SMITHSONIAN MISCELLANEOUS COLLECTIONS VOLUME
107,NUMBER
8SOME IMPLICATIONS OF THE CERAMIC COMPLEX OF
LA VENTA
(With
6 Plates)BY
PHILIP DRUCKER
Bureauof American Ethnology, Smithsonian Institution
'v::
U T^.
'i^
m
(Publication 3897)
CITY OF WASHINGTON
PUBLISHED BY THE SMITHSONIAN INSTITUTION
JULY
30, 1947SMITHSONIAN MISCELLANEOUS COLLECTIONS VOLUME
107,NUMBER
8SOME IMPLICATIONS OF THE CERAMIC COMPLEX OF
LA VENTA
(With
6 Plates)BY
PHILIP DRUCKER
BureauofAmericanEthnology, Smithsonian Institution
(Publication 3897)
CITY OF WASHINGTON
PUBLISHED BY THE SMITHSONIAN INSTITUTION
JULY
30, 1947ZU
£or5 <§<xit\mou{pvtee BALTIMORE, MD.,U. 8.A.SOME IMPLICATIONS OF THE CERAMIC COMPLEX OF LA VENTA
By PHILIP DRUCKER
Bureau of American Ethnology, Smithsonian Institution
(With
Six Plates)The
investigationsof the National Geographic Society-Smithsonian Institution expeditions atLa
Venta, Tabasco, yielded a quantity of valuable dataon
an importantMeso-American
culturewhich
hascome
tobe called"Olmec."
Thisdesignation, with itsshadowy
ethnic connotations, is perhaps not the happiest one that couldhave
been selected, but still it is better than theterm "La Venta"
suggested for the culture at the conferenceon
theOlmec problem
at Tuxtla Gutierrez in 1942, for the sitename
shouldmore
properly be re- stricted to the particularcomponent
or horizon ofOlmec
culture represented there.By way
of background, the excavations atLa Venta were
notrandom
explorations, but ratherwere
part of a definiteprogram mapped
outby
Dr.M. W.
Stirling for an attack on theproblem
ofMeso-American
culturegrowth from
the peripheries ofMaya
ter- ritory. After the first season'swork
atTres Zapotes, Stirling recog- nized that hewas
dealing with a culture, which, though ithad Mayan
linkages,
was
not simply a pallid marginal derivative, buthad some
distinctiveness of itsown. Among
themore
impressive discoveries hemade was
that of acarveddate that appearedto refertoBaktun
7.Stirling also
was
struckby
thestylisticsimilaritiesbetween
themonu-
mental stone art—
particularly the colossal heads— and
the mysteri-ous "baby-face" or
"Olmec"
figurines of jadeand
of claywhich had
not at that time been associated with an archeologicallyknown
hori- zon.He
reoriented his plan of research to allow for amore
inten- sive study of thisnew
culture of southernVeracruz
state.Excava-
tions at Tres Zapotes
were
continued into a second season,and on
thebasis of stratigraphic materials Iwas
subsequentlyable to outline a local ceramiccolumn which
substantiated Stirling's conclusions as tothe probable contemporaneityof the early datewhich
hehad
basedon
a studyof the stonemonuments
in that it revealedan earlymono-
SMITHSONIAN MISCELLANEOUS COLLECTIONS, VOL. 107, NO. 8
2 SMITHSONIAN MISCELLANEOUS COLLECTIONS
VOL. I07chrome
horizonwhich showed
sufficient specific typological resem- blances—
not justvague
similarities—
towares from
archaicMayan
levels at far-away
Uaxactun
to warrant assigning it an approximatelycontemporary
dating. Following conformablyon
this early horizonwere two
succeeding ones, Middle,and Upper Tres
Zapotes. In the course of reconnaissance in the region, Stirling visitedLa
Venta,where
hefound numerous monuments
stylistically akin to those ofTres
Zapotes,^and
he judged the site to bean
important one.The work
at Cerro de lasMesas
in 1941 proved tobear only indi- rectlyon
theOlmec
question, forwe
soon realized that neither in ceramics nor inany
other important respectwas
that site likeTres
Zapotes. It provedtorepresentan intrusiveHighland
culture, geneti- cally related throughout its history to that of the Mixteca-Puebla area. Thismeant
thatthewesternornorthwesternboundary
ofOlmec
territory
must
have beenbetween
Cerro de lasMesas and
Tres Zapotes, though thetwo
sites are less than 50 miles apart, airline.The
following year Stirling sentme
toLa Venta
to obtain strati-graphicsamples of theceramics
and
to test theceremonial structures.In 1943 Stirling
and Wedel
carried out extensive excavations of the ceremonial complexes,and
subsequently, the former extended his reconnaissances of the region to the point of being able to define with considerable exactness the geographical extent ofOlmecan
