1
./01 2 /34 5 6
) :
22 / 2 / –93 :
19 / 7 / 93 (
5 7
89$ : !;<
/+ = 2 3; < > . ? 2@ ? => A )4
/B B> :1
./ 6! 7 $<
C D A .
F$ <
/G
H (I )4
< 5
< ( B JK .
:> LM ./0 > !?
/6$
5< B B BN/> B?
. .< B . OB B :B !;<
C P
$ ? :1 :>
8< 4
<
Q/R . /L? ( =S R B 5
. B /0 $ B ?
2@ < /TU0 . /L? 0 V ) :>
: 8
+/ 1 :1 .
B $ B > D 2 / . ?
:0 $ 34
#S . ?
< N W N B X K
B 1 . /BG FB$ <
YZ
B0L[ 60B % .< . O /0 $ > 1 :1
.
\J4 :S F$
< 60 % F$ 6 67 0
) ( B ! . B > /N ^MB$ /4
; (
<
-
< 6 ?/
G -
> $< /> 2 4 .
. 1 2 8`
- 6 ?/
.< . O B
B /0 $ aB ; ^MB$ /4
4 JK
; ( ! . > /N ( JK .
1.E-mail: [email protected]
!"#$% & '() * + , - , . ,/ 0 1 ,2 3
*
/ 456 7 58 9% :' .
-,- 3 '() * +
,<
, =1 >, ) 9# 9-5 >
?@ ,/ ,/ A ,%
/ B -,- 9 C * + +
9 D E 3 /
, ' % <
*5 5@
A 9% 5 F '() , ' 5 >
. 9 -,- G :C C
H
&I J% K (%
*> L% * M 9"% +% , 5% ) G :C 9"% +%
H 9 % ' 2 % 5
, K
9%
9N NO 9/ , 5/
,P '() * + * Q- H
R S
,#+
H 9 "% +% ,
, 9%(/ * ?:@
H 8+@ > ,#T #8I U
5V%
C H C5 5?
WX
56 :C
. 9? 5
45 5F G / H
Y, C , 9%(/ * ?:@ 9"% +% * , W 9
@ 9 % Z
Z 9/ , <
,N 9#Y, 3 < %
9%
6 . C ,S < ,#+
U 1960 ] / ^ _Z
_ ,F 4 C 5V#% ` D > # ,T F 9 a aV * b
Z
=8 6 H5 6 D 5 = ,%
U
*
7 #% ,N 5= ?@ ,/ ,/
9%
+<
' :L% 5 7 = ,F C 5 #/ > *
9 =#% C
5+ % 9 %5S * , < /
% ,- H 4 C
=% HcV * C
1- * ,#+ * -
9#
) O (
5+O T#
/
=86 * , * U
> d 9 ?@
C 9% G$/ = * 5 -
.
,#+
H
?+
8+@
U ) 8 d( a B
C % ) 8 e,# -
4 f W H*
=86 C
=86 9/,#/ H9 W " * C
8+@ , N > C T < > * 9" < * C
*
) 8 d(a /
. -,- G 9
C
% , G
I 7 ":
H4 ,Pg % a ,#T
5 ++<
b
,#+ * C, Ph 5
. Y S 1 < ,#+ % H #6 9
9"% +% 7X % -
R S *
i 8 :
1 . j:< '() T# ,#+
9%
+<
5 B
2 .
4 ,:- '() T# ,#+
j:< 45++<
9%
+<
5 B
3 . +
* Q-W% '() T# ,#
j:< 456 9%
+<
5 B
4 . Y, ,#+
C 9
* = ,S * ,
% / C * S /, > , N *
C
lC , 9%
+<
5 .
5 .
9 N:C 9N# ,#+
*
=86 U O n=
9 % @
/ G =:% Z
56 l ?/ 9"% :< ! &M
) H^ ,8IZ 1385 : 169
.(
,N ,#+ 56 9
C 9F *5@ * B
, O % 9%
: K' . +% 5+
9
>
=86 j 9/,#/
U Y,' > * A a% F 9 ?@
C ) e> %Z Hp +C, H L
(...
5 H5 Z /
4 6
?@ % * C Z * C,JS
S %Z . 9 Hj6 G 5 /
% q5C AW"#
A 5E
* C
%> H 6 + WC,F H,
H 5 r F 4 ,:# % / .
* + G
@
" E C
, V+% , *
*5 5@ * I E < * , 2,' *> L% * M A
/ 4 ,<
H 7 I /Z
*, QF ,
< 9 s / D , ,
1#/
4 C
%,L% ,V+% *
H t5t C / #$ N , W *5@ * 9- /
9 :
, , Y, C *
9 e :6 H lTO Z * C5 5? >
,< 96 F .
e( I a% G 9%
6 9"< 9#S +6 1Ig% >
C
*> L% * M 9 "% +% *
?u 3 9# +% * ,8C ] V%
4 /
6 9F
Z H 9N NO ,#+ , Ph
> , 9%(/ * ?:@ 9"% +% , 4
C 9 N+C, 9/ / H9# +% H9% K * )
9/ , 9"<
6 .
e( ' M 5 ?
