Response of the common bean to nitrogen

(1)

Elias Franco

*

, Carlos Alberto de Bastos Andrade, Carlos Alberto Scapim e Paulo

Sérgio Lourenço de Freitas

Departamento de Agronomia, Universidade Estadual de Maringá, Av. Colombo, 5790, 87020-900, Maringá, Paraná, Brasil. *Autor para correspondência. E-mail: [email protected]

! " " # $

" " % " # ! " # $ "

# ! #& ' # " " " " ' " " " $ "

# ! ( # ' # " " ' )

*+ , - * , . - * , . / - * , / . 0 - *1 , . + */ , + 2 & +

3 4 */ # ! ( ' " 3 " " 5 *+

3 6 $ 7 ' # " " 8

# 5 # # 9 ' # " " # 9 " : # ") ;

' # $ " ' #& # ! ' # " " ! " "

' # " 3 < = > > ? " " ' " " "

@ $ " ' #& " ; ' # @ "

# " " ' # " 3 < > > < # ! ' #

@ ! " "" + ! " " " ' # " = ?

! ' " " ' "

A ! # ( "

' # " ! ! "

! "

" # 3 ' # 9 ##

"B" " " B & " " " # " & #

" C ## " & ' # *& ' & " C 2 C "

& " " " ' " '' " " # & "

## * " C " ' ## C") *+ , - * , . - * , . / - *

, / . 0 - *1 , . + */ ,+ 2 & + _{' 3 3} _# _{*/ C "}

" C D & & " 5 *+ ' & 3 6 7 C " #

" C & & & 8 " *& 9 # 2"

5 # " C " # 3 < = > > ?

" # ' 5 B ' # " ' # # ' # C

# ' '' " C ' # ' B # ' 5

' " # B # ' # ' 3 < > > E C ' #

# ' " & "" " C ## " = ? ' #

"& C " ' '' "

$ # ! " A ' # 9 " # # ' # "

B #

# " " #

" " F" " 4" <

" G " "

! # ! %" " " %" $ "

# ! # '

H " " " " (

" ' G G

# ' "" $ "

" ' #& " " " ' (

( "" " G " #

" # " " ' #& " # " "

# " " # " '# "

" ! 68 /7 <

# G " + 2 & +

( "! "" " #

' 68 /7 " ! (

'# ( " ! "

I " #$ G $ " "

(2)

%&' (

' J G J 68 #

+00 7 " ! ' ; "

# ! E G # % " !

' # 5 68 #

+00 " & +0017 ' # G

( ' " K/6'# "

# " " # : 9 6+0 /77

# " K 6+00+7 $

1 2 + _{"" "} _{' #& "} _#

6+00/7 ' G # " ' ( "

( " #$ ' #& "

# ! # " @ &

! " " 4 " G '

I ( '

6 7 #& G " # " 9 "

# 9 $ # ' #

# ; G ""! ( 9

" @ " #

! " 4 '

' 5 ! " F ( G "

> "" : 6+00 7

L ( % # '

( $ "" " ( $

" " " " $ 6K " #

+0 8 /7

( " ' I

# 5 G ! 5 ' " " " "

" M " G !

$ " " '; " 6K +00+7

4 # ( " " " " '

( N " # ' GO(

# " " " ! !

" ! ' !

6K " # +0 7

8 6 /7 # ' 4"

" P " " G " " "

9 " ! 1+ 6/ L7 # "

& " " " " " % # ! (

(" " " " " '

4 " # " G " # " #

" " # " # # ! >Q3

)+ 6A " +0 07 ( "

" ' %" # " ( ' 5 !

" # A " 6+0 07

4 " " # 9 " ' 6 17 '

# ' " # " " "

" " ( # # '

# " G # !

( ! '# "

" !

! " " " "; "

" 5 " 6 17

# # ! + +/

2 & + ₍ _'

" " # #

' 9 # ' ! # 9 '

D > > # ! $

' # 9 " 8 1 6G ' #& '# #

" 1 L " # "7 " 8 0

6 " M " '# " " 1 L "

# "7 " " # " 5

++ + ' #& " ' # # " " K/6

'# " 1 L " # "7 >

" # G # ! (

" ' " ' " " # ! '

@ " # @ " "

"" + " " 3

& '# ( ! " #

6 17 9 5

! # " !

