THE EFFECT OF CONTENT-BASED INSTRUcnON AND TASK-BASED
LANGUAGE TEACHING ON STUDENTS' COMMUNICATIVE
COMPETENCE
A Thesis
By :
MARYATI
SAI.MJAH
NIM : 045010140 (S.Pd Unlt'el'IIW NeJeri Meclan)
SMti/IW to tlv
&rzl4lt
~ UIIS'I4tfa Sttulyl'rozr-
Ito ltutW FoJfi/lmnU ~1 tlv hqoJ-~>for tllo 1>qrwof
Masf~Nr HlmfiiiiiDnt
Enaum
Applied
Liqulstict Study Proaram
Poltp'aduate
School
State University of Medan
Advisers' Statements
1 certify that I have read this thesis and tbat, in my opinion it is fully adequate in
scope and quality as a Thesis for the Degree of Magister Humaniora.
Dr. &rlin Sibarani. M. Pd fi rst Adviser
l certifY that l have read this rhesis and that, in my opinion it 1s fully adequate in scope and quality as a Thesis for the Degree of Magister Human.iora.
Pro( M. Silitonga, Ph. D
Approval
Thi$ Thesis
was
cXJlmined on 27 August 2007 by the Board of Examine~0<. Berlin Sibarani, M. Pd
Board of £ uminen ~
Prof. M. Sili10nga. Ph. D
Prof. Tina Manany
Arifin.
M A , Ph.D.Prof Amnn Salagih. Ph. D
0.. 811$11\in Gwnin&, M.Pd..
Prof. 0<. Belfrik ~nullang
NIP : 130 5 18 778
TheUeod U"l!uistic
ish Applied
ACKNOWLEJ)GEMENTS
The writer would like to express her !hanks to several
per.;ons.
They are Pro( Tina Mariany Arilin Ph.D as the bead of English Applied Linguistics in UNJMEO, Williem Satogih, M.Ed as the secrewy of this depaltment They 1-olve given o lot of advi«!, guidance to me to finish this thesis. The writer also wishes to pass his gratitale to Dr. Berlin Siborani, M.Pd and Prof. M. Silitonga. PhD who hove kindly assisted him in guiding, directing. revising and correcting theorganization or the concep1 of this thesis. May God bless them.
The writer is indebted to all lecturers and rutors, who hove given the
valuable knowledge during hl'f study in English Applied Linguistics of Graduate School in the State Univtrsily of Medon (UNlMED),
Finally, the writer would like to tharik to her beloved porcnts, brother and sisters for their patience to let him continU!e her study until she finish this thesis. And also to aU ber friends who gave her Suppoo1S. May God bless whoeYer has been given his/hcc constructive sugge<~ i on forr the shape of this thesis.
Medan, Scplcrnber 2007 The writer.
Solaioa., ~,.,..~~.
ne
t:ffoct o1c --
Baod•••noc:Uoe
aadT.n
-Bated Languat T .. ohiag oo Studeau' Com•oaialive Compelftlee. Tbais:£aglid A.pplitd Linpislic GDCI1UIIe Prognua UNIMt:D. l006
This Thesis deals wilh lhe quantiurtive sludy aboul cor~ent - based instruction and task - based lansuagc teaching. II was caniedl out to find the effect of content -based imuuction and !ask - based language tcachir41 on studems • ~c
compeler¥:C. To fmd OUI
wbicb
of coJilent - based instruction and task- basedJaoguoge t.eaching is """" cffi:ctive.
The effect was c:crnplled swislically by using One Way AnaJysi$ of Variance.
All« ~ina !he
data.
!he result ol variables were obuincd:I. There is slgniliwt etlix:t of....- - bose!~ instruction aod task- bose!~
lang.age t~
on
studmcs' CO!Iml.lliCaliYC COJJ1lCICilCe2. Task - based language teaching is mo.-. effcclive !han COIIICDI - based instruction
on
SIUdeols' <XXII!IIIIJiica cornpclenCe. This was found ~by using Newman - Keuls fonnula.