9%
6 +% , 5% * C ,8C 9S,
*> L% * M , 9%(/ * ?:@ 9"%
6 9 ,&%
. G , + H G# I a% G q5 C
/ F f/,F G 9 %5a% * C C
/ :
- , w 9 "% +% A ?1% 9# +% * ,8C ] V% NO *> L% * M ,#+
9%
C 5 x
- 5 5? , 9%(/ * ?:@ 9"% +% * , NO ,#+
>
9%
6 x
-
5E O , 9%(/ * ?:@
A C 9 ,#+ J 5 C A L 5
5 #
x > ,n 9"% +% , 5% 9 S
>
b 9"% +% '() * + H
)
#/ / 3 :&%
fC y F
* C
*, K A L
8' < # ,- /
>
: 1 . ,K C fC y F
* C 9% :' b
&% @ U 9 '() B
2 . fC yF
* C
":' R S
/ +% 9% K
,8 B 3 . 9# +% &I J%
. G - fC yF H C
j ,#T 4 *5&
H '() * + , Ph 9 "% +% , ,#+ R S
7% 6
9:
B 6 / , #? G , +
" E C * ,K
* C ] 9" Y G
I 9 "":
H 9 +&
E . ,-
19 l I ,8 I H 4> / 2
3* N
, 1 G 8
@ *> L% * M 9"% +%
6 G fC yF za C
6 q,), .
E l F .
,- 9 H + / 9C -5 ,-
/ 9 % C * , 8C &I J% 5
I
K V%
9%
,- 3 :' 9%
+<
5 . 4 -5 G { / , H
d( a D E @
* C
,@ Hl , H9% E 98CQ%
/ l
%>
& / *> ,N HG %> 56 A,- # U
+%
U
+% A ?1%
. 3 ,8 I l F H
Ja U E l F 7 a%
. ,- , E 9 9 % - , B G
1. Realism 2. Liberalism 3. Constructivism
l F H ,N > ,|< , G
I
# G & 9"S 9/ / 7% ' :C H7":
G I 9 "":
I C 4 N @
* C ? G
I
# 5' E G & 9"":
5 <h 9 #I ,N >
9 % 6 .
H9->
GC <
* 1
, 2
, Ph 4 6 lC +% , '() * + 4 ,<
5 B , ,#T ? Z %
/Z , QF
* C 5 <h * #E *
#6 5 .
* )
'() * + 5 5? l a# %
4 6 / 4 ,=
B A, 5E A ?1% % a#' Z <3
H / +% K+% G * ,
/ .
> / l F 4
* N H 5 <h &E L 9N NO , 1 , H45 6
, G H
>
E . ,-
"Y l I ,8 I 9 9% # ,-
6 . F G l H
&E C 9' :#@ * )
C C
+%
&1 C ( S /
# U D :#@ / /
F G , + H4
A 5 % 5 I > 5 I },&%
/ . G >
H*
> / 4 , * N E q(S .
,- l I ,8 I 9 H
9 F :&
l C i ,T % *
9"< / .
4> / 9 ,-
~,) 7 "V +% > *, F A ?1%
9 / / * C ,
*
>
4 ,< j:< 9# +% / / /
, > B 9"< .2 % j b
+%
4 /
9 : 6 H
, ="
+ %>
5 <h Z 9%
6 .
> / 4 N b
*> L% * M +%
H 5 5? ,
C>,% D 9# C * C>,% 4y
* / >
5 5 <h 9 '() p+@
. V , *> L% * M b
V p+@ > • b
A L G# ,- 9% , Ph Z Q-
.
*> L% * H
&E % >, %
9% G > 3 S ,
Eriksson, 2006)
.(
I a% G H 56 #1- r Z @ H
C >
C
> / 3 ,8 I * 4
G 8 * , N
4,? *> L% * M 9"% +%
* , 9%
6 B :& , =+ G:2 l
C ,T % * i
l C
" :=
9 C
* 5 <h 7C *,K 9%
6 .
5+ Z &2 > 9#/ • l # =+ * , b
l 6 # 6 9"% +%
H C % / A>`
l / +T ,#? Z , ,#% * ,8C 9# +% ] V% *> L% * M .
M G H ', /
< 9 '()
=:%
/ G 6 , 1 3,#+< H7a#+%
H -
*, N:T O U f W
9 % B5
'() e ,- G +r:C H
,
%> / G C
N , 9 "% , 9 "% ,N >
f W 9%
C 5 .
W '() 3 a# ,u
- U
*, N:TO 9% 9 W
5 . , G H
% , 1 3 a# 9 '() ,#T , a
8/
9%
6 : l , - > 9 "J% , -5
1. Keohane 2.Nye 3.Soft Power
,N S H ?@
, 5 Z /
: Z { /
l , - 5++< * . '() , ' * + H
q J&
,N > 5 C S f W '() e ,- *, QF 9 %
5 + . +% € , /
'() 5 , '() - -
5++< G %h f S > % .
