Teaching in the Multilevel Classroom
M
elinda Robertscomes to Pearson Education from Southern California, where she has an extensive background in teaching ESL to adults. In addition to her ten years of classroom experience, she has developed curriculum for EL Civics and CBET (a California community-based ESL/family literacy program). She also served as a program facilitator for a collaborative model CBET program between a community college and a K-12 district. In addition, she served as a mentor teacher and was involved in the organization and development of trainings and workshops addressing instruction, classroom
management, methodology, and curriculum development. She has presented at the local, state and national levels. Melinda has a TESOL Certificate from UC Irvine and her MATESOL from Azusa Pacific University.
National Educational Consultant
Inmyroleasthenationaltrainerfor PearsonEducation,Ihavetheprivilegeof travelingaroundthecountryandworking withteachersineverytypeofprogram -communitycolleges,adultschools,private languageschools,prisons,andcommunity-basedprogramsinlibrariesandchurches. Inalloftheseprograms,Ihavediscovereda commonquestion:Isthereaneasier,more effectivewaytomanageinstructioninthe multilevelclassroom?Theresponseisnot ascomplicatedasonemightimagine,butit doesrequireanexaminationofavarietyof factors.
What makes an ESL
classroom “multilevel”?
Thestudent’seducationalbackgroundin his/herfirstlanguage.Studentsarrivein anESLclassroomwithvariededucational backgrounds.Somestudentshavehadlittle ornoeducation.Othershavecompleted theequivalentofourjuniorhighorhigh school,whilestillothershaveattended tradeschool,collegeoruniversity,and evendoctorateprograms.Asliteracyis tiedtoeducationalbackground,students inthesameESLclassroomcanrangefrom illiterate/low-literatetohighacademic proficiency.
Thestudent’scomfortwiththeRoman alphabet.Literacyproficiencynotonly appliestoreadingandwritinginone’s firstlanguage,butalsotoanESLstudent’s familiaritywiththeRomanalphabet.While Chinese,Korean,Egyptian,orPersian studentsmaybehighlyliterateintheir nativelanguages,theymustlearnnew alphabetcharacterswhenlearningEnglish. Thechallengeoflearninganewsetof alphabetcharacterscanaffectastudent’s abilitytoparticipateoptimallyintheESL classroom.
Theculturalexpectationseachstudent hasregardingtheroleoftheteacher. StudentsfromoutsidetheUnitedStates mayhavedifferentexpectationsforthe
classroom.Manycountries,forexample, stillconductclassesthatare100percent teacherdirected,(i.e.,thestudentssit andlistenwhiletheteacherinstructs). Studentswiththiskindofeducational backgroundmaynotfeelcomfortable participatinginacommunicativeESL classroom.Thestudentsmayeventhinkthe teacheris“bad”forrequiringthemtoask questions,participateinclassroomgames andactivities,workwithpartnersorin smallgroups,orself-orpeer-correcttheir assignments.
Thestudent’spersonality.Astudent’s individualpersonalityisanotherfactorthat affectsinstruction.Personalityplaysahuge roleinastudent’swillingnesstoparticipate inactivities,takerisksusingEnglish, andbecomepartofthelargerclassroom community.
Thestudent’sgoals.Researchonstudent persistenceisclearthatthemorespecific astudent’sgoal(s),themoremotivated thatstudentistoattendclass.Students,for example,whoarecomingtolearnEnglish sotheycanhelptheirchildrenwiththeir homework,orsotheycangetabetterjob, willbemoremotivatedtocometoclass thanthosewhoarecomingsimply“to learnEnglish.”
Thestudent’sage.MostESLclassesare madeupofadultsranginginagefrom18to 80ormore.Generallyspeaking,theolder thestudent,themorechallengingitwill beforthestudenttoretaininformation. Personalityandmotivation,however,tend tohaveagreaterimpactonacquisition thanage.
Thestudent’slearningstyle.Ateacher mustbecognizantofthethreelearning styles-audio,visual,andtactile-and ensurethatclassroominstructionand activitiesaccommodatethesedifferent stylesoflearning.Ofcourse,agoodstudent bookandteacher’seditiondoesthis automatically.
