1
! " #$ % ! " #$ %
& '
% ( " #$
) :
18 / 9 / 1392 - :
30 / 2 / 1393 (
( )
* + * , -(. * / 0 -( 1 " ' 2 3 +
- 4 2 5&
67 8 9
(. (:8
9
; & " < =>
& ! ? : * (&@ * A
? B 5 . D E ; /D+ FE ; B > G 8
F /" H 5&
" / +
.I 9 (.
56(> 5 ? : J * ; , KE I BL() M(#% =>
( B KE
. 9'(
5*
B I 5& * ; 9 (.
-(. * =>
5N + + + * ,
:( E :#4 2 O+ 5& + =&
2 O+ 2 ;PQ8 R#4 S 5*
5 (.
K /
, S 2 H 2
T#? ' " 1
% . 67 8 U E
D+ F
> + :
U(#1 * 5( 5 ?
>
5'( ; B
-(. 5&
;(Q+ 5* 56(> 5 ? : * V ,
U(7
! R 5( /
-(. W X Y
>
! 5*
= (E K
>
B .
(#& Z
/ #:
' $ Y
/, /
9 [ / / / = I S 5 (.
)
=>
-
B* . (
1.
1 . ! " # $% &' ( )*# + , -./ ! 01 ,2 .1 + 34&' 567 $' 7
+ 8 9 6' 9 :;
<2 = ,> '0;2 .? ! % 5@ " + 9 (
»
$&;B9
& 9 C &# ,7 D' E F;GH 9 I;GJ7 C &# 9 .1
;' ' « 2 .
% &' L M*' I+
: 66726100 Email: [email protected]
1
1 . : 3;29 <*=
0;P' ;*! Q7 *! R D% 4' );-> S ! + ,% ' 2
( P 2 9
E / ,' S 9 " T;7 Q/0! 5 S ! 7
2 7 ! U L ' V0 - .
+ 57E
90H' 5 ! B L ' 2
W 9 X ! S JY2 Z[ -\' 9 ,/0! 9 /
E S / V *;7 /
! U , ( P 2 E S ! Q' ) &;B9 .?
,' </ / 0.7 ! + 2
! ! ) W 9
, V ]+ S /
(01 0./ &;B9 ! .
,' ^ ' L ' ) _;B 1
' 2 7 !
$ (`9 S ^ S ! W [
<;a? S / V
X 2
! ( D7 0;% 9 29 2
,' \' ^ W -? ! b7 E 3P7 V + ! 5 9 0;% c T ! 9 07 9E 02
.
^9 ! 07 ^9 ,7 7 = d;/ V) +
!
# e 9 0/ ( ^ ,% ' );.f _;B
2 );\' E BE 9 W Q#
. ) ! U , _;B VL # 0 !
9 F' + ,6 07 9 !
! ^
$-/
7 ^ + g 1 7 / 9 ; R e 1 T;/ ,
. , h 9
;.!
)
,-7 + 2 ) , <*= ) E
/
; X 07
8
^ = &;B9
% D'
$
+ i X S =
. );.f ST;f jG ! 9 2 k' U , , l , h 9 !
R 5 01
&;B9 m 0/ X 0;' 57 .
!
^9 2 W [ V) 07
8 -# T;7 &;B9
,! S9 G@ L e9 );-> ; R e , +
*7 (0 .
b7 ) S T' ( P 2 9 U , _;B S ! V
,&;D4 R \% 4' 2 W [
1 :-+ J S / 6+ R ;! 5 9 .
! ) C &# U , _;B V a.'
+ I;GJ7
»
&;B9
$ 9 .1
« ,' (0;' 7 1
F;GH 9 T5 9 ,2 ! V 2 (01
.
!
^9 V)
<b' n7E
! ,' a7 2 ,= &# 9 ,b& ,7 D' ! b7 ) _;D4 V02 .
) I V9
b7 BE 9 W Q# );;D
&;B9
$ 9 .1 ) U , (
C D47 2 W [ V,^ X C &#
\% 4' ,= &# 9 ,b& ,7 D' ! E 1
.
2 0e _;&H )
) ! ,
c2 / 2 W bP' +
&;B9
$
! o e9 9 9 .1
9 U , _;B E p *;f I;GJ7 C &# b7 ) BE 9 W Q# T;7 9 E b7 U m
&;B9
$ ) ! 2 S ! p 2 2 ,= &# 9 ,b& ,7 D' ! 9 .1
c2
*Y7 qHD' V / V
&;B9
$
\% 4' I;GJ7 C &# 9 .1 '
, 1 W bP' E 9
e .? 9
&;B9
$ 9 9 .1 T;7 b7 BE 9 W Q#
c;
P
! )Y2 ,' ;' 0 E . Ir2 qHD'
VW9
b7 U m Q' !
(01 ,' X ;' ' & 9 C &# a.' 1
.
2 . :
W [ " # 1 7
<b' 2 D.^ )
S /
&;B9
$ ,2 ! 9 .1 1
. ) 9 W bP' ! V9
e .?
&;B9
$ 9 .1 )
*Y7 0.!
( E BE 9 W Q# 9 )
W9 0.!
( ,' X 1 .
2 . 1 .
! "
# $%
&;B9
$ 9 .1 -;7 1
$ 9 Q ! ! S ];' </ 7 = W9
$
! o 7 ( 9 , >=
^9
' 2 );'s S ! I;GJ7 ,= &# W a7 I E 9 0'E
$ :7 ! / E ( P 2 01
) ,7 D\1
VS 20.+
1392 t V 28 - 11
.(
$&;B9 W bP' ! b! , .1E S ! u \ ! V 9 .1
) u%
( b7 e .? 9
(01 ) g ( ,' X 1 .
&' ( &)*+,
:' % ) 7 L 2 1897 W + ! ,7 *+ );%9
V 1 ;!
! + 1 + ,7 '
@
,' c; o \ ' 9 S ? 9
$&;B9 : 9 .1 $&;B9 V 2 o 7 ,1 7
.
&;B9 );.f S
,' -;-" E v " ' , ! 7 w 1 1
.
&;B9 );.f / ^
! + 2 ) S
,' ,= ! U ' X 9 PX R e 07 '
+ 1 Q.
'
$
0 * ! X S ? ^
) Government Stocks and Other Securities Investment…
.(
L 2 1903 W V ' ," =
;! 2
+ +
&;B9
! 0/ X 9 .1 V01 ! 1 , h 9 2 S :
VL9 2 S9 &;B9 E S
E 9 ^ ' , <? V01 ! , x(0.
VW9
R 5 S ? ^ 2 E
x0.+ ;;k J ' ! ,7 ' + 1 VW 2
t Y1 o @ L -? ,X ! + ,7 '
Sl
! S ? _ @ 07 ! + 1 V 1 W 57 &;B9 3P7 2
$
&;B9 L -6' ,
0/ ' c 5 9 0.+ 0 29
) Re Yorkshire Woolcombers…
.(
E <;- ) S
S0\!
0; s T;7
)01
Re Orleans Motor…; Re Hayman, Christy & Lilly…; Re Matthew Ellis…;
Scott, Clauson and Luxmoore…; Smith v. Bridgend…
.(
! , 0;2 a70 05 ( S
' ," =
! 8
&;B9
$ P 9 .1 :
»
&;B9
$ X \;D@ 9 .1 9 2 m ;;k 9 y H '
L ! L # &;B9 v " ' L ' S9 C P / 0 9 ,>\! + ,7 ' 2
;!