'() * + {,#/ 9 > 7 I
H*, QF *5+:
9?@ 6
G , , a * ,
aJ+% ,N > C T<
lC , 9 ?@ * 9%
+<
* , / G=:% < 5 5 T < fI O
6 4 1#/ ,N 5 5?
. '() , ' H
W I , C
<, 6 H C
5 +O * H9 # "%
%> / C 4 ,- H9#I , t * , 9 +@ * C
C p +@ / G =:% , 9#
98 ,$ 9 '() 5++< A 5E
. '() * + H
H9C5 %, + %> ,N > 9
f W f S ,% V * C , i 8 * ,E, 3,#+<
9%
C 5 B G :C
.:@ )
* Z
• E '()
b 5+: Hq 5C
* C j:< 7&1I 4 aI +:6 * C ,=":' 9%
+<
5 .
9"S ,K >
H
5+: L '() * +
* C
I 9/ / * #E H9' *
C
j:<
9%
+<
5 . q J& *5+: H ',/ f W H5 5@ 9# +% ] V%
() e ,- *, QF 8 / '
I 6 3,#+<
, C '() ‚ ,S
9%
6 .
> 9S, I
C 9& / 9 % +<
5 +
5++< 3,#+< '() >Z 9/,#/
) 9 J"/
y : 1386
B(
'() e , - , C T < G
3,#+<
H5 G F ƒJ / 5 % 9E 5 + % *, N 9' :#@ * #E > %
&/
7:V#% 9N#
9%
6 5
) ,8IZ H^
1385 : 53
.(
*> L% * M , Ph f W ,
* +
C *
I < / 456 @ % 9% K C
,- 9# ]/ #% * 4
8 6 * C 9% K
H
~( / 9 C
+< 5 F 9/,#/
+ 9% E ? Z < 5
> /
@ N+
9 5E " a% a#%
C
# ,T F * U
S, 9% K 5 W
.
* E * C T < "' p+@ > tZ * , , a * C T< 9 H
, ' 9 -y
7 "V 9S, 5+O,C < / '() 4 ,< 4 6 Z 9% K ,-
5 H 4 ,# - ) b
/ 45T cV Z
) H>,@
1384 : 240
.(
,#+
',/
7 1V%
* C 9 :"' H 9C NT H
/g%
* C
E * L
/ 456 9 ?@ ƒJ/ .% @ * #
.
9 -,- G :C
9 *,T / a / B
lC >
+<
9%
, Ph q _ :C , Z U
8+@
C
5 5: *
% , w G
. + %> > 9 = C
H / 45 6 9 / / 9 -,- e $# / < 9
.:@
/ '() > 4 1#/ * Z .
E , V+% Y S "
,#+ , -
*
, H = (S < / C
4 N#/ 4y
„ W * C T < 9 '() * C H
=8 6 >
U
4,? !"#$% 5Y a% * , ,#+ 9 ?@
9%
- 5 , . 9 %> / ,N > G b5 '
> * >
, U |%
'() ``
* , ,#+ > 1
9 / / @ A,@ d = 6
b 5 5@
H 9 +&
1. Information brokers
> 9/ / @ 4
=86 C * 4 1#/ * 9%
+<
5+
) H9 1386 : 34
.(
/ 4 ,# - +O ,#+
<
5 I j
9:
Z 5 3,#+< 9#
5+<
.
> ,#+
4 aJ+% L U
* #E
E C T< :< 52 O n= 9 ?@
7a# % * C T < :< 5#E H*, QF
7=T%
9%
5+<
.
> ,% ?@
H '() 3 8 ) 8
% / G =:
*, ,
9% K * #E H9/ /
^=', Z w%
H Z 5 a
% / G =:
z a
L 9 (=T%
5+<
. h V * > 5 C T< 9% K 5E
* #E 5 E , P
? Z / B
<,6 5E lC * #E 5E C
/g%
* C
* L 9N#
4> ,% <
5E G H f
= Z >
C` < ` V% 4 8 5 I 4> 5
H 6 *, - lL
4 C
? Z 9) 8 5E 4> 5
9% *, - 6
.
'() 9/,#/ =%
H ,JS
* C 5@
*5
9#I * L * C ? * ,
4 Z @ B
, G D 2 %
* C 5 5@ 9 # +%
9 a / / 4 ,< 5 F ?u * .
9' :#@ * C , H
,- 9+&
4 C
%> / *5 ,?6 * C
9#I , t *
N.G.O)
i a <(
,# - ?@ !"#$%
4 4 W ? Z 9- ,# - lL , #/ F 5 9%
6 H 5 + ,- b '()
=86
> < 5+# C * 4
7:' ,#+
9%
+<
5 . ,2 3 H
=86 C *
* 45 Z ,-
. >
9"Y b5++<
G 5 '() 8S
b5 ++<
,8C C <, C
f8 +@
* C
l /, !"#$%
b5++<
%> / f8 +@ * M ' % C ,8C q 5C C
9 #I , t *
,C !"#$% i a 45+< ,F T<
* 5 .