Thestudent’sstatusinUnitedStatesculture.Astudent’s personalsituationcanalsocontributetoamultilevelclassroom environment.HasthestudentcometotheUnitedStatesasa refugee?Isheorsheherealoneorwithalargergroupoffriendsor family?Isthestudentpoor?Middleclass?Quitewealthy?Doesthe studenthavelegalstatus,orisheorsheundocumented?
Thestudent’saccesstoEnglishoutsidetheESLclassroom.
Finally,thenumberofopportunitiesstudentshavetouseEnglish outsidetheclassroomcanimpactinstruction.Whilesomestudents mayliveinaclosedcommunitywhereeveryoneeverywhere speakstheirfirstlanguage,othersdonotandmustuseEnglishto communicateineverydaysituationsand/oratwork.Ofcourse, themorelanguagelearnersuseEnglishintheireverydaylives,the morequicklytheiracquisitionandproficiencyimproves.
Levels of Proficiency in the
Multilevel Classroom
Whenplanninginstructionforamultilevelclass,teachersmust firstconsiderthevariedproficiencylevelsoftheirstudents.In general,manystudentsperformatthesameorsimilarlevel; however,therearealwaysstudentswhoperform“below”leveland otherswhoperform“above”level.
Below-level.Thesestudentsarestrugglingtokeepupwith instruction.Theyneedextratimetocompleteactivitiesandare oftendependentonpeersupporttobesuccessful.Thesestudents mayhavefeelingsofinadequacyandlowself-esteemandare usuallyverycognizantofthefactthateveryoneelseinclassis learningmorerapidlythantheyare.Below-levelstudentsareat riskbecausetheyoftenbecomefrustratedandblamethemselves fortheirinabilitytolearnmoreefficiently.
At-level.Thesestudentsaredoingwellwiththeircurrentlevelof instructionandareprogressingastheyshould.
Above-level.Thesestudentsmayhavemorelanguageproficiency thantheat-levelstudents,orthesestudentsmaybeableto“getit” morequicklythantheirclassmates.Above-levelstudentsareat riskbecausetheycanbecomefrustratedwiththeteacherfornot providingmorechallenginglessons.Theycanalsobecomebored ordisruptivewhilewaitingfortheotherstudentsto“catchup.”
Thefourlanguageskills.Adiscussionoflevelsofproficiency cannotbecompletewithoutfirstaddressingthatastudent’s abilitiesineachofthefourlanguageskills-reading,writing, speaking,andlistening-mayalsobeatvaryinglevels.Thesame studentcanbeanabove-levelspeaker,anat-levellistener,an at-levelreader,andabelow-levelwriter.Ateachermustbe cognizantofeachstudent’sstrengthsandweaknessesduring instructionandwhenassigningtasks.
Grouping Strategies in the Multilevel Classroom
Managingaclassroomofstudentsatthesedifferentlearninglevels canpresentachallengeforinstructors;however,accordingtoa CALPROarticleonmanagingthemultilevelclassroom,“Theuseof groupingstrategieshasbeenfoundtobeaneffectivemanagement
toolinmultilevelsettingstoprovideefficientuseofteacherand studenttime.Studentscanassisteachother,whichfreesthe teachertoworkwithindividualsorsmallgroups.”
Therearefourwaystogroupstudents:
•Pairwork(twostudentsworkingtogether)
•Groupwork(threetotenstudentsworkingtogether)
•Teamwork(teamsofstudentsworkingtogetherincompetition withotherteams)
•Whole-classwork(theentireclassparticipatinginanactivity) TheroleoftheESLteacherisnotonlytodeliverinstruction, butalsotoorchestratethepairing,grouping,andteaming-upof students.Inthemultilevelclassroom,thisprocessisespecially criticalforthebelow-levelandabove-levelstudents.
Studentscanbepairedandgroupedaseither“like-ability” or“cross-ability.”Like-abilityiswherestudentsofthesame proficiencylevelworktogether.Thebenefitoflike-abilitymatching isthatsimilarneedsofthestudentscanbeaddressed.Cross-ability iswherestudentsofdifferentproficiencylevelsworktogether.The benefitofcross-abilitymatchingisthatthehigher-levelstudents canhelpthelower-levelstudents.
