THE TOLERANCE
THE TOLERANCE
THE TOLERANCE
OF
OF
OF
Bacillus
Bacillus
Bacillus
subtilis
subtilis
subtilis
AND
AND
AND
Bacillus pumilus
Bacillus pumilus
Bacillus pumilus
ORIGINATED FROM BOVINE COLOSTRUM TOWARD
ORIGINATED FROM BOVINE COLOSTRUM TOWARD
ORIGINATED FROM BOVINE COLOSTRUM TOWARD
ACICITY AND BILE SALT AS A PROBIOTICS CANDIDATE
ACICITY AND BILE SALT AS A PROBIOTICS CANDIDATE
ACICITY AND BILE SALT AS A PROBIOTICS CANDIDATE
Khusnul Khotimah
1, Ratu Safitri
2, Nia Rossiana
2, Anisa Syara
21 Agriculture and Farms Faculty, Muhammadiyah Malang University, Malang
2 Biology Department, Mathematics and Natural Science Faculty, Padjadjaran University, Jatinangor
Kj
Introduction
Bo i e olost u is the p e- ilk luid p odu ed the a a gla ds of atle ate i th B a da o et al., . Colost u also o tai p o ioi a te ia F a dso , . P o ioi s a e i oo ga is s that a suppo t the ala e of i olo a i
the digesi e t a t. P o ioi a te ia has the ha a te isi s a e tole a e to a idit , tole a e to ile salt, also p odu i g a i i o ial o pou ds. Ba illus is a G a posii e, spo es a e esista t to high te pe atu es. Ba illus is a le to g o at a idit , is a le to g o at , % ile salt o e t aio s, so e Ba illus p odu e e t a ellula e z es su h as p otease, lipase, a lase, a d ellulase hi h a help the digesi e s ste Chou a d Wei e ; Spi osa et al., ; Ba osa et al., . Ba illus su ilis, Ba illus
lausii, Ba illus pu ilus, a d Ba illus oagula s i luded i o e ial p o ioi p odu ts Sa de s, . I this stud e e pe ted spe ies of Ba illus o igi ated f o o i e olost u that ha e ha a te of a idit a d ile salts tole a e so it a e used as a pote iall p o ioi a te ia. This stud a e a asis fo the used of p o ioi s f o o i e olost u to e de eloped i to a o e ial p o ioi p odu ts.
Ba te ial ultu e of the ge us Ba illus isolates o tai ed f o o i e olost u , Al ohol % , N CH COOH, ile salt O oid L- , API CHB Bio e ieu , ediu Nut ie t Aga O oid , ph siologi al NaCl.
Method
The stud o sisted of t o phases, the des ipi e ethod fo the i st phase is the ide ii aio of Ba illus o igi ated of o i e olost u usi g API CHB. The e pe i e tal ethod used i the se o d phase, a el the ha a te izaio of the
Ba illus p o ioi a didates ith o pletel a do ized desig CRD ith fa to s o sisi g of t o tests a e tole a e of a idit test, a d tole a e of ile salt test. Tole a e of a idit test efe s to Ha dia i gsih ith fa to ial t eat-e t i st fa to is theat-e t peat-e of a didateat-e p o ioi a teat-e ia Ba illus B hi h o sists of t o le els, Ba illus su ilis a d Ba illus pu ilus . The se o d t eat e t fa to is the le el of a idit P hi h o sists of le els of pH p , pH p a d pH p . Tole a e of ile salt test efe s to Bu i et al, ith fa to ial t eat e t i st fa to is the t pe of a didate p o ioi a te ia Ba illus B hi h o sists of t o le els, Ba illus a didates A p o ioi a d Ba illus p o ioi a -didate B . The se o d t eat e t fa to is the o e t aio of ile salts E hi h o sists of t o ile salt o e t aio le el of . % e , a d ile salt o e t aio of . % e . Pa a ete s easu ed at tole a e of a idit test is the u e of
olo ies of CFU/ l to dete i e the highest tole a e to the a idit . Pa a ete s easu ed i tole a e of ile salt test is the u e of olo ies of CFU/ l e e g o o solid ediu o tai i g ile salts . % a d . %. The data o tai ed ill the
Materials
Result and Discussion
Ide ii aio ge us Ba illus a te ia f o o i e olost u usi g API CHB has fou d Ba illus su ilis o tai ed ith a u a . % Figu e a d Ba illus pu ilus ith a u a . % Figu e .