* ,8C 9# +% ] V% G , + 45 r F H
5C S 9 +< 9# +% ] V% > , B
* )
+ G <
* C Y,' C
: 9 6> 9 N+C, H9' :#@ H9% K H* #E H9/ / *
,< 5C S 5 F .
] ,6 G H
9 C T <
-,- S <
9 C > 5 ++< -> /
-,- 9 C ,< 5+C S ,T F H5+6 4 -Z B
G < * T< %
5+= # -
H / 8L%
G &2 G 5C
H L #
d $# 5E
,P * Q- / > S 9%
C 5 .
, G H / A>`
% ,
y ,#/ W
C 9"% +% * H
• A5' ] ,6 9#
* M +% G %h * C =C C ,8C H ?u * , 8C 9# +% ] V% > 7% <
G 8 G 5 *> L%
+<
5+
.
!"
:C ,K U A K 9"% ,N >
G I
# &E 9"% +% H7":
9 9# 5 6 *5 "<
G # $
l?% * @ "' 56 ? Z 9 ? q5C G ,
. 9"% +%
H + 6 3 / A ?1%
* B
%
fC -5 H % = ,C ,=":' 9 >
b 9"% +%
z$T%
9%
+<
5 .
9"% +% ,a#/
Y q5C ?O 9 #/ K+%
9%
- , :
1 . 5 ,?6 > u 1 +% * ,E, I
": 7 a%
C > 9 6 9 = W *
9@ S . +%
B 2 . L
* #E • G %h
5 ,?6 * , 4 B
3 . e> 3 % …1
&% @ , l< * C B
4 . +/ H C L+C 8?
e C
9-5 > 3 5#% * C
? Z …1 .
S /, > H9% K * , H ,w@ H ,P
* C 7 : H7 a A K C H V q(# X *
*5+:
l?% > , l "& ~ J/ 9#&+Y * C 7 E 9 + ' H{ V% , Y +' G ,
4> 5 I 9"% q 5C 9 #/ * , *, - C
/ .
*5 +: H9 "% ,8C H9 %> / * C
e> 3 Y H9+ 9:"' f l< * C
&% @ ,
4 *, 8C H
U
"%
9
9+C0 { V% 7% ' ":@>
H / 9"% ' ,N >
4> 5 <
*, -
/ 6 ? Z
) H^ ,8IZ 1385 : 20
.(
'() , '
H 5 + :C H 5E 9+C0 { V% ,Y +' :C
f H 5E 9#+/ { V% 7% ' 8 )
*, N:TO
/ f W
. , C
/ 98 9# +% D .
> f +%
Z 9 :#1- 9+C0 9# C % H56 9 , 9# &E = .
+% A ?1%
H
?+
J U
?1% 9+ T @ 9+ T+:C A
* C ,N
* H. +% H 5 E r:C
HƒI % Hq 5C 5 5?
C ...
?1% 9N:C <
A
* C I / l?8%
9 H5
† 5 % † 5 %
* C
9% S
5
) Hj @ 1381 : 9
.(
W l : N8$ H9 +< ] ,6 H9% ?1% 7=T% ,
> /
# &2 9
‡E +#%
5+O
` J V%
9 5 r F 9% ?1% H. 5 b
, E 9 ":' *, K
# ,- 5 . 9I 9% <
l C S 5 5?
* C S 9# +%
@ 9&E 9 l +< @
H
5 5@ * C, w#%
9 / >
H,N /
*> L% 9 * :&% < 5 456
5 .
5 5F ,C b 9# +%
5 5?
C Y, C 4 G ,E 9 H
5+O 45 r F 4,?O
/ 9:
F L # ,< l /, q 16 9# C Z * , + &% z$T% 5%
9 6 5 % .
,=
1 ,&
9 H9 ":' 9:
6 5
b ƒ ,Y 9+:2
b N +% H5 5?
! ,&
,<
) H >Z 1379 : 342
.(
5 r F C % =+
b
> @ +%
b
# , QF ! ,& ?+T F 56
b 9% :'
Y,' G D :@ 7 E 9:
C H5 / / q 5C ,< G6 * , e( > , 8&
d L 9# +%
9%
+<
+% A ?1% > 91 ,& < 5
l C /
:
» 9+ ' 5& 9"% +%
H e> 8 5 5? 5a
?@ q 5 C . +% H C
+ G =+ > {, 5a H9+C0 C
9"% * ) e>
q 5C . +% H C (
A LC % )
= W 9
9= W , t (
,E fL+/ % 5 T .E 9%
C 5
«
) Hj @ 1381 : 47
.(
":@>
5 5?
* C
< 9# +%
/ G=:%
,#+
Z
? 9 W , Ph
56 #6
H 9%
,< 4 6 , > * C V%
:
- A 5E
* C ,- > 5 , +% 7$%
4 C ƒ" %, t ƒ" % * B
-
% e,# -
9 C , @ H9 E(S H 5 $% % 7 8E> 9' :#@ * H9' :#@ l
E,/
...