# " " ' % !

" ""! %" # "

G #& "F

G #& "

;' " # " !

" # " G ' " %

# ! ( " "

" ""M " = &# 6+00 7 " ' "

" # ! $ ! ' !

" G # ! "F 9

' " M " G

G ' " # 6 #

7 " # ' "

#& " $ " # ' "

R " " G !

G # "

# 9 # F" % " # ! #

" ' ( ' $ 4" "

" # " A > 9 " 6 7

G " $ 1 L (

G $ $ # " '; " #

# " # 5

" " " # " 4"" " "

" G " " "! " ' "

G $ $ ' 1

" #& ' #

" " ' # D<K S %"

" " ( " $ " # ! G

# ! " # "

# ! " "

" " "

8 6 ""! ' #& ' # # 7 "

(3)

) * + " %&,

5 ' 9 ;

T" ' " "U 6 ! 7

" Q Q 1

: 9 4" # > #$ ; # 4" #

# K " <K " !

4" < 6 V - 1+ VW P C

-/ 7 # !

# "" ' ! = $ >' 6D < K +00 7

; 5 ""

! # # ;

G # G ' "

# $ " : +

0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40

01/08/04 31/08/04 30/09/04 30/10/04 29/11/04 29/12/04 28/01/05

Período (meses)

T

em

p

er

at

u

ra

(

oC

)

0 50 100 150 200 250

P

re

ci

p

it

aç

ão

(

m

)

.

Prec T mím T máx

( - . * ; 5

! # # ; "

1 <K H " ' " # 6 " #F < 7

" # 5 # ' 4

6+0007 # "" ' " 3 "" # 8 #&

'$

" # #

' 5 # ' #

# F G " ' "" " # " "

" # " ' " # "

# $ ) "" , 0 2 + _' _,

/ 2 + _{" #} _{, ++} ₂ + _{# ,} ₂ +

G # " G ; "" ' # 9

# " # 4

6+00 7 " E 6E 7 , / - E 6> ># 7 , 1

+-#..._, _# _{- E}._. _#..._, _0/ _#

- > .._{, 1} _# _- .._, _#

- =._, _# _{< , ++} _{- N}

, / # >*> , + / # 8L

, / / - > , 1 - "

" : , 1 - ? , +

- > , 1 ,

4 ' ! " " # " # " ! '

# 9 # 9 G " !

" " " # / / L ! ' "'

"" ' " 2 < 1

& + ₂ ₌ _& + _'

' "' # " ># < "" "

# " " ! "

" ' # 9 Q+ Q

#& Q +Q 1 # # 9 '

D<K S # > &

" 6* DD7

# 5 # # 9 ' #

" # 9 " " " M "

# ' ' # 9 " "

# G '

# " 6"

" @# 7

" " " " ' ' " "

' ) *+ , - * , . - * , ./ - * ,

/ .0 - *1 , .+ */ , + 2 & + _{3 4}

*/ # ! ( ' "

3 " " 5 " & 6*+7

3 ' $ ' #

" " 8

6 ""! ' #& ' # # 7 "

" # : 9 6+0 /7 '

# F5 " ' # " ' '

' # " " '; " # "

! ' # 9 " # "

" " ' " N B# 1 "

+ + 2 + _" _" _# _# _"

& " ' # 9 # ! 1 A

& + _:# _{9 '} _N _# _' _{# !}

, 1 A+ _G _' _"

" 8 6 ""! ' #& ' # # 7

< " ' " ""

# # # " '

# 9 # 9 F"

# 9 ! # # " '# "

# 9 ' * 9 # 1 "

1 & +

" # " ' " ; " " " # & "

/ " " " " "

1 " " +

" " # " # @ #

# ' " # " " # & " "

5 # " 1 " " 5 " "

@ # # 1

" ;" " " " ' ) ;

' # $ " ' #& ' #

" " !