Teamworkisalwaysacross-abilitygrouping(itwouldbedifficult forbelow-levelteamstoeverwin),asiswhole-classwork,byits verynature.Withpairworkandgroupwork,however,teachers candecide,baseduponthetask,whethertomatchstudentsby like-abilityorcross-ability,aswellaswhotomatchwithwhom. Asidebenefitofongoingandvariedmatchingisthebuildingof astrong,vibrant,comfortable,safelearningenvironmentand classroomcommunity.
Multilevel Instructional Strategies
Therewasatimewhenapopularmodelformultilevelinstruction requiredtheteachertochooseatopicandthendevelopdifferent lessonswithdifferentobjectivesforthedifferentproficiencylevels inhis/herclassroom.Theteachermovedfromgrouptogroup, ineffect,managingathree-ringcircus.Thelessonplanningwas overwhelmingandexhausting,oftenrequiringtheteacherto develophis/herowncurriculumandhandouts.
Todaythereismoresupportforthemultilevelinstructor, includingteacher’seditionsandready-madereproducibles, whichcanbeeasilyadaptedtomultilevelinstruction.Insteadof creatingdifferentlessonswithdifferentobjectivesforthedifferent proficiencylevels,teacherscan“teachtothemiddle”andthen assigndifferent,appropriatelyleveledtasks.
Lesson Planning
Begin the lesson with the whole class together
Beginningthelessonwiththewholeclasstogetherprovidesa foundationfortheleveledtasksthatwillfollow.Throughout thepreviewandpresentportionofthelesson,theteacher intermittentlylowersandraisesinstructiontokeepthebelow-levelandabove-levelstudentsinterested.Sincemostlessonsin
beginning-levelESLclassesbeginwithlearningthevocabularythat willbeusedintheunit,itiseasytostartalessonwiththewhole classtogether.Thenaturalprocessofpreviewing,presenting,and practicingthevocabularylendsitselfperfectlytowhole-class, multilevelinstruction.
ssign leveled tasks using a variety of groupings
Duringthepracticeandevaluationstagesofthelesson,students’ tasksareleveledaccordingtoproficiencyandlanguageskill.If theobjective,forexample,istocompleteanorderform“froma mail-ordercatalogcompany,astudentcanlearnskillsoffollowing writteninstructions,fillingoutforms,anddoingvariousmath operations”(Cowels,1997).Theleveledtasks“canbevariedto suittheskilllevelsandinterestsofthelearner:onepersonmight orderasingleitem,likeahat,whileanothermighttakeonthevery challengingtaskofmeasuringwindowsandorderingcurtainsof thecorrectsize”(Cowels,1997).Itishelpfultohaveateacher’s edition,whichprovidesavarietyofexpansionactivitiesforeach lesson.Theseexpansionactivitiescanbeinvaluableresourcesfrom whichtochoosespecifictaskstoassigntodifferent-leveledgroups. Inthediscussionthatfollows,wewilllookmorecloselyathowto useboththestudent’sbookandtheteacher’seditiontodothis.
End the lesson with the whole class together
Intheapplicationstageofyourlesson,bringthewholeclassback togetherforreviewandtoassignawhole-classactivity.
Using Your Core Text to Develop Leveled Tasks
Itiseasytoleveldifferenttypesofactivitiesusingthestudentbook. Thissectionlooksatlevelingconversationexercises,writingand dictationactivities,andlisteningtasks.
Leveling conversations
Thetypicalconversationtaughtinamultilevelenvironmentmight looksomethinglikethis:
A.I’mgoingtothesupermarket.Whatdoweneed? B.Pleasegetsome__________.
A.__________?Allright.Anythingelse? B.Yes.Wecanprobablyusesome__________ andsome__________.
A.__________and__________?Sure.Noproblem!
Teachtheentireconversationtothewholeclassbyusingparroting techniques.Thenhavestudentspracticeinlike-abilitypairs.The below-levelpairspracticeonlythefirstpart:
A.I’mgoingtothesupermarket.Whatdoweneed? B.Pleasegetsome__________.
Havetheat-levelpairspracticethewholeconversation.
Havetheabove-levelpairspracticethewholeconversation,plus comeupwithfivedifferentresponsesthatcanreplace“Sure.No problem!”Forexample,“Okay,I’llseeyoulater,”or“Allright. CanIhavesomemoney?”Or,“Sure,honeybunny.I’llbeback inajiffy.”
