Smithsonian
Contributions to Astrophysics
VOLUME 4, NUMBER 3
ORBITAL ELEMENTS OF METEORS
by GERALD S. HAWKINS and RICHARD B. SOUTH WORTH
SMITHSONIAN INSTITUTION
Washington, D.C.
1961
Publications of the Astrophysical Observatory
This series, Smithsonian Contributions to Astrophysics, was inaugurated in 1956 to provide a proper communication for the results of research con- ducted at the Astrophysical Observatory of the Smithsonian Institution.
Its purpose is the "increase and diffusion of knowledge" in the field of astro- physics, with particular emphasis on problems of the sun, the earth, and the solar system. Its pages are open to a limited number of papers by other investigators with whom we have common interests.
Another series is Annals of the Astrophysical Observatory. It was started in 1900 by the Observatory's first director, Samuel P. Langley, and has been published about every 10 years since that date. These quarto volumes, some of which are still available, record the history of the Observatory's researches and activities.
Many technical papers and volumes emanating from the Astrophysical Observatory have appeared in the Smithsonian Miscellaneous Collections.
Among these are Smithsonian Physical Tables, Smithsonian Meteorological Tables, and World Weather Records.
Additional information concerning these publications may be secured from the Editorial and Publications Division, Smithsonian Institution, Washing- ton, D.C.
FRED L. WHIPPLE, Director, Astrophysical Observatory,
Smithsonian Institution.
Cambridge, Mass.
For sale by the Superintendent of Document*, U.S. Government Printing Office
Washington 25, D.G. • Price 15 cents
Orbital Elements of Meteors
By GERALD S. HAWKINS 1 and RICHARD B. SOUTHWORTH 2
The meteors whose orbits we study here were chosen from the Baker Super-Schmidt photo- graphs taken from stations at Dona Ana and Soledad, New Mexico, from February 1952 to July 1954. The photographs form a homo- geneous and fairly continuous record of the night sky, the major interruptions being caused by periods of moonlight. The principle of the classical decimation process was used to ensure a random sample, every tenth meteor being chosen for analysis. Heights, velocities, and radiants for these meteors were given pre- viously (Hawkins and Southworth, 1958).
The orbital data were computed by the method of Whipple and Jacchia (1957).
The fundamental data for each meteor tabulated in our earlier paper included date, height of appearance, height of maximum light, height of disappearance, radiant, zenith distance of radiant, extrapolated extra-atmospheric ve- locity V
m, photographic magnitude at maxi- mum light, and rise in magnitude above the plate limit.
The orbital elements of 359 meteors, com- puted by Whipple and Jacchia's (1957) method, appear in table 1, which has been arranged to facilitate comparison with other papers in this volume of meteor papers. We omitted one meteor (1954 April 29.13439) because its velocity could not be determined.
We assigned the orbit of the earth to two me- teors (1953 April 11.14238 and 15.24742) whose velocities V
mfall short of the velocity of escape.
Each double-station meteor has two trails and two trail numbers; in the first column of the table we tabulate the trail number used 'by other investigators at Harvard. Forty-six of the meteors selected for our random sample had already been accurately reduced by Jacchia (Jacchia and Whipple, 1961) and are desig-
1
Boston University and Harvard College Observatory.
1
Harvard College Observatory.
nated in the table by an asterisk; the tabulated values are his. The date (Universal Time) will permit identification of the meteor in our 1958 paper.
Members of meteor showers included in the Whipple and Hawkins (1959, p. 545) list have been identified in the usual way. To conform with other papers in this volume, they are designated here in the following code:
Blank—Sporadic 1 —a Capricornid
2a—Southern Taurid-Arietid 3 —Southern t Aquarid 4 —Geminid
5 —Southern 2 Aquarid 7 —Pereeid
8 —Orionid
9 —Draconid (Giacobinid) 10 —Quadrantid
17 —Northern Taurid 19 —Monocerotid 26 —Northern S Aquarid 28 —Andromedid (Bielid) 33 —Northern c Aquarid.
The successive columns in table 1 contain the orbital elements referred to the mean eclip- tic and equinox of 1950.0: major semi-axis a, eccentricity e, perihelion distance q, aphelion distance q', argument of perihelion u, longitude of ascending node &, inclination i, longitude of perihelion defined here as T = u + Q,, and elongation of the true geocentric radiant from the earth's apex X. The values of a, q, and q' are expressed in astronomical units; the values of «, &, i, and r are expressed in degrees.
The standard deviation AV. of the extrap- olated extra-atmospheric velocity V
m, as estimated from all the uncertainties in the reduction, is listed next as a guide to the accuracy of the result. We give no standard deviation for meteors analyzed by Jacchia;
these were long trails of superior quality whose standard errors in V
mwould be less than 0.1 km/sec. The radiant was determined with
85
86 SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ASTROPHYSICS
VOL. 4comparatively small error, averaging seven minutes of arc. Representative values of the errors in the orhital elements that can arise from an error of 0.1 km /sec in V
mare as follows:
a:
e:
q-
± 0.008a
±0.003
±0.003
±0?2/e
ft:
i :
*•:
X:
no error
±0?2 ±0?2/«
±0?2
These values may be multiplied appropriately for larger errors in F . . In unfavorable cases the errors in the elements may be larger.
Whipple's (1954) cosmic weight C.W. and comet-asteroid criterion K are tabulated in the next columns of table 1. The final column contains an approximate value of the mass TO. of the meteor above the atmosphere, com- puted on the conventional model of the single- body meteor (Hawkins, 1957, equation (48)).
Acknowledgments
The research described in this paper was sup- ported jointly by the U.S. Army, Navy, and Air Force under contract with the Massachusetts Institute of Technology. The photographic equipment was constructed and operated under contracts with the Air Force Cambridge
Research Center and the Office of Naval Research. A few of the meteors included in the sample for statistical homogeneity had been reduced previously by Dr. L. G. Jacchia under contract with the Office of Ordnance Research.
References
HAWKINS, G. S.
1957. The method of reduction of short-trail meteors. Smithsonian Contr. Astro- phys., vol. 1, pp. 207-214.
HAWKINS, G. S., AND SOUTHWOKTH, R. B.
1958. The statistics of meteors in the earth's atmosphere. Smithsonian Contr. Astro- phys., vol. 2, pp. 349-364.
JACCHIA, L. G., AND WHIPPLB, F. L.
