! )
: 7 / 4 / – 91 :
3 / 7 / 91 (
/ :
"
»
$% & ' ( ) * + , - .( ( )
1«
1 )
234 4 1) 56 6 * 7 8 4 ' 1 * 1) $ 9:4 ; ( $
1 < = " -4 ( 8 > , .
( ) 3 ) 1) " 54 $ 9:4
@ 1 < = , < 4 $ A B C D C 4; )
E FG
9( H & ' .( < 9* E 4 $ ( ) I J
.
$% & ' K ; 1 ! 8 + - 8 9* K 4 " 1 :, ) $L4
; ) 14 I
M N ( ) I 5 . ) (
I9 ; 8 EO P @
6 E H 9
.
$Q :
$% & ' 2 9(S ( ; ) 2 .( 2 , - 2 ( ) I
.
ir . c a . ut
@ naieniali :
*
1Beliefs and leadership in world politics: methods and applications of operational code analysis, edited by Mark Schafer and Stephen G.Walker, first published in 2006 by Palgrave Macmillan.
!" #
$%
&'()
%*+
, -. / 0 1-223 -45 6
-2 &78
9 6 :2 -; .
<
=# %# > ? , (%( =@%45 &5 ; AB"
-%3
- .
& D5 6 =!" 28
$%
&'() 6 ED > 2;
0 # 3
F';
=
=5 - %G =# %# > ? , (%( 3
%*+
>H
&78 %I. 0
=5 -2 .
# $ J H 3 # 1 K @5 1 ( L BIM25 <
N 7I
< -2!O %I. 1-2 P I
0 &D!O5 =# %# > ? , (%(
%I.
&78 =Q "
=5 R-2
0 ST
# U2Q > T 6
V I) @5 > WX YT 0 %O =# %# > ?
Z%(
='A > G- %G X3
> -%3
!8 - . 5 :%! = L ?
>- [B
$%%? \ "
E%T , -. > %5 E2 > T =2%
6 0 %
>- :2G &%'4
:2 5
# 0 =X YT
> 0 T
$%
&'()
!X%
N O]
-8 .
8 ^ 5
% M _ !3 3 $M%!#
»
?
# %#
> 9Q 3 98
= %'(; > Ga5 &%'4
«
=c# T L ?
$ 0 % -2!O d-d .
_ !3 ='A e4
3 # =2!?5 =!" 28 1 aG $
»
= ( 0 > 2;
=2 f 3 &(; %I. 0 1
g%h
# %#
%( > 9Q
%O -
«.
> G-2O
$ a3 ( '@5 $ _ !3
" 3 -
Wi
> -(!# %#
6> jW!# %#
=Q " # %# " , (%(
3
&5 8 4
%4Q g@#
6 Y !#
6
k%!3 V -.
# l f c
=5 -223
"R . 9 H -2!O m h 5 $ $%%? =T
Wi 3
> 2;
0 # 3
=F';
, (%( - $(h 1 3 &(;
6 0 =# %# > ?
&78 %I.
1
=!" 28 , X G 9 H
:25
=5 8 . Q 5 5 $
=5 8 3
- -Q , ;B<
?) . ! &78 %%n %45 0 L ]
= 8 o - -Q -
.
=2I _ !3 &5 3 > 2;
"
98 l> 9Q # %# ?
&p%'4 p 3
= %'(; > Ga5
"
-%3+ > G-2O 3 - =5 > X p" 1 M!p# p5 [ 1Y
7 > 2; >H P &%O !T 2d pi =p# %# 1- -T I) @5 # 2X
-p =(!O%# g@# i g@#
. p!45 &p%'4 p =p2!?5 _ p!3 =p# 28 [
[ L-5
0 # &%'4 0 2%50 $ 3 #
> Ga5 p%'(;
=
operational code analysis)
(
- %G =5 1 9 V : =(3 , A 3
=5 8 .
= %'(; > Ga5 &%'4
$%!Oc '%p# p
) $ S!%
Z9
=GY k X'
G . 1 M!# 5 .
- Op7) -pI pQ
q
Ga5 =p# %# p V p > 2; =# %# > ? = %'(; >
!Op p Z%( p
V -.
. Q 5
.
!# 92 S!%) 3 =) ] p 3 o [ $ 0 %) -2
, pA $p q pQ 3 6 92X%T ZO X' Z9 V " ='3 = A 92 6 !9 2I5 -
%) -2 8
=
=Q p" p# %# 0 = p 10 p] $%p%? -2( -. 1 D) - -Q
3 & -?
