252 ASSESSMENT OF THE BEHAVIOR OF THE POST-TENSIONING SLAB FOR DIFFERENT
FRAMING UNDER THE EFFECT OF LATERAL LOAD Ashish Kumar1
Research Scholar, Department of Structural Engineering,
School of Engineering and Technology, K. K. University, Nalanda, Bihar Deepak Kumar2, (HOD)
Assistant Professor, Department of Civil Engineering,
School of Engineering and Technology, K. K. University, Nalanda, Bihar
Abstract- Taking a look at the current construction trend Post tensioning systems are preferred in construction over pre-stressing systems because post tensioning incurs fewer losses than prestressing and allows tendons to be shaped in any shape. Following that, level chunk Post Tensioned (PT) ligaments are included as post tensioning gives unrivalled execution because the PT level floor structures offer worked on break as well as avoidance control, and allow moderately large range to thickness proportions of the request for 35 to 45, which is less in the case of RC up to 30. It also lowers the floor to floor level, resulting in lighter designs. Post-tensioning improves the productivity, manageability, and toughness of the development cycle. Recognition and examining the behaviour of level floor frameworks revealed to parallel powers or potential migrations in tremor-prone areas, such as high seismic zone areas, is a major worry. Finding the seismic power opposing limit of these structures in the inclusion or exclusion of a Lateral Force Resisting System is becoming an important topic. Nonlinear static analysis is used because it is an imperfect and relatively simple middle solution for the complex problem of anticipating power and deformity requests imposed on a structure and its components due to ground movement. This investigation is an attempt to determine the true strength of a structure, and it is a useful and viable tool for executing a plan.
Keywords: Nonlinear Static Analysis, PT Slab, Prestressed Concrete, Base Shear, Punching Shear, Deflection.
1 INTRODUCTION
Reinforced concrete slabs are widely used in concrete construction projects. The torsional solidity of the slab is ignored in the initial evaluation. Whenever this stiffness is taken into account, the appropriate theory of flexible plate bending shows that the contorting minute decreases by almost 25%. The primary purpose of floor and roof frameworks is to support gravity stacks such as segments as well as dividers. Moreover, they expect a central part in the flow of wind and seismic powers to the upward parts of the sidelong burden restricting system. The effect of the chunk sheets isn't viewed as in built up substantial fundamental examination since modelers ignore their responsibility in equal burden resistance. Generally, the advancement finished is supported cement with pieces giving the useable floor an area.
As they outline a tremendous piece of essential structure, in this way makers should get advantage from their broad in plane immovability. So in this examination the response of two essentially same designs, with and without considered
robustness of chunks were evaluated and checked in view of changed assistant boundaries out. Supported substantial pieces are by and large used as a piece of the substantial turns of events. In helper examination, the torsional immovability of chunk is disregarded likewise. Prestressed concrete is in a general sense concrete in which inside anxieties of a fitting significance and course are given the objective that the nerves coming about due to external weights are checked to an optimal degree. Prestressing of cement is described in perhaps one or two ways. The main request is pre tensioning and post tensioning which relies upon the gathering of tossing concrete and applying strain to ligaments. The system of tensioning done directly following tossing of cement is known as Post-tensioning. Post-tensioning associates in beating the difficulty of fixing required profile of ligaments in pre- tensioning. In building development, post tensioning grants greater clear ranges, more thin chunks, less bars and progressively thin parts. Post tensioning is the game plan
253 of choice for halting designs since it allows
an elevated degree of flexibility in the portion design, range lengths and slope plan. More slim section infers less concrete is required. As the floor system expects a critical work in the general cost of a structure, a post-tensioned floor structure is made which reduces the best an open door for the development and overall expense. Post tensioning in this manner grant a colossal diminishing in building weight versus an ordinary substantial structure with same no of floors. This reduces the establishment load and can be a huge piece of slack in seismic locale. In the current review we are contrasting a G+15 and porch RCC traditional piece with PT section (in level chunk) taking into account seismic burden according to zone V over a hard layers. For investigation Csi SAFE and Csi ETABS programming projects are thought of. Here we concentrated on the varieties in Frame powers, second, nodal removals and backing responses additionally contrasting the planning with decide the best and efficient casing.
