The Readiness of Palm Oil Industry in Enterprise Resource Planning - Bina Darma e-Journal

Darius Antoni <darius.antoni@binadarma.ac.id>

[TELKOMNIKA] Please Revise Your Paper

6 messages

TELKOMNIKA Editors and Authors Meeting <team@journal.uad.ac.id> Mon, Nov 19, 2018 at 3:22 PM To: darius.antoni@binadarma.ac.id

Cc: muhamad.akbar@binadarma.ac.id Dear Sir/Madam,

For preparing your final paper to publish in TELKOMNIKA (Telecommunication, Computing, Electronics and Control) ISSN: 1693-6930, e-ISSN: 2302-9293 Issue December 2018. Please revise your paper based on the comment on the paper. You have 1 day to revise your paper until November 20, 2018. Please revise in the paper that attached in this email and don't make another file. We hope your response soon. Thank you.

Best regards, TELKOMNIKA Staff

26 19Oct18 13May18 9883 (2018-11-02) (LILA).doc 469K

Darius Antoni <darius.antoni@binadarma.ac.id> Mon, Nov 19, 2018 at 3:29 PM To: team@journal.uad.ac.id

Cc: Muhamad Akbar <muhamad.akbar@binadarma.ac.id>

Noted with thanks.

[Quoted text hidden]

Darius Antoni <darius.antoni@binadarma.ac.id> Mon, Nov 19, 2018 at 3:59 PM To: Muhamad Akbar <muhamad.akbar@binadarma.ac.id>

[Quoted text hidden]

Darius Antoni <darius.antoni@binadarma.ac.id> Mon, Nov 19, 2018 at 3:59 PM To: Muhamad akbar <akbartea@gmail.com>

[Quoted text hidden]

26 19Oct18 13May18 9883 (2018-11-02) (LILA).doc 469K

Darius Antoni <darius.antoni@binadarma.ac.id> Mon, Nov 19, 2018 at 5:02 PM To: team@journal.uad.ac.id

Dear Admin Telkomnika,

Please find our the final revision of our paper attached thanks

Darius Antoni

[Quoted text hidden]

RevisedbyDarius26 19Oct18 13May18 9883 (2018-11-02) (LILA).doc 456K

TELKOMNIKA Editors and Authors Meeting <team@journal.uad.ac.id>

Thu, Nov 22, 2018 at 10:29 AM To: Darius Antoni <darius.antoni@binadarma.ac.id>

Dear Sir,

Received, thank you.

Best Regards, TELKOMNIKA Staff

[Quoted text hidden]

--

Best regards, TELKOMNIKA Staff

Darius Antoni <darius.antoni@binadarma.ac.id>

Revised paper for id 9883

7 messages

Darius Antoni <darius.antoni@binadarma.ac.id> Tue, Oct 2, 2018 at 7:51 PM To: "Int. Conf. - ICW TELKOMNIKA" <icw.telkomnika@journal.uad.ac.id>

Cc: tole@journal.uad.ac.id

Dear ICW Telkomnika Conference Committe,

Please find the revised paper and Mentor Comments form attached

Thanks Darius Antoni

2 attachments

3rdRevised209020#9883 (8-15-2018) journal Telkomnika Readiness of Palm oil Industry - Darius Antoni.doc

356K

FORM COMMENT REVIEW.docx 23K

Tole Sutikno <tole@journal.uad.ac.id> Tue, Oct 2, 2018 at 7:51 PM To: darius.antoni@binadarma.ac.id

Dear Sir/Madam,

Your email has reached my queues safely, so i will get back in touch with you there as soon as i can. Just a heads up i might not get back to you straight away, as i answer all emails in order to keep things fair.

How to submit your manuscript

To make a submission, you must have a user account and be enrolled as an Author. User accounts can either be created by the Journal Manager or you can register yourself (this journal policy allow you create user account by your self as a Reader, an Author and/or a Reviewer). All fields with an asterisk beside them (Username; Password; Repeat Password; First Name; Last Name; Email) are mandatory. Your username and your email address must be unique;

furthermore, while you can change your email address at a later date, you will be unable to change your username. If you want to register in another role within the same journal (for example, if you are already a Reader, but also want to become an Author) you can log in; go to Edit My Profile (under My Account on your User Home page); and check off the checkboxes next to any available roles, near the bottom of the page. Once you have an account, log in to the journal site and select the role of Author. The Author is asked to upload a submission file and to provide metadata or indexing information. (The metadata improves the search capacity for research online and for the journal.) The Author can upload Supplementary Files, in the form of data sets, research

instruments, or source texts that will enrich the item, as well as contribute to more open and robust forms of research and scholarship.