. E " 5 ,P r# ='%'4 =M%3 7 [ $ 3 >H &%) l
0
2%50 V L I k%27 )
Verbs In Context System
( !45 &%'4
=(3 = Wc# T
5 ,P J#
=5 1 9 =# %# E23 s
%G .
" a3 ( 2%50 V L I k%27
= 2c# 6=5 (; =A " , % 5 6
8 6
?] 5 6 S M23
5 5 > W L . &D &%'4 1 . 1- %G Z%( = ; ?@5
=( . 1 M!#
- .
=M%3 7 0 " E -%T 0 dH 0 = %'(; > Ga5 &%'4
Q 5 a% =t(3 7 0 1 M!# %" =) =5 1 9 1 E:2#
# ! G . u'!c5 > WX YT .
'A [ =t(3 7 $ '(Q 0
at-a-)
distance
(
l #
I5 $
=GY 3 =2
# 2X Z%D!O5 =# !# > - =
>H = M8 L I s ?2!#
=5 . =t(3 E:2# 5
%G .
1Yp p =Q p" p# %# Zp9 >H %G 7 =G !OG [ $ 0 # =t(3 1 WX 1 WX W %" 7 5H
# 1 3 k(3 .
a5 &%'4 = %'(; > G
)+O5 =# %# =# 2X I) @5
»
" $% , -. / 0 W
« 1 p3 1 8 p >H
1- -T > 2;
=5 -('. =; (!Q p" p5 =# %# V 3 -23
pW
0 ,B5 I $ =W Wi 1 &78
=5 . %OM 5 , -. 25 -p
.
$p 0 [
v" 8
= 10 G -23 =5 1 M!#
3
>H p ?O [ W 1 4 1-223 $%%?
p#
. 5
s 5 L v" 8 =MO'
5 p s 5 V v" 8 p
-2!Op ap .
ap p p" 0 > p% > p9Q p ?Op 98 W W ( =MO'
[ W G
-28 =5 = .
v" 8 $ 0 -2 ?;
:
1
=# %# > 9Q % 5 :
6 !#
( " 6=?%3 6
m
? :
;0 25 6=?%3 6 7(
2
[0 v%cX
=# # :
=2% - =2%?8 "
7 1-8 f c {- m
3
=# %# > 9Q =2% E%T %' . :
Z3
0 8
jT kO : [ jT 6[ jT V-;
4
=c ,P 4 L !23
: Z3
0 9
V -. > 50 %(
. 5 S 8 ED : 0 Z3 10
a 0 1 M!#
: 0 Z3
> G-2O 5 )
V &
( L I > 3 a5 =W Wi s 5 &o O5 6
1 . =# 5 9 " 8 E:2#
&] 5 25 $ - 5
-223 =5 > % 0 G :
1 - , 9~ ='I , ?; &I $%%I
2 -
&5 8 L I > 3 a5 :
u) ( t-I!5 L I = # 28
_ (
?•5 [0 $%%I L I 3 =2I5 $ - l &I =M25
Q 7(
( " L I ?•5 [0
-2!O " =M25 [0 0 .
L I
- %G =( . =# 5 a% =•2"
.
q ( G - s 5 &I > 50 72 $%%I
!8j
72 # - =5 € 1-2 H L ]
.
( L I 3 4 $ - l L I ,-8 0 -2 !# o
> (•5 [0 0 , 0 :5
) 3 - ( - -9 6 ) 2 - ( 6
M) c5 ) 1 - ( (] 6 ) 1 (+
6
$!O > (%T )
2 (+
0 %!5
[0 0 [ T )
3 (+
-2!O "
.
!8jG L I
[0 X%(
3 + 3 - -28 =5 .
3 -
# " 5 &I 3 =2I5 $ - l &I L (8 10 ] $%%I 5
W .
4 - R # 1 ! ƒ M 'rO5 i 5 3 =2I5 $ - l &I m h 5 $%%I
5 - 1-8 jGa5 L I = 9 -2 /(Q
=# 2X 7 > 2; = %'(; > Ga5 &%'4 3 -2!O D!; $ > G-2O
=5 -45 % BD; =2!?5 I) @5 >
&%'4 1- -T K @# =# %#
$% =(!O%#
3 &'() .
N # $ 6
& _ !3 > G-2O 6Z9
Z 1 0 Z 0 2%50 V L I k%27
L-5 =2%%? %n!5 > 2;
=5 1 M!# 5H -223
&
Z:2T a% Z!X
1 $
!O %n!5 > 2;
=5 - %G .
