Contradiction: Inclusion of multiple dispute settlement clauses in the agreement - Narotama University Repository

(1)

10/1/23,2:12PM Gmail-[IJCJS]Acknowledgmentofanewmanuscriptsubmission

https://mail.google.com/mail/u/2/?ik=ff2b48e652&view=pt&search=all&permthid=thread-a:r-4553317436179513279&simpl=msg-a:r-4551664948… 1/1

[IJCJS] Acknowledgment of a new manuscript submission

Dear Dr. Habib Adjie,

Thank you for submitting the following manuscript to theInternational Journal of Criminal Justice Sciences.

Track: Regular Track

Title: Contradiction: Inclusion of multiple dispute settlement clauses in the agreement Author(s): Habib Adjie

Corresponding Author: Habib Adjie

Affiliation of Corresponding Author: Universitas Narotama, Surabaya, Indonesia Date of Manuscript Submission: 24-September -2022 (UTC)

In a couple of days, a confirmation email including the manuscript ID will be again forwarded to you when the journal manager looks through your submission and confirms it. Further progress on your submission can be checked through the following online system.

* Online System URL:https://www.manuscriptlink.com/journals/ijcjs

If you have any questions regarding your submission, please contact the journal editor-in-chief.

Best regards,

Journal Editor-in-Chief

International Journal of Criminal Justice Sciences Homepage:https://www.ijcjs.com

=============[Note]=============

This email is only for the delivery service.

Please do not reply to this mail.

HabibAdjie <[email protected]>

IJCJS<[email protected]>

To: "Habib Adjie" <[email protected]> Sat, Sep 24, 2022 at 12:44 PM

(2)

10/1/23,2:12PM Gmail-[IJCJS]EditorDecision

https://mail.google.com/mail/u/2/?ik=ff2b48e652&view=pt&search=all&permthid=thread-a:r5305235011811922730&simpl=msg-a:r217769292639… 1/1

[IJCJS] Editor Decision

Thank you for submitting the following manuscript to theInternational Journal of Criminal Justice Sciences.

The manuscript ID: IJCJS-670-2022

We have confirmed and forwarded your submission for reviewing process. Further progress on your submission can be checked through the following online system.

Best regards,

=============[Note]=============

Habib Adjie <[email protected]>

To: "Habib Adjie" <[email protected]> Sat, Sep 24, 2022 at 2:23 PM

(3)

[IJCJS] Editor Decision

We have reached a decision regarding your submission to theInternational Journal of Criminal Justice Sciences, "Contradiction: Inclusion of multiple dispute settlement clauses in the agreement".

Our decision is: Revisions Required

Please revise your manuscript based on reviewers' comments and suggestions accordingly and resubmit your revised manuscript no later than one month.

Let me know if you have any questions.

Best regards,

=============[Note]=============

---

e h

T study"Contradiction:InclusionofMultipleDispute SettlementClauses in theAgreement

"explains dispute resolution clauses inIndonesia .It effectively setsthestage foryour

h c r a e s e

r , outlining itspurpose andsignificance .However, here aresomesuggestions for t

n e m e v o r p m

i :

Reviewer- A

Decision: Major revisions required

To: "Habib Adjie" <[email protected]> Sat, Oct 29, 2022 at 2:45 PM

https://mail.google.com/mail/u/2/?ik=ff2b48e652&view=pt&search=all&permthid=thread-a:r1486571872852534608&simpl=msg-a:r-90335587048… 1/2

While the abstract is informative , it could benefit from a slightly clearer structure to make it easier for readers to grasp the key aspects of your study quickly.

Ensure that the keywords listed at the end of the abstract are reflective of the key concepts and terms discussed in your study.

You mention that your study aims to examine dispute resolution clauses , but it would be helpful to specify what kind of agreements these clauses are typically found in. Are you focusing on commercial contracts , legal documents , or a broader range of agreements ? Clarifying this in the abstract would provide more context.

While you mention that you use a qualitative approach and content analysis, it would be beneficial to briefly explain why you chose these methods and how they contribute to your study. This would help readers understand the rigor of your research.

The study mentions the significance of your research but doesn 't delve into specific implications or potential applications of your findings . Consider briefly mentioning the practical relevance or real - world applications of your study's outcomes.

--- 1.

2.

3.

4.

5.

(4)

Thisisawell -written study .However ,incorporating thefollowing improvements would make this study more concise andreader -friendly while providing aclearer understanding ofyour research.

