Corresponding Author Jurnal Komunikasi

(1)

9/6/22, 2:39 PM Gmail - [JKMJC] Editor Decision

https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/h/950y2g497lhe/?&q=komunikasi&th=1744cdd4a54ed3ef&ser=AIKcX54yCHeXKodkRgjUQe8c-yfVKdpYdw&v=pt&s=… 1/4 Imron Rosidi <[email protected]>

[JKMJC] Editor Decision

3 messages

Assoc. Prof. Dr. Abdul Latiff Ahmad <[email protected]> Tue, Sep 1, 2020 at 3:26 PM To: Imron Rosidi <[email protected]>

Dear Imron Rosidi:

We have reached a decision regarding your submission to Jurnal Komunikasi:

Malaysian Journal of Communication, "Negoitating Representations of Korean TV Dramas among Indonesian Muslim Youth".

Our decision is: Revisions Required

Please log in to the system to view reviewers comments and address them before uploading your revised manuscript at the author's section in the same entry. You may refer to the "User Guides" section for detailed steps.

A Revision form is attached with this email. Once you have uploaded the manuscript, please send a notification email to me and attach the completed Revision form in the email.

Please also include 1 citation from Jurnal Komunikasi if you haven't done so already.

There is a fee charged for each article published. Please make sure you make the necessary payment once the revised manuscript is accepted for

publication.

Thank you again for your submission. We look forward to receiving your revised copy soon.

Assoc. Prof. Dr. Abdul Latiff Ahmad

Centre for Communication and Digital Society Faculty of Social Sciences & Humanities, Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia

[email protected]

--- Reviewer A:

Article Title:

Check spelling; and negotiating what?

Technical requirements:

Word count is between 5000 - 7000 words (excluding abstract, biodata, and references)

:

Word count requirements met Abstract is between 200 and 250 words:

Abstract meets word requirements Five keywords are included:

Yes

Part 1: Reviewer’s comments. Please write comments in the spaces

(2)

https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/h/950y2g497lhe/?&q=komunikasi&th=1744cdd4a54ed3ef&ser=AIKcX54yCHeXKodkRgjUQe8c-yfVKdpYdw&v=pt&s=… 2/4 provided.

Introduction :

Not very clear. The author needs to be very specific - what kind of representation? Islamic values? masculinities? moralities?

Literature Review:

The fear of cultural imperialism has led to the notion of cultural protectionism - there is no clear review of literature in the context of Indonesia.

Methodology:

There is no clear statement about the employment of methodology in this study - quantitative or qualitative?

Findings & Interpretations:

Acceptable - if there are details about context of study in this article.

Discussion:

Acceptable - if there are details about context of study in this article.

References/ Bibliography (APA system):

Acceptable

Title, Abstracts & Keywords (articles written in Bahasa Melayu must also include abstract & keywords written in English):

Need a Malay version of title Additional Comments:

This article needs major revision - no context of study and research design is quite poorly written.

Part 2: Overall evaluation. Please rate the article based on the following scales.

Originality :

Poor Coherence:

Fair

Scholarly Contribution:

Poor

Technical Quality:

Fair Relevency:

Fair

Language quality:

Fair

--- --- Reviewer B:

Article Title:

Negoitating Representations of Korean TV Dramas among Indonesian Muslim Youth.

(3)

https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/h/950y2g497lhe/?&q=komunikasi&th=1744cdd4a54ed3ef&ser=AIKcX54yCHeXKodkRgjUQe8c-yfVKdpYdw&v=pt&s=… 3/4 Technical requirements:

Word count is between 5000 - 7000 words (excluding abstract, biodata, and references)

:

Word count requirements met Abstract is between 200 and 250 words:

Abstract meets word requirements Five keywords are included:

Yes

Part 1: Reviewer’s comments. Please write comments in the spaces provided.

Introduction :

A good introduction; helps gain reader's interest to read further.

Literature Review:

Quite an extensive literature.

Methodology:

The methodology has been explained clearly.

Findings & Interpretations:

Sets a clear problem statement and significance of the study.

Discussion:

Sets a good discussion.

References/ Bibliography (APA system):

APA style observed.

Title, Abstracts & Keywords (articles written in Bahasa Melayu must also include abstract & keywords written in English):

Sufficient.

Additional Comments:

I must admit that this article is interesting and relevant to this journal theme.

Part 2: Overall evaluation. Please rate the article based on the following scales.

Originality :

Excellent Coherence:

Good

Scholarly Contribution:

Good

Technical Quality:

Good Relevency:

Good

(4)

https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/h/950y2g497lhe/?&q=komunikasi&th=1744cdd4a54ed3ef&ser=AIKcX54yCHeXKodkRgjUQe8c-yfVKdpYdw&v=pt&s=… 4/4 Language quality:

Good

---

________________________________________________________________________

Jurnal Komunikasi: Malaysian Journal of Communication http://ejournal.ukm.my/mjc

revision form jkom.pdf 37K

Imron Rosidi <[email protected]> Wed, Sep 2, 2020 at 10:17 AM

To: [email protected]

[Quoted text hidden]

--

Imron Rosidi, PhD

Lecturer at State Islamic University of Sultan Syarif Kasim Riau, Indonesia revision form jkom.pdf

37K

Imron Rosidi <[email protected]> Wed, Sep 2, 2020 at 10:30 AM

To: "Assoc. Prof. Dr. Abdul Latiff Ahmad" <[email protected]>

Dear Prof. Abdul Latiff Ahmad,

Thank you for the decision. I will surely revise my paper based on the reviewers' suggestions.

Best wishes, Imron

[Quoted text hidden]