SOME NOTEWORTHY EXTRA-EUROPEAN CYPRINIDS
By THEODORE GILL
In a
former
articleon
"The Family
of Cyprinidsand
theCarp
as itsType," were
considered afew
of the characterswhich
serve to differentiate the Cyprinidsfrom
other fishesand which have
been used to subdivide the family itself intominor
groups. Furthermore, those specieswhich
bearnames
thathave
been transferred inAmerica
to other specieswere
briefly noticedand
illustrated. In the present article are introduced afew
of the innumerable host occurring inAmerica and
other countries,which
are conspicuous for various reasons.American Cyprinids
In
North America
about250
species ofCyprinidsoccurand
almostall belong to genera or at least sub-genera
unknown
toEurope
or Asia.The genus
Barhns, sonumerously
represented in the old world, has nota single representative inthenew,
norareany
of the related ones represented.The genus
that replaces it, so far asnum-
bers
go (and
so far only), is Notropis,which
includes about two-fifths of the
American
Cyprinids—
overone hundred
species; it be- longsto thegroup
calledLeuciscinse.The genus
Leuciscus {Squalius ofmost European
ichthyologists), as understoodby Jordan and
his disciples, is representedby
about twenty-five species, the closely related Rutilus (Leuciscus ofEuropean
ichthyologists)by
four species,and Abrmnis by
two. All the otherAmerican
Cyprinids belong to genera peculiar to the " nearctic " or "arctamerican"region,but
most
ofthem
belongtothegroup
(LeuciscincB) towhich
the bulk of theEuropean
Cyprinids do. Othershave been
referred to another ill-definedgroup
{"ChondrostomincB")
typifiedby Eu-
ropean fishes. Still others {"Mylopharodontincs")
are closely re- lated to the Lenciscince buthave
been differentiatedfrom them on
account of thepreponderance
of blunt ormolar
pharyngeal teeth.Better defined are three
groups
peculiar toAmerica —the so-called
"Caniposfoniincc," "Exoglossince"
and
"Plagopterince."The
sys- tematicvalue ofallthese groups,however,
remainsto be discovered,and
can only be realized after athorough
study of theiranatomy.
Two
of the characteristics of theAmerican
cyprinoid fauna arenoteworthy
: (i)The
specialized character of the aggregate of297
298 SMITHSONIAN MISCELLANEOUS COLLECTIONS
[vol. 48 species,and
(2) the comparative relations of the species to the oldworld
faunas.The
isolation of America's cyprinoid fauna affords one of themany arguments
against the association of all the northern faunas into one great realm or region variously designated as the triarctic, holarctic,and
periarctic.The American
Cyprinidsmay
be segregatedunder two geograph-
ical divisions,
one
including the species of the Atlantic slope as well as of the Mississippi Valley,and
the other thoseof the Pacific slope.The former
are themost
characteristicallyAmerican,
the lattermost
nearly related to oldworld
forms. It has long been maintainedby
botanists— by many at least—that there is a striking analogy on the
one hand between
the types of easternAmerica and
eastern Asia,and on
the otherbetween
those of westernAmerica and
western Europe.Some
features of the fish faunasmight seem
to support such a contention, but amore
critical consideration of the evidence leads to a different conclusion.The
fauna ofEurope
extends east-ward
intoAsia and
the resemblancebetween
the fish faunas of westernAmerica and Europe
is simplydue
to that factand
to theapproximation
of thetwo
continentstoward
the north.Another noteworthy
circumstance is the large sizewhich many
of the Cyprinids of the Pacific slope attain, in this respect rivaling old
world
species,and
con- trasting with those of the cismontane regions.On
theother hand, almost all of the
numerous
Cyprinids, not only of the streams of the Atlantic slope, but of the greatMis-
sippi Valley, are of small size,
only a couple of species
under
ordinary circumstances reach- ing a length of a foot.The
large Cyprinids of
Europe
are tosome
extent replacedby
theCatosomids
(suckers) ofAmerica.
In
more
detail,none
of theAmerican
specieshave
threerows
of pharyngeal teeth asmost
of the oldworld forms
have.Fur-
ther, a rather striking feature is the reduction in the
number
of pharyngeal teeth in themain row
; theEuropean
species generallyhave
five (inveryfew
less) whilemost
of theAmerican
specieshave
only four.The Chondrostomines
ofEurope have
mostly six orFig. 36.
—
Pharyngeal bones and teeth of Chondrostoma nasus. After Heckel.gill]
noteworthy EXTRA-EUROPEAN
CYPRINIDS299
even seven, while theAmerican
representatives, withone
exception{Orthodon
microlepidotus)have
only four or five.Still anotherinteresting coincidence isthe
development
of barbels.The
majority of the oldworld
Cyprinidshave two
pairs of well developed supramaxillary barbels, while not one of the indigenousAmerican
species has asmany and when
barbels are developed in a single pair they are usuallyvery smalland
evenmay
be said to be obsolete.The
great majority of theAmerican
Cyprinids, as already indi- cated, belong to thesame
greatgroup
(Leuciscines) as the majority of theEuropean, and have
thesame
kind of lips, pharyn- geal teeth, alimentary canal,and
dorsaland
ventral fins.No
dis- tinction can be maintainedbetween them and
theAbramidines
or breams. Indeed so little difference is manifestbetween them
thatan
eminent ichthyologiston
one occasion mistook for a variety of theAmerican bream
orcommon
shiner (Abraniis orNotemigonus
chrysoleucas) a fishwhich
he afterwardsascertainedtobean
escaped individual of the EnglishRudd.
This case givesan example
of the closeness of observationwhich
is requisite to properly determine the species of the family.Only
afew
of themore common
or otherwisenoteworthy
speciescan
be noticed here.First
some
of the eastern Leuciscinesmay
be considered.Atlantic and Gulf Slope Cyprinids
The most
characteristicAmerican
genus, so far at least asnum-
ber of species goes, is onenow
generallynamed
Notropisand com-
prising a largenumber
of species (about ahundred)
mostly con-founded under
the general designation ofminnows.