Your paper ID?

Please ALWAYS put your paper ID number in the subject line of email communication when making inquiries. For example, if your submitted manuscript

URL: http://journal.uad.ac.id/index.php/TELKOMNIKA/author/submission/1234, your paper ID number is 1234.

Your cooperation is very appreciated.

Thank you Best Regards, Tole Sutikno Editor:

TELKOMNIKA TCEC, http://journal.uad.ac.id/index.php/TELKOMNIKA

---

**Journal Form for Hardcopy Order**

Please download "Journal form for Hardcopy order" and contact us if further information is needed:

1.

Mr. Sulchan Hidayat: sulchan.hidayat@gmail.com, +62 81328731075

2.

Mr. Son Ali Akbar: sonjannah@gmail.com, Phone: +62 85643888512

3.

Dr. Anton Yudhana, eyudhana@yahoo.com, +62 85746722592

--- Our events:

---

International Conference and Workshop on Telecommunication, Computing, Electronics and Control (ICW-TELKOMNIKA), September 18-21, 2018 in Yogyakarta, Indonesia

http://journal.uad.ac.id/index.php/TELKOMNIKA/pages/view/conference

---

2018 5th International Conference on Electrical Engineering, Computer Science and Informatics (EECSI 2018), October 16-18, 2018 in Malang, Indonesia.

http://eecsi.org/2018

---

Int. Conf. - ICW TELKOMNIKA <icw.telkomnika@journal.uad.ac.id> Wed, Oct 3, 2018 at 11:50 AM To: Darius Antoni <darius.antoni@binadarma.ac.id>

Cc: "Assoc. Prof. Dr. Tole Sutikno" <tole@journal.uad.ac.id>

Received, thank you.

[Quoted text hidden]

Int. Conf. - ICW TELKOMNIKA <icw.telkomnika@journal.uad.ac.id> Thu, Nov 1, 2018 at 9:22 AM To: Darius Antoni <darius.antoni@binadarma.ac.id>

Dear Sir,

Please revised again your paper based on the comment on the paper. You have 1 day to revise your paper until November 2, 2018. Thank you.

Best regards,

ICW TELKOMNIKA Committee

On Tue, Oct 2, 2018 at 7:51 PM Darius Antoni <darius.antoni@binadarma.ac.id> wrote:

[Quoted text hidden]

28. 9883 (2018-10-02).doc 352K

Darius Antoni <darius.antoni@binadarma.ac.id> Thu, Nov 1, 2018 at 9:32 AM To: "Int. Conf. - ICW TELKOMNIKA" <icw.telkomnika@journal.uad.ac.id>

Hi there,

Thank your for your information regarding our Paper revision.

Actually, we are happy to revise our paper to getting better but it is impossible to revise it in one day. This is because I am on the way right now. It is ok, please give us more days to fix the paper and we will email it as soon as possible.

If you dont mind please send your mobile to get rapid response from you or please WA to +6281273691390

Thanks Darius antoni

[Quoted text hidden]

--

Darius Antoni, S.Kom., M.M., PhD

Ketua Program Studi Magister Teknik Informatika

Darius Antoni <darius.antoni@binadarma.ac.id> Fri, Nov 2, 2018 at 11:21 PM To: "Int. Conf. - ICW TELKOMNIKA" <icw.telkomnika@journal.uad.ac.id>

Dear Editor,

Please find our final revised paper attached Thank you

Darius Antoni

[Quoted text hidden]

Final Revision 28. 9883 (2018-10-02).doc 374K

Int. Conf. - ICW TELKOMNIKA <icw.telkomnika@journal.uad.ac.id> Mon, Nov 5, 2018 at 9:15 AM To: Darius Antoni <darius.antoni@binadarma.ac.id>

Dear Sir,

Received. Thank you so much for your hard work.