Leveling writing activities
Studentsinbeginning-levelmultilevelclassroomsneedandwant theopportunitytopracticewriting.Writingisaskillthatisoften challengingenoughinthewriter’sfirstlanguage,letalonethe secondlanguage.Forstudentswhohavealimitedvocabulary andunderstandingofgrammar,tryingtoorganizesentences canbefrustratingandunproductive.Writingactivitiesmustbe meaningfulandusefulinthestudents’English-speakingworld. Taskssuchascompletinganapplicationorpersonalinformation form,writinganabsencenote(forthestudent’sownESLclassor forhis/herchild’sclass),writingane-mailorpostcardtoloved onesoutsidetheUnitedStates,orwritingarequestforvacation timefromanemployer,areonesthatstudentswillencounterin theirpersonallives.
Writingtasksshouldstartwithamodelandprovidestudentswith clearinstructionsonhowto“swapout”theinformationonthe modelwiththeirown.Toensuremybeginning-levelstudentswere successfulwiththeactivity,Iuseddifferent-coloredmarkerson awhiteboardoroverhead,sothestudentswereclearonwhere toputtheirowninformation.Evenwithmodeling,however, sometimesseveraldraftshadtobecompletedbeforeapaper wasperfect.
Writingactivitiescanbecompletedasawholeclassorwith studentspairedincross-abilitygroups.Asthehigher-level
studentscompletetheirtasks,theycanworkalongsidethestudents whorequireadditionalsupport.
Leveling dictation activities
IneverylevelIhavetaught,fromliteracytoadvanced,students havealwaysaskedformoredictation.Inormallydiddictationat theendofclassbecauseIwantedmystudentstohavetimetogo homeandself-correcttheirwriting.Imightdictatefromadialogue wehadjustpracticed,givingthebelow-levelstudentstheoption ofkeepingtheirbooksopen.OrImightdictatefromavocabulary list,andthebelow-levelstudentswouldwriteonlythevocabulary word,whiletheat-levelandabove-levelstudentswouldwrite thewholesentence.So,thestudentsmighthear,“apples,apples, apples.Pleasegetsomeapplesatthestore.”Thebelow-level studentswouldsimplywrite,“apples,”whiletheat-andabove-levelstudentswouldwrite,“Pleasegetsomeapplesatthestore,” andunderlinetheword“apples.”
Thefollowingmorning,asstudentswouldarriveatclass,each wouldwriteonevocabularywordorsentencefromalistonthe board.Whenallthesentenceswerewritten,wewouldcorrect themontheboardasawholeclass,whileindividualstudentsself-correctedtheirownpapers.
Listening strategies
BecauseIfoundlisteningactivitiestobedifficultforstudentsat alllevels,Iimplementedastep-by-stepstrategy.Iexplainedtothe studentsthatiftheyfollowedallthesteps,theywouldbesuccessful withtheactivity.Thestrategywentlikethis:
•First,reviewwiththeclassthetasktobecompletedafterthe listeningactivity
•Second,studentslistentotheaudiorecordingwiththeireyes closed
•Third,studentslistenagain,lookingatthetasktobecompleted
•Next,studentslistenagainandcompletethetask
•Next,studentslistenagainandreviewtheirwork
•Next,studentscomparetheiranswerswiththeirpartner’s answers
•Finally,listenagainandstoptheaudiotorevieweachansweras aclass
Using Your Teacher’s Edition to
Develop Leveled Tasks
Themostimportantcomponentofabeginning-levelESL curriculumistheteacher’seditionofyourclassroomtextbook. Howmuchadditionalsupportdoesyourteacher’seditionprovide? Agoodteacher’seditionwillcontainmanysuggestions,andeven additionalresourcesandworksheets,thatexpandonthecore lesson.Yourteacher’sedition,forexample,mightcontainaset ofconcentrationcardsforthelow-levelstudentstouse(withor withouttheirbooksopen),whiletheat-levelstudentsparticipatein achainstory,andtheabove-levelstudentsdiscussacontroversial topicandwriteaparagraphabouttheirconclusions,whichthey readtothewholeclass.
Choosingwhichexpansionactivitytoassigntoeachlevelrequires familiaritywitheachstudent’slanguageskills.Thegoalistoget eachlevelofstudentstocompletetheassignedtasksatthe sametime.
