JURNAL KEUANGAN DAN PERBANKAN
JOURNAL OF FINANCE AND BANKING
ISSN-P : 1410-8089 (Print) ISSN-E: 2443-2687 (On-line)
PAPER REVIEW FORM
Paper ID
:
8524
Title
:
The time horizon of corporate governance effect on firm performance: a study of Indonesia financial industry firms
Please rate the manuscript concerning the following items (X). Some of the fields are optional.
You do not have to fill out all categories.
Technical correctness: Novelty/originality: Reference to prior work:
Excellent Excellent Excellent
Good Good Good
Acceptable X Acceptable Acceptable x
Fair Fair X Fair
Very Poor Very Poor Very Poor
Quality of experimental results
Organization and clarity: Importance to the field:
Excellent Excellent Excellent
Good x Good Good
Acceptable Acceptable Acceptable x
Fair Fair X Fair
Very Poor Very Poor Very Poor
Comments About Paper:
Strengths Overall research method provides a complete and relevant method, followed by results that have been adequately explained and analyzed critically.
Weakness - The novelty, research gap, and update of this research are very low. Many titles similar to the same research object have been published previously.
- Only 72,91% of references of the last 10 years used in this research. The author need to increse the latest refences until at least 80% or more.
Other comments and Recommendation to Author
-The manuscript is poorly written in English. Did the author just translate them without using professional proofreading?
It’s tough to understand this manuscript.
1. Please do the proofreader using native people or professional services to revised this manuscript.
2. Please choosing just one English style to write this manuscript, either british or America style.
- The manuscript title is straightforward and informative but is too common.
- Please using the lastest 10 years published reference when writing the manuscript.
Recommendation (X):
Publish as it is
Publish with the minor revision noted above
Publish with major revision noted above √
Resubmit for review Resubmit Elsewhere
Decline Submission (Reject)
JURNAL KEUANGAN DAN PERBANKAN
JOURNAL OF FINANCE AND BANKING
ISSN-P : 1410-8089 (Print) ISSN-E: 2443-2687 (On-line)
PAPER REVIEW FORM
Paper ID
:
8524
Title
:
The time horizon of corporate governance effect on firm performance: a study of Indonesia financial industry firms
Please rate the manuscript concerning the following items (X). Some of the fields are optional.
You do not have to fill out all categories.
Technical correctness: Novelty/originality: Reference to prior work:
Excellent Excellent Excellent
Good X Good Good X
Acceptable Acceptable X Acceptable
Fair Fair Fair
Very Poor Very Poor Very Poor
Quality of experimental results
Organization and clarity: Importance to the field:
Excellent Excellent Excellent
Good Good X Good X
Acceptable X Acceptable Acceptable
Fair Fair Fair
Very Poor Very Poor Very Poor
Comments About Paper:
Strengths
1. The theme is in accordance with the JKP Journal’s theme.
2. The article template match with the JKP Journal’s template 3. Author has mentioned the grand theory of this research article.
4. Author has written references according to APA style rules
Weakness
1. The author does not mention the novelty of this research article.
2. In the introduction there is no explanation of the research gap between this research and previous studies.
3. The author still uses references to journal articles published before 2017 so they are not updated.
4. The author has not cited and mentioned in references, at least 2 article titles from the JKP Journal (Jurnal Keuangan dan Perbankan).
Other comments and Recommendation to Author
1. The author must mention the novelty of this research article in the Introduction
2. In the introduction there must be an explanation of the research gap between this research and previous studies.
3. The Author must use references to journal articles published after 2017 so that they are more updated.
4. The author must cite and mention in references, at least 2 article titles from the JKP Journal (Jurnal Keuangan dan Perbankan).
Recommendation (X):
Publish as it is
Publish with the minor revision noted above X
Publish with major revision noted above Resubmit for review
Resubmit Elsewhere
Decline Submission (Reject)
LETTER OF ACCEPTANCE
Dated: 10/01/2023 Dear Authors, Yie Ke Feliana
This article has passed the review, and the author has also made revisions; this article will be published in the JKP journal Vol 26 Number 4, Oktober 2022.
Title : The time horizon of corporate governance effect on firm performance: a study of Indonesia financial industry firms
Paper Id : JKP – 8524
Status : ACCEPTED WITH MINOR REVISION
we continue to improve the quality of the manuscript that will be published in JKP (Jurnal Keuangan dan Perbankan) SINTA 2 http://jurnal.unmer.ac.id/index.php/jkdp, Universitas Merdeka Malang, Indonesia, for that we thank you for your hard work in revising our reviewers, we congratulate you once again.
Best Regards,
Prof. Supramono., SE., MBA., DBA
Editor-In-Chief Jurnal Keuangan dan Perbankan
