2 , F D@ J gt; 6 9< 9 H @ = 1 9> 6 7

(1)

) :

!" # (

1

! " #

) :

10 / 2 / 92 - :

27 / 11 / 92 (

$

, - .

# /0 .1

# 2 3 4

$ 5 6 7 , 6 8 9:

; 0<

= 1 9>

6

? @

@ .

# 2 B C D@

#

?E .@

6

, F

6

; 0<

DF G , H

I . D@

.@

,

?E#

6 .

# 2

, F

D@

J 7 29 , 0 6 9>

6 9<

9 H

@

= 1 9>

6 7

? ,

D@

.1 / K- , 6 D= 1 6 F D9- .$

@ L

, 6 1 6 .I

# D D@

=@

D= 1 M9

? "

. 2#

D7 F /

@

"F. 1 .@

G

#

? @ N '.@

D@ I 1 O P ' .

# 2 B , 6 1 6 .I

# D D= 1 .@

/ F . , 6 1 6 .I

# D@ I H<

5:@

G F

6 DF

? .93I .1

# 2

* .1

# 2

5:@

9>

# 2 F

@ G

@ 2 .@

. Q>

D@ I

? .I (1 . R

#

# G

#

? @ N

D 0 1 9>

@ 1 .

S(>

#

; . .F D @

; 1

# .

# .<

#

# 2 F

"

G

@ 2 .@

. F G

#

? @ N

# 2

? D 6 G

TU@

1.

.

TU@

1.

# V 7 W 6 1 6 .I

# 1

= 1 9>

6 7

. ! "

Email: Ardestani2009@yahoo.com

یدیلک ناگژاو

(2)

#

$!%

&' ( )

* +, -. /

" 0%

1 2 34 )

&

( 5

# 6,7(

- 5&

8 + 89 ,&5

:, . ,

; ( 5

%

< : ( ' ', 1

&

;

=

>

? @ AB

!/

1 /'

>

C5,

*

?

") D E(

E=

,

* F (&

E(

,

;

# - 5

" 0%

1 G H : I (

;

!/

EB ,

;

< #

&J @ :

J!%

1

" 0%

1

" EC:KL E)G:

) )C M

? , + N EO+ ! E(

@ AB

* P,&Q, RC", 1 (

#

5 -

@

*

" 0%

1 EC', S

* @ S , ,

;

@ AB G"

1 B

! !

#

&@

T 1 : B

" RN ) , U V W X 1 S , ,

;

@ AB !B 8 2C , .

X 1 +, M0

&

; YN G Z&[

,

;

?< #

=

>

E/'

# E/' JC 1 ( . E/' JC 1 E(

#

<\

9

&

R

#

& 9 X

* . )

;

EB

&R

&' E( * : 1

? " &(

C"

] :, * G" + EB

CN 1 +#& ,

") D

@ AB ; ,

EC ", C"

", S , +,

$!^

89

@ "+ ' .

% 1 EB E(

F (&

1 :

?

=

>

E/'

#

E/' JC 1 ( E(

O _ 1 , U V W T G H 1 : EB

`R +,

&Q a bcR",

#

B&N

@

*

@ 1 de(

# E"

: )

<

@

* Zcf, E" G=Q

# gV

% E"

1

", - f

)J(

&

. E(

g@

)

; H)V

? ,

;

< # @ : bcR",

@

* ( 1 g:

*

@ AB 1 C @ ) M EB

Jg@

1

* O , E/'

# h)

&A !C:,

)

&J!(

E(

?&=

1370

.(

( h) +#&

*

; , bcR",

@ j _ E/'

# h)

&A N V&'

>

B V#

@ ,&5

&L .

,

; ) 8

? : 8, C(

' ) '

@

* C5,

* k O gC%, 1 , M0

&

; O _ 1

", EB l5,#

E(

" +9 1 ,&(

* ,

; bcR",

@ G H : .

&(

g@

)

;

?m ',

; , EV R

# d'&h

< gO Z&[

', : EX! , #, 9

`R cRC', T

AB E(

' L )

&

* - 5 +, a &Q N

?bD

<#&L

E0G%

,

* n S 1 ", E(

G0(

/_#

) /'

>

C5, *

#

@ 1 89 AB

&o!

p :

#

EX! , q#

9 ( X ) E

&(

' ) '

@

* +, h) d / ))

;

< :

#

* ,&L E"

1 8, E(

h)

&A

#

/'

>

C5, * ' p

; , EV R 1 : B M) ( DB&g

&(

+

< ( Gg E(

,

; ' r ,

@ ' h

@ M) .

h) d +, j#&:

Y2(

#&_

* ', s!

#

!/

*

&s"

S , +, E/'

# /'

>

C5,

*

;:#

!B ) M . 8 !^

EB 1

", )

?M

&/

t E/' PcS&(

&( kB k(

) + k u 8 k'9

")

# X t=Ce

&X

* E(

S,&

S

&/

v 1 +, 89 EW, , 1 !!B . , ko!

8# k(

#

# E(

,

; -. o

&s"

*

?

&/

t

&ks"

kS , +, E/k'

# /k'

>

kC5,

* ( k) 8

1

!B ) M EB EA)g@

( , ) - E/' P ,&C ( q 0v E/' E(

B

< &(

1 :

) k ( , k) -

E/'

# /'

>

C5, *

&J!(

E(

Schumpeter, 1934& Myrdal, 1975:

.(

(3)

E(

=B Q 1

? E/' ,&

!

* w( !^

/

* ', EB

&Xv O g q q &

# CS ' E/ %

#

@ 0"

, E(

1=X:

h 1 &))x @ EB C"

] 89

% G0(

/(, ' ) ' 1

? O gC%, 1

? J!@&

1

?

#

C5,

* 1 : .