B -
=6
"E G q C
f ,- f W A K 9 > 98CQ% H9% E * WL * C
8") U
9% E
) Hj @ 1381 : 47 - 193
B(
- A 5E
* C l #=C * = ,S H9# , B
- 4 %Z , 9%(/ * ?:@ "' ?@ 9% :' = *> / U+ %>
5 ,F b
# C
*
5 5T A 5E C ,V l C
"' B ,
- A 5E
^ ,/
N 9 '() * C 9%( / * ?:@ "' 9# ,#+ 9/ / @ ":'
, . + G , H '() , ' D 2 %
C
"Š %
* C D +#%
7X % # 6Q- 8 *,
9a" 9"% +%
9%
6 . 4 > < ?@ , / ,/ '() >Z e , - H, ' G
,#+
Y 9%
-
` 9"% +% 7X % ƒJ/ '() +% D 2 % H , 9 %
,
L # H e,# - ] 9"% +% ! ,&
9%
5 .
# $ $ % ! & %
- ( (
,#+ 9- ,# - @ 4> ,%
H 4 V 9/ , 5a%
,P * Q- 9 N+C, +% , Z
* ,2 T< 9/ / /
. ,2 3 H
5 2 , ,#+ *5 5 6 9 / / w "8
A L , 9%( / * ?:@
9 % - , .
&@ ,%
U V1 Y j Q - U
d 5 + %
www.gooya.com) (
9%
9# ,#+ 9 T /
l<
> 5 , !I $% 9 , 4 ,- 7?O
9S, A K
%> / C A E H9# + : * H 5%
,T
* C
G :L G 5+O 9+ % = 52
9/,#/ 9%(/ , t 9+ w "8 .
9 %
> H ,#+ 1- . , / HG ,
HG ,
d Q@
9 $6 G ,
* ?:@ * a#' 9/ / 1I $% * , 9 ":' =% G ,
/ 4 Z lC , , 9%(/
e( % <
9%
6 8+@ 9S, C
6 ƒ ,T Z * .
> lC ,#+
?% /
R S 9 y * # 9N+C, * C NI lC
4
*
9% 3 8 Z B l?%
9N+C, ‹ VI > ,#+ 7X % G , H
* #V% • J A5' 2,'
45 6
@ * # * C L+C 9N+C, * C NI / !"#$% .%
.
* +
G ,#T * , ,#+
/ 456 9 ,) 3,#+< G ,#:< ',/
B 3, #+< 3 :' G , + 6 Z 9 E(S * C
/
) H + 6Z 1382 : 2
.(
,N ,#+ 9N+C, 7=T%
H 8"t U 9 +t . +% 5 a 9 "N >
>
C / ,N * B
J"/ L # U
, 9 "N >
>
C ,N *
" / U
a ,#+
9%
6 . ,K , + 45'
> * 5+:T 5 H
,@
G I W <,% 9 ,@ '() 9"":
- 9 % , F
d,t 3 :6 >
†,6 d +@ * / B /
&/ * C T< >
#
* C T < * /
&/ 3 .
91+% H ,-, aV H* :' H = ,@ G -
J"/ ,
@ /
) H ` % 1371 :
66 - 60
.(
O & / 3 .% @ 9I # L 9) 8 7 / < / G l?% f/,F Z x ,< 5C S L *, w 8/
C ,#T 56 /
C 9 % 6 • "S = Z
C C
* * 9%
C ,V < 5 / 1$ C T< G
x5C ! 9
j 6 H G
j 9&JE / F f/,F 8 @
5 * .
†, &% @ ,C ] ,6 9%
+<
5 9:
5 Y
G •"J% A = + %>
,< 45+
. Z , W 9% :' p+C, 9 F H &% @ , 5% , 5 H
G !&2 56 I S A>` / F D G & W * #E #S / 7% '
H , C
A 5<
,P Q- /
) 9+ &%
* 5:"' H 1384 : 117
.(
,8+O 5%Z # ,- 9 ,- 5+F b
*> L% %
&E i 8 L 9 A5' H
,V
>
/ . A / ?@ G ' GC0 9N - G H
9N+C, 9/ / 91+% PZ 4 ,:C
9%
Z .
% G H ,#+
@ 4 N ,=":' /
9
B
* ) C 9: 5E i JS ! &M <
C ,#+ " / H
G , V 5 5T
/ ,Pg% .% @ .
,#+
, N 5 + % +
* C & / 3 . % @ 5 5@ * Œ(% < Y
! ,&
456
# ,- <
9:
6 . % @ G , K >
4, ?
> * , ,#+
H
&E %
6
5 ,E *
. .% @ G H + dQ@
* C
* H5 5@
,#+ ":@>
H V
* Œ(% <
% , 45+< ,F
*W 45T Y 9%
- , .