cul- ture. Since Iwas
otherwise occupied, theLa Venta
potterycom-
plexes gathered dust inWashington, and
only recently has it been possibletostudy them.The
complete reporton thework
atLa Venta may
be delayed for a time, so it seems well tosummarize
the results of theceramic study.La Venta
is situatedon
a small islandlike structure of solidground
surroundedby swamps,
a short distance northeast of the junction of theTonala and
Blasillo Rivers. It liessome
little distance inland, but so low is the general terrain that the low Gulf tides floodand
ebb in the riversand
sloughsaround
the island.The
habitable areais relatively small,
and
certainlywould
not have supported theman- power
thatmust
have been utilized to handle the stonemonuments and
build the massive structures—
itseems more
probable that the sitewas
a ceremonial center with a smallpermanent
population of priests, or priest-rulers,and
their personal servantsand
perhaps artisans, supported by tributefrom
neighboring villages located on similar elevated areasamong
theswamps, from
which, as well, the laborerswere
recruited formajor
constructional endeavors. If this1Stirling, M. W., Stone monuments of southern Mexico. Bur. Anier. Ethnol.
Bull. 138, 1943.
NO. 8
LA VENTA CERAMIC COMPLEX — DRUCKER
3surmise is true, it indicates considerable centralization of authority
and an
elaborate organization.A
series of40
test pitswas dug
to locate the areas of continuous occupation.Thick
beds of culture- bearing depositwere found
to befew and
small, although inmany
places extensive thin caps of deposit occur.
On
the basis of the evi- dence suppliedby
the test pits, three stratitrencheswere
putdown.
One,
stratitrench2, ran into sterile soilafew
inchesdown —
a recheckof the nearby deep test pit
showed
that a little gully or pockethad
been filled with refuse,but theareal extent of deep depositwas
negli- gible.The
othertwo
trencheshad
respectably thick layers of sherd- bearing refuse,4 and
5 feet each,and between them
yielded a total of a little over 24,000 pottery fragments.From
the esthetic point of view.La Venta
ceramicsare disappoint- ing.One would
scarcely anticipate finding so drab a lot of waresamong
the remains of themakers
of the great sculpturedmonuments and
the carved jades.Of
course, part of this drabness derivesfrom
the poor preservation of the sherds, heavily erodedand
leached bysoil acids;
now and
again a better-preserved fragmentshows
a lustrous surface that suggests that the general efifect of the potterymay
have beenmore
pleasing. Similarly, rarebut well-executed bits ofmodeled
ornaments,and
occasional examples of graceful vesselforms
(pi. 2) demonstrate that themanufacture
of artistic wareswas
notbeyond
the makers' capacity. Itwould seem
that the people ofLa
Amentahad
but slight interest in ceramics as a field for artistic expression, notenough
to leadthem
to elaborate the painting of their vessels, or to carve or incise anything but the simplest of designs on them. Painted decoration is extremely infrequent in our samples,and
incised ornament, though a littlemore common, most
often con-sists of a
few
circumferential lines about the rim or lip of a pot.A
number
of decorative techniqueswere known
: in addition to model- ingand
pre-firing incising,heavy
pre-firing grooving, punctation,and
rocker stamping (pi. i, c-e) occur inthelocal ware, butwere
utilized so infrequently that they scarcelyshow
in thepercentage tables.The
high priestwho
conceived amonumental theme and
chalked the guide lines on ahuge
block of basalt,and
the master artisanwho
translated the guidesinto delicately
modeled
planes, bothwould seem
to have been indifferent as to the appearance of the everyday vessels
from which
they ateand
drank.Even
the pieceswhich must
have served ceremonial ends, to judge by the fact that theywere
placed in the cists in the Ceremonial Enclosure,were
of thesame
rudelymade
types as the pots in daily use in the occuption areas.On
the basis of thickness of deposit, amost
inexact criterion but4 SMITHSONIAN MISCELLANEOUS COLLECTIONS
VOL. 10/one
which