1.1 Seismic Force
Architectures on seismic areas were seen to start serving more overlay in previous seismic tremors. Shivers cause significant structural failure, such as the loss of people in the building and the collapse of the structure if the tremor intensity is high.
People have been generated irrefutably in recent years, resulting in the propagation of urban zones as well as towns. As a result, distinct structures are becoming inalienable inclining zones. India has a long coastline that is anchored by mountains and plateaus. These zones' structures are constructed on sloping terrain. A large portion of India's unyielding extends to fall under seismic areas II, III, and IV, which means that collaborating in the set - up of inclining grounds is extremely vulnerable to seismic quake. This is a possible result of the way the pieces on the ground floor separate in heights, as evidenced by the ground's proclivity. Pieces are limited on one side and lengthy on the other, and they are extremely fragile due to their exceptional essence. Due to the obvious associated abnormality, seismic powers act more discretely in slanting zones.
Furthermore, seismic quake practises have been found to be skewed in slanting
reaches. In India, for instance, the north- east states. The lack of plain ground in slanting reaches powers headway advancement on slanting ground acknowledging assorted basic designs, for example, supported concrete enveloped expert's workplaces, universities, inns and workplaces laying on lopsided tendencies.
The lead of designs amidst quake relies upon the dispersal of mass and steadfastness in both even and vertical planes of the designs. In inclining area both these properties shifts with anomaly and unevenness. Such upgrades in seismically skewed areas make them displayed to additional unquestionable shears and twist.
Unfortunate direct of short partitions is a result of how short region is stiffer when appeared unmistakably in association with the long piece, and it attracts more critical quake control.
Robustness of a zone is the immunity to catastrophic events - the more conspicuous is the faithfulness, more imperative is the power expected to turn it. In case a short locale isn't appealingly proposed for such a liberal oblige, it can persevere through fundamental deception in the midst of a seismic quake. The quick static game plan of building is showed up with their straightly adaptable strength of the structure. Course of standard shake requests for the straight static system connected with static sidelong powers whose total is relating to the equal weight.
At the point when it is gotten together with the straightly versatile model of the structure it will achieve diagram advancement amplitudes approximating most essential migrations that are typical in the midst of the strategy shudder. To engineer the earth quake loads to calculate the inward powers will be reasonable assessed of anticipated that in the midst of would configuration earth shiver.
Fig. 1 Seismic Failure in India (Assam)
254 1.2 PT Slab
Post tension slab is a combination of conventional slab reinforcement and additional distending high-strength steel tendons, which are thus exposed to tension after the concrete has set. This hybridisation accomplishes the arrangement of an a lot more slender slab with a more drawn out range without any segment free spaces. Post-tensioning outcomes in more slender concrete slabs making the important investment funds in floor to floor tallness accessible as additional floors. This can give extra rentable space inside a similar by and large building stature. Post-Tensioned Slab has a touch of slack over others as it makes an extraordinarily powerful base for floor plan with thin chunks and column less spaces in greater reaches. It offers an organizer the chance to work wholeheartedly with his designs. Exactly when a mind-boggling live weight is brought upon a design, its substantial section encounters pressure, which prompts the game plan of breaks and in the end bending occurs. To alleviate this issue, post tensioned steel ligaments are inserted at the hour of establishing and tensioned ensuing to solidifying with regular rebars. Post-Tensioned pieces show lessened parting, further developed solidness and lower support costs. Their evasion can be compelled by varying the proportion of post-tensioning to change any piece of applied loads following centering.
The essential part of a post-tensioning structure is known as a tendon. A post- tensioning tendon is contained something like one pieces of prestressing steel, covered with a protective covering, and housed inside a course or sheathing. Exactly when these post tensioned steel ligaments are centered around, the substantial is squashed, in various terms, the substantial is compacted which builds the compressive strength of the substantial and at the same time the steel ligaments that are pulled increase the elasticity. Thusly, the overall strength of the substantial increments.