0 P
D2 + 1 W 57 L -? ,>\!
&;B9
$
& 2 9 0D*n! &;B9 v " ' L ' ! 9 .1
0!
) «
Illingworth v. Houldsworth
.(
1. floating charge.
2. Romer.
1 bz G;' % V0\! = : 90#
V
! ' ," = + S e .? W -
o e9 .?
&;B9
$ ( + , \' 9 .1 2
;' n7E QG! V *;7 S 9 " &;B9 ) *7 9 .1 S ! V
,2 2 ;-/ ; X 2 )
W 2 , h 9 V
&;B9
$ S ! Q/0! S E ,.\ V 9 .1 '
$
( ^ *+ 90! R 5 07
8 E T - ^ ' + 2 &;B9
&;B9
$ ,' ! B 1
) Agnew and Another v. Commissioner of Inland Revenue…
.(
0; s T;7 % IG5' Ir2
S E );6;
(079 bz );.f S + a7
:
»
! W 57 2 &;B9 v " ' ,
&;B9 .?
,-7 t X ) X S !
0/ { 3 =9 ,X ! + ,7 ' 0!
. V Ge )
&;B9 2 i X &;B9 E 9 0.+ ( P 2 &;B9 v " ' , + 2 E m «
) National Westminster bank plc. v Spectrum Plus Ltd
…
.(
C &#
| 2 ! T;7 ,*;GJ7 7
S E c;
P u \ S ^ ! V
&;B9
$ );;D ! V 9 .1 9 e .?
9 , h S / 2 7
$ E
X
) 07
McCormack, 2002, p. 391; Stamp, 2001, p. 1144; Goulding, 1999, p. 325:
Bourne, 1998, p. 229
+(
5.
,' ,2 ! 1
.
- ( *. / ,' W G\' V01 P n7E
+ 1
&;B9
$ 2 9 .1 , h 9
+ ,Ge
0 ! E ! / X
1 :
1 .
01 2 3 4
5 )6 7 8 9/ ":) 8 2
o]X !
&;B9
$ , Y6' L ' + ! B '
v "
,' = &;B9 V ;
&;B9
$ , Y6' L ' 9 .1
,-7 ( &;B9 ! 2 (9 QG! V 1
0' , S
&;B9
$
= 9 ) X
,'
; .
! S }' : , # 9 ( ' : L @ ~,1 T/ 2 )Q-' (0..+0;% + 1 VL
9 *! 9
) 5 V9
&;B9
$ E W - ! ! B ,' ' V *;7 )Q-' /
~,1 /
!
F;Q6 .?
0./
8 ,6Y!
2
$ ,.\ V + 1 , 2
$ V0;% ^ S /[ +
+ u;e .
* 1 V) ! .!
2
&;B9
$ W 7 2 ! 07 ! 9 .1 V 1 -;-" (01 S m
07 ;r! 2 E , Y6' , ! Q7E S ^ ! .
2 S /
R D? , !
07 : -/
$
);1 ' 9 R T;b5 V, 0;% ^ S /[ + VR[E
V R D% 4' 9
) Goulding, 1999,
pp.323-324
.(
&;B9
$ )Q-' 9 .1 9 01 ! (0. E 9 ^ ' , <? 0' , W - S9 2
, -/
9 ^ ' S / E
(0.
; ! );-> .? ! + 1 S 5 R ;G-? ,' - 9
) Tajarloo, 2005, p. 297
.(
) '
V ,2 2 , h 9
&;B9
$
*;7 9 .1 x
! )Q-' + ,.\' )
&;B9 2
$ F' 1 b. 9 .1 2
$
, ,e X
) 1
Federated Cooperatives…
9 (
T;7
,' + *;7 W [ 9 01 ! ^ ' L ' ! z 7 w& 07 2
$
</ (0. E , F' 1 ,
) 6!
Re Bond Worth…
.(
! ,%9
&;B9 );.f L -\' @
! S
$-/
' (0. E 9 ^ ' L
,' 0'
) 1
Wood, 1989, p. 195
.(
5
&;B9
$
, S9 9 .1
S
! ./ +
^9
+ 1 (0' ;7
! E
( 9 ;7 2 2 3 1 ;*! V
) Goulding, 1999, p. 326
.(
2 .
; <, 2 / = )*7 > ? :) * @, R 5 S ? ^ &;B9 v " ' ,
;;k J ' ! ,7 ' 9 Z D ' ,'
0!
.
2 ^ ' , V3= 9
$
&;B9 v " ' ,
$ 2 7 9 .1 2
R ' ! 9
;;k V + 1 R 5 0/ X
) Bourne, 1998, p. 229
.(
3 .
) ? = ! 3 4B :) ! + = C
D
&;B9 / ^
$ ,' Q/0! + 2 ) 9 .1
' , 07
S ? ^ &;B9 v "
" ! ;7 90! 9 R 5 07
8 G' \' &;B9 0.+
x -/
&;B9 &\7 FD= + @
! X ! S ; X );.f
) Re Florence Land…;Re Borax Co…;Re Crompton…;Royal
Trust Bank…; Ferran, 1988, p. 229
.(
&;B9
$
! B 7 0' 90! &;B9 v " ' , L &
07 "
8 ,' 3.' E 9 ;;k F! = , S9 &;B9 ,D2 .' FQ1 F;% );-/ ! 9 0.+
*;7 U .
R 5 S ? ^ &;B9 L -6' , ! G' \' S E VF! &' V
&;B9 b.6; !
$ 9 .1 ' ,' 5.
) 1
McCormack, 2002, p. 391; Goulding, 1999, p. 324
.(
! QG! V *;7 _G4' , L & 7 0' S E D%
$42 9 W 0=
»
S ? ^
R 5 « ,' 90H'
) 1
Re Panama, New zealan and Australia… ; Re Yorkshire…; Re
Borax..; Hubbuckv. Helms…; Ferran, 1988, p. 229
.(
\' V J R D? ! v " ' , ! G'
&;B9 w&
&;B9 + 1 S 5 S ? ^ + 2 D \' , e (01 W 57 m
) 01 !
Siebe Gorman…; Re Keenan Bros…
.(
! S VL }' ,' + 1 S0;% R[ H' 07
019 P! X
) Re Florence Land…
_ @ (
&;B9
$
) ! B
Re Automatic Bottle Makers…;
Wheatly v. Silkstone…
9 .1 ( ) Re Benjamin…
);1 ' 0/ = c X ) );-> (
R[E
' v "
&;B9
$ 0 -7 • \ c X
) Goulding, 1999, p. 324
L ' W - U9 _# ,%9 V(
07 X
) Taylor v. M’Keand…; Hubbuck v. Helms…
.(
)
)/ U9 V9
'
! )b ' 0 X V 1 , W - F' 1 L 07
8
&;B9
$ 1 0/ Y7 W0& _# 9 .1
) Re Mobile Electric…
.(
&;B9 + , e L -6' , L & 7 V0 -7 F-? X R 5 S ? ^ _D@ m
07 S ? 9 2 €;He &;B9 8
F& .' ! D*7 &;B9 + S J , Y1 ;%
,
! ,&# @ ! ' ,-7 m V( 9E 2
) 1
R. v. F.B.D.B…
.(
^ | 2 ! + 1
X S 5 S ? F-?
L -6' L ' L & 7 V0.+
2
$ v " ' + ,
&;B9
$ V 2 9 .1
,' D2
E 1
07 i X &;B9 L -1 /
% ' 9 , ,' F; H +
&;B9 v " ' V 1
= ,' 9 ; ) 079 ' ,' 0!