is probably safeenough
in arough and
ready way,we may
judgetheLa Venta
occupation to have been ofmoderate
length.The two
stratitrenches appearon
thebasis ofware
distributionsand
trends to have been not contemporary but successive: the deposits of stratitrench i, with an average depth of about4
feet, succeed those of stratitrench 3,which had
a thickness of about 5 feet, withlittle if any overlap. Ceramically speaking, there is
no major
break between the
two
deposits, indicating that they represent a con- tinuum.Nine
feetof culture-bearing deposit, ina tropical zonewhere
somuch
of the organic refuse is destroyed orwashed away com-
pletely, is really a fair amount. Fortunately,
we
are not completely dependenton rough
guesses as to deposition rates for a chrono- logical placing of the materials, for typologically theymay
be related tothose of othersitesatwhich
ceramiccolumns
have been established, particularly the Tres Zapotes sequence.This is not the place for a detailed account of
La Venta
wares, but their general characteristicsmay
besummarized
briefly.While
painted decoration occurs in simple, not to say crude, patterns, in red or blackon
one or another of thecommon
slips, it is so infre- quent thatwe may
call the pottery essentiallymonochrome.
Several of themajor wares
are very like certainTres
Zapotesmonochrome
wares, heavy-walled, not too wellfired, with abundant coarse aplastic (which appears to be stream sand with a high proportion of quartz particles),
and
with about thesame
range of slip colors within the"brown" and
"black" groups.White and
red over-all slips occur in smallquantities.As
at Tres Zapotes, therewas
inuse a firingmethod which
produced dishesand
bowls with dark grayand
black bodiesand
nearly white or grayish rims.However
itwas
done, atLa Venta
it
was
not so standardized as at the former site, butwas
practiced witha variety of dififerent pastes.Even more
likeTres
Zapotes, there occurs an importantgroup
of vesselsmade from
a very finelydivided paste withno
visible aplastic,which
fired insome
casesfrom
orange tobufifin color,and
in others, toblackand
gray.This is the
same
kind of potterywhich
I designated the "Poly-chrome Group
ofWares"
inthe description ofTres
Zapotesceramics, because theybecame
the chief vehicle for thepolychrome
decora- tion of theUpper
Tres Zapotes period.However,
it cannot be demonstrated that they bore painted decoration throughout their history,and
Inow
prefer to callthem
Fine Paste waresand
dififer- entiate between theirmonochrome and
painted varieties.The
his- tory of development of the Fine Paste wares will be of considerable importwhen
completelyworked
out—
T believethem
to be ancestralNO. 8
LA VENTA CERAMIC COMPLEX — DRUCKER
5to the
well-known
FineOrange which
is suchan
important timemarker
throughmost
of centraland
southern Mexico.At La Venta
Fine Pastewares
occur in small but gradually increasingamounts
in the stratitrench 3 deposit,and
achieve a high numerical frequency in stratitrench i.One
importantLa Venta
ware, Coarse BufT,which
occurs throughout thecombined
deposits, did not appear atTres
Zapotes, nor can I relate it toany
other describedceramic type.Vessel forms, expectably enough,
show numerous
points ofcom-
parisonwithdominant
Tres Zapotestypes. Flat-bottomedlow
bowls, or dishes, with flaring sides,and
rimswhich
run through a series of variantsfrom
a simple direct to flaring to everted, arecommon
in all wares (pi. 2, b),and
"composite silhouette" bowls, with walls that lean infrom an
angular break, then recurve strongly to a flar- ing rim, likewise occur though they are never abundant.With
these latter, as atTres
Zapotes, is associated a double, elongateS
design.Both
neckedand
neckless jars occur, the latter being one of themost
frequent of all forms.As
for modifications, both solid lugsand
loop handles occur, though never in particular abundance. Feetand
legs are noteworthy by their absence.There
is only oneexample
of afootin theLa Venta
collections,and
itmay
be an importedpiece.Annular
bases,on
the other hand, are fairlycommon
(pi. 2, g). It will be recalled that atTres