&(

g@

)

; m ',

? /'

>

C5,

* , 1 8, :

<,&g@

( ,D , d

&y )

@

* V)

* MO, +,

&y )

@

* ) D X 1

?

" ", 1

?

# O gC%, 1

", . , P&f

&s"

+,

q 0v

?E/' Ez"9

!/

* 5) a ,

; Zc[f, ,

;:#

1 + ' O go

>

{S :

@ 1 ',

EB E(

g/ Q

,&(

* 89

&s"

1 L ) "&

. M0

&

; ,

; {S :

@ ! GO +, : V) {V S "

= 1

GNP)

# (

9 E",&'

NI) ( I {S : /'

>

" ", 1

HDI) ( I {S : 9

h ,

SSI,GNA) (

I '&C' 1 E(

u+ 9 gO 1

# :, 0(

" Jg@

1 I DB&g , + 1

# I B A

{S :

&(,&(

* - 5

&S I

#

|N / 8 "+

f&O

>

O gC%, 1 . ,

; EV R E(

' &(

1

# _ ) } ,

; {S :

@

# 34 )

&

' ) '

@

*

* ,&L

"

>

V#

89

@ 1 M +, &h .

&(

g@

)

;

?m ', , C(,

C5, ' ) ' 1 +

< ( Gg 1 1' &( , M)!B

1 # M): B ' ) '

@

*

* ,&L E"

,

; AB , E(

Q {eA

;:#

M)!B .

~•' E , ,

E(

' &(

1 O )!

1

{S :

@

* E/' ,

; AB

# 34 )

&

' ) '

@

*

* ,&L E"

89

@

@, S ) M S, &h .

h 8

") D +,

"9 Ez ECvL M , C"

) Eo L )

&

*

@, S ) M

&B .

!

+

< ( Gg b !%

& 9 R ,&5 ,

# h eC 89

< ,&@

', . ,

; AB

< +,#

#

") M )=

) 8

&v"

/g%

) , EB ) J"

)

;

!' 1 89

@ 1 / 20 ' ',

# 8 (+

@

*

=J", ) 1

?

" :

?

# ' ) E=( !

8 (+

@

* g' 1 89 ', . ,

; AB 8&5

M@ + "

) c

* E(

&g/C 8 C =J", G

H : .

+, ' 1965

? MB MB uc

@ ,&(

* cRC', ,

; AB + €9 :

# q o",&' '

1970

0g%

* +

< ( Gg E(

Q g' 1 qcO,

%

&B . +

< ( Gg D%

•

&S9

;

@ AB * b !%

& 9 R ' EB E(

]

# ( , : * (

= "

1 j, # 1 !B EB

~h +, bcR",

#

<+ G

=O ) E

g/C', E(

- 5 ' ) .

+ # AB *

# N q '#

")

#&

* B ,

&(

1 L )

&

. l( ! GQ ) / 1 H :

€+

?$!'

?cQ

G!h

>

@ B 1

#

") HX ', .

-. 2

, f 1 ,

; AB H : ch )!

) q

? EG!h

? B G!

? cQ

?

V9 )

@U *

;@9

#

- % !

', EB E(

@ AB * 9

&

R

* ( !%

1 ) 8 / 24 f (

? 0g%

*

,&B ) T J!B ) 6 / 17 f (

?

", ( ) 7 / 15 f (

# , -.

2C X & 9 ) 4 / 10 f (

f 1 :

# m ',

!f l

< 9 + ' * , D)"

XA ) H 1 @ .

-. 2

, ,#

1 ,

; AB

H : : )

; .9 -

# 0o )

?-,D

-. 2

E" S B ,

*

? ,

# , 1

# S ' ', EB +,

(4)

@ AB * 9

&

R

* ( !%

1 ) 8 / 40 f (

? G ,+

) ) 6 / 29 f (

?

# , -.

2C X & 9 ) 9 / 4

f ( ,#

1 :

)

&J!(

E(

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zimbabwe: (

( ,

;

? N ,&(

* ƒ -. 2 C5, ' ) ' 1 ,

; AB ( +, ' 1966 j#&:

&B .

,

; '

#

~h +, qcO, cRC', T

EG" %

(UDI)

# E(

;(

( ' ) 8 -,&B,K V#

8 C =J", (

XN g',

) ) MB N + # (

? ', S

&2 M C5, * + # E(

8 + '

H=

EW, , : . g@

)

;

? C', ' 1970 V#

g', ) ,

; AB , 0g%

* qcO,

&B .

ECGV, 89 8 +

`R

& 9 R

* ( !%

1 ,

; 0g%

* , E(

g' ) S !:

. , (

%#

qcO,

V#

0g%

*

? Q 1 8 g@

'

? @ -,+ G h )

",D 1

=O ) E V#

g', ) : :

#

C"

) o

>

,

;

# R

? @ V#

5#

( E%

E(

A

=S, 1

#

% S 1

?

^ "

: ( 2 ,

= 1

& 9 R 1 +

< ( Gg

(ZANU)

E(

&G@

* -&(, E( L

# 2 , q &

& 9 R 1 +

< ( Gg

(ZAPU)

,&B,K 1 , E(

s!

}=f

# R ) M - 5 + €9 !B . 8 :

&B„

', EB 8 + g', )

?

/_#

) C5,

* +

< ( Gg b =[

( . H #9 q o",&' 1979

1 ( eC", AB ; , ?

)' *+#&)h E( < ( Gg + 1 R & 9 q & 2 , 89 1Q EB : ,DL&(

. AB q " ' 8 g@

M &2 # &L 8 h 1=S, $!% ? &))x < ( Gg + E(

@

&(

EC:, ' EX! , :

1980 EB < (# 1 ( eC", # (

", - s"

dO GC bDN # E( L ? : ,DL&( 8 C =J

ZANU)

" )' - 5 E((

.

d , # d , *#&)" TgB ( M@ E( L 1 &

", ? ( ECS ' EB

&(

u :

* @

1( # < L

< L 9 aW E R ;)g@ # )CS, EB 1 s" *#&)" TgB ( E( L : *,

? :, E"

4 , 1' )' ` ,&: ", C( 0!

1 g S - 5 u&C L ( EX=( ? Ae( - G

Ef&O ' E( < ( Gg + , a=[ - 5 ?$!@& # j gC%, EC &L C5, +, @

&)J(

.

*#

' ", 1CN 1988

bDN # # ZANU

' S # !B q € , M@ , ZAPU

, % bDN

< 0O E(

bDN # &)J(

ZANU-PF

@ H)XA ,

. +, E( ?~h 89 M€

;)( * @ 0" - _,&CO,

< ( Gg + ?1==gV, T

# ', < ( MB N 1 , f HgO

D% 1 B

AB ; , 1CB&N "# ', EC ", C" *# 8 X D" # E( L 3

: ( ,KL&)4 .

1' &( ~h

< ( Gg + 1' )' C5, &X=gO E(

Q 1 &( dg) # E( L &X=gO 1' &( E( M)RC

&L

)

&J!(

E(

Smith, 2009:37-79:

.(

1 8, E(

C' 1 O ,

&B EB ,#+

+

< ( Gg

~h +, qcO, cRC', ,

; AB + €9

< :

', EB ( gB N ) E( L

# bDN dO GC

<,&g@

? ( ,& + /_#

) C5,

*

? ' ) ' 1

?

#

O gC%, 1 ,

; AB HG5 +, qcO,

? cRC', +,

cRC',

< , g@

&C0(

(

<

',

# +

< ( Gg Q 1

q g ,

; '

@ HgO E(

- f q#,

E(

RO EC ', . , (

;

? N "#

V#D"

1 ,

;

(5)

AB +, ' 1999 E(

F R' ,+9 G H :

# : )G 1 8, !^#

E(

S

&L ,& + ? '

1999 bDN MB N O ,

&B EB v' )

@ 1 f /g%

) ,

; AB , XA ) H 1

? !@

, 70

f + )

;

@

* H( 5 AB ,

; AB , ' " , . 89

?8 + + )

;

@ E" G=Q#,

&S

# u#&

1

? : , E( L ' 2000 + )

; v' ) ' h

@ ,

<

# 89

@ , ()

;

' )

<

' h

@ + l

&B . ,

; q, 5,

€ )

" " 5&

1

? E(

d@ B -, f + # AB

*

&o!

: EB

h) d +, 89 de(

gO -, f ,

; AB , XA ) H 1 , . C"

) Eo

? S„

)

&

+ , * +

< ( Gg

( ) d@ B

?

#

&R

# () X * ( ) ,D , . d

/_#

) N

&_ N +

< ( Gg , : 8, C(

E(

; , - f EfcS

&B EB M@

8 !B,

+

@ !(&

H2g|

< :

# - S +

!(&

1 !"

b9

#

…&(

# -,&( e

#&

: h )

<

# +, ()

;

EC ",

#

&R

# () g * '#

) l

#

< &C L ', . aGQ u ,DL 8 + ' :, 0(

" 0%

1 '

2008

? , ) E(

L "+

1 )

!/

1

#9&(

) J"

)

;

&gO

# ( V ( +,

# N 63 '

`',#,

@

>

"

E(

# N 43 ' EC d@ B ',

.

†&

# )

&

8 "+

( ) . ( EC ',

#

=O 89 E(

&

) ! GO +, -cXA N )

; ,+

?8 g ,

?+

(#

?

# '

&

() g

*

@ .

&@

ECv@

H5, N %

() ,+ "

!%

)

; bc_

@

*

&0:

@

< ,&

? h eC ,

; AB 1

:

#

;C

R(

*

%, 8, ,+ "

# 8 B B EV (+

@

*

&0:

*

& , * O * ', .

< JA",

@

# m ,

HgO +, C', V S 1

< : ",

#

&@

~B ( B ", 1

", 1 +, ,

; AB 1

&L D . ,

; AB (

/%

>

" ", 1 E(#

# ', . E/%

,

* EB

• '

&

< &C L

# O 8 &X"

f,

#

", 5 )

;

M=O C5, ,&(

* ,

; AB E(

< #9 8 x , ',

) GQ )G )

?8

? g2 q ,D@

f

*

? ' ƒ C'

.(

; , , G' " : ,

; AB E0%,

( -cXA

# ( E%

E(

, EX!

E( L X 1

+, D"

8 X S , E(

' T" ( DB&

*

b !

< &B

? ( 8# ( E", CAh h

‡ ^ B !

) V h 1 EB E", CAh u,

`R

| ,

* -&(, E( L ( (

# ,

; E=

8, (

% h) d EB

",U

>

2008 _&O

>

h +, 81143 f

HG5 +, 89 E(

658 )=

) 8 f ' )

) http://www.fingaz.co.zw

.(

8 ", C5, 89

, , 5 v 1

"

C5, 8 0%

1 !", EB

R

` q J!@

$!%

" 0%

1 8 C' o

… v ,

< C , . (

# % 1

? _&O

>

h +

< ( Gg , Q 1 '

@

* 2006 2008 1 8, EsNc

&B .

(6)

L <

1 .

; "

C.

G L $

#

? @ N

' L9

&G C•' 2006

&G , "

2007

&G ' 2007

",U

>

2008

",U

>

2008 m

2008

;W#U 2008

_&O 8,D)

>

h ) .

< ( Gg + ( 45

8 )=) 35

8 )=) 67

8 )= &

100 8 )= &

170 8 )= &

800 8 )= &

25 8 )= , B +, d)(

900 8 )= , B

,

; ' ) ' k

&C0(

J(

) M ' "

) ' k Q G", 1 V h 1

% : ˆ&"

q ,

; AB E(

M5

# (

" &X"

1 231 )=

) 8 f ' 2008 '&(

EB aGQ ' &(

1

8, C5,

& 9 X 1

?

C', ) EX!@

? l5,#

( ) () A

&C +, ,

; , R ',

# ( S : 1 , %

CPI +, ,&(

* 89

ECS ' : .

? s! ; (

#

* {S : %

*

&/

1

< &B ', . ,

; {S : EB E(

{S : EX!@

P#&/

< :

? ', ˆ&"

q +

< ( Gg (,&(

&

80 (&_

10 E(

8, 21 + , ( 1

< : I ', S&"

1 EB

!(

&(

' &(

1 EX!@

YO ( 1 : 5) g

@ E(

Q

&R G 1

&@

24 O '

#

&(,&(

" :

Hanke, 2009) (.

# % 2

@ AB 1 EB C5,

")

^ 6,7(

q &

< :

? ", E(

<,&g@

) 8,D q

89

@

# 8 +

") +

&(

,

*

#

&(,&(

8 : 5) g

@ ,

;

@ C5,

< 9 ', .

L <

2 . 1.U@T

; 0< 9> a# 1 6 ,

AB q ˆ&" ; & . (

@ ) E"

q ˆ&" ; & . (

@ ) E"

*,&( + )" 8 +

# 8 : &(,&(

g)5

@

8 C' o

*. % 1949 30

/ 1

* 1016

f 6

/ 15 O '

< ( Gg + , "

&G 2008 000

/ 000 / 006 / 79

f 7

/ 24 O '

*#c L

> ",U 1994 000

/ 000 / 313

f 4

/ 1 +#

8 gV9

&GCB, 1923 500

/ 29 f 7

/ 3 +#

8 "

&G , "

1944 300

/ 11 f 5

/ 4 +#

Prof Steve H.Hanke, Febrauraay 5.2009

8 g@

Q EB EsNc 1

? : +

< ( Gg + !@

E(

B o 8 C' B ", 1

~h +,

$!%

" 0%

1 q#

'&"

)

?<

, EC ", ', B q

#c L * Q 1

$!%

" 0%

1 q#

, !XA(

# 1

& . ( +,

#c L * EC:, : ( .

(7)

!zg@

)

;

?

# % 3 1 8, ˆ&"

q

@ ) E"

AB +

< ( Gg , E(

<,&g@

{S :

5) Cg 1 + (

" + 1 5

",U

>

2007 24

&GCB, 2008

< @ A

&B .

L <

3 . b.

1 , D G

#

? @ N

/ !

"# $ /

%

&

' ( /

/

% ) /

* ' /

!

+ ,-

% / . '

/ '

* /

/ % '

/0, /

/ %

%

' 12 3

* / / '

!

! 4,

%.

/ /

*.

5 6 '

/ / (%

5 7 /

/ '

% .

% 5 /

/ .!

'*%

%(

5 $ /

/ ' /

% /

%

"# $

(

% (

/ /

% /

%

(

%.

8 &

/ / % .

%' / (

(

%(

9 /

/ /

(

% - + , /

/ %%%

/

(

! /

/ *.(

/

**%

(

%' /0, /

% / /

/ ' /

%!

/

* /

*

* ( 12 3 /

* / / !

/

% /

*.

/ / .!

( / 12 3

( / / %

/ ( / ( /

/ '

( ( 3 / 12

! / /

/ / %%

/ /

%

(8)

(

% / 12 3

/ '' / / /

/

!

(

%.

4, /

. / / !

/ /

!!

/ ' /

/ '.

/ .

(

%' / 5 6

* / / %

/ / / .*

/ / /

*

! ( 5 7 /

* / /

/ / / / / !

/ / '!

/

( 5 7 /

. / / *

/ / /

! / / !%

/ / ' /

( 5 7 /

/ / *.!

/ / / / / /

/ / /

!

(

%*

5 7 //

/ ' / /

/ / / / /

/ %*

/ / / /

%'

(

! 5 7 /

/ / '.

/ / / / / / ' /

/ %*

/ / / / (*

/

!

( / 5

/ /

% / /

/ / / / / / (.

/

/ *

/ / / / / .!

( * / 5

/ / ' / . /

/ / / / / / /

/ ( !

/ / / / / / (.

Imara asset Management Zimbabweand author's calculations

8 g@

Q EB +,

# % )h

? ', C 3 ' E" v "#

F R' C5, ,

; AB E"

0!

&GCB,

2008 N

!B 8 :

< G"

? ', EX=(

- , 5, E", &e( "

# ' ) '

@

* ' "

C5, *

G' : : ) F R' ,

; AB

&(,&( !^

:

? E(

Q

* EB

*,&(

Š

? ,&(

* E=( R (

,D , d 5) g

? @ E(

%

* Zcf, ' ) '

@

# x ))

&

)

&

/_#

) ' "

C5,

*

? E( L E(

&C!B 5) g

@

# , o tR'

@

* 5) Cg 1

#

*

#9 . V#

,

; AB

#

*

@. B *

=f, 1 s"

)

&

G' + # AB

*

?

?8 "

- „ B, S 1

?

?&X:

? : L S„

&

=f, 1 ,K€

1

# B tR' 5) Cg 1

,KL .

&C!B 5) g

@. B

*

=f, 1

# ,K€

1

? ECGV, +,

&Q a E",

@ 1

#

&' E ,KL

*

@

*

CV#

1

#

!zg@

)

; JC' )

&

*

# -,+ o 8 L !:#&

#

",&%

1 q o", 1

&L EB E(

Hg/V, C'

@

* CV#

1 HgO g"

1 " &B . g@

>

HW ; ,

YO ( :

<+#& , +

< ( Gg ( GgB

:

?,K€

S '

# + ,

% S 1 E%, : (

? E(

Q

* EB 8 + ' H=

E(

,

; AB TgB

,K€

1 1

) !B

Mail & Guardian, 2009

.(

# % 4

? 1 8, ' )

&

ˆ&"

q ,

; AB , +, ' 1980 ( E N

< @ A

&B

)

&J!(

E(

Coltart,2008:

.(

(9)

L <

4 . c- , 6 R 6 G

#

? @ N G . 1 Ld 9 ; G G

' 1= {V S " 9

GNI) (

. )=)

q ˆ&"

) 1g' ( 1=S, {V S " :

1980 55

/ 8 7

4 / 14

1981 41

/ 8 14

5 / 12

1982 8

/ 6 15

6 / 2

1983 59

/ 6 19

6 / 1

1984 31

/ 6 10

9 / 1 -

1985 47

/ 6 10

9 / 6

1986 91

/ 7 15

1 / 2

1987 48

/ 8 10

1 / 1

1988 05

/ 8 8

5 / 7

1989 6

/ 7 14

2 / 5

1990 54

/ 6 17

7

1991 03

/ 6 48

5 / 5

1992 5

/ 5 40

9 -

1993 94

/ 4 20

1 / 1

1994 98

/ 5 25

2 / 9

1995 59

/ 6 28

2 / 0

1996 26

/ 6 16

4 / 10

1997 27

/ 5 20

7 / 2

1998 07

/ 4 48

9 / 2

1999 44

/ 3 56

6 / 3 -

2000 42

/ 3 55

9 / 7 -

2001 37

/ 3 112

7 / 2 -

2002 42

/ 3 198

4 / 4 -

2003 12

/ 3 598

4 / 10 -

2004 59

/ 2 132

8 / 3 -

2005 1

/ 2 585

3 / 5 -

2006 7

/ 1 1281

8 / 4 -

2007 48

/ 1 66212

7 / 5 -

2008 ---

T # 1' # #

f 8 )=) 6

/ 3 -

V#

< ( Gg + '

2003

? 1 J!@

EB q 89 AB T ,D@

q f

? ( E'

&vf +, m !X',

* @ S , PKN

&B

? , V#

*,&(

0 8 &B q

* B q o", , "

#

`R E(

>G!%

1",#

PKN

@&vf

< ! (

&B .

(10)

EX! , ‹2 E( ?; ,&( !(

&4, PKN

&vf +, 8 )

? q

& Kh " 0 C5,

89 AB ,

8,& #

&B

# .

< ( Gg + +, M@

): h M@.

?8 !B, q

; , AB 1 R & 9 +, +&

< +

8 )=) f EC:KL

# V#

*,&(

8 #9&(

+ )"

?8, "#&0:

& DL "

+,

‡ ^ m !X',

* @

X 8 )=)

* .

< : ', EB

; , , m !X'

* @

<+

M@

8, !^

AJ@,

< G"

# CN 1

* @ !J!

<+

,

*

!) +

>

@ C'# ,

#

* , ( N E(

(

< #9 ',

# MoN

*. ( h

*,&(

8, "#&0:

( ) ', < !@ ,+9 (.

&

89 +, EX! , T" (

*DB&

< ( Gg + E(

1L+

qcO,

< &B

', EB

&J K€ B m !X', 1 B

*,&(

‡ ^ h + )"

' , "

) Hanke, 2008 (

.

+, E" A"

@

* F R' C5, +

< ( Gg E"

0!

ˆ&"

q . ( * ,

; AB EB (

1 s"

)

&

',

# +,

@

* V %

# ECGV, 3 t' J",&(

) D 6,7(

q &

', 1

? EX=(

ˆ&"

() X * ,

; AB

, '

? E(

Q

* EB ˆ&"

() X

* ,

; AB 8 h

' 2008 E(

94 f ' )

<

',

) Mail & Guardian, 2009

EB (

,

; ˆ&"

M@

8 zg@

ˆ&"

q ,

; AB 1" &X" # ( ',

.

,

; E=

( ˆ&"

: C5, * 89

") D

… f 1 !B . ˆ&"

: C5, * ,

; AB

~h +, ' 1990 EA)g@

v!

1

< ( ',

# X 1 +,

&CgB

;

@ f * : C5, *

")

b 2

1 : . /_#

) ,+9 * C5, * M@

,

; AB ( ) /_

) t

# tf#

"

1" A

', I E(

#

?<\

+, ' 2000

#

~h +,

"&(

>

Zcf, + , *

?E( L ,+9

*

@

* C5, * ,

;

AB ( ) /_

) t :

# 5 /C 89 /_#

) C5, * M@

# E(

S#

0"

? E(

Q

* EB

<+#& , ,+9

*

@

* C5, * ,

; AB EB '+, *

!(

)

&@

C) ]

&(,&(

7 / 22 + , ( 1

< :

? ',

G

>

178 , ) 8

@ AB * t=Ce E(

,

; AB n CS,

< , ', . ,

; AB )

8

42 AB

& 9 R 1 G

>

42 , , .

!zg@

)

?;

Œ e V#

5 / 56 f +, V) {V S "

=S, 1 ,

&(

1

&)L EB ECGV, de(

MsO, ,

; Œ e a &Q +,

‡ ^ h

#

•&5

;C &L V#

+, T" ( DB&

* 3 )

; 1 : EB

M0

&

; V) H 6,7(

q &

,

; AB , XA ) H 1 @ . MoN E",

@

* CS, &h 1

") D ,

;

C5, ( )

? '. ( ˆ&"

E &/

@

# V) -

@

? '. ( l",

€ )

&

E &/

,

* ( )

*

#

% ,

#

", 5 )

;

# -, &R CV#

1 ( ) HXA + '

#

< &C L ', .

!zg@

)

?;

!(

)

&@

C) ] ˆ&"

, , * ,

; AB , ( ) . ( + , ( 1

< &B

# EG !(

*

(CPI) {S : ,

; AB

G >

154 ) 8 179 AB '

2007

%

* EC &L ',

# ,

; 8, ( ' !/

EB X 1

+,

& '

;

@ C5,

*

") , , )

!(

)

&@

C) ] E(

HR"

+, 2V, )!

1

# (...

.

&(

m ', u ,DL V#

< ( Gg + '

2008

? 80 f +, q &

&R a=[

1L "+

1 " &B . 9 89

@

&@

<

(

&(,&

( 13 ,D@

)=) .

< ( Gg + ( EB ( E%

E(

1. hyperinflation.

(11)

`' C ˆ&"

*&(,&(

+ , ' EC:KL / 41 . X & 9 1 : . ECGV,

* ,& , EB

&R

a=[

1L "+

1 " &B 30 f +, / %

>

< ( Gg + ,

H)XA 1 " , EB j go 9

89

@

&@

<

&(,&(

( 100 )=) .

< ( Gg + ( . 100 )=) .

< ( Gg + '

C:KL

>

* c) / 30

!' X & 9 u+ ,

) :,

Draper & Freytag, 2009 (

.

"

#

$% &

' (

8 g@

EB Q

< @ A

? : gO, ' ) '

@

*

* ,&L E"

V#

E( L +

< ( Gg

% : E"

0!

,

; AB E(

/'

>

C5,

* k O gC%, 1 '

")

? ( EX=(

8 g@

) 8,D

E/' ,

* EB :, ,

") D +,

@ ( '

. ' &(

1 {S :

@

* E/' ,

; AB E(

H B Q

,

; j _ 1 ) 3 , !B

EB E , , E(

89

@

@, S ) M S, &h . ' &(

1 ,

; {S :

@

1 ", M@

' }[

/5,#

1 /'

>

,

; AB

# M@

34 )

&

O )!

1 ' ) '

@

*

* ,&L E"

,

+ N C5, 8 A"

@ .

)

$) %

*

!

*

2 {V S "

=

) 1

GNP

- GO(

', +, j go u+ ,

@. B

# - S V)

: 0"

1

E/ % 1Q T ' / )

; . ,

; {S : EC %&(

&

; xC )

&

8 A"

!@

/_#

) 8cB

C5,

* ', .

&(

,

;

?m ', 9

=

) 1

NI

- GO (

', +, u+ , 0"

1

=B )

>

@. B

#

- S V)

< : AB

Q 1 T ' V 1 EB do!' 89 +,

&Q a 9 H , O V)

S, &h

@ 1 ', EB E(

H , O t=Ce L

)

&

AB 1 a=/

&)L . {S : 9

= 1

E",&'

") D +, R ) M {S :

…

&(

/g%

) AB / ))

; 1 : .

&(

m ', {S :

?…

T" (

" 0%

1 +, Ž 2V }[' 9

*

?

@ AB ,

E(

0^

<#&L

@ AB

* ( , ,

* 9

h )

?;

( 9

`' C

# E(

h )

;

? ( 9

`' C

# E(

. (

?

# ( 9 . ( R ) M !(

*

< &B ', .

+

# Gg

<

( V) {V S "

=S, 1 549 . G

>

163 8 0%

# ( 9 E",&' V ' ) E"

460

. G

>

161 8 0%

, E(

S n CS,

< , ', . ,

; {S :

•D%

/_

) t

&

;

@ g"

*

+

< ( Gg {S :

@

* E/' E(

g:

1

# . ,

; g 5

? /' 1

< : ', R E ,

*

()

; +

< ( Gg

#

@ AB

* g@

>

89 +, Ž 2V {S :

@

*

?E/' V) {V S "

=S, 1

?

V) {V S "

= 1

?

# 9 V ' )

"

>

E",&' - f L )

&

.

(12)

J 1 . 7 1 - c7 -

? @ N #G

@

# #. R 6 , F -.

)

…# !f ()

;

==gV, 1 h

? 2010 (

( E%

E(

, g"

. ( 1 ()

!) M +

< ( Gg ( 5.447 )=

) 8 .

&CgB

; V) {V S "

=S, 1

, ) 8

@ AB * g@

E EC:, ', .

@ AB *

", (

? G ,+

)

# G ,+

) T

# N * 9

* G:

) E E(

M@

EC:, ",

? E(

Q

* EB

V) {V S "

=S, 1

? ", ( G ,+

)

# G ,+

) T E(

&

) 27.802 I 20.101 I

# 21.835

)=

) 8 . ', . ) 8 ,

;

@ AB 9

&

R

* ( !%

1 G "

E(

g@

8 J S /_#

)

( )

&C0(

* EC:,

# ( V) {V S "

=S, 1 525.806 )=

) 8 .

& . (

; V) {V S "

=S, 1 , E(

S n CS,

< , ', .

8 :

&B„

', /(

+, 9

&

R

* ( !%

1

?

")

&o E ( V) {V S "

=S, 1 380.226 8 )=)

& . (

; V) {V S "

=S, 1 , ,

; ) 8 , . ) (

(13)

J 2 .

# #. R 6 , F -.@ ? @ N #G c7 - R )

…# !f ()

;

==gV, 1 h

? 2010 (

&(

m ', 9 E(

'

< 9 +,

…# !f ()

;

==gV, 1 h ' 2010

? +

< ( Gg G "

E(

@ AB

* g@

>

S h )

;

&

; 9 {V S "

= 1 ) 5.547 )=

) 8 . ( , E(

S

n CS,

< , ', .

V % E%

', EB

@ AB *

? ", ( G ,+

)

?

# G ,+

) T

") D (

=f

>

gB 1 G "

E(

M@

T C', B&N 1 !!B

# ,&:

`

&(,&(

*

? " , E(

Q

* EB 9 {V S "

= 1

", (

? G ,+

)

?

# G ,+

) T E(

&

) 12.501

? 15.691

# 10.212 . 8 )=)

', . ,

;

) 8

? 9

&

R

* ( !%

1 /_#

) ( ) ( S 1 , G "

E(

'

&

@ AB

? , E(

Q

* EB (

9 {V S "

= 1 354.414 . 8 )=)

& . (

;

%

< J , , , ' .

")

&o E

") D /(

+,

9

&

R

* ( !%

1 ( V) {V S "

= 1 206.664 . 8 )=)

q# q R ', .

) (

(14)

J 3 . ) ' - OcQ,

#

!C ", 1

@

* , 8,&

# 8 0%

E(

HR"

+, T" (

" 0%

1

? 2011 (

(

@ J"

1 , KL E(

,

; , g"

") D 1 () M EB /_#

) +

< ( Gg ,

; {S :

") D

b =[

")

? E(

Q

* EB ( 9 V ' )

"

>

E",&' 460 . ) 8

@ AB

* Y2(

%

< J Mo!h , E(

S n CS,

< , ', .

G ,+

)

#

")

&o E (

=f

>

gB 1 +, M@

T C', h) d 1

? "#

E(

Q

* EB G ,+

) 9

V ' )

"

>

E",&' 1071 .

#

")

&o E 9 V ' )

"

>

E",&' 1180 . , " , . CX"

>

H( 5 E%

,

; , g"

h) A 1

;C &L

", ( ,

; {S : G "

E(

'

&

? ' @ AB E(

Q

* EB (

9 V ' )

"

>

E",&' 6790 .

%

< J

#, , E(

S n CS,

< , ', . 9

&

R

* ( !%

1

") D

( E=f ,

* MB ) 9 V ' )

"

>

E",&' 6090 . ( G "

E(

,

; AB

%

< J q#

', .

8 :

&B„

', G ,+

) T ( 9 V ' )

"

>

E",&' 440 . ) 8

@ AB

*

< :

%

< J

&S9 , B

< &B ', .

g@

)

;

?E[(,

",&'

>

9 {V S "

= 1 , 1 8, X 1 +, M0

&

; {S :

@

* E/'

&@

AB * E(

g:

#9 .

(15)

J 4 . . R c7 - G

#

? @ N e L , 6 1980 1 2011

@ 9 * E(

'

< 9 +,

",&'

>

9 {V S "

= 1 +

< ( Gg Q 1 '

@

* 1980 2011

8 A"

1 @ EB

",&'

>

9 {V S "

= 1 +

< ( Gg '

@

* + €9

;

~h +, bcR", "#

V /C 1 EC:,

? ', , +, ' 2000 ( + €9 ' ) '

@

* - Ncf, + ,

* -&(, E( L

@ : F R' :

* 9 {V S "

= 1 +

< ( Gg C @ )

?M E(

Q

* EB ' 2010 9

",&'

>

+

< ( Gg E(

h )

;

&

; N S ' )

<

', .

$% &

' ( + HDI) (

u+ , O * {S : /'

>

" ", 1

&@

AB EvVr 1 @ , EB ! GO +, : 8, , S&(

*

+,

". Q&gO 1 q•

(

? c'

, 8

&/

+# ",

*

# B M=O

? 8, '&C' 1 E(

l( !

#

- " X , q+.

,&(

* , S&(

* +, L "+

1 ' ! . {S : /'

>

" ", 1 ) J"

)

;

"+#

1

< '

+, E' {S : BK

', .

! ,

>

,

; {S : ()

; O T )

&ŠB, N (

#

&vf ) H5, N ( x ))

&

1 !B .

@ AB 1

HDI (

&(,&(

( 8 / 0

# ()

&CA E(

!O 8,

@ AB

* ( /'

>

" ", 1

?. (

@ AB *

HDI (

&(,&(

( 5 / 0 8 / 0 E(

8, !O

@ AB 1 ( /'

>

" ", 1

`' C

#

@ AB *

( {S :

&CgB +, 5 / 0 E(

8, !O

@ AB 1 ( /'

>

" ", 1 h )

; ERGQ !(

* 1 " : .

(16)

de(

HDI u+ ,

? +

< ( Gg G "

E(

@ AB * ( /'

>

" ", 1 h )

?;

1!/

!B )

#

b !%

,&2f * 9

&

? R }[' h )

;

&

* ,&5 EC &L ', .

!B ) ,

; g 5 : ( S 1 ,

G "

E(

'

&

@ AB

*

&s"

+, S 8 A"

< , ',

# ( {S : 509 / 0

& . (

;

HDI u+ , , ,

1V N I

EB

")

&o E ( {S : 295 / 0 h )

;

&

; EG , G "

E(

'

&

@ AB *

&s"

+, S 8 A"

< , ', .

, g"

+

&

R E ,

* V g%, 1 ) 8 +

< ( Gg

#

@ AB * Y2(

+, N ) Y u+ ,

#HDI

H , O r

&4

&(

E/' - f EC &L ', .

J 5 .

# 3 G

#

? @ N -.@ @

, F

G f HDIgG J

h .P .@

D= 1

http://www.undp.org)

(

de(

HDI :

? +

< ( Gg G "

E(

'

&

@ AB *

&s"

/_#

) H( 5 V G5 1 , +,

S 8 A"

< , E(

Q

* EB

~h +,

")

&o E

%

< J q#

', . 8 :

&B„

', ,

; de(

OcQ, 1 +,

@ AB * b !%

&2f ,

* 9

&

R

#

@ AB * ( /'

>

h )

; '

") .

(17)

: HX 6 . R

>

HDI :

@ AB 1S&( ( < ( Gg + http://www.undp.org

, g"

+

&

? +

< ( kGg +, Ž k2V {S k:

/k'

>

" k",

) 1

HDI

k((

@ AkB *

?8 k0%

@ AB * ( /'

>

h )

;

# B

@ A * ,&2f * 9

&

R +, ' 1980 ' 2010 R E

< :

', . ,

; , g"

8 A"

< ,

< : ', EB +, k' 1980 k' k 1990 +

< ( kGg +, Ž k2V

{S : /'

>

" ", 1

# E(

h)

&A (

<

# ' )

&

/f * ', EC:, .

J 7 . c-

= 1 3 L e 6 , 1980 1 )2010 http://www.undp.org (

,

; '

@ G "

E(

{S :

" 0%

1

=f

>

+

*

? :, , G "

E(

@ AB *

/'

>

" ", 1 h )

;

# ,&2f * 9

&

R "#

&C0(

* , h) d

#

* S EC:, ', . ( ,

;

? N +,

' 1990 E(

] "#

V#D"

1

&B , )h

# ' 2000 ( ,&%, 8 : ' ) ' - Ncf,

+ , * E( L E(

h )

;

&

; 8,D) S ' )

? E(

Q

* EB E"

0!

=f

>

( )

* + ( , g"

" 0%

1 h) ,

? &B EX=(

+,

@ AB

* ( /'

>

" ", 1 h )

;

#

@ AB

* ,&2f * 9

&

R

") D

h )

;

&

? 9 E(

Q

* EB ,

;

@ AB )

@ AB * ( /'

>

h )

;

#

@ AB * ,&2f

* 9

&

R (

1Q '

* @ 2000 2010

&)' /f * , EC:, "

? , +

< ( Gg 8 !zg@

"#

V#D"

1 S ,

(18)

E , , ,

? E(

E" L ,

* EB ,

; !^

' S, )

&

•D%

/_

) t

&

;

@ AB {S :

/'

>

" ", 1

HDI) E(( g:

', < 9 .

+

<# Gg ( {S : 140 /

HDI 0 G

>

169 1!/

>G

&S9

8 0%

, E(

S n CS,

< , EB ',

•D%

@ AB * /'

>

" ", 1 h )

; E(

g:

1

# .

. !

/

& 0 1

X 1 +, {S :

@

* M0 do!' 8,D)

E/' JC 1

? @ AB u&C L

- " X , :+ 9 1

# '&C' 1 8 '9

# , 8 J N9 /g%

) AB

@ E(

- " X , BK

I ', ,& + ,

;

{S :

? @ ) 8,D E%

V#

@ E(

&'

>

" ", 1

#

&' E ,KL * l( !

" ", 1 , E(

8, !O

M0

&

; ƒ&2 :

# /'

>

C5,

*

~X/!

1 + ' . {S :

@ 1 8 zg@

G0(

ˆ&"

G4 q "

d",

?8,+ 9 ,D , d ˆ&"

, ' (

*

? ,D , d ˆ&"

G4 q "

8,&CS m ,

M0'

Œ e u+ 9

# u #&h +, HB V) {V S "

=S, 1 +, E" g"

@

* do!' /'

>

de(

u+ 9 T AB !C @ . +, '

*

?&J '&C' 1 E(

- " X ,

# - S C:, 0(

1

") D X 1 +,

{S :

@

* do!' B ) v ) L "+

1

# 8,D) E/' JC 1 ' @ AB .

+

< ( Gg ( {S : 3 / 892 + )!

>

:, 0(

G

>

110 8 0%

, E(

S n CS,

< ,

', . : 8

&B„

', '

2003

? 7 / 33 f , ,&

•V ( +

<# Gg E(

+ , cCG " ( EB

60 f 8 "9 , 8 "+

H)XA 1 , "

. ,

; E!) + 1 8, E(

{S : , ) E(

L "+

1

< :,

&B . HX:

8

? {S : , ) E(

L "+

1 +

< ( Gg Q 1 '

@

* 1980 2011

, 1 8,

&B < @ A .

(19)

J 8 .

? @ N #G I G D@ c- )

http://www.undp.org (

( E%

E(

, g"

EW, ,

< : 1 8, EB

/_#

) +

< ( Gg +, Ž 2V {S : , ) E(

L "+

1 b =[

")

? E(

Q

* EB +, ' 1990 @ : "#

V#D"

1 ,

; {S : M)C @ EB

EB ,

; {S : '

2005 E(

h )

;

&

; N S 1 ' . +, ' 2005

? @ : :

( ) 1gB ,

; {S : M)C @

? E(

E" L ,

* EB , ) E(

L "+

1 +

< ( Gg '

2011 E(

{S : 4 / 51 1 ' .

23 3 4

, +DB&g 1 E(

!/

* ,KL,#

* Ae(

1 +, , E(

?aQ ! d@ B V / )

@

* CV#

1

# 8 &•' 89

E(

de(

f S

1 E(

s!

,D , d B , 1 +,

&Q a B A

&

1

| 1 C( 5 1

?

/'

>

C5, * )g@,

#

<\

,

* EC ', . ,

; + ) E!

? +

< ( Gg ( () X * 94 f

*

HgO O

* +, B A

&

1 ',

?

|

* C( 5 1 89 gB

$"&

< : ',

# de(

f S

1

%

< J

<\ #

*, ,

; AB , "

. +

< ( Gg '

2010

?

# )

; AB R )

&

8 0%

< ( ', .

2 , F D@ J gt; 6 9&lt; 9 H @ = 1 9&gt; 6 7

) :

!" # (

2 , F D@ J gt; 6 9< 9 H @ = 1 9> 6 7