Robust Fuzzy Control Design Using Gene

(1)

1

Lampiran Peer Review Korespondensi Proses Submit Publikasi Internasional

Judul Makalah: Robust Fuzzy Control Design Using Genetic Algorithm Optimization Approach: Case Study of Spark Ignition Engine Torque Control

Jurnal Internasional: Iranian Journal of Fuzzy Systems Reputasi: Terindeks Scopus - Q1

Item Halaman

1. Submission letter + original submission (28 Nopember 2014) 2. Decision letter (28 Desember 2015)

3. First round reviews with editor comments (28 Desember 2015) 4. Second submission with revisions confirmation email (19 Januari

2016)

5. Decision letter (14 Mei 2016)

6. Second round reviews with editor comments (14 Mei 2016) 7. Third submission with revisions confirmation email (06 Juni 2016) 8. Decision letter (9 Agustus 2016)

9. Email with conditional acceptance with reviewer/editor comments (9 Agustus 2016)

10. Writing revision (9 Agustus 2016 – 18 Oktober 2016)

11. Email with copyright transfer indicating acceptance (16 November 2016)

12. Email with final proof acceptance and response (29 May 2017) 13. Final acceptance and publication information (29 May 2017) 14. Issued publication information: volume and number (5 July 2017)

2 4 4 6 10 10 12 15 15 15 – 41

42 50 51 52

(2)

<<--->>

From: Iranian Journal of Fuzzy Systems <ijfs@usb.ac.ir>

Subject: Editorial system registeration Date: 28 November 2014 15.09.18 GMT+7 To: aristriwiyatno@yahoo.com

Reply-To: Iranian Journal of Fuzzy Systems <ijfs@usb.ac.ir>

Dear Aris Triwiyatno

Welcome to Iranian Journal of Fuzzy Systems website.

Thank you for your registration in the Editorial System Online Subbmission and peer review tracking system. Here is your username and confidential password, which you need to access the system at :

http://ijfs.usb.ac.ir/

Your username is: aristriwiyatno Your password is: 14132249

Please save this information in a safe place.

Your can change your password and other personal information by loging in at http://ijfs.usb.ac.ir/ and choosing "Change Password" from the menu bar . Yours sincerely,

Journal Manager

Iranian Journal of Fuzzy Systems http://ijfs.usb.ac.ir/

<<--->>

(3)

3

Subject: acknowledgment receipt (#2080-IJFS) Date: 28 November 2014 15.57.40 GMT+7 To: aristriwiyatno@yahoo.com

Cc: ijfs-submit@usb.ac.ir

Manuscript ID: 2080-IJFS  Manuscript Title: Robust fuzzy control design using genetic algorithm optimization approach: case study of spark ignition engine torque control   Authors: Aris Triwiyatno, S. Sumardi, Esa Apriaskar   Dear Prof. Dr. Aris Triwiyatno

 I wish to acknowledge receiving the above-mentioned manuscript.   It should be noted that the manuscript will be reviewed for possible publication in Iranian Journal of Fuzzy Systems.  Please be sure that the submitted manuscript has not been published previously and will not be submitted elsewhere prior to our decision, in order not being considered as a

plagiarism action.   Our editorial decision will be brought to your attention once the paper has been reviewed due to the referees' consideration.   I wish to take this opportunity to thank you for sharing your work with us.   

Yours sincerely,

Managing Editor of Iranian Journal of Fuzzy Systems R. A. Borzooei

<<--->>

(4)

From: fateme kouchakinejad <kouchakinezhad@gmail.com>

Subject: Revision Paper No. 2080-IJFS (R1) Date: 28 December 2015 15.27.45 GMT+7 To: aristriwiyatno@yahoo.com

Cc: kouchakinezhad.ijfs@gmail.com

Reply-To: fateme kouchakinejad <kouchakinezhad@gmail.com>

Manuscript ID: 2080-IJFS  Manuscript Title: Robust fuzzy control design using genetic algorithm optimization approach: case study of spark ignition engine torque control   Authors: Aris Triwiyatno, S. Sumardi, Esa Apriaskar    Dear Prof. Dr. Aris Triwiyatno

We have reviewed your paper. Based on the results of the reviews of our reviewers, your paper is included in the scope of our journal and can continue the process of revision. There are some substance revisions that must be made for your paper.

Here is a list of repairs that you have to do.