Tolerance of Acidity
Based o the the a al sis of a ia e ANOVA esults sho ed that the alue of F ou t > F ta le, hi h ea s Ba illus su ilis a d Ba illus pu ilus has i te a io to pH. Be ause the ANOVA esults a e eal the it ould e follo ed Du a 's
Muliple Ra ge Test DMRT at sig ii a e le el % Ta le . Based o the Ta le the g o th of B. su ilis a d B. pu ilus i lue ed the pH the highe the pH, the o e olo ies g o . Ba illus su ilis a d Ba illus pu ilus at pH has the est ia il-it . It a e see f o the highest ate i the t eat e t of B. su ilis pH ith a populaio of . CFU/ l a d ith a populaio of B. pu ilus . CFU/ l. I DMRT esults a e see that pH is opi u pH fo the g o th of the
a te ia, this is i a o da e ith the atu e of hi h is Ba illus eut ophils e ui es a opi u pH is . - . . At pH B. su ilis a d B. pu ilus a sill g o ell. Ba illus su ilis is o e tole a t of a id to pH o pa ed ith Ba illus pu ilus ith a
populaio of . CFU/ l a d . CFU/ l. Whe eas at pH B. su ilis a d B. pu ilus a ot g o . Ba te ial Tole a e to a idit aused the a ilit to ai tai a toplas i pH o e alkali e tha the e t a ellula pH. Highl a idi o diio s at pH has a e st o g i lue e of B. su ilis a d B. pu ilus. A id i hi iio of a te ial ell g o th o u s th ough the i lue e of de atu aio of e z es that e ist o the ell su fa e, lipopol sa ha ide a d oute e a e is da -aged a d a de ease i toplas i pH th ough i eased e a e pe ea ilit Us iai, . Ba ilus pu ilus a d Ba illus su ilis ased o the esults of tests of tole a e to a id a g o i a id to pH , so B. su ilis a d B. pu ilus has o e of the e ui e e ts as a a didate p o ioi has tole a e of a idit .
Tolerance of Bile Salts
Based o the a al sis of a ia e ANOVA esult ho ed that the alue of F ou t > F ta le, hi h ea s Ba illus su ilis a d Ba illus pu ilus has i te a io to ile salt o e t aio of . % a d . %. Be ause the ANOVA esults a e eal the it
ould e follo ed Du a 's Muliple Ra ge Test DMRT at sig ii a e le el % Ta le . Based o Ta le sho s that the t eat e t of . % gi es the lo est alue of a te ial ia ilit , he eas . % t eat e t ga e the highest alues of a te ial ia ilit . It is sho f o the highest ate i the t eat e t of ile salt o e t aio of . % ith a populaio of . CFU/ l i Ba illus pu ilus. Ta o k , states that p o ioi a te ia should e a le to a hie e i the digesi e t a t
ai tai i g a populaio of - CFU/ l a d a p o ide health e eits. Media NA + . % ile salt is a ediu hose o diio ese les the digesi e t a t o tai i g ile as su fa e-a i e o pou ds that a pe et ate a d ea t ith the
to-plas i e a e Hill, . The highe the o e t aio of ile salts the fe e a te ia g o i g populaio . It a e see that the u e of olo ies of Ba illus su ilis a d Ba illus pu ilus i lue ed the o e t aio of ile salts. Good e-sista e to ile salts o u s e ause of the ole of pol sa ha ides as a o situe t of the ell all of G a -posii e a te ia. Ba illus su ilis a d Ba illus pu ilus has esista e to ile salts ith a ii al o e t aio . A o di g )a aglia et al. ,
. % ile salt o e t aio is high e ough o e t aio s to sele t st ai s that a e esista t to ile salts, a d all the i o es that su i ed ate g o i ediu plus . % ile salts, othe ise e esista t to ile salts . This is o e of the e ui e e ts of a de la ed p o ioi a te ia.