The literature review section provides adetailed overview ofdispute resolution in common lawand civillawcountries ,followed byanexamination ofthelegalframeworkfor dispute resolution in Indonesia . Overall ,itoffers acomprehensive and informative review .However ,itisquite extensive , covering different aspects andcountries .It could benefit fromamorestructured organization . Consider grouping theinformation under clearsubheadings ,suchas"Dispute Settlement inCommon awCountries"and"Dispute SettlementinCivilawCountries,"tomakeiteasierforreadersto follow.

Ensure thatyouprovide proper in-textcitations forthesources youreference .Thisis important for academic integrity andallows readers tolocate theoriginal sources for moreinformation .Also, ensure thatyourcitations followaconsistentformatthroughout theliterature review .Forexample, youmayuse APA,A,oranothercitation style ,butit shouldbeconsistentforallsources.

_________________________________________________________

InternationalJournalofCriminalJusticeSciences Homepage:https://www.ijcjs.com

Reviewer -B

Decision: Major revisions required

After presenting the legal frameworks in common law and civil law countries , it would be beneficial to connect these findings to the specific legal framework in Indonesia . This can help readers understand the context and relevance of your research.

Consider including a brief discussion or synthesis of the information presented in this section .You can highlight key similarities and differences between dispute resolution mechanisms in different countries and how these insights relate to your study in Indonesia.

When discussing dispute resolution in Indonesia , consider adding information about the local context , such as cultural or societal factors that may influence the choice of dispute resolution methods.

1.

2.

3.

4.

5.

(5)

10/1/23,2:13PM Gmail-[IJCJS]Acknowledgmentofamanuscriptrevisionsubmission

https://mail.google.com/mail/u/2/?ik=ff2b48e652&view=pt&search=all&permthid=thread-a:r-6085121232002834340&simpl=msg-a:r-2068896821… 1/1

[IJCJS] Acknowledgment of a manuscript revision submission

Thank you for submitting the following manuscript revision to theInternational Journal of Criminal Justice Sciences.

We have confirmed and forwarded your revision submission for reviewing process. Further progress on your submission can be checked through the following online system.

Best regards,

=============[Note]=============

To: "Habib Adjie" <[email protected]> Mon, Nov 14, 2022 at 11:28 AM

(6)

Response to Reviewer 1

Sr. No. Reviewer's Comment Response

The study "Contradiction: Inclusion of Multiple Dispute Settlement Clauses in the Agreement" explains dispute resolution clauses in Indonesia. It effectively sets the stage for your research, outlining its purpose and significance. However, here are some suggestions for improvement:

Many thanks respected reviewer for your kind remarks and suggestions.

1 While the abstract is informative, it could benefit from a slightly clearer structure to make it easier for readers to grasp the key aspects of your study quickly.

Many thanks for your kind suggestions.

We have now revised abstract with clearer structure to make it easier for readers to grasp the key aspects of your study quickly.

Please see page 1 2 Ensure that the keywords listed at the end

of the abstract are reflective of the key concepts and terms discussed in your study.

Dear reviewer, following your kind guidelines. Keywords listed at the end of the abstract are now reflective of the key concepts and terms discussed in your study.

Please see page 1 3 You mention that your study aims to

examine dispute resolution clauses, but it would be helpful to specify what kind of agreements these clauses are typically found in. Are you focusing on commercial contracts, legal documents, or a broader range of agreements? Clarifying this in the abstract would provide more context.

Dear reviewer, Thank you for your kind suggestions. Clarified as suggested.

Please see pages 5-8

4 While you mention that you use a qualitative approach and content analysis,

Respected reviewer, Thank you.

Done as suggested.

(7)

it would be beneficial to briefly explain why you chose these methods and how they contribute to your study. This would help readers understand the rigor of your research.

Please see pages 13-14

5 The study mentions the significance of your research but doesn't delve into specific implications or potential applications of your findings. Consider briefly mentioning the practical relevance or real-world applications of your study's outcomes.

Thank you, dear reviewer. Done as per kind suggestion.

Please see page no 18-20

(8)

Response to Reviewer 2

Sr. No. Reviewer's Comment Response

This is a well-written study. However, incorporating the following improvements would make this study more concise and reader-friendly while providing a clearer understanding of your research.

Thank you for your feedback on the paper. It's essential to provide constructive comments to help improve the quality of the paper. Here is the detailed response please

1 The literature review section provides a detailed overview of dispute resolution in common law and civil law countries, followed by an examination of the legal framework for dispute resolution in Indonesia. Overall, it offers a comprehensive and informative review.