1961. Precision orbits of 413 photographic mete- ors. Smithsonian Contr. Astrophys., vol. 4, pp. 97-129.
WHIPPLB, F. L.
1954. Photographic meteor orbits and their distribution in space. Astron. Journ., vol. 59, pp. 201-217.
WHIPPLE, F. L., AND HAWKINS, G. S.
1959. Meteors. Handbuch der Physik, vol. 52, pp. 519-564.
WHIPPLB, F. L., AND JACCHIA, L. G.
1957. Reduction methods for photographic meteor
trails. Smithsonian Contr. Astrophys.,
vol. 1, pp. 183-206.
r- oo * m * oo r>» *
C N O I C o r - v O r H i n r H v D r H O t v O V O r H C M CN OD CO f » I - OO O » H rO *
8
* m * O O D C O r H r H v O r H r H r H c O r H CM Ol O fH o l * r l O * HI * CN O in VD O VO CN OOl * COVO 00 O vo r-4 o O O o -O o o o o o i i n v o o o in o o o m rH o o *-H c o O c o c o r H m o o in •*•*• o oi r~ o Ot B * O O O O O O O O O O O r H O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O -H O O * O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O r H O Or*» * rH Ot r H r H rHCN r* O rH vO CO CD P* Ot m * CO rH Ot P* CN O O 01 O rH O O O O O CO O O O O O O O O r H O O O O r H o i O O O O r i o O
• m * c N v o r^otoiot ot o ao * o * v o * m o ot
O O rH CN CN Ol f H r H O O C N O O P - Ot P- O VD * O 00 * CM CN fH VO m CO * vO inOrHOOt r H C O O t C N C O
rH r H r H rA fH fH rH fH
% CMCOCMin r o m v O v O C M CMtHOtCOCM C N V O C N f H i n (N Ol VO * Ol C O * rH VO COCOr* fH CO P- CO Ol d O O O O O O O O O r H O O O O O O O r H O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O
o t o o i n o i r H m o» in <-t co r- r— in ot rH en o oi oo co m in m o r— CM vo Ot CM r» * vo ot o t - 00 r- Ot r— oi H
vocNt~«*oi co o co co r- rHoo»o»cn * ot tH co o CM o o r» * * « t o * n vo oi Oi oo tf> Is o o o t-" o vo * CO Oi * co c— o <n co in r- o o CO N t i r f n co
"n CD H O r* f* O r H O O C M O l O O i r o m m <f l^ <f CO H O O ^ O t r H r H O CO oi Ot Ot vO CO CO CO vO
•H 00 CM O •—I i n f H CO CM CO VO ^ P* ^ ^ f\ Ot O l"^ f—I I** Is* * f ^ Ot fH CM OO * i n r*»
U rH i^* f^ f*^ c*j r** r^ in in co * H t—i CN r^ co o ^r CM CO CO fH fH »H _J _ • i _i i
c o r - o t O i O t
3 280 . 2 281 . 5 282 .
202 . 177 . 171 . 1 282 . 170 . 1 282 . 261 . 1 282 . 174 . 6 282 . 1 283 .
169 . 164 . 6 104 . 319 . 3 105 . 67 . 5 292 . 275 . 7 292 . 267 . 2 292 . 9 292 .
275 . 345 . 9 293 . 273 . 8 113 . 147 . 0 114 . 26 . 1 294 . 254 . 4 115 . 0 295 .
83 . 308 . 4 296 . 7 298 .
197 . 240 . 0 299 . 5 299 . 6 301 .
262 . 294 . 239 . 8 301 . 211 . 1 121 . 149 . 0 123 . 77 . 8 124 . 4 307 .
83 . 236 . 4 313 . 5 313 .
271 . 290 . 4 315 . 181 . 8 136 . 0 317 .
108 . 276 . 4 317 . 279 . 3 319 . 185 . 4 321 . 246 . 3 321 . 8 322 . 276 . 211 .
CO
o
VO
95 2
o
72 7
o
3.4 9
oo
r- rH rH
m
o oi CO t- at at
o o
§
97 7
o
ot at CM IAMO vO vO vO
o
2.8 8
o
3.0 5
o
2.8 9
CM cn CM
57 8
o
95 2
o
1. 9
p-
*
98 1
o
t
97 7
o o o
* p>
vO VO
o
2.7 2
o
2.9 6
o o
CO 00
r»
m at vo t>
at co
o o
CM O CM
69 2
o
VO CO * r» o co at Q O at
o o
9. 5 4.4 6 o
0. 5
O Ot ro tn m tf\
CO
52 5
o
* *
Ot at
°
O r» co f» o o m in m
o o
ot ot oo co r» at r- r» r-
o
2.0 1
o o
2.5 8 2.5 2 o
CO .H w
60 9
o o m
cn m cn in
o
0.75 1
o
1.3 7
CM 00
07 6
o
99 8
o o
r
-
94 1
o
76 3
o
3.9 8
rH
98 9
o
71 6
o
2.4 1
r»
co VO
vo to
5 3 o
01 4
rH
8. 1
o
93 4
o
3.2 9
* rH VO CO
*
96 6
o
65 5
o
2.8 0
*
77 8
o
69 4
o
2.5 5
rH co
r» o
in r- m co O
01 6
rH
o
78 9
o
1.7 5
in
oo
78 0
o
72 3
o
2.8 1
in
*
95 9
o
20 3
o
1.2 0
o
08 8
o
96 1
o
2.2 4 66 4 o
* 00
m co
76 2
o m oo
CM CO r* ro
O
2.4 1
o
1.1 5
m
79 4
o
76 2
o
3.3 4
in rH
M
CM COrH
00 CO m co 00 co
o
14 4
o
1.0 0
O
96 4
o
9.2 4
co vO O r*
m in CN vO * 00 CO at co
o o
*
.49 9
o
* CO O
co m •-•
at co co o o
2. 9 2.7 1 o
2.6 3 47 4
o
80 7
o
CO vO
98 5
o o
CO
69 7
o m m
vo at
o
2.4 5 2.8 3 o
6. 9
8
VO
47 7
o
87 1
o
3.6 9
vO vO
93 9
o
47 9
o
1.8 0
* * * c o * * * c o * * i n t n t n m m m m m m t n
sssss sssss m i l ||||s H i l l 1 1 | | | SSSSS SSSSS
