#/&DM (,N=<2CO
0 12&&'
P..Q=-#
<))J).
5,
∗
I &GJ !"
) ',*%+*%
- . . /0 1 2*+*%
- .7 . / 4
3a
1"
I"%-M1W%PI8<6 ',3
\<*
r '&
w<S+%#S,$%S$<S=t%3 S&S-6
7
>
'"$'M ,Y1
"
7P9"
<6'0
<"
"
D6W%P%
$ + 1%S,*
Y
%S "%%
+U8"%I<M"
>
CQ%+1
@
% "D T
$86DP *,
;",O : 7 1'S=S6*
TR$<
\<*D
<&%^0
%M"
f6%
"
\-"17+8 R$0<$
"
78S2SQ"SS,<=*j
"
17"6IM"6
<
"
1 Y 7<=
e
"
Q '
*j
$ 4"L6IM%<, S
S$'S=OSCY1
"
+8
\-"17
\S-"I, "%'%0<$<0<$
<0<S$
m0<S$
'S%
"
% D# S Y
7;
] C
\-"17+8$
O*S&LS)1#TW%PI8<&%T<$
78S2S6oS.7S2&%Y
%
,
"0 7;^
>
% '8
%% "%$
IS,6%01SS'S3E 8'Q","T<"H9r"
'"(&
<=,
>
#<1b7
3
T%% "
;"
: TR$<1'=7 D6W%P
>
-A< ∗ i
7s&0077.D0s Email: Futur1359@yahoo.com
!"#"$%
&'(&
)*+
&,/
-
&32
;5
-H=6N
DE
"3N (*
&K
^8"$S/;(*C5 .77l
11#[
|
% W-Q
%
^ .77s
$-J"#,#9zS-(=#[
1 -; 8$C $V*6+*
@
1CM1J1#
H 1J))
-F '
;#h#$S%,K(*C5A- }
(1M/1#+8161,AU
,nV
$8,Z-W/,F,J
@ G1;,"C86,
.-
H YV,U
"1W-Q #U G60
' 1,A1-A-1C
,KYV }
-",G;,"C86 )8/ $%(V-
18"
o111 111 111%g111p(111*A111-B
K A6111%111#111e111#
) Huber and Illmer, 2007, p32
$8,U#K(
@ ,
"C86 1, G1;
1- H
1. Rome II Regulations 2. Lex Loci Damni 3. Specific Conflict Rules
B' 1J#
M1J1#K(1*o1 1W 1
"1,G1;18 1-
11:1X+
"11 11I11"11,G11;11,$11U-1191111#g#11 11115
-11K"11
$11115-(11/ $11%11p11j11811,n11V(11M/
11F K
^11CG11#,11,
(?
"
i
&
' 1-"1,G;, 1#18I)181SI1#h1K1pd1,11#1-
%#%p '
. ' A-L
"11%G1Q; I)1818181,K(1=
K )181SI1#h1
%#%p#8I '
0 ' A11-11L 11#h11K11%g11,11pI11811811,K(11=
I)11811SI
%#%p#8 '
1#1V1FK(=
K$1(1=
$1C 1 d11C$-)181-)18Ia1
%AU 8 K
11 Z1-1#W1J1#
K 41 1-C$1#
K +1"1,G1;181,
#V+86,V '
19111#^1C1#K1CA1-1#
@ 1,"1C861,
Z-M
# H
"/y$U? $ MS^C / $%
M
"#
'
5.(<1&CX8V U
F 2
!!!
;6
+KI#8(r8"J ,A-
}
#U G6
$C%
' 1?/
K K1
#A-
,
"1,G1;18,"C868"U G6
- - K ph%#
|
"ASC%d%K8I#)8$C K
(=
5#pd,G;-)8GQ; G;,"C86#Kh%A-*;
'
-#g, ph%"<F
|
#K)8$C S?%#J
| F$J }
g1- K 1#
G=64 h%K5-
%
$11#18"1 1C,1F
I^#(*o J
1C8
^1C1T6[1#"1#
nh? G
#A-U##
' (Dickinson, 2008, p38)
$-,-U/b 8"A--MS-I
^19: 8C
"1,G1;1,KA1X1"1,1M1JK%tb8I%NF - WP,#-
%-MF#
11-A,^C#"=F
"
' (Symeonides, 2008, p1301) 1S-I*68$/6
K K(1*1
#
",G;,I!8+JU G6,$/X -
1-
$, F '
G; A-#
K
$
$- 8"<F (1M/1< 1#W-,r8
1,
/ $%
:Q",G;8,K)8 8
$+86%-98 1%
'
K5- -8"8",G;T
I-
"S 1-%+-
I+
"M8C
-?
I
"S#
F -$/C6", -
#
"F?%-d, '
"AC#
K (*A-*(*AUp
$-1C6L$?8K
KQ, C
"
I##"#,
"
"- Io-
"$U1=
K
"
"1-C6
:Q )8F8
"
G161,$-1C6?#
1U 1-h1? 1A1-
$ -C ' -",G;,KIW689
-
"1-C6#,A-#
:Q
#8
$v6 -I
(Grazino, 2007, p487)
A1F1="J#8S-
37
-H=6N
DE
"
$pU "/
"
&
[8WStb$-J$U 1%Z-MZ
QV%#
"/
1U G161,818AU .