However, it is quite extensive, covering different aspects and countries. It could benefit from a more structured organization. Consider grouping the information under clear subheadings, such as "Dispute Settlement in Common Law Countries" and "Dispute Settlement in Civil Law Countries," to make it easier for readers to follow.

Dear reviewer, done as suggested.

Please see page 7-12

2 Ensure that you provide proper in-text citations for the sources you reference. This is important for academic integrity and allows readers to locate the original sources for more information. Also, ensure that your citations follow a consistent format throughout the literature review. For example, you may use APA, MLA, or

Many thanks. done as suggested.

(9)

another citation style, but it should be consistent for all sources.

3 After presenting the legal frameworks in common law and civil law countries, it would be beneficial to connect these findings to the specific legal framework in Indonesia. This can help readers understand the context and relevance of your research.

Dear reviewer. We have now connected the findings to the specific legal framework in Indonesia as suggested by your kind self.

Please see pages 11-12

4 Consider including a brief discussion or synthesis of the information presented in this section. You can highlight key similarities and differences between dispute resolution mechanisms in different countries and how these insights relate to your study in Indonesia.

Dear reviewer, Thank you.

Done as suggested.

Please see pages 18-19

5 When discussing dispute resolution in Indonesia, consider adding information about the local context, such as cultural or societal factors that may influence the choice of dispute resolution methods.

Done, dear reviewer as suggested.

Please see page 19

(10)

https://mail.google.com/mail/u/2/?ik=ff2b48e652&view=pt&search=all&permthid=thread-a:r-8220509634827887050&simpl=msg-a:r33970538165… 1/1

[IJCJS] Editor Decision

We have reached a decision regarding your submission to theInternational Journal of Criminal Justice Sciences, "Contradiction: Inclusion of multiple dispute settlement clauses in the agreement".

Our decision is: Revisions Required

Please revise your manuscript based on the reviewers' comments and suggestions accordingly and resubmit your revised manuscript no later than one month.

Let me know if you have any questions.

Best regards,

=============[Note]=============

To: "Habib Adjie" <[email protected]> Wed, Dec 21, 2022 at 12:05 PM

(11)

10/1/23,2:14PM Gmail-[IJCJS]Acknowledgmentofamanuscriptrevisionsubmission

[IJCJS] Acknowledgment of a manuscript revision submission

Thank you for submitting the following manuscript revision to theInternational Journal of Criminal Justice Sciences.

We have confirmed and forwarded your submission revision for reviewing process. Further progress on your submission can be checked through the following online system.

Best regards,

=============[Note]=============

To: "Habib Adjie" <[email protected]> Thu, Jan 19, 2023 at 10:17 AM

(12)

Response to Reviewers

Sr. No. Reviewer's Comment Response

The revised version is good. However, by addressing the following points, you can enhance the clarity and structure of your paper and provide readers with a more cohesive understanding of dispute resolution practices in different legal contexts, including Indonesia.

Many thanks, Respected Reviewer.

1 While your recommendations are generally sound, providing more specific details on how these recommendations can be implemented would be helpful.

Many thanks, for kind comments. We have now provided more specific details on how the recommendations can be implemented would be helpful.

Please see page 19 2 Whenever possible, support your

recommendations with evidence or examples from your research or relevant case studies. This can strengthen the credibility of your suggestions.

Dear reviewer, done as suggested by your kind self.

Please see page 18-20

3 Begin your conclusion by summarizing the key findings of your study concisely. This serves as a quick reminder for readers of the main takeaways.

Dear reviewer, Thank you for your kind suggestions. Done as suggested.

Please see page 22

(13)

https://mail.google.com/mail/u/2/?ik=ff2b48e652&view=pt&search=all&permthid=thread-a:r-2263024698122411499&simpl=msg-a:r55119897116… 1/1

[IJCJS] Editor Decision

To: "Habib Adjie" <[email protected]>

Congratulations! the following of your manuscript.

Has been accepted for publication in International Journal of Criminal Justice Sciences (Vol. 18 No. 1, 2023).

Thank you for your interest in our journal. Your Journal paper would be indexed in Scopus (Elsevier), Google Scholar, Scirus, GetCited, Scribd, so on.

We look forward to receiving your subsequent research papers.

Best regards,

=============[Note]=============

IJCJS<[email protected]> Mon, Mar 06, 2023 at 1:46 PM