& 3 $M%!# M%8 ^ 5 5 0 1 M!# Z!M ZX8 6V 9i 6V #
0 r
7 $ !9 6&t(75 [ > 2;
? Q 5 %G Z%(
0 ) . & D5 1- %G Z%(
1 3 = 0 ? Q =2 f
&
-2i
=5 > 50H < _ !3 0 - jG
.
_ !3 »
> 9Q # %# ? «
&(!X5 6
='A Ec 12
0 &
; (:5 288
# 1-%# „ i 4MA .
Ec M%8 ^ 5 3 $M%!#
0 Oc
L &
!3 _ = %'(; > Ga5 &%'4 E -%T \ " e] ?5 o $(h
6>H s 5 ,P 4 =#
0 $% ƒ 4# =2 f T > (%8
N
1970 1990
!" T
> X
=5 2 - 3 $
\ "
- g'A 6
> Ga5
-2!O% > O7 = %'(;
:%!
? , M!5 E%T
=5 - %G .
=5 > X … !
3 - N T > (%8
$% ƒ 4# ?O
? 1 3 f c a%5H ;0 25 )
v" 8 6 (
# $r(@5 !(3 =c ,P 4 L !23 " = \ "
) v" 8 4 (
=) l
!O $% - _ ; g'A † =2% E%T \ "
-2 .
V Ec 6
I) @5 >H 3 †%D4 =# 28 [ s 5 &o O5 > G-2O
=5 =# !X% , %oaQ =Q " # %# , (%(
-223 . V Ec 4 _ !3
> 2;
"
98 :
=(# 9)-5 !45 &%'4
"
& &5 8 V
V #
# .
&
V
M!# 1-(; <
0 1 2%50 V L I k%27 , ;B< !45 &%'4
> ? -2 D?< = 0 25 Q 5
=# %#
a3 ( .
M%8 ^ 5
W &5 8 %G Z%( 1 %# ?IQ 3 - 8 =5 3j!5 V & 3 $M%!#
3 0 #
#H 3 # K @#
l-2!O% N !# & . =
$ 2
6 Z9
1 3 -%T %G Z%( 1 %# ?IQ > 3 # 0 % =Q " # %# , (%(
Z 8 k a A 2; $ " 28 .
1- %G Z%( 6Z9 $ Z95 aQ 0 =7
>H [ W =W Wi
# . s 5 &o O5 6& $ 5 K @5 _ !3 =# 28 [
-8 1 8 >H &?. (O. 3 8 =5 .
\ " s ?2!# r 0 1 M!# a% V # &
, 4%Q )
Theory of Inferences
about Preferences
( 6 o =# %# > ? -%'3 0 =; h 5 -2 D?<
=5 -23 .
'% 5 W G
3 $M%!#
& $ 6 0 ST / .
?!3 U2Q 1973
&78
0
, # =2 f
0 1 M!# $% ƒ 4#
v" 8 L
6 V 3 ZX8
-8 3f !X%T l
† =# !# 1 3 &%'4 6
'O 6
$ O $ Z%'O
. ]B5 5 _ i i
=5 -2 . , # =2 f 0 -%3+ 3 -2 =5 > X 9 H
3 -23 =5 =2% E%T -23 _ c! Q 5 /h ‡M] # %# - 5 3 # $
& D5 { <
Z
$ -23 =5 f c # %#
.
/h ‡M] # %# - 3 # >H 1-2 > X $% ƒ 4# =2 f 0 = < 0 3 _ c! Q 5 Q 5 /h %%n # %# (# 5 3 -23 =5 =2% E%T 1
3 ] - -Q 2 aG _ c!
-23 .
–
> 2; 4 _ !3 V 9i Ec
"
3 :
? 10 ]
-
> X5
"
0 &7X!5
V 9i L
# Z:2T .
X 3 , 7#
'
&
V 9i
&%'4 ƒ ?@ *
G0 # !" #
10 ] , M!5 = % nQ =!# %#
=5 0 T . 5 $
u'!c5 , ;B< O D5
=#
%*+
0 Oc i , G 5 S%'W
='A > X5
John nott ,Francis pym ,Geoffrey Howe ,Nigel Lawson) (
# %#
=Q "
S%'W V :
=5 8 . 8 0 i 2% 3 -8 •; , M!5 u I > G-2O
%*+
. E:2# 5 2% 3 =!# %# = W(
=5 -2 . 25 $ 3
L # -27) U2Q - 1982
L # = 2Q D H Z 4 6 1986
s 5 e] ?5
9 7(
!.
=# 5 I) @5 > 2; T
=5 - 8 . :%!
3 # >H
Z%( 0 =" ,B ( =Q " # %# ='A &o O5 5 ) > { 78 > %G
=5 s 5 a%5H ;0 25 7 > 3 L ? i 2% 3 > X5 8
.
%O
0 5
> 9Q % 5 i > X5 l ( " =# %#
) v" 8 1 (
=2% - 0 6 -22% =5
) v" 8 2 (
kO [ jT V-;
) v" 8 8 ( 1 M!# 1 " 9 %G Z%(
a 0 0 )
v" 8 10 ( - & ( .
> O% V #
&
Z:2T 2% 3 I) @5 q Q
[
=5 0 T s 5
> Ga5
= %'(;
9(Q S%
E X5
> ( T u'!c5
/@D5
&?.
0 -I
11
?5 !ˆ#
2001 O D5
=5 -23 . ,B(] $ = : %G , * 5
9(Q S%
> X5
='A [
= 0
=5 8 . 0 =7
! 3 # >H & $
0 -I [ 11
?5 !ˆ#
2001 3 %%n %W(Xi <
1 7 ;0 25
# 1-8 ) d /h 5 .
$ 2
6 3 %h $
> 4 . :
%%n , 2I5
Z!O%#
=5 l- 8 -% W - 8 o 0 ST
=5 8 . V ED > %5 $
$ a% [ > X5 . ]B5 5 7 %%n
=5
%G .
1 3 &(; &D!O5 %n!5 > 2; i 2% 3 s 5 I) @5 , M
# %#
! jW g%h
=5 l-2
%n!5 [ 2% 3 7%) ]
!O -2!O
# T 3
^ 45
%%n =Q " %45
=5 -223 .
> 2; %%n $
3 0 # F';
&(; =
=5 -223 0 -I [ 2% 3 =Q " # %# , %%n 3 11
?5 !ˆ#
-223 =5 $%%?
.
!"#$ %& '&
Ec
> 2; 4 _ !3 V 9i
"
3 :
&'() $% %25 10 ]
"
3
&7X!5 0
L 6ZX8 Z!M Z!X
# 6
&%'4 3
> Ga5
= %'(;
? s (I5
=!%25 , I) @5 10 ] =X YT
%G =5 . ]B5 5 .
=‰%) 5 > 3H &
6ZX8
3
=2 f 9 0 &%'4
Subjective games) (
ui G $% = T
> W
# U2Q 9!
6
=#
1 3 , *
= : %G -2
^ 45 V =Q "
_ c! )
>H 5
= 0 .
=5 - . N # $ 6 & D
> W &5 I
!# ( " E2% %%n 0 ! G . =# 5 = 50 /@D5 # ui G )
S7I) ( W -7 ?O ? $ 8 =5 !MG $c#
. 0 -2i =' P %%n $
7 5H 9(Q # $ 1 W m %%n '(Q 1 € > 9Q ?O 8
%G =5 . E:2# 5 G 1 9 " 8 0 1 M!#
. U2 > % &
Z!M =#
?
$%i > %5 0 -I = 50 /@D5 >
> X # U2Q
=5 - Wi 3
, M
" 0 > %5 ?8 3 > W
'%#
> 4 k L < ='A > W 0
$%
=''()
=5 8
# %# f c
- ED
.
!X% 1 W , %*+ > %5 $
7( 6 !#
$%i 9(Q S% o $%Q 2%?8 " Q > %?o 8 $i ?O
/h 5 7 5H ) " ='" , c! &5 ; ED a% > 9(Q S%
8 =5 =# ='(; =. D] ?2Q 0 > LBD!# \ " ? $ .
&
Z!X U L 8 6 7# 0P [ W a3 (
=GY 23
0 $
> ?
=!O 6
=!% c8 , %A "
, M
> Ga5 = %'(;
>H
W ?O
=# %# > ? )
65 M ( . ]B5 5
=5 - .
, M †%D4 !
-23 =5 -% + 1 G $ # 28 > 0 =GY .
!"#$ %& & ( )
-2O
> G Ec
> 2; 4 Z:2T
"
3 :
&'() $% =# %# !. 10 ]
"
6
=# %# !. 10 ] = %'(; > Ga5 &%'4
$%
&'()
Š
L (;
=5 -223 .
0 Ec $
&
6Z9 Z Z 0 3 # 1-8 &%7X 10 ] 5 I) @5 k
-
1Y &5 8
=5 8 . T 3
&
Z9 0 1 M!#
Z 4
!.
'%#
#‹
1 3 =# 7 5H 9(Q L # $% = 50 10 3 -# =5 :%! $
1966 2000 > 9Q ?O 7 5H (Q #‹ !# 1 W 3 1 G 6
?
0 1 M!# l1 !(3 9 H Q 7(
# 1-8 !X% !. Z 4 a
.
!
='" %n!5 O D5 9(Q S% %n!5 3 - =5 > X )
#Π$! G
P I '%#
='" ,B7X5 0 =5 (; 7 > 3 { 425 V 5 9(Q S%
(
=''() $% %n!5 )
& D5 X3 E2 0 (
* 6 =2I5 ,
!X%
# %# f c
Z 4 .
> O %!# %!5 &
Z : , B!" =#
‹ 9(Q # 7 5H
3
!. 9!# %# f c jG %*+ 9 " 8 0 k
=5 X3
0 T .
=# %# 9 G- 3 - =5 > X 1-2O ! $ !X% 6 9(Q #‹ = c!
!. # %# ED
5 $ 3 X3
Z%( V %(
-9 =5 1 -% + 95 6='A > G- %G .
a > 5 3 &
Z 0 0 $! G 1 9 a%
2%50 V L I k%27 ED
k #‹
a3 5 9 -] =. 8 %#H X3
9) # !. > 4 &A 1997
1999 -5
> 4 =) 5
D@25 $ 1 8
1 3
%*+
= %'(; > Ga5
=Q " # %# ! >H s 5 )
. Q 5 D@25 $ 9
=5 - .
=5 > X & $ ! 3 -
T X3 $ a3 5 97 #
"
a2%3 U2 -
=! 3
"
# 1-8 2
N # 3
- =5 &%7X 7( >H .
& D U2 $
"
r k%#B3 =3P U2
k%#B3
"
=) 5 L ? € , ?* !8 . =''() $% =) 5 9 , a : 0 !# "
? 1-8 ! jT =''() $% = 9Q !. 0 3 5 l-23 =5 L ? .
E:2# 1-2O
X3 a3 5 k %45 # 9 H &5 I #‹ $ \ " ZX8 L 9 " 8 :%! $ =''() $% =) 5 9 9 X3 Q 5 =# %# Z!O%# 6 5 3 -# =5
k #‹
5 X3 a3 5
a
> 9Q Q 7( , f
%*+ 6=# %#
=
# !8 jG Q e4 5 X3 ='5 >B3 !. Z%D!O5 .
V : # 3 $M%!# M%8 ^ 5 Ec
ZX8 = T & 3
%G :%!
# l
2; = %'(; > Ga5 &%'4 1-2 H 5 >
=X YT
m 5 1 . Q 5
, < ? u'!c5 > %5
5 W 0 =X YT 45
5
!" # =X YT
45
%*+
1-2 H >H
# %#
e4 > 9Q
=5 -223 .
* +*
='3 <
6
!45 !" # 0 _ !3 1 " Z:O25 =
† - -Q =
E
$% 10 ] > YT
=5 0 &'() -23
. -I!5 5 , I) @5 _ !3 , . @D
>H
# 10 ] 3
! G . =# 5 u'!c5 = 50 /< D5 , M!5 =!# %#
- .
=5 a% _ !3 uIh s D 0
>H 1 M!# 5 [ s 5 9?%#H >
&%'4
1 3 1 8 .
=# %# E23 % 5 &%) X3 =# %# > ? s 5 = M8 L I
Q 0 ?!;
-2!O% " P > 2%(<
. W uIh
\ " $
=5
$ 0 -
=# %# > ? # 0 1-8 > % , 9~ 6 9 50 0 3 -8 . -A D5 &%)
1 ?!; :%! ! G " U 6\ "
=5 . 8-" 5
%G .
= < 0
$!5 l=# %# > ? , 9~ 5 ="
3 # 1-8 Z% 2 E%T 0 = '%#
, 3 1-8 %9 =!) > aG 3
O% > -(!# %# =I@. W ( .
> ( MG - > T
!8 9~ > G-2O 3 G
, M =" l- 1
s 5
2%50 V L I k%27 O D5 > -(!# %# 1-8 1 5H &?. 0 , 9~ s 5
>H 9 - !c%W " , 9~
=5 1- 8 . 8 Q 5 - ? &o O5 $ !?) 3
1- - 0 %O $%%? = %'(; > Ga5 &%'4 [ P &%O !T = T 8 ! G .