"11J[180
'
(De Boer, 2007, p21)
$M-$V*6 1/I
"1F '
^S1%1
I$
"
$-1C
"
- 1?1 1
1F1V#
18"1
86 -G;,"C IJ -
#
"
'
!A-#
K GS1/;(1*#M$-C6$?G; #"P/*A-
$1Y1QV-$V*6dpA-#$r;?fzV +1
'
;#C,8"pWbA-8e
=
# :Q
"$F8 1#8
(=#)8/8/
?,:X+*
b11#g- V9Z-
I"#)8
%-V)8-
%WI9-b#
1 K
= F8/ IK(
K M/#
R1= K1,nV,(
$ F ' 5.(<1&CX8V FU
M-/N-3/FH&2
7P7- 9
%%S 9?-
| (*
:Q"-C6
$?$S-#8
"6[=,vP
",(M/
'
;
$K?A-G G1; 1#I
C+* $U,G;
8$;
,-S-G#*
Z-^?,
"-SU#
'
|G#O -",G;, -
:Q8"$, 1%#$-%II#8
K 1#
GC; #J C
}
$;A-##KSA-(V
$#
+816T
1. Conflict Justice 2. Material Justice
3. Principle of Functional Alloction
5.(<1&CX8V U
F 2
!!!
3
MS#b (V?J#
1-$**6#$,*6 1-
1-I18 ' AC1p
$QP%dG#,o-TSI K
18
$J1V$-)18^CU11j W1I19
$ ,8"IK%
1%+816$"/y#S '
A1-"1C86
:QK, }8
(V
$$JV,(?j"*-
1S-#J #
)CU - F- 4-V",G;
tX#
,
$ 6K-C 1#1,A-(
F*, {1 1#
1#$1;(1,1#
r816<1IF18
"
-"-C6"J$,
$F- 1%
' A1-1#
^16
^S1%
}1#
,A-$-8 o AU G6}
8%tb S-
"G#, i
^^S%
-",G;,^C -
b 1*,A-"C86S#"
p#
| -",G;8vU)8$C
$- 1#G,6Kh%A-%#
11T11;/
K
$11 1111
| 1111J$ 11-; 11#8N1111,^11C '
(De Boer, 2008, p21)
$^S%A-
<F
"
4 9
)=,A-$#
g1"1-C6T#
K:1U(1=1#8"$,"C86 F8/
G1#,1I1#
4
$I#M$b-%K"$#
:1Qg1?1 "J 18
-#",G;,"C86 F$#
' 8W A-#
K
"TK)
p
)8a
"
&
:Q",G;
1%1-1#$18$-)8CAaK8
$"-<8h%A-*; MIGraS#"
8 ' 191 K
A1-OP1
"jC 11J1T<
' (Rushworth and Scatt, 2008, p283&284) 1#K1j
-",G;,"6[=
)8GQ; M/8"K- 1pI:1Q1-
I$%
d,#, '
:Q"ASC 8
} 1-#^68$
- )8K"- K
^1$C,#
1 1#18)181C#1
1
| 1C
$p/MC8/
;119/ W;/#8-VK%
1. Marketing
38
-H=6N
DE
F ' A- (=
K I<K)8GQ; G;9 K
8K-#
:Q",G;L pK"8
| 8I?%$C
$1KfV)
$111 111-"111,G111;111,1118111F 111-
@ f111111, H
111%+81116 '
) Huber and Illmer, 2007, p42 (
^S%
p
| -",G;)8$C G1;A1-1,"6[=#-
"$8$/) '
"C, 1C181%M11-h1%Ko1 $-
$"F8/ "$6[
4-1V";1Q1V1#I
<1
-C ' 41 "1#,(1p"1(?h%A- 1p$1#
|
"1,G1;)18
- - ' A-##
K ,F8/
# 1p+L
| :1Q"1,G1;)18 18
1#
pS-#dA-<
#
| b -
^18n1V$MS
4 d,#I$#
"
#K 1-,,"C86$6 1-
1M-#
"- K 6#V",G;, -C+8
'
"<F-#M-A-
#h%A-9
%gpF8/ "-C6T
11#^116A11-11#K11(11*11#$11=QV F11-$11V#11T+11L
) Huber and Illmer, 2007, p45 K(
1#$1M1SA1-Y1QV1#$1/1
8/
JF '
#o [X
$1$#V
$1U<-eOP1%1181
:QCJ 8
h1%A-#G #",K
"6[1=1, 1#W1J1#
F S#4/9#
' 1(1?#
19K1 K
"1,G1;1,K1W16
-
#-*- A,-
-^6#
-
" <
1A1-K
"11C
"
' h%#SN/
"
4 "#, 1-"1,G;,A%$#
1#1-
/
"8
$ 181%#1-A1,"C11#"186,A-
?JI;)C6
"1 j1(V '
1- h1%A1-1#1-?K
$1
"%Q;
K I-#S#
$8":X"$6[
I
-C<
' C#9 F8/ ",G;,^
-^6#
- 8 K#
-
$$FJ <K8
%#
' - K -
$M- 41 G#,(?j#
$1#
5.(<1&CX8V U
F 2
!!!
39
p?
| 8/ #V",G;)8 }
1#11-JK1:X
"C1
V",G;,^C
@ 8/
H 18"- x
18/ 19 1A1-
-8V(S
$6 S
%
&'
# h%C#U G6,$?8 6Ko K G; A-!
"J8"U
#I F :Q"-C6"C
"F8 '
$11
C
=KA-$-JjI#
| A#
K1$1g1J$U(?$C/
-o-
$$ Ae
$8$5--C CjI
} 1A-$**6G;
-"
$$- #4-V#
S '
X7G#O
$
"/y#+86,AU , 1T)18/ $%
"-(<
'
U G6aA-K :1Q"1-C6
F18
$$#-
"1U,1#J %
115 (?11J1 A1-A1e
$#$-
' 1-1#1V{1#K1 1-; 18KSI^
8= CK8 }
8/ $U=()Q;
} 1V1/1
$
%#
' / W/LU KA-##
1 1-; #$U=F8 G1#,L$-1#1
"S '
$-1 18r8$V*6K$,*6;/#KSI K
wb1
[8 1FK1 1-; *6K g1"1-C61*6A1 1#j11
:Q U 8#-*%%#F8 A1,KU1 ^16-
G8 JA-
'
^6 K G-eG-)##*A-#J # K
$ 1#1 1C/ 1%"<F
:QC g"-C6J#KU G6,A-gp 1 8KF8
&
'
(?8$
B 1W1/,1%5-C8 tX D
1#(1*
W-Q
"
""%#AC- '
3:
-H=6N
DE
API
$ 11-:^?#AX#K-F i
F18/ "1-C6
:QG#*$- :1Q"1-C6K$-1 LF8
G1#*$-1 F18
F8/
8/ G1#*$- F8/ "-C6"-$- L F1
(?f 8$U,:K$- L
` :Q"-C6 8
_
<
o1
I#G|
"F, '
;dpA-A?