Best regards,

ICW TELKOMNIKA Committee

[Quoted text hidden]

Darius Antoni <darius.antoni@binadarma.ac.id>

[ICW-TELKOMNIKA 2018] #1570464527 has been uploaded

4 messages

lppi@uad.ac.id.edas.info <lppi@uad.ac.id.edas.info> Thu, May 31, 2018 at 11:32 AM Reply-To: lppi@uad.ac.id

To: Darius Antoni <darius.antoni@binadarma.ac.id>, Muhamad Akbar

<muhamad.akbar@binadarma.ac.id>, Deni Fikari <denifikari@yahoo.co.id>, Ferry Jie

<f.jie@ecu.edu.au>

Cc: telkomnika@journal.uad.ac.id Dear Mr. Muhamad Akbar:

Thank you for uploading your paper 1570464527 (The Readiness of Palm Oil Industry in Enterprise Resource Planning) to 1st International Conference and Workshop on Telecommunication, Computing, Electronics and Control 2018. The paper is of type application/msword and has a length of 365568 bytes.

You can modify your paper at https://edas.info/showPaper.php?m=1570464527 and see all your submissions at https://edas.info/index.php?c=24932 using the EDAS

identifier muhamad.akbar@binadarma.ac.id Regards,

Assoc. Prof. Dr. Tole Sutikno General Chair

lppi@uad.ac.id.edas.info <lppi@uad.ac.id.edas.info> Thu, May 31, 2018 at 11:32 AM

Reply-To: lppi@uad.ac.id

To: Darius Antoni <darius.antoni@binadarma.ac.id>, Muhamad Akbar

<muhamad.akbar@binadarma.ac.id>, Deni Fikari <denifikari@yahoo.co.id>, Ferry Jie

<f.jie@ecu.edu.au>

Cc: telkomnika@journal.uad.ac.id

[Quoted text hidden]

lppi@uad.ac.id.edas.info <lppi@uad.ac.id.edas.info> Thu, May 31, 2018 at 11:34 AM Reply-To: lppi@uad.ac.id

To: Darius Antoni <darius.antoni@binadarma.ac.id>, Muhamad Akbar

<muhamad.akbar@binadarma.ac.id>, Deni Fikari <denifikari@yahoo.co.id>, Ferry Jie

<f.jie@ecu.edu.au>

Cc: telkomnika@journal.uad.ac.id Dear Mr. Muhamad Akbar:

Thank you for uploading your paper 1570464527 (The Readiness of Palm Oil Industry in Enterprise Resource Planning) to 1st International Conference and Workshop on Telecommunication, Computing, Electronics and Control 2018. The paper is of type application/msword and has a length of 359424 bytes.

[Quoted text hidden]

lppi@uad.ac.id.edas.info <lppi@uad.ac.id.edas.info> Thu, May 31, 2018 at 11:35 AM Reply-To: lppi@uad.ac.id

To: Darius Antoni <darius.antoni@binadarma.ac.id>, Muhamad Akbar

<muhamad.akbar@binadarma.ac.id>, Deni Fikari <denifikari@yahoo.co.id>, Ferry Jie

<f.jie@ecu.edu.au>

Cc: telkomnika@journal.uad.ac.id Dear Mr. Muhamad Akbar:

Thank you for uploading your paper 1570464527 (The Readiness of Palm Oil Industry in Enterprise Resource Planning) to 1st International Conference and Workshop on Telecommunication, Computing, Electronics and Control 2018. The paper is of type application/msword and has a length of 357888 bytes.

[Quoted text hidden]

TELKOMNIKA 2018

RESPONSE TO MENTOR(S) COMMENTS

ID Paper : 9883

Tittle : The Readiness of Palm Oil Industry in Enterprise Resource Planning Authors : Darius Antoni, Deni Fikari, Muhammad Akbar, Ferry Jie

ABSTRACT

1. Mentor’s Comment #1 :

The order of keywords should be

Critical Success Factor, ERP, Palm Oil, Readiness

Respond to Comment #1:done

2. Mentor’s Comment #2 :

Check spelling errors in the paper, for example requireda(should be “required”) Respond to Comment #2: Done

3. Mentor’s Comment #3 :

Benefit of the contribution (examining the readiness of palm oil industry) is not clear.