1st reviewer:

1- Please declare of your novelty based on fuzzy system improvement

2- Check another references or research that have similar idea in robust fuzzy.

What's the difference?

3 - Please give more analytic results than graphical results only.

Recommendation: Accepted with major revision 2nd reviewer:

1- You don't need to explore SIE model deeply, since the model only to prove your method.

2- Please give more result analysis to prove your method, since using GA give us more complex calculation.

3 - Gain of every operating condition must be stated in a table and show how to calculate them.

4. The flowchart must be in English.

Recommendation: Accepted with major revision 3rd reviewer:

1- Please use references in 10 years publications recently.

2- Make a comparasion with another controller method.

Recommendation: Accepted with minor revision Truly yours

M. Mashinchi

(5)

5

From: fateme kouchakinejad <kouchakinezhad@gmail.com>

Subject: Reminder to revision Paper No. 2080-IJFS (R1) Date: 13 January 2016 01.36.31 GMT+7

To: aristriwiyatno@yahoo.com Cc: kouchakinezhad.ijfs@gmail.com

Reply-To: fateme kouchakinejad <kouchakinezhad@gmail.com>

2080-IJFS (R1)

Robust fuzzy control design using genetic algorithm optimization approach:

case study of spark ignition engine torque control Dear Respected Corresponding Author,

According to our record you have not sent your revised paper yet.

If you do not revise your paper during one month it will be deleted from further reviewing process.

Truly yours M. Mashinchi

Editor-in-Chief IJFS F.Kouchakinejad

<<--->>

(6)

From: Aris Triwiyatno <aristriwiyatno@yahoo.com>

Subject: Re: Reminder to revision Paper No. 2080-IJFS (R1) Date: 19 January 2016 10.36.31 GMT+7

To: Fateme Kouchakinejad <kouchakinezhad.ijfs@gmail.com>, "ijfs- publisher@usb.ac.ir" <ijfs-publisher@usb.ac.ir>

Reply-To: Aris Triwiyatno <aristriwiyatno@yahoo.com>

Dear Prof. M. Mashinchi,

At first, many thanks for accepting our paper in your journal.

According to reviewer corrections, here are our paper revision Paper No.

2080-IJFS (R1) for Iranian Journal of Fuzzy System.

Yours sincerely,

Aris Triwiyatno

(7)

7

Ctt: Revisi pertama disampaikan dalam bentuk file lampiran bersama dengan paper yang direvisi (format pdf)

Respond to reviewer comments:

Reviewer Comments Respond Page (in

paper) 1^st

reviewer Please declare of your novelty based on fuzzy system

improvement.

The novelty of this research is providing a method to repair control action

discontinuing over transient state behavior (of system with transient state changes rapidly as spark ignition engine) by developing an iterative based optimization programming as genetic algorithm (GA) method to produce more accurate gains appropriate to gains that calculate using LQIT optimal control design.

Page 2

Check another references or research that have similar idea in robust fuzzy.

What's the difference?

Some literatures (related to robust fuzzy method)

reviews have been added in Introduction section.

Page 2

Please give more analytic results than graphical results only.

Some analytic results have been added in Result and Discussion section.

Page 12

2^nd

reviewer You don't need to explore SIE

model deeply, since the model only to prove your method.

Some theory of SIE model

has excluded. Page 5-7

Please give more result analysis to prove your

method, since using GA give us

Some analytic results have been added in Result and Discussion section.

Page 12

(8)

Reviewer Comments Respond Page (in paper) more complex

calculation.

Gain of every operating

condition must be stated in a table and show how to calculate them.

A table of operating condition gain has been added.

Page 4-5

The flowchart must be in English.

Repaired. Page 4

3^rd

reviewer Please use

references in 10 years publications recently.

Most of references use some publications in 10 years recently.

Page 14

Make a

comparison with another controller method.

A comparison method has been added (Linear

Quadratic Integral Tracking – LQIT Control Method).

Page 12

(9)

9

Subject: Acknowledgement of Revision (#2080-IJFS (R1)) Date: 6 February 2016 23.58.41 GMT+7

To: aristriwiyatno@yahoo.com Cc: ijfs-submit@usb.ac.ir

Manuscript ID: 2080-IJFS (R1)   Manuscript Title: Robust fuzzy control design using genetic algorithm optimization approach: case study of spark ignition engine torque control  Authors: Aris Triwiyatno, S.

Sumardi, Esa Apriaskar  Date: 2014-11-28   Dear Prof. Dr. Aris

cript Thank you for submitting the revised file of your manus Triwiyatno   

The Editorial Office will Iranian Journal of Fuzzy Systems  

to the

If there is proceed on your manuscript and inform you in the earliest time.   

Yours sincerely   anything else, please do not hesitate to contact us.   

R. A. Borzooei l of Fuzzy Systems 

Iranian Journa Managing Editor of

<<--->>

(10)

From: Fateme Kouchakinejad <kouchakinezhad.ijfs@gmail.com>

Subject: Revise Paper No.2080-IJFS (R2) Date: 14 May 2016 02.49.12 GMT+7 To: aristriwiyatno@yahoo.com

Cc: ijfs-editor@uk.ac.ir, kouchakinezhad.ijfs@gmail.com

Reply-To: Fateme Kouchakinejad <kouchakinezhad.ijfs@gmail.com>

Manuscript ID: 2080-IJFS  Manuscript Title: Robust fuzzy control design using genetic algorithm optimization approach: case study of spark ignition engine torque control   Authors: Aris Triwiyatno, S. Sumardi, Esa Apriaskar    Dear Prof. Dr. Aris Triwiyatno

We have accepted your last reviewed paper. Based on the results of the last reviews of our reviewers, there are some other revisions that must be made for your paper. Here is a list of repairs that you have to do.

1st reviewer:

1- Your claim for robust fuzzy control using genetic algorithm needs more proof to run under continuous state. Please give more result to proof your method.

2nd reviewer:

1 - How to calculate the operating condition gain is not described yet.

3rd reviewer:

-

Truly yours M. Mashinchi

<<--->>

(11)

11

From: Kouchakinejad <kouchakinezhad.ijfs@gmail.com>

Subject: Reminder to revise Paper No.2080-IJFS (R2) Date: 28 May 2016 03.18.39 GMT+7

To: aristriwiyatno@yahoo.com

Dear Respected Corresponding Author,

According to our record you have not sent your revised paper yet.

If you do not revise your paper during one month it will be deleted from further reviewing process.

Truly yours,

M. Mashinchi

<<--->>

(12)

Subject: Re: Reminder to revise Paper No.2080-IJFS (R2) Date: 06 June 2016 09.26.17 GMT+7

According to others reviewer corrections, here are our paper revision Paper No. 2080-IJFS (R2) for Iranian Journal of Fuzzy System.

Yours sincerely,

Aris Triwiyatno

(13)

13

Ctt: Revisi kedua disampaikan dalam bentuk file lampiran bersama dengan paper yang direvisi (format pdf)

Respond to reviewer comments:

Reviewer Comments Respond Page (in

paper) 1^st

reviewer Your claim for robust fuzzy control using genetic algorithm needs more proof to run under continuous state.

Please give more result to proof your method.

Added some experimental results (with some transition state and steady state of system operation) that proof the claim. See the Table 2 in page 12.

Page 12

2^nd

reviewer How to calculate the operating condition gain is not described yet.

The operating condition gain calculated using LQIT

Problem as defined in page 5.

Page 5

3^rd

reviewer - - -

(14)

Subject: Acknowledgement of Revision (#2080-IJFS (R2)) Date: 29 June 2016 00.08.34 GMT+7

To: aristriwiyatno@yahoo.com Cc: ijfs-submit@usb.ac.ir

Manuscript ID: 2080-IJFS (R2)   Manuscript Title: Robust fuzzy control design using genetic algorithm optimization approach: case study of spark ignition engine torque control  Authors: Aris Triwiyatno, S.

Sumardi, Esa Apriaskar  Date: 2014-11-28   Dear Prof. Dr. Aris

Thank you for submitting the revised file of your manuscript Triwiyatno   

The Editorial Office will Iranian Journal of Fuzzy Systems  

to the

If there is proceed on your manuscript and inform you in the earliest time.   

Yours sincerely   s.   

anything else, please do not hesitate to contact u

R. A. Borzooei Iranian Journal of Fuzzy Systems 

Managing Editor of

<<--->>

(15)

15

From: Kouchakinejad <kouchakinezhad.ijfs@gmail.com>

Subject: Style of IJFS Paper No. 2080-IJFS Date: 9 August 2016 03.24.23 GMT+7 To: aristriwiyatno@yahoo.com

Cc: IJFS Publisher <ijfs-publisher@usb.ac.ir>, "Iranian J. of Fuzzy Systems" <ijfs- editor@usb.ac.ir>

Dear Prof. Aris Triwiyatno,

Please make your paper according to the TeX style of IJFS. The style file and a sample paper are in attachment. The reference part of your paper should be arranged

alphabetically. Please put TeX file and PDF file and all packages you may use in a ZIPPED file and resend it to kouchakinezhad.ijfs@gmail.com with a Cc to ijfs- publisher@usb.ac.ir as early as possible [within 2 weeks].

Also, please pay attention that all references must be cited through the paper, otherwise it must be removed.

Yours sincerely,

M. Mashinchi Editor-in Chief

C/o IJFS Editor-in-Chief F. Kouchakinejad

<<--->>

(16)

From: Fateme Kouchakinejad <kouchakinezhad.ijfs@gmail.com>

Subject: Style of IJFS Paper No. 2080-IJFS Date: 9 August 2016 03.18.51 GMT+7 To: aristriwiyatno@yahoo.com

Cc: ijfs-editor@uk.ac.ir, kouchakinezhad.ijfs@gmail.com

Reply-To: Fateme Kouchakinejad <kouchakinezhad.ijfs@gmail.com>

Please make your paper according to the TeX style of IJFS. The style file and a sample paper are in attachment. The reference part of your paper should be arranged alphabetically. Please put TeX file and PDF file and all packages you may use in a ZIPPED file and resend it to

kouchakinezhad.ijfs@gmail.com with a Cc to ijfs-publisher@usb.ac.ir as early as possible [within 2 weeks].

Yours sincerely,

<<--->>

(17)

17 From: Aris Triwiyatno <aristriwiyatno@yahoo.com>

Subject: Re: Style of IJFS Paper No. 2080-IJFS Date: 23 August 2016 21.14.10 GMT+7

According to your last email, here are our paper submission for Iranian Journal of Fuzzy System no 2080-IJFS according to the TeX style of IJFS.

Yours sincerely,

Aris Triwiyatno

On Tuesday, August 9, 2016 1:56 AM, Fateme Kouchakinejad

<kouchakinezhad.ijfs@gmail.com> wrote:

Yours sincerely, M. Mashinchi Editor-in Chief

<<--->>

(18)

From: "IJFS Publisher" <ijfs-publisher@usb.ac.ir>

Subject: Re: Style of IJFS Paper No. 2080-IJFS Date: 4 September 2016 07.22.33 GMT+7

To: "Aris Triwiyatno" <aristriwiyatno@yahoo.com>

Please change the following points in the style of your paper and resend it :

1- PDF file does not run.

2- Make the Table 1 smaller. Now, it goes outside of the margin.

3-The captions of all Tables should be put under them.

4- Pleaes mention the name, address and email address of each author at the end of your paper.

5- Make the acknowledgement part according to the IJFS style.

6- References should be according to the tex style of IJFS.

7- Type references according to the alphabetical style of IJFS.

Yours Sincerely F. Montazerifar

Yours Sincerely R. A. Borzooei

Managing Editor of IJFS

Journal Site: http://ijfs.usb.ac.ir/

For Free Download:

http://www.usb.ac.ir/fuzzy/Default.aspx ________________________________

Professor in Mathematics Shahid Beheshti University Tehran, Iran

Tel&Fax:(IJFS office) 0098-54-33431060 http://ijfs.usb.ac.ir/borzooei.pdf

<<--->>

(19)

19

---Original Message---

From: Aris Triwiyatno <aristriwiyatno@yahoo.com>

To: Fateme Kouchakinejad

<kouchakinezhad.ijfs@gmail.com>, "ijfs-publisher@usb.ac.ir"

<ijfs-publisher@usb.ac.ir>

Date: Tue, 23 Aug 2016 14:14:10 +0000 (UTC) Subject: Re: Style of IJFS Paper No. 2080-IJFS

Yours sincerely,

Aris Triwiyatno

<<--->>

(20)

Yours sincerely,

Subject: Re: Style of IJFS Paper No. 2080-IJFS Date: 17 September 2016 20.21.52 GMT+7 To: IJFS Publisher <ijfs-publisher@usb.ac.ir>

Dear Prof. F. Montazerifar and Prof. R. A. Borzooei

According to your last email for some additional corrections, here are our paper submission for Iranian Journal of Fuzzy System no 2080-IJFS according to the TeX style of IJFS.

Yours sincerely,

(21)

21

On Saturday, September 3, 2016 2:57 PM, IJFS Publisher <ijfs- publisher@usb.ac.ir> wrote:

For Free Download:

<<--->>

(22)

---Original Message---

Date: Tue, 23 Aug 2016 14:14:10 +0000 (UTC) Subject: Re: Style of IJFS Paper No. 2080-IJFS Dear Prof. M. Mashinchi,

Yours sincerely,

Aris Triwiyatno

Yours sincerely,

(23)

23 From: "IJFS Publisher" <ijfs-publisher@usb.ac.ir>

Subject: Re: Style of IJFS Paper No. 2080-IJFS Date: 3 October 2016 06.11.21 GMT+7

2- What is the first name SUMARDI? Please put the name of all authors in paper.

3- There are very space after Tables 1 , 3. Please make them shorter.

4- Determine the corresponding author.

For Free Download:

<<--->>

(24)

To: IJFS Publisher <ijfs-publisher@usb.ac.ir>

Date: Sat, 17 Sep 2016 13:21:52 +0000 (UTC) Subject: Re: Style of IJFS Paper No. 2080-IJFS Dear Prof. F. Montazerifar and Prof. R. A. Borzooei

Yours sincerely,

Aris Triwiyatno

<<--->>

(25)

25

For Free Download:

<<--->>

(26)

---Original Message---

From: Aris Triwiyatno <aristriwiyatno@yahoo.com>

To: Fateme Kouchakinejad

<kouchakinezhad.ijfs@gmail.com>, "ijfs-publisher@usb.ac.ir"

<ijfs-publisher@usb.ac.ir>

Date: Tue, 23 Aug 2016 14:14:10 +0000 (UTC) Subject: Re: Style of IJFS Paper No. 2080-IJFS

Yours sincerely,

Aris Triwiyatno

<<--->>

(27)

27

Yours sincerely,

<<--->>

(28)

Subject: Re: Style of IJFS Paper No. 2080-IJFS Date: 16 November 2016 06.26.25 GMT+7

Thanks for your email. The acceptance letter will be sent to you shortly.

Yours Sincerely F. Montazerifar Yours Sincerely R. A. Borzooei

For Free Download:

<<--->>

(29)

29

---Original Message---

From: "IJFS Publisher" <ijfs-publisher@usb.ac.ir>

To: "Aris Triwiyatno" <aristriwiyatno@yahoo.com>

Date: Tue, 15 Nov 2016 11:25:14 -1200

Subject: Re: Style of IJFS Paper No. 2080-IJFS

For Free Download:

<<--->>

(30)

Date: Tue, 18 Oct 2016 13:14:20 +0000 (UTC) Subject: Re: Style of IJFS Paper No. 2080-IJFS

Dear Prof. F. Montazerifar and Prof. R. A. Borzooei, Managing Directors of IJFS

According to your last review of our paper in Latex, here are our corrected paper in one folder that support Latex system (tex, dvi, pdf, jpg, etc.).

Actually we do not know what did you mean about the first review, as: "The PDF file is not running", because we can open that pdf file in Acrobat Reader properly. We used MikTeX 2.9 to convert tex file to pdf file (plug-in feature to WinShell 3.2 in

pdfLatex program calls).

Could you give us another solution?

Yours Sincerely

Aris Triwiyatno

Department of Electrical Engineering

Engineering Faculty - Diponegoro University - Indonesia

<<--->>

(31)

31

On Sunday, October 2, 2016 1:48 PM, IJFS Publisher <ijfs-publisher@usb.ac.ir>

wrote:

For Free Download:

<<--->>

(32)

Yours sincerely,

Aris Triwiyatno

<<--->>

(33)

33

For Free Download:

<<--->>

(34)

---Original Message---

From: Aris Triwiyatno <aristriwiyatno@yahoo.com>

To: Fateme Kouchakinejad

<kouchakinezhad.ijfs@gmail.com>, "ijfs-publisher@usb.ac.ir"

<ijfs-publisher@usb.ac.ir>

Date: Tue, 23 Aug 2016 14:14:10 +0000 (UTC) Subject: Re: Style of IJFS Paper No. 2080-IJFS

Yours sincerely,

Aris Triwiyatno

<<--->>

(35)

35

Yours sincerely,

<<--->>

(36)

Subject: Re: Style of IJFS Paper No. 2080-IJFS Date: 18 October 2016 20.14.20 GMT+7

Dear Prof. F. Montazerifar and Prof. R. A. Borzooei, Managing Directors of IJFS

According to your last review of our paper in Latex, here are our corrected paper in one folder that support Latex system (tex, dvi, pdf, jpg, etc.).

Actually we do not know what did you mean about the first review, as: "The PDF file is not running", because we can open that pdf file in Acrobat Reader properly. We used MikTeX 2.9 to convert tex file to pdf file (plug-in feature to WinShell 3.2 in

pdfLatex program calls).

Could you give us another solution?

Yours Sincerely Aris Triwiyatno

Department of Electrical Engineering

Engineering Faculty - Diponegoro University - Indonesia

<<--->>

(37)

37

On Sunday, October 2, 2016 1:48 PM, IJFS Publisher <ijfs-publisher@usb.ac.ir>

wrote:

For Free Download:

<<--->>

(38)

Yours sincerely,

Aris Triwiyatno

<<--->>

(39)

39

For Free Download:

<<--->>

(40)

---Original Message---

From: Aris Triwiyatno <aristriwiyatno@yahoo.com>

To: Fateme Kouchakinejad

<kouchakinezhad.ijfs@gmail.com>, "ijfs-publisher@usb.ac.ir"

<ijfs-publisher@usb.ac.ir>

Date: Tue, 23 Aug 2016 14:14:10 +0000 (UTC) Subject: Re: Style of IJFS Paper No. 2080-IJFS

Yours sincerely,

Aris Triwiyatno

<<--->>

(41)

41

Yours sincerely,

<<--->>

(42)

Subject: Scientific Acceptation of Manuscript (Manuscript #2080-IJFS (R2)) Date: 16 November 2016 00.11.27 GMT+7

To: aristriwiyatno@yahoo.com

Dear Professor Triwiyatno, Aris,

The acceptance of your paper and a copyright form is attached to this e- mail. As our regulation, we need you to complete the copyright form. Please fill in the form and e-mail it to ijfs-publisher@usb.ac.ir with a Cc to

kouchakinezhad.ijfs@gmail.com as early as possible. Our publisher will contact you as your paper being in the process of launching.

Yours Sincerely M. Mashinchi

Editor-in-Chief of IJFS

Journal Site: http://www.usb.ac.ir/ijfs/

For Free Download:

http://journals.usb.ac.ir/Fuzzy/en-us/

http://www.usb.ac.ir/fuzzy/Default.aspx

Thomson Ruters Report: Impact Factor 2014 is 0.534 ---

Professor in Mathematics

Shahid Bahonar University of Kerman,

(43)

43

From: "Iranian J. of Fuzzy Systems" <ijfs-editor@usb.ac.ir>

Subject: Pap.No. 2080-IJFS (Editor's Decision Notification) Date: 16 November 2016 16.49.47 GMT+7

To: aristriwiyatno@yahoo.com, sumardi.undip@gmail.com, esaindo@gmail.com

Cc: "Iranian J. of Fuzzy Systems" <ijfs@usb.ac.ir>, IJFS Publisher <ijfs- publisher@usb.ac.ir>, IJFS managing editor <ijfs-meditor@usb.ac.ir>

The acceptance of your paper and a copyright form is attached to this e-mail. As our regulation, we need you to complete the copyright form. Please fill in the form and e-mail it to ijfs-publisher@usb.ac.ir with a Cc to

For Free Download:

Shahid Bahonar University of Kerman, Kerman, Iran

Tel & Fax:(office) ++98-34-33221080

<<--->>

(44)

Subject: Re: Pap.No. 2080-IJFS (Editor's Decision Notification) Date: 16 November 2016 17.15.49 GMT+7

To: "Iranian J. of Fuzzy Systems" <ijfs-editor@usb.ac.ir>

Cc: "kouchakinezhad.ijfs@gmail.com" <kouchakinezhad.ijfs@gmail.com>

Dear Prof. M. Mashinchi Editor-in-Chief of IJFS

At first, we would like to thank you for the opportunity given to us to publish our research in your journal (IJFS).

As your request for regulation of copyright form filling, we attached that filled copyright form with this email.

Yours Sincerely

Aris Triwiyatno

Department of Electrical Enginering Diponegoro University – Indonesia

<<--->>

(45)

45

On Wednesday, November 16, 2016 12:27 AM, Iranian J. of Fuzzy Systems

<ijfs-editor@usb.ac.ir> wrote:

The acceptance of your paper and a copyright form is attached to this e-mail. As our regulation, we need you to complete the copyright form. Please fill in the form and e-mail it to ijfs-publisher@usb.ac.ir with a Cc to

For Free Download:

Shahid Bahonar University of Kerman, Kerman, Iran

Tel & Fax:(office) ++98-34-33221080

<<--->>

(46)

Subject: Pap.No. 2080-IJFS (Editor's Decision Notification) Date: 16 May 2017 15.23.02 GMT+7

To: aristriwiyatno@yahoo.com, sumardi.undip@gmail.com, esaindo@gmail.com Dear Professor Triwiyatno, Aris,

As our regulation, we need you to complete the copyright form. Please fill in the form and e-mail it to ijfs-publisher@usb.ac.ir with a Cc to

kouchakinezhad.ijfs@gmail.com as early as possible.

For Free Download:

<<--->>

(47)

Subject: Re: Pap.No. 2080-IJFS (Editor's Decision Notification) - Copyright Form Date: 17 May 2017 05.49.11 GMT+7

To: "ijfs-publisher@usb.ac.ir" <ijfs-publisher@usb.ac.ir>

Cc: Fateme Kouchakinejad <kouchakinezhad.ijfs@gmail.com>

Dear Prof. R. A. Borzooei

As your request, along with this email I attach the copyright form for our paper.

Your Sincerely

Aris Triwiyatno

Department of Electrical Engineering

Universitas Diponegoro Semarang - Indonesia

On May 16, 2017, at 3:23 P M, IJFS Publisher <

ijfs-publisher@usb.ac.ir> wrote:

As our regulation, we need you to complete the copyright form. Please fill in the form and e-mail it to ijfs-publisher@usb.ac.ir with a Cc to

kouchakinezhad.ijfs@gmail.com as early as possible.

For Free Download:

<<--->>

(48)

Subject: Re: Pap.No. 2080-IJFS (Editor's Decision Notification) - Copyright Form Date: 17 May 2017 11.05.10 GMT+7

Thanks.

Your Sincerely F. Montazerifar Yours Sincerely R. A. Borzooei

For Free Download:

<<--->>

(49)

49 ---Original Message---

Cc: Fateme Kouchakinejad <kouchakinezhad.ijfs@gmail.com>

Date: Wed, 17 May 2017 05:49:11 +0700

Subject: Re: Pap.No. 2080-IJFS (Editor's Decision Notification) - Copyright Form Dear Prof. R. A. Borzooei

As your request, along with this email I attach the copyright form for our paper.

Your Sincerely

Aris Triwiyatno

Department of Electrical Engineering

Universitas Diponegoro Semarang - Indonesia

On May 16, 2017, at 3:23 P

<<--->>

(50)

Subject: Galley proof of paper no. 2080-IJFS Date: 29 May 2017 13.02.18 GMT+7

To: Aris Triwiyatno <aristriwiyatno@yahoo.com>, sumardi.undip@gmail.com, esaindo@gmail.com

Dear Prof. Triwiyatno, Aris,

Please find a galley proof of your paper as a pdf file attached to this e-mail. We are going to publish it in the next issue of IJFS. Please check it carefully and if it is OK please announce me soon and if it needs some corrections please mark them on your paper and send it back within 2 days.

For Free Download:

<<--->>

(51)

Subject: Re: Galley proof of paper no. 2080-IJFS Date: 29 May 2017 14.26.28 GMT+7

Dear Prof. F. Montazerifar and Prof. R. A. Borzooei Managing Editor of IJFS

As you asked earlier, we declare that our paper (paper no. 2080-IJFS) has no errors and can be published.

Thank you very much for the opportunity to publish in your journal.

Yours Sincerely Aris Triwiyatno

Dept. of Electrical Engineering - Diponegoro University - Indonesia

On May 29, 2017, at 1:02 PM, IJFS Publisher <ijfs-publisher@usb.ac.ir> wrote:

<<--->>

(52)

Subject: Pdf File of Paper No. 2080- IJFS Date: 5 July 2017 12.28.13 GMT+7

To: Aris Triwiyatno <aristriwiyatno@yahoo.com>

Dear Prof. Triwiyatno, Aris,

I am pleased to inform you that your paper no.

2080- IJFS

has been published in our current issue: Vol. 14, No. 3 , June 2017. The final pdf file of this paper is in attachment.

For Free Download:

<<--->>