} -",G;,"C86h?
1-
@ :1Q 18 H
"#
Q,
"8eG#,G-e(J G-)K8N i
B)
@ (CDEF!GH73I53(DF!G!)-JK(0 (1=1#L
$,h? A-8W/LK$*b
"8%KF
$-1 F- K
/ #
$11V11#1V11#K$U=()Q;F8 1%
IV8 :Q
<1jK 8M8$F8
U ^68 C%WI9)8A- K
:##
-J NF
1",K$- '
K1L$1VA1,^1CK{-1%A1-
O, K -",G;A,#8A-I8 F-
1?JM1J1
(VO,
$- F8/ "/y
$ '
119 K
U 8#
"1-C61#$181A1,KU ^6-
:Q
"gpF8 '
M
@ (CDEF!CG!)-IC53(CDF!GH73JK(0 1UL
%!SU-JA-8M 8$F8/
U ^6 1#1,
)8a
$$- #V 6K-C
:1Q"1,G1;,"C8 18
| 8"$CS;
IWJ#
:Q
$$- 8+*F8 1
:Q"-C64-VgJA,-M(C
%V#F8 '
,#"-C6A-(%
8"
K 1;#J # }
$1J"6[1=o1 1+1T
(*
:QF$6 8
} nV$- K
-1V1-##[r 4
5.(<1&CX8V U
F 2
!!!
3;
$-)8KJ8 GQ;
5I W1I19I1j-C<
6[=$U+#KF 1J"1,G1;$-1 181,^C"
8/ S-MJ
$- L}
184 )1Q;G1?,A1-a#
V",G;
@ :Q 8 }
$- H G£/
' 1A1-(1?j#
11#
} 1V
@ 8/
L}
-
$ H -M:=AC
"11#1 '
18"1$/16A1-
%F
$- 8$-JC,68$- L A1-$--GC;
$C%"
118A1-$1VA,n-MV##
$C?#
# A,#+9"-
#V 1p1#SI
|
I?%-)8A-$C V",G;
#(?j#
' (=A-{*89
8"
K --",G;,K(*o #J #
@
$-1 L8, H
K
-d,-)8GQ; G;,#VJ
@
$- 8, H
$ 1#
ASCW A-
"
K
# K$-rX
$-1 181A1,^C#
-#"-C6 -
$- L}
%#
'
N
@ (CDEF!G!)-I53(DF!G!)-JK(0 1#K#1o-1L
^11?
11V 115
| 11#$11 '
G11#*$-11 F118/ "11-C6
:11Q :11Q"11-C6$-11 LF118 F118/ 11##$-11 F118
$- L
$1"1J F18/ G1#*$-1 F18/ g1p1
-C"-* $- L '
Q,;/#K(U? A-KSI^
K
$#1, -#
"8%
1I$-1 L5 ?,G#*$-
"1 ' M14181#189
-MK-I$/C6"/y
| C#"##MC8 yG?,A-|
"/
1 F18/ 1#
%GC; $- C "C,#I/ )8"-
% 1#C8}
$$JV F
x
"115 ()1?1#+816$#,#bU#A- '
KSI :Q",G;,^C 8
g
$I LF18/ 181%
$-1
T$$#-#
"/y#+86 :QG#*4-V$/C6
F18
33
-H=6N
DE
$#%#%
% K -K$CFA-j)C6 1%G1C;$-1
' 1#
K^r 8/
} 1CJ$- 89- #[V()Q;8$-
$pC/I WK8
A1-Z1-1$/1C6(1=1#18$ 1LM1#
tb1K1%1V"V #?5K/ W$%-+ T#K8
"?,",$ <
K 1#Iq;9(Ub,vP9
1V18
"#
' -(?#
K /ywb(<
"
"<8(< #KT
K
dC5 K
$-)8p
^"<8#
$- $V#
F '
^6 K
$;119K- <K)8AC-V#$- %FF
,G;,^CK-I#(LNV^?#-F
"
- :Q+
1J #K8
N1V1A1-#$- A,"C86#K-6-)8GQ; G;#
}
8/
}
$$,WJ#$- 8%
K (1/ I^C8MC#
C/I88/ A-
$p
%
"$*b K
+8(/
p"<8 1%
}
- #
"$*bL '
89 K 1C8"<8- #(/ 9
"V#
K
#"<8^M A-
- $V#)8"C,48 C
$
%#
' -(?#
K 8/ F }
8)8$- +
1C8"1C,8p"<8
KCAU I#M 4 "J#A-
1#1518"$pU G6T$#
,"C86 +-[
$- F
' - [1K1A-$- ,^CK
aM8/ S?%##SI#
$1/ 4 $?, K1%
"/y$C56#
4 G#,L
$J$#
$-"C,jA-C88
"%)8 '
F8"$/6A- K
8/ J#
}
$1C/I18/ K$-1
*,8+-IT GS%AC#
(Q
#V 1#1C/I$V
%
$p :Q8
8 } T$- -V#8+-I
1C/I)18I
$WI9 41#1C/I18/ A1-$1-"1C,K)K{-1%A-K%
p"C, - %
"
"1J1#Kj (1/ 1h16r816^1C
5.(<1&CX8V U
F 2
!!!
34
$?%K$V aMM
8/ $?,
$1C5- 1F
' 1p1-#
1818
8/
$- }
A-
$CK
?-(U? A-$-#
G1#,Lh1%1#
4
#$#
1V"C1,nK+86, Ko1 1
191-C1
18 K
) K
41 G1#,Lh1%A-dp
"1)81pG1;1#$1#
K 1-V"1U# 1
:Q 8 } I$-
Kj S9 K%%
"
8 1-1#15)18A
:Q",G;
%p8 K
?%$-)8pS#
1#
"1-<8G1;IM1I
$ 8 '
$KW ##
,"<F 1/ W11#+86,AU $- NF
F4 $
$GS #=8%NF:[V#
h? $QP%- 1#
+86,AU
$ V 1o-1K1A- 1,A1-1J$1%
K15-K1?V#$CA-C8
1#
1C(1=
1?J[18 g1p1#
, --"
$IW-Q 8
"
U?
1T6[MI
1C ' (Symeonides, 2008, p33-34; 2007, p10; 2004, p109) 18"1$/16A1-
#Z-
|
%A-#6= C8-C/
1
:Q"-C6APJC
$F8 1%#
:1Q
1 18$F18
$-1
# I h%
"#"-C6A- '
A-L9
"1-C61FK(=
1Cg1
:Q K#TF8
$M- K
1%#
1-}
K :1Q1#
F18
- 1Vv1P1#K1U1,98J(/ Wj- K
$ <V^6#8-MF#$, 1
& 18$1%
T1 1
$,1*6(1
$-
"
K S#
$,*6A-8M$CS;T K
# -
"V#K$-S-I,*6 '
C#"$8+A-(?j#
1J G1-e
C i JK)-O3-3P8Q--G
!)- 8A-L K
81 18 41%{1
1. “Favor Laesi” Principle.
35
-H=6N
DE
%-N $- 8
"
-OP%#K
$1J- 181
K {-1%"1-1#
t[1=#K-G(5 $=G;-- G;,K$=V 4-1V1-
K
-MF#/ $%(M/#+86,#$S-vP#"
'
@ K
.77s YK
&ll
&H
)(R(-*S'-#
-#A,A-
$J- G1;1,118
8/ (5 $=
)18GQ; G;-
$1S- 41 "1#,h1%1#
1#I$1#
V K -CvP
.'
P*S-#
-MF#[
|
",G;K#
- 1-MFMJM- 1
#vPG#,
:Q|
8
$p -C
0'
(3$T-50 M;()-L
K pA,SIJ#
1J1A1-
K W6=
T
#$-S
aA-#
1C1 U G6 1
8
# +L C
| $CK([V :1Q#vPG=M-5
18
$11;
1%#
'
$V#
(Cavers, 1977, p706-720) ,
$ 8
1-IW1J1#8 1-
$ ,+8$;K/ G;A, -
-+
I1-+1#-
# d,
%GQ; I)8- 1-+11%GQ; I)8+8$;
#I 1-Cv1P4-1VG11#$S-K" d, '
v-11
@ .77s YK B>
H -C1C-1
@ .77c YK 0 x l H 18
@
&sll K Y
&7 x
&&
H 11#M1
-MF9 #W AC
$h? G9W8Z-8
16A1-K%#
-#
FT- W,8
-MF#
'
[r 8 -G;,
; G;
$=-V#^Q;$S-MG- vP6J#
G, 1#1?/#
1. Hague Convention on The Law Applicable to Product Liability (1972), Art.6:
“where neither of the laws designated in article 4 and 5 applies, the applicable law shall be the internal law of the state of the principal place of business of the person claimed to be liable, unless the claimant bases his claim upon the internal law of the state the place of injury.”
2. Swiss Codification, Art.135 – Italian Codification, Art.63.
3. Civil Code of The Russian Federation, Art.1221.
5.(<1&CX8V U
F 2
!!!
36
%A,A-Z-^C
$)$X
W AC#. K
A1,1-C1
-",G;
1-A1P1-V1#)18G1-; K1-d1,K)18"V1K-
:Q 8 } -#K$- J$--
}
$vP
.
CA-#
#
$1$#V K16X181
1, K4-1V1
I F4 $F
'
#5 ,K )#";Q$
1%
A1 } 181#
-",G;,%
-
"6[1=1,#
$1v1P 1F
' I
";Q
"-#$- d? gwJ MJM9
- 18 M1I41
$ + I
-; A,-$V#
| +-#$
'
^r#
K
$ 1
G8#84%Z-##
&
88%
K
$VKIWJ#
1
FZ- -; 8
$C 1#8
1 1,11V
$ -CtXF K
G1;I1A-$S- 89 1%#1%"1,
'
+S6A-[X K
F#
FV$68"
1#"JG#,M$- L
8UA- U (=K
-I$S- ",FV K$- 8$S
A-$C tb#$FYQVFA- 1"6[1=
F
"
x 1#1A1-Z1-Mh1? $1 KR"6[=A-h%
#K-S- F
-M5 8"
| S6=bV#CA-
"
1L G1#,
%#gCJ
.' (Garnet, 2006, p9; Lanterman, 2005, p16)
"C
"6[=A- R
/ W$%
"9
0' 1#
1X
1. Brussels Convention, Art.6.1.
.' 11C
|
"6[11=A11-11- G11=11"11; 11 11-; 11*6$-11,R1111
"
The ubiquity Principle
"
-IWJ#%-
",- tX#[K
1FM 1
1?-GUd,G;8
@ The forum loci acti or The country of origin H
1KG1-C (1=K
tbM-d,G;V
@ Forum loci damni or The country destination 'H
0 ' KA-89 1#16181IZ1-"ASC8J$<P=
d1,
%#
' -
?%
J
"/ $%
Multi-Local Torts
"
$ '
47
-H=6N
DE
^CU K :QKG?,A- 8
$1(1V9)8<j8 K1%
-VG?,-tX#
8 } -4-V8#)8I }
)8$=
<8
$C 8
$$#I$C S#K
$1$SCACV 181%
K
p$- LF8/ { )8/ (=
| 1FK1 GVI 1
#$- #
6[=
,"
VYP%V$- :Q
$1VF18
F#UJ"C6V 1-C:1UF8/ ",G;
v181#
V#$-,"6[=
# C#)(C Kg?
1T11U G6,^
4-V -C- x
W8, (1=1#KI$%(V(/
:Q",G;,KOP 8
}
$+86$- 1
A-1#1A1-1#
ASC"-C6
#
$GC I '
6/N-]/<3/F/H&/2McF.(<1&CX8V 1 K$, 1$8X#S#K/ $%,(M/YQV
U G6,K,nV(M/
1g1p$p K
1-1:[V1#
1
h?
K
$, 5-
"8 K w;=(?#
"O,K '
$,*6A-8 KM
$V#9
@ K- 8
&0l>
YK ...
%
K
&0>l YK 0&D K1Q
&0l&
YK
&.D H
F*,"C86 y
"/
1L1 1#K1,
$C1p1-w-1=1X d1K
$ -C K
# F-
@ K$,5
&0>c YK 0c0 K$C/
&0>l YK 0 g
K
&0lc K
Y
>B HK Jd,G;,K?J 8e#
"6[1=,#
$1U
$ 8
$8T I"-*
K ,#
} K1-1*6U G6$8
C*6tbT$?^=$V#
"
-T
|
"Q*
"
(1pG=
4 G#, (V#$#
"
"FZC8 '
-Ta-N
|
#Q*
$=?
-*6$"/y
"IM
IYQV8
y
#8"/
}
"1$J1V1Q9-Z-
5.(<1&CX8V U
F 2
!!!
4
Kh? RPGKM
)=
I18$S,
"
1V1Q*
"
d1,1#
-GU 5I#
1-Fg1, 1*A1,-11#
1%#
' a-N1 1S9
"
4 "#,(p +86,$#
"
G1Ud,G;,"6[=#$-?#
$-J K?-
?#Q* 8 y
d1G#,[8K"tb"/
"J
#89
$CJ
*6
$-G 1#1S-"11#K
:U(=
4 #,
"(V"d$#
K Cp
"1:U
A#*6
$=QVGC/
CGC; #$Cp 8
4 G#,"#
1?$1#
K+86,
##
4 G#,
#
"?$
'#
?AC K
A#*6C, G1C/
A1 1;A-1#1#?-GUd,G;,"<F-#M$=QV 18
} A1-
"(p
18$1<PA,89
^1CG1#,1J?1%Z1-
$
%#
1V18$1S,K K1-G1
I 1/U1#"1
"
"1 1#K
4
$#
-N
"
'
$?A-!#
d1,G;,"C86
1*61?-G1U1
,nV(M/U G6$8,#- A1-^1C11Cd
)8/ $%,(M/YQV,
#K
;
$-?
1L$1()S%#
"J$UG#,
A1-1U G6YV,Z-gp(p8$ )S%
$A%G?, -C
'
"V +V()S%A-8e#
'
3FH&2McF.l-XG#<3T8VM]H dF 4 N"[&.-7TH
Q* 9
$=?
y 11*6"/
y
"/
"11-$1
@ K1-
&0>&
K Y
&.
+,
K
&0>>
YK Dc H
"Q;?
' 1
y 1"/
y
"/
$C -b YV,#
y K"/
%NF8 9#:bU
1 1-
$$"/y
#I$-aF9*6K-F
"1
68 Q* a-N $V#$
$=?#
y 11- #"/
1 '
48
-H=6N
DE
@ K- 8
&0l>
YK ..D H KAC
|T6[
:Q"-C6, F8
&K v1Q
^
&0>>
K
$#
&c
&>
$1C$,#- I N1F
118 y F18/ "/
:QG#*(V)8 KF8
?JA%#[
| M1$,1*61;/#K<8
-T#?b
| b#:=#bV
|
"??
"
/ W
"
"
p
"
#
*;
"$8I '
!A-#
K A#*6F
$1V1*6$#1 #$1=QVG1C/
=
| A#
G1Ud1,G;,"C86a-N K+#GC/
1A1-1?-1
h?
^S%A-#
*68"J$
F,G=$-?
"
#KI8 w/Q#
K$ <$?
G6
"-%M$CS '
1C,f
$CM(pU G6 C
,Z-#
' , d1,G1;,"C86
GU -T#
| W Q*
' C 181F
$1F 1-T1I8
| 1Q*
$#*6 ,8%
NF I 8#
y
"/
1#$1?1L1
Q*
C,K-Nz#
A#*6
"1)M$=QVGC/
K 1-Ta-N1 AC1p
|
#I^C858KU G6$=,#8N +816YV{-%#J
# F,U -$?#
K
1"1V1-:1Q#-[r
F#%^8N,"C86KF$#-:X 1,1%J
-MF#- '
&'
&c x
#8:Q#(V?J"/y OP1%11#8$FgJOP
$$/$=QV+$,*6-$**6 :Q#p(VWJ8%#
"1%8 '
#V^y-I$F-C-?U%K"8%#[$JV8%
' Q?
x 18
6RP 8
$1/1%"1V $,1*6OP1%^11-#(V%#$,*6YP%
"$,*6OP%^y--G-J$-MJ"/y '
&>
x Ib11#1%#v1U(V-)8F8p{ %p(V-)89
:Q#$ VKW F8
1 r8161*M1J"V #(V?J#[RP
%VS;(V##9^U '
5.(<1&CX8V U
F 2
!!!
49
e 4 [&.-7TH M-7hr
s*#.
-h8.
a-N #J #
` Q*
_
$=?#
y
$"/
$U,1K1*6
4 G#,(V8 1?Q*IG)=K"$#
1 y 1P+1$/
?SIMJK"%
y L#"/
+-CKQ*
'
#1#
(1pKA-
4 G#,
$11#1#$#
"
1Q* 1-T
"
1- ' 18
"
* 1Q
"
K
$1V#
F-
@ K$CL
&0>0 YK
&7B H
"
%;
y
$1,[V1,1#$"/
"
1#
4 (p?
$#
$11-?JG#,(V#-N 18
' KF1-A1-
y 9VK$"/
} (=-"Q* ?#8V$C 1
V 1#$1CJ$1$1,[V1,1-K"1b;8VY
$AU[VA-8$-
8
$;
%;A-$S-F y
"/
4 To-#
$#
":U$^C-N '
"$-#
8
#
"<
"Q*
?#
y )18/ $%(V"/
- $S-K-*6 T
"
4 "#,(p
$#
"
(1Vd1A1-M
1"1-(p%$$<
/ 1#(1Vv1$1,[V F18
J# C
"
' Vg,#8"tb^A-^6 }
"
$1;A,
"
18
"(pA-A #,-T-, K
d1,G1;,--d,G;,
?-GU
^T 8%Q "ASC -GUd,G;,
G1#,"11#K?
4
#$#
*K-G#I
"
-
^)A g,
"8 '
189
)8F8/ W/Lp6^6 S?1%#
| A1#wb1I(1=g1-
$1C/
j(T
$< C8 4 nV$-)88
8#I"V$#
%=
' W A-#
K 1,1L$,%+86(=
1#1I"1/UG1;
K(V?J -",G;,";
-d,-- K
$C
^1C
4 G#,L8/ #A,A- 8NG=##"$#
$ I$<
I#
'
4:
-H=6N
DE
C&l-X-1R}78VCV f -G"/UG;,^C%(?jSI K
,#*68
K"tbU G6$8
)8/ $%$"/y ,A-$J $?#
8$A-$##"#K"F K
) K
$11-1*6-I 1
K 1
*6 :Q"-C6K$- W11#+816,AU $-C6?#8
j"-N / K
A1,1U G16Ij1 K$-1C6?A-a-N (=
$$#-9
%
dF 4 8VCV
8"- :Q"-C6
*68 y
1#-$"/
"tbG=Z- '
^AC#$,W-Q
&0>>
*MJ$#4
1#1p1#1I(1/ W18$F8/ #(V##9 :Q
%F8
"
$-C6?a-N
J*68N Z%
$C$,#?%
NF x a"ASC89
$ 1*"1-C6A-^C
-I,A-#
'
$-I8"I$^
?A--J$, # K
1#1*6
A#*6 ,gp^?#K$=QVGC/
b;#8#
v A1-"1V
4 h? GG F,:
$#
% -
$,h?
K
KI#+86FM8C T JA9
# 1P '
$/16
$118
"1-#
"F4 -$8"$;b"%#
'
U G6, GS%#K$b,V4- LI
V1$-F
"#ZV '
# -
$,*6{#K4 $-
#$SFM8C
$$-JG
$8$b#%#
1FSKI8$;#S #
$F
#K8
"1-"11$#1o-1 1 F1J1#K
1#KI"
U G6,CGS/;
1CZ1C8$-1J !#
' A1-1#
5.(<1&CX8V U
F 2
!!!
4;
*?X$,*6{#RPd$-KT 8#
111#
K 1#1J 1#
QP ,$S-M-JKI$ e
#$?
G16OV1%*G;
"FTU '
"y 9
$;
"$-F
$- + R1P$,1*61
$CJ#(=Z-#
K 1KVYV(,##
h1?
#h? G
$=QV y A-KJA-#-MF#
"1-1$/1?*1Z- i
UA,;8Tgb, h? $S-MG#M8C
#$8$F-
, ?-* 8 [+#,CG?
+C ,1*61
$1=11#$
-N
% (Morse, 1984, p5)
,
$ M RP Kh1?
? gp , G6
U ,
"F '
,A-"*"AC a$CJ##
"S%
" #$CI
$RP
'
#
$1QQP 1K- 1,1%
aW*U *6
$C
#K$=QV*6MS-X
";=Ko-
$ J$-+T85-- U G6,^C 18CM-
dG#,L?-* U G6$,I
'
# 4*K-
1*61,M
T$-8K$=QVQ,
A1,U TC$S%
K S1%I
$ TA-89
1A-#
$111*618"11
$1=QV
$=QVK$M K
$L
@' K,#
&0>D YK Dl H
=$-8A-C:X##
A,U | (<S-
1
!, I- fX '
S-I*6Z- K
1 U#
}
S#1#1
&
@ K1-
.77&
YK
>>D x
>>s HK v[1*();
1F IW1J1#18+-1%
` G161,
U _ ([S%?S-#
K
C*KU G6+5TZ-#S J#
&
' Babcock V.Tackson
$/F A-
-
# 1-d1,G;,"C86#A/
8^
}
$Q
"/-8
#- d, V,#
K#
1S-"
",-:X K#
"#8 '
43
-H=6N
DE
,G; -X
"
"/$CJ-Q, (1=1#18$-1
"%V$U<*/#
G6
$GQ F
'
"A%
8 b#p#*b8$F- 1-$1CJg# K
"/Q,
$8
%VGLAX"/:QK8 '
"1ASC
"
"/gG;
"
6AU }
A#*6K$Q,*6
^1*UK$CGC/
%#A- K
| A#*6
$=QVGC/
F
$ -#
`
1U "/1
A, _ 1p,C g#$8J M< A-%#
"1J$b#
F^8
"
F I
#5 8F
| + , V 1FKC"#jS-I*6 1
y
"/gG;
1-^1C1#"VV
(
$1QP%
F*A,C+86 '
(Castel, 1995, p10)
$8"JAC V
S- Z1V1,1I8g"J
$-%KU G6 8
1- $-1 *68S-
$11#IN1F I1
";
"
U G6,AU $-FM#
"
-
"
g<
$-F 1, 1;
"
1*6
A#
C(*8-$=QVGC/
|
"I#
'
6 } 1TKA1,U
`
1U G161,A1U $1-FM#
_
$1#
vP#U G6,GC;{#-I K1$1QP%1
Q,U %/K$Cg GS1%1#158"$-
1F
/
$$CJ F
' (Fentiman, 2009, p2-3)
F-A- A1#1*61#"?Q,S-#
18 $1=QVG1C/
-M
$11-*1-1,#-*U G6,$CJ 18
,"-
$#
V(=A-##-8-MF
":"
4
AU F,%
'
"
S- x
:
"
G;
"
-M x 1-
"
1- 1#1
%
%#
@ (1*1/ $%"/y#+86,AU IC
$T6[
% H
#-
^!
1; 1%tbd G
1Q,1
$-18
5.(<1&CX8V U
F 2
!!!
44
%#V##
'
@ K$F8 .77s H
"<G#,M*68$-/
'
- 8"
(=(); A- -J#C
=F
| 1-#KA,U
"<F KM$V*6
#+86,AU 1/ $1%1,(M/
)18 K 1-#
#r#,
| C+86^?#"-M#
1#;#8I#$, v1b
:Q"-C6$U-K 8
K -CA '
9
e 4 (<1&CX-&V}
:[V#
,(M/#+86,AU #K(*
)181/ $%
$-*6 1-1#"1FT^CG#,A,$<X"-#
1J1-
vP#"I8S M#
W1V^6#8-MF#$, 1
$ ' pd,G;K)8GQ; K/ ,$MJAU K-
:1Q",G;
K18
11T11?1#KUA,A-Z-;jIAFT#
", '
"-(V(*8"$%A- -MF#$b;
-"-{;"-C6G=IJ %
"1-F- 1#$1b;
1
,?
}
"%-8N '
@ l
&*
H
?%
$U?XX#
15V,%#
' f1 (1*1F
/ W#+86,AU $,< A9 K"
"$##
h?X#%NF8 +V I#
' A-##
K
$-$V*6
<1#
?A- :Q#
8 1J"1%?-;9K/ Wj8
)8/ G;+86A,8
@ 1?-1G1Ud1,G1;,#
H K
8GQ; G;, )
@
"11C:Q8-V$r/j8)8F HK
&'
`
$J$/(V-$b;"-(V$%,nV(M/#^CG#,,
# K$b;"-(VjYP%
WJ#8#V$, Z-#8N,
F$AU 9
¤ -G;,"C86,
¥ tX#,-?J"J8$QP%SIK
"-Fg,I-#$U,8-MF#8,K"C '_
45
-H=6N
DE
V",G;,
@ -,)C6 H
MJU? S#K
1#$1S-K1
"6[=,
8 F#-MF#
' :1Q1#"?,A- K18
VG8?J#
1#18/ #"?(
1-I1-d1,1
$ F ' VF8/ K,A-^C#89
$C-"-#eV
89J))
$ C6I#",#
$148?-6^
1#- '
?/
K
"$-#
8 -M4-M#"?,4-MA- -M/
1C##{?
y 5V"/
K
$-5I -M8
4-M 1#4-M#"-M-
8
| p(V)8
$+V%
F :QC
$1g- F8 1F
K
-X ,A-^C }
1aF%$#U G6 y
"/
g1<1#$1UCJ1
:QOP%
8 -}
#+VM- '
4 "#,(pK,A-, / #WP,$#
"8 '
189 K
I
#8F
% K
^1C"-(p
"
$1,[V1,
"
"A1C
1b#16
|
$"??
"
*6+G=#
$"/y
$#
181%
, A#*64-V +1%#1?- G1=A1-1jI1#M1$=QVGC/
4 G#,L,#J8/
+,$#
'
^6A-#
K 1,A1-^C K
#$CU 8/ #(=I(?j
1L$118"
G1#,
4 vP,#$#
#%
| V
"
'
"$&
"C86
"
-",G;,
"-
# y
"/
K)8/ $%, 1C
gp"-* #
:QG#*$- F8/
LF18
$-1
"1-C6
:Q LF8/ G#*$- F8
"$- '
1,A1-^C#89
I
y
#8"/
| :Q LF8
$- F8/ $-
$tX
% K C
U 8A, U ^6-
"11#
1,
--",G;
"
$^C
% A1,:[1V1#KA1,A1-1S-1#J #
5.(<1&CX8V U
F 2
!!!
46
K$- 8
^1CK11J(1V?J"J$*,W8 1I
-1 F8/ #
$
"11-11,1 1<
' Y1QV1S9
:Q 1V"1,G1;1,^1CM1$-1 F8 F18/ G1#*1I
$- L G8?J#
#V(V '
- - I|58 M1JM9
$#, "-*
-M48 /
#P$- F8/ # '
C
| 1-
"$/6
"K(*8
:Q"-C6
"F8
A-$-C6?#
"%C,, x
%-G; #J #8$-
$CT#"
'
*6 -
K
"a-N
:Q"-C6 8
"
?#
*6$-
J- '
8$-?
KI
$K(?j#8F -J$, #
I
A1#*6#
181C1 $1pU G161,K$1=QVG1C/
K IW1J1#
K
:Q ,-(VF8
#V
18A, 11#{? 1
@ 1#
1-d1,G1;#)8GQ; G;8,KOP(=
1-
"1,G1;
:Q 8 H
"6[=,#$S-
-MF#
+8161V(1V?J#
-C 8$#P
| XI
$ 11#{? 1$1S-MG11J(p#
I
8 -";
4 "#,#h I$1$1#
11#
| 1V
"
'
57
-H=6N
DE
.8
&' g
#K
@
&0lc H
*6K A#
=QVGC/
$ nK .K K v#(K '
.' K,#
C;
@
&0>D H g<Q,*6j K A1#*6$-F
G1C/
$1=QV K
<
@
$,*6 H
C%K D>
'
0' K11-
$U116
@
&0>&
$1111*6 HK B
K (11K$11%8$11M11J
K$*6S '
B' C;K$,5
@
&0>c A#*6 HK
$=QVGC/
nK . K K M '
D' K%
@
&0>l H U $-,K
#+86,A 1,
K 1-
$,1*61
@
$,*6()*C5 H
K K K 5(
'
c' +,
$ K
@
&0>>
H
$"/yK K
+<
K K M '
l' K- 8
=
@
&0l>
H M/K ,nV
@ 1,Cp HK
n
&
K K (1
'
>' 1 111111111111
@
&0l>
H 1-$,1*61T1U/b1*6+*K K
"1#
+%
K K
$"8%
'
s' K$C/
$p$5 pK
@
&0>l H ,K ,LYV(M/#+86 K
C%K<
cl '
&7 ' KQ C;
@
&0l&
H A#*6K
$=QVGC/
K K FI(
'
&&
' K$CL 5
@
&0>0 H
"#,K 4
$#
p
"/y
$ K K
"8%
$
12.Castel, Jean-Gabriel (1995), Back to The Future! Is the New Rigid Choice of Law Rule for Interprovincial TortsConstitutionality Mandated?,Osgoode Hall Law Journal, Vol.33.
13.Cavers, David (1977), The Proper Law of Producer’s Liability, International and Comparative Law Quarterly, Vol.26.
14.De Boer, Th. M (2008), The Purpose of Uniform Choice of Law Rules, Netherlands International Law Review, Vol.6.
15.˰ѧѧ˰˰˰˰˰˰˰˰˰˰˰˰˰˰˰ (2007), Party Autonomy and Its Limitations in the Rome II
Regulation, Yearbook of Private International Law, Vol.IX, Sellier, European Law Publisher, Swiss Institute of Comparative Law.
5.(<1&CX8V U
F 2
!!!
5
16.Dickinson, Andrew (2008), The Rome II Regulation on the Law Applicable to Non-ContractualObligations, London, OxfordUniversity Press.
17.Fentiman, Richard (2009), The Significance of Close Connection, The Rome II Regulation, Edited by John Ahern and William Binchy, Martinus NIJHOff Publishers, Leiden & Boston.
18.Garnett, Richard (2006), An Overview of Choice of Law, Jurisdiction and Foreign Judgment, Media and Arts Law Review 341, Vol.11(4).
19.Grazino, Kadner (2007), The Law Applicable to Cross-Border Damages to The Environmental, Yearbook of Private International Law, Vol.IX, Sellier, European Law Publisher, Swiss Institute of Comparative Law.
20.Huber, Peter and Illmer, Martin (2007), International Product Liability, Yearbook of Private International Law, Vol.IX.
21.˰ѧѧ˰˰˰˰˰˰˰˰˰˰˰˰˰˰˰ (2007), International Product Liability, Yearbook of Private
International Law ,Vol.IX, Sellier, European Law Publisher, Swiss Institute of Comparative Law.
22.Lanterman, Katrin & Schafer, Hans (2005), Jurisdiction and Choice of Law in Economic Perspective, German Working Papers in Law and Economics, Vol.Paper 1.
23.Morse, C.G.J (1984), Choice of Law in Tort: A Comparative Survey, The American Journal of Comparative Law, Vol.32.
24.Rushworth, Adam & Scatt, Andrew (2008), Rome II: Choice of Law for Non- Contr`actual Obligations, Ltoyd’s Maritime and Commercial Law Quarterly, Vol.274.
25.Stone, Peter (2009), Product Liability Under The Rome II Regulation, The Rome II Regulation, Edited by John Ahern and William Binchy, MartinusNIJHOff Publishers, Leiden & Boston.
26.Symeonides, Symeon (2004a), Choice of Law for Product Liability: the 1990s And Beyond, Tulan Law Review, Vol.78.
27.˰ѧѧ˰˰˰˰˰˰˰˰˰˰˰˰˰˰˰ (2004b), Tort Conflicts and Rome II :A View From Across,
Published in Festschirift Fur Erik Jayme, H-P Mansel,etal,eds.
28.˰ѧѧ˰˰˰˰˰˰˰˰˰˰˰˰˰˰˰ (2007), Rome II :A Centrist Critique, Yearbook of Private
International Law, Vol.IX, Sellier, European Law Publisher, Swiss Institute of Comparative Law.
29.˰ѧ˰˰˰˰˰˰˰˰˰˰˰˰˰˰˰ (2006), The Quest for the Optimum in Resolving Product Liability
Conflicts, Essay in Honor of J.P Kozyris.
30.˰˰˰˰˰˰˰˰˰˰˰˰˰˰˰˰ (2008), Rome II and Tort Conflict: A Missed Opportunity, American
Journal of Comparative Law, Vol.56.
31.Weintraub, Russel (2009), RomeII: Will it Prevent Forum Shopping and Take Account of The Consequencesof Choice of Law?, TheRome II Regulation, Edited by John Ahern and William Binchy, MartinusNIJHOff Publishers, Leiden & Boston.