Respond to Comment #3 :Done

4. Mentor’s Comment #4 :

What is the parameter to determine palm oil industry is well prepared to implement ERP from four dimensions?

Respond to Comment #4: The Abstract already revised by adding the significant factors that influence the readiness of Palm Oil Industry

INTRODUCTIONS

5. Mentor’s Comment #5 :

Check spelling errors in the paper, for example descritive(should be “descriptive”) Respond to Comment #5: done

6. Mentor’s Comment #6 :

This paper should explain clearly why examining the readiness of palm oil industry is needed

Respond to Comment #6: The Problem Statement already mentioned in paragraph 4,5 and 6.

There are a number of studies has been conducted to evaluate the readiness of the ERP implementation from various perspectives such as Abdinnour-Helm, et al.

[8]investigatedthe readiness of human resources in ERP implementation. Abdolvand, et al. [9]

conducted an assessment on the readiness indicators that are determined based on the

critical success and failure factors including egalitarian leadership, collaborative working

environment, top management commitment, supportive management, and use of information

technology. Raymond, et al. [10] conducted an analysis to develop the concept of ERP

implementation in smal-medium sized enterprises through four dimensions including the

organizational context, external forces, and perception of ERP and business processes.

Ahmadi, et al. [11] developed a novel approach to assess readiness model for managing the interrelation degree among activities within organizations. Ram, et al. [12] examined the organizational readiness is associated with four critical success factors including project management, business process re-engineering, training and education and system integration, to achieve effective ERP implementation in organizations.

Although a few of these studies attempted to assess the readiness of organizations in implementation of ERP, they are mainly descriptive surveys. They are based on limited cases of human resources, leadership, management supports and business processes. There is thus a lack and provide empirical evidence based on organization resources including management, process, technology, data and human resources using gap analysis.

Moreover, the majority of the above studies are predominantly based on the readiness of general organizations in implementing ERP. There remains little research on readiness of palm oil organizations or companies. Importantly, the readiness of palm oil companies can be more complex than other organizations due to the absesnce of management, process, technology, data and human resources.

Thus, this research aims to examine the ERP implementation readiness using the critical success factors (CSF). The aggregated CSFs are classified into five groups that is management, processes, technology, data and human resources. Assessing these factors measures the readiness of ERP Implementation. This research investigated the readiness through conducting a survey in four companies in the sector of the palm oil industry within the scope of Banyuasinregency and MusiBanyuasinregency of South Sumatra province, Indonesia.

7. Mentor’s Comment #7 :

Based on the abstract, there are three methods: CSF method, a survey method, and a gap analysis. However, only CSF method is described clearly in IntroductionRespond to Comment #7: done.

Thus, this research aims to examine the ERP implementation readiness

usingquantitative method, the critical success factors (CSF) and a gap analysis.

Quantitative method is used to obtain data through survey using closed-ended questionnaire that is developed from prior studies.The aggregated CSFs are classified into five groups that is management, processes, technology, data and human resources. Assessing these factors measures the readiness of ERP Implementation. This research investigated the readiness through conducting a survey in four companies in the sector of the palm oil industry within the scope of Banyuasinregency and MusiBanyuasinregency of South Sumatra province, Indonesia

8. Mentor’s Comment #8 :

Don’t only mention figures or tables in the paragraph. All figures and tables should be referenced in the paragraph.

Respond to Comment #8: done

RESULT AND DISCUSSION 1. Mentor’s Comment #9 :

All variables in Tables must be explained. For example, what is SA, A, and M in Table 9? (If variables are explained in other section, please mention that section).

Respond to Comment #1: already explained in section 2.2

2. Mentor’s Comment #10 :

3. How to obtain the predicted data that is shown in Table 8?

Respond to Comment #10: it has explained in section 3.1 and table 3

CONCLUSION

4. Mentor’s Comment #11 :

5. The last paragraph of conclusion (the difference between companies with or without ERP can be seen based on the gap value) is not correct, because it is not supported by the experimental result.

Respond to Comment #11 : That statement already deleted from conclusion

6. Mentor’s Comment #12 :

Give the future research that is related with the topic of this research in the conclusion

Respond to Comment #4: the future research have been added in the conclusion of

research section