Incommon
with a
number
of otherAmerican
genera it has amain row
of only four teethon
each pharyngeal bone,and sometimes
only those four, but inmost
of the species there is a secondrow
ofone
ortwo
teeth;
most
of these are of the " prehensile " or "hooked
" type (GreifzahneHeckel
called them),and have
either a very nar-row
grinding surface ornone
at all; thejaws have
thin lipsand no
barbels,and
the scales are rather large.Such
is the"
genus
" as recognizedby Jordan and Evermann,
but their ar-rangement must
be regarded as only provisional.They admit
anumber
of sections or subgenera—
adozen — and
several areworthy
of notice.The
typical section—
Notropis proper
—
has scales loosely im-bricated
and
of regular form,and
the teeth are intwo rows
(2,4
—
300 SMITHSONIAN MISCELLANEOUS COLLECTIONS
[vol. 48 4, 2)and
sharp-edged or without grinding surfaces.More
than a score of species are recognizedby Jordan and Evermann. The
typeand
bestknown
is the Notropis atherinaides, " the largestand
Fig. Ti7.
—
Notropis atherinoides. After Agassiz.handsomest
species "' of the section; it occasionaUy attains a length of six inchesand
is "abundant
in lakes, quiet placesand
river channels" in the GreatLake
basin as well as in theOhio and
Mississippi valleys.Fig. 38.
—
Notropiscornittits, female. AfterBaird.
Fig. 39.
—
Notropis cornutus, male. AfterAgassiz.
Another and one
of the bestmarked
sections has been designated as Luxilus. It is distinguishedby
the highand
closely imbricated scales so that theexposed
portions are unusuallynarrow
in propor-gill]
NOTEWORTHY EXTRA-EUROPEAN
CYPRINIDS 301 tion to their height; a secondrow
of pharyngeal teeth is developedand most
of the teethhave narrow
grinding surfaces.The
species (about four) are comparativelylargeand
the largestand
bestknown
is the Notropis cornutns.
Fig. 40.
—
Scales of Notropis cornutns. After Baird.The
Notropis cornutus ismost
generallyknown
as the redfin;' othernames
shared with other fishes are daceand
shiner. It isone
of the largest of its genus, reaching a length of five to eight inches,and
is one of themost abundant wherever
found. It is-often a
companion
ofthecommon
shiner{Abramis — Notemigonus —
chrysoleucas).
The
color is steel-blue above, but in the spring the malesbecome
conspicuous for theirgay
attire, red or rosy lowerfins,
and
tuberculatedhead
; it is allusion to these tubercles, remind- ingone
or horns, that thename
cornutus involves. It is frequentlycaught by
the angler for small fishes.Fig. 41.
—
Notropis hudsonius.
302 SMITHSONIAN MISCELLANEOUS COLLECTIONS
[vOL. 48Fig. 42.
—
Notropis hudsonius. After Jordan and Evermann.
A
third section{Hudsonius)
includes fishes with largeand
nor- mallyformed
scales,which
are regularly imbricated; pharyngeal teeth, besides themain row
(four), are generally existent to thenumber
of one or rarelytwo
in a second, but there is considerable variation in this respect (i,4 —4, o or i, 4 —4, i or i, 4 —4, 2 or
2,
4 —
4, i).About
adozen
species areknown,
themost
notablebeing the Notropis hudsonius
which
has received suchnames
as spawneaterand
spot-tail,and
shares withmany
others those ofminnow and
shiner. It reaches amaximum
length of six inches.While
especially "abundant
in the Great Lakes,and
not rare eastof
theAlleghany Mountains,"
it also extendswestward
toDakota and southward
toSouth
Carolina. It isknown
tomany
as "the•choice live bait of the St.
Lawrence
angler,"and
fishermen along theHudson commemorate,
in aname
theyhave
given to it(spawn-
eater), the belief that it is especially injurious to thespawn
ofmore
valued fishes.Most
of thenumerous
other species of Notropis,confounded under
the generalname
ofminnows,
aremuch
smaller than those mentioned.Another
interestingAmerican
Cyprinid, related to Notropis but"oneof the
most
remarkable ofour littleminnows,"
istheEricymba
bnccata,which
nevertheless appearstohave no
distinctivevernacularname and
is merely one of the hostconfounded under
the designa- tion ofminnow. The
species is distinguishedfrom
all othersby
the porous or cavernous condition ofmany
of thehead
bones, especially the lower jaw, interopercularand
suborbital bones,and
the swollen appearance of the tunnels or channels perforatedby
the pores. It is to this condition that thename
Ericyviba refers, it being derivedgill]
NOTEWORTHY EXTRA-EUROPEAN
CYPRINIDS303 from
theGreek
intensive particle ipcand
thenoun
x'jfij3r], cavity.The
species is prettywide
spread in the countrywatered by
the northernand
eastern affluents of the Mississippiand
extends north-ward
intoMichigan and southward
intoWest
Florida,and where
Fig. 43.
—
Ericymba biiccata. After Jordan and Evermann.
it does occur, is tolerably
common and
" locally very abundant."It rarely attains a length of five inches.
The
interestofthisgenus
isinthe factthatit repeats in the family of Cyprinids a characteristicwhich
is manifest in isolated genera ofanumber
of other families,but notably inthe fresh-water Percids (as inAcerina
orCernua) and
Cichlids (as in theTrematocara
ofLake Tanganyika)
. Itwillbean
interestingstudyforfuture natural- ists to investisrate the correlationbetween
this structural featureFig. 44.
—
Horny Head, Hybopsis kentuckiensis. After Goode.and
habitsand
to ascertainwhether
the analogous structures are adaptiveto identicalor different conditions.Cope
evidentlyassigned toomuch
relative importance to the characterby
giving to itsubfamily rank
and
isolating thegenus from
all others.304 SMITHSONIAN MISCELLANEOUS COLLECTIONS
[vol. 48 Closely related to Notropis is thegenus Hybopsis which
includes nearly a score (seventeen) of species. Like Notropis it has a principalrow
of four pharyngeal teeth,and
insome
a single tooth represents a second row, butsometimes
there isnone
(4— 4 or
I,
4 —4, I or I, 4 —4, o), and the teeth are essentially like those of Notropis; it differs from the kindred genus by the development of a barbel at the end of each maxillary bone.