Zapotes heavy annular bases occurredalso, although in addition various types of feet
and
legs, mostly of tripod vessels,were
found.The
over-allLa Venta
ceramic patternis, in short, close to that of
Tres
Zapotes,and
specifically to that of theMiddle
period.Clay figurines
from La Venta
belong in the archaistic tradition ofhandmade,
usually solid, figures, with features indicatedby
incising or applique orboth (pis. 3-6).No mold-made
specimenswere
found.Typologically, nearly all the
La Venta
pieces fit into the pattern representedby Middle Tres
Zapotes, inwhich
therigidly standardizedforms
of theLower
periodwere
manipulatedand
modified into a series of variants,owing
in part, perhaps, to certain alien influences, but also to processes of local developmentand
elaboration.At La
Venta,some
of theself-same types occur as inMiddle
Tres Zapotes, along withsome
variant types, the ultimate kinship ofwhich
withLower Tres
Zapotes is clear.For
cross-dating purposes, theLa Venta
figurines aremost
sig- nificant: they point to a very definite time correlation withMiddle
Tres
Zapotes. This, it should be emphasized, is thesame
dating that the general picture of the ceramics suggests.One
factor only sug- gests a modification: the high frequency of Fine Paste sherds in6 SMITHSONIAN MISCELLANEOUS COLLECTIONS
VOL. I07stratitrench i.
At Tres
Zapotes, these wares, oftenadorned
with painted decorations, attain high frequencies only in theUpper
period, atwhich
time a series ofaHen
elements such as mol(i-made figurines, Teotihuacan-type tripod bowls, "candeleros"and
the like suddenlymake
their appearanceon
the scene. Since all these latter traits areunknown from La
Venta, it seemsmost
logical toassume
that the zone of development of the Fine Paste ceramicsmust
have been in or near theLa Venta
region,and
that they, or at least the increased emphasison
them, dififusedfrom
there in a westerly direction, thatis, to Tres Zapotes, affecting the latter site at the
same
time as a series ofnew
influences,presumably from
the Highland,made them-
selves felt.
The
absence of the whole series ofHighland
elements atLa Venta may
be attributed to a slight time lag in diffusion, or to local conservatism—
perhaps to both. I suggest that chronologically theLa Venta
occupation likely overlapped the L^pper Tres Zapotes period slightly, or to put it another way, that theMiddle
Tres Zapotes-LaVenta
period persisted a little longer atLa
Venta. This slight extension in time need notmodify
toany
great degree the rough equation of this period with the Tzakol of the Peten.The
fact that the ceramic inventories of theMiddle Tres
Zapotes-La Venta
horizon reveals respectably long lists of differences as well asnumerous
similarities seems tome
to be significant. It indicates that thetwo
centers represent well-rooted local manifestations which, though descendedfrom
acommon
ancestral pattern,and though
in- fluencing each other throughout their history, nonethelesswere
suf- ficiently well established to have developed local specialties towhich
they clung. I trust it will not be considered unfair to mention that field inspection of sherdsfrom San Lorenzo
Tenoxtitlan, between the firsttwo
sites, likewise suggests that local specializationhad
been at work, resulting in another series of related but variant ceramic elements.Had Olmec
culture, aswe know
it, been the result of a rapid but short-lived diffusion,we
should find farmore
uniformity in itscomponent
elements.The
foregoingLa Venta-Tres
Zapotes comparisons have linked thetwo and
have suggested an ancientand
firm establishment ofOlmec
culture in the zoneinwhich
these sites are situated.The
next step, logically, is to define the areal extent of the culture. In point of fact, ourtwo
key sites lie near the boundaries of the civilization they represent. Attempts have beenmade
to delimit theOlmec
areaon
the basis of the distribution of finds ofOlmec
figurines, particu- larly those of jade, but objects so portable are less trustworthy markers of the culture than such things as stonemonuments
in theNO. 8
LA VENTA CERAMIC COMPLEX — DRUCKER
7characteristic art style, ceramic complexes,
and
patterns ofmound
construction.