# ! ' # X % ' # 6 :7 " '

" ' "

6 17 G " " # " " ' #& "

G # " #& " " @ #

# " '# " 6K/7

H " " # " " (" ' #& " ' # # "

(4)

%/0 (

# < " ' #& " " ("

" " ' #; # 5 #

Y' V & " " "

' # " ' " "

" " # # " " " '

/1 > # ! ' ""

" " " " ' # " ' # # "

" " $ "" " # " ' #& "

# ' " # # ' # #

' ; ' # 6D :7 G '

"! # ' #

# # # 6 7 ' "

N " 6 7

4 # ! " " 3 < = > >

? " " ' # 9 "

# " K 6+00+7 G " "

# " " ' #& " " # " # "

' # /1 > $ "" "

" ' < # 9 !

" " ' # " " " ' #& " G

# " ' 6 17 F"

"" # "" # ""

" ! @ # 9 !

; #F " ' " "

" " " " 4" " " "

# ' # " " G

' # " # #

6+00 7 G 3 # 9 !

$ = & #- < = > > ?

" ! ; #F

" " 5 ") < Z # - = Z

' & - > > ?

" ' " ! J

! " " # " " ' 5 " ; "

# " ' #& " ' '

# 9 K 6+00+7

: " 9 # " " @ #

" # " "

" " ! ) @

" # 638<7 @ ! "

63P87 "" + ! " 6 + P7 3

' # " ' " #F K0

6 " " " " #

: 9 +0 /7 ' #

! " 6<K H7 % #& " "

# " @ # " ! " ' " " " "

"" " ' " + L

5 ""! ) , 6+ [ 7Q 6+

7 G ) , "" - , ""

- [ , 6L7- [ ,

! , 6+ L7 " # M "

# " & 6< <7 ' "

" @ " # " ' "

@ # # " ! #&

F" # # ! " " "

# " " ;" " !

> " 6+0 7 # 9 " 4P

6K S +7 [:8 " M "

" $ " " " ' ' "

# " = ; # 1L

" " " " # " " I $

" ' #& 6 :7 ; ' # 6D :7

# ! # " & +_{6< <7} _@ _"

# 638<7 @ ! "

63P87 "" + ! " 6 + P7

6<K H7 " * # +

" " G & ' " D : :

38< <K H ! ' " "

' " " " < < 3P8

+ P 6* # +7

" " " " # " " I " "

' # " 3 < = > > ?

" * #

. K " # " I # ! # " 6< <7 ; ' # 6D :7 $ " ' #& " 6 :7 @ " # 638<7 @ ! " 63P87 "" + ! " 6 + P7 < ! " 6<K H7 ' ! " " $ " # ! ! # ' 4" <

Q 1

X " $ "

: ! P A

< < D : : 38< 3P8 + P <K H

* 1 1+0/ +" ₁ _001\ _++\ ₊ _{/ \} ₊₊ ₀₊ " _{+ +0} " ₊ _{0 /} _\

N# " + 0 / + + / + 1 + 0 ++ 0

K "; + 1 + 0/++ / + 0/ 1 / +/ 0+ / 0 01+

" , ! " ' # " :- \ " ' # " : 6 ≤ 17

& K " # " I " " ' # " 3 < = > > ? ' ! " " $ "

# ! ! # ' 4" < Q 1

X " $ "

: ! P A

3 < = > > ?

* 1 + 0 \ 0 + 0 \ 0 /"

/ \ 1/ / / \ \ / "

1 1"

N# " + +0 11 + 0 1 + 0/ 1 +

K "; / / / 0 1 / +/ + 0// 00 0 / 1 00

(5)

) * + " %/.

" " G & ' " " "

' # " 3 < > > 3 !

' " " ' " " "

" " ' # " = ? 6* # 7

" $ " " ;" " # " ' !

" " $ " # ! !

# ' "

* #

4 # ! @ # " &

6< <7 ! & ' " "

3 G " ' ; ' # 6D :7

" " G ' " "

" " " # " 6D :7 '

" " " G " "

" " + 2 & + ₃ _" _"

# " ' " &

G # G 1 2 & + ₃ _# _"

" G " " # " $ "

D : " 6' + / + 7 ' "

G " " "

6* # 7

4 # ! % $ " ' #& " 6 :7 "

" # " G " #

( " # " + 2 & +

3 G " " # " " " $

1 2 & + _{3 6*} _# _{7 4"" "} _{" #} _"

G 3 " " # G 1 2 &

+ _{3 '} _{" '} _@ _# _$

" ' # " " " ; " " "

" G " G "

3 > " ' G " "

# # $ I

& "" # ! 3 " " "

# " # " " # "

"" ' #& "

" " 6* # 7 G & '

" ' " @

" # 638<7 " $" " 38<

2 & + ₃ _" _"

" G " " " .