Secures are in like manner used to remain the ligaments into the substantial while finishing or joining two ligaments. Essential limit of wharf is to move the zeroing in on capacity to the substantial once the zeroing in on methodology is done.
Fig. 2 PT slab 1.3 Soil Type
Soil-Structure Interaction is an attempting multidisciplinary subject which covers several areas of Civil Designing. In each functional sense each progression is associated with the ground and the collaboration between the old inconsistency and the establishment medium may affect basically both the superstructure and the establishment soil. The Soil-Structure Collaboration issue has changed into an essential piece of Basic Engineering with the technique of huge upgrades on delicate soils, for example, atomic power plants, concrete and earth dams. Structures, stages, passages and underground structures may in addition require specific idea to be given to the issues of Soil- Structure Interaction. Seeing how the earth reacts to fruitful seismic tremors could be vital to plans and coordinators outlining future structures to withstand the level of quickening estimated in this shudder. The data will in like way offer seismologists some assistance with developing new models to associate the impacts with these sensational and to an exceptional degree convincing occasions. In this study we are considering hard strata which can be said as soil element with good bearing capacity and distribution of stresses.
2 LITERATURE SURVEY
Sridhar and Rose (2019) The creator was commended for using ETABS and SAFE to organise a post-tensioned structure.
Extended 3D Analysis of Design Systems is addressed by ETABS. The most important justification for this item is to design the multi-story structure in a precise manner that adheres to Indian Standard design codes. The creator adventure tried to deal with the plan of events of quake as well as wind resistance framework in which the
255 least sizes of section and bar given were
C500*500 and B300*500, and later Seismic examination was completed utilising ETABS programming in which the entire team was passed through the agreement. Because the layout was a tensioned one, it proved to be effective. Srilaxmi et. al. (2018) The originator channelled that pre-tensioning as well as post-tensioning systems are usually used in large-scale construction modifications these days. Under the pre- zeroing in on the strategic plan, the two systems of pre-tensioning and post- tensioning are was using. In which there are few advantages over basic non-zeroed in constructions, such as a wider reach to significance scope, a greater moment, and a higher shear limit. PSC bracings, sleepers, Bridges, Slabs in Structures, Concrete Pile, Repair and Rehabilitation, Nuclear Forces Plant, and so on were all used to bring these methodologies to successful conclusion. Prakash et. al. (2017) Post- tensioned story areas are regarded as one of the most economically beneficial betterment for strip retail outlets, office designs, as well as halting where reaches exceed 7.5 metres, according to the creator. The overall represented' supported' tendon using from 3 to 5 individual pre-pushing strands housed in oval ducting and obtained in level fan-molded safe hook castings is the inclined toward post-tensioning layout utilised. Nethravathi et. al. (2017) The outcomes of an investigation of the unbonded post-tensioned cast set up halting floor introduced to different approaches of tendon plan subject to FEM evaluation were recognised by the creators of the research paper. SAFE programming was used to display and examine the post- tensioned level plate. As shown by the tendon setup, corresponding hardships subject to interface profiles were affiliated with the level plate. For the distinct tendon plans at organisation and outrageous location of restriction state, framework minutes, organisation minutes, hyper-static minutes, transient aversion, long stretch redirection, and punching shear were considered. Dobariya et. al. (2017) In the strengthened as well as unbonded bar with one of the most remarkable strain zone interact profile, the creator investigated a long-range T-shaft with 10-20m territory point of support evaluation. Based on the improvement costs of both systems, the
speculative findings were based on IS 1343- 1980 and ACI-318. The linkage was built on explicit boundaries based on aversion, minute bending, and sheer power. While stood out through numerous shafts under two-point stacking and single-point stacking circumstances separately, the prestressed strong support point with elevated PT powers (64kN and 42kN) accomplished the most absurd burden. The parts started to occur definitively underneath the stacking centres, indicating that the bars had been bombarded by flexure. Jasani and Pandey (2017) The enquiry was completed by changing the position of the exchange brace in plan and also changing the position of the shear divider, and the trying to demonstrate of a G+11 floor building was completed using Etabs implementation. Indeed, the flexural behaviour of the shaft, that was precisely positioned on the post-strain move brace as well as the segment that supports the transfer assistance, was investigated. The expository findings stated that because of the transfer brace within the structure, placing shear dividers on each of the four corners of the structure proved to be more beneficial than placing shear dividers along either side of the exchange support.
Nishant et. al. (2017) On post-tensioning, the author emphasized the use of two distinct methods: fortified and unbonded methods. Fathom by hypothetical as well as programming in stress, efficiency, redirection, twisting minute, as well as load adjusting conditions with reinforced and unbonded frameworks. From ACI code examination with IS code, fortified and unbonded pushed and effectively usable.
The ACI code specifies the combination of various types of architectures: reinforced as well as unbonded. Szydlowski and Barbara (2017) The geometry, trademark, and redirection of raised pieces were demonstrated in the author's paper. During the construction of the sections and the first two years of their use, three larger- than-normal chunks were diverted. Despite the fact that the sections are profoundly larger and slenderer than the given a prescription greatest extreme prediction of range and length to profundity proportion, the chunks are redirected far from the furthermost point esteem, assign projects of known and future frameworks of long-range prestressed pieces. Mordak et. al. (2016)
256 The findings of the preliminary investigation
were introduced in the creators' evaluation paper, which focused on one more advancement pre-zeroed in on post- tensioned road expansion made arrangements over a water supply plant under special field load testing in Topola Village, Poland. A number of extraordinary tests were coordinated for a comprehensive evaluation of the various strong parts of the expansion's construction. The broad scope of the one-of-a-kind test drove a flexible assessment of the platform's components through the overall examination, leading to the conclusion that the expansion qualified for fundamental organisation under Poland's regulations. Dhamaliya et. al.
(2016) The creators' research study centred on the post-tensioned section without a drop and level piece, performing a parametric analysis of Post-Tensioned Flat lump without a drop as well as r.c.c level lump for a specific board size. Etabs and ADAPT pt@2012 programming have analysed and organised this segment for various reach (6m to 10m), that are the most widely perceived navigates used during rehearsals. The findings led to the conclusion that the divider load was regarded as being distributed throughout the floor (KN/m2) during the post-tensioned construction evaluation. As a result, the client had the option of fostering a divider in any expected location in the event of post-tensioning. The post-tensioned level piece without a drop required 4 kg/m2 of prestressing steel, while the post-tensioned level lump with the drop required 3.2 kg/m2. The prestressing steel required for the post-tensioned level piece with no drop, for example, was significantly higher. Paul and Yedu (2016) The author evaluated the structure's exhibition variables, which included vertically reinforced ligaments that were correspondingly circulated along four sides of the segments. The shopping complex structure in Pattambi, which is located in seismic zone III, was selected for investigative process. Corner sections were constrained by increasing vertical PT forces to half of their pivotal load limit and using the most extreme fortification steel up to 4% of the territory. The findings of the study revealed that increasing PT steel and PT forces in ligaments can improve Performance point, highest base shear, reaction reduce factor, pliability component,
and over-quality factor. Szydlowski and Magdalena (2016) The author presented the important configuration standards, as well as the consequences of framework disfigurement throughout erection as derived from a hypothetical FEM model and approximated, as well as related advancement. The results of implementing a prestressed move chunk in the framework were discussed in this work. Five stories are supported by a chunk built over an underground tunnel. The demonstrated project was the first of its kind in the authors' venture workshop. Consequences of diversion guesstimates throughout the structure's advancement show minor variances from expected qualities. Qualities were determined, but exact consistency was difficult to predict in simple models using a replacement load strategy. Forced circumstances met with a specific hold, according to the guesstimates of redirection in the last identified phase of execution. For post-tensioned bars carrying 5 stories, the most excessive range/profundity proportion was 17.6. In tests with thorough comparable acknowledgement, this was higher. Four-advance prestressing and an unusual state of base compressive loads were used to achieve this. Mathur et. al.
(2015) The investigation presented in the study was pre-focused on cement anchoring devices, which have a huge impact on conceptual design choices. It includes various prestressed solid procedures that aid us in good perspective the component of the working foundation and various mooring gadgets that are ready to conduct for structures. Furthermore, when compared to RCC, prestressing structures are more dependable, solid, and smaller in size. As a result of the use of anchoring devices, more solid structures can be built.
Furthermore, the pre-stress shaft can withstand higher loads than the RCC pillar.
It's one of the most basic methods for trying to secure the shaft at a lower cost. Ahmed et. al. (2014) The creator completed a positive investigation such as versatility, pliability, framework dispersing, and so on, with the goal of developing rules for precast construction in earthquake-prone areas.
Regardless of the fact that the essentiality dispersed was low, the adaptability of the PCB prototype was stronger than the MCB model, the additional distortion of the PCB model was practically nothing, and the PCB
257 model's mischief level was lower than the
MCB model. There was only a principal break between shaft and segment in PCB models, and the bar had small shear parts.
This indicated that the PT tendon was more appropriate than level fortresses in the support point on pieces with reducing shear parts. Boskey et. al. (2013) The author looked at four cases with different floor architectures as part of a contextual investigation for the use of structure technique in a place of business (G+4). The quantities of fortifying steel, pre - stressing steel, and concrete needed for the piece, shaft, and portion were calculated and displayed in an unimaginable structure. In addition, the total cost of the structure per square metre was determined, and the price correlation of all 4 cases was completed.
Tanyeri and J.P. Moehle (2012) Using the E- Defense shaking table office, the author aimed a 3D quake reproduction experiment on a full-scale, four-story prestressed solid structure. Two post-tensioned (PT) contours in a single heading and two unbonded PT precast splitters the other way were among the seismic forces opposing the test building's setup. The test construction was subjected to a series of quake ground motions, which ranged from helpful to close crumple. The behaviour of the structure's divider heading under various ground movements was reenacted using nonlinear reaction history analysis of reasonable basic building designs, and the 2D dramatisation results were compared to the test results.
3 METHODOLOGY
This study shows a comparison between two structures with same loading and properties condition with the effect of slab stiffness considering general RCC slab structure and PT slab Structure to check variations in both in a Tall G+15 RCC building considering seismic zone V with hard soil type Under the seismic effect as per IS 1893(part I) -2016 non-linear analysis. This study is attempted in following steps: Step-1: To prepare a literature survey of past researches related to PT technique, structural analysis and effect of diaphragm over a structure. Step- 2: To prepare modelling of the selected geometry For modelling of the structure we are considering a plan area of 300 m2 with symmetrical frame. ETABS is utilized in
modelling of the structure whereas for modelling of PT slab SAFE software is utilized.
Fig. 3 Plan of the model
Fig. 4 PT technique in slab
Step-3: Assigning PT slab using analysis tool SAFE. SAFE software is utilized for assigning PT technique to the structure.
Step-4: Assigning anchors to fix the Post tensioning tendons. Tendons are need to be fixed using anchors to assign tension as per requirement, this tension can be generated by stretching tendon wires using anchors.
Fig. 5 Assigning Anchors
258 Step-5: Generating PT slab with tendons in
flat slab: In this study we are considering PT technique in flat slab as it is considered as the most suitable type of slab for Post tensioning technique.
4 CONCLUSIONS
From the present study it was examined that PT slab stiffness is much efficient in comparison to simple RCC slab frame system in reducing moment, storey displacement, peak displacement and forces. Following conclusions are observed in chapter 5 are as follows: Axial Force: As results observed in above chapter it can be said that vertical distribution is generally same in both the cases. Variation of 8% is observed in PT slab as it is more resisting and distributing. Shear Force: In terms of unbalance forces it can be said that unbalance forces are linear in both the cases, and values on PT slab case is on the higher end with approximate variation of 5%. Displacement: In terms of displacement it can be concluded that PT slab structure is comparatively more stable 25% less displacement as compared to RCC slab structure. Bending Moment: In terms of bending moment it is observed that Pt slab structure is comparatively more economical and stable structure since ending moment observed is less by 15%.
REFERENCES
1. Amalu Paul and Yedu Krishnan.M (2016),
“Lateral load analysis of Post tensioned and RCC building using Pushover analysis”, “International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology (IRJET)”, Volume: 03 Issue: 09 | Sep-2016.
2. A.C. Tanyeri & J.P. Moehle (2012), “Seismic Performance and Modeling of Post-Tensioned, Precast Concrete Shear Walls”, “15 WCEE LISBOA”.
3. Boskey Vishal Bahoria and Dhananjay K. Parbat (2013) “Analysis and Design of RCC and Post- tensioned Flat Slabs Considering Seismic Effect”,
“IACSIT International Journal of Engineering and Technology”, Vol. 5, No. 1.
4. D.Y. Wang, Z.B. Li, W.M. Yan, E.W. Guo, L.Y. Shi (2014), “seismic performance of precast prestressed beam-column concrete connections”,
“Journal of Beijing University of Technology”, Vol 32:10, ISSN 895-900.
5. Gardiner, D.K. Bull , A.J. Carr, (2018) Trends of Internal Forces in Concrete Floor Diaphragms of Multi-storey Structures During Seismic Shaking, World Conference on Earthquake Engineering.
6. Maulik G. Kakadiya, Hitesh K. Dhamaliya (2016)
“A Research on Comparison of R.C.C and Post Tensioned Flat Slab with or Without Drop Using Software”, “International Journal of reseach and development advances”, Volume 2, Issue 2, Print ISSN : 2395-1990, Online ISSN : 2394-4099.
7. Nishant M. Dobariya,, Ankit Agrawal (2017),
“Comparative Study Of Bonded & Unbonded Post-Tensioning For Long Span Beam In Building”, “International journal of development sciences”, Volume 4, Issue 4.
8. Nethravathi S.M and Darshan Prasad (2017),
“Analysis and Comparative Study of Unbonded Post-tensioned Cast-In-Place Parking Floor on the Effects of Tendon Layout using Safe”,
“International Journal of Engineering Research
& Science (IJOER)”, Vol-3, Issue-7, pp 34-50.
9. Arkadiusz Mordak and Zbigniew Zee Manko (2016) “Effectiveness of Post-tensioned prestressed concrete road bridge realization in the light of research under dynamic loading”, “9th International conference, Bridge in Danube Baisn” Vol 1, ISSN 3463-4521.
10. Arkadiusz Mordak and Zbigniew Zee Manko (2016) “Effectiveness of Post-tensioned prestressed concrete road bridge realization in the light of research under dynamic loading”, “9th International conference, Bridge in Danube Baisn” Vol 1, ISSN 3463-4521.
11. Amalu Paul and Yedu Krishnan.M (2016),
“Lateral load analysis of Post tensioned and RCC building using Pushover analysis”, “International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology (IRJET)”, Volume: 03 Issue: 09 | Sep-2016.
12. A.C. Tanyeri & J.P. Moehle (2012), “Seismic Performance and Modeling of Post-Tensioned, Precast Concrete Shear Walls”, “15 WCEE LISBOA”.
13. Boskey Vishal Bahoria and Dhananjay K. Parbat (2013) “Analysis and Design of RCC and Post- tensioned Flat Slabs Considering Seismic Effect”,
“IACSIT International Journal of Engineering and Technology”, Vol. 5, No. 1.
14. D.Y. Wang, Z.B. Li, W.M. Yan, E.W. Guo, L.Y. Shi (2014), “seismic performance of precast prestressed beam-column concrete connections”,
“Journal of Beijing University of Technology”, Vol 32:10, ISSN 895-900.