The
bestknown
species is theHybopsis
kentuckiensis, popularlyknown
as the horny-head, jerker, river chub,and
Indian chub. Itranges
from
"Pennsylvania toWyoming and Alabama, on
bothFig. 45.
—
Scales of Semotilus atromaculatus. After Baird.sides of the Alleghanies "
and
is "everywhere abundant
in the larger streams,seldom
ascending small brooks." It rarely attains a length of nine inches.The genus
containing the largest easternAmerican
species isnamed
Semotilusand
differsfrom
Leuciscus mainly in the fact that there is a little skinny flap called a^^^ ^^^ ^'^^
* barbel— and a very little one it is
—
^K^ -^A vSLK)
nearthe hinderend
of eachupper jaw
^^^ ^S^^
"^S^r *-"' supramaxillarybone,and
the dorsal^^^^T \
fin is a little fartherback; the pharyn-••
\
gs^l teeth of one side are also reduced innumber
(2, 5—
4, 2).There
aretwo
very distinct species(6'. atromaculatus
and
S. corporalis), mostly designated as chubs in the eastern states, but alsoknown
as dace
and by
various other names.A
third'more
southernform
(S. thoreauianus) is scarcely distinguishablefrom
the S.atromaculatus.
The
fish generally calledchub
or,more
specifically, silver chub, in the eastern states orNew England and
theMiddle
States, is a fish alsonamed
corporal, windfish,and
fall-fish. Besides these, other Englishnames
given to Cyprinidshave
been misplacedupon
Fig. 46.
—
Pharyngeal bones and teeth of Semotilus. AfterBaird.
gill]
noteworthy EXTRA-EUROPEAN
CYPRINIDS3Q5
it, as cheven or chivin (an English
synonym
of chub), dace,and
roach. Its scientificname
is Semotilus corporalis. It isby
fartlie largest of the Eastern
American
Cyprinidsand sometimes
reaches the length of eighteen or even twenty inches, althoughone
twelve inches long is regarded as agood
sized fish. It prefers clearFig. 47.
—
Seinoliliis corporalis, young. After Fowler.
swift streams
and
affords considerable sport to the angler.When young
it has quite a different appearancefrom
the adult, beingmarked
with a distinct lateralband and
theform
of thehead
isalso different.
A
related species distinguishedby
the black spot at the base of the dorsal is the Semotilus atromacnlatns,known
as the creekchub
Fig. 48.
—
Semotilus atromaculatus. After Baird.
or
horned
dace. This has been closely observed in thespawning
seasonby
Professor Reighard, butno
complete recordofhisobserva- tions has been published.Both
of these "chubs" are ratheromnivorous
feeders.They
catch small fishes that
come
in theway, and
also crawfishes, butdepend
mainlyon
insectsand
entomostraceous crustaceans as well asworms. A
further considerable percentage of the food consists of filamentous algaeand
vegetable debris.Considerable difference of opinion prevails as to the gustatory quality of the chub.
The
opinion ofThoreau —"it is a soft fish,
and
tastes likebrown
paper salted"—
has been often quoted. In3o6 SMITHSONIAN MISCELLANEOUS COLLECTIONS
[vol. 48 Opposition to this the fishcommissioner
ofCanada
(E. F. Prince) declares (1905)^ that "Thoreau was
very far astray "and
that the fish's " flesh is white,"though
"not quite as white as the whitefish,and
of a deHcate flavour, the bones being far less troublesome "Fig. 49.
—
Semotilus corporalis. After Storer.
than those of "its near allies, the suckers." Prince
had
"known
it(wittingly or unwittingly) served
up
as whitefish at sportsmen's elubs,"and
inCanada
itis frequently called whitefish.Another
type related to Leuciscusand
stillmore
to Semotilus has beennamed
Platygobio tocommemorate
one of the chief dis- tinctions,thebroad
flattishhead
; the teeth arebiserialbut in reducednumber
(2,4 —4, 2) and have narrowed grinding surfaces; max-
illary barbels are well developed.
Three
species areknown and
the bestknown
is the Platygobio gracilis, designated as the flatheadFig. so.
—
Platygobio gracilis. After Gill.chub. Its range is
from
the east slope of theRocky Mountains
to theSaskatchewan
River,and
it is "abundant
in river channels as far south asKansas
City, not ascending to springs." It attainsa
length ofafoot.^Twenty-seventh An. Rep. Dep't Marine and Fish.
—
Fisheries, p. Ixxviii.gill]
NOTEWORTHY EXTRA-EUROPEAN
CYPRINIDS307
Fig. 51.
—
Pharyngeal bones, teeth, and scales of Platygobio gracilis. After Gill.The
shiner ofmany
parts of theUnited
States(Abramis —
orNotemigonus —
chrysoleucas) ismost
nearly related to thecommon bream
of Europe, but instead of bearing thatname,
hashad
forcedon
itthose of the English roachand
dace. Itisone
of thecommonest
of theAmerican
Cyprinidsand
reaches a larger size thanmost
of the others—
often asmuch
as six inchesand
occasionally, it isclaimed, even a foot in length.^ It affects mostly grassy or reedy- waters
and
is generally tobefound
in mill-ponds. It is often angled forand
readily takes ahook
baited withan
ordinaryearthworm.
Fig. 52.
—
Abramis chrysoleucas. After Goode.
By
Storer "it is said to be a delicate fish for the table," but it is really scarcely, if any, better thanany
other Cyprinid of thesame
size. It
was more
aptly saidby him
to be "the best bait " for pickerel in Massachusetts. It is not likely, indeed, that the pickerel exercises choice, but simply that, because of its size,abundance and
facility ofobtainment, it is the
most
used.^The largest ofthousands the present writer has caught or seen was barely ten inches long.
3o8 SMITHSONIAN MISCELLANEOUS COLLECTIONS
[vol. 48Dace
is aname
given in theUnited
States tomany
different Cyprinids, but inthe vicinity ofWashington and many
other placesit is applied to the species of Rhinichthys, another
genus
peculiar toAmerica and
not very nearly related toany
other.The name
isFig. S3.
—
Rhinichthys didcis. After Jordan and Evermann.
often extended into black-nosed dace.
