ATOM INDONESIA
Author's Responses
Article : #947
Article Title : Characterization of the heat transfer on spray quenching for different material properties
Line # Referee’s Comments Author's Responses
Please explicitly declare the purpose of your study in ABSTRACT
and in INTRODUCTION. The purpose of study is already explicitly declared in
ABSTRACT and INTRODUCTION
.You have not improved the ABSTRACT. It has to consist of research
gap, research objective, research methodology, and results. It is already revised accordingly as suggested Furthermore, in ABSTRACT you mentioned: "... the spray flux of
4.2, 10 and 13.7 kg/m2s ...". Unfortunately, these spray flux never discussed in the manuscript.
Yes, it is.
It is discussed all over the discussion supported by figures in different boiling regime.
Since Nickel is also part of this study, please add the results of your
own experiment for Nickel into Figs. 10, 11, and 12. It is already revised accordingly as suggested Please provide scientific reason for choosing Nickel and Aluminum
alloy AA6082 for this study.
Scientifically, Nickel and Aluminum Alloy AA6082 are the two non- ferrous metals representing two different casting process from which they are produced. Nickel is produced through continuous casting process while AA6082 is through direct chill casting. Besides, they have different thermophysical properties which are suspected for the reason of having different quenching characteristics.
How do you decide the heating up temperature of 560o C?
Temperature of 560o C is the optimum point for comparing AA6082 and Nickel. Nickel physically can undergo a higher temperature but not for AA6082. Under this designated temperature both AA6082 and Nickel are still good physically and providing feasibility to see some phenomena of interest e.g., film boiling, Leidenfrost transition for the sake of analysis.
For CONCLUSION, please state only your main findings regarding
your research objectives. It is already revised accordingly as suggested
Please return to Atom Indonesia Editorial Office via
supplementary file in OJS application.February 10th, 2021
