ReviewProcess IntJournal Istadi jun2009

(1)

PROSES

DI JURNAL INT

Oleh: Dr. Istadi (Teknik K

Email: istad

Website: http://teki

PELATIHAN PENULISAN (WORLD CLASS UNIVERSITY - Lembag

16-17 J 16 17 J

REVIEW

TERNASIONAL

Kimia Universitas Diponegoro)

di@undip ac id ;

[email protected] ;

im.undip.ac.id/staf/istadi

N JURNAL INTERNASIONAL

ga Penelitian UNIVERSITAS DIPONEGORO) Juni 2009

(2)

(3)

Shanghai Jiao

Criteria Criteria

Quality of

Education

Alumni of an instituti

and Fields Medals

Quality of Faculty

Staff of an institution

Fields Medals

Q

y

Highly cited research

Social Science Citat

Size of Institution

Academic performan

of an institution

o Tong Criteria

Indicator Weight

Indicator Weight

on winning Nobel Prizes

10%

n winning Nobel Prizes and

20%

hers in 21 broad subject

20%

N t

d S i

*

20%

Nature and Science*

20%

Citation Index-expanded,

tion Index

20%

tion Index

nce with respect to the size

(4)

Ranking Crite

g

Citations Citations Peer Peer Review Review Citations Citations per Faculty per Faculty Review Review Int’l Faculty Int’l Faculty Int’l Students Int’l Students

Recruiter Recruiter Review Review Student Student Faculty Faculty Ratio Ratio Review Review

eria & Weights

g

Peer Review – 40%

Composite

score

drawn

from

peer

review

(which

is

divided

into

five

subject

areas).

5,101

responses.

Recruiter Review – 10%

j

)

,

p

Score

based

on

responses

to

recruiter

survey.

1,482

responses

Student Faculty Ratio – 20

%

International Faculty – 5%

Score based on proportion of

Score

based

on

proportion

of

international

faculty

Score

based

on

proportion

of

international

faculty

International Students – 5%

Score

based

on

proportion

of

Citations per Faculty 20%

international

faculty

Citations per Faculty– 20%

Score

based

on

research

performance

factored

against

the

size

of

the

research

Quacquarelli Symonds

qsnetwork.com) 4

(5)

Webometr

Indicator

Size

Number of pages recovered from four engine Search and Exalead.

Rich Files

After evaluation of relevance to academic an considering the volume of the different file fo considering the volume of the different file fo selected: Adobe Acrobat (.pdf), Adobe PostS (.doc) and Microsoft Powerpoint (.ppt). Thes Google, Yahoo Search, Live Search and Exa

Scholar

Google Scholar provides the number of pape academic domain. These results from the Sc academic domain. These results from the Sc papers, reports and other academic items.

Visibility

Th t t l b f i t l li k

The total number of unique external links rec only confidently obtained from Yahoo Search

rics

rics Criteria

Criteria

rics

rics Criteria

Criteria

Weight

es: Google, Yahoo, Live

20%

nd publication activities and

ormats the following were

15%

ormats, the following were

Script (.ps), Microsoft Word se data were extracted using

alead.

15%

ers and citations for each

cholar database represent

15%

cholar database represent

i d (i li k ) b it b

50%

ceived (inlinks) by a site can be

h, Live Search and Exalead.

(6)

Citations per F

p

Well

Well--understood bias

understood bias

--

against non

against non--English publicatio

English publicatio

--

against arts and humanities

--

against national

against national--oriented topi

oriented topi

against national

against national oriented topi

oriented topi

Faculty Score

Cl

i

f

yy

Classic

measure of

research quality

Citations per staff

member

(not per paper)

5 year score (changed

from 10 in 2006 to

increase “topicality”)

Source:

Scopus

(7)

200

20099 Faculty Le

Faculty Le

for Top 100 Asi

Arts

&

Humanities

Engineering

&

IT

Life

Scie

Biomed

UGM

(14)

UI (15)

ITB (20)

UI (44)

UGM

UI (2

ITB (

ITB (50)

IPB (86)

UGM

(51)

UNDIP(86)

IPB (87)

IT (

UNAIR

UNDIP

UNAIR (92)

UNDIP(96)

IPB (87)

IPB (

In overall, UNDIP ranks at 17

evel

evel –

– Indonesia

Indonesia

ian Universities

nces

&

dicine

Natural

Sciences

Social

Sciences

(16)

29)

50)

ITB (27)

UGM

(37)

UI (18)

UGM

(25)

ITB (50)

50)

R (59)

P(90)

UI (58)

IPB (70)

ITB (50)

UNAIR (64)

UNDIP(71)

(92)

UNDIP(98)

UNDIP(71)

IPB (88)

UNBRAW(90)

1th Top Asian Universities

network.com

(8)

Indonesia Re

THE - QS THE QS

1 University of Indonesia (287) 1 2 Bandung Institute of Technology (315) 2 3 Universitas Gadjah Mada (316=) 3 3 Universitas Gadjah Mada (316 ) 3 4 Airlangga University (501+) 4 5 Bogor Agricultural University (501+) 5 6 University of Brawijaya (501+)j y ( ) 6

7 DiponegoroUniversity (501+) 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 15

Intelligence Unit 8

esults (2008)

(

)

Webometrics Webometrics

Universitas Gadjah Mada (623)

Bandung Institute of Technology (676) University of Indonesia (906)

University of Indonesia (906) Gunadarma University (1604)

Institut Teknologi Sepuluh Nopember (1762) Sekolah Tinggi Teknologi Telkom (1960)gg g ( ) Petra Christian University (2013)

Bogor Agricultural University (2063) University of Brawijaya (2152) Sebelas Maret University (2159) Airlangga University (2672) Universitas Padjadjaran (2730)

Electronic Engineering Polytechnic Institute of Surabaya (3016)

Bina Nusantara University (3026)

(9)

Could I publ

J

DEFIN

YES … YE

lish in International

Journal?

ITELY

(10)

Types of Aca

ACAD

PAPE

Conference

Paper

(Non-referred Paper, Proceeding)

Boo

ademic Papers?

Referred

Conference

Paper

EMIC

ERS

Referred Journal Paper

(Research, Review,

(Research, Review, Short Communication/

Technical Notes)

Book &

(11)

Keuntungan Pub

Internasional ?

Original Free Offprint

(25

(25 exmplr

exmplr))

Keuntu

Publikas

Original Free Offprint

+ 1

+ 1 exmplr

exmplr Issue

Issue

Publikas

Interna

+ 1

+ 1 exmplr

exmplr Issue

Issue

(25

(25 exmplr

exmplr + 1 Issue

+ 1 Issue

Journal)

Credit

I k t b

k

t ib

i

d

Credit

(40 cre

I kut berkontribusi pada pen

di World University Ranking

blikasi di Jurnal

Free of Charge

(online PDF)

ungan

si

si Jurnal

Jurnal

Online Submission

si

si Jurnal

Jurnal

asional

O

e Sub

ss o

O

e Sub

ss o

Point

i

k t

i

k t i

tit

i

Point

edits)

(12)

Journal Citation

J

Fa

Bagaimana

Jurnal Internasional

Dikatakan

BERKUALITAS

?

I mpact Factor is a ratio

a ticles that cited to th

articles that cited to th

number of articles pub

n Rating / Impact

g /

p

actor

Ditentukan oleh:

JCR (Journal Citation Rating)

or

IF (Impact Factor)

o of the number of

he jo

nal to the

he journal to the

(13)

Kriteria Penila

Jurnal - DIKT

Penamaan Berkala (5)

Kelembagaan Penerbit

Penyuntingan (21)

P

il

(9)

Penampilan (9)

Gaya Penulisan (11)

y

(

)

Substansi I si (36)

Keberkalaan (10)

Kewajiban Pasca Terb

aian Akreditasi

TI

)

t (5)

Artikel yang Berkualitas

(14)

What is Suitable Journ

Quality of Research Outpu

area

Read the types of articles

D

id

t

f j

l

Decide on type of journal

Review Art., Short Commu

Read papers from that jou

familiar with the journal

Read the AUTHOR GUI DE

nals for Your Paper ?

ut

Î

Decide on subject

in Most Suitable Journals

(R

h A t

paper

(Research Art.,

unications, etc.)

urnal if you are not

LI NES

(15)

Mengapa Perlu Pros

PEER RE

Mempunyai

peran penting

dalam

PEER-RE

PROC

dalam

menjaga

standar

kualitas suatu

jurnal ilmiah

ses Peer-Review ?

Untuk

memastikan

EVIEW

memastikan

bahwa artikel

yang dipublikasi

EVIEW

CESS

di jurnal ilmiah

tertentu

mempunyai

kualitas saintifik

yang baik dan

standard

(16)

Siapa Yang Menjad

p

g

j

Internasional ?

R

i

/ R f

di ilih

Reviewer/ Referee yang dipilih

atas

expertise/ keahlian

me

di

j

l

l l

b h

Editor jurnal selalu menambah

waktu berdasarkan track recor

Referee juga dapat diperoleh d

dilakukan oleh Editor

Semakin banyak kita publish d

akan semakin dikenali oleh Ed

diundang oleh Editor untuk

m

diundang oleh Editor untuk

m

Biasanya jurnal selalu minta sa

ketika anda men-submit-kan p

reviewer

Î

manfaatkan sebai

di Reviewer Jurnal

J

l h Edit

j

l b

d

k

oleh Editor jurnal berdasarkan

ereka

h

k l k i

f

d

i

k

h

koleksi Referee

dari waktu ke

rd Referee

dari

searching di jurnal

yang

di Jurnal I nternational maka kita

ditor. Bahkan suatu saat kita bisa

enjadi Review er

aran

List of Potential Referee

paper paling tidak 3-5 potential

paper, paling tidak 3-5 potential

(17)

Reviewer ???

Apakah dibayar?

TIDA

Apakah dibayar?

TIDA

Apakah tertulis di hala

Terus apa keuntungan

Dikenal oleh Editor Jou

Mendapat akses penuh

FULLTEXT SCIENCED

AK

aman jurnal?

TIDAK

n jadi Reviewer?

urnal

h ke SCOPUS

dan

(18)

First Fast Review (

Reviewed)

Evaluasi pertama

Î

skop

tidak sesuai maka langsun

j

l d

k

jurnal dengan skop yang

Bahasa

Î

English Gram

sangat tidak standard bia

langsung di-

reject

tanpa r

Artikel yang

Accepted

te

baik

Î

maka Reviewer a

b t lk

membetulkan grammarny

akan me-review atau mem

dimana letak English yang

(Before

Peer-p artikel

(

Jika skop jurnal

ng di-

reject

. Jadi pilihlah

i)

sesuai)

mmar

.

(Jika English grammar

sanya artikel tersebut

review lanjut)

etapi English- nya kurang

akan meminta penulis untuk

t t

i R

i

tid k

ya, tetapi Reviewer tidak

mberi komentar/ saran

(19)

Aspek-Aspek Pentin

Aspek Aspek Pentin

Originality

(asli karya sendiri ata

Biasanya

Referee

akan melakukan

terhadap artikel-artikel terdahulu

Penulis sebaiknya bisa

proof

kan

Penulis sebaiknya bisa

proof

-kan

lebih baik secara eksplisit di bagia

Discussion

.

Novelty

(dimana letak kontribusi

Kebaruan dari artikel sebaiknya di

teks artikel atau secara singkat di

merujuk kepada paper-paper yang

terbukti.

Metodologi

(tepat atau tidaknya

menyelesaikan masalah)

ng yang di-Review

ng yang di Review

au tidaknya hasil paper riset).

n search dan membandingkan

di jurnal.

keaslian dari teknologi yang diekspos

keaslian dari teknologi yang diekspos,

an

I ntroduction

dan ditegaskan lagi di

barunya di ilmu pengetahuan).

ibuktikan secara eksplisit di dalam

bagian pendahuluan Artikel harus

bagian pendahuluan. Artikel harus

g baru agar letak novelty-nya

(20)

Aspek-Aspek P

Harus memenuhi

kode etik

duplikasi terhadap riset ora

Presentasi hasil riset

har

dihasilkan harus menunjang

Kadang-kadang jika hasil ris

j

k

i

l

menunjang kesimpulan, pap

Signifikansi hasil riset

da

h

i

ifik

d

l bih b

harus signifikan dan lebih b

terdahulu serta menunjang

A

j

dikl i

di K

Apa saja yang

diklaim di K

di-support oleh data penelit

Penting Yang Di Review ……(2)

k penulisan

(tidak boleh

ng lain).

rus jelas dan data-data yang

g/ mendukung kesimpulan.

set tidak signifikan dan tidak

k

di

j

t

per akan di-

reject

alam paper. Hasil penelitian

b ik d

i i

t i

t

baik dari riset-riset yang

Kesimpulan.

K

i

l

h

b t l b t l

(21)

Keputusan Diterima

k

/A k l

Manuskrip/Artikel

Jumlah Review er

Î

hak Edi

Biasanya:

2- 3 Review er

Î

sa

Jika 1 Referee menyatakan Acc

dan 1 Referee lagi juga Accept

biasanya Editor akan memutus

Jika 1 Referee menyatakan Acc

menyatakan Rejected, biasanya

satu Review er lagi

, jika Acce

Accepted with major or minor r

Namun jika kedua Referee men

paper itu akan

Rejected

Teta

paper itu akan

Rejected

. Teta

jumlah reviewer 4 orang

a/Tidaknya Suatu

tor untuk menentukan

atu manuscript

cepted (with major/ minor revision)

ed (with major/ minor revision),

skan

Accepted w ith Revision

.

cepted dan 1 Referee yang lain

a Editor akan memilih

tambahan

epted, maka paper itu akan

revision.

(22)

Strategi Penyiapan A

Internasional ?

Penyiapan

Manuskrip Revisi

Stra

Perlu strategi dan

Stra

Penyi

Manu

e u st ateg da

berhati

berhati--hati dalam

hati dalam

menjawab

pertanyaan Reviewer

(23)

Contoh Rev

CONTO

“Review Resul

view Result

OH:

(24)

Teknik Menjawab Ko

Jawab komentar Reviewer

Berikan alasan yang saintif

menolak saran/permintaan

Jika menolak, maka sebaik

betul-betul saintifik dan jela

Jawaban komentar harus d

jelas di dokumen (halaman

CONT

“COVERING LETTER” DAN “JAWAB

omentar Reviewer

r secara singkat dan jelas

g

j

fik, baik itu menerima atau

n dari reviewer

knya diberikan alasan yang

as

dijelaskan letaknya yang

n, baris, paragraf)

TOH:

(25)

Contoh “ACCEPT

FROM E

CONTO

“Acceptance Lett

TANCE LETTER

EDITOR”

OH:

(26)

Contoh Artikel “

Un

CONTO

“Uncorrect

ncorrected Proof

”

OH:

(27)

HOW TO SUBMIT

TO INTERNATION

T A MANUSCRIPT

(28)

Bagaimana Ca

M

k i ?

Manuskrip?

Amer

MANUSCRIPT

SUBMISSION

ara Men-submit

Online Submission

(Elsevier Springer

N C

(Elsevier, Springer,

rican Chemical Society (ACS), Taylor & Francis)

No Cost

E-mail Attachment

(Elsevier Springer

No Cost

(Elsevier, Springer, Taylor & Francis)

Hardcopy Submission

(Elsevier, Springer,

T l & F i )

Costly

(29)

Daftar Alamat

El

i

htt

/ /

Elsevier

: http:/ / www

Springer

: http: / / www

American Chemical

http:/ / pubs.acs.org

p / / p

g

Wiley I nterscience

:

http: / / http: / / www3.int

Taylor & Francis

:

http: / / www taylorandf

http: / / www.taylorandf

Etc.

Jurnal Internasional

i

di

t

w.sciencedirect.com

w.springer.com

Society

:

terscience.wiley.com

(30)

Manuscrip

All T

t D

t i M

All Text Document in M

Covering Letter

(sing

i t)

point)

Text Manuscript

(Title

I t d

ti

M t i l

Introduction, Materials

Discussion, Conclusio

References Figures C

References, Figures C

Tables

(compact in on

Fi

(

fil

Figures

(separate file

is preferable)

pt Documents

MS W d

L t

MS Word or Latex

gkat & padat, to the

e, Abstract,

d M th d R

lt &

s and Method, Results &

on, Acknowledgment,

Caption)

ne file, no vertical line)

fi

TIFF f

(31)

Tahap-tahap O

p

Pilih menu REGISTER

account

baru sebaga

Lengkapi isian

di me

mungkin konfirmasi a

mungkin, konfirmasi a

email termasuk passw

Login sebagai Autho

login yang sudah di-cr

Online Submission

R untuk

register

i Author

nu Register selengkap

akan dikirim melalui

word.

