Reviewed the manuscript for the journal JAMME / AMSE
Created by IndexCopornicus Publishers Panel
Manuscript: #ICIP18686
Title: Modeling Analysis of High Effect of Roll Hoop Main on the Strength of Student Car Formula Chassis Authors: Mastiadi Tamjidillah, Rachmat Subagyo, Hajar
Isworo, Hendry Y. Nanlohy
Reviewed: 2020-04-21
Data download file: 2020-04-30, 15:19:22
1. Do you think that the paper title corresponds with its contents?
Yes Comment: yes, I Think the paper tittle corresponds with its content
2. Do you think that the abstract expresses the paper contents well?
Yes Comment: ya, the abstract is clear
3. Are the results or methods presented in the paper novel? Not found.
Comment: Not found.
4. Do the author(s)state clearly what they have achieved? Not found.
Comment: yes, its clear
5. Do you find the terminology employed proper? Not found.
Comment: the termonology is okay
6. Do you find the bibliography representative and up-to-date? Not found.
Comment: Not yet
7. Do you find all necessary illustrations and tables? Not found.
Comment: Yes
8. Do you think that the paper will be of interest to the journal readers?
Not found.
Comment: Yes, of course
9. The paper be accepted as it stands 4
Comment: accepted
10. Do you recommend that (tick only one) Not found.
Comment: Not found.
11. Do you think that the paper title corresponds with its contents?
Yes Comment: Not found.
12. Do you think that the abstract expresses the paper contents well?
Yes Comment: Not found.
13. Are the results or methods presented in the paper novel? Yes Comment: Not found.
14. Do the author(s)state clearly what they have achieved? Yes Comment: Not found.
15. Do you find the terminology employed proper? Yes
Comment: Not found.
16. Do you find the bibliography representative and up-to-date? No Comment: not yet
17. Do you find all necessary illustrations and tables? Yes
Comment: Not found.
18. Do you think that the paper will be of interest to the journal readers?
Yes Comment: Not found.
19. Do you recommend that (tick only one) The paper be accepted as it stands Comment: Not found.
Final comment: please update the references Decision reviewer: accepted without corrections
