1 Dear Dr Novita Dewi Kristanti,
Your Manuscript ID MH20210331030321-R2 with title "Encapsulated of Cassava, Skim Milk and Malto Dextrin symbiotic characteristic and their synergitic effects against Salmonella sp. Inhibition" has passed the initially quality checks and is now transferred to the Editor of the journal to be considered for review process.
This email is for your information only and there is nothing for you to do at this moment. We will keep you updated with further information.
Regards,
Nexus Academic Publishers
Nexus Academic Publishers (NAP) Lahore, Pakistan
Phone: 0092 300 7786573
email: [email protected] [email protected]
2
. Manuscript
Handler <info@manuscripthandler.
com>
S e l , 1 3 J u l 1 9. 0 2 kepada saya
Terjemahkan pesan
Nonaktifkan untuk: Inggris
Dear Dr Novita Dewi Kristanti,
We have received reviewer's reports or editor's assessments for your Manuscript ID
MH20210331030321-R2 with title Encapsulated of Cassava, Skim Milk and Malto Dextrin symbiotic characteristic and their synergitic effects against Salmonella sp. Inhibition in Advances in Animal and Veterinary Sciences.
The manuscript is with Editor to make final decision.
This decision may take some time as it is being discussed with the Editorial Board members. Not hearing the decision on your manuscirpt indicates that the decision is not yet agreed. As soon as the decision is committed, you will be informed.
This email is for your information only and there is nothing for you to do at this moment. We will keep you updated with further information.
Regards,
Nexus Academic Publishers (NAP) Lahore, Pakistan
Phone: 0092 300 7786573
email: [email protected]
BalasTer uskan
3 July 6, 2021
Dear: Editorial Office
Nexus Academic Publishers (NAP)
Response letter for our manuscript’s review
Firstly, we sincerely apologize for the delay in response. We highly appreciate the thoughtful review of the manuscript for all the reviewers and editors. Their suggestions are vital for the improvement of our manuscript. We agree with almost all their
comments and, thus, we have revised our manuscript accordingly.
We respond below in detail to each of the reviewer’s comments. We hope that the reviewers will be satisfied with our responses. We are willing to finish the revised version of the manuscript, including any further suggestions that the reviewers may have.
You may read all of the comments followed with our responses in italic attached with this letter.
We are looking forward to hearing from you soon.
Sincerely,
Novita dewi kristanti
Editor’s comment
Comment 1. Review the peer review comments and requests carefully, and edit the manuscript accordingly.
Response.
The correction has been made. We have been accepted all changes in document.
Comment 2. Include a separate point-by-point response file addressing the reviewers comments along with an explanation of any request of the editor or the reviewers that you do not address in your revised manuscript. Your list of responses should be uploaded as a Cover Letter in addition to your revised manuscript.
Response.
As suggested, we have been arranged and uploaded the cover letter.
Comment 3. Please colour (e.g. red in contrast to black text) all changes in the revised manuscript, without such coloured changes the manuscript may be returned or rejected.
Response.
All corrections in manuscript have been made in red font.
Comment 4. Verify the placement and accuracy of each reference in your manuscript as well as the accuracy of all of the values in your tables and figures.
Response.
We have been verifying all the reference and numbers on the table or in pictures.
Comment 5. Please ensure that all author’s names and their affiliations are placed correctly.
Response.
Author’s name and the affiliation have been written and sorted correctly.
Comment 6. Make every effort to address the remaining concerns and to resubmit your manuscript. If you anticipate an additional delay, or if you do not wish to resubmit your manuscript, then please notify us as soon as possible.
Response.
We tried to do the best to fix our manuscript.
Comment 7. Please keep your coauthors apprised of the status of the article throughout the revision process.
Response.
We have been informed all co-authors about the status of our article and we have been working together to revise the manuscript.