-./ - / .0 - .+ + 2 & + _{3 '}

" - ++ 1/- ++ 1- + /

+ / L I # !

( $ # !

( G " # #

" > " " " # "

# H " 6+00 7

X @ ! " 63P87

" ! ' '# # " " 6* #

7 4 " " # 9 " 6+00 7

# ! 3 ! ' '

3P8 " " " " "

# 3P8 " '

'# ( " " "

# F

4 # ! % "" + ! " 6 + P7

" ! ' '# # " "

# 9 " * " " # " " F5 "

1 1 G $ # " #

6* # 7

4 " ;" " # "

"" " " $ "

M " # " " # " "

; " 5 " " ; ""

" ( " M " " ; "

; " ! " G

'# " "! M "

" " " "

> ' " ' : + "

( " ! F" "

" ; '# " '

' " X % ; 5

" ; '# "

' " G ; "

" " " ' ' " 5

# " " ; '# " ! '

' # " " "

6 7

" ' # " " F5 + > G

" >

1 > " ! " "

! # @ '# "

@ " G " #

/ 8 # " $ " # ! # " 6< <7 ; ' # 6D :7 $ " ' #& 6 :7 @ " # 638<7 @ ! " " 63P87 "" + ! " 6 + P7 ! " 6<K H7 ' ! " "

$ " # ! ! # ' 4" < Q 1

> ;" " * $ Q " "

< +

D : : 38< 3P8 + P <K H

*+ +00 /// 0/ + 1 1 + 1

* . + /// + 0 + + / 11

* . / + + / ++ 1 + 0+

* / . 0 + 111 + ++ + 1 + 10 +

*1 .+ + + 0 + + /1 1

*/ + +/ 000 + / + / 0 + 11

$ + 0 0 1 + / / + 1 1 + 0 0

> 8 6L7 ++ + 1 + /+ + 0+ ++ / +/ +

H 1 / + 1 1 + + 0 /

(6)

%/& (

! " 6<K H7 '

" " " " '

" " " " G " "

./ - / .0 - .+ + 2 & + ₃ _G

G " " # ! " " "

. 2 & + _{3 6*} _# ₇

2 & + ₃ _" _{" G}

" " " ./

-/ .0 - .+ + 2 & + _{3 '} _" _"

++ +1/ +11 / + 0 L "

4"" " " # " I # !

3 # " "

" G # " #

" " # '

9 ! # D"

" 5 # # ! " ; "

M " F" ( '

G " ;

! ' " !

# "" " +0 $ ' " '# "

9 " " # 5 ! 6: +7

> " " " # " " #& "

= &# 6+00 7 # 6 7

6 7

" # " $ " " " ' # " 3 < =

> > ? " * #

4 # ! 3 ' # " " G

' " " "

' " .+ 2 & + _{3 "}

" / . 0 - . / - 6 . + 7 2 &

+ ₃ _" _{" ' #} _" _{3 '} _" _"

. + - / . 0 - . / 2 & + ₃ _{# !}

% ' 5 ; " # # "

K 6+00+7 G $ 1 2 + _$ _"

' #& " + - . 2 & + _{3 "} _"

' ' 5 ; E

3 ' #& ' ! " " " " "

6* # 7 K " # " #& $ '

" # H " 6+00 7

6+00 7 6 7

4 ! " "

" G " " G " "

' # " ' " " " ' 5 ; */

, + 2 & + _{3 G} _"

' 5 ; ' " " " "

# D<K S 3 " " " *

6 . 2 & + ₃₇ _{*+ 6 2 &} + ₃₇ _"

" ' " 6* # " 7 R

" G * */ !

& ' " ' # " 3

& ' # ! % 4""

" # G G 3

# 9 */ 6+ 2 & + ₃₇ _#

" ' " # 9 '

; G * 6 . 2 & + ₃₇ _' _!