On
the basis of these last-named criteria,Olmec
cul- ture at its greatest continuous expanse never crossed the lower Papaloapanon
the west nor rangedmuch beyond
the Tonala- Blasillo drainage to the east.Our
excavations at Cerro de lasMesas
demonstrated that, although afew
unmistakablyOlmec
pieces oc- curred, particularlyamong
the jade specimens,and
certain features suggested a certain kinship with an ancient widespread ceramic pat- ternwhich
likewise appears tounderlie theOlmec
pottery complexes, the bulk of Cerro de lasMesas
culture—
pottery figurines, jade-carv-ing,
and
stelae—
represent transplantations ofHighland
patterns.A
glance at a topographic
map
of the regionshows
readilywhy
there aremore
fundamental points of difit'erence between the cultural in- ventories of Cerro de lasMesas and Tres
Zapotes than between the lattersiteand La Venta which
ismore
than twice as far away.The
lower reaches of theRio San
Juan, the Papaloapan, the string of lakes connectedby
theRio Limon and
the Rio Cacique,and
the in- numerable small streamsand
sloughsemptying
into the lowerBay
of Alvarado,
form
a hopelessly uninhabitablemorass
ofswamps which
prohibited awestward
extension ofOlmec
culture.While some commerce may
have been carriedon
throughthe tortuous net-work
of channels that crisscross this no-man's land, intimate con- tact of the sort that leads to diffusion of entire complexes seems to have beenmade
impossible by this geographic barrier.Similarly, the
swamps
ofTabasco
restrictedany
eastward spread.La
Venta,on
one of the islands near the borders of theswamps,
isthe easternmost of the
major
ceremonial centers of the Olmec.The
site of
San
Miguel, a short distanceup
the Blasillo,was presumably
an occupationcenter tributary tothe ritual focus.The
southernmar-
gin ofOlmec
territory ismore
difficult to define precisely but it seemsto correspond with theedge of the coastal plain, never extend- ing into the foothills flanking the rugged highlands.La
Ceiba, on theRio
de las Playas, has been determined by Stirling's investiga- tions to represent an overflow of the Chiapas highland, or"Upper
Grijalva" complex,
down
into the lowland.The
only point atwhich
an approximateboundary
cannot be set as yetis alongthepass across the Isthmus. Perhaps therewere Olmec
outposts, or even secondary centers, clear across to the Pacific side.The
occurrence of reliefs carvedinpurestOlmec
styleas farsouth asSan
Isidro PiedraParada
in
Guatemala
suggests strongly that suchmay
have been the case.^2Thompson, J. Eric S., Stone sculptures from southeastern Quetzaltenango.
Carnegie Inst., Notes on Middle American Archaeology and Ethnology, vol. i, pp. I00-II2,fig. a, pp. 104, III, 1943.
8 SMITHSONIAN MISCELLANEOUS COLLECTIONS
VOL. IO7Well up
in the Highlands of central Mexico, in the state of Morelos, is the site of Chalcacingo,where
a series of bas-reliefson
the cliff face presentpronounced Olmec
characteristics.^ This, if itproves tobe inall respects an
Olmec
site, is the only one yetknown
situated definitely in the
Highland
area.To
account for a colony so far detachedfrom
its native territorywould
require farmore
infor- mation thanwe
yet possess.However,
the presence of such an out- post might well explain the source of thewell-known
"baby-face"figurines in the Valley of
Mexico Middle
Culture. Possibly the site, if itwas
Olmec,had
todo
withsome
trade route, such as those link- ing the southernVeracruz homeland
withOaxaca and
Guerrero.*To summarize
:The
heart of theOlmec
region lay in the coastal lowlands along the Gulf, in the region flanking the TuxtlaMoun-
tains.