Figure . Result Idenii aion
Ba illus su ilis
Figure . Result Idenii aion
Ba illus pumilus
Bacillus subtilis
Bacillus pumilus
pH
Bacteria CFU/ml
Bacillus subtilis
Bacillus pumilus
2
nd C
nd C
a
a
4
55,12 x 10
5
B
16,40 x 10
5B
a
b
6
35,38 x 10
8
A
19,36 x 10
8A
a
b
Bile salt
(%)
Bacteria CFU/ml
Bacillus subtilis
Bacillus pumilus
0,3
6,692 x 10
8
A
8,745 x 10
8A
b
a
0,5
3,506 x 10
8
B
5,570 x 10
8B
b
a
Ta le . Dun an's Muliple Range Test Toleran e
Ba illus su ilis
and
Ba illus pumilus
to Bile Salt
Ta le . Dun an's Muliple Range Test Toleran e
Ba illus su ilis
and
Ba illus pumilus
to pH
Conclusion
Based o the test esults of the p o ioi p ope ies of Ba illus su ilis a d Ba illus pu ilus i esista e to lo pH a d ile salts, pe fo ed a al sis of a ia e to dete i e the pote ial oth as a a didate p o ioi a te ia. It is k o that Ba illus su ilis a d
Ba illus pu ilus eet t o e ui e e ts as a a didate p o ioi that is tole a t of lo pH at pH a d pH a d tole a t to ile salts at a o e t aio of . % a d . %.
Reference
Ba osa, T.M., Se a, C.R., La Ragio e, R.M., Wood a d, M.J., a d He i ues, A.O., . S ee i g fo Ba illus isolates i the oile gast oi tesi al t a t. Applied a d E i o e tal Mi o iolog : - .
B a da o P, Rassu SPG, La zu A. . Feedi g Dai La s. Dala Puli e G. B i i R Edito J Dai Sheep Nut iio Walli g Food : ABI . Pu lishi g.
Bu i , N., Cha tha hu , S., Ho gpata ake e, T. . S ee i g of La i A id Ba te ia F o Gast oi tesi al T a s of Ma i e Fish Fo Thei Pote ial Use As P o ioi s. So gkla aka i J. S i. Te h ol. Suppl. . Chou L.). a d Wei e B. . Isolaio a d ha a te izaio of a id a d ile tole a t isolates f o st ai s of L.a idophilus. J Dai S i -
-F a dso , R.D. . A i al A ato a d Fisiolog . th Ediio . Gadjah Mada U i e sit P ess, Yog aka ta.
Ha di i gsih, R. . Isolaio a d Resista e Test of Se e al Isolates of La to a illus i Lo pH. LIPI , Bogo . Hill, M. J. . Role of Gut Ba te ia i Hu a To i olog a d Pha a olog . Ta lo , Ne Yo k.
Go ez, A.A. da Go ez, K.A. . Staisi al P o edu es fo Ag i ultu al Resea h. UI P ess, Jaka ta.
Sa de s M. E, L. Mo elli, a d T.A. To pki s. Spo efo e s as Hu a P o ioi s: Ba illus, Sporola to a illus, a d Brevi a illus. Co p ehe si e Re ie I Food S ie e a d Food Safet Vol. , Spi osa, M.R., B a i i, T., Ri a, E., De Feli e, M., Mo elli, L., Pozzi, G., a d Oggio i, M.R., . O the fate of i gested Ba illus spo es. Resea h i Mi o iolog : - .
Ta o k, G. W. . A f esh look at the i tesi al ik olo a. Ho izo S i ii P ess.
Us iai S, B oto W, da Sei a to H. . Cha a te isi s of o 's ilk u d usi g p o ioi a te ia sta te . Jou al of A i al a d Vete i a S ie es, :
-)a aglia, A.G., G Ko iu i sk , P. Pe ez a d G. De A to i. . Isolaio a d Cha a te izaio of Biido a te iu st ai s fo p o ioi fo ulaio . J. Food P ote t. :
-Des ipio : Dife e t apital lete s ead i to the e i al di e io i di ates sig ii a tl dife e t p> .
Dife e t lo e ase lete s ead i to the ho izo tal di e io i di ates sig ii a tl dife e t p> . d: ot dete i ated u e of olo ies CFU/ l
Des ipio : Dife e t apital lete s ead i to the e i al di e io i di ates sig ii a tl dife e t p> .
Dife e t lo e ase lete s ead i to the ho izo tal di e io i di ates sig ii a tl dife e t p> .
pH B. su ilis pH B. su ilis pH B. su ilis
pH B. pu ilus
pH B. pu ilus pH B. pu ilus
Bacillus subtilis and Bacillus pumilus population growth on
pH , , and agar plates medium
Bacillus subtilis and Bacillus pumilus population growth on
bile salts 0, % and 0, % agar plates medium
, % ile salts , % ile salts
, % ile salts
, % ile salts
Ba illus su ilis