" # > ' A > 9 "

6 7 G 3 $ # %"

" # # 9 ! & $ 1 L

G ' $ %" " "!

" ' " I 3 "

" # $ " #

# # 6+0 7 3 $ J

" # $ $ " 5

" " " " $ "

"$ " " " " # % #

" & 6+0017 3 " # "; "

; " ! "

' ! " '# ;' " ' ;' " '# (

3 ! ! " # @

'# " " # ! " " $

" # 6+00/7 6 7

8 6 /7

3 G " ' ' # < " '

" ' 5 ; " K

6+00+7 G $ 1 Z 2 + _$ _"

' #& " " " " & *+6 7

* 6 . 2 & + _{37 <} _" _" _"

" " ' 5 ' 5 ; " G

'F"' " ' "" # !

' ! " " # " : 6* # 7

K " # " #& ' 'F"'

6+00 7 " G " " " M "

" " # " "" # !

K 6+00+7 " & 6+0017

" ! 3

" '; # G ' " ! <

' "" # A " P #& 6+00 7

"" 6=7 " ' #& " ! '

' ! " " " 3 " $ " # !

"" 4 " " " " "

' # " "" ' 5 ' 5 ;

" K 6+00+7 G $ 2 +

$ " ' #& " 6* # 7 4" " #

; " G # # 9

"" F5

$ " " # 9 " # D < K G

' / 2 & + _# _6+00/7 _# _G

# " ' " = ' " '# "

" ! ! "

" & 6+0017 = # " "; "

; " 9

@ " #$ " # "

4 # ! % " ! = # '

' ! # ! 3 "

' " " " '

# " ' # " ! =

(7)

) * + " %//

% 8 # " $ " " " ' # " 3 < = > > ? '# " ' 6 " K/7 ' ! " " $ " # ! ! # ' 4" < Q 1

3 "

* $ Q " " 3 < = > > ?

6 2 + _{' #& 7} ₆ ₂ + _{' #& 7}

*+ + + 1/ +1 1 + + ++ 1 /

* . / +/ / 01 + / / /

* . / 1 + +/ 0 0 + + / 0 +

* / . 0 11 / +/ / + 0 ++ 0 /

*1 .+ 10 + + +/ 1+ + / + // +/ 00

*/ + + 0 / + 1 + 1 0 1/ +

$ 1 + +1 + 1 ++ + 0

> 8 6L7 1 / + + + + 00 + 1 1 1

H 1 0 1 /1 + 01 + 1

$ " " " " # # ! ' " ; # 1L # # " =

# 6> 7 " ' #& " " "

" ' ' 5 ; "

K 6+00+7 G $ + 1 2 + _$

" ' #& " < $ & ' " '

*+ 6 2 & + ₃₇ _" _" _"

< " " G # !

! " " ' # " > '

" " *+ 6 2 & + _{37 6*} _# ₇ _G

$ G "" ' 9 ""

G "" # ' "" "

( " # 9 G

" # ! ( K

6+00+7 A " P #& 6+00 7 " &

6+0017 4 # ! % " ! # 9!

' 3 " !

3E.

$" 6 7 " ' #& " '

" & 6 ' 5

' 5 ; 7 " " " " G

" " " " " ' # " "

' 5 ; " K 6+00+7 G $

1 1 2 + _$ _" _{' #& " 6*} _# ₇

G $ G ""

' 9 "" G "" # ' ""

" ( " #

9 # ! ( K

6+00+7 A " P #& 6+00 7 " &

+0017 " ! " '

9 # " 3 ' #

' ; $' % " !

68 # +00 7

6> 7 " ' #& " '

* 6 )/ 7 " " "

* " " " ' ' 5 ;

" K 6+00+7 G $ + 2 +

$ ' #& " 6* # 7 ' !

9 "' ' " ! "

J " " 3

" #& " G " ! ! '

# 6+00 7 " G

! ' # 9

> " ' #& " *& " 6+00 7

' G & '# ( ' (

' ' " ! >

" ' #& " > " # " G

' # > ' G # (

' 3 3E. _{# !} _{% '} _{3 3}

" ! ! # ! " & 6+0017

# G # " # 3

' (

9 6? 7 " ' #& " ! '

" " " " " " '

' 5 ; " K 6+00+7 G $ +

1 2 + _$ _" _{' #&} _6* _# ₇

*& " 6+00 7 # '# (

' ( ' ' "

! ? " ' #& " " " ' # "

? ' " G ' # (

' 3 3E. _{# !} _{% '} _{3 3}

" ! ! # ! " & 6+0017

$ G @ ?