The few
species are distin- guishedby
a projecting snout, inferiormouth,
dark color,and
generally a darker longitudinal lateral stripeon
each side; in the breeding season, however, the malesassume
a brilliant dress,becom-
ingmore
or less suffusedwith crimson.They
are active little fishes,preferring clear
running
streams,and
aremuch
used for bait for largerfishes.They
prepare a nest of stones for the reception of the eggs,which
is takencharge ofby
the male.Data
respecting the habits of Rhinichthys atronasusare givenby
'C.
N. Holder
in Harper'sNczv Monthly Magazine
forDecember,
1883 (Vol. 68, pp. 100-103,under
the typographicalmisnomer
^RhyiichichiJiys abroiiasus),
and by
C. C.Abbott
in 1884 in"A
Fig. 54.
—
Rliinichthys atronasus. After Storer.
Naturalist's
Rambles
aboutHome
" (pp. 419, 420). This is a small species about three inches long.A
larger one, about five incheslong, has a
more prominent
snoutand was
thereforenamed by
the old ichthyologistsR. nasiitus, buta still oldername
—
cataractcr—has
gill]
NOTEWORTHY EXTRA-EUROPEAN
CYPRINIDS309
been revivedby
recent authors for the species.The
lattername was
given because the type specimenswere found
aboutNiagara
Falls; its favorite resorts are also indicatedby
thename,
for itlargely resorts to rapids
and
swiftrunning
streams.A
characteristiceasternAmerican genus named Hybognathus
has been referred to theChondrostomines
because it hasan
elongated alimentarycanal (three toten times as long as the body), but other- wise it is not like the typicalmembers
of the group.The jaws
areFig. 55.
—
Hybognathus niichalis. After Fowler.
sharp-edged
and
without corneous coveringsand
the pharyngeal teeth are uniserial (4—
4), cultriform,and
nearly straight.The gudgeon
of the vicinity ofWashington
is the type of the genus.That
type{Hybognathus
nuchalis) is a fish with large scales, often about six inches long, of an olivaceous green color, with silvery sidesand
almost translucent. This style of coloration has also gained for it thename
of smelt. It ismuch
angled forfrom
thewharves and
shore-walls ofWashington and
is alsoused forbait.There
are a couple of genera wellmarked
as such, but otherwise possessingno
salient external peculiarities that arrestimmediate
attention,
which on
closer examination are discovered tohave
quite exceptional characters; theyhave
beennamed Campostoma and Exoglossum. Both
ofthem were
setapartmany
yearsago
(in 1866)by
E. D.Cope
as the types of independent sub-familieswhich
henamed
Mesocystiand
Cochlobori, but forwhich
those ofCam-
postominse
and
Exoglossinaehave
been substitutedby
laterAmerican
ichthyologists.
The Campostomines,
althoughhaving
asomewhat
peculiar physi-ognomy,
presentno
external featureswhich would
leadone
to3IO SMITHSONIAN MISCELLANEOUS COLLECTIONS
[vol. 48 suspectany
great internal differences or that theywere
very distinctfrom minnows
or chubs.The mouth and mouth
parts are normal.Fig. 56.
—
Campostoma anoinalum, showing the air-bladder (in outline) involved in thecircumvolutions of the alimentary canal. After Cope.
Dissection, nevertheless, reveals a strange
and
otherwiseunexampled
condition of the viscera.The
intestinal canal is extremely elongatedand
it goes out of itsregular course to involve the air-bladder
and surround
it withmany
coils,
and
within these coils are also involved even thegonads
(ovaries of the femalesand
spermaries of the males). Thisarrangement
contrasts strongly with that manifest in other Cyprinids and, in fact, in all other teleost fishes, inwhich
the air-bladder(when
present) isnext to the roof of the
abdominal
cavity.The
only genus,Campostoma,
accordingtoJordan and Evermann,
has four species, fishes ofmoderate
size asAmerican
Cyprinidsgo
Fig. 57.
—
Teeth of Campostoma anomalum. After Agassiz.Fig. 58.
—
Campostoma anomalum. AfterJordan and Evermann.
gill]
NOTEWORTHY EXTRA-EUROPEAN
CYPRINIDS 311 (up to about eight inches),and which
rangefrom New York
toMexico;
in otherwords
they occur in the streams tributary, directly as well as indirectly, to the Mississippi basin,and
in those discharg- ingwest of itin the GulfofMexico,
but not in those of the Atlantic seaboard.The
bestknown
species is theCampostoma anomalum which
rangesfrom
centralNew York
to Tennessee,Texas and Wyoming, and was found by Jordan and Evermann
to be "every-where abundant
in deep or still places in small streams, runningup
small brooks tospawn
in spring." Itbrings stones together into anestand
isknown
popularlyas thestone-roller.Fig. 59.
—
Cut-lips Minnow, Exoglossum maxillingua. After Fowler.The
Exoglossines, although in general appearance like the ordi- naryminnows,
manifesta certain peculiarity inphysiognomy which
is soon
found
to resultfrom
the singularly shapedmouth, and
espe- cially the structure of the lower jaw.The
peculiarity of structurewas
first recognizedby Cope
(1866)who
correctly described the fqremost or principal elements of the lower jaw, " dentary bones, straightand
flat, united together throughout their length"; thus modified, they simulate a tongue,and
to this thename Exoglossum
(i'cw,outside,
and
yhoaao., tongue) alludes.The
tongue-like struc- ture, however, has nothing todo
with the truetongue
unless it be to entail a recession ofitbackwards.As Cope
has stated, " the incom- pletely definedbody which
in this family represents thetongue
issituated in the
back
part of the oral cavity, since the glossohyalbone
is excludedfrom
its usualplace,and
is short; its approximation to the interopercleand
ceratohyal, with the basihyaland
strongly elongate urohyal, defend the lower surface of thehead
effectually."The
linguiform extension of the lowerjaw
is utilized for the pur-312 SMITHSONIAN MISCELLANEOUS COLLECTIONS
[vol. 48 pose of scraping shellsfrom
the rockson which
they are found.Mollusks
form
the principal food of the fishesand
crushed shellsmay
be almostany
timefound
in the stomach.On
account of theFig. 60.