ACKNOWU?OOEMENTS
ABSTRACT
TABLE OF CONTENTS
UST OF TABLES I.IST OF FIGURES LJST OF APPENDICES
TABLE OF CONTENTS
CHAPTER
RffRODUC110N
I. I. The Background oftbe Study
1.2. The Problem ofthe Study 1.3. The Soope of1he Study
1.4. The Objective of 1he Study
I.S. The Significance of1he Study
CDAPTER ll REVIEW OF LITERATURE
Page j_j iii vii viii ix 4 5 5 6
2. 1. CIJilliOOilicative CompelellCe 7
2.2. Content- Based Instruction 9 2.2.1. The Principles ofColiA: nt - llascd lns1ruction 12 2.2.2. Nature ofU!nguage on Content- Based Instruction 12 2.2.3. 'llleo<y of learning oo Contcot - llascd Instruction 14
2.2.4. Design of Content-Based Instruction 16
2.2.4.1. The Objectives ofConent - Based Instruction 17 2.2.4.2. The Syll.OOS of1he Cootent- Based Instruction 18 2.2.4.3.The Types of Learning and k:aching Activities
of the Content - Based Instruction 18
2.2.4.4. The Learner's Roles in !he Coment - Based 1 ostruction
2. 2 .4.5. The Roles of 1he Teacher in 1he Contcm
-Based Instruction
19
2.2.4.6. The roles of !he Materials in lhe Content
-Based l<lWUC:rion 20
2 2.4.7. The Proccdun: of the Content- Based
I nstructioo 2 1
2.3. Task - 8as<d~Tcaching 2 1 2.3. 1. Theoryof~ge in Task - Based
~8" Teadting 25
2.3 2. Theory of~ on Task - 8as<d
~8" Teadlu1g 27
2 3.3. The ObjocOves ofT ask- Basod I ""ll'"'&'!
Teaching 29
2.3.4. Tho Syllabus on Task - Based~
TeodtJna 29
2.3.5. The Types
ofl..cami'l!
and TeachingActivities 31
2.3.6. The Lamers' Roles 36 2 3.7. The Teacher's Roles 37
2.3.8. The Role of Instructional Malcrial 38 2.3.9. The Procedure of Task - Based ~8"
Teaching 40
2.4. Conceprual Frrunewo.t 41 2.5. Hypotheses of !he Study 42
CHAPTER lU M ETHOD OF RESEARCH
3.1. Resean:h Design 43
3.2. Population and Sample 44
3.3. Vlriablcs 45
3.4. lnstNncr1t for Data Collection 45
3.5. Validi1y and Rctiabilily 45
3.5 2. Reliabo1ity
3.6. The l'rooe:<be of Data Collcc:tion
3.6.1. Preparation
3.6.2. Pretest 3.6.3. Treaunent 3.6.4. Posttest
3. 7, The T eclmique of Analyrins Data
3.8. Statistical Hypotheses
CIIAPTER IV DATAANALYSIS 4. 1. Data Analysis
4.1.1. Validity 4. 1.2. Reliability
4.1.3. The Effect of the Treatments on COilll1lU71icativc
Competence
4. 1.3. 1. Teaching EnaJisll
thto<Aah
Conteo1t-Based46 47 47 48 48 48
49
49
so
Sllnstruaion on ~ C on.,... 52
4.1.3.2. T caching EnaJISII
tiJro<ch
Task - Based~ Teacbi~ on Con'municative
Competence S4
4. 1.3.3. Teaching English
tko<.t!h Conventiooal
ooCommunicative Competence
4 1.3.4. The Most EfiO<>ti,'C TCKhing Activities
4.2. 1beTestirogHypolheses
42.1. l!ypolhesis O.X: C001en - Based lnstruaion
and Task-Based~ Taoching SigniJicandy Affect
on Convnu>icaUve
51
58
~ 58
4.3.2. Research Findinss of !he Second Research
Probletm 61
CHAPTER V CONCLUSIONS AND SUGG£STJONS
4.S.I. <:ontlusM>ns
4.S.2.
SusgesriMs62
63
LIST OF TABLES
Table Page
2.1. The Differences llctw1len Comem - Based lnsuucticn
and Task - BISCd Language Teaehing 40
3.1. The Randomlsed Groups. Pre - 1eS1 and
Post -
test desigJI 44 4.1.ThePost -
Test Scon:s ofG~ Expetimallall{ Conlm • Ba5Cd Instruction in T eaclliJ1g
eomrn.nc.tive~ )
4 2. The Pos1 Test Scon:s of Expcrimcnl Groo.lp 2 {Ttik - B....S
J..anaulae
Teaehirrg)4.3. The Po>1 - Test Scon:s ofConlrol G""4' (~ual)
4.4. Analysis of Variance Table of
the Post - Test of the Three Groups
4.S. The Ncwn1an Keuls Test to Decide
the Mosl Effoctive Teaching
S2
S4
56
S8
fipe
4. 1. Histogrum !tom oable 4. 1
4.2. HIStogram fi'OO> lable 4 2 4.3. Hisloarom liom table 4.3
LIST OF FlGURES
Page
53
55
LIST OF APPENDICES
Appendix
I. The =mple of the test
ll Ths is the example or Jldi.,jties in the experimenlal group. m . The Compwtion or the Post -Test &om the
Tbrce G""''l' in Cornmmicative C0111pe1"""" Test IV. NEWMAN - KEUI.S CALCULATIONS
V. Reliobohty
Page
68
78
82
BS
CHAPTER I
INTRODUCTION
1. 1. Tbe'Bacl<gr-o-d oflht Study
The WOI'Id is now experiencing ,...,... stages or social. ccooomical, and
dcmogHqiliatl tJinUXms The
c:mc:rpg
global cx:ouotll) is very ~ - Inthis age of cechnology, infonnalion conccmi.na the speedy developnent in various
f1Cids of lrlCbnology and saonce is IIICOIIy CO<M:)<d IM>ugJ> ~
n-.
such os internet.
Globalization and the free tJide maric<t have mode English extremely
olij)OI-
""-'"elhCn:
isno
OCherlarc'av
that hiS wide -spreadusc
~the world. It is inevitable tl1ot Indonesia, IS a developing counuy, is in need of the
English langulae IS iofonnation
conca
nirc
advanc:ed 1ec:lmlogy andsc"'""'
isconl!e)'Cd in
Enclish:
One of the basic problc:rm in forcisn
Jancua8"
""'cbms
is to prepare lcamas to be oble touse
the ~ 1llcre atesome
needs and be able to do inordct 10 speak in another language, one nocds to know how to articulate sounds in • ~ible ...,., one needs an adequate ~ . and one needs to
haYe masiCry nf S)'1UX. ,.,..,.., •aaiatiooJS add ~ 10 lir1guistio Wti.,CICiu;.
Howeva-. while l~tic tc>iupettu::e is necessary. it is oot suJfteienl for
-.:one
wbo WITIIS 10 COIJli1Ulicote .,.,.,.,....ly in another ~The lc:aching of English IS 8 foreign
Jancua8"
in Indonesia is 1101 rm.d:i,.
2
languoge ha>e been widely o<WBJiized. A susvey condiiCied by !he Dc:portrrem of
EducaloOn and Culti.I'C of the RepU>tic of Indonesia (2003· 17) bas oeponcd thai
teacbcB (95.4 % of pobli<: and 91.90/o of pivllle schools leaC!oeB) admillcd that
""' Enalish
muctioto has been IDSUCX>CSSful.Many colleges in Medon now demand !heir studenl$ to be able to
c:ormaci:ale
in
~ So, they u.1te syllobus on their college t1oo1Enalish
istatJgt. since the first semester llllil eigbllt semester. The researcher is one of the
~.ish """"""' in the college. NOC only tbe researcher has difficolmcss to teado
the students bw also IIIIOtbcr
Enal.ish
tca<:hor. However, so for tbe opproach to dealwith these ooncems bas been focused 001 methodology rather than on more filrodomcntol issues derived fiom ~studies.
T eacbcB and educators tend to identiiY !he methodology as the SC31'"!,'03~
The old method is oq>laced with 1 new
one,
and the introcluc:llon ofa
rw:w methodis intc:ndcd to oorrcct ""' previous
one.
Ho""""'.
in the tlw)Sitioow.l period. teo<:henarc olleo
blinded by tbenewness of !he method instead of c:ritic:ally reviewing whcthc:r the unsatisfactory learnit1g ... do in filet relale to DZ1IIoclokJtjca poblcms (see Hubbud,
Jones, Thornton and Whcclc:r, 1983~
Being coocenocd with the ilO!IliDinic:atve compc:titnce of sta.dcnts, for
~
Enalish
cducolors then turned to tbe al<IIIIUlicative approech did notculminate in evaluation process of the sl<ms that !he ·~
was
supposed to3
c:ntrar<:e teS~ which still emphasize sllUCilnl lcoowlodge rathe< !han oommuni<:orive slo11s.
Modem ~ pcdaao&Y emphasizes a fOO\IS on meaning over fonn as
the beso pllh ooward
oommunicaliw:
coupeto""' aod ocancy (B,., aodCadlin.
1980; Widdowson: 1978). The Comoru.micoiM: ~ Tcadling lesson
ccnoered on giving stuclenls oppct1\Jilioies oo ptactioc using lhe oonmwlicaoi""
fWICtioll of
rnekirc
pcdietioas. In these...,.C>IIC:bd
~ lhon "learning 10 useEl18fisb, • studenos " use English 10 leom it'" (HOWitt 1984 ~ Conlelll - based lanb""'&<: oeacbing ptOVide$ an impcnant means of acbi<W>@ ohis fO<IJ$ on
meaning (Cnudall: 1987; Swain: 1999). Conlel<l ..., como from a varieoy of
sowa:s, such as penonal malk:IS, e.g., soudcnos' favo<ioc music and food,
occo'l""i'nOn ...,.. as
in lang\lljlOfor
specific JlUliOSOS,c.a..
funRcoeinecrs
raoding ..00.. aoaitmb& and globol issues, c.s., pcaoc.
t..man
riglu. and environn•:rnal education (CateS: 1990).Task! refer 1<> IIClivities carried .,.. in ohe classroom by soudcnos who use
ohe oargot 1angtag<: in ways lhao rclaoc 10 wbolo obey mighl ha"" 10 do O<JOS!de obe
elassroom. As studenos wort on purposd\ol
w1<s.
obey are ~ in meaningful activities which focus on ~ and ~ of obe Jorcuasio, thesemay """"""' !heir learmng (Foster and Skehan: 1996~ FO< ~ l e, a oeacher rray ...., studau 10 do a SllllDIBI)' because obey may - such a oask in
4
Becanse
or
thooe """""'· the rcsean:her is intercsled to coodoct • """""'b10 lind out the effectiiiCilCSs of these two imtructions, conlenl and wit based
~on studcra" com:ru::ic::ati COiUV Jc •o ..
1.2. 1'he Pn>bte. oftheSiucly
Based on the becl(groonl wbldl is
g;...,.,
aboYe. tbis SIUdy wiD irMsbgatethe
use
of .,.,...,.,. - basedinslna:lion
n1 task - based ~anguo&e tcachins inteac!Unil English class. It means tllat the $IUdy will investigate the ongoin(l ~ish ~ withoul c:onocnt and taSk based loj)pi<*iles as ots besic meas...,.,._ Based on the notioo, the problem of the SIUdy can be staled in the
fol~ questions:
I . Do the
cont.,. -
based imtnlelioo and task - bascd lang~age t1C1Cbingsignificantly affect student's communicative competence?
2.
Which of the - - based instruction and task - based 1anguo&e~ os the more elftdive to the stllel<3' s conmlll'icaiM:
OCJ<l1)0tenoe 1
1.3. T1oe Scope til .... Sflldy
There an: a lot IIJllllllaChcs tllat teocbers can usc in enhancin(l the studenb
OCJ<l1)0tenoe ;., ~ especially in CCITI1U1ication
a..
in this atSC thewma
j1B1 b:uscs her ...-cb oo the use
or
two tudoitc>, they ..-e ..,.,.... - bascdI
I
s
1.4. ne Objediva of • St.ly
In carrying out the research, it i! necessaty to state what arc the objectives
time.
So
the cbjecdves of this study are:I. To find out whether the ClOI'IIet>l - based iosuuction and taSk - based
2. To find 0U1 and make """ whethe< the C><ldelll - based instruotioo ot
task based la111,ouage taochiog is more effective on students'
t.s.
ne Sipillcuce of.-St.~yThis research findings are
C'lCJ'C"ted
to be usefUl&o
English teacbe1s toeonccmin8 ...
,th
loangulgeusc
andteacbina
~research.This study is CllpOCttld 10 povidc infi>nnltion, wbich may ha-..e pnl<tical OS
well
os
thcomical values fot Englishq'"l!"
tiCOCbcr. Thom:tically. the resullof
the study will add what has been fuund in the area of English teochi11(1 in fomgn
6()
CJIAPTE.R V
CONCLUmQNSAHDSUGCESnONS
5.1.
CONCLUSI.ONS
This chapter of intensive reseliiCh oo the effect of cotUem - based
instruction IIJ1d task - based language teaching on srudents' communicative
compelmCe showed the sigpilicanl
.met.
This is c:cncludod as follows a.c...- -
based inslnlc6onw
task - based ~ "'""~sisroif....-ly alliaod oo st\ldalts' <IOimlUiicolive
C<Ct\>0"""""
It wasshown on the F
,.__.>
F -(8.6 > 3 . 22~b. The task - based language teaching is the most effective reaching oo
students' COIIlllll.lli<: compctcllCe. It can be seen fiom lbc NtwmRII -Keuls tecMiquc that the mean and RST of W1c - bosed language reaching is boJIIOSI lhon lbc two ~ ( """" and RST of COill«ll - based
tn$truelioG
ODd~ ~ 6.4 < 6.S. mean ODd RST of theCootenl - bosed instruction and task - based language teaching IS. S > S.S 1
and mean and RST of contem - based insiJUction and laSlc - based
61
S.l. SUGC£STIONS
S.:..:..l s~
are
offeredfor
funner n:scon:b in order 10obloin
lhc:maximal
findings laler 00S<M:taJ
SUW"'hOIIS IW:o.
The findings of lhis srudy can be used for developing studellts'commumcativc oompc:tenee.
b. 111o I&Sk - '-sed ~ leaChing
can
be appliedon
lhc: English 1eaclil1gclassroom especialJy fur lhc: leOChcrs who wao1 10 develop lb<iJ-Sllldenls'
~c:ompe;.nce
c. Another ltiiCher can make I&Sk - ~loosed ~ IA:ae~
owe ereati..,
and iMOvative ~to lhc: students' competence and interest
d. Teacher can trtale
new
material besod oo lhe task - b-' langllllgC ICOChina62
REFERENCES
Ary, Dooald. (1979). /ntnxluctlon to Research Education. United State of America: Hol~ Rincbatt and Winston. Inc
Bachman. L .. F. and l'alrn..-, A.S. (1982} 'Tne COfiS/nJCI Validation of Some Components of Communicative Proficiency. TESOL Quartely, 16 (4)
Bell, J., and b. Burnaby. (1984). A Handbooli for ESL Literacy. Toronto:
Ontario
Institute fro Studies in Education
Broc:n, M, and Cadlin, C.N. (1980). The /!.'ssentia/s of a Communicative Curriculum Language Teaching. Applied Linguistics
Breeu, M. (1987). /.earner Contributions to Task O..ign. In C. Candlin and D.
Murphy (eds.} Language /,earning Ta.<As. Englewoods Cliffs, N.J.: Pl1:nticc
Hall
Brinton, D .. M., M.A. Snow, and M.B. Wesche. (1989). ContenJ .. 8osed Second
Language Instruction. New Yori<: Newl><lry House
Bygate, M. (1987). SpeaAing. Oxfo<d: OxfOrd U niv=ity Press
Cates, K. (1990). Teaching for a &11er World: Global l.f:rues in L.onguage Education. The Language Teacher 14
Cl'omsl<y, N. (1965). A.<pects of the Theory of Syntax. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Crandal, J. (eels.). (1987). ESL 1'hmngh COntenJ - 8a.«d InStruction. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Pl1:nticc Hall
CIOI<es, G. (1986). Task Classification: A 1.:'ross - Disciplinary Review. Honolulu: Center for Second Language Classroom Research
D'Anglc:jan, A., and R Tucker. (1975} Tk Acqlli!•lion of Complex English Structures by Adult Learners. Language Learning 25
Depat!ement Pendidilcan dan Kebudayaan. (2003). Survey Pengojaran Bahasa lnggris di SMI' dan SMA Sellll'tlh Indonesia. Jakarta: Depancmen
Pendidilcan dan Kebudayaan
63
Dye. Joon, and Nao;y F181tion. (1994). Specmmt: A Commllnicotive Owrse In £ny,/1Sh. London: Prmice Hal~ Inc
Edelsky, Carole, Bcos Alwagcr, and Batbora Florea. (1991). Whole Ltm~ :
What's the Differen«? Portsmouth, NH:
HeintmaM
Feez, S. (1998). Te.rt - based Syllabus De.•lgn. Sydney: National Ccntet rro English Teaching and Reset>Ich
Fas1et P., and P Skehan. (1996). The Jnflumce
of
P/Dnlling on Pu{OI"11IDTICC InTask &sed U orntng. Sn.dies in Seconcll.angut&e Acquisition 18
Honeyfield, J (1993). Responding to TDSir. DiffiCVIty. In M. Tdoo (eds ).
SimplifKXJitOtt: 7Moryand Prr>ctice. Sillppoce: R.,.;o..l I ""e'Rg!' Centct
Hubbard, P .. Jones, H., lbomlon, B., and Wheeler, R. (1983). A Trailling Ccur.tt
for TRFI. Oxford: Oxfunl Uni-.iey Pn::ss
Hymes. D. H. (1974). On Communicative Comp<tence. In J. Pride and J. Holmes (Eds. ), Sociolinguistics. Penguin
Howar1. K.B. (1984). Undenlanding Comm1111icotion in Second Language
C/auroom. Camlrilge:
Caml>rid&e
University PressJ<Jo~Dtc, K. (19f'l). Approoclres to Sylloln4 destlf!'
for
Foreign LanguageTenchmg_ New York: Prallice Hall
Long. M., and G. Crooltes. (1991).Three AfJP"))Ches to Task - &sed Syllabus
Dwgn. TESOL Q\latlely 26
Long. M .. and 0 . Crookcs. (1993). Unil.f of Analys/3 in Course ~tiff!' - The Case for TasA. In G. Crooltes and S. Gass (cds.}. 7'asks in Pedt«IJgical Context:
lnii!1(!'UIIIIg Tlteary and Proclicft. Clevedon: Mullilircual Matters
Moban, B. ( 1986). Lon~ and Content. RC*Iirc. Mass: Addison- Wesley Nlmn, D. (1919). Durgmllg Tasks for the CommvniCOtive Classroom. New
York:
CaJrbrid&e
Uniwssily PressPica.
T., R. K~~»&Y. IIDd J. Faloduo. (1993). ·Choo&ing and Using Communicative Tasks fro S«ond Language /nstrucJion. In G. Crooltes andS.
Gas$ (cds.),l'a.<k and l.angiJIJge Leoming: Integrating 1'/reory and Practice. Clevedon: Multilingual M""""
64
Rodgers. 'Tbeodonl aod Richards, Jaelc. C (200 I). Approaches and Metlltxh m
Languogt Teaching. Cambridge: Cambridge Uniw.,.ity Press.
Satire, W. (1998). On /AngiJ08": 11le Summer
of
this Content. New YOtt Tunes. August 19, 1998Saville, N. aod
HotiJea,.,.,
P. ( 1999~ A.rses.mg Speo!tng tn tht nvised FCE.ELT joorral, SJ (I)
Savignon. S. (1997). Comm1111k:otive 0JmpeJenct: Theory and Cl=room
Proctice. New Y or1c Mc(lraw-Hm.
Savignon, S. (2001). "Cormulicati>-e ~ teachll18 in lhe IWCDCy•fir>t
cermy."
In M. Cck»-M<Ria (eel.), Teachmg English as a Second orf'ortign Language. ll<loton: Heinie & Heinle.
Slcehan, P. (1996} A Fro,.wod
fro
the IMplementatlo#lof
Task - lkU<d/n.slri/Ciifm. Applied Linguistics
Sk ... P. (1998}A oog>tllm Approado t& lartgllllg< Learning. Oxford: Oxfool Ummily Press
Smith, D. ( 1971). Task Train/rtf?. In AMA F..ncyclopodia of Supervisory Training. New YOtt: Americon Manogcmcnl Associolioo
Sloller, F. (1997). Project Wort: A Means to Promote l.anguag< and Content.
~ Teacbng Forum. 3S (4): 2-9. 37
Stryker, S., aod B.
Leaver.
( 1993). Content &sed Instruction in FON!i8f1wngwge EdiiCQtion. WasJ>iretoo. O.C: O<lorsclown University Press
S"''l!in, M. ( 1999). lntegrotrng Language and Conttnt Teaching 71troug/l
OJI/oborative 7'asks. In C.S. Ward & W.A. Renandya (ods.). New lmlghts
for /.artglllll,,. Ttoehtr. S...,.,.e: SEAMO Rcgioolll..anguoae Cmer Weir, C. ( 1988).
,
...
U!mmunlootiW l-anguage Tesnng. Exeter. Exeter UniversityWesc;he, Maljone. (1993). ()l.rciplifUI - &sm Apptoachu to lon81J08'! Study:
Ro.-rch I.!IWS and Olllcomes in Krueger. M. and F. Ryan (ods~ Languagt
65
Widdowwsoo,tt (1978). Twching Languuge a.< Communi001i0tl Oxford: Oxford
Univcrsily l'n:5$
WOIIs, J. (1996). A Fltxrblt fo'romttWork fro Ta.vk - Boaed Leamrng. In J. Wnlis
and 0 . Willis (cds . ~ Chall•nge and Change In Langu<Ige Teadrrng. Oxford: