 6 /12!3!424 1/3 020154 4/452!32 1! 2 /!3 2210 ' @ 7 ,

(24)

103

24 9 ; : / 5303 431 0/2 3 5052 !/3 22002 15/5 022515 ' @ 7 ,

0 ' ; .8 /50 34 ! ! 1/45 03 33 3/54 23! ! 22/!3424 ' @ 7 ,

0 ' '- 6 ; .8 /! 30 33 !/11 3 0!01 5/140430105 3/15! 12 4 ' @ 7 ,

0 ' 6 7 .8 /! 2 31!20 3/5 3 22 32 5/404405 53 21/455!503 ' @ 7 ,

02 ' 6 % 9 /!!1 5/3! 041 1! 1/!0222! 24 5/ 101!4 0 ' @ 7 ,

00 ' 6 /112503010 4/ 05 335!! /01! 043! 0 /42 254 ' @ 7 ,

0! ' 6 '- 6 ; : /5 4 1 1 /0 5 353 3/230 24 5 52/1053 !04 ' @ 7 ,

05 ' . , < . /4224!5 1 4/414 214 /50!3 024 01/ 033 0 5 ' @ 7 ,

01 ', ; : /3 34 5 1 !/3 34 1 / 2!13 2 35/51!4144 ' @ 7 ,

03 ' , /! 500 40 4/ 0 2252 ! 5/1131!2 15 0 /4 0 5 ' @ 7 ,

04 % 7 .8 /1315 3 3/ 32520215 /550 54 ! 2!/11 2123 ' @ 7 ,

! % '- 6 ; .8 /!45 4 1 3 1/550 452 3/ 1 22!5 2 /!151!3 4 ' @ 7 ,

( ( ( ? !"

( C" ( C"

. 6 '- 6 / !134 20 /5403 0

; : / 0! 1!!2 4/! 5!50244

2 8 > : /20!1213!4 /555!2 42

0 8 ; : = @,6 / 1 4 30 /1445 553

! , = : / 2 350 10 /!0 5 224

5 , ; .8 / !3 042 /354 12525

1 ; , . /205 0540 /25244 0

3 ; 8 , /24!020! 4 / 2 555!05

4 ; 8 + , / 3!5 455 /2!!5 414

(25)

; 9 : ; : = @,6 /2 !5 3 3 /44 50!1

9, ; : / 5031 42 /502 ! 4!

2 9, . /0 !23 /! 50 3 1

0 9, '- 6 ; : /20 50235! /4 2253 52

! / 3 2504! /32021!22

5 + ,- . /00014 551 /! 0! 2

1 , ', , ; : / 5!03 0! /!12 23440

3 , ', , ' / 5 51 /3!45441!5

4 > , , . @ / 211 11! / 0 10! 0

> , < . /!!41 1 5 /1045 !

> . . /11 12 00 /04 0242

, = ' , / 53012324 /0! 0200

2 7 : . /!0 5! 0 5 / 2! 0 30

0 7 ; /04 35 2 / 134 1

! 7 : < / 5!042!!5 /114222444

5 , , ? / 015423 /1!5 55022

1 : ? .9 / 4 42 /!15 133 1

3 : ? ', 8 : ; .8 / !05!3 23 /! 5 40!22

4 : ? % .8 6 ; .8 / !044!4 2 /3 10142

2 -8 = % : / 1! 2 /5!4 3!!

2 7 .8 / 3 343 53 /5!042 1!!

2 7 , / ! 2 !! /!44 ! 5

22 7 .8 / 123 1324 /315 1 0

20 , : / 0 1430 /53!0 332

2! ;& : / !4 122 /! 03011 5

(26)

105

21 '- 6 / 01410243 /150 020

23 , . ; .8 / 445 3 /11 552

24 9 ; : /51 41302 /01044401

0 ' ; .8 / !532 2!4 / 22 5 11

0 ' '- 6 ; .8 / 024220!2 /30!! 52!

0 ' 6 7 .8 /! 23!!312 /54!133!5!

02 ' 6 % 9 /3! 0 405 / 4 4 5

00 ' 6 / 0011! 1 /30!3!3!

0! ' 6 '- 6 ; : / 10245 /2 520

05 ' . , < . /!2 5 45! / 5140!5

01 ', ; : /!3! !!5! / 111 41 3

03 ' , /233 ! 1 / 01 45150

04 % 7 .8 / 44 0455 /4 2 50 5

! % '- 6 ; .8 / !0243 1! /3 501 1 2

( ': ' : , ? : . !"

& .