vo -H >H ot m * m m ao o c n o t r H r - i o oi * ot ao m oi co CN O I O I o t * v o m o t m r ^ o t c n * CN CM oo ro ot ot c* cn ao >H ot co rH ot o co * in o co oo r» ot at m o m m r» m M c* CO CD H O> ot o * m r> o o i ot vo cn in m »H CM * rH o o O o at CM oi r-» r* r~ co * r- oo m rH * oo C M C M r » o c NO
*
VO vO r- O> Ol O> H rHrHro*CO Ol co * m vO vO 00 O O oo CM co CN rH ot as oi m at at o ot * vo r » m * v o v o CM o ot o
co o CN co * vo ot m oi * v o o t o c O t H c o v o r - o o oi * vo vo oo r i n M M
n o co ot ot ot at at at r» o o vootooOtH covor-oo oi * vo vo oo HH r<inot CM n * r» ot m vo at o CM _ 00 OK CF Ol Oh 0^ O^ t O CD O CD *"^ CJ <r4 ^H «**4 *rH (^j oi oi Ol O4 oi Of ro T O *^ r*i "^ oi oi \Q r^i tO -f** N O '"""I in r^
U SB Ol Ol Ol Ol 91 Ot Ot CO O O VO «O VO O vO VO VD vo vo vO vO vO VO vO vo vO vO vO vo oi CM Ol oi vO Ol CM CN vO CO co f* * rH fH r-l * r H r H r H r H « f H r H f H « r H r H
88 SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ASTROPHYSICS
Q ft *t
•-4 r** o H rt in h oi eft <*> i n i n i n m o ^ v o c N v o * H * ( N ^ ^ ^
8
vO <N <-i o CO O ft rf vo t r i H i N i n n 0 0 O > - * r ~ - O ro CM o w in o r- 00 *t 00 n a m N o rM r- ^ oi m O O «N <•»"-• C M O O O O 'H CM <N "tf CM H 00 O 00 ^ r» O O 1^ •-• O >-l •-< •"• O "-4 ^ r-l O •-< ^ <N O >H a 6 O O O O O O O O O O •-* O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O o O o O o O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O o r- m vo vo *f « H o n in ^ o> o> o< H <•> C I r- m OD •-> ft \o r~ o m i» r> n eo m o e o H n r~ M a ~ O V O C M O O !-• (•> ^ O ^ O N 5T n fH ^ r-l M <N r-l Oft (N t^ CM * i n i N f M O t N * N O H H (N CM ^ .H ,-3 j£ . . . . .O •-» O O O O O -I O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O ( N O < - < O O O O O O O O O O O O
• vo m IN m CM 9> vo * <N ^f r~ r* in H I»I O D t— N n o n (0 >-t o o ft CM r- ^ in <N o 9 > m 3r H vo r> Oi Is f*- o o 9* r* GO n oi H ^ I D N vo ^ H ^ n M oo ^ 00 ^ 0ft vo C N Cft •-! vo *"> O on »-* m oo o O O « N H « n C M r H r > > P - v 0 | n ^ ^ V O - H O I ^ ^ J
ff
<| O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O o O o
co 00 vo oo vo CD 9" o ft r» CM CM o oo r- n 09 o > o vD vo oo 9i r~ <N ft CM n vo in ^ o ft o cr> on •-) m en co
£ £ 2 !£ 2 O ^ O O H
n 0i in I D n in in <M m vD Ot io m n n on r^ oo *-*»-* ^f Cft vo 9* ro CM CD in GO CM CM GO o r~ Cft ^ H m vo n co < N CM * o*i CM «# • * eft * » H m H M m r - OM vo on m vo oo • * o > * H eo H 91 ^ n o vo H •-< s f o m r» on m o n ^ r t mocMn* n o O n « n < N ^40ftp»vom omr»CMvo r t n ^ n n von-aoeno ri H o ^ ^ H in « m oo m n o vo eft ft 9> ft vo in vo ao oi rv ^ in H Hflin m m m m <» H H H O ) ( N N ^ H O\ O
o> in CM CM <• >* <<r m •-» r~ (Nr-tmro^ t i m N ^ m in m ^ ^ m ^ ^ i n r - i n m r ^ r - mmmmi^- m m m r ^
r - n m o r o
aft _ _ _ _ _ . . _ . . _
i ^ m n M n H * N H « ft r* ft e* e* r-t vo oo co vo o n c f t v b o o o c M ^ i r i in vc ri in vo r»iin^»ob' Tf ft
»~i CM ^f oi CM **H f^ ci oft in vo o co ft Cf r** o m ^p r** vo **^ o in in *~i ft vo CM r** 9* GO oo co in in oo f\ ^f o
^ 00 in O CM CD 1*1 O n ^ d CM f^* CM ft ft Or^^Oftr* CO 00 ^ O Q0 O 00 ft O CM OOOOftOftCft 1^ Is O vO vO
*"• O* ft r** vo i n i n i** »-i eft vo vo r** oft r^- 00 oo eft eft ^ 0ft vo r^* on ^ 0ft vo r^ r** r^ 00 9 i vo r^ Cft on 9t oft fi *t oo r*
m
o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o
n o ft oo o **4 o ft vo o *^ oft CM ^ vo *H *J* (^ (*) oo vo M Is o Is N o r-i ft in co CM o in co ^ o en CM oo on
•H io« nn o oo o H vo N nr^enmr^ rn m on oo en <r oo ao en en co n H M H o H N in ^ en o n oo oi tf • i^- 9* r*» i** r - CM eft eft vo vo v o ^ r ^ ^ v o ^ vo r* ^ * i n H vo CO 5f ^ eft r^ o> I D Is* co r* vo i n vo vO co co vo i n
O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O
O O tH Cft vO O
. . 10 IB (0 18 (0 10 18 « ID 10 it) 10 (0 (0 10 10 10 10 18 (0 IB 10 It! Qi
fe.hk.hh h h h h h XXXXX XXXXX XXXXX XXXXX XXXX*
f^ (O H vD O o O CO O^ CO co m N n H IN ^ n ^ (N r* u> r* o> IN 0t r*) CD n H (^ H o N irt o *N o «-< Is*
*o ^t *f "NI O *N O ^ f^ o *o IO VD *~i ^jj1 cr* f^ r* o o i f ^ n oo cr* H ui H o *~H CN ro o 04 CN ro r^ n (D IN