—
Exoglossum maxillingna. Lower bones. An, Angular; Ar, Artic- ular; B.Hy, Basihyoid; 3Br, Branchiostegal rays;
CHy,
Ceratohyoid; CI, Clavicle Coenosteon; G.Hy, Glossohyal; 10, Interopercular; M.Mass, Masseter Muscle; P.O, Preopercular; Pt, Pterygoid; Qu, Quadrate; S.O, Subopercular;
U.Hy, Urohyoid. After Cope.
adaptation
and
foodhabits of the type thename
Cochlobori (shellfish- eaters)was
given to the subfamily by Cope.The Exoglossum
maxillingna is the onlycommon and
naturally the bestknown
species of the group,and
is sufficiently largeand
conspicuous tohave
received anumber
of popular names, such as cut-lips,day
chub, nigger chub,and
nigger dick, the first, of course,Fig. 61.
—
Lip of Exoglossum maxil- lingna. After Jordan andEvermann.
Fig. 62. -Teeth of Exoglossum. After Agassiz.
recalling the trenchant lower
jaw and
the lasttwo
the dark color.Its geographical range is
from
the St.Lawrence
basinand Lakes
Ontarioand Champlain southwards
into Virginia. It is, asJordan
gill]
NOTEWORTHY EXTRA-EUROPEAX
CYPRINIDS313 and Evermann
remark,"abundant
in thebasinsof theSusquehanna, Hudson, Potomac,
James,Roanoke and Kanawha,
but not widely distributed." Its ordinarylength is aboutfive orsix inches.Another
interesting type of very limited distribution is that desig- nated as the Plagopterinse or Medinse.These
are small fishes dis- tingfuishedbv
the structure of the dorsaland
ventral fins.The
ven-FiG. 63.
—
Plagoptcnis argentissiiiius. After Cope.
tral
and
the anterior dorsal rays are peculiarly modified.The
dorsal has a first spinewhich
is shortand
slender or rudimentaryand
this is followedby
a largecompressed
onefurrowed
behindand
closely pressedupon by
a smaller third spine.The
ventrals are stillmore
modifiedfrom
the ordinary cyprinoid types: the innermost rays areFig. 64.
—
Lepidoineda vittata. After Cope.
tied to the
body by
amembrane
extending alongmost
of the length of the rayand
all aremore
or lesscompressed and
inarticulate at base, butfrom
their inner edgesbranched and
articulated raylets divaricate, thewhole reminding
one of a flat chip w^hoseedge
has been partly slivered ofif.Fig. 65.
—
Lepidoineda vittata. After Cope.
314 SMITHSONIAN MISCELLANEOUS COLLECTIONS
[vOL. 48Two
of the specieshave
perfectlynaked
bodiesand
are veryclosely related, but nevertheless are distinguished
by
the presence or absence ofbarbelsand have
consequently been referred to differ- ent genera—
Meda and
Plagopterus.The
longestknown
species is theMeda
fulgidawhich
hasno
barbels. It is a little fish rarely exceeding
two
inches in lengthand
of a bright silvery color. Itwas found by
C.H.
Gilbertand N.
B. Scofield (1898) tobe"extremelyabundant
intheupper
course of theRio
Verde, near Chino,"and
occurs elsewhere in Arizona.Pacific
Slope Cyprinids
As
already indicated (p. 298), the cyprinoid fauna of the streamsand
lakes of the Pacific slope hasmany
features incommon
with that of Europe,and
the English anglermight
recognize, in the objects of his capture,forms
that hehad
been familiar withfrom
youth.He
would, probably, even be inclined to call one ormore
chub,and
thechub genus
—
Leiiciscus
—
is representedby
anumber
of species.
None
of the species, indeed, are closely relatedand
all belong to sections or subgenerapeculiar toAmerica,
but the differ- ences are so slight as to justifytheir union inthesame
genus.The common
"chub
" of theSan
Franciscoand Sacramento
markets is the sole representative of a peculiar section(Siboma) and
isconspicuous for themassiveappearance of thecaudalpedunclefrom
a side view,and
to this thename
L. crassicauda alludes; it isvery
much compressed and
high, squeezed out, as it were,upwards and downwards
; the scales are comparatively largeand
well im- bricated(50-56
along the lateral line) ; the pharyngeal teeth are generally in unequalnumber on
the opposite sides (2,4 —5, 2) ;
the color of the
back
isbrown and
of the sides white, but the scales generally are dotted with dark. Its ordinary length is about a foot.It is caught in large quantities
and
is a staplemarket
fish but chiefly utilizedby
theChinese.Another
verycommon
species is the "chub
ofUtah
Lake," or the "greatchub
"common
in the streams of the plateauxand
bot-toms
of theRocky Mountains —the Leiiciscus lineatus of recent
ichthyology. It is typical of a
group
of species(Tigoma)
charac- terizedby
small or moderate-sized scaleswhich
are less imbricated than usual; the pharyngeal teeth are essentially like those ofLeu-
cisciis crassicauda.
The
color is very dark—
blackened— and this
darkness extends to sides
and
belly even, especially about the edges of the scales, for the centers aresomewhat
paler; thisarrangement
of colors has given rise to the rather misleading scientificname
gill]
NOTEWORTHY EXTRA-EUROPEAN
CYPRINIDS315
(lineatus) of the species. Otherwise, asJordan and Evermann
add, the species "varies greatly with ageand
surroundings." Itgrows
Fig. 66.
—
Chub of Utah Lake, Leitciscus lineatus. After Gill.toa length of a foot or
more —at least to fifteen inches occasionally.
According
toJordan
(1884) it "is excessivelyabundant
inUtah Lake
and, as it ascends the streams tospawn
almost simultaneously with the trout{Salmo mykiss
clarkii?), it is extremely destructive to theyoung
of the latter. It is taken in considerablenumber
inseines,
and
is sold in themarkets
of SaltLake
Cityand
othertowns.Rather
nearlyrelatedtothechubsand
dacesisagenus whose
head- quarters are in the Gila riverand from
this it has derived itsname
{Gila).
The physiognomy
of the fishes is characteristic, the caudal peduncle being exceptionally slenderand
elongate; the caudal fin is deeply forkedand
enlargedby rudimentary
or fulcrum-like rayswhich
increase its extent aboveand below
the peduncle; the scalesFig. 67.
—
Gila elegans. After Girard.
are very small
and
barely imbricated; thehead
isbroad and
the snoutprominent
; otherwise it is essentially like the chubsand
has pharyngeal teeth of thesame
general type as theTigomas
(2, 5—
4,2).
3i6 SMITHSONIAN MISCELLANEOUS COLLECTIONS
[vol. 48As Jordan
(1883) has remarked,"the
various species of Gilaabound
in the basin of theRio
Coloradoand Rio
Gila,and
are used as food inNew Mexico and
Arizona.They
reach a length of about eighteen inches."Another
of the Leuciscine genera char- acteristics of PacificAmerica
is that called Ptychochcilus,whose
specieshave an
ap- pearancesomewhat
intermediatebetween
chubsand
gilas; thehead
is long, the snout prolonged,and
themouth
deeply cleftand
almost horizontal, thussomewhat
resemb- ling a pikewhose name
has been usurped for itby some
of the inhabitants of itscountry. In accordance with its large
mouth
are the pharyngeal bonesand
teeth, theformer
elongate, the latter sharp-pointedand
sharp-edged.Three
species are generally recognized.The
largest of theAmerican
Cyprinids belong to thegenus
Ptychocheilus, one inhabiting the Colorado river {P. Indus), being locallyknown
as the "salmon,"and
another (P._ oregonensis) ofOregon and
theSacramento
river beingdubbed
the "pike" or"
squaw
fish"; theformer sometimes
attains a length of five feetand
a weight of eightypounds and
the latter is not verymuch
smaller.
They
are rapacious animals with largermouths
than are possessedby any
otherAmerican
Cyprinids.Both
arecommon
Fig. 68.
—
Pharyngeal bones and tooth of Pty- chocheilus major. After Agassiz.SAW ^^
Fig. 69.
—
Ptychocheilus oregonensis. After Jordan and Evermann.
fishes intheir respective regions
and
held insome
esteem as market- able fishes. InOregon,
the species of its great river is very highly esteemedby
the Indians,and
is a rival in their favor ofthe salmons,and
hence has been designated as the squaw-fish, aname which
gill]
NOTEWORTHY EXTRA-EUROPEAN
CYPRINIDS317
has indeedcome
into quite general use. In theSacramento
basin, other names, besides pike, according toJordan and Evermann,
are "chub, pig-mouth, box-head, yellow-bellyand
chappaul."A genus
of thesame
generalgroup and having
thesame form
as the preceding is Pogonichthys, sonamed
because, unlike all theFig. 70.
—
Pogonichthys iiiccqnilobns. After Girard.
preceding, it has little skinny tags or barbels at the hinder ends of the
upper jaw
bones (oneon
each side) ; another peculiar character, developed in the adults, is awant
ofsymmetry
in the forked tail-fin, theupper
lobe beingmuch
larger than the lower; furthermore, the fulcral or basal caudal rays are unusually developed.The
scales are rather large (about 65 in lateral line)and
well imbricated.Only
one species isnow
recognized.The
split-tail is thename
aptly given to thePogonichthys macro-
lepidotus. Its ordinary length is about a foot, butsome may
attainFig. 71.
—
Mylopharuduii coiiocephalus.that of eighteen inches.
According
toJordan
(1883), it "is verycommon
in the Sacramento,and
isbrought
in considerablenumbers
to theSan
Francisco market."3l8 SMITHSONIAN MISCELLANEOUS COLLECTIONS
[vOL. 48 All theprecedingspecies ofthe Pacificcoasthave
been universally recognized as Leuciscines; a couple of other west coast typesresem- blingthem
in structureand
form, as well as in the short intestinal canal, but differentiatedby molariform
pharyngeal teeth,have been
Fig. •J2. Mylocheilus lateralis. After Jordan and Evermann.
segregated
by Jordan and Evermann
as the "Mylopharodontince."'Three
generahave
been established,two
ofwhich
are noteworthy.Both
ofthem have
the teeth intwo rows
(2,4 —
5, 2 or 2, 5—
5, 2),.and
each is representedby
a single species.The
Mylocheilus lateralis (miscalled caurinus) has theupper jaw
slightly protractileand
a small tag or barbel at theend
of each maxillary.According
toJordan
(1883), it"abounds from
Cali- fornia toPuget Sound
in all the streams ofOregon, Washington
Fig. 73.
—
Chondrostoma nasus. After Heckel and Kner.
and
Idaho,and
often enters the sea. It reaches the length of littlemore
than a foot," Itwas
formerly little used for foodwhere
troutand
other fishes abound, butnow,
according toJordan and Ever-
gill]
NOTEWORTHY EXTRA-EUROPEAN
CYPRINIDS319 mann
(1902), "it possessessome
importance as a food-fish.At some
places in theColumbia
basin it is served as 'whitefish' at the hotels,and
elsewhere it is peddled over the country as 'trout' or' fresh-water herring.'" It is also esteemed as
an
angle-fish. "It takes thehook
readilyand
possesses considerablegame
qualities.The
best baitseems
to besalmon spawn,
but it will bite at almost anything."The Mylopharodon
conocephalus has theupper jaw
fixed (not protractile)and
is destitute of barbels. It occurs with the socalled pike (Ptychocheilus oregonensis) " in theSacramento and
isbrought
with it into the markets." It reaches a size scarcely less than that of its associate(two
to three feet)"but is less plentiful,"
and
does not extendbeyond
theSacramento
basin.Three
other Pacific slope Cyprinids arenoteworthy
because they belong to agroup
chieflyrepresented inthe old
world (Chondro-
stomines) distinguishedby
the elongated ali-mentary
canal(which
ismore
than twice as long as thebody)
and, in the typical forms,by
ahorny
plateinvestingeach jaw.One
of these (Acrocheilus ahitaceus) has, like the typicalChon-
drostomines of Eurasia, ahorny
plate to eachjaw which
is veryFig. 74.
—
Headfrom below ofChondrostoma nasus. AfterKner.Fig. 75.
—
Acrocheilus ahitaceus. After Jordan and Evermann.
conspicuous
and
sharp-edged.The
structure orform
of the lipsand mouth have
suggested the genericname
(axffo^ sharp,xedo^
lip) as well as the vernacular
names
of the species (chisel-mouth,hard-mouth and
square-mouth). It differs,however,by
the reduced320 SMITHSONIAN MISCELLANEOUS COLLECTIONS
[vol. 48number
of pharyngeal teeth (4—
5)which
arehooked and have
broad
grinding surfaces.It is a
common
fish in places in the "Lower Columbia
Riverand
tributaries, as far
up
asSpokane and Shoshone
Falls." It isone
of themany
foot-longfishes. It is onlyeaten in lieu of betterfishes.Fig. 76.
—
OrthodoH uiicrolepidotus. After Goode.
A
second generic type(Orthodon
microlepidotus) hasno horny
covering to the jaws, but the lower is sharp-edgedand
has aknob
at its symphysis; in the
number
of pharyngeal teeth, however, itagrees better with the old
world Chondrostomines
(6—
6 or 6—
5) ;the teeth are lancet-like
and
nearly straight,and
to this peculiarity the genericname
refers {ofj6o^, straight,and
odoo:^, tooth).The
color is dark olivaceous butpaler
below —dark enough, however, for
it to be called, as so
many
othershave
been, blackfish in California;
of course this is a distinctive
name
only in itshome,
butno
other has been recorded.Itranges generally
between
a footand
a footand
a half inlengthand
its size secures it a place in the markets. "A good many
are sent to themarket
inSan
Francisco,where
they are eatenby
the Chinese."The
third of the so-calledChondrostomine
fishes (Lavi)iia exili- caiida) hasno horny
plates to thejaws and
the lowerjaw
shuts withintheupper.The
pharyngealteeth are uniserial (4—
5 or 5—
5)and
cultriform withbroad
but shallow grinding surfaces. Like several of its compatriots its caudal fin is reinforcedby
anumber
of rudimentary or fulcrate rays procurrent above
and below
the peduncle.The
peduncle isquite slenderand
it is to that slenderness that the specificname
{exilis, slender, cauda, tail) refers.A
footgill]
noteworthy EXTRA-EUROPEAN
CYPRINIDS 321"is the average length. It is, according to
Jordan and Evermann, an
inhabitant of the "streamsof the CoastRange
aboutSan
Franciscoand
Monterey, locallycommon
as far north as Clear Lake." It iscaught to
some
extent for the markets.Fig. yj.
—
Lavinia exilicauda. After Girard.Mexican Cyprinids
Cyprinids extend far
down
intoMexico
in the streams of the tableland, but in diminishingnumbers
southwards,and
are prac- tically absentfrom
the streams of the lowlands south of theRio Grande
valley. Altogether, about a halfhundred
(48) species occur in temperateMexico,
ofwhich
nearly half (23) are confined to the countryand
the rest (25) arecommon
toitand
southwesternUnited
States.
Two
score species (40) occur in the valley of theRio Grande and
five in theColorado
river system. Five of the genera {Xystrosus, Stypodon, Falcula,Aztecniaand Evarra)
are restricted to Mexico, but aremonotypic
or representedby
onlytwo {Evarra)
or three species (Astecula). Further detailsmay
befound
in SethMeek's monograph on
"The
Fresh-water Fishes ofMexico
"
(1904).
Northern Asiatic Cyprinids
The
cyprinoid fauna of northernAsia
is simplyan
extension of theEuropean
fauna eastward or,more
properly, there is a great Eurasiatic realm, extendingfrom
the Pacific to the Atlantic oceanand from
theHimalaya mountains and
isothermal regions north- wards,which
hasacommon
fish faunaas well ascontinuousmammal
and
bird faunas.Many
genera extendfrom
oneextreme
to the other; for instance, Leuciscusand
Phoxinus, the dacesand min-
nows, are asprominent
inJapan
as in Britain.322 SMITHSONIAN MISCELLANEOUS COLLECTIONS
[vol. 48The
barbelgenus (Barbus)
is representedby
at leastthree species in Palestineand
one ofthem (Barbus
longiceps) is quite closely related to thecommon
barbel of Europe, but has the head,and
especially the snout,more
elongate, as thename
(longiceps or long-FiG. 78.
—
Barbus longiceps. After Tristram.
headed) indicates. This species is peculiar to the
Lake
of Galileeand
the riverJordan
and, according to Tristram (1884), "isone
of themost abundant
of themany abundant
species in the Lake."It is noteworthy, too, that it is also "
one
of the best kinds for the table.'"A
peculiargenus
(Capoeta), related to the barbels, is distin- guishedby
the transverse inferiormouth and by
the branches of theFig. 79.
—
Capoeta fratercula. After Heckel.
lower bent inwards in front
and
with the anterioredge
invested in a subcorneous sheath. It is richly representedby
speciesfrom
near the confines ofEurope
to Central Asia,and no
less than seven species occur in Palestine. In that holy landone
of the species (Capoeta fratercula) hasbecome
the recipient of exceptional atten-gill]
noteworthy EXTRA-EUROPEAN
CYPRINIDS323
tion. Tristram tells that " at the Algerian village of Deichun, near
Safed
in Galilee, there is a large fountain full of this species.These
fish arelooked
upon by
theArabs
as sacred toMohammed, and
they willon no
account allowany one
to take them.A
littleto the north ofTripoli also, atthe shrine of SheikhelBedawi,
is a copiousspring, with a large basinand
streams flowingfrom
it,choked
with these fishes,which seem
piledup
in layers, with hardly space tomove.
