Developing metacognitive interaction between tutor and student in PBL-tutorial
Tri Hanggono Achmad
Medical Education Research and Development Unit (MERDU) School of Medicine, Universitas Padjadjaran, Bandung-Indonesia
Tutoring is a teaching skill central to problem-based learning. To facilitate student independence and foster student’s critical thinking and self-directed continued learning, the tutor should guide the students at metacognitive level. Interaction with the student at the metacognitive level is the basic function of the tutor. Metacognitive thinking skill provides the key to the positive and active role of the tutor. Structure of tutorial process is a road map for sequence of metacognitive thinking, to shape student to become a self directed learner. The desired end point of the tutorial process is when each student employs his own metacognitive skills automatically and easily with every task, situation or problem, which could mean that the tutorial group will eventually run on its own. For this purpose, tutors as well as students should understand properly the structure of tutorial process and metacognitive thinking. This could be achieved by continually monitoring and evaluating the tutorial process, and giving feedback to the tutors as well as to the students.
Faculty of Medicine - Universitas Padjadjaran
Tri Hanggono Achmad
Developing
Developing
Metacognitive
Metacognitive
Interaction
Interaction
between Tutor and Student
between Tutor and Student
in PBL
in PBL
-
-
Tutorial
Tutorial
Faculty of Medicine - Universitas Padjadjaran
Tri H. Achmad
• TUTORIAL IS CENTRAL IN PBL
IT IS
THE
HEART
OF PBL
• THROUGH TUTORIAL STUDENTS ARE
DRIVE TO DEVELOP
REASONING
SKILLS
AND BECOME AN
METACOGNITIVE THINKING
METACOGNITIVE THINKING
METACOGNITIVE THINKING VS
IMPULSIVE THINKING
THINKING ABOUT THINKING
POSITIVE-ACTIVE ROLE OF THE TUTOR
Qs, CHALLENGES
STUDENT AWARENESS WHAT SHOULD BE
THOUGHT-SOUGHT
FACILITATE STUDENT’S INDEPENDENT,
SELF DIRECTED LEARNING AND
CRITICAL THINKING
METACOGNITIVE THINKING
PROBLEM
INVESTIGATE
(OBS, Qs, TESTING, PROBING)
REVIEW, REFLECTION, THOUGHT, DELIBERATION
METACOGNITIVE THINKING
METACOGNITIVE THINKING
THE PBL CYCLE
THE PBL CYCLE
THE PROBLEM
WHAT WE DO NOT KNOW
APPLY
LEARN WHAT WE DO
STRUCTURE OF
STRUCTURE OF
PROBLEM SOLVING
PROBLEM SOLVING
STEPS IN THE TUTORIAL PROCESS
4.
3.
a.
b.
c.
2.
i.
ii.
i.
ii.
a.
b.
c.
1.
Learning
Issues
I don’t know
More Info ?
Mechanism ?
20
19
20
18
18
13
18
18
P.Sila
(2)
Civics
(2)
Agama
(2)
BH VIII
(1)
BH VII
(1)
BH VI
(1)
BH V
(1)
BH IV
(1)
BH III
(2)
BH II
(2)
BH I
(2)
CRP
IV - (4)
CRP
III - (2)
CRP
II - (1)
CRP
I - (3)
FBS X
(2)
FBS V
(2)
CHOP
IV - (2)
CHOP
III - (3)
CHOP
II - (1)
CHOP
I - (3)
FBS IX
(3)
FBS IV
(2)
CSP
(1)
CSP
(1)
CSP
(1)
CSP
(1)
CSP
(1)
CSP
(1)
FBS VIII
(2)
FBS III
(2)
Incl.
Lec/Lab
Incl.
Lec/Lab
Incl.
Lec/Lab
Incl.
Lec/Lab
Incl.
Lec/Lab
Incl.
Lec/Lab
FBS VII
(4)
FBS II
(3)
RSS(6)
TMS (6)
GIS (6)
1.
Learning issues that discuss in 1
st
day are:……….
2.
Learning issues that discuss in 2
nd
day are:……….
3.
Learning issues that discuss in 3
rd
day are:……….
4.
Learning issues that discuss in 4
th
day are:……….
5.
According to tutor how does the learning issues appear?
a. by themselves
b. by guiding
c. difficult
6.
According to tutor how did the time provide for the case?
a. need more time
b. enough
c. more than enough
7.
Did the tutor in this case change?
a. Yes, why?
B. No
8.
On the last day did all the learning issues discuss by students?
a. Yes
B. No, why?
9.
According to tutor’s opinion what is lack from or what learning
issues should be added?
Case evaluation
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
5a
5b
5c
6a
6b
6c
8a
8b
RPS
NBSS
DMS
HIS
GIS
EMS
RSS
10
12
8
11
No. of Case
RSS
EMS
GIS
System
7
8
11
No. of Case
System
Faculty of Medicine - Universitas Padjadjaran
Student evaluation on tutor performance
Firman F. Wirakusumah & Tri H. Achmad
Pitfalls in tutorial process
Systematic vs jumping process
Metacognitive vs impulsive
More structured, integrated & better contents
Challenge to a deeper knowledge
Reflection
METACOGNITIVE THINKING
METACOGNITIVE THINKING
USING PRIOR KNOWLEDGE,
EXPERIENCES
TO UNDERSTAND A PROBLEM
AND
FORMULATE A SOLUTION
Reference :
Reference :
Barrows HS, The Tutorial Process, revised edition,
Springfield, Illinois, Southern Illinois University,
School of Medicine, 1988
Kiley M, Mullins G, Peterson R, Rogers T, in Leap,
Problem Based Learning,
Faculty of Medicine - Universitas Padjadjaran – www.fk.unpad.ac.id