Reviewer 1
Comment [d1]. If it is okay, can we change the title? ? To Characteristic of
Synbiotics from Local Materials, Which are Encapsulated Using Skim Milk and Malto Dextrin? Because the inhibition against salmonella was not performed in this study and even not mentioned in your objectives. We can just state in the discussion that the encapsulated synbiotics could be a potential alternative on salmonella reduction in chickens
Response.
We have been change the title with ‘Encapsulated of cassava, Skim Milk and Malto Dextrin symbiotic characteristic and their synergitic effects against Salmonella sp.
Inhibition’. Because we have been added the inhibition against salmonella in this study and mentioned in our objectives.
Comment [d2]. Delete ‘word’.
Response.
As suggested, we have been deleted
Comment [d3]. You may state your abstract in shorter way or just direct to the point.
What was the general result?
Response.
As suggested, we have been changed the abstract in shorter Comment [d4]. Italize
Response.
As suggested, we have been changed to italize
Comment [d5]. Do you have limitations encountered of your study? You may also incorporate at least 1-2 sentences to give the readers the whole idea of the study that shows the methods, results and even possible recommendations based on the findings and or limitations of the present study
Response.
As suggested, we have been added sentences to the methods present that methods, results and even possible recommendations based on the study
Comment [d6]. Not italize Response.
As suggested, we have been changed to not italize Comment [d6]. Same comment with [d5]
Response.
As suggested, we have been changed to not italize Comment [d7]. Not italize
Response.
As suggested, we have been changed to not italize Comment [d8]. Not italize
Response.
As suggested, we have been changed to not italize
Comment [d9]. Please cite the author/s of this statements.
Response.
As suggested, we have been added cite the author/s of that statements in our manuscript Comment [d10]. Better if you can find a recent references.
Response.
As suggested, we have been added and explained in our manuscript
Comment [d11]. Can you search a related study that uses symbiotic and state the effects against Salmonella sp. and the levels of combination. So that your introduction will really provide a strong articulation.
Response.
As suggested, we have been added and explained in our manuscript about a related
study that uses symbiotic and state the effects against Salmonella sp Comment [d12]. Delete ‘word’
Response.
As suggested, we have been deleted Comment [d13]. Synbiotic
Response.
As suggested, we have been changed with correct ‘word’
Comment [d14]. Why is this different from the Trichoderma presented in the introduction? I guess, you should be consistent
Response.
As suggested, we have been consistent. The strain of Trichoderma is Trichoderma koningii
Comment [d15]. Its better I guess if you could provide at least 1-2 sentences here on pH test so that the reader will have an immediate idea how this being performed , though you have a citations, but much better to provide ideas on this
Response.
As suggested, we have been added and explained in our manuscript about pH test Comment [d16]. Follow comment 14
Response.
As suggested, we have been followed, added and explained in our manuscript about proximate test
Comment [d17]. In past form Response.
As suggested, we have been changed Comment [d18]. Pamungkas et al. (2011), Response.
As suggested, we have been changed Comment [d19]. 6.20
Response.
As suggested, we have been changed Comment [d20]. 4.40-5.80
Response.
As suggested, we have been changed Comment [d21]. Use decimal Response.
As suggested, we have been changed
Comment [d22]. Same comment ‘Use decimal’
Response.
As suggested, we have been changed
Comment [d23]. Please use decimal all figures of this table Response.
As suggested, we have been used decimal all figures of our table
Comment [d24]. decimal Response.
As suggested, we have been used decimal
Comment [d25]. What does this result mean? It’s better to elaborated what does it mean to decline? Or increase? Its better also to arrange the idea accordingly..
For example:
a. what is the general findings?
The results of the synbiotics was higher in…..as compare to…
b. why this is the result and the possible articulation?
The findings of this study suggest that….
c. what does it mean to have that result?
This means that …..
d. whom had related or inverse result?
This findings is in agreement/supported/coincided/related with the results of the study conducted by…..
Apply this throughout the discussion Response.
As suggested, we have been elaborated and explained the through out the idea on our manuscript
Comment [d26]. I think this can be deleted because this is part of proximate analysis Response.
