12/04/2023, 13:49 View Letter
https://www.editorialmanager.com/wpt/ViewLetter.aspx?id=927444&lsid=58a51839-6062-4871-8b1a-c169abf203a9&prod=&sgTask=0&cm= 1/1
Date: 17 Dec 2022
To: "Abdul Rivai Suleman" [email protected] From: "Water Practice and Technology" [email protected]
Subject: Submission Confirmation for Flood Mitigation of Bila River in Sidrap Regency Indonesia Based on Eco- drainage Retention Pond
Dear Mr Suleman,
Your submission entitled "Flood Mitigation of Bila River in Sidrap Regency Indonesia Based on Eco-drainage Retention Pond" has been received and will now be peer reviewed for possible publication in the journal Water Practice and Technology
We have emailed all those you listed as co-authors asking them to verify that they are a co-author of the paper. Please ask your co-authors to look out for the e-mail. Your paper will not be assigned to an Editor without verification from all co- authors. Once they have completed this the paper will be sent to an Editor and you will receive a manuscript reference number for your paper.
You will be able to check on the progress of your paper by logging on to Editorial Manager as an author. The URL is https://www.editorialmanager.com/wpt/.
Thank you for submitting your work to this journal.
Kind regards, The Editorial Office
Water Practice and Technology
__________________________________________________
In compliance with data protection regulations, you may request that we remove your personal registration details at any time. (Use the following URL: https://www.editorialmanager.com/wpt/login.asp?a=r). Please contact the publication office if you have any questions.
https://www.editorialmanager.com/wpt/ViewLetter.aspx?id=932573&lsid=3762bcd2-0f0c-4b2a-940c-2b007b8567ae&prod=&sgTask=0&cm= 1/2
Date: 08 Feb 2023
To: "Abdul Rivai Suleman" [email protected] From: "Water Practice and Technology" [email protected]
Subject: WPT-D-22-00365 - please submit revised manuscript for further review Attachment(s): WPT-D-22-00365_MyReviewComments.pdf
Water Practice and Technology
Article title: 'Flood Mitigation of Bila River in Sidrap Regency Indonesia Based on Eco-drainage Retention Pond' Reference No: WPT-D-22-00365
Dear Mr Abdul Rivai Suleman,
I am pleased to inform you that we have received the reviews of your paper, and invite you to submit a revision, taking into consideration the reviewer comments as detailed at the end of this message.
We will be happy to consider your article for publication in Water Practice and Technology, if you can address the reviewer comments to their satisfaction. Please be aware that your article may still be rejected if the revised version is not satisfactory.
For your guidance, any specific reviewers' comments are appended below the signature lines. If the reviewers have uploaded any extra files for your reference, you should find them attached to this message. You may also view them by logging in to Editorial Manager, and clicking on the 'View Reviewer Attachments' Action Link for the paper.
You must also make sure that the correct information for your co-authors has been added to the manuscript details and that all of your co-authors have verified their involvement through the links emailed to them. We will not be able to proceed with the next stage of peer review unless all co-authors have confirmed their involvement with the paper.
Please ensure that your revised manuscript also contains the following:
Marked-Up Copy of Changes: Please include a manuscript copy detailing the changes made to your revised article as a separate document.
Response to Reviewers: Please include a document detailing the changes made and why or why not you have made the changes recommended by your Editor and Reviewers.
Graphical Abstract: This should offer readers an at-a-glance visualisation of your paper via a single, concise image.
Data Availability Statement: Please ensure that you have selected the correct Data Availability Statement option in the 'Additional Information' section of your submission.
Conflict of Interest Statement: Please ensure that you have selected the correct Conflict of Interest
Statement to certify that the authors are not affiliated with or involved with any organisation or entity with any financial interest or non-financial interest in the subject matter or materials discussed in this paper. You will be able to enter your statement in the 'Additional Information' section of your resubmission to Editorial Manager.
Please address queries about Conflicts of Interest to the journal office: [email protected].
To submit the revised version of your article, go to https://www.editorialmanager.com/wpt/, log in as an Author and click on the Submissions Needing Revision folder. You will find your submission record there.
We would like to receive your revision by 01 Mar 2023. If you do not submit your revision by this date, we will consider your paper withdrawn from the review process.
This email has only been sent to you, as the corresponding author; please pass on this message to your co-authors.
Your username is as follows:
********
Once again, thank you for submitting your manuscript to Water Practice and Technology, and I look forward to receiving your revision.
Yours sincerely,
Lucy Ibbotson Journals Manager
Water Practice and Technology IWA Publishing
https://www.editorialmanager.com/wpt/
12/04/2023, 13:48 View Letter
https://www.editorialmanager.com/wpt/ViewLetter.aspx?id=932573&lsid=3762bcd2-0f0c-4b2a-940c-2b007b8567ae&prod=&sgTask=0&cm= 2/2 Reviewers' comments:
Dear Author,
Especially in figures 1-5 and 6, the texts on the maps are too small to be read. You have to make it readable.
Nese Yilmaz Editor
Reviewer #1: Please elaborate the principal differents (construction, aim, function) between eco-drainage systems and retention ponds a little bit more clear.
Please see Reviewer #2's comments in attachments.
In compliance with data protection regulations, you may request that we remove your personal registration details at any time.
(Remove my information/details). Please contact the publication office if you have any questions.
drainage Retention Pond
Comments to the authors:
1. Since the retention ponds require a large land, how suitable and feasible is it for that particular region and remediate to that scourge?
2. What is the plan in place in terms of adequately maintaining the retention pond due to invasive species, health, and safety associated with it?
3. How did you validate the data obtained? As I can see there is time invariance as time is not exactly uniformly distributed to the hydrographs you have presented in your study.
4. Furthermore, The base periods of the hydrograph over effective rainfall uniformly distributed over a given period of time are not the same, why? And how can this significantly affect the accuracy of your hydrographs?
5. What are the strategies to manage water quality? Especially since anaerobic conditions can
occur without regular inflow and no reduction in runoff volume.
12/04/2023, 13:51 View Letter
https://www.editorialmanager.com/wpt/ViewLetter.aspx?id=934656&lsid=3a0dda31-00b7-4af1-95d7-92677d2352c5&prod=&sgTask=0&cm= 1/1
Date: 28 Feb 2023
To: "Abdul Rivai Suleman" [email protected] From: "Water Practice and Technology" [email protected] Subject: Submission Confirmation for WPT-D-22-00365R1
Water Practice and Technology
Article title: Flood Mitigation of Bila River in Sidrap Regency Indonesia Based on Eco-drainage Retention Pond Reference No: WPT-D-22-00365R1
Dear Mr Suleman,
Water Practice and Technology has received the revised version of your submission for consideration for publication. It will now be sent to the Associate Editor who will contact you soon with their decision.
You may check the status of your manuscript by logging onto Editorial Manager at (https://www.editorialmanager.com/wpt/).
Kind regards, The Editorial Office
Water Practice and Technology
__________________________________________________
In compliance with data protection regulations, you may request that we remove your personal registration details at any time. (Use the following URL: https://www.editorialmanager.com/wpt/login.asp?a=r). Please contact the publication office if you have any questions.
https://www.editorialmanager.com/wpt/ViewLetter.aspx?id=935269&lsid=5210b110-131c-4cdc-9685-49e7a2d18087&prod=&sgTask=0&cm= 1/2
Date: 08 Mar 2023
To: "Abdul Rivai Suleman" [email protected] From: "Water Practice and Technology" [email protected]
Subject: WPT-D-22-00365R1 - please submit revised manuscript for further review
Water Practice and Technology
Article title: 'Flood Mitigation of Bila River in Sidrap Regency Indonesia Based on Eco-drainage Retention Pond' Reference No: WPT-D-22-00365R1
Dear Mr Abdul Rivai Suleman,
I am pleased to inform you that we have received the reviews of your paper, and invite you to submit a revision, taking into consideration the reviewer comments as detailed at the end of this message.
We will be happy to consider your article for publication in Water Practice and Technology, if you can address the reviewer comments to their satisfaction. Please be aware that your article may still be rejected if the revised version is not satisfactory.
For your guidance, any specific reviewers' comments are appended below the signature lines. If the reviewers have uploaded any extra files for your reference, you should find them attached to this message. You may also view them by logging in to Editorial Manager, and clicking on the 'View Reviewer Attachments' Action Link for the paper.
You must also make sure that the correct information for your co-authors has been added to the manuscript details and that all of your co-authors have verified their involvement through the links emailed to them. We will not be able to proceed with the next stage of peer review unless all co-authors have confirmed their involvement with the paper.
Please ensure that your revised manuscript also contains the following:
Marked-Up Copy of Changes: Please include a manuscript copy detailing the changes made to your revised article as a separate document.
Response to Reviewers: Please include a document detailing the changes made and why or why not you have made the changes recommended by your Editor and Reviewers.
Graphical Abstract: This should offer readers an at-a-glance visualisation of your paper via a single, concise image.
Data Availability Statement: Please ensure that you have selected the correct Data Availability Statement option in the 'Additional Information' section of your submission.
Conflict of Interest Statement: Please ensure that you have selected the correct Conflict of Interest
Statement to certify that the authors are not affiliated with or involved with any organisation or entity with any financial interest or non-financial interest in the subject matter or materials discussed in this paper. You will be able to enter your statement in the 'Additional Information' section of your resubmission to Editorial Manager.
Please address queries about Conflicts of Interest to the journal office: [email protected].
To submit the revised version of your article, go to https://www.editorialmanager.com/wpt/, log in as an Author and click on the Submissions Needing Revision folder. You will find your submission record there.
We would like to receive your revision by 22 Mar 2023. If you do not submit your revision by this date, we will consider your paper withdrawn from the review process.
This email has only been sent to you, as the corresponding author; please pass on this message to your co-authors.
Your username is as follows:
********
Once again, thank you for submitting your manuscript to Water Practice and Technology, and I look forward to receiving your revision.
Yours sincerely,
Lucy Ibbotson Journals Manager
Water Practice and Technology IWA Publishing
https://www.editorialmanager.com/wpt/
Reviewers' comments:
12/04/2023, 13:59 View Letter
https://www.editorialmanager.com/wpt/ViewLetter.aspx?id=935269&lsid=5210b110-131c-4cdc-9685-49e7a2d18087&prod=&sgTask=0&cm= 2/2 Dear Author,
Please mark your corrections on your paper and sent it again. I need to see you arrangements for my decision on your paper.
Best regards,
Assoc.Prof.Dr. Nese Yilmaz Editor
In compliance with data protection regulations, you may request that we remove your personal registration details at any time.
(Remove my information/details). Please contact the publication office if you have any questions.
https://www.editorialmanager.com/wpt/ViewLetter.aspx?id=935840&lsid=8045a376-fd1d-4ba9-b5a3-54ef21989dbd&prod=&sgTask=0&cm= 1/1
Date: 13 Mar 2023
To: "Abdul Rivai Suleman" [email protected] From: "Water Practice and Technology" [email protected] Subject: Submission Confirmation for WPT-D-22-00365R2
Water Practice and Technology
Article title: Flood Mitigation of Bila River in Sidrap Regency Indonesia Based on Eco-drainage Retention Pond Reference No: WPT-D-22-00365R2
Dear Mr Suleman,
Water Practice and Technology has received the revised version of your submission for consideration for publication. It will now be sent to the Associate Editor who will contact you soon with their decision.
You may check the status of your manuscript by logging onto Editorial Manager at (https://www.editorialmanager.com/wpt/).
Kind regards, The Editorial Office
Water Practice and Technology
__________________________________________________
In compliance with data protection regulations, you may request that we remove your personal registration details at any time. (Use the following URL: https://www.editorialmanager.com/wpt/login.asp?a=r). Please contact the publication office if you have any questions.
12/04/2023, 14:01 View Letter
https://www.editorialmanager.com/wpt/ViewLetter.aspx?id=937164&lsid=be5c5db2-b599-4f63-adcd-426873f66c21&prod=&sgTask=0&cm= 1/1
Date: 28 Mar 2023
To: "Abdul Rivai Suleman" [email protected] From: "Water Practice and Technology" [email protected]
Subject: Your Submission has been accepted for publication WPT-D-22-00365R2
Water Practice and Technology
Article title: 'Flood Mitigation of Bila River in Sidrap Regency Indonesia Based on Eco-drainage Retention Pond' Reference No: WPT-D-22-00365R2
Dear Mr Abdul Rivai Suleman,
I am pleased to tell you that your work has now been accepted for publication in Water Practice and Technology. It was accepted on 27 Mar 2023
Any specific comments from the Editor and Reviewers may be found below.
If you would like to order an offprint of your accepted paper, please see here.
Thank you for submitting your work to this journal.
With kind regards, Lucy Ibbotson Journals Manager
Water Practice and Technology
Comments from the Editors and Reviewers:
Dear Author,
I accepted your manuscript for publication.
Best regards, Nese Yilmaz
In compliance with data protection regulations, you may request that we remove your personal registration details at any time.
(Remove my information/details). Please contact the publication office if you have any questions.