'% ( ? , C"

'E ? #(

C" ;F ' @ 7 ,

( C" ( C" '6 9 C" % -C" G :96 C" , C"

. 6 '- 6 / 1 / 2 / 0 / / / / / / 2 / 4 / 30

; : / !5 / / 30 / / / 3/41 1 / / / / 4

2 8 > : / / / / / / / / / / /

0

8 ; :

= @,6 / 1 / / !23 / 52! / / / ! / / !0 / / 4

! , = : / / / / / / / / / / /

5 , ; .8 / 21 / / 3 4 / !24 / / / / / 44 / 20 / 5

(27)

3 ; 8 , / / / 143 / ! 0 / / / / / 0 / 3! / !5

4 ; 8 + , / / / / / / / / / / /

; 8 '9 , / / 24 / 4! / / / / 125 / / 2 / 2 / 3

; 9 : ; : = @,6 / 0 4 / / 12 / 4 0 / / / 2! / / 0 / 0! / 5

9, ; : / 31 / 513 / / 4 / / / 5 / 2 5 / 21 / 43 / 10

2 9, . / / / / / / / / / / /

0 9, '- 6 ; : / 3 / / 52 / !40 / / / 5 / / 205 / 4! / 1

! / / 0 / 5 0 / / / / 4 / 322 / ! / 4 /

5 + ,- . / / / / / / / / / / /

1 , ', , ; : / / / / / / / / / / /

3 , ', , ' / 54 / 5! / !1 / 1 / / / / / 14 / !3 / 23

4 > , , . @ / / / / / / / / / / /

> , < . / / / / / / / / / / /

> . . / / / / / / / / / / /

, = ' , / / / / / / / / / / /

2 7 : . / / / / / / / / / / /

0 7 ; / / 2 / 1 / 02 / / / !4 2/2 5 / 5 / !50 / !25

! 7 : < / / / / / / / / / / /

5 , , ? / 1 / !0 / 20 / 52 / / / / 5 1 / 04 / 55 / !5

1 : ? .9 / / / / / / / / / / /

3 : ? ', 8 : ; .8 / / / / / / / / / / /

4 : ? % .8 6 ; .8 / 31 / 3 / 111 / / / / / / 5 / 43 / 3

2 -8 = % : / / / / / / / / / / /

2 7 .8 / 13! / 13! / /05 / / / 14 /0 21 / 303 / 1 / 50

(28)

107

22 7 .8 / 2 / / 2 0 / 203 /21! / / 5! / / 203 / /

20 , : / / / / / / / / / / /

2! ;& : / / / / / / / / / / /

25 & : / 12 / / !1 / 5!3 / /! !0 /0 1 / / 3 / /

21 '- 6 / / 3 / 5 0 / / / / 54 /4502 / 1 / 2 3 / 2 5

23 , . ; .8 / / 5 / 41 / 514 / /1 30 /! 3 / 01 / !3 / /

24 9 ; : / 2 2 / ! 3 / 51! / / / / /55! / 1 3 / ! / 0!1

0 ' ; .8 / / 0 / 54 / !2 / / / /05 ! / 25 / 5 / 24

0 ' '- 6 ; .8 / / / / / / / / / / /

0 ' 6 7 .8 / / / / / / / / / / /

02 ' 6 % 9 / / 41 / 53 / / /2514 / 250 / / !0 / 31 / 53

00 ' 6 / / 3 / 314 / / / / 22! / / 0 / 2 /

0! ' 6 '- 6 ; : / / / / / / / / / / /

05 ' . , < . / / / / / / / / / / /

01 ', ; : / / 2 / 2 / 2 4 / / / 05 / / 31 / 32 / 00

03 ' , / / 41 / 2 / 32 / / 3 / 4 / 0 / 2 / 4 /

04 % 7 .8 / / / / / / / / / / /

! % '- 6 ; .8 / / / / / / / / / / /

?? , . , 20 2 ! 20 04 00 2 24 0 2 3

Referensi

Dokumen terkait

Implementasi dari konsep minimum spanning tree dalam teori graf biasa digunakan dalam pembangunan infrastruktur salah satunya pada pembuatan jalur pipa air di Universitas Sumatera

Ukuran perusahaan digunakan untuk menjelaskan pengungkapan CSR yang dikaitkan dengan teori agensi dimana perusahaan besar memiliki biaya keagenan yang lebih besar

Pengamatan dilakukan pada Pabrik Roti Aji Kurnia yang berada

Salah satu bagian yang cukup berperan penting pada bank tersebut yaitu.

Sehubungan dengan point 1 dan 2 tersebut di atas, Pokja.II ULP memutuskan bahwa Pelelangan Paket Pekerjaan Pembangunan RKB SMPN 15 Dumai dinyatakan GAGAL dan

Dengan ini kami mengundang penyedia yang telah lulus pada tahapan Evaluasi Administr asi, Teknis dan Har ga, Pengadaan/ Pelelangan Jasa Lainnya : Belanja

Berdasarkan Berita Acara Hasil Pelelangan (BAHP) Nomor : 09/ULP/MB.SET/SETDAKO/IX-2014 Tanggal 13 September 2014 dan surat Penetapan Pemenang Nomor :

Sumber data yang digunakan penulis dalam menyusun penelitian hukum ini adalah sumber data sekunder yaitu data yang didapat dari informasi atau