>» o co ^ i£> o co n ^ t o o i <T\ m so \o <x> r- 00 r* <N PH « - 4 ^ r ^ a o c o VD co m n H Q ^ m N H ( M n 0 0 0 ^
• 03 o o o in r * * r ^ * o © o ^och^r^r1* c*ci^r^\D^f ^f ^f ^ n n ^f*H0^(N\o OO<NU">CO r* co in cn in Q ^^ irt o i o# co ^1 ^* ^f r^ ^f n 01 ^f ^^ ^l ^l ^l PO ^H ro ^f ^f ^t r^ ro ^sF ro ^O xF n^ ^f ^* ^^ ^" ro ^4 ^^ co ^^ ro A l A CH O l f l f > ro ^f if xt *& ^ 00 CO CO Oft Cft O * H H H CO CO f ^ ^ r ^ Is- 0 ^ C>
H rl H H ^ (N fN fN (N (N r ^ « H «HI »-
u) CO co o ^ N n \o co IN <n m r*- ^f n to ^ n 1/1 in r- *H m r* Cft oi *-* CN ro r^ *f vo <r» OD -H in r^ ^ in in
• H r ^ i A ^ D C O ^ I N ^ *o H CA H n 00 o o i CM ^ u> oo O O O CM CN m r ^ C f t r o \ D m m r * - r o ^ H r - C f t t - H r o m
^ ^ ^ ^ ^ m m m # - i o * H r » i < M r * c o co co co co co cftCftCftcftcn e f t o v e f t o o o o o o o o o »H f-i • - ! U> «£> U> \O U ) U ) \O vD O 5f O O O \O \D ^D \O \O vO *JD V D VO VO U> V O (0 I O vO Is n r- I*- in m rn r— i> f^- r» r*-
00 nt
to H o to p * ^ t o o O p ~ p i f i P * o c M P I *t •*& oo ^ to i n CM
8
CM O r** m ro P I "H oo o o P- P I vo O oo ^ # H N h in m H in in CM P* CM o * • o 00 9* ^ vo P I VO O in vo N l f l N O H O O O C M i n r H O H O O O O CM •"• O O 00 CM H I H <« r-4 O VO O PIVDCMI^H MH«tO B O O O H O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O H O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O CM en ^f ^5 c^ oo C3 0ft P I 9* r^ P I in CM ^* CM OO ^f CM P I CM CM *H Ot oo ^f 00 P I 00 to m p* P I to P I C3 ^^ P I r*t p»^ QI H ri in *n p) o ICM oft CM in in oo o in vo P I P* to P I m «~4 P* oo o o ^f ^ o in in ^ oo CM «H CM P* OO P~
O O O O O O O P I O O O rl O ( M O >-* O O O O O O O O H O O O O O O O O O O
ooo
01 n
r» P I 00 P I o n t n o i n P I P I P I in P I P I P I CM o CM P I CM CM m CM P I 00 CM CM P I P I « n n N O O O O O - H O O O O O O O O O O O f-4 O O O O O O O O * - i O O O O O O O
in o to vo IA in to in ^ P I a) H ^ o f i H oi p* o d H o CM Oft ^ GO P- vo in p* CM P I H (0 H o oft oft vo H o H H in CM P I oft oo oo en to oo (** r*- o oo t** oft o oo oft to
0^ O Oft o> i> on e* c* t*
o o 9i CM vo c o r H t o ^ o I N oo at H o I O H H « o o oo P I to H CM m o o 9t P I H oft r-i 5f ao r» oo o» oo CMOt^tO CMHCMCMO 00«-lr>-CMtD P l r ^ f l f t O O ^ P l i n ^ C M P I O H P | 0 » H 0 0 P » > - t t O ^ F> N IN O 4
« ^ CM tO tO C M • • -
o
iS c£ o i H i H r o ro r i -<t ^t l A m m i n m V O O O H C M r o m v o ^ Q CM CM (N <M CMCMOIO N N M IM IN N l<) fl C| 1*1 m»-l»-lf»»CM
CM CM
M O n ^ M O O * N (* oo o 00 n
<N r CM VO f oo * CM oo m n n ) M O en <o m « o O t o o r t v o o o o H VO CM CM MKINO m CM in r> * n o\ r~ o>
4 l N H H H C M C M C M d CMCMCM CM C M t C M 3 CM vo ^ vo H O P I O r- ^t H •* to CM r» CM VO f» oo •* CM r~ oo IA IA CM PI H CM CM O ot to m io
ia 4 H N m oft ao CM. to oo o H vo CM CM r> 4 m N o m CM in r> o> PI O< r* 9> CM r l H H M N tHHN CM CM rH r4 t-i CM CM CM PI CM CM rM CM CMHCM •-•
«-• en m r~ CM
P I m t o ^ m •<* I-H » * I A r>" t D H i o o t o M I ^ N 01 o ^ CM to CM VO r» oo vo PI 9> m oo r~ en en o ot o 9> * m o * « M or»o»«nto r n ^ H ^ p i PI o « oo n 91 en oo r» ao H O M O O I an 91 to ao VO OI o co PI n on P I ao o\ CM r~ I > r- on CM ao o» r- 00 <* 00 Oft r~ ao CM O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O H O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O 00 r- fM ^ vo ^cMtrtOOr" o o ^ ^ f o i o n a< ao r~ o CM CM m H ^ ^ O » P I H r « « h H OIM PI H in on >H 00 0ft 00 H CM o o r-i o ^t oft >• p" r^ P I P I 00 to o to o> r» IM r» P- ^ r~ P I r» CM ao tn in KHM^H P I O to to t - Oft r- to r- o r- P I oft 00 to p> 0ft r- ot 00 O» 00 m <-i oft to to ^f P I Oft P I P I r» •-* to vo m CM <H O»
O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O H in H PI CM *^f CM H oo in in m r*» PI O ot o 01 P* O *$ CM ^ to PI CM PI ^ to *H PI p* PI CM o CM in ot H ot *H PI ^ in ot PI 1*1 CM O CM m o o o 10
PIPJPJPIPI P»P»P>PIPI PIP»P»P>PI PiP>p»p»cM C M ^ C M J ^ P I m tn tt tt m pi«np»p>p» PI PI PI <M CM m m m m m m m t n m i n m in in m m m m m m m >n \t\ tn u% m tn *n m m tn m m i n t n m t n m m i n i n
h M h M M M M M h h H U U U U h h h h h U U U H >i >,>,>, >i >, >, >, >, >, >, >, >, >, >• >i
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * £ J82SS2 £ 2 2 2 2 i i m
P I CO m « m vo vo CM P I CM i n c M v o o i f - i CM CM, O in CM r» m o P» r» m tp o> oo r>- m ao oo n P I r- oo «M oo * ao P I P I CD CM H H H(D4 P I ao vo vo oo P I * ao • * Oft 00 oo m r > H en CM m in r- o 01 o r- H «4 nHh m CM m Oft vo oft • * vo m r- CM <M P I VO co m o CM VD r» m H r- oo ^r t n is O i a i vo 0ft ao o P I VO P I P I m CM
•« • * CM * m m vo o o « « m m m m oo <M vo vo • * o> CM m oo o ao oo CM P I P I P I VO OO m CM «O VO VO H H VO
^i ^ o j ^i ^i i ^ & ^ f f ^ co ^ ^i co 4 oi o ^i ^i oi o o i o f 01 ^ f
C I O I O D O H ff> P I PI «tf vO « O IN 4 in O PI <-* * O 0 ) 0 4 O < i f t i f t H P i r- r- O O H P I H M * r» o» H * vo m 00 o CM tM • * vo vo vo oo H P i m m H CM VO * oo t-» o i n p u t <" r~ o <M <* ^ vo oo oo r4 r-i CM CM CM CM CM PI PI PI PI PI PI PI PI if *t "• 5T CM IM H CM H 5f 4 in m 1(1 Ol in in VO »O VO tO tD tO O
90 SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ASTROPHYSICS
VOL. 4o <*>
. _ _ . _ CN CM _ _
O O O O r H O O O O
o o o o o o o o o o
3 vD rH rH o « (D o N o o <N o »-i o o <•* o o
r» n CM m m co o> m o H %
o in o m vo <»> r> n «n o NOMno r» r^ in m OJ CM o <* O m O ro O O ** OKMOH rH o O rH £!
O O O O O O O O O O O rH o O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O
<2> r^- •-< ro n so m
Hm o o m m
JKD N H HO O O O O O O r-l O O O ••* O O O
O O O O O O rH O O O O O > H O O H O O O Or- OD
o 4 n
* rH vO
vo m o r» o
m m oi in
o o o o
m o r o n s CM o CM m r*i CN
o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o O O o o o o o
rn <r> eo oo 03 n m oo
CM m o> o m oo vo m con o o n n
O N O H NH
4
1n at
i
O cn o vo (0 o n
^ O in cn on rH m
CM CN CMco c* cn
r*> cn co r* cn cn o cn r* r» oo
CM CM O I iN o r- <r>
en m vo oo vo oo
oo in m oo oo n n o o c n m n m en oi cn n
CMcn m in co
cn * j m co o 4 co
r» CO
.2 3
rH m co 00
o
o
rHCD vo m an o CN
o o
rH
r- o
cnan o
rH rH cn • *
on
cn an.3 5
CM CM
o o o
VO CM Ot rH
O 00
«-l O
.1 2
VO
on o
* 00 oo vo m rH m
vo o
o cn o
i n
r»
o
.9 7
o o
.4 7
m cn o
on ao CM O vO VO
rH rH
o
in i-i
o o
rH i-H
.5 5
o
a>o
.4 2
O
<n .6 8 .2 5
•H
in co m
VOo
i no o
.6 4
m o
r-t.1 4
o on
O.8 5
rH
O rH ro
00
o
.4 6
VD O rH
.7 9
o r- o
OI rH
VO
OI
o
.3 7
o o
CM m vo o
vo cn o oo rH O
.7 8
n OI
o
.5 8
o
.7 0
H
•<*
•-<
O
.0 5
o
.8 0
rH
rH o
CMvo co co o co vo cn in
<-H O «-H OOm
CMin ># r» vo m r- r~ <-* rH vo rH en o r» oo oi o oi r~ r-> ct vo to a) io n o f m H in cn o CM on CM in in a n ^ m ^ c n cn CN CM m ^ o i o m c M o i »t r- ^ o m ^ m cn co co V in oo r» vo rH co ^r cn in r- r~ oo r» r» cn ao on *t vo vo r- cn co co vo in «t on vo r- d oo m
Hoo r» ^ co ro oi O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o
I N H m o
oi in t-i m o>«
ui
10
a
•H •
• £
CM CN m m
ro
cn o
2
o o o
CM cn ^
Ma y 5 Ju n 5 Ju n 5
vO vo Cn rH vO CM cn m on co m co CM m CM CM OI cn
o
ro co ro CM 00 00o
cn CM o i rH CM co (O O CN O
o o «*
rH r» ^
^ r^
CN Hco
in m
r
OI CMo
< *
VOOI
r» r»
«
1
co COm
CM<f
CM CMrH
s
I o o o
COm
• > *
00 CMrH CO
m
1
m
I
00 oo cn a\r>
rH
m m
^*
m vo
CM i n^.
o m
CM>-{
ro
m
I
CMon r^
on
<-*vO
r»
vo r**
m co
rom m m
11 o o
CO l »
r» m
co oo I N CM oo oo* o
Ju r
cn
coo
0*OI CO
m
Ju r
covO VOCM CO CO
GO CO
co cn co
r»
CM
m
OI rHro ro ro ^
m m
|
COCM 00 ror*^00
00O
5
O
m
r-i roroin m
It
m co r» oo CM O co co (J\ 0\ Q\OI 00 00
o
on oo CN ^ co mr» CN rH i n
§
CM
•<*
00 rH
o
i n O|rHco ro
m m
| |
VO rH O 0000 o i VO VO oi co ro ro rH r^t co m t>
<o
i nJu r
on
CM•n o
vOi n roi n
Ju r
co o
ro vOrHOS on on
00 00 00 00
*
c*
OI
m
Ju r
00
co vo
ror^
rH VD roro
roi n
Ju r
o o o
fOo
OIo
CMro
m
1
OI i n
|
m
in m CM1
CO ro O
vOCM OI rH
CM CM
vO
o
i - H
OI roOI
00 OI
ro ro
*
cn
in CMrH o ii n,_, 1 o
ro OI OI
r>
vo
i nc cn
rH roOIOI
m
rH VOCM rH OIin in
Ju r
i n rHOI OIOI i nOI
co
^» «
rH VO OI i nCMrHrH r*.
OIrH i n
C
"t
^#rH CO (Oi n
Ju r
o co
ro on cn OI CM O I ro<N rH
cn on
rH«
in in
ro,_,
*TrM r~
ro
^ .
co
vO ro Or-lon
vo mCO OIi - H
ro
m
1-33 n OIOo o
rHcn cn ro co
m m
3S
r- on
r** ^
ro CO OI OI in m rH rH ro oi O CNO O
CO COORBITAL ELEMENTS OF METEORS 91
r-i o m m .-i
o o o o o o o o o o
m CO rt to r- •V O O P I tO <• * tO P» 00
Ol P* rH p» p^ oi CD *H ^ in OD PI OI ^ d 00 00 OO PI rl m r l rl 00 H M IN (T> O O O tO O <N O P»
•-torn «N o •-< o o PI to o o o t o o o t o o o o o o o
O O P I O O O O O O f N O O O O O O t O O O O O O Oo
d o o d o
o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o
to * on m
r* «ooomr>r- con
O O O O O O O O
10 n ^ n o o r » O 0 0 0 0 0
o o 00 to r~ 00 to vo <-* n
«* 00 00
04 •-• er> n eo
p* ^ P » P » P » O o " * " * ^ r* p * p i P i m w P- * o oi ^ p » m p i ^ p i on p » ^ r » i - 4 p i co oo PI co oo <N ^ on o o H N ui m n mp»cn<-ir>i
p^ ^ o QO
NOIOHIO r - o t m o o * * •» r u t o
m p*o fMi-i^mot rtw^HH
» - l ^ t ^ l H H H
in CM n oi ^ r ^ H r ^ f M o i m o m i oiiii
iiiii iiiii iiiii Miii sssss iii
cn«r>-<r. aoocncMto « OD « m H p-r-«nr-f>t i f l M H w o j 01 00 00 co r- 00^4-^ooin
rJ
2 2 2 2 2 2
.-l H « rl It n
ri ri p» PI m m ^t
+•
on m n nriMnn ^ O PI o N O n en ^ p-m m r» 5 m ^ *"* in en PI en
01 • • • • • . . . . . • . . . • • • • • • • « • • • • • • • . . . . m » » * * - j« * c j - o « - > * * * * * * - • e o ^ m r - ^ - > { C * $ 2 - * r , g ^ * P > J » * c o r H S ^ * f> •-! ao ^* **4
P^i0 to "^ *"4
P^c4 in in
PI OOon in »~i o p^ oo
PIto
P**to to O
P** P^m oi oo m p*
PIto to on on en o o ch r-i IA IA to to t^ o on o to to o ^ en vo o ^ ^ IA I A f) or^p^cnoi en r-i ^ in en n h- m H ^
01 n o H f i S OSHOO o P- o en S en en «N r- o <N en to en en o en en o ^ oo o en en en « c o c n c o r >OHOo'o OOOOO rio'rioo O O O O r-l O O O O O H O O O O O r H O O O O O O O O
^ ^ H rt PI ao on p** PI o ocninto<*> ^ ^ r * i * i i n r»tf>f>p*co H h H o w oooninp^m r*» to ^ o to to 04
<N P^ «H P*to ^ r**
P* ft o **) oo <Nin d d tH
«Hci
P^in oo on
*H GO CDto ^ ^
P*Ift *^ *~* on oo ^
*H P*9 ao p^ en on en en p* on en on «o o to on P- on to OD oo in on on p- on on t o i n o n o n c n ro on en to o en oo en en on O O O O O O O O O O O < H O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O OOOOr-l O O O O O
r-
on oi p» i n c n a o t o o t N i n ^ ' P I f t ao to «N m en vo r-i o r- o to m
C*l CO «H ^f o OI d d d C4 <N PI Ci 00 O On
CNrH ^ f>j r*> 00 c*l ^ P* OI OI ^4 OI OI rH ^f oi oi P"- ^ P^ tO On rH
nH ao to »H « n r » p » m .-• *4 «o ^ I-I ro
m c i i n m
n n n o i i n O I O I O I O I O I
w n N n n r<( n in n n p i m m n n
in m m m i n m m m m m m i n m m i n m m m i n m m m m m i n* 22333 ^1 2
12* 2
1? S
1? ? ? ? ? 2* 2
12" 2
1g i g » » c n g i O> &> O> ff> O > CnO<CnOiO>
^ 5 3 3 3 3 3 2 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3
o - issSa s25s£ sSSSs S S S K J S S S S ? S S S ^ S S S S S S §g§J3 5SSJS S3J3S S3333 32333 33SSS SSSS
00 o m vo r^
01
PIin
PIoo
m m m P» m00 00 00 00 00
92 SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ASTROPHYSICS
8 e
X
cj
i
001 7
o
co vO rH
.0 3
rH
in
o
013 0
o
rH
O
.1 5
CM rH
000 8 018 5 04 3
o
rH CN rH
.4 0
o
en
o O
rH
fH
in oo
O
O
en on rH001 3
o
in en
-
1.1 4
en o
en cn CM en
o o o o
oo in m r>
O o
1
060 0
660 0
o
3
o
CM 00 CO m en CM
o m o o
rH
in en vo C N
o o o o 005 1 013 2 o cn o
.4 8
CM
O
O
VO CN
O
.9 6
in
o
in en en in
o o o
co oo CM
.3 3
o
r- o
o
009 6
o o o
rH
VO en 01 O
CO o
04 1
o
rH
o
.1 6
en o
OTT O
o
VO
o
.0 0 .001 0 o
CM CN
.6 5
o
fH
000 7
o
03 7
o
CO rH m CM
o
.4 7
rH CM
o
.7 0
00
o
003 6
o
CN rH
o
1
.0 6
en O
010 8
O .04 5 .012 5 o o
en CM vO O en CN
O
.9 8
CM
o o
.6 7
CN
O
o
rH
CM
O
.000 4
o
.4 7
rH
.06 8
m o
.03 5 .002 4 o
.2 6
o
i
cn
rH
en
O
O
.7 7
rH
.8 2
CN
o
.014 0
o .005 9 .000 5 o
m vo en CN
o
.9 1
fM
O o
.8 5
CM
O O
.9 5
o
.3 6
p~
o
.000 5
o
.5 2
o
.4 5
„
o
.000 3
o
.3 2
CM
.3 8
m o
.003 9
o
.8 8
rH
en
rH
P-
o
009 3
o
in rH
o
i
P>
rH
CM O
000 9
o
.09 0
o
CN
004 1
o
cn iH
o
.3 9
CO
M*
O
000 2
o
• < *
o
.6 7
o
en
O
fZO O
o
fM
o
rH
o
011 4
o
•H
m o
02 9
o o n o
co co o
•H
en
O
fM
fM
O
en <n vo •** r» en C N en vO m P- vo t en m
CN rH 0V CM 00 cn ^r co rH ( N C M en C N rH cn
o
V rH1
i Rando m S a
«
•H
w
rH ID U
— Orb i
•H
cS
3
tr
V
«
•0
2 12 3 42 .
co
14 9
CM
VO
3 o
.93 8
o
en m
co rH
42 .
o
19 9
cn rH
99 4
o 2 11 4 42 .
co
14 6
o
rH
en o
m co o o
VO <*
«N T»
en in
CM t
<* CO fH rH
m
1- CO
fH O O rH
!"• CM en m CO 0t
o o
2.0 6 8.9 9 0.95 1 0. 9 4 10 6 45 .
co
20 3
CM
o
60 6
o
0. 7
rH
CO
co on cn
29 4
00
m o
.44 2
o
1.0 3
p -
32 1
en
in
O
rH CN
49 .
vo in
25 7
CM
vO O
rH en vo cn cn P »o O
30 5
en
en o
77 7
o cn on o
CO rH *rH
52 .
cn
32 2
rH
o
94 7
o
2.3 8
CM
69 .
o
20 4
rH
01
O
70 1
o
3.2 4 3 12 5 71 .
m
21 7 117 .
rH
51 .
o
CM
73 .
m
31 0
0i m CM
o
98 5
o
9. 0
O
.72 0
o
1.9 3
o
93 7
o
3.2 2 73 . 22 8
en
54 . 12 4
en CO CN
cn CM
o
42 2
o
1.5 7
O
5 12 5 74 . 27 5
co
o
5 11 3 54 . 34 6
CO
en o
xf rH m
cn co oo
co cn p-o
2.4 7
o o
4.6 1
CM
76 . 24 3
en
r- o
71 3
o
2.7 0
en
56 . 12 9
en
CNen o
73 6
o
1.1 7
CM
57 . 12 1
cn
CM
en O
74 1
o
1.3 7
CM
57 .
VO
o
76 4
o
2.8 0
rH
CM
57 . 3 17 7 77 .
CM
CM
fM
in
o
rH CN
oo o
CN P>
01 CM
m cn o
1.4 0
o
CN CN CO
o o
CO
23 1
o
CN CM CO
22 7
rH en
co oo
o
51 0
o
1.7 9
o
94 7
o
cn
82 . 26 1
00
VO
O
CM
13 2
o
rM
CM
O m vo o
2.8 0
o
1.5 2 2 14 8
CM
10 .
co vD O
88 1
o
5.6 0 3 13 1
CM
27 6
o vD
n vo O
81 7
o
3.3 0 1 17 4 83 . 28 3 40 .
•<*
en o
98 1
o
0. 4
• » *
83 .
rH
27 4 26 .
o o
96 5
o
m
rH
84 .
rH
25 5
r»
00 CM
o r- O
59 9
o
1.7 9 2 13 7 25 3
(T>cn o
05 7
rH
in rH
m
12 0
vO
o en
fN
en o
80 4
o
1.6 9 1 15 2 85 .
rH
22 6
cn
VD
CO CO
o
76 4
o
3.6 8
iniH
in oo 00rH
31 6
VO
39 .
fSI rH
o
99 3
o
cn co
m r~
m
03 COm
rH26 8
•H in
m co m m o
82 4
o
3.1 5
O
77 3
o
in
i I 1*1* 1*1*
* O rH rH en O * rH
cn o o
<H CM CN CM ^s* s* s* s* s*
< co to co co o CM oo en en r- CM in co CM en CM oo m r>
m r-t «n t> en cn rH CM en en
CN CN CN
m m m a o, a
« S» a)
CO u) M 00 CN rH m cn rH cn vo p»
en rH r~
en en ^
o, a,
(a co 8* g* g 1 8* g*
to co to co co vO P» CO P» en m vo en xf en O en xf O <-t p* oo co cn p*
en C M C M C M en
Q, Q, Q, Q, 0, CD <0 Ci) CD 0) 10 CO (0 10 0) r-t rH rH VO C n VO P* O P- rH en in o o xf
p-» p*>
\ o vO vO r-t rH en en en04 Qi P i P I P I 0) CU 4) CD 0) W W W CO W en m en fM P -
aao.fr
(u cu CD y o W W CO O O H<f r/OO^ en fH r» 0*
m co xf vo O n en oo o H en en xj* CM e*)
m m m vo oo vo
on 0i oo o vo m m vo 00 CO en en
cn vO vO • VO CM * VO VO CM vp VO vO vO vO en en en en CO
cn t * o -H o
<-t o en m P»
CM en cn en cn
t CM •>» vo oo CN CN * f xf TT in in m m m
in vo r~ P» oo vo co o <N t in in vo vo vo
o oo o CM o r> vo cn GO o vO vO vD P* CO f * t rf CD <D
1
c.w .
.041o
.043
o
.00052
o ro CO ro
* (N H O
11.9
0. 3
o
i
6.21
o ro
1.08
1. 0
.0101 o OIo o
2.91
ro O
.089
o
• « *
o
o
2.00
Ot Ot OI OI
o
Ot OI o
2.20
o
m m o
i
1.21
0. 2
0TT0*o
Ot OI
o
1.53
0. 2
.0094o
rH o
T0T0*
o
m
rH o
3.19 3.89
0. 3 0. 2
.0029o
co rH
0.30 .033
o
o
1.67
0. 1
0105 .00193o
ro rH O
7.04
o o
o
0.68 .00148
o
rH o>
rH
7.63
o o
.0097
o
0033
o
.0086
o O ro CO ro ro tO O
5.48
0. 3
o
2.97
o o
4.45
0. 7
0119 0063o o
at « OI OI rH O
LI.9 2.98
o o
0102
o o
rH
o
15.9
0. 3 03 3 o
rH O
2.72
o
00189
o
0170
o
at ot OI
0.14
0. 2
o
1.37
0. 1
00060o
rH rH OI
0.20
0. 5
00042o
0095 0035 0134 .00044
o o o
at «o to r»
ro oi ro O rH
0.16
0. 4
O OI O
2.50 2.16 2.96
o o o o
PM to
o
0.83
0. 8
134 0055o o
OI 00 at o
o o
0.93 L2.2
o o
0073
o
OI OI
o
0.812*0 0102
o
00190
o
a t * Ot ro OI
1.52
rH
LI.6
0. 4
0152 00054 00163 0030 00052o
r4 OI O
8.83
0. 2
o
CO rH
0.71
0. 4
o o
s
0.76
0. 4
to OI
o
ro OI r-l
0.22 0.84
0. 3
ro CD r» ro CD
r- m ro <* o « <o <o a H OO ro * to ro oi m ao oo to « I < I O H « oorHr^mto
in • * r- so at \o at <-H rt m oMAHn rH at at oo oi at to to ^ ro ao ro ao o to r* oi y rt is o rH o o at rH m o ro rH « co n inr> ^ • r- N in ao m ro ot to m o i o i r o r o ro <• at m ro oi <-\ t- m oi a> i n ••» ro * '-t «n o i o r^ot oi c» r» i*- r» m i© nh<< to to r» m
rH rH rH f\ ft 1-1 rH rH rH rH rH r- r~ at p~ co m co a o to to r- to t o at to co oo oo ot at at r~ at at r*- at co at at r» o o o co ao ao at at ao ao o t o t a t o i r o m in m m m m to to co ao a t o t o o o o N n N n r o m m m m to to t o r- r» r~ r~ •> co oo co aa co •-< rH ot ot at at rH ototrHOtat O I H n CKM O OI OI O O OOIOOOI OIOIOOIOI n n n o o rlHH rH w-\ r* ft wt ft rH rH t-t OI O» O| ft OI OI OI OIO|
co oi m at oi o oo ^t ro in o o to m rt r» r- ao at oi at m m r» to in to 10 o 4 r- m ro r» in to m ro ao ot
r- m * 00 00 OI OI i n rH
r» <N r- r- ro co at oo root oo m r- co ot r- «o oi at ot « oi o at r- o t o t o o ^ r o co r> to ^ m m at at ro to oito^rror* at at to to r» ot in r i at r> o at at o oi er> «o «-i ot at ^ r> o H m ro vo at to r» r» ao at r» to D* co CD r» in to ot at m ro oi atrHi^otoi m r* m in CM ^ o Ot r i r> co ro at ro in ao rH ot «o ro r» m m p» r*- 0 0 0 0 0 O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O o O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O 01 rH o ro Ot Tf " * ro rH ro at at o 00 "t P» O ro Ot >* in O H I N in Ot to rH oi ro O O ro 00 oi 00 CO Oi r-l Is-
n ro o at o ^ o <-i r- at rH • * oi o •-« r- co ^r r» oi • * otr>a0r-4to H O M O * O I <• co oo ^t m m m r- ~
•H v ^ m at r- to r~- ro r* r» oo a t o t r ^ o o o t r^ eo ro at oo to to ot at at at oo at r» ao rH oo «o at a t m at at a t
O
o
.4 6
o o o
ro rH t-» oi 03 O
.9 2
o
.3 7
o
.4 6
o
OS*
o
.7 3
o
.4 5
o o
C O
* <-*
o
.3 9
o
.4 9
o o o co m
ro 00
o
.944
o
.1 8
o
.4 7
o
.8 5
o o
to to
o
.2 6
o
at
o o
.9 5
o
00
o
.4 4
o
.5 3
o o o
.952 .04 .14
o o o
oi m
o
.7 5
o
at
o
m
o
00
o
.2 6
rH ro «» tO 00
U m ro ro ro ro rooioiroro rororooiro o i o i o i o i o i M r« n N in oioioioiro oi oi oi oi ot O I O I O I O I O I r" m in in m m m i n i n m m m m m m in m m m m i n u* tn ttt >n m in m m m m m in m m m minmmm
• 4J -P +J +> -P -P -P -P -P +» -P -P -P -P -P -P -P -P +• -P -P -P -P -P -P * ! * ) + » + » * » *J +» *1 -P -P *» -P -P *» -P
S ^8H^H 88888 88888 88888 88888 88888 88888 88888
i*-romr»t^ oi oi oi o m MniAHn ootor^aoo rnaoomo* *r»r»ror» oo«oitnin om*o»p.
m o N « o o i >* at rH oi « <r H « io r^-aotoroo ot m ao r» r* n oo m * r i n^o wo ^ <» H r> n
>t ro ro ro • * ro IN r» r- <* r-» <o n (M H H r» o to at O oi ^ CO at in o ^ O ro rH oi <r to tO at ot r» m ro m
* m ot ^ ao cr> at at ot • * • * r H r - i t - i r o r o r- ao to ^f m m rH ro ro oi o to ao ao oi <» ^ • * r- oi oi r» ro to ro O oi oi ^f oi ro ^^ ^4 ^4 OI oi ro oi ro ro ro OI oi Oi ro ro ro oi ro ro ^f ^l* *^l ro ro ^f ^f ^f ^f o§ ro ro ro ^f OI ro
ro ro «*» to r» at at at at at atoooioi n n ^ * * f to vo to to r» at at at at at at ot rH «-
N N M N N
•H 09 t in 00 r- ro O 00 rt rt t O O O O O t O • * oi in r- at r H o i ^ t O ' N Oi N r l * r > M1* O * <T tO m Ot ro O -ri . o i ^ t o a D r H rt ro oi in in r ^ O t o i i n ^ r- r« Oi H r i oi ^ \O to 00 OQrHroroOt u> in in r*- at at rH ro to 00 a o co ao co a3 at at r» r- at a> at at o r>- o r» r» r- co ao act ao ao ao o ao at at at o at at at at at a t o o o o U 55 00 00 00 09 CD aO 5f ^r ao CO <O CO Ot • * Ot *» M> f rt " * rt rt ** rt Ot rf rt rt rf at rt rt rt t rt rt tn m m m
*H * • * « *