' G ' 3 $ 3E . _{# !}

3 6+00 7 " G

! ( ? "

' #& "

(" 6 7 " ' #& " ! '

" " ' 5 ;

" # " K 6+00+7 $

+1 + 2 + _$ _" _{' #& "} _G

" # " ' * 6 ./ 2 & +

37 */ 6+ 2 & + _{37 6*} _# ₇

*& " 6+00 7 # '# (

' ( ' ' "

! " ' #& " " " ' # "

' " G ' # (

' 3 3E. _{# !} _{% '} _{3 3}

" ! ! # ! " & 6+0017

$ G @

# ' ! G ' 3 ' '

3E. _{# ! % 3}

' # " " #

(8)

%/% (

" #

"" " ' #& " ; ' #

@ " # ""

' # ( #

$" ' # ! " " "

# " (

3HK H4 > N : # " # " 9

" # " P " # '

N ";# 1 ++ 0

3HK H4 > N P C & B

# # "

5' +1 +10 1

3HK H4 S N D '# ( ( 9F

# ( " " # ! #

" " ' 8 " 1

1 /1 0 +00

3HK H4 S N K " " # '

% # ! ' # # ( %" M "

" # A "

00 1 +00

K: 4' " # " " " "

( ' # )

> 3PK4 3 >D 3 A H4 <4 X[D H4

:4DS] 1 P I P I ) 4

>3< : 1

N43D3> <

M " " " S #) :

> < E ! "# $

$ "% < ) : #G +0

> D3D * - :K 3> > : 5 ! #F

( ) 8D4DK > 64 7 & '#) " "

" # 4" " 8 " ) [:8 +00

+1 +

4 NK < 4 " N " # < "G "

( ) K S )

4 >3< +00

4 NK < 4 " N " # < "G "

* + , "# K S )

4 >3< +000

:4K3^3H4? :

, ' 6 A 7 > # ) >D * +0 /

D < K D " J <

+ A ) D +00

6H + 7

=D4EA S > K " & " ' #B

" * < 1 1

/ +00

A K > N4? W K N # !

"F# '# #

#& " " # * I #

6 P7 * 8 " / /

A <4 6* 7 ( , !

< # ) - < 'F" +0 0

A <4 - P[DAE4K 4 A K - , .

) " " J " #

! < # ) +00 6 # $ 7

A 8 A* 4 "#

! < # ) > " +0

A 8 A* 4 "#

) ; " # M " < ) < 'F"

+00

KD * 4 S & '#) # ! A )

D < K

K >E34K E ( ,

A ) < "" +001

4DK : H " " $ " # ! (

' # #

N ";# 1

AD84DK D < 3 ! # ' 5 ! #F

( K [S K 6> 7

, ' < ) < ' " +00/ +/0

+/

K DS N 8 & + "# < ) < 'F"

+00+

KDN4DK S[3D K S D * /

8 " ) [:8 +

K A4 > 0 "# + "# , ' < )

< ' " +0 6> # $ 7

DA8 * K N ! "; "

" " # ' " "

# * 1 + +

DA84DK < - H >43 4" " "

# " = " " 3 # ' !

) K4[3D] 3 >D 3 A H <4 X[D

H4 :4DS] +00 A A )

D +00

DA84DK < ! '

# " # " ""! # "

N ";# + 1

D 4< K " #F < H " ; #

)1 22333 + 4 "" ) + 1

K ** K < K " " '

" # # (

* 1 + 0 0/

*E 3 > S 4'' ' ' # 9 '

E ' & #2 " # & 9 " & &

C & & " & " 2 ' 5

0 <& # # & +/ 0 1 / +00

8 A4 : K & ) I

" # " " # " A ") 4" #

P ' [ " +00

8D4DK > ! # # ) 8D4DK >

64 7 & '# 8 " ) [:8 / ++1 +

& + 6 78 799: