$1$/,6,6/2.$6,,1'8675,6(5%8..$5(7$/$07(5$.7,9$6,
6.$78178.$63$/.$5(7
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
7HUDNWLYDVL6.$7
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
0HPLOLK WHPSDW WHUEDLN SHQGLULDQ VHEXDKSDEULNGHQJDQGXDDWDXOHELKORNDVL
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
%$+$1'$10(72'(
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
6HWHODK GLODNXNDQ ZDZDQFDUD SHQGDKXOXDQ GDQ GLGDSDWNDQ KLHUDUNL NHPXGLDQ GLODQMXWNDQ GHQJDQ ZDZDQFDUD PHQJJXQDNDQNXLVLRQHU\DQJWHODKGLVXVXQ 5HVSRQGHQ\DQJGLSLOLKDGDODKSDNDUDVSDO GDQPDQDMHPHQ37;;;/DQJNDKODQJNDK \DQJ GLODNXNDQ GDODP SHQHQWXDQ DQDOLVLV ORNDVLVHVXDLGHQJDQODQJNDKODQJNDKSDGD PHWRGH$+3\DQJGLNHPEDQJNDQROHK6DDW\ 7LGRUH GDQ 6HW\DZDQ VHEDJDLEHULNXW D 0HQHQWXNDQ WXMXDQ GDQ MHQLVMHQLV NULWHULD\DQJDNDQPHQMDGLSHUV\DUDWDQ E 0HODNXNDQ ZDZDQFDUD SHQGDKXOXDQ
NHSDGD SDNDU DVSDO XQWXN PHQ\XVXQ KLHUDUNL GDUL NHVHOXUXKDQ VXGXW SDQGDQJ PDQDMHULDO GDQ NXLVLRQHU SHQHOLWLDQ3DGDKLHUDUNL\DQJGLVXVXQ SDGD VHWLDS VXE NULWHULD GLODNXNDQ NXDQWLILNDVL XQWXN PHQLQJNDWNDQ REMHNWLYLWDV
%HUGDVDUNDQZDZDQFDUDSHQGDKXOXDQ KLUDUNL SHQHQWXDQ ORNDVL SDEULN 6.$7 GDSDWGLOLKDWSDGDJDPEDU
F 0HPEXDW PDWULNV SHUEDQGLQJDQ EHUSDVDQJ GLLVL GHQJDQ ELODQJDQ \DQJ PHQJJDPEDUNDQ UHODWLI SHQWLQJQ\D VXDWXHOHPHQDWDVHOHPHQ\DQJODLQQ\D VHSHUWLSDGD7DEHO
6NRU SHQJLVLDQ HOHPHQHOHPHQ SDGD PDWULNV EHUSDVDQJDQ VHSHUWL SDGD 7DEHO
ovZ UíìóXìõìlu :ovZ^UíìõXìóñlu WouvP :ovZ^/UõìXíñðlu W :ovE]}voWUðXîóò :ovE]}voUñXóñô :ovE]}vo^UñXòíí :ovE]}vo^/UðXôïó ]lul :lWrlUîìlu :lr<Uíñìlu :l^r<Uññìlu >}l]}]uµu Zvlµ :l^/r<Uóîìlu :lWr'dZUòñìlu :lr'dZUííôlu :l^r'dZUîõôlu :l^/r'dZUïîlu
,PoZvWUîUñiµ ^uvP ,PoZvUîiµ
,PoZv^UíUðiµ ]Ç ,PoZv^/UïUñiµ
hDWWUîUñiµ
hDWUïUîiµ ^]}i} hDW^UîUðiµ hDW^/UïUòiµ .HWHUDQJDQ5HPDNV 3 3DOHPEDQJ & &LNDPSHN 6( 6HPDUDQJ 68 6LGRDUMR 3DQMDQJ-DODQ.P SDQMDQJMDODQGDODPUDGLXV.P -DUDN.P -DUDNUDWDUDWDSDEULNNHVXPEHUEDKDQEDKDQEDNXNDUHW DODPGDQ*URXQG7\UH5XEEHU*75 +DUJDODKDQ,'5 KDUJDODKDQGLPDVLQJPDVLQJNRWD *DPEDU+LHUDUNLSHQHQWXDQORNDVLSHQGLULDQSDEULN )LJXUH+LHUUDUFK\WRGHWHUPLQHSODQWORFDWLRQ & $ $ $ $ « $Q $ D D D « DQ $ D $ D « DQ $ D D D « DQ $ D D D « DQ « « « $Q DQ DQ DQ DQ « 7DEHO0DWULNVSHUEDQGLQJDQEHUSDVDQJDQ 7DEOH3DLUHGFRPSDULVRQPDWUL[ .HWHUDQJDQ5HPDNV & .ULWHULDDWDXVLIDW\DQJGLJXQDNDQXQWXNSHPEDQGLQJDQ $$$Q 6HWHOHPHQ\DQJDNDQGLEDQGLQJNDQ
DD« .XDQWLILNDVL SHQGDSDW GDUL KDVLO NRPSDUDVL \DQJ PHQFHUPLQNDQ QLODL NHSHQWLQJDQ $L WHUKDGDS$M
G 3DNDU PHODNXNDQ SHQJLVLDQ NXLVLRQHU
WHUNDLWKDQ\DSDGD´NULWHULDµDQWDUDODLQ DVSHN SDVDU EDKDQ EDNX GDQ ELD\D WHUNDLWODKDQGDQXSDKVHGDQJNDQSDGD ´VXENULWHULDGDQ´DOWHUQDWLIµGLODNXNDQ SHQJXUXWDQ VHVXDL GHQJDQ GDWD 3DGD PDWULNV SHUEDQGLQJDQ EHUSDVDQJDQ GHQJDQ VNRU SHQJLVLDQ VHSHUWL SDGD 7DEHO H 'DODPPHODNXNDQDQDOLVLVVXENULWHULD \DQJ WHODK GLNXDQWLILNDVL DVXPVL \DQJ GLJXQDNDQVHEDJDLEHULNXW $VSHNSDVDUSDQMDQJMDODQQDVLRQDO PHPLOLNL ERERW GXD NDOL OLSDW OHELK EHVDU MLND GLEDQGLQJNDQ GHQJDQ MDODQGDHUDKXQWXNVHWLDSNLORPHWHU SDQMDQJ MDODQ QDVLRQDO GLNDOLNDQ GXD VHGDQJNDQ MDODQ GDHUDK GLNDOLNDQVDWX
%DKDQEDNXMDUDNEDKDQEDNX*75 PHPLOLNL ERERW WLJD NDOL OHELK EHVDU MLND GLEDQGLQJNDQ GHQJDQ MDUDN EDKDQEDNXNDUHWXQWXNVHWLDSMDUDN VDWX NLORPHWHU MDUDN EDKDQ EDNX *75GLNDOLNDQWLJDVHGDQJNDQMDUDN GHQJDQ EDKDQ EDNX NDUHW DODP GLNDOLNDQVDWX
%LD\D ELD\D XSDK PLQLPXP PHPLOLNL ERERW GXD NDOL OHELK EHVDU MLND GLEDQGLQJNDQ GHQJDQ KDUJD ODKDQ KDUJD ODKDQ GLNDOLNDQ GXD VHGDQJNDQ ELD\D XSDK GLNDOLNDQ VDWX
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
3DGD SHQHOLWLDQ LQL DVXPVL SDVDU \DQJ GLJXQDNDQ DGDODK MDODQ EHUXSD MDODQ GDHUDK PDXSXQ MDODQ QDVLRQDO GHQJDQ UDGLXV.PGDULORNDVLUHQFDQDSHQGLULDQ SDEULN 3HPEHQWXNDQ KLHUDUNL SHQHOLWLDQ \DQJGLSHUROHKGDULKDVLOZDZDQFDUDGHQJDQ SDNDUVHVXDLNULWHULD\DQJGLSLOLK<DQJHWDO PHPLOLK NULWHULD EHUXSD SHPDVDUDQ V X P E H U G D \ D P D Q X V L D 3 H U D W X U D Q 3HPHULQWDK GDQ NHGHNDWDQ GHQJDQ EDKDQ EDNX XQWXN PHQFDUL ORNDVL +DVLO SHQJRODKDQ GDWD GHQJDQ PHQJJXQDNDQ 6RIWZDUH([SHUW&KRLFHORNDVLWHUEDLNXQWXN SHQGLULDQ SDEULN 6.$7 EDJL 37 ;;; PHQXUXW SHQJDPELO NHSXWXVDQ DWDXSXQ SDNDUGDSDWGLOLKDWSDGD*DPEDU
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
:ovZUíìóXìõìlu ~ìXîîí :ovZ^UíìõXìóñlu ~ìXïîð WouvP ~ìXíóó :ovZ^/UõìXíñðlu ~ìXíðô W ~ìXñðõ :ovE]}voWUðXîóò ~ìXìîõ :ovE]}voUñXóñô ~ìXìòõ :ovE]}vo^UñXòíí ~ìXìòñ :ovE]}vo^/UðXôïó ~ìXìðð ]lul ~ìXïíñ :lWrlUîìlu ~ìXïïí :lr<Uíñìlu ~ìXíóí :l^r<Uññìlu ~ìXìóí >}l]v]]v]l^<d WdXyyy Zvlµ ~ìXîòõ :l^/r<Uóîìlu ~ìXìðõ :lWr'dZUòñìlu ~ìXìîó :lr'dZUííôlu ~ìXíìí :l^r'dZUîõôlu ~ìXìïñ :l^/r'dZUïîlu ~ìXîíñ
,PoZvWUîUñiµ
~ìXìñó
^uvP
~ìXïôî
,PoZvUîiµ
~ìXìóõ
,PoZv^UíUðiµ
~ìXíóí
]Ç
~ìXíôï
,PoZv^/UïUñiµ
~ìXìðì hDWWUîUñiµ ~ìXíõõ hDWUïUîiµ ~ìUíìõ ^]}i} ~ìXíîò hDW^UîUðiµ ~ìXîòñ hDW^/UïUòiµ ~ìXìôí dµiµv <]] ^µ<]] ov]( *DPEDU+LHUDUNLGDQKDVLOSHUKLWXQJDQ$+3 )LJXUH+LHUUDUFK\DQGUHVXOWRI$+3PHDVXUHPHQW /RNDVLSHUXVDKDDQVHEDJDLWHPSDWNHJLDWDQ SURGXNVLWHUVHEXWEHUDGDGLOXDUNRWD\DQJ F X N X S M D X K M D U D N Q \ D . R Q G L V L L Q L GLPDNVXGNDQ XQWXN PHQJXUDQJL SROXVL \DQJ GLKDVLONDQ GDODP SURVHV SURGXNVL \DQJGDSDWEHUGDPSDNSDGDPDV\DUDNDW
'LWLQMDX GDUL VLVL NULWHULD SDGD KLHUDUNL DVSHN SDVDU PHPLOLNL ERERW
WHUWLQJJL MLND GLEDQGLQJNDQ GHQJDQ MDUDN WHUKDGDSSDEULN6.$7WHUKDGDSEDKDQEDNX GDQELD\DWHUNDLWKDUJDODKDQPDXSXQXSDK PLQLPXP +DO LQL GLVHEDENDQ GDODP S H Q J H O R O D D Q L Q G X V W U L D V S D O S D V D U PHUXSDNDQ KDO \DQJ VDQJDW SHQWLQJ EDJL NHEHUODQJVXQJDQLQGXVWULLWXVHQGLUL3RVLVL SDEULNGDULSDVDU\DQJDNDQGLVDVDUPHQMDGL KDO \DQJ VDQJDW GLSHUKLWXQJNDQ WHUXWDPD
GDUL EHVDUQ\D SDVDU \DQJ GDSDW VHUWD
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
+DVLOSHUKLWXQJDQSDGDVXENULWHULD ELD\D ODKDQ VHUWD XSDK PLQLPXP 8SDK PLQLPXPDSDELODSDEULN6.$7GLGLULNDQGL
6HPDUDQJ PHQHPSDWL SHULQJNDW SHUWDPD +DO LQL GLNDUHQDNDQ XSDK PLQLPXP GL ZLOD\DK6HPDUDQJSDOLQJUHQGDKGLLNXWLROHK XSDK PLQLPXP ZLOD\DK 3DOHPEDQJ 6HGDQJNDQ GL XUXWDQ NHWLJD DGDODK ELD\D ODKDQ GL 6HPDUDQJ \DQJ PHUXSDNDQ KDUJD ODKDQWHUHQGDKGDULKDUJDODKDQGLZLOD\DK ODLQQ\D'DULKDVLOSHUKLWXQJDQGDSDWGLOLKDW EDKZDXSDKPLQLPXPOHELKSULRULWDVGDODP SHPLOLKDQORNDVL+DOLQLGLNDUHQDNDQXSDK PLQLPXP DNDQ PHPSHQJDUXKL ELD\D RSHUDVLRQDO GDUL SDEULN 6.$7 VHFDUD WHUXV PHQHUXVVHODPDSDEULNWHUVHEXWEHURSHUDVL
+DO LQL VHMDODQ GHQJDQ SHQGDSDW :HEHU WLQJNDW NHXQWXQJDQ VXDWX LQGXVWUL DNDQ VDQJDW WHUJDQWXQJ GDUL ORNDVLQ\DWHUXWDPDSDGDELD\DWUDQVSRUWDVL GDQ WHQDJD NHUMD \DQJ NHGXDQ\D KDUXV VHPLQLPXP PXQJNLQ %LD\D WUDQVSRUWDVL EHUWDPEDK VHFDUD SURSRUVLRQDO GHQJDQ MDUDN GLPDQD ELD\D XQWXN VHOXUXK LQSXW XQWXN SURGXNVL DNDQ EHUWDPEDK EHVDU DSDELODMDUDNVHPDNLQMDXKGDULWHPSDWDVDO LQSXW EHJLWX SXODRXWSXW SURGXNVL \DQJ OHELKMDXKGHQJDQSDVDUDNDQPHQLQJNDWNDQ ELD\D
%HUGDVDUNDQKDVLOVLQWHVLVWHUKDGDS NULWHULD GDQ VXE NULWHULD DOWHUQDWLI ORNDVL SHQGLULDQ 6.$7 VHFDUD EHUXUXWDQ VHVXDL ERERW \DQJ GLKDVLONDQ DGDODK 6HPDUDQJ &LNDPSHN 3DOHPEDQJ GDQ \DQJ WHUDNKLU DGDODK 6LGRDUMR GHQJDQUDVLRNRQVLVWHQVL
6HPDUDQJ WHUSLOLK VHEDJDL ORNDVL WHUEDLN GLNDUHQDNDQ GLDQJJDS PHPLOLNL NHXQJJXODQ GLEDQGLQJNDQ GHQJDQ ORNDVL ODLQQ\DWHUXWDPDGDULVLVLSDVDU\DLWXMDODQ QDVLRQDO PDXSXQ MDODQ GDHUDK GDQ ELD\D EHUXSD XSDK PLQLPXP VHUWD ELD\D ODKDQ PHVNLSXQ MDUDN GHQJDQ EDKDQ EDNX WLGDN WHUODOX GHNDW 6HGDQJNDQ 6LGRDUMR PHQMDGL SLOLKDQ\DQJSDOLQJDNKLUPHVNLSXQPHPLOLNL NHXQJJXODQ NDUHQD ORNDVLQ\D EHUGHNDWDQ GHQJDQ VXPEHU EDKDQ EDNX *75 DNDQ WHWDSL GDUL VLVL ELD\D ODKDQ MDUDN GHQJDQ VXPEHU EDKDQ EDNX NDUHW PDXSXQ XSDK WHQDJDNHUMDWLGDNOHELKEDLNGDUL3DOHPEDQJ GDQ&LNDPSHN
.(6,038/$1
%HUGDVDUNDQ KDVLO DQDOLVLV GHQJDQ PHQJJXQDNDQPHWRGH$+3GLNHWDKXLORNDVL WHUEDLN XQWXN PHQGLULNDQ SDEULN 6.$7
GLNDUHQDNDQPHPLOLNLSDVDU\DQJSURVSHNWLI GDODPUDGLXV.PGHQJDQSDQMDQJMDODQ QDVLRQDO .P GDQ MDODQ GDHUDK VHSDQMDQJ .P 0HVNLSXQ MDUDN GHQJDQVXPEHUEDKDQEDNXNDUHWDODPWLGDN VHGHNDW DSDELOD SDEULN GLGLULNDQ GL 3DOHPEDQJ VHUWD MDUDN GHQJDQ VXPEHU EDKDQ EDNX *75 WLGDN VHGHNDW DSDELOD SDEULN GLGLULNDQ GL 6LGRDUMR 6HPDUDQJ PHPLOLNLNHXQJJXODQODLQ\DLWXKDUJDODKDQ VHUWD XSDK WHQDJD NHUMD \DQJ OHELK PXUDK GLEDQGLQJNDQGHQJDQNRWDODLQ
'$)7$53867$.$
$WDHL00XOWLFULWHULDVHOHFWLRQIRUDQ DOXPLQDFHPHQWSODQWORFDWLRQLQ(DVW $]HUEDLMDQ 3URYLQFH RI ,UDQ 7KH -RXUQDO RI 7KH 6RXWKHUQ $IULFDQ ,QVWLWXWHRI0LQLQJDQG0HWDOOXUJ\ ²
$]L]L 0 5DPH]DQ]DGHK 0 'HWHUPLQLQJ HIIHFWLYH FULWHULD IRU WKH V H O H F W L R Q R I 0 ' ) L Q G X V W U \ L Q 0D]DQGDUDQ 3URYLQFH $SSOLFDWLRQ $+3)RUHVW6FLHQFHDQG3UDFWLFH %UDJOLD 0 *DEEULHOOL 5 $ GHFLVLRQVXSSRUWV\VWHPIRUORFDWLRQDO D Q D O \ V L V L Q S D S H U L Q G X V W U \ ,QWHUQDWLRQDO -RXUQDO RI /RJLVWLF 6\VWHPV DQG 0DQDJHPHQW ² ' R L , - / 6 0 .RD ( %XUKDQ +$ $Q DSSOLFDWLRQ RI DQDO\WLF KLHUDUFK\ SURFHVV$+3LQUHDOZRUOGSUREOHPRI VWRUH ORFDWLRQ VHOHFWLRQ$GYDQFHV LQ 0DQDJHPHQW $SSOLHG (FRQRPLFV 0XUUD\ 01 'RZHOO 3 0D\HV '7 7KH ORFDWLRQ GHFLVLRQ RI DXWRPRWLYHVXSSOLHUVLQ7HQQHVVHHDQG WKH 6RXWKHDVW 7HQQHVVHH 86$ 7KH 8QLYHUVLW\RI7HQQHVVHH
0X]D\DQDK 7HUDSDQ WHRUL ORNDVL LQGXVWULFRQWRKNDVXVSHQJHPEDQJDQ NDZDVDQLQGXVWUL.UDJLODQ.DEXSDWHQ 6HUDQJ-XUQDO *HRJUDIL
(XURSHDQ -RXUQDO RI 2SHUDWLRQDO 5 H V H D U F K ' R L ,
6HW\DZDQ5(6WUDWHJLSHQLQJNDWDQ GD\D VDLQJ LQGXVWUL IXUQLWXUH URWDQ ,QGRQHVLD GL NDZDVDQ $6($1 GDQ 7LRQJNRN 7HVLV ,QVWLWXW 3HUWDQLDQ %RJRU,QGRQHVLD
6XU\DQL < 7HRUL ORNDVL GDODP SHQHQWXDQSHPEDQJXQDQORNDVLSDVDU WUDGLVLRQDO WHODDK VWXGL OLWHUDWXU 3URVLGLQJ 6HPLQDU 1DVLRQDO (NRQRPL 0DQDMHPHQ GDQ DNXQWDQVL 61(0$ S 3DGDQJ ,QGRQHVLD )DNXOWDV (NRQRPL 8QLYHUVLWDV 1HJHUL 3DGDQJ 7LGRUH $ $QDOLVLV VLVWHP SHPDVDUDQKDVLOSURGXNVLSHULNDQDQ WDQJNDS VWXGL NDVXV .HFDPDWDQ 7REHOR.DEXSDWHQ+DOPDKHUD8WDUD 7HVLV ,QVWLWXW 3HUWDQLDQ %RJRU ,QGRQHVLD
7LP 7HNQLV $VSDO .DUHW 3UD VWXGL NHOD\DNDQ SHPEDQJXQDQ LQGXVWUL PDVWHUEDWFK GDQ DVSDO PRGLILNDVL E H U E D V L V N D U H W D O D P - D N D U W D , Q G R Q H V L D . H P H Q W H U L D Q 3HULQGXVWULDQ
:HEHU $ 7KHRU\ RI WKH ORFDWLRQ RI L Q G X V W U L H V & K L F D J R 8 6 $ 7 K H 8QLYHUVLW\RI&KLFDJR3UHVV
<DQJ&/&KXDQJ63+XDQJ5+ 7DL && /RFDWLRQ VHOHFWLRQ EDVHG RQ $+3$13 $SSURDFK 3URFHHGLQJ ,((( ,QWHUQDWLRQDO &RQIHUHQFH RQ ,QGXVWULDO(QJLQHHULQJDQG(QJLQHHULQJ 0 D Q D J H P H Q W S ² 6 L Q J D S R U H 6 L Q J D S R U H , ( ( ( (QJLQHHULQJ0DQDJHPHQW6RFLHW\ <DYX]06HOHFWLRQRISODQWORFDWLRQ LQWKHQDWXUDOVWRQHLQGXVWU\XVLQJWKH IX]]\ PXOWLSOH DWWULEXWH GHFLVLRQ PDNLQJ PHWKRG 7KH -RXUQDO RI 7KH 6RXWKHUQ$IULFDQ,QVWLWXWHRI0LQLQJDQG