& / 3 * C T< > * H
,#+
,< < s / 6 7=6
" / *
* , * Z / 9%,-, / -
5 <
H
" / +' U
4 1#/ 9 '() 9:
6 . L # H
•:< 5 6 @ 9
6
@ b5 '
45C T% + %> G * #S / 3 V H9# ,#+ , <
9:
6 . Y > * H , K
5a ,8C
?@
. E HG 6 *, -
> 9 = 9 :"' * C ,= • 8J+% +
T%
9"Y (=
H , 9%(/ * ?:@
9 % ,#+ ?@ % 5 +
. , S I / H
' 6 T# 7"S L %W:C U
e>
&% @ !"#$% * C,TE H C
@ R S
H
,- 4 C 5C *
< 5+# C 9 F },&%
A C e>
C 9 ,E
# ,- 5
<
N N ,T #+%
9%
5++<
/ 4 , < . , 7 ? 5+ , G ,#+
.
&% @ U 9&) a% % @
4 ,< e> 5a { G >
H*
e(
/ 4 , <
G a
> *, N%
,N .1 ,% ,#+ 5+ % * W
5+<
) Hj @ 1381 : 160
.(
3 .% @ ,#+ ‚
&/
H 5F 9# &2 4 Z 5
/ Z > <
A 9N+C, < %,F / 9%
6 . 8'
,N H / a% 7 E < %,F / A / ?@ 9I # L i 8 7 / B
:C
< )
< %,F / z$6 H
Ž,O C` < D > ":% S 9#/
9%
+<
=8 6 H5 C
9 # ,#+ *
# C D 7% 6 91"#$% * e>
f ,- C 2,' ,#T % 9N+C, * C
9 % +<
5 +
) 9+ &%
* 5:"' H 1384 : 118
.(
* :
%5S
9
* 1386 9% e W- 5C
9T :C
, ,#+ +'
7 4 NT Z !"#$% * >
/ 456 W-, 9I w6 G J " Z .
f :C G H
b N @ 4
&% @ ,#+
U / 45 6 ,K 3 8 cV 9# ,#+ ,8 > ,%
. 4 N @
„(
, 9 , Ph
,#+
,
• 9a / % a / % 5%Z @
9 C , N *
,- 4 C 5 "a * E(' % * C V% ,N > , d,t p+C, > 45++<
U
?Y C
b ,#+
,
!!!
,- 4 C
= > F * U
=86 , W >
C * 4,? ,K > H*
+ > *, -
*
,< 5 F 9 W > ?% H # ,T F 4
5 . ,N * / >
H 9/ / C,=C 56 ,
4 , - S
,< 9/ / 9' :#@ 7X % 4
5 .
<,% 9' :#@ * C , G H
< ) 9 "
H
=8 6 C *
#1- *5 ,? 6 9 %
6
) H•
1384 : 287
.(
p +C :C ,#+
> 8% * C ,8C *> / b
=86 C
*5 ,?6 * 9 W , Ph
. D() 9C5 %> / * ,8C '() 3 8 9 /
H
> $T% > 9= 4 :C :
C
=86 * C
*5 ,?6 * 4
/ . , - G 4 C >
,#+
U |%
W
*
% , * , > / <
4,? 9% ,% } ,#' j ,V *W
* , 9%
+<
5+
.
D :L%
H
/ '() d(a O,- 1- 5
C 5 E f W * 5 *
j:< jO < * C T<
9 % +<
5 + H
* q> @ / 5 a#&%
Z , Ph , 5 E f W
„ W * C T<
H / ,#T B
.:@ , >
? * Z
U
5 5@ '()
H AW"# % "t
%,/
U + N+/
9 / . 9 C T<
% 5+
* , # "N H = ,%Z
* >
+ %>
U
.:@
? * Z
U '() V ,N * C T< < 5
,E D &TI 9%
C 5 . , N * / >
H
L "t ,T F * C T<
5++<
{ / C &% -
% / C 9 '() * 5
.
*, - <
,#+ 9 "N >
H : U 9 S D 2 % G * , /
) H*
2007
.(
& %
$ % ! )
*+ , & -.% &
(
9/ / . % > 9= l , 5 / 4 ,T
/ f% Z l "' 9 # / QI
+
* C
* 5 5@
5 G ,#:<
9%
5 / * C ? S 5 # †(S < 9 %>
,P Q- U |%
# &E 9
* ,2 A>`
H
> / 5 F H
5 6 5 C S ,#T 9 ,N G .
, N
9:
5 5? l ,
* 8+@ > ,< 9a" 9"S U
G I 5 % 7 t Z 9 "":
B 4> , %
l ,
H
*5 5?
G I / # ,-, . % @ A : / ,T 7< "' 9"":
.
, 4> ,%
C 5 '() * + ,T F A N:C 8 5?& {
G E
4 ,< 56 H Z 3 Y 5%Z f F
4 5 . , C 9 ,N > *> L% * M , Ph V
G I 8 9"":
56 7 5 4 5 9%
5 + ) 8 ,a H9 5 +C $ < L< , C A 5 E
* C
= ,S 9# , U
5 ++< , @ S B
#I "% H aJ+% ‘ C G , + 9
":@>
, 9%(/ * ?:@
H
>
A 5E
* C 9: % ? Z 5 %
.
< 91 ,&
9%
, , 5 <h l , >
l 9# ,#+
/ H
> / 8'
:
A 5E
* C
% ,
*W 9 $6, t 9/ / } ,t 4 ,:C 5+: 5C 456 H
"' C
=%
4 C 4, S0 *
> ? Z 456 4
=8 6 U 9% 5 E G +O > q5 C 9 ?@
H
/Z Z ? Z * / ? Z *5@ * C
) :
*
&% @ U 9 '() (.
9 j 6
45 r F > 9=
W G , C 456 4 , 4,? 9# , q 5C * , Z > +< < 9 H
,#+
/ . , < / ,#+ * ?+
C 9%
=+ 5 *> L% A WC 5+
5 Q- * @ , S > * H
> ,n S 3 % TS 5
.
*> L% * M H
/ 6 b
, t ,N > * , I &
7 E 9#I /
: l #<
l #=C H1
, ,8 / 2 3l
.
6 / G G *5+ >,% 5+O,C b
l?8% 9C - I &
/ H
* , q 5 C ƒ 2 ƒ ,T
9N NO A 5 E
* C , - 4 C
9# , *
H 5 1%
/ . 1# / l #<
b 3 :&%
7#$%, t ,#+ > 45++<
< 4 6 Y S K+% > 9 8 #TF :
B5 6 9 5 + %
=86 > T- U
d S / L H '() < * , 9 ?@
D 2 % 3 / /
> "J%
4 H Z
b | 8%
q(#X HR S "J% D 2 %
% , H*> L% * C
*W
L 9N+C :C A 5E
* C
, K %
. l / #=C H
, < j C 7 :' , < O n=
7:' 9 ,- B / : * ,
":' C 5E A C
> 4 1#/ 9 ,N6
, < jC * C
* ,
":
# / 9
*5 @ /Z Z 5 Z 3( S L q5C 9# ,#+
B 5 + %
} ,#' 5 He % S * C : H*> L% * C
9I / < S * C
% C { , H C
,<
A C *
* .
*> L% * M % 9 ,N:C d a > / 8' l , ,8 /
9# , I &
B
* , C -Z , < ,< jC A 5E : U
Z q5 C Z
/Z S Z #T< r:C *5@ * C C
5 56 * #E * .
1.Activism 2.Hactivisim 3.Cyber Terrorism
,- =+ > {, 9 ,N 4
C
> * , b
T < "% *> L% j ,#=I
*
5 6
% / C 7: H9' H9# +% * H*_, 3 a# H C5 / H9 C i JS H7a
I 8%
* C 4, t * #E * L H
4 ,< *5@ /Z H
:C :C H5++< 7#$% Z
5 5F b
#S +6 56 b i 8 l , ,8 / 5
Carleton University, 2006)
.(
6 / % b
I &
< 456 b5++<
l , C % 9 -,-
/ 45:' 9"Y 9 ,N H i ,%
/Z ’ # E '
* C
":
C
* a % 9= ,#=I W %Z
/ .
=86 #S / *
,#+ 4y H
,- #S / a% 7 E 4
C
9# , *
B /
, t #S / 9+&
, t W<,:#%
" "/
98 ,%
) H^ ,8IZ 1385 : 182
.(
,- 4 C
> 7=T #% 9# , *
%> / C
!"#$% * ,L . +% < 5
U C S I 8% l
9 % +<
5 + .
=8 6 U
9# ,
H
9 7=6 lL +%
/
‘ C *
%> / z$T % 9C5 %, W<,% - C
*
q &#%
. ,- 4 C
* 456
> 5 +C $ < %> , C 4
,#+
H
=8 6 S U
7 #% 9# ,
H4 ,<
,N 7:' 7a# % % 9%
+<
5+
.
, C 8 / * , H 5E 9+ &% 9 ,w@ 4 N @ H4
9 5+O >
{,# / l C
,E S &E % B5 5
G , + 9%
&E % > 5+
C
": A 5 E z$T % *
5++<
. G -
":
C + WC b5 '
A L *, #:<
9 % B , -
%
%5 Y
* C 9 - W
<,6 C
> * #E * L * S /,
C T < * 9 %
+<
5 + . ,#+ > 4 1# /
K+%
> T ' L
4 F A C 5 5? *
, f $F W %Z
C
"
l C *
' Z H 5+ % +VY U A 5' - ,- H C >
A 5E
* C ,- 4 C I E < / 9# , *
,@ 3 9 p+@
/ .
>
4 9/ / @ 0 1
=86
* H , C *5+:6> '() b
% / C *
T< 9' q5C
S /, > H C
7: * 5 + H*_, 3 a# 7a
C NT ` F 4
C
% H
G :C * L * #E
% , )
C
N# / 9# , 5 2 *
4 C 5 F / H9 # +% *
9%
+<
":' 9 ,) ? Z < 5+
S +6 i a
/Z j:< q5C T< , QF 9%
+<
5 .
#=
U
% > * < / L+ l?%
H , C 9 %
> 5 + 4 . :@
= 6Z * Z
5 + / S 5Y a% Z 7 "V WL '()
.
» 1# / b '() > = 6Z
e > 4 1#/ 5 @ %
?+F 9 E, t * C 9
H 7E 5 < @ =% G
#TC > % '() 9% : 5Y b
.:@ G:6 ,< * Z
.«
G
":@
H C +$/
7 "V
=" H 9# +% 9 '() ,-
":@
9 C O,# > # ,-, U
9 6> %Z * :+C
_ < / 45' aI U
2003
# w / 45%Z /
) H^ ,8IZ 1385
.(
P U 11 ,8% #n/
2001 H 9 J > : G , - 5 6 H9 ,) * , ,#+ A
5 6 ":' * ,@ 9C5 %> / H9N+C :C .
^ F P G >
H 9"= 6 l , ,8 /
1#%
"Š % ,- S U
» /Z , > 9=6 % },& 5 > *, QF «
~,J%
2 % '
) H9 1380
B(
, N+< 4 $ ?:@ -5+ : < * ) b
Z
= ,%
H U
S 5 "< 5+O T ?+ 5 ,< A(' V1Y
5 "<
9 , * , 9 # ,#+ i 8 j
#E j / 9 < A ,% 9-5 > G#S 5 ,JS
4 6 %
% / G=:
> 5 b
j
: H
• ,JS 56
B ,2 3 H
,#T
% = C I # ,T F * C
5E Y * H
l , ,8 / , , ,8C
C 5:' * 4
*
*> L% * 0 $
,<
4 ,- 4 C 9 # +% *
45 5F G 4> 8% * ,
# ,- %5S 5
.
/Z T< 9 / H
,#+ 4 > 4y H
56 9&E *,%
/ 9 B
" E G
5 ,N 5++<
4
* 9 W
Z 9 % /
H
" / U l 5 9 5 +O 9' .
> * < &E G C
#I * 9 9 $6 7 #% lC
5 H 8#% G C0 G +O
9%
+<
< 5 45'
•5 * ":
C p +C :C * 9 %
+ I & 5 C
% K *
* T < 9
,# - 4 +< 7#$% * +
5 .
%,L% = ,S
G I 9"":
H 5+ % ,@ * C5
%> / l
# U rE O E H• ,JS
4, t 9I % ,8C(< H 5$% % W
%,L% * C # 7 ? * , ,#+ >
U S
4 1#/
9%
+<
5+
.
%,L%
H 9I % * C ? 5 5?
4 , <
< 5
Z, A5 ' Y
#/ S C T H
% / C 9 *
? Z * C S < >
+ 5 S 5 . 9 +@ * C5 G
<
=%
* C / +6 9 I &
9 % +<
* Q -W% * C5 5? H5 + W ?L 45 6
{
9% 6,K % *
9% G 86 *W O 5+#/, 5+ -
:
»
<
Z + 9%
+<
5
% <
9%
l U xl +< :6
«
) H^ ,8IZ 1385 : 186
.(
( ( 0 1 23 & %
T< "' 9/ / @ ":' H
":@>
5 5?
* C 9# +%
9% :6 B
% :C 7 I
/Z D 2 % 9- ,# - G > < *5@ * C
H 5 5? T<
% 9 +<
D 2 % G H5
9/ , 7a# % Y
9%
6 .
a8) { '() Hf 9 +< * < L Z>
*5+
e> > 9 :?% f$ 456
<,6 9 C
H
%> /
7 =T 9#I 9Y S * C ? C
9%
C 5 H 4 6
* 8' 4
< '() G Y
4 C
= ,#=I 9 9
H /
W
> 9 "% , 9 "% , ,N >
6 :C 9?@
S, /
. ,#+ 9 '() 4 ,C 6 G H
*> fa 4> ,%
1 , E 5 E ?% …1 H <
N , ,N >
& 2 G H
9# ,#+ 9/ / @ U |%
~,J% E G *> , F * , l?% * W 9%
> / :
<,6 4> ,%
C /g%
* C
9 #I * C ? * L
I & A L * ,
* C
H S
= > , W- ,#+
B5 Z 5 < * ) H
,%> I &
b 7 #$% ? Z 9 %
6 .
4, S0
* L 9 "% +% H9Y #S H9 H{ '() 3 a# e> ,F H*> / 4, t A L 3 ,:# % Y G# ,-
/ .
'() G 3 a# W 7 /
H q5 C
=86 9/ / @ 7% ' * , 9 S
* / .
=86 9/ / @ 7% '
* 9%
'() 5 +
Z H5+ W %5Y
? 5+C , w * =#/ H B
< 9I ,C u
9% ,K G < 5/
'() Y
I 9"Y 5
. '() 9%
4, S0 . +% >
Z 9 = ,#=I *> /
$ E,/
,< 7a#+% ?@ > Ja ,C ',/ ,< * , .
9# ,#+