As suggested, we have been deleted
Comment [d27]. Did Santoso (2011) mentioned up to what percentage of the DM could accelerate the accelerator?
Response.
As suggested, we have been accelerated Comment [d28]. Please indicate its source Response.
As suggested, we have been added the indicate
Comment [d29]. In my own opinion, and I hope I am correct, it’s not proper to claim as best treatment/combinations. It is safer to state the highest results or lowest was derived from…..
Apply this to the whole discussion.
Response.
As suggested, we have been applied and explained about treatment and combinations.
Comment [d30]. Use point/decimal/period, instead of comma. Apply this in the whole manuscript.
Response.
As suggested, we have been applied in our manuscript Comment [d31]. Use dot/decimal, not comma
Response.
As suggested, we have been applied in our manuscript
Comment [d32]. The encapsulated synbiotics based of the results could be a potential for reducing salmonella in chickens, however, the highlighted statement should not be included here because the test for salmonella using the encapsulated symbiotic was not performed in this study. Instead, state here that the findings of this study could be a potential for salmonella reduction. This is a good future research as alternative to antibiotic as you mentioned in the introduction.
Response.
As suggested, we have been added and explained in our manuscript about how The encapsulated synbiotics based of the results could be a potential for reducing Salmonella in chickens
Comment [d33]. This conclusion is too long. Please summarize this by stating the general findings or the highlight and the possible recommendation based on the findings and or limitations of the study.
Response.
As suggested, we have been made conclude and summarized short Comment [d34]. Enclose with parenthesis
Response.
As suggested, we have been Enclosed with parenthesis
Reviewer 2
Comment [YK1]. Encapsulated of cassava, Skim Milk and Malto Dextrin symbiotic characteristic and their synergitic effects against Salmonella sp. Inhibition Response.
As suggested, we have been changed
Comment [YK2]. Remove the ANOVA test in your result reportiing Response.
As suggested, we have been deleted
Comment [YK3]. Need to elaborate your result rather than reporting significantly difference or not. Use appropriate word which justif
Response.
As suggested, we have been elaborated and explained in our manuscript Comment [YK4]. Define what is RAK? pattern
Response.
As suggested, we have been added
Comment [YK5]. What about the bacterial inhibition potential of the symbiosis of the cassava, skim milk and malto dextrin ?
Response.
As suggested, we have been explained in our manuscript Comment [YK6]. Future tense
Response.
As suggested, we have been changed
Comment [YK7]. Indicate the specific humidity range at that time Response.
As suggested, we have been explained in our manuscript Comment [YK8]. Is this a proposal or article
Response.
As suggested, We have made corrections in the reference
Comment [YK9]. Should be written following the procedure indicated Rakhmani (2005)
Response.
As suggested, We have made corrections in the reference Comment [YK10]. Use standard (SI unit) e.g. gram= g Response.
As suggested, we have been used
Comment [YK11]. Write in appropriate way of narrriating your report .. If the fungus grow in room temperature whay you said 25-370C
Response.
As suggested, we have been added and explained in our manuscript Comment [YK12]. This is more of discussion not Methodology
Response.
As suggested, we have been change
Comment [YK13]. Following the procedure/formula of Bacteriological Analytical Manual, Husmaini (2012).
Response.
As suggested, We have made corrections in the reference
Comment [YK14]. What is your base to select the following ratio?
Response.
As suggested, we have been added and explained in our manuscript Comment [YK15]. FIELD CODE CHANGED
Response.
As suggested, we have been changed
Comment [YK16]. This is direct speech. Please write in scientifical way of reporting speech Response.
As suggested, we have been added and explained in our manuscript
Comment [YK17]. The collected data was subjected to ANOVA using SPSS version 17.
Further Treatments mean differences were separated by using Duncan test.
Response.
As suggested, we have been added and explained in our manuscript Comment [YK18]. -
Response.
As suggested, we have been added’a’
Comment [YK19]. Of what?