There were
cultural connections,and
possibly colonies, to thesouthward
across the Isthmus of Tehuantepec,and
theremay
have been afew
scattered outposts in the Highlands to the west, but the culturedefinitely centeredin thenarrow
stripbetween
the Papaloapanand
the Tonala-Blasillo.The Middle Tres Zapotes-La Venta
horizon, inwhich
the art of sculpture reachedits zenith,was
also the period signalized bymarked
cultural isolation.That
is, the forces producing the artistic climaxcame
whollyfrom
within the culture,and were
not the results of external stimuli. Earlier,on
theLower
Tres Zapotes level,and
pos- sibly even during a hypothetical developmental period inwhich
the unique art style began to take form, thereseem
tohave
been lines of influence, particularly to the eastward, alongwhich
flowed traitsand
patterns such as the ceramic styles linkingLower
Tres Zapotes with early Peten levels.However,
there isno
proof that the ancientOlmec
only received elements of culture without contributing.On
the contrary, there is a strongpossibilitythat a
number
of complexes, such as the JaguarMonster
cult,had
their originamong
the Olmec,and
spreadeastwardtotheMaya and westward
tothe early Zapotec.^^Cf. figure inlower right, p. 171, inCovarrubias, M., El Arte "Olmeca"o de LaVenta. Cuadernos Americanos,
Ano
V, Julio-Agosto, pp. 153-179, 1946.*Olmec jades seem to be not
uncommon
in Guerrero, so that parts of that state have been considered by some writers Olmec territory. Although the region isnotwell knownarcheologically, there are, however, no indications that any other remains unmistakably Olmec in type occur there, and it seems morelikely that the jades were carried there in trade
—
perhaps in exchange for un-worked jade. Ourdata are at present too fewtosettle thequestion conclusively, of course.
^Stirlinghas outlined a possiblelineof development of "Jaguar
Mask
panels"in his paper "An Initial Series Date from Tres Zapotes, Veracruz, Mexico,"
NO. 8
LA VENTA CERAMIC COMPLEX DRUCKER 9
In Other words, the
Ohnec
area constituted adynamic
focus of cul- turefrom
earliest times, until aboutA.D.
looo,when
it mysteriously dwindled away.The
significance of this pictures lies in its flat contradiction of the classic appraisal ofMeso-American
civilization in terms of a singleMayan
fountainhead of culture inwhich were
evolved all the higher attainments of the area,and from which
in diminishing in- tensity these complexeswere
dififused tobackward
neighborswhose
rudenesswas
directly correlated with their remotenessfrom
the"Mayan
focus."The
history of theOlmec
indicates instead that the culturegrowth
of the area ismore
likely to have been the result of interchanges between anumber
of local centers or foci, in each ofwhich
inventions, or elaborations of imported traits,were
developed in accordance with local standardsand
then dififused or redififused to neighboring provinces.National Geographic series inMexican Archeology, No. i, 1940, whichhas been amplified and extended to include Monte Alban masks by Covarrubias in his recent contribution, "El Arte'Olmeca' 6 deLa Venta," 1946.
SMITHSONIAN MISCELLANEOUS COLLECTIONS VOL. 107, NO. 8, PL. 1
Various
LaVenta Ceramic Products
a and h are unusual figurines: a, a startled small boy, /', a monkey skull apparently served up on a plate; c, d, and c, coarse buff sherds with rocker stamping and pre-firing incised lines; /, brown lacquer jar (approximately 35 cm. high).
SMITHSONIAN MISCELLANEOUS COLLECTIONS VOL. 107, NO. 8, PL. 2
Various
LaVenta Vessel Forms
((, an elliijtical l)lack ware disli; l>, an example of a very ciminiDn dish; c, tlie
neck of a bottle-like ve.ssel; .(/, an annnlar sn]ii)()rt of a .small dish or bowl of coarse buffware.
SMITHSONIAN MISCELLANEOUS COLLECTIONS VOL. 107, NO. 8, PL. 3
Figurines
Showing Close Relationship to Middle Tres
Zapotes
Modificationsof Early Types
SMITHSONIAN MISCELLANEOUS COLLECTIONS VOL. 107, NO. 8, PL. 4
La
Venta
FiGURtNETypes Showing
Varfationof Early Patterns
The derivation of tliese from Lower Tres Zapotes prototypes is apparent.SMITHSONIAN MISCELLANEOUS COLLECTIONS VOL. 107, NO. 8, PL. 5
Profiles
of
FigurinesShown
inPlate
4SMITHSONIAN MISCELLANEOUS COLLECTIONS VOL. 107, NO. 8, PL. 6
Figurine Bodies
from
LaVenta
Notethejaguar niunsterdesign unthe heh ut tlie specimen in the upper left.