Open-Entry/Open-Exit Multilevel
Classrooms Management
Inadditiontonegotiatingthechallengesofmultilevelinstruction, asignificantpercentageofprogramsparticipateinopen-entry/ open-exitenrollment.Theeasiestandmosteffectivewayto managetheongoinginfluxofnewstudentsisfortheteacher toorganizea“welcometeam”(generally,withtheabove-level students).Whenanewstudententerstheclassroomafterthestart ofthesemester,thewelcometeampairsthenewstudentwith abuddywhospeakshis/herfirstlanguage.Thebuddygetsthe newstudentsettledin,andthenewstudentisthenimmediately connectedtotheclassroomcommunity.
Summary
Thereareseveralwaystokeepyourheadabovewaterwhen teachinginamultilevelclassroom.First,findacurriculumwitha teacher’seditionthatprovidesvarioustasksthatcanbeadapted toavarietyoflevelsandgroupings.Second,attendworkshops atyourlocal,state,andnationallevels.Third,hoardanyand allreproduciblesyoucangetyourhandson.Finally,keepup withESLwebsitessuchasDave’sESLCafé,theInternetTESOL Journal,andFocusonBasics.Getcomfortablewithsearching theinternetforESLandmultilevelinstructionsites.Thereisa wealthofinformationontheinternet,includinglessonplansand downloadablereproducibles.
Teachinginthemultilevelclassroomisbothchallengingand rewarding.Nomatterhowwellyoupreparefortheday’slessons, onceyoustartteaching,theproverbialcurveballmaycomeonce, twice,orevenadozentimesbeforetheendoftheclasssession. Whatkeepsthededicatedteachermovingforwardwithstaunch resolveisthedeterminationthatallthewonderfulstudentsinhis/ herclasswillfeelthattheylearnedsomething,thattheirconfidence wassustainedoruplifted,andthateveryoneislookingforwardto thenextlesson.
Bibliography
Balliro,L.(1997,September).Ideasforamultilevelclass.Focus onBasics,1(C).RetrievedMay31,2006,fromhttp://www. ncsall.net/?id=771&pid=443.
Balliro,L.(1997,September).Multiplelevels,multiple
responsibilities.FocusonBasics,1(C).RetrievedMay31,2006, fromhttp://www.ncsall.net/?id=771&pid=444.
Broad,S.(1995,May).OutreachandretentioninadultESL literacyprograms.ERICDigest(ED383241).RetrievedMarch 29,2006,fromhttp://www.ericdigests.org/1996-1/outreach. htm.
Burt,M.(1997,September).Themultilevelumbrella.Focuson Basics,1(C).RetrievedMay31,2006,fromhttp://www.ncsall. net/?id=771&pid=442.
Cowles,S.(1997,September).Technologymeltsclassroom walls.FocusonBasics,1(C).RetrievedMay31,2006,from http://www.ncsall.net/?id=771&pid=440.
Florez,M.,&Terrill,L.(2003,July).Workingwithliteracy-level adultEnglishlanguagelearners.CAELADigests.Retrieved March29,2006,fromhttp://www.cal.org/caela/esl_resources/ digests/litQA.html.
Hess,N.(2001).Teachinglargemultilevelclasses,NewYork, NY:CambridgeUniversityPress.
Hofer,J.,&Larson,P.(1997,September).Buildingcommunity andskillsthroughmultilevelclasses.FocusonBasics,1(C). RetrievedMay31,2006,fromhttp://www.ncsall.net/ ?id=771&pid=445.
Managingthemulti-levelinstructionalclassroom:instructional strategiesinthemulti-level,multi-subjectclassroom.California AdultLiteracyProfessionalDevelopmentProject.Retrieved March23,2006,fromhttp://www.calpro-online.org/training/ multi.html.
Parrish.B.(2004).TeachingadultESL:apractical introduction.NewYork,NY:McGraw-HillESL/ELT.
Shank,C.,&Terrill,L.(1997,September).Multilevelliteracy planningandpractice.FocusonBasics,1(C).RetrievedMay 31,2006,fromhttp://www.ncsall.net/?id=771&pid=453. Shank,C.,&Terrill,L.(1995,May).Teachingmultileveladult ESLclasses.CAELADigests.RetrievedOctober3,2006,from http://www.cal.org/caela/esl_resources/digests/SHANK.html.
0-13-135220-2