or

menggunakan user

or

menggunakan user

(32)

Masukkan

Title of Manusc

Pilih

Article Type

: Researc

Pilih

Article Type

: Researc

Communication, Book Revie

Masukkan

Authors Name

d

Masukkan

Abstract

Masukkan

Key Words

Pilih

Document Classificat

Pilih

Document Classificat

ada)

Masukkan

Comment to Ed

ti

l) K d

k d

E

optional). Kadang-kadang E

Upload/Attach Documents

Letter, Manuscript, Tables,

,

p ,

,

diurutkan kembali.

Biasanya beberapa jurnal m

orang)

Jika semua document suda

document

akan di-create o

Cek dokumen PDF yang su

pada

Submission Approva

cript

ch Article Review Article Short

ch Article, Review Article, Short

ew, atau Erratum

dan urut-urutan Author Name

tions

(beberapa jurnal tidak

tions

(beberapa jurnal tidak

ditor

(bukan Covering Letter,

Edit

d

t di ilih

Editor dapat dipilih.

s Files

(sesuai urutan Covering

Figures). Jika tidak urut, bisa

g

)

,

minta saran

Reviewer

(4-5

ah diupload, maka

PDF

oleh server.

udah jadi, jika semua oke, klik

(33)

Contoh GUI O

(Elsevier)

Contoh

Journal of Food Eng

Alamat Submit:

http:/ / ees.e

Alamat Submit:

http:/ / ees.e

Online Submission

gineering

(Elsevier)

(34)

(35)

(36)

(37)

(38)

(39)

(40)

(41)

(42)

(43)

(44)

(45)

(46)

(47)

(48)

(49)

Contoh Online

Contoh:

I ndustrial & Engine

(ACS)

Î

Revised Manuscript

Alamat Submit:

http: / / pubs acs org/ paragonp

http: / / pubs.acs.org/ paragonp

e Submission (ACS)

eering Chemistry Research

Submission

(50)

Revised S

uu

(51)

(52)

(53)

(54)

(55)

(56)

(57)

(58)

(59)

(60)

Example o

Revised Ma

Contoh:

Chemical Engineer

Alamat Submit:

http: / / ees.els

Alamat Submit:

http: / / ees.els

of Final Decision:

anuscript (Elsevier)

ring Science

(Elsevier)

(61)

(62)

(63)

(64)

(65)

(66)

(67)

THANK YOU

SB

f

t

S

emoga

B

erman

faa

(68)

Profile:

Editorial/Re

Reviewer for international journal (

FO

Springer) (2007 – now)

Springer) (2007 now)

CH

COMMUNI CATI ONS

, Taylor & Franc

f l l ( Reviewer for international journal (

JO

Elsevier B.V.) (2006 – now)

JO

CHEMI STRY

S i P & El i

CHEMI STRY

, Science Press & Elsevie

Reviewer untuk jurnal Nasional (

JURN

Asosiasi Pendidikan Teknik Kimia I ndo

Chief Editor of

BULLETI N OF CHEM

CATALYSI S

, Chemical Engineering, D (http: / / www.tekim.ft.undip.ac.id/ crec/

Dewan Redaksi untuk journal Nasiona Teknik Kimia, Universitas Diponegoro

Wakil Ketua Dewan Redaksi Jurnal

TE

Wakil Ketua Dewan Redaksi Jurnal

TE

Diponegoro (2007 – sekarang) (http:/

eviewer Experiences

OOD & BI OPROCESS TECHNOLOGY

,

HEMI CAL ENGI NEERI NG

cis) (2007 – now)

OURNAL OF FOOD ENGI NEERI NG

,

OURNAL OF NATURAL GAS

B V ) (2005 )

er B.V.) (2005 – now)

NAL TEKNI K KI MI A I NDONESI A

), onesia (APTEKI NDO) (2006 – now)

I CAL REACTI ON ENGI NEERI NG &

Diponegoro University. (2006– present)

/ bcrec

al Terakreditasi (

REAKTOR

), Jurusan (2007-now)

EKNI K

Fakultas Teknik Universitas

EKNI K

, Fakultas Teknik, Universitas