, / 0 9 B Q.
V
&;B9
$
! V GD 9 .1
&;B9
$ F 0D ! B ,'
E v " ' , ! 9 1 2
&
,'
)0!
Landall Holdings v.
Caratti…
.(
) S 2 v " ' ,% ?
079 8
! W 2 ' 9 o9 \'
» :65.
« );;D
01 (
) 2
Royal Bank of Canada v. Sparrow Electric…
.(
2 . 2 .
# !
"
6 # C
<b' BE 9 W Q# )
&;B9
$ ,2 ! R 9 " + 9 .1 1
&;B9 GD V )
u%
( _# 9
E Fe # W0&
) g ( 2 .
&' ( , I;GJ7 C &#
V _# & 2 S !
&;B9 L -6' , ! &;B9 V
9
` -;-"
01
) C H%
1( GD 9
2) ,' ( P 2 1
. o]X ! V &;&#
&;B9
$ -/ + ! B
•E
!
,' & *' &;B9 v " ' L ' V 1
&;B9
$ V‚Y6' 3 =9 ,>\! C P V 9 .1
! B ,e X v " ' 9 ‚Y6' L ' ! &;B9 _#
,-7
) 1
McCormack, 2002, pp. 403 &
413; Wood, 1989, p. 204; Goulding, 1999, p. 323
&;B9 + ,7 ' VF;% );-/ ! 9(
$ 9 .1
&;B9 !
$ F 0D ! B V
*;7 ^ F! = V 67 & *' E v " ' L ' ! 9
) Goulding, 1999, p.
324
.(
F 0D );-/ &;B9 GD ' V 5; 7
&;B9
$
&;B9 ! 9 .1
$ 2 ! B
) Wood, 1989,
p. 195; Armour, 2004, p. 28
.(
GD ! 2 ,6Y! W - ! &;B9 _# V &;B9 )
$ ,
);\' V(01
! = I + 1 +
V 2 ^ ' GD aH% 9 ( 9E 2
& 2
,'
) 0!
Goulding, 1999, p. 323
.(
D? !
! V J R DG
V &;B9 9 .1 \;D@
E - X
,' 0!
x
! ,' );! , L & 7 Q' + S @ 07 9 9
8 ,' &;B9
&;B9 07
^ U
0 -7
) Gullifer, 2008, pp. 399-400
.(
1. Attach.
2. Crystallise.
9 L]H7 v9 1
;P $
! ( X V + 1 V QDG@ 2 X ! 01 ! S ; X R e
D2 GD
&;B9
$ ,' 9 .1
) 1
Re Florence Land…; Robinson v. Smith…; Re Crompton…;
McCormack, 2002, p. 392; Bourne; 1998, pp. 229-230; Wood, 1989, p. 204; Armour, 2004, pp. 28-29
.(
, ^
,' = ,J *Q1 9 S ? H Q/0! +
DB Q. );;\ V ;
2 X ,' &;B9 GD D2
;-/ V = 1
.
!
^9
;\"9 V)
*;7 )19 0.f E
) Wood, 1989, pp. 204-205
.(
,' &;B9 GD D2 + S J 0 9 );;\ V 1
(0..+
) Receiver
+ 2 (
! ( 9 '
» 0'
)«
Administrator
2 ( W 7 ;;k ( )
Enterprise Act 2002, s. 248
,*+ ! 9(
,' P
; X + 1
! + 1
90! V ^ ' 9 L -\' + 1 : R e
0.+ X V 1 ;P 9 FH.' + 1 Q.
) Gaskell v. Gosling…; Gullifer, 2008, p.
401;Fairweather&Border, 2004, p. xix
.(
S );.f );;\ !
! G;29
$ QDG@ ( V
&;B9
$ ,' GD 9 .1
; X Q/0! aH% ) V0!
8 W9 H' c X ,
,'
) 1
Re Florence Land…; Robinson v. Smith…; Re Crompton…; McCormack, 2002, p.
392; Goulding, 1999, p. 327; Wood, 1989, p. 204
.(
9T 0 9 9 ! c;
P ,' J./ V + 1 : .? ! X R 5 + 1 +
,' ! 2 L9 0 ' 9 L -\' 9
'
$ ,' u= ' X R 5 V0.+
&;B9
$ GD 9 .1
,'
) 0!
Robson v. Smith
…; Government Stocks…; Re Woodroffes…; William Gaskell
Group…; Wood, 1989, p. 205; Bourne, 1998, p. 229
V(
R 5 + u= '
9 .1 G?
,' );! &;B9 !
) !
McCormack, 2002, p. 392; Ferran, 1988, p. 229
.(
L & 7 V) ! .!
&;B9 GD ^ ' ,2 2 R 0b\ W -
$ ,' 9 .1
) 1
Re Hillstead…
.(
0 9 0..+ GD ' 8
! ) X + S J
E 2 + X GD ƒ 1 V R 9 "
x
!
9 •H' ! + ,.\' ) v =
‚Y6' 0 9 V(01
&;B9
$
;7 90! 9 + X R e ! 9 .1
-? d;/ W 57 ! GD ' S J F
,'
5; 7 + 1
$
&;B9 v " ' , ! G' \' ; X E
,'
) m
Ferran, 1988, p. 234
.(
ƒ 1 D ? t X , /0 0.f /
S /
c;
P
) ^9
Goulding, 1999, p. 328; Ferran, 1988, p. 234
V(
m " # L # '
,@ 1 );.f + (01 ,' &;B9 + X GD ^ ' 9 2 D \'
) 1
Evans v. Rival…; Re
Woodroffes…;Re Real Meat…;Re Bond worth…; Re Brightlife…;Re Permanent House…
.(
S B -' QDG@ ! D*7 ,@ 1 );.f D%
07 W0& ^ ' 9
&;B9
$ 7E ! 9 .1
,-7
) 1
.(Insolvency Act 1986, s. 251; Sealy, 1986, p. 26; Ferran; 1987, pp. 32-33
V 5; 7
07 V 1 m ,@ 1 );.f D ? 8
,' &;B9
, + , e 0.+ ƒ 1 07
W 9 1 -+ &' 0# + 1
9 , Y6' 0# + 1 S /
) McCormack,
2002, p. 393
+ 1 (
&;B9
$ J 0.+ 5 , S9 S 9
0? ' &;B9 S )
r7 );\'
) Goulding, 1999, p. 328
V(
&;B9
$
! ;7 90! 9 + X R e ! 9 .1
d;/
GD S 4X 7 ,'
0!
.
- (
# , E
+0 = C F =
W0& _#
;'
&;B9
$
&;B9 9 9 .1
$
! B ) 1 (
&;B9 0.f 9 V
$ 9 .1 ) 2 (
&;B9 V
$ 9 9 .1
, >= QDG@
) 3 ( V
&;B9 9
$ -' 9 9 .1 )
4 ( 5.
,2 ! ,' 1 .
1 .
# , E =
!
&;B9 V01 ! (01 0&\.' ! B </ 9 9 .1 &;B9 </ ( /
$
! ! B
&;B9
$ W0& _# 9 .1 x
&;B9 0\! , # 1 S /
01 ! (01 5 9 .
) Re Panama, New zealan and Australia…;
Wheatly v. Silkstone…; McCormack, 2002, p. 407; Sealy, 1986, p. 26
V(
, ]' \' );.f
_ @ ,.-" ; X '
$ 2 (01 ( ( ^ R 5 S ? ^ W 0= 9 S 5 ;% \
) Re Ind, Coope…; Ward v. Royal Exchange Shipping…; Wheatly v. Silkstone…
.(
2 .
# , E G ) =
&;B9 &;B9 v " ' , ! G' \' ,.-" ; X
$
! 9 .1
; X + 2 3;29 S 0=
5
&;B9
$ ( ^ &;B9 L -6' , ,6Y! S9 S0\! 9 .1 ,'
) 0/
RePanama,
New zealan and Australia… ; Re Automatic Bottle Makers…
.(
!
^9 5 V)
&;B9
$ 9 .1
W - S9 2
$
! 0/ Y7 5' &;B9 v " ' ,
) Re Household Products…; Re
Benjamin…
x(
= Q. J' );6;
( ^ );.f 01 ! (01 ( S
) Savin Canada…
.(
L # n7 .f
&;B9 0.f 9 + 1
$ V01 ! ( + 4? 9 .1
t X
W 0+ Q.
:
E
</ V W0& _# J S J ! /
;' C &#
7
</ 9 9
$ I;GJ7 , >=
o] X
^9 a7 .
C &# ,X ! + 070& \' 7
&;B9
$
! S0\! 9 .1
&;B9
$ 9 .1
);6;
W0&
) Goulding, 1999, pp. 329-330
x(
( J ,>\! VIQ? ! 9 /
0.* 7 V
&;B9
&D@ 1 5 ' ! ^ ! 9 .1 S / ,' S0.!
)0..+
Re Benjamin…;
Stamp, 2001, p. 115; Ferran, 1988, pp.215 & 235; Goode, 1988, p. 87
.(
J ,X !
) !
07 9 ! + _#
&;B9 W0&
^ ! 9 .1 S /
! E GD
/
) 2
Griffiths v. Yorkshire
Bank…; McCormack, 2002, p. 393
.(
J a7
+ ,>\!
(
! I;GJ7 S / 1
9 C &# ,X ! 7
0; s ( + 07
! + 2 ) V ,G+ @
&;B9
$
! 9 .1
&;B9
$ S0\! 9 .1
W0&'
9 2
w&
, e
&;B9
$
! S0\! 9 .1
&;B9
$ 9 .1 );6;
+ W0& _#
&;B9 5 ; X + 1
$
= S0\! 9 .1
&;B9
$ ƒ 1 9 ( + …P# X S ! L9
(01 w&
v " ' , ,6Y! F' 1
&;B9
$ 01 ! *Y7
) Re Benjamin…; Re Automatic
Bottle Makers…; Bourne, 1998, pp. 232-233
.(
3 .
# , E =
:) HI = C F
2 (9
$
+ 0' ,
c1 H
&;B9
$ ,7 ' V = 9 .1
&;B9 +
$ 9 .1
! 2 )Q-' V(067 GD ' G;29
$ 1 u;= QDG@
) Evans v. Rival…; McCormack,
2002, p. 403
V(
0' _G@ 9 E , L ' ) ( -1
,' 'E + 1 8
u;=
2 , >= QDG@
.
u;= Q/0! , L #
1 9 , ^ R ;G-?
c;
GD
)
&;B9
$
! 9 .1 V02
, >= QDG@
! 07 8
&;B9
$ ,' W0& _# 9 .1
) 0.!
Re
Opera…;Norton v. Yates…; Goulding, 1999, p. 332; Bourne, 1999, p. 233; Wood, .1989, p.
208
x(
) ;•
VR e 07
8
&;B9
$
! 0/ X W0&' , >= QDG@ ! 9 .1
) Ontario
Development…; McCormack, 2002, p. 393
.(
4 .
# , E =
8 04 = )
;P 9 + 1 + , e
1
! 9 );;\ (0..+
&;B9 ; ) S /
-' V0! GD 9 .1
) Schedule 6 the Categories of Preferential Debts, Section 386
Insolvency Act 1986
!(
&;B9
$ 0. */ W0&' 9 .1
) Insolvency Act 1986, ss. 40 & 175
x(
! )
, + ,.\'
E V01 D7 , + -' W - X S ! &;B9 90!
, /
L -6'
&;B9
$ 01 0./ X X 9 .1
) Bourne, 1998, p. 223
.(
3 .
# :
$ K*)LM = C
N O = *N) N *P 8
&;B9 b7 F;GH S !
$
;' ' & 9 C &# 9 .1 ,! V E U m Q' 9
0 ! -
7 V ,7 D' † 2
;a7 S b7 C &# b.
&;B9
$
& V 07 ^9 9 .1
,-7 T;7 ;' '
, U , _;B Q' S !
. ) F# ( b. V) ! .!
&;B9 ,Ge e .? 9 + + 2
$ ,7 D' 9 .1 F;GH 9 T5 ;' ' & 9 C &#
1
! 0;2 a7 Fe , 2 .1 ! V b7 ) S ;.! e .? 9 + , 2 .1 _ @ .
)
&;B9 v " ' , ! U V9 )
*Y7 0.!
( V L ' ! G' \' Q' (0. E
) 0.!
W9 (
&;B9 v " ' ! ,% -^ <G? P+ V )
W 2 0.!
( V
, •D= W0?
' v "
&;B9 ) 0.!
W bf (
&;B9 ,1 7 );-> ! ,% - # 9
$ 9 .1 )
<5. 0.!
(
\;1 & 9 C &#
,2 ! ,' 1 .
3 . 1 .
!
"
> ? :) = ! K *Q
! S ^ ' L ' + , e
^ '
&;B9
$ 0! 9 ; = ,. X ! );-> 9 .1 Q/
! S J L ' + ) TJ ^ 9 &;B9 L -1 E om# T;7 9 L ' E L & 7 ; X E S ^
) + V01 ! 1 V
&;B9 , l , h 9
$ F 0D ! ,& );.f V 2 U , 9 9 .1
-/ V 2 €;He &;B9 v " ' L '
+ @
' 8 784 2 ( + &' ,70' 7 = :
» F 0D
2 T ^ ); @ ," ! J L ' ! )/
«.
! R D?
,' 0&? ); @ V J
_ 0.7
! &;B9 v " ' L ' 01 ! 5' Q/0! + 0..+
( P 2 S ? @ 0.+
! 9 0/ L & 7 9
+ ,% ' / 9 i X &;B9 L -1 L ' E VL & 7
! ! Q/0! ;QG' ! E
,' ,' F; H (0. E 0 E E FH' 9 01 ! &;B9 v " ' V 1
V G@
1 L e9 .
_ @ ! ' , ;;k 9 &;B9 v " ' , ! G' \' 0' S E V 5; 7 ,' ,1 7 ); @
07 ^9 E He S0 + 1
.
3 . 2 .
# !
"
5 )6 3 ! + = C
E &\7 W J./ ,= &# F-? v " ' + ^9 ,& ' C &# 9 ;' ' &
,' 5 (0. E 9 *;7 ^ ' 1
x .f V 2 );? 3 .' + ( ^ 0&? v " ' +
( ^ R0' S .B 9 ' L @
!
,' ^9
0 E 07 S0 E He T;7 ,*+ 9
) VS T , D@ D@
1421 V t 53 VS ;1 W Q' x 1425
t V 16 V + x 1387
t V 277 x VS 9 J.% S P\^
2537 V
t 1082
.(
V);.n-/
! ! ,70' 7 = )
' 8 842 (
;' ' b;& a7 9 V
,% ' ! D*7 2 )Q-'
! (0. E +
,' ^9
;e9 V0 E 1
) V,P57 1404 i V 28 t V 278 V,+ + ,G' ? x 1414
i V 10 t V 99 x
G# ']?
V, 1420 t V 338 ,7 H! x V 1405 V t 417 x VˆG' ? ˆ.;*#
1419 i V 23 t V 261
.(
G' \' Q' '
$ L '
! (0. E .?
0? = 8 ,' -?
' FH 2 0 x
! S @ +
c; He
R[ H' U9
^9 S0^ 0 9 a7 o] X S 6! R ? . ' 9 S 9 6+
) . y . VS 20.+ ,7 D\1 1392
V
t 120 - 82
G' \' v 7 / V E , # 9 W90\' L ' 3;! ;' ' S b& S ;*! 9(
D*7 S
!
^ ' ;• L '
*7 F@ ! 07
) V,P57 1404 i V 24 t V 56 V‰ T ˆ D@ D@ x 1409
t V 745 V,• ' x 1417 V
t 213 V,= 7 x 1415 t V 362 V,G' ? ,.;*# x 1419
i V 18 t V 83 i 9 22 t V 130 V,G# ']? x 1420
t V 277 9 297 x
V,+ + ,G' ? 1414
i V 9 t V 145 V,7 H! x 1405 t V 189
.(
C &# S ;*! T;7 ' C &#
,Q 7
-? w 1
S / = ,'
! z 7 0&? v " ' L ' ^9 E <Q# );\' );?
( -1 ! = &\7 W J./
07
)
V +
1388 t V 182 VS0;b1 x 1388 t V 308 VS 9 J.% S P\^ x 2537
V
t 564
, # 9(
P ,X ! V07
, ]' \' +
' v "
V 2 );\' );? )/
! 0 7 / ' );?
? ' ,-7 (0. E L ' 9 01 ! ^ ' 0&
)/ ! 1
)
V +
1388 t V 184 VS0;b1 x 1388 V
t 309
.(
<b'
! ^ ' R 9 " S ! + ,G;% ) '
v "
Š (0. E L ' 3;! ]4! 9 G' \'
V(01 ' 8 361 ,70' 7 =
) V,' ' 1385 t V 221 9 431 VS0;b1 x 1388 t V 308 - 309
' :;G- 3.' 9 (
L
2 ^ ' ;•
) V,P57 1404 i V 24 t V 211 V,+ + ,G' ? x 1414
i V 9 t V 145 V,• ' x 1417 t V 211 V,P57 x
1422 t V 217 V Q-/ 9 ' _&H' x 1389
t V 405
x(
! 0.f / ,' a7
);.f ]4! ,Ge F;% 02
G' \' 01 ! E ) *7 S • S
) V,= 7 1417 t V 94 V,P57 x 1404 i V 24 t V 56 9 77
@ x V,-= , D@ D 1426
V
t 245 x VS T , D@ D@
1409 t V 746 V,' ' x 1385 t V 417
.(
!
^9 F [ ! . 2 V) c;
P G' \' v 7 / ]4! S ! F! = (0. E L ' ! D*7 S
! 10X ,' a7 / z V02 '
8 361 C . W . ,' ! );.f
! z 7 ( ' ) <Q# + 0 E
+ 2 ,"
F' 1 9 01 ! ^ ' L ' ! D*7 G' \' ! ); @ S .!
, /0 29 +
' v "
! (0. E G' \'
,' ^9
,-7 V0 E 1 x
! 7 = Q7E (h 9
,2 2 w 1 m
! ƒ ! ' '
v "
V G' \'
! ,.D' ,} 0# T;7 , 9 3! .' 9 *7 07 ƒ 1 ! ^ '
D*7 G' \' ]4!
! ^ ' ;• L ' ! .?
0? = 8 07 ^9 ,G+
.
9T
! ) ,' 67 W90\' ' ! ;Q% ' _G\ 3.' V ]Š = + 0/
:;G- V a7 ) !
1 0. 0&? R l S > &' S 07
x ,% # E R l S > &' 0&? );# ;QG' L & 7 +
Xs 9 0&? _;G\ G-^ VS ' QG! V *;7
;Q% ' L & 7 ; V
2 )Q-'
;'
Ge ;Q% ' L & 7 9 0&? &\7
;!
0.
. G' \'
$
<G2 9 ,G+
T;7
;Q% ' L & 7 ;Xs
2 )19 .
</ Z '9T% ;Q% ' L & 7 V,Q;G- &? V 5; 7
R e = F;Q6 ! '
,-7
; . 0&? &\7 I T;7 (0. E L ' X ;Q% ' V = v " ' 5 ! 9
! X
,' F& .' 1
x T;7 ,Q;G- &? R l S > &' ! 9 2 ); @ 2 X _ ' + S '
07 , k' .
,' (0. E L ' :;G- D2 0&? V3= 9 _G\ W90\' ! ;QG' Q. 7 V 1
; .
! R D?
,' F& .' ,7 ' ;Q% ' V J
+ 1
' v "
2 ^ ' =
. ,X !
( + € (0. E L ' 5 0\! ;Q% ' 5 ! T;7 ;' ' S b&
07
) V,P57 1404 i V 28 V
t 364
.(
t X
• W bP' t X + P 0 ! T;7 (0. E L ' U9 ! S •
;'
^9 a7 o] X ;' ' S b&
.
• 7E ,X !
*7 4X S .\' ! 07
x ( X
o e9 I.^ 0&' ! Fb^ 4X s6.' '
v "
,1 7 01 ! G' \' ) 1 07
! R 0=
.;-@ 9 3;D' <;G*
) 1 07 (0. E 3;D' 5 !
) V,= 7 1417 t V 322 VˆG' ? ˆ.;*# x 1419
V
i 19 t V 327 V,• ' x 1417 t V 314
.(
,>\!
*' S • 3;!
,' L b5' 3;! ! S9 0.7
)
‰ 2 '
V‰ .5!
1419 t V 148
9(
,/9 070& \'
• &' V
% b^ 6 + 2 S 4X .
2 .? 9 S • V( 0 )
x 4X S J 9 Fb^ ,Q V
2 )Q-' T;7 4X 9
? o e9 ! Fb^ ,1 7 01 ! );" ? ,Q ^9 ! Fb^ ,1 7
! R 0= );"
E <;G*
) V,P57 1404 i V 22 t V 388 V,= 7 x 1422 t V 30
.(
/ G' \' _ ' ,X ! ^9 VL #
c; F;D= V(0. E L ' ! (07 U9 -;-" ! 3;! 9 S 9 6+ R[ H' U9
-2E
) . y . VS 20.+ ,7 D\1 1392
t V 86 9 134 0\! !
,' 67 (
^9 + 0/
,Gb^ 4X 7 /
,-7 G' \' ]4! D2 ,' • QG! V 1
QGb' ! 9 01 ! ;}+ * !
;!
0.
x
-/
2 (0'E • S k% S .\' + 7 .
( + € T;7 b& ,X ! + 07
7 /
! 9 S • VS 4X G' \' / 9 01 0/ Y7 G' \' 01 S • D2 G' \' S 4X F@
]&? 9 o ? 9 01 D7 H' *' F! = Z ? + 2 S 4X V • &' QG! x *;7 E
0..+ # x
,! E F! &' 9 0.7 0! T;f 7 ]&? 9 o ? + S 4X 7 9
• V0.1 ! 9
(067 g *H' V
! 0/ Y7 0&? He ! FY'
) V,• ' 1417 t V 314 V,. 9T= | 2 ' x 1424
t V 872
.(
)
! V9 ,' a7 02 9 ,! ; 2 L - # + 2 S • , e (0. E L ' ! G' \'
01 ! u;\" 3;D' L # x
! o ? + S @ 9
]&?
S E \' ^ T;/
( / ,%9 V0..+
5 )z '
v "
1 i X L - # 9 Y! % # + 01 ! S 0= ! (0. E G' \'
9 +]/ % # 9
! V01 ! 1 07 0 01 :*
7 G' \' );.f \' ^ 0.' X + S S
! 9 0.7 0! , ]&?
E
*7 €;He E 0 ! V07 9 R D'
) VS 20.+ ,7 D\1 1392
t V 134 -
140
.(
3 . 3 .
# 1 !
"
R I # /
> ?
)/ ;\"9 •D= c&7 t X 0.f /
;' b&
^9 a7 o] X ;' ' S
) . y . VS 20.+ ,7 D\1 1392
t V 141 - 153
( = )/ He ƒ 1 •D= ,70' 7 = ,%9 V(
2 .
!
^9 V) W a7 ,7 .+ ;\"9 9 ,= &# F;GH q;#
V,70' 7 = D7 ƒ 1
, •D=
&;B9
$
! 9 .1
,' ;^ R e )
b7 ) + 1
! ,e X ,
,-7 ( &;B9
( QDG@ •D= ! , E 1
1 QG! V07 -! ,= ! 9 o 9
2 ,' ( &;B9 ! , S
S ? ^ , 2 E L -6' , + 1
R 5
!
@
,' ;;k '
0!
.
<*= ) + 2 ,\;D@ V) ! .!
&;B9 V
•D=
ƒ 1
01 D7 0&? He x
! V GD ' Q7E (h 9 07
8
&;B9 _# ,.;\' 9 ‚Y6' L ' ! &;B9
F 0D 9 GD ' QG! V 07
&;B9
$
! 9 .1
&;B9
$ L ' ! QDG@ + 2 ! B
,' ,.;? _# , Y6' 9 0!
E .' &;B9 v " ' , L & 7 Q/0! VI ,' 3
1 .
3 . 4 .
# $G ! "
! :' 47 9 / ) %S > ?
&;B9 b7 f
$
! &;B9 v " ' , 9 .1
! ' ) ' V *;7 ‚Y6' F' + @
,-7 ,GGX 0&? He
! W G\' 9 2 ,H' *' &? &;B9 )/ 0&? V07 2
W [ R b^ 3;-^ &;B9 v " ' L '
*;7
) V,P57 1404 i V 25 t V 141 VS 9 J.% S P\^ x 1382
V
t 208 - 209 VS 9 J.% S P\^ x 1386
t V 48 ( x V:;
1387 t V 144
,' P+ E ! ,% -^ <G? 9 (
0.+
.
! V 5; 7 S E u 7 , W - ( / VL }'
! /
^ '
&;B9
$ V0 E &;B9 H 9 .1
= &;B9 v " ' L ' + 57E ‚Y6' Q/0! , F+ &' ' 9 07 );;\ ;G!
,' );;\ E | 2 ! T;7 &;B9 v " ' 9 2 E He ! <Q# 0 ! V 1
.
3 . 5 . 9< M ! "
8 : U 4H, = ! :' 40
&;B9 ! + S
$
^ ' , L & 7 ; X + 2 ) V(01 9 9 .1
&;B9 u;\>
$
,' 9 .1
) 1
Gullifer, 2008, p. 402
) 9 (
v " ' );-> 01 ,% - # ! 2 )Q-'
,1 7
&;B9
$ 9 .1 5.' .
! 9 *;7 _G4' ; X ) + 1 ^ 0 ! ' G;29
$
,' 90H' R 5 S ? ^ F-?
1 .
! 07 Q7E (h 9 8
,' &;B9 ' E 07
GD
;J! , L & 7 S G^ _ @ ) 9 2 .
9T
! 9 ) ! + S & 7 V)
! ,' a7 + 2 ) V02
&;B9
$ , &;B9 S ! X \;D@ | 2 ! 9 .1
( P 2 U 2 (01
,' ; X QDG@ ! 9
! c X R 5 S ? ^ 0/
,
0/ ' X R 5 9 0 -7 G' \' &;B9 v " ' x
,% #
| 2 ! +
c;
V P 0/ X jG S9 R 5 V01 ! 1 07 X U , L & 7 ; X + 1
01 . _# 3-^ + 2 ) ! b7 ) U] W -
&;B9
$ 07 8
;% \ _# 9 &;B9
! Q/0!
1 );'s 9 / 3 .' + ; R e S H7 .
,\;29 cY! ! &;B9 L -1
! &;B9 v " ' , ! G' \' ; X 9 Q/0! , c; , 0/ );.f _&H a.'
,.;!
2 (01 .
! (9]?
V
&;B9
$ 9 .1 P 2 8
</
' J ,-7 3.' &;B9 _# W *=
0.+
x
! ,.\' )
G@ +
; X QD
&;B9
$
! B 0 -7 mX V 2 F ' + Q/0! L ' : / S9
.
,%9 F+ X ! 07 7 9 01 D7 9 ,/0! T;' ! 2 )Q-' S9 ! B , + 57E
&;B9 b7 &;B9 90! ,/0! X ! S ! V0.+ );-> S9 ,/0!
$ ( P 2 9 .1
,' 1 x
! , S ;*! S9 QDG@ + 2 o \ ' I;GJ7 C &# + S @
&;B9 Q/0!
$ ( + mX ! B ,= ! , W - S9 9
&;B9 S9 (07 '
$ ,' 0&\.' 9 .1 0..+
) Gullifer, 2008, p. 403
.(
<+ V) ! .!
&;B9 €42 )
$ W - ' X 9 ,.;!0! ! 9 9 .1
7 ) ! D*7
&;B9 ( P 2 V b
$ + 2 ) b! U , _;B S ! 9 .1
X G@ ,6Y! X ! S ! b. QDG@
&;B9
$ S ! ,%9 V01 ! 1 ; X ! B
(0-? cY! 2 )Q-' + J -*=
W 9 , S ,.;-> d;/ V0/ F;Q6 (0./
01 ! 1 07 ^9 .
S QDG@ -# S ! + , / Q/ D%
&;B9
$ b7 ) 9 .1
c;
(01 ,.;!
2 L -1 F;D= V 2
$ _# 9 E ) X 2 GD ' Q' 9 &;B9 v " ' ,
W0&
+ , /
&;B9
$
! 9 .1
,' 2
+ + ! D*7 ,G= 0# U J7 ) V 9E
&;B9
$ 9 .1
,' o0/ 9 0.+
! ) X S ! .;-@ 9 );->
,' </ ,! X 9E
.
4 .
< 0 X .1 _ @ U , _;B + ! ) ! ,\2 V % &' ) b7 e .? 9 W bP'
&;B9
$
<b' 9 1 ,2 ! I;GJ7 C &# 9 .1 );;D E BE 9 W Q# )
. 5; 7
$
! (0'E 2 )
L -1 \29 f , / Q/ ! 2 (01 ,\2 b7 ) + ! 2
$
V E S ^ 9 &;B9 ) X 2 GD ' Q' 9 (0. E 9 ^ ' <? V &;B9 v " ' , 07 8 1 -# 9 .1 &;B9 .
!
</ ( P 2 Q7E (h 9 '
&;B9
$ S ! 9 .1 9 ! B
07 8 Q' E m
! 9 2 (07 V ; )
&;B9
$ ,' 9 .1 07
9T L ' Q. !
! 0' ! B
S
&;B9 .? ! c X G@ );->
$ V01 ! 1 ; X ! B
T;7 Q/0! (0. E 9 U L '
! .?
&;B9
$ V 5; 7 9 ; &;B9 ! 9 .1
S9 G@ W - X !
);->
.
! T^
) 0' + T' ) Q/0! S ! V
^ &;B9 v " ' , ! 07 ! 9 01 ! 1 ; X U X , L .+ 9 ) 9 0.+ G' \' c X R 5 S ? (
' ) + D! , W 9 ( P 2 }+ 0#
, T*! <b2
\2
$ ) 2 1 ,= &# I;2s .
b7 ,Ge o e9 9 e .? F;GH !
&;B9
$
;' ' & 9 C &# 9 .1 V
) !
,' ,1 7 ); @ _ &;B9 v " ' , L & 7 ; X + < 0;2 5; 7
S0 + 1
*;7 E He .
Q. J
C &# 9 b& b6' a7 o]X !
^9 V 7 '
v "
G' \' W J./
V01 D7 • ! ,. D' + , e (0. E L ' ! G' \' 9 07 R 9 " 0&?
2 €;He .
! 0/ X €;He ; );-/ ! T;7 (0. E L ' _;B V 5; 7 .
! V);.n-/
,' P+ E 0&' 9 o e9 9 / ' L ' ! ,% -^ <G? V &;B9 0&? ! ,H' *' F;%
0.+
9 ) 2 );;\ V9
$
! <Q# S ! V01 ! 1 );;\ ;G! = + &;B9 v " ' ,
! 0/ X , + &;B9 He .
9T
! ,\-^ a7 ;\D ! ,70' 7 = 0.f / V)
V ;' ' b;&
,' ! );.f E 9 2 ( = )/ He ƒ 1 •D=
U m + 0 E
b7 B9
&;
$ 9 9 .1 Q' ' ,7 .+ C &# _D@ U , _;B
! V *;7 m )
-/
V
+ 57E
&;B9
$ ,-7 ( &;B9 ! , Y6' L ' 9 .1 2 QG! V 1
v " ' , S
,' = &;B9 ,' );;\ (0. E E C 0 ' 9 ;
' &;B9 v " ' •D= 0 D7 V 1
0&?
= E He w 1 .
9 ,= &# W a7 ! , k' U , _;B V 5; 7
07 ' ,b& ,7 D' .
! ) L # V ,' b.6;
BE 9 W Q# V3' ^ ,7 7 = 9 ;b ! 1
);;\ = ! b7 ) QDG@ _;= );;\ 9 &;B9 90! QDG@ -# ! 9
-' V , >= $ 9 b7 ) S ^ Q'
!
</ ,! X E
9 .
V!
LWX
&' ( :1 O
1 . )*#0;2 V,' ' )
1385 (.
,70' C &#
. 6 i V0G^
1 b V<61 9 *;! ‹ f V :
;']2 .
2 . P\^0-H' VS 9 J.% S P\^
) 2537 (.
( R 5 9 ,70' C &# o \-%
. i 1
‹ f V ,! VL9
^ : S E F\6' .
3 . k\^0-H' VS 9 J.% S P\^
) 1386 (.
( Š C &# ,' -? o \-%
. VC P%
i 3 b VL9 V : c7 j.
.
4 . k\^0-H' VS 9 J.% S P\^
) 1382 (.
C &# <G? ,G? P*G .
b VL9 ‹ f :
c7 j. 7 Y! + .
5 . ( )*# V:;
) 1387 (.
,70' C &#
: );\' &?
) 2 (.
b VL9 ‹ f :
S0.2 X .
6 . )*# 9 ,G\']• Vg . ,P;2 ( .' V(
) 1388 (.
» C &# 9 & v . 2
«.
$G5' V,= &# R &;&H U
50 t V
161 - 217 .
7 . S / VS 20.Œ+ ,7 D\1 )
1392 (.
$&;B9 C &# ,7 D' E F;GH 9 I;GJ7 C &# 9 .1
;' ' & 9 . ' 7
S R '0X 9 , >= W G? ( J67 V01 ,2 .1 + .
8 . S0b' VS0;b1 )
1388 (.
i V,70' C &#
1 : R 0b\ 9 / = F;Q6 .
b V< P/ ‹ f :
05' .
9 .
e 7 V +
) 1388 (.
/ = ,' -? 0? = .
i 2 :
= D ? 9 &\7 -
7 a
$ Vl P7 W0? 9 ]4!
b VL9 ‹ f :
6 7 ,' b2 + 1 .
10 .
e 7 V +
) 1387 (.
,70' C &#
: );\' &?
. i 1 :
• \' R]' \' -
V,Q;G- &?
b V</ ‹ f :
,' b2 + 1
6 7 .
11 . ,P4 ' 0;2 V ' _&H' Q-/ 9
) 1389 (.
;' ' & / = C &#
. i 2
<= VL9 ‹ f V :
HD2 .
- ( :!*/
1 . u2 V,7 H!
) 1405 (.
( z .% _Š 0H%
. 25 i V0G^
22
<= VL9 ‹ f V :
,']2 R 6 7 .
2 .
^ 0;2 VˆG' ? ˆ.;*#
) 1419 (.
$' Q% Ž P' .
23 i V0G^
13 V 18 V 19 9 23
<= VL9 V : ˆ']2 R 6 7 .
3 . ˆ•G#
) ']?
( V u2 )! )*#
) 1420 (.
;? 6% W Q#[ H .
6 i V0G^
3
<= VL9 ‹ f V :
C e W ' *2•' )
v .(
4 . ˆ& 0;2 V,-= ˆ D@ D@
) 1426 (.
);H% % i b.' ,7 D' .
10 i V0G^
8
<= VL9 ‹ f V :
C 6% <G= R 6.' .
5 .
@ D@
<z +0-H'0;2 VS T , D )
1421 (.
2 Q-% ;1 # .
2 i V0G^
1
<= VW9 ‹ f V :
;G;? -2 *2•' .
6 .
<z +0-H'0;2 VS T , D@ D@
) 1409 (.
(9 ? ,&B % . 2 i V0G^
2 R9 ;! VW9 V :
R ? D4-G% ,-G?‘ $*2•' .
7 . ,G? V,+ + ,G' ? );*# )!
) 1414 (.
0e &-% 3' ^ .
13 i V0G^
9 9 10
<= VW9 ‹ f V :
;D% LE *2•' )
v .(
8 . Ž P% 0D? Vˆ• ' )
1417 (.
$;b&P% ) 9 .\%
. 2 i V0G^
2
<= VL9 ‹ f V :
ˆ']2 R 6 7 .
9 . e 7 VS ;1 W Q' )
1425 (.
/ &P% 7’
: 3;D% g + .
<= VL9 ‹ f V0G^ : :
,G? W '“ 2 0' )!
,!’
% @ ) v .(
10 . )*# 0;2 VS .5! S 2 ' )
1419 (.
0? &%
;b&P%
. 7 i V0G^
4 V 6 9 7
<= VL9 ‹ f V :
S b% 67 .
11 . ˆG?0;2 Vˆ. 9T= ‰ 2 ' )
1424 (.
W Q#‘ 3;! . .
i 2
<= VL9 ‹ f V :
ˆ']2 R 6 7 .
12 . )*#0-H' ;1 VˆP57 )
1404 (.
W]Q% / ^ .
i 22 V 24 V 25 9 28 R9 ;! V< P/ V :
,! \% ” % ~ ;#•
.
13 . ˆP57 )
~ 4k% u1 + (
)*# V )!
P\^
) 1422 (.
$/ &P% 7’
: 3;D% g + . u57 VL9 :
$*2•'
~ 4k% u1 + .
14 . 0-# ˆ% ' Vˆ= 7 )
1415 (.
$\;6% 0. *' .
19 i V0G^
14
<= VL9 ‹ f V :
$*2•' v ;D% LE .(
15 . 0-# ˆ% ' V,= 7 )
1417 (.
W ‘ 0Š ? . f V0G^ :
<= Vˆ']2 R k;GD VL9 ‹ .
16 . 0-H' ˆ% ' Vˆ= 7 0-# )!
) 1422 (.
W Q#‘ C 6' .
<= VW9 V0G^ : :
0-# ]' 9 ‰0b']' );;= 7 ( J.+
.
Y ( :7 W 1. Books and Articles
1.Armour, John, (2004), “The Chequered History of The Floating Charge”, Griffith L. Rev., Vol. 13, No. 1, p. 25-56.
2.Bourne, Nicholas, (1998), Principles of Company Law, 3rded.,London: Cavendish Publishing Limited.
3.Fairweather, Mark & Border, Rosy, (2004), Setting up Limited Company, 2nd ed., London: Cavendish Publishing Limited.
4.Ferran, Eilis, (1998), “Floating Charges - The Nature of the Security”, C.L.J. (The Cambridge Law Journal), Vol. 47, No. 2, p. 213-237.
5.Goode, R. M., (1998), Legal Problems of Credit and Security, 2nd ed., London: Sweet &
Maxwell.
6.Goulding, Simon, (1999), Company Law, 2nd ed., London: Canvendish Publishing Limited.
7.Gullifer, Louise, (2008), “The Reforms of the Enterprise Act 2002 and the Floating Charge”, Can. Bus. L.J. (Canadian Business Law Journal), Vol. 46, p. 399-429.
8.McCormack, Gerard, (2002), “The Floating Charge in England and Canada”, in: The Reform of United Kingdom Company Law, Chapter 16, Edited by Dr. John de Lacy, First published, London: Cavendish Publishing Limited, p. 389-414.
9.Pennington, Robert R., (1960), “The Genesis of The Floating Charge”, Mod. L. Rev. (The Modern Law Review), Vol. 23, p. 630-646.
10.Sealy, L. S., (1986), “Company Law - Floating Charge –Priorities”, C.L.J (The Cambridge Law Journal), Vol. 45, No. 1, 1986. P. 25-27.
11.Stamp, Mark, (2001), Private Company Law, 3re ed., London: Cavendish Published Limited.
12.Tajarloo, Reza, (2005),
AvoidanceofAntecedentTransactionsinEnglishCorporateInsolvencyLaw, UniversityofEssex.
13.Wood, Roderick J, (1989), “The Floating Charge in Canada”, Alta. L. Rev. (Alberta Law Review), Vol. 27, p. 191-225.
2. Cases
1. Agnew and Another v. Commissioner of Inland Revenue (Re Brumark Investments Ltd.)[2001] 2 A.C. 710.
2.Evans v. Rival Grantite Quarries Ltd. [1910] 2 K.B. 979.
3.Federated Cooperatives ltd. v. Blesse [1981] 3 W.W.R. 514.4.Gaskell v. Gosling [1896] 1 Q.B. 669.
5.Government Stocks and Other Securities Investment Co. Ltd. v. Manila Rly. C0. [1897] A.C.
6.Griffiths v. Yorkshire Bank plc. [1994] 1 W.L.R. 1427 81.
7.Hubbuckv. Helms [1887] 56 L.J. Ch. 536.
8.Illingworth v. Houldsworth [1904] A.C. 355.
9.Landall Holdings v. Caratti [1979] W.A.R. 97.
10.National Westminster bank plc. v. Spectrum Plus Ltd. [2005] U.K.H.L. 41.
11.Norton v. Yates [1906] 1 K.B. 112 &2 K.B. 746.
12.Ontario Development Corp. v. Trustee of the Estate of I.C. SuatacConstraction Ltd. [1976]
69 D.L.R. 353.
13.R. v. F.B.D.B. [1987] 43 D.L.R. 188.
14.Re Automatic Bottle Makers Ltd. [1926] Ch. 412.
15.Re Benjamin Cope v. Sons Ltd. [1914] 1 Ch. 800.
16.Re Bond Worth Ltd. (1979) 3 All. E.R. 919 & [1980] Ch. 228.
17.Re Borax Co. [1901] 1 Ch. 326.
18.Re Borax Co., Foster v. Borax Co. [1899] 2 Ch. 130.
19.Re Brightlife Ltd. [1986] Ch. 200 & [1987] 2 W.L.R. 197.
20.Re Crompton & Co. Ltd., Player v. Crompton & Co. Ltd. [1914] 1 Ch. 954.
21.Re Florence Land & Public Works Co. [1878] 10 Ch.D. 530.
22.Re Hayman, Christy & Lilly Ltd. [1917] 1 Ch. 283.
23.Re Hillstead Ltd. [1980] 103 D.L.R. 347
24.Re Household Products Co. Ltd. [1981] 124 D.L.R. 325.
25.Re Ind, Coope& Co. Ltd. [1911] 2 Ch. 223.
26.Re Keenan Bros Ltd. [1986] B.C.L.C. 242.
27.Re Matthew Ellis Ltd. [1933] 11 Ch. 458.
28.Re Mobile Electric Ltd. (1979) 29 C.B.R. 204.
29.Re Opera Ltd. [1891] 3 Ch. 260.
30.Re Orleans Motor Co. Ltd. [1911] 2 Ch. 41.
31.Re Panama, New zealan and Australia Royal Mail Co.[1870] 5 Ch. App. 318.
32.Re Permanent House (Holdings) Ltd. [1988] B.C.L.C. 563.
33.Re Real Meat Co. Ltd. [1996] B.C.L.C. 254.
34.Re Woodroffes (Musical Instruments) Ltd. [1986] Ch. 366.
35.Re Yorkshire Woolcomers Association Ltd. [1903] 2 Ch. 284.
36.Robinson v. Smith [1895] 2 Ch. 118.
37.Royal Bank of Canada v. Sparrow Electric Corp. [1997] 143 D.L.R. 385.
38.Savin Canada Inc. v. Protech Office Electronics Ltd. [1984] 8 D.L.R. 225.
39.Siebe Gorman & Co. Ltd. v. Barclays Bank Ltd. [1979] 2 Lloyd’s Rep. 142.
40.Smith v. Bridgend County Borough Council [2002] 1 A.C. 336.
41.Taylor v. M’Keand [1880] 5 C.P.D. 358.
42.Ward v. Royal Exchange Shipping Co. Ltd. [1888] 58 L.T. 174.
43.Wheatly v. Silkstone & High Moor Coal Co. [1885] 29 Ch.D. 715.
44.William Gaskell Group Ltd. v. Highley [1994] 1 B.C.L.C. 197.