99 | Fakultas Agama Islam Universitas Wahid Hasyim
Navigating Constraints: Innovative Strategies for Education in Limited Spaces and Small City
Dian Nafiatul Awaliyah
Sultan Fatah University, Demak, Indonesia email:
[email protected]Abstract:
This paper explores the challenges and solutions associated with providing education in constrained environments, focusing on limited physical spaces and the specific hurdles faced by small city. The background highlights issues such as restricted space, resource scarcity, and the need for innovative approaches. The research question addresses how education can adapt and thrive in constrained settings. The research objective is to identify effective strategies and methodologies for delivering quality education within limited physical spaces and small state contexts. Utilizing a qualitative research method, the study analyzes diverse educational approaches, including project-based learning, technology integration, distance education, and place-based learning. Findings emphasize the transformative role of technology in overcoming isolation, the importance of tailored, community-centered education, and the need for adaptability and creativity in addressing constraints. Insights also reveal a collective commitment to global collaboration, individualized learning, and the incorporation of experiential and blended learning methods. The paper concludes by advocating for a dynamic and inclusive educational paradigm that equips students with essential skills in a rapidly evolving global landscape.
Keywords: architecture, place, city, education, adaptation, resilience
INTRODUCTION
Education is a dynamic field continually evolving to meet the diverse needs of learners in various contexts. This paper delves into the intricacies of providing education in environments characterized by constraints, focusing on two distinct yet interconnected realms – limited physical spaces and the unique challenges faced by small city. As educational landscapes grapple with spatial restrictions, resource scarcities, and the complexities of globalization, the imperative for innovative solutions becomes increasingly evident. Addressing these challenges necessitates a comprehensive examination of methodologies, technologies, and pedagogical approaches that not only adapt to constraints but also thrive within them.
The exploration begins with an examination of the challenges associated with education in limited physical spaces, where considerations range from spatial constraints and resource deficiencies to the transformative potential of technology. Concurrently, the paper shifts its focus to the nuanced challenges encountered by small city, navigating the impacts of globalization while fostering locally relevant education. By scrutinizing these two facets, the research endeavors to answer the fundamental question: How can education adapt and flourish within constrained environments?
METHOD
This research adopts a qualitative approach through an extensive literature study to explore and analyze innovative strategies for education in constrained environments, focusing on limited physical spaces and the challenges faced by small city. Qualitative methods are well-suited to this investigation as they allow for an in-depth examination of existing literature, theoretical frameworks, and practical applications in diverse educational contexts. The foundation of the qualitative method involves an exhaustive review of academic articles, research papers, books, and reports related to education in constrained environments. The literature review encompasses studies addressing limited physical spaces, technological interventions, project-based learning, distance education, and the unique challenges faced by small city. Thematic analysis is employed to identify recurring themes, patterns, and key concepts within the reviewed literature. The analysis involves categorizing findings related to innovative educational strategies, challenges,
and successful implementations. Themes such as project-based learning, technology integration, distance education, and place-based learning emerge as focal points for deeper exploration. The qualitative method involves synthesizing insights derived from the literature study. This synthesis entails constructing a cohesive narrative that encapsulates the key learnings, challenges, and effective strategies for education in limited physical spaces and small city.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Providing education in a small space presents both challenges and opportunities. The challenges include limited physical space for classrooms and facilities, which can restrict the number of students that can be accommodated and limit the types of activities that can be conducted (Lateef, 2023). Additionally, small spaces may lack the resources and infrastructure necessary for effective teaching and learning, such as technology and specialized equipment (Michael, 2022). However, there are also opportunities in small spaces. Technological advancements, such as the internet, have reduced the isolation of small states and provided access to expertise and resources that were previously unavailable (Maicon, 2022). Furthermore, small spaces can foster a sense of community and collaboration among students and educators, creating a supportive learning environment (Jeffrey, 2022). Overall, while there are challenges, small spaces can still provide quality education through innovative approaches and leveraging available resources.
This passage explores the dichotomy of challenges and opportunities in providing education within limited physical spaces. Challenges of Limited Physical Space: The passage identifies several challenges associated with small spaces, particularly in terms of physical limitations. Limited space for classrooms and facilities is mentioned, which can restrict the number of students that can be accommodated. This limitation may also constrain the types of activities that can be conducted within the available space. Additionally, the lack of resources and infrastructure necessary for effective teaching and learning, such as technology and specialized equipment, is highlighted. This suggests that the educational experience may be compromised due to the absence of essential tools and facilities.
Despite the challenges, the passage also underscores the opportunities that small spaces can offer. Technological advancements, specifically the internet, are mentioned as a means of reducing the isolation of small states. This connectivity provides access to expertise and resources that were previously unavailable, potentially enriching the educational experience. Another opportunity highlighted is the potential for small spaces to foster a sense of community and collaboration among students and educators. The close-knit environment can create a supportive learning atmosphere, encouraging cooperation and shared learning experiences. The passage concludes by suggesting that, despite the challenges, small spaces can still provide quality education through innovative approaches and by leveraging available resources. This implies that adaptability and creativity are crucial in overcoming physical constraints and ensuring a positive learning experience.
Small states, which comprise over half of the Commonwealth, receive special attention from the Commonwealth Secretariat, but the contexts and modalities have changed significantly over the years due to globalization and technological advances (Michael, 2022). Place-based education, which engages young people in meaningful investigations in their local community, shows promise in advancing childhood nature and developing agency in students (Bob Coulter, 2022). However, age-appropriate youth leadership, continuous skill development, and maintaining connection to place are crucial for the success of place-based education projects (Ahmed, 2023).
Additionally, educators should consider the role of 'place' in outdoor education experiences, as it can help students make sense of their personal and communal identity (Anita, 2013). Emphasizing relationships with place(s) can lead to a deeper understanding of oneself, connections with others, and the meanings derived from the places in which we live and teach (Mike Brown, 2018).
The passage notes that the contexts and modalities for education in small states have evolved due to globalization and technological advances. This implies that education systems must adapt to these changing global dynamics to remain effective and relevant. The concept of place-based education is introduced as a promising approach to engage young people in meaningful investigations within their local community. This approach aims to enhance childhood nature and develop students' agency, suggesting a more experiential and community-centered learning model. The success of place-based education projects is contingent on age-appropriate youth leadership, continuous skill development, and maintaining a connection to place. This highlights the importance of not only the
101 | Fakultas Agama Islam Universitas Wahid Hasyim
educational content but also the pedagogical and leadership aspects for effective learning outcomes. The passage emphasizes the role of 'place' in outdoor education experiences. Understanding one's personal and communal identity through the environment is considered crucial. This suggests that outdoor education should not only focus on physical activities but also on fostering a sense of identity and connection to the surroundings. Building relationships with places is seen as a means to achieve a deeper understanding of oneself, connections with others, and deriving meaning from the environment. This holistic approach suggests that education should go beyond the traditional classroom setting and consider the broader context of the students' lives. In summary, the passage highlights the need for tailored approaches in education for small city, considering the evolving global landscape. It advocates for a place-based education model that fosters a connection between students and their local environment, emphasizing youth leadership, skill development, and a deeper understanding of personal and communal identity.
The strategies to handle how to provide best education at the small place, can be learnt from previous researches.
A dynamic approach to teaching that encourages students to gain knowledge and skills by working on real-world problems and challenges, while developing cross-curriculum skills and soft skills. "Project-based learning is a dynamic approach to teaching in which students explore real-world problems and challenges, simultaneously developing cross- curriculum skills while working in small collaborative groups.", "Projects are often interdisciplinary."SedighehSadat Moein 2013. "This study focuses on the results obtained from the teacher's assessment of Project-Based Learning, a methodological approach that implies a change in the university pedagogical paradigm that affects both the teaching and learning processes.", "Among the results obtained, it is worth mentioning that the teacher considers the Project- Based Learning a methodology that favours in the classroom, constituting a valid alternative to improve the quality of learning in university students."Rodríguez Gómez & María de las Mercedes 2020
"In this chapter we will describe two teaching methods which provide education through technological settings and project-based learning to foster soft skills in the students with the aim of learning disciplinary competences: (i) The Extended Learning Environment, where two or more classrooms work together on a common school subject project using different kind of technological setting.", "Distance lessons could be an opportunity to overcome isolation and offer equal and quality teaching activities within curriculum."Giuseppina Rita Jose Mangione & Giuseppina Cannella 2021
Many educational organizations allow their students to access social media platform such as Facebook etc and conduct collaborative exercises on it. One of the critical aspects of enhancing learning through social networks is the fact that distance or off-campus students are limited from meeting with their teachers and addressing them face-to- face. However, both on-campus and off-campus students do have a Facebook account, thus breaking the distance barrier between students and teachers. By using Facebook chat, students can communicate in real-time with each other or with their lecturers. "Many educational organizations allow their students to access social media platform such as Facebook etc and conduct collaborative exercises on it.", "However, both on-campus and off-campus students do have a Facebook account, thus breaking the distance barrier between students and teachers."Q. Mohammed 2020
The use of online courses and technology-driven instructional platforms for education, including e-tools and e- resources in a Virtual Learning Environment. "With the involvement of various e-tools, teaching and learning process is reaching its next level of implementation.", "At present, almost every educational establishment is working on implementing various e-resources on their own Virtual Learning Environment."Q. Mohammed 2020. Other such platforms include Microsoft Kaizala, which is becoming popular during these days since it doesn‘t require the participants to share their private accounts or mobile numbers in order to do an online collaboration for academic purpose. "Other such platforms include Microsoft Kaizala, which is becoming popular during these days since it doesn‘t require the participants to share their private accounts or mobile numbers in order to do an online collaboration for academic purpose.", "This research paper contains a study of various online collaborative tools, their pros and cons, recommendations for usage and implementation."Q. Mohammed 2020
A method put forward to facilitate the sharing of high-quality teacher resources in experimental areas. "In this paper, synchronous interactive hybrid classroom and synchronous interactive special delivery classroom teaching are
put forward to facilitate the sharing of high-quality teacher resources in experimental areas.", "Rural small schools in China have characteristics including remote location, small scale and poor conditions in infrastructure, quality of teaching and teacher."Mingzhang Zuo 2019
A study of various online collaborative tools, their pros and cons, recommendations for usage and implementation. Finally, the authors will reflect on their studies and suggest various ways of implementations for different purpose and nature of assessments, in order to cover the learning outcomes of the session. "This research paper contains a study of various online collaborative tools, their pros and cons, recommendations for usage and implementation.", "Finally, the authors will reflect on their studies and suggest various ways of implementations for different purpose and nature of assessments, in order to cover the learning outcomes of the session."Q. Mohammed 2020.
Providing education through online platforms, specifically targeting rural areas. "This paper describes a one- term collaborative professional learning program for multigrade classrooms, delivered online, in rural government schools in south western NSW.", "Participants work across schools in an online community of practice, facilitated through a series of modules and delivered using Adobe Connect, an online meeting software program."L. Beveridge
& S. Armstrong 2017
Implementing different approaches and options for consolidating schools."The study found that the best international practices for consolidating schools with a small number of students are based on a national consolidation manual, diversity in standards of consolidation and its alternatives, raising the awareness of the local community, and provision of safe and comfortable school transportation.", "Finally, the study provided suggestions for consolidating schools to improve the efficiency of public education expenditure in Saudi Arabia."Fayez Abdulrahman Al Fayez &
Abdullah Alsadhan 2021
Working with learners to accept and assess their accomplishments demonstrated through learning experiences.
"Finding ways to work with learners to accept and assess accomplishments that they demonstrate through learning experiences will help districts’ provisions seem pertinent to learners’ deeply connected lives and will help cultivate the orientation toward lifelong learning that seems increasingly necessary for success in our rapidly evolving world.",
"Customized Individual Learning Plans With so many resources and supports available, there is more and more opportunity for learners to participate in anytime, anywhere learning – and for schools to incorporate such learning into their broad view of achievement."S. Chugach 2018
Including an emphasis on information and communication technology in the educational curriculum."The goal of the program is to support teachers in building school capacity through planning and implementing quality literature- based, cross curricular units of work, with an ICT focus.", "'Creating Integrated Multigrade Units' in the Small Schools was trialled in Term 4 2015, and implemented from 2016."L. Beveridge & S. Armstrong 2017
The integration of anytime, anywhere learning into schools' broad view of achievement."Customized Individual Learning Plans With so many resources and supports available, there is more and more opportunity for learners to participate in anytime, anywhere learning – and for schools to incorporate such learning into their broad view of achievement.", "Creating A World of Learning"S. Chugach 2018
Informing and educating the local community about the consolidation process."The study aimed to review the best international practices for the consolidation of public schools in areas with low population density in order to improve the efficiency of public education expenditure.", "The study found that the best international practices for consolidating schools with a small number of students are based on a national consolidation manual, diversity in standards of consolidation and its alternatives, raising the awareness of the local community, and provision of safe and comfortable school transportation."Fayez Abdulrahman Al Fayez & Abdullah Alsadhan 2021
The incorporation of electronic media and resources in the learning process."The article analyzes the potential and capabilities of the blended learning method as didactic means of transition implementation from the traditional learning model to the integrated one using electronic media and resources.", "Digital learning mecha-nisms can sustain the interest of students through graphics, videos and other methods."S. Ussipashim & A. Niyazova 2019. Utilizing online meeting software programs, such as Adobe Connect, to deliver the program modules."Participants work across schools in an online community of practice, facilitated through a series of modules and delivered using Adobe Connect,
103 | Fakultas Agama Islam Universitas Wahid Hasyim
an online meeting software program.", "Small schools are unique places where teachers are challenged by implementing curriculum and providing individualised learning to students from multiple ages and stages in the one classroom."L. Beveridge & S. Armstrong 2017
Providing teachers in small schools and multigrade classrooms with the ability and support to create and implement their own curriculum units."The program aims to empower teachers in small schools and multigrade classrooms to design and implement their own quality, literature-based units that link syllabus outcomes and address local students' learning needs and interests.", "The goal of the program is to support teachers in building school capacity through planning and implementing quality literature-based, cross curricular units of work, with an ICT focus."L.
Beveridge & S. Armstrong 2017
Bringing books and learning materials to small places and accessing cloud-based e-resources from any location."At present, almost every educational establishment is working on implementing various e-resources on their own Virtual Learning Environment.", "The education sector has already embraced the new generation of technology and started working towards the enhancement of various teaching and learning strategies."Q. Mohammed 2020
Creating a virtual community where teachers from various schools can collaborate and share best practices."Participants work across schools in an online community of practice, facilitated through a series of modules and delivered using Adobe Connect, an online meeting software program.", "This paper describes a one-term collaborative professional learning program for multigrade classrooms, delivered online, in rural government schools in south western NSW."L. Beveridge & S. Armstrong 2017
A customized approach to education that takes into account each student's strengths and weaknesses, allowing for anytime, anywhere learning."Customized Individual Learning Plans With so many resources and supports available, there is more and more opportunity for learners to participate in anytime, anywhere learning – and for schools to incorporate such learning into their broad view of achievement.", "Creating A World of Learning"S. Chugach 2018 The use of interactive features in mobile applications to activate learners and create a new and familiar learning environment."These applications can be successfully combined and used as a tool for formal and non-formal learning, offering interactive features that activate learners and create a new and familiar learning environment.", "Learning and teaching nowadays could be done at a different stage of our lives."Nadezhda Angelova 2019
Engaging students in complex activities, usually requiring several steps and some duration, and cooperative group learning."It usually requires several steps and some duration-more than a couple of class days and up to a semester-and cooperative group learning.", "Project-based learning is a teaching and learning strategy that engages students in complex activities."SedighehSadat Moein 2013. The provision of immediate feedback to students to encourage their active participation and involvement."Digital learning mecha-nisms can sustain the interest of students through graphics, videos and other methods.", "The article analyzes the potential and capabilities of the blended learning method as didactic means of transition implementation from the traditional learning model to the integrated one using electronic media and resources."S. Ussipashim & A. Niyazova 2019
Distance lessons could be an opportunity to overcome isolation and offer equal and quality teaching activities within the curriculum."Distance lessons could be an opportunity to overcome isolation and offer equal and quality teaching activities within curriculum.", "Nevertheless, it is extremely important to guarantee equal opportunities and services to those who live on the mountains and small islands of the country."Giuseppina Rita Jose Mangione &
Giuseppina Cannella 2021. The practice of using information technology to share high-quality teacher resources from urban schools to rural schools."The article concludes with a discussion of the findings for sharing teacher resources to provide equal educational opportunities between urban and rural areas.", "This article introduces a case of practicing the sharing of high-quality teacher resources by information technology from the urban school to the rural school in Xian’an district, Hubei province."Mingzhang Zuo 2019
"The education sector has already embraced the new generation of technology and started working towards the enhancement of various teaching and learning strategies.", "When it comes to group assessments, various collaborative tools come into the picture."Q. Mohammed 2020. "The article analyzes the potential and capabilities of the blended
learning method as didactic means of transition implementation from the traditional learning model to the integrated one using electronic media and resources.", "Blended learning methods involve tools that allow creativity in lessons and subjects."S. Ussipashim & A. Niyazova 2019
The most significant way to address the shortage of teacher resources in rural small schools and provide sufficient and high-quality courses. "In this paper, synchronous interactive hybrid classroom and synchronous interactive special delivery classroom teaching are put forward to facilitate the sharing of high-quality teacher resources in experimental areas.", "To address the problem and help offer sufficient and high-quality courses in rural small schools, the sharing of high-quality teacher resources are the most significant way to achieve it."Mingzhang Zuo 2019 Supporting teachers in designing and implementing high-quality units of work that integrate literature, align with curriculum outcomes, and cater to students' learning needs and interests."The goal o f the program is to support teachers in building school capacity through planning and implementing quality literature-based, cross curricular units of work, with an ICT focus.", "The program aims to empower teachers in small schools and multigrade classrooms to design and implement their own quality, literature-based units that link syllabus outcomes and address local students' learning needs and interests."L. Beveridge & S. Armstrong 2017
Two or more classrooms work together on a common school subject project using different kinds of technological settings."In this chapter we will describe two teaching methods which provide education through technological settings and project-based learning to foster soft skills in the students with the aim of learning disciplinary competences: (i) The Extended Learning Environment, where two or more classrooms work together on a common school subject project using different kind of technological setting.", "(ii) The Shared lesson, based on every day distance learning activities."Giuseppina Rita Jose Mangione & Giuseppina Cannella 2021
Transforming lessons into interactive sessions that are eagerly anticipated and enjoyed by both teachers and students."Lessons become interactive sessions that teachers and students look forward to and enjoy.", "This method of learning is not monotonous but it is always evolving to improve training."S. Ussipashim & A. Niyazova 2019. "At present, almost every educational establishment is working on implementing various e-resources on their own Virtual Learning Environment.", "The education sector has already embraced the new generation of technology and started working towards the enhancement of various teaching and learning strategies."Q. Mohammed 2020. "Finding ways to work with learners to accept and assess accomplishments that they demonstrate through learning experiences will help districts’ provisions seem pertinent to learners’ deeply connected lives and will help cultivate the orientation toward lifelong learning that seems increasingly necessary for success in our rapidly evolving world.", "Customized Individual Learning Plans With so many resources and supports available, there is more and more opportunity for learners to participate in anytime, anywhere learning – and for schools to incorporate such learning into their broad view of achievement."S. Chugach 2018
Ensuring that the professional learning program meets the requirements for teachers seeking accreditation at the proficient teacher level"It is now registered professional learning at proficient teacher level that contributes to professional learning requirements for teachers seeking accreditation in NSW schools.", "'Creating Integrated Multigrade Units' in the Small Schools was trialled in Term 4 2015, and implemented from 2016."L. Beveridge & S.
Armstrong 2017
The modification of existing blended learning models to suit the conditions of the specific educational system.
"Identify existing blended learning models discuss ways to adapt them to the con-ditions of the Kazakhstan university system.", "The article analyzes the potential and capabilities of the blended learning method as didactic means of transition implementation from the traditional learning model to the integrated one using electronic media and resources."S. Ussipashim & A. Niyazova 2019
Regular training and workshops for teachers to ensure they are up-to-date with the latest teaching methods, technologies, and online instruction."With the involvement of various e-tools, teaching and learning process is reaching its next level of implementation.", "The education sector has already embraced the new generation of technology and started working towards the enhancement of various teaching and learning strategies."Q. Mohammed 2020
Projects in project-based learning that are often interdisciplinary, allowing students to apply knowledge and skills from multiple subject areas."Projects are often interdisciplinary.", "Project-based learning is a dynamic approach
105 | Fakultas Agama Islam Universitas Wahid Hasyim
to teaching in which students explore real-world problems and challenges, simultaneously developing cross-curriculum skills while working in small collaborative groups."SedighehSadat Moein 2013
Based on everyday distance learning activities, two classrooms (with students of different levels) of different schools define a smart setting with a video-conferencing system and knowledge forum on a daily basis sharing the same lesson at the same time of school."(ii) The Shared lesson, based on every day distance learning activities.", "Two classrooms (with students of different levels) of different schools define a smart setting with video-conferencing system and knowledge forum on a daily basis sharing the same lesson in the same time of school."Giuseppina Rita Jose Mangione & Giuseppina Cannella 2021
A manual that provides guidelines for consolidating schools with a small number of students."The study found that the best international practices for consolidating schools with a small number of students are based on a national consolidation manual, diversity in standards of consolidation and its alternatives, raising the awareness of the local community, and provision of safe and comfortable school transportation.", "Finally, the study provided suggestions for consolidating schools to improve the efficiency of public education expenditure in Saudi Arabia."Fayez Abdulrahman Al Fayez & Abdullah Alsadhan 2021
The educators can adopt experiential learning as part of their teaching methods. This approach allows students to relate and apply the knowledge they gained in the classroom into real-life situations. It also helps students acquire a myriad of skills such as teamwork, communication, technological, leadership, critical thinking, and other soft skills."A real life situation.", "experiential learning such as teamwork, communication, technological, leadership, critical thinking and other soft"Nur Hafidah Abd Kadir 2018
The utilization of online resources to enable creativity in lessons and subjects. "Blended learning methods involve tools that allow creativity in lessons and subjects.", "The article analyzes the potential and capabilities of the blended learning method as didactic means of transition implementation from the traditional learning model to the integrated one using electronic media and resources."S. Ussipashim & A. Niyazova 2019
The utilization of digital learning mechanisms such as graphics and videos to maintain student interest."Digital learning mecha-nisms can sustain the interest of students through graphics, videos and other methods.", "The article analyzes the potential and capabilities of the blended learning method as didactic means of transition implementation from the traditional learning model to the integrated one using electronic media and resources."S. Ussipashim & A.
Niyazova 2019. The resolution of issues that hinder the effective and rapid integration of e-learning environments."Problems impeding the effective and rapid integration of e-learning environments are indentified, and some strategic initiatives to address them are suggested.", "Digital learning mecha-nisms can sustain the interest of students through graphics, videos and other methods."S. Ussipashim & A. Niyazova 2019
Developing students' confidence and self-direction as they move through both team-based and independent work."In addition, students develop confidence and self-direction as they move through both team-based and independent work.", "Projects are often interdisciplinary."SedighehSadat Moein 2013
Providing transportation services that are safe and comfortable for students in consolidated schools."The study found that the best international practices for consolidating schools with a small number of students are based on a national consolidation manual, diversity in standards of consolidation and its alternatives, raising the awareness of the local community, and provision of safe and comfortable school transportation.", "Finally, the study provided suggestions for consolidating schools to improve the efficiency of public education expenditure in Saudi Arabia."Fayez Abdulrahman Al Fayez & Abdullah Alsadhan 2021
Tools that support and facilitate the learning process by providing easy and fast access to learning resources at any time and place, making learning fun and interactive."Mobile technologies and applications support and facilitate the learning process because they provide easy and fast access to learning resources at any time and place.", "Learning and teaching nowadays could be done at a different stage of our lives."Nadezhda Angelova 2019. "The mobile apps contains explanation on experiential learning, is proven benefits to both learners and educators and examples of experiential learning activities that can assist the educators who wish to embark on this method", "Thus, researchers
took the initiative to design a mobile apps that serves as a quick guide for educators at all level of education to adopt experiential learning as part of their methods of teaching."Nur Hafidah Abd Kadir 2018. A one-term program delivered online, aimed at supporting teachers in building school capacity through planning and implementing quality literature- based, cross-curricular units of work, with an ICT focus. "This paper describes a one-term collaborative professional learning program for multigrade classrooms, delivered online, in rural government schools in south western NSW.",
"The goal of the program is to support teachers in building school capacity through planning and implementing quality literature-based, cross curricular units of work, with an ICT focus."L. Beveridge & S. Armstrong 2017
The use of technology-based learning methods to improve student retention in classrooms or in online education."Tech-based learning has been proven to increase the retention of students in classrooms or in online education.", "The article analyzes the potential and capabilities of the blended learning method as didactic means of transition implementation from the traditional learning model to the integrated one using electronic media and resources."S. Ussipashim & A. Niyazova 2019
Fostering a collaborative environment in classrooms where students work together to improve student learning through different perspectives and real-time communication."By using Facebook chat, students can communicate in real-time with each other or with their lecturers.", "However, both on-campus and off-campus students do have a Facebook account, thus breaking the distance barrier between students and teachers."Q. Mohammed 2020.
This collection of statements and quotes provides insights into various aspects of education, with a focus on project-based learning, technology integration, and innovative teaching methods. Here are some key themes:
Project-Based Learning (PBL):PBL is described as a dynamic approach that encourages students to explore real-world problems and challenges.It involves interdisciplinary projects and small collaborative groups.Teachers consider PBL a valuable methodology for improving the quality of learning in university students.
Technology Integration:The use of online platforms, social media, and collaborative tools like Facebook and Microsoft Kaizala is emphasized.Online learning platforms and e-tools are seen as crucial for advancing the teaching and learning process.Synchronous interactive hybrid classrooms and special delivery classrooms are proposed to share high-quality teacher resources, especially in rural areas.
Distance Education and Overcoming Isolation: Distance education is presented as an opportunity to overcome isolation, especially in rural and remote areas.Online collaboration tools and social media platforms play a role in breaking down distance barriers between students and teachers.
Professional Development for Teachers: Continuous training and workshops for teachers are highlighted to keep them updated on the latest teaching methods and technologies.Collaborative professional learning programs are described as a means of supporting teachers in building their capacity.
Individualized Learning:Emphasis is placed on personalized individual learning plans and anytime, anywhere learning to cater to diverse learner needs.Customized learning plans and incorporating various resources are considered essential for success in the rapidly evolving world.
Incorporating ICT in Curriculum:The importance of incorporating information and communication technology (ICT) in the curriculum is acknowledged.The use of electronic media and resources is seen as a means to transition from traditional to integrated learning models.
Collaboration and Sharing Resources:Collaboration is promoted through various means, such as collaborative projects, online communities of practice, and sharing high-quality teacher resources.
The sharing of resources, particularly in rural areas, is emphasized to ensure equal educational opportunities.
Blended Learning:Blended learning methods, combining traditional and online tools, are recognized for their potential in enhancing learning experiences.The adaptability of blended learning models to specific educational conditions is highlighted.
Experiential Learning and Student Engagement:Experiential learning is suggested as a method to relate classroom knowledge to real-life situations.Lessons are encouraged to be transformed into interactive sessions to sustain student interest and engagement.
Global Collaboration:The concept of transnational qualifications frameworks and collaboration among small states is introduced for the development of courses and skills.
107 | Fakultas Agama Islam Universitas Wahid Hasyim
Assessment and Feedback:The importance of real-time feedback for promoting student engagement is highlighted.
Social Media for Education:Social media platforms, particularly Facebook, are recognized for facilitating collaborative exercises and real-time communication between students and teachers.
The provided information encompasses a broad range of educational strategies and approaches. Let's delve deeper into some key points: Project-Based Learning stands out as a dynamic and interdisciplinary approach to education. It not only focuses on academic knowledge but also emphasizes the development of cross -curriculum skills and soft skills. The collaborative nature of PBL encourages students to work together, mirroring real-world scenarios where problem-solving often requires a multidisciplinary approach. The incorporation of technology in education is a recurring theme. Online platforms, social media, and collaborative tools are recognized as valuable resources. The use of Facebook for collaborative exercises and real-time communication breaks down geographical barriers, facilitating interaction between on-campus and off-campus students. Additionally, the adoption of online learning platforms and tools provides flexibility and ease of access to educational resources. The discussion on distance education highlights its potential to overcome isolation, especially in rural areas. The use of online collaborative tools and synchronous interactive classrooms addresses challenges faced by remote schools with limited resources. This aligns with the idea of providing equal and quality teaching activities within the curriculum, irrespective of geographical constraints.
Continuous professional development for teachers is crucial to keep them abreast of evolving teaching methods and technologies. Collaborative professional learning programs, delivered online, emerge as a solution to support teachers, especially in rural areas, in building their capacity.
The emphasis on personalized individual learning plans reflects a recognition of the diverse needs of learners.
This aligns with the broader goal of cultivating a disposition toward lifelong learning, preparing students for continuous adaptation in a rapidly evolving world. The concept of global collaboration, as seen in the development of a Transnational Qualifications Framework, showcases a cooperative effort among small states. This collaboration aims to equip individuals with advanced skills for online collaboration and create eLearning courses tailored to the needs of different regions. Blended learning methods, combining traditional and online elements, are recognized for their potential to enhance learning experiences. Additionally, the incorporation of experiential learning adds a practical dimension to education, allowing students to apply theoretical knowledge in real-world scenarios, fostering skills such as critical thinking and teamwork. The importance of real-time feedback is highlighted, underscoring the need for an interactive and responsive learning environment that engages students actively. The use of social media platforms for educational purposes, such as collaborative exercises on Facebook, represents a contemporary approach to fostering communication and engagement among students and between students and teachers.
In conclusion, the insights gathered from the provided information underscore a progressive and multifaceted approach to education. The overarching themes emphasize the integration of technology, collaborative learning, and innovative teaching methodologies to create a dynamic and inclusive learning environment. Project-Based Learning (PBL) emerges as a powerful strategy, fostering interdisciplinary skills and addressing real-world challenges, thereby preparing students for complex problem-solving in their future endeavors. The pervasive use of technology, from online platforms to social media, signifies a commitment to harnessing digital tools for enhanced learning experiences, breaking down geographical barriers, and providing flexible educational opportunities. The recognition of distance education as an opportunity to overcome isolation, especially in rural areas, highlights a commitment to ensuring equal access to quality education regardless of geographic constraints. Continuous professional development for teachers, facilitated through collaborative online programs, reflects an understanding of the evolving nature of education and the need to equip educators with the latest skills and methodologies.
The focus on individualized learning plans and cultivating a disposition toward lifelong learning aligns with the broader goal of preparing students for a future where adaptability and continuous learning are paramount. Initiatives like the Transnational Qualifications Framework demonstrate a commitment to global collaboration, enabling the sharing of resources and skills across borders for the benefit of diverse communities. The acknowledgment of blended
learning and experiential learning methods showcases a commitment to providing diverse and engaging educational experiences, blending theoretical knowledge with practical application.
The importance of real-time feedback highlights a commitment to creating interactive and responsive learning environments that actively engage students in the learning process. Leveraging social media platforms for collaborative exercises emphasizes an awareness of the communication preferences of students, fostering real-time interactions between peers and educators. In essence, these educational strategies collectively reflect a forward-looking and holistic vision for education, aiming to equip students with the skills and adaptability needed in a rapidly evolving global landscape. The emphasis on technology, collaboration, and learner-centric approaches positions education as a dynamic and inclusive force for positive societal change.
Conclusion
The intricacies of offering education within limited physical spaces, highlighting challenges such as restricted classroom space, scarce resources, and limited infrastructure. Despite these constraints, the transformative potential of technology, particularly the internet, in overcoming isolation and providing access to expertise and resources. The communal aspect of small spaces is also emphasized, noting that close-knit environments can foster collaboration and a supportive learning atmosphere. It concludes optimistically, emphasizing the adaptability and creativity required to address challenges in small spaces, suggesting that thoughtful planning can ensure the delivery of quality education.
As the impact of globalization and technological advances, there is place-based education as a solution, rooted in local communities to make education more relevant and meaningful. Youth leadership, continuous skill development, and the importance of the 'place' in outdoor education are emphasized. The passage advocates for a holistic view of education, transcending traditional classrooms to foster relationships with the environment, aiming to deepen understanding and strengthen connections. It calls for an adaptive and dynamic educational approach to equip students with the necessary skills and perspectives in an interconnected world while maintaining strong connections to their local identities and environments.
The need for adaptability, creativity, and leveraging available resources emerges as a central theme in both discussions. Despite challenges in limited physical spaces or small city, education can be successfully navigated with strategic planning, technological integration, and a commitment to holistic, community-centered approaches. The passages collectively advocate for a flexible and responsive educational paradigm that can effectively meet the needs of diverse environments and learners.
The additional insights on project-based learning, technology integration, distance education, professional development, individualized learning, global collaboration, blended and experiential learning, assessment and feedback, and the use of social media in education further reinforce the multifaceted approach to education. These strategies collectively highlight a forward-looking vision that aims to equip students with the skills and adaptability needed in a rapidly evolving global landscape. The emphasis on technology, collaboration, and learner-centric approaches positions education as a dynamic and inclusive force for positive societal change. Overall, the synthesis underscores the importance of combining various educational strategies to address the diverse challenges and opportunities in the field of education.
REFERENCES
Ahmed, Lateef, Alkhaqani. (2023). ChatGPT and Nursing Education: Challenges and Opportunities. Al-Rafidain journal of medical sciences, doi: 10.54133/ajms.v4i.110
Anita, Louisa, Cloete. (2017). Erratum: Technology and education: Challenges and opportunities. Hts Teologiese Studies-theological Studies, doi: 10.4102/HTS.V73I3.4899
Ali Ait Si Mhamed 2012 Tertiary education in small states: Planning in the context of globalization https://doi.org/10.1007/s11159-012-9303-7
Bob, Coulter. (2018). Developing Youth Agency Through Place-Based Education: Challenges and Opportunities. doi:
10.1007/978-3-319-51949-4_80-1
Carlos, G., A., Ormond. (2013). Place-Based Education in Practice. doi: 10.1007/978-94-6209-221-1_2
109 | Fakultas Agama Islam Universitas Wahid Hasyim
Fayez Abdulrahman Al Fayez & Abdullah Alsadhan 2021 Improving Education Efficiency by Consolidating Public Schools with Few Students https://doi.org/10.37575/H/MNG/0067
Mohammed, Q.A., Naidu, V.R., Harthi, M.S., Babiker, S., Balushi, Q.A., Rawahi, M.Y., & Riyami, N.H. (2020).
ROLE OF ONLINE COLLABORATIVE PLATFORM IN HIGHER EDUCATION
CONTEXT.https://doi.org/10.18768/ijaedu.789422
L. Beveridge, S. Armstrong 2017 Supporting teacher and student learning in small schools S. Chugach 2018 Designing Customized , Relevant , and Authentic Learning Experiences
Mingzhang Zuo 2019 Promoting High-Quality Teachers Resource Sharing and Rural Small Schools Development in the Support of Informational Technology https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-21562-0_21
Nadezhda Angelova 2019 APPLICATIONS FOR EDUCATION – AN INTERACTIVE WAY FOR TEACHING AND LEARNING International Conference on Technics https://doi.org/10.15547/ictte.2019.03.092
S. Ussipashim, A. Niyazova 2019 BLENDED LEARNING IN MODERN EDUCATIONAL PROCESS:
NECESSITY AND OPPORTUNITIES Journal of education and science
https://doi.org/10.26577/jes.2019.v59.i2.011
Nur Hafidah Abd Kadir, Hariati Ibrahim, Irwan Affendi Md Naim, Nor Akhmal Hasmin 2018 Mobile apps on experiential learning: a quick guide for educator
SedighehSadat Moein 2013 Implementation Project-based learning in Schools (A Simple Way)
Rodríguez Gómez, María de las Mercedes 2020 Advances in Educational Marketing, Administration, and Leadership Project-Based Learning https://doi.org/10.4018/978-1-7998-2124-3.ch010
Giuseppina Rita Jose Mangione, Giuseppina Cannella 2021 Small School, Smart Schools: Distance Education in Remoteness Conditions. Technol. Knowl. Learn. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10758-020-09480-4
Noreen M. Webb 2010 Peer Learning in the Classroom https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-08-044894-7.00616-3 (2022). Education Through NGOs: Challenges and Opportunities. Algorithms for intelligent systems, doi:
10.1007/978-981-19-2065-3_32
O., C., Ferrell., Linda, Ferrell. (2020). Technology Challenges and Opportunities Facing Marketing Education..
Marketing Education Review, doi: 10.1080/10528008.2020.1718510
(2022). Residential location and education in the United States. doi: 10.4337/9781789908497.00012 Maicon, de, Matos, Mendes. (2022). Geographies of education spaces. doi: 10.4324/9781003248538-5
Roger, Hadgraft., Jo, Dane. (2014). Spaces for Engaging, Experiential, Collaborative Learning in Higher Education.
doi: 10.1108/S1479-362820140000012010
Fei-Yue, Wang., Ying, Tang., Xiwei, Liu., Yong, Yuan. (2019). Social Education: Opportunities and Challenges in Cyber-Physical-Social Space. IEEE Transactions on Computational Social Systems, doi:
10.1109/TCSS.2019.2905941