Response.
As suggested, we have been explained in the title table 2. pH Synbiotics Cassava Flour Media
Comment [YK20]. Please make it short and conclude and summarized based on your main or important findings!
Response.
As suggested, we have been made conclude and summarized short
AUTHOR QUERY FORM
Journal: AAVS
Article Name: Encapsulated of Cassava, Skim Milk and Malto Dextrin Symbiotic Characteristic and their Synergitic Effects against Salmonella sp. Inhibition
Corresponding Author: Novita Dewi Kristanti Author Queries:
1. During the process of final proofreading and typesetting of your manuscript, the following queries have arisen. The queries are related to RED text in the galley proof. Please check your typeset proof carefully against the queries listed below and make the necessary changes either on this query form or directly on the PDF galley proof. Watch short demo (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VsvY660PIok)or follow the page given beneath for making changes directly in the pdf.
2. No further changes will be allowed once article will be fully published.
Quer y Ref
Page number
Details required Author’s
response
AQ1
Please carefully check:
1) Names of all authors (First Name and Surname) 2) They are given in the correct order
3) Their affiliation are labelled and are given in the correct order Please note that once the article has been submitted the list of authorship is not liable to be changed. No additions, deletions or change in order will be accepted/allowed.
AQ2 Please check for the scientific names and confirm that they all are given in correct order and italic font style.
AQ3 Please go through the reference list and delete the references that are not cited in the text.
AQ4 All The references in red are not given in the reference section of the article. Please provide these.
AQ5 7 Please provide Novelty statement.
AQ8 6 Table 9 is not cited in the text please check.
Any query or additional file related to the article may be sent to email
Making Corrections in Galley Proof (PDF) File
Please follow these instructions to mark changes or to add notes in the galley proof. You can use Adobe Acrobat professional version 7.0 (or onwards) or Adobe Reader 8 (or onwards)). The latest version of Adobe Reader is available to download for free atget.adobe.com/reader.
For additional help please use the Helpfunction or, if you have Adobe Acrobat Professional 7.0 (or onwards), go tohttp://www.adobe.com/education/pdf/acrobat_curriculum7/acrobat7_lesson04.pdf
Displaying the toolbars
To display the toolbar please follow this link:
Adobe Reader 8: Select Tools Comments &Markup Show Comments and Markup Toolbar. You must see the following bar:
Acrobat Professional 7: Select Tools Commenting Show Commenting Toolbar.
Adobe Reader 10: To edit the galley proofs, use the Comment Toolbar (Sticky Note and Highlight Text).
Using Text Edits
This is the quickest, simplest and easiestmethod both to make corrections, and for your corrections to be transferred and checked.
1. Click Text Edits
2. Select the text to be annotated or place your cursorat the insertion point.
3. Click the Text Edits drop down arrow and select therequired action.
You can also right click on selected text for a rangeof commenting options.
Pop up Notes
With Text Editsand other markup, it is possible to add notes. In some cases (e.g. inserting or replacing text), a pop-up note is displayed automatically.
Display:Todisplay the pop-up note for other markup, right click on the annotation on the document and selecting OpenPop-Up Note.
Move: To movea note, click and drag on the title area.
Resize:Toresizethe note, click and drag on the bottom right corner.
Close:Toclosethe note, click on the cross in the top right hand corner.
Delete: To delete a note, right click on it and select Delete. The edit and associated note will be removed.
Saving the comments: Don’t forget to save the comments
To save your comments, save the file (Filesave) before closing.
AUTHOR QUERY FORM
Journal: AAVS
Article Name: Encapsulated of Cassava, Skim Milk and Malto Dextrin Symbiotic Characteristic and their Synergitic Effects against Salmonella sp. Inhibition
Corresponding Author: Novita Dewi Kristanti Author Queries:
1. During the process of final proofreading and typesetting of your manuscript, the following queries have arisen. The queries are related to RED text in the galley proof. Please check your typeset proof carefully against the queries listed below and make the necessary changes either on this query form or directly on the PDF galley proof. Watch short demo (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VsvY660PIok)or follow the page given beneath for making changes directly in the pdf.
2. No further changes will be allowed once article will be fully published.
Quer
y Ref Page
number Details required Author’s response
AQ1
Please carefully check:
1) Names of all authors (First Name and Surname) 2) They are given in the correct order
3) Their affiliation are labelled and are given in the correct order
Please note that once the article has been submitted the list of authorship is not liable to be changed. No additions, deletions or change in order will be accepted/allowed.
Corrected name of author’s is KARTIKA BUDI UTAMI
(UTAMI KB)
AQ2
Please check for the scientific names and confirm that they all are given in correct order and italic font style.
Salmonella sp, Trichoderma and Salmonellosis are italic font style
AQ3 Please go through the reference list and delete the references that are not cited in the text.
We’ve deleted references that were not cited by marking them in red:
Husmaini (2012):
Purwoko (2007):
Rulinggar et al., 2017:
Saju et al. (2002):
Sudarmaji et al., 1984:
Penta
and Mujoko (2012):
Sitio and Alam, 2019:
Saono (1976):
Gray and Williams
(1971):
Fardiaz, 1987:
Adriansyah et al., 2015:
AQ4 All
The references in red are not given in the reference section of the article. Please provide these.
We agree that all references are not given in the reference section of the article
AQ5 7 Please provide Novelty statement.
Novelty statement stated: “The development of Trichoderma
probiotics that are bred in local ingredients such as bran, corn and cassava which are available in Indonesia is expected to provide opportunities for farmers to be able to make their own synbiotics mixed in feed, so as to achieve independence in the provision of feed to increase the
availability of healthy animal protein”.
AQ8 6 Table 9 is not cited in the text please check. It’s clear that there is no Table 9 in the text.
Any query or additional file related to the article may be sent to email
Dear Author,
It is our pleasure to inform you that your article is now fully published in Advances in Animal and Veterinary Sciences:
http://nexusacademicpublishers.com/table_of_contents_articles/4/SXNzdWUgMTA=/20 21
It is the responsibility of the corresponding author to update all co-authors. We take this opportunity to exploit our social media tools for dissemination of your work and
increasing the impact of your research. You can go to the html version of the article and share your article by clicking on either of the social media icons including Twitter,
Facebook, LinkedIn etc. Additionally, we request all authors to cite this article where it is appropriate and valuable.
Thank you very much for your contribution in Advances in Animal and Veterinary Sciences and we look forward to receiving your future contributions soon.
Submit next article at: http://manuscripthandler.com/nexus/Advances-in-Animal-and- Veterinary-Sciences
Regards, Irfan Rasool Managing Editor,
Nexus Academic Publishers (NAP)
Website: http://nexusacademicpublishers.com Email: [email protected];
[email protected] 0092 300 7786573
Novita Kristanti <[email protected]> Sen, 6 Sep21.23 kepada Nexus
Dear Editor
Thanks for your information.
Regard
Dari: Nexus Academics <[email protected]>
Date: Sab, 21 Agu 2021 22.14
Subject: Galley Proof of your Article (AAVS_MH20210331030321-R2_Kristanti et al) in Advances in Animal and Veterinary Sciences
To: Yendry Junaidi <[email protected]>, Rohaim, Mohammed
Dear Author,
Thank you very much for your contribution in AAVS.
We have now formatted your article according to the journal's format. Please take a good look before its final publication in full. There is a query form attached for the queries arose during type setting. You can
send changes in reply to this email. Once you have approved your page proof and the final version is published on the journal website, no additional changes will be allowed.
Thank you for your fine contribution. On behalf of the Editors of the AAVS, we look forward to your continued contributions to the Journal.
Regards, Irfan Rasool Managing Editor,
Nexus Academic Publishers (NAP)
Website: http://nexusacademicpublishers.com Email: [email protected];
[email protected] 0092 300 7786573