They
arean
object of veneration,and
arealways fedby
theworship- ers.They
follow inmasses any
visitor as he walksby
the edge,gaping
forfood." ThisCapoeta
is calledby
theArabs Semakh
nahriand
is esteemed asone
of the best fishes of Palestine. Tristram considers that "it is excellent eating,and
its flesh is a pale pink colour."Several of the other species of
Capoeta
(especially C. damascina, C. syriacaand
C. socialis) are veryabundant
in theLake
ofGen-
nasoret,theSea
of Galilee of theBible.The
C.damascina
isequallyabundant
in the lower reaches of theJordan
and, according to TristramCanon,
is " carrieddown
into theDead Sea
in greatnum-
bers,
and
perishes atonce, strewingthe north shore."Another
of the characteristicand
verycommon
fishes, but locally, of Syria, is a small species, a realminnow
closely related to theEuropean minnow and
dace, but distinguishedby
the combination of the imperfect lateral line behind, thedevelopment
of only nine anal rays,and
the presence of onlyone row
of pharyngeal teeth. Ithas been
named
Leuciscuslihanias well as Phoxinelliisand Pseudo-
%7 Fig. 80.-
—
Pseudophoxinus libani. After Lortet.
phoxinus. It is " generally less than
two
inches long"and
"rarely reachestwo and
one-half inches in length." Itwas
"discoveredby
Dr. Lortet in the little lake ofYammuneh,
amountain
tarnabove
Ainata inLebanon,
wellknown
to visitors to theCedars from
Bealbeck,and
4,800feetabove
thesea.These
littlefishes, apparently the only inhabitants of thelake, at the seasonwhen
the little stream-lets of the tarn are at their fullest,
crowd
into them,and form an
324 SMITHSONIAN MISCELLANEOUS COLLECTIONS
[vol. 48 important article ofcommerce
for the villagers."The
inhabitants of the little hamlet ofYammuuneh
catchthem by
thousandsof kilo-grams and
sellthem
in the neighboring villagesand
convents for eighttoten cents a " battle "which
isameasure
ofaboutfivepounds.Fig. 81.
—
Discognathus lamia, female. After HeckeL
A
characteristic Asiaticgenus
representedby
anumber
of speciesis Discognathus. It is related to the barbels and, like the typical species of that genus, has
two
pairs of barbelsand
threerows
of pharyngeal teeth, but the lip is transformed into a subcircular suctorial disk with freemargins.The
air-bladder is small, especiallyFig. 82.
—
Discognathus lainta, male. After Day.
its hinder portion.
The
males of the lamta, in the height of the breeding season,may
develop a remarkable subfrontalprominence and
this, as well as the snout, is beset with spiniform tubercles.A
singular appearance is thus imparted to the
head
and, as themouth
is inferior
and
concealedfrom
observation, onemight
mistake, at first glance, the cleftbetween
the frontalprominence and
snout for themouth. Females have
the ordinary barbel-likehead and
theI
gill]
NOTEWORTHY EXTRA-EUROPEAN
CYPRINIDS 325 contrastbetween them and
males is very striking.The
lamta (Dis- cognathus lamta) has awide
range in Asia, rangingfrom
Syria into Indiaand
still further eastward,and
iscommon
in the affluents of theJordan and
theLake
of Gennesaret; it also extends intoAbys-
Female. After Heckel. Male. After Day.
Fig. 83.
—
Discognathus lamta.
sinia. It rarely
grows
tomore
than six to eight inches long.Ac-
cording toDay,
it putrifies very rapidly after death,and
generally dies almostas soon asremoved from
water.Peculiar Upland
Cyprinids.In streams of the great
mountain
regions, theHimalayas and
their outliers, isolating India
from
the rest of Asia, are to befound
peculiar fisheswhich have
beencombined
in agroup named
(by McClelland) "Schizothoracinse."The group
includes fisheshaving
thesame
generalform
as the barbels,and
indeed called hill-barbels^Fig. 84.
—
Schisothorax sinnatus. After Heckel.
326 SMITHSONIAN MISCELLANEOUS COLLECTIONS
[vOL. 48 but distinguishedby
a remarkable type of squamation.Above and on
each side of the anusand
anal fin is aband
of enlarged scales differentiatedfrom
the othersand forming
a kind of sheath intowhich
the base of the anal fin is concealed. In other respects thereis little diflference
from
the true barbels; there are, as inthem, threerows
ofpharyngeal teeth inthe typical forms,but in others there are onlytwo;
thenumber
of barbels varies,some
specieshaving
four, others two,and
the remaining none.About
fifty species representing ten or adozen
genera areknown,
the principal being Schizothorax,which
contains about a score of species.Species of this
genus
are very voracious. J.McClelland
(1838) claimed "thatit isno uncommon
thingto find "one
"soovergorged
that the tail of its prey remains protrudingfrom
themouth,
to beswallowed
after that portionwhich
is capable of being received into the capaciousstomach
is sufficiently digested to admit of the intro- duction of the remainder."He had
seen fishes " so often in this state " that hepresumed
"they are easier caught in it than inany
other."Some Chinese
Cyprinids.Another
type isnoteworthy on
account of the singularity of ap- pearance as well as the size of thefew
species.The
forehead or interorbital region is high upraisedand
arched,and
consequently the eyes are abnormallylow down on
the sides. This inferior posi- .tion of the eyeshas givenname
to thegenus (Hypophthalmichthys)
Fig. Ss.—Hypophihalmichthys nobilis. After Steindachner.
and group
or sub-familywhich
it represents (Hypothalmichthyines).Another
remarkable peculiarity is the structure of the gill-rakers in association with a peculiar superbranchial shell-likeorgan which
gill]
noteworthy EXTRA-EUROPEAN
CYPRINIDS327
has been describedand
illustratedby Boulenger
(1901).The genus
is represented
by
about eight species occurring in various waters of Centraland
Eastern Asia.The
largestand
bestknown
of these are the ChineseH.
molitrixand H.
nohilis.The Hypophthalmichthys
molitrixisan
inhabitant of China,where
it is
known
as theLenhi
; itsometimes
attains a large size— between
three
and
four feet.^ It is highly esteemed as a food fish,and
is the object of a considerable pisciculture, not only in China, butby
Chinese be-yond
the borders of their country.According
to Mitsukuri (1905) the Chinese ofFormosa
import the young, "when
nine to ten inches long,"from China
"inNovember and
December,"
placethem
inponds
^'^^ 86.-Pharyngeai bones of, , a 1 1 1 r ^ if Hypophthalmichthvs. After
where
they-' are abundantly' fed,' c,Steindachner.^ 1,and when
theyhave become
a " footlong" they are ready for market.
The
"fish is cultivated in all parts ofFormosa."
The
clupeiform Cyprinids typifiedby
theEuropean
sichling (Pelecus cultratus) are representedby
Chinese fishes distinguishedfrom
Pelecusby
thedevelopment
ofthreerows
of pharyngeal teeth (5 or 4, 4, 2—
2, 4,4
or 5). Parapelecus argenteusand
P. machce- rius are species.Japanese
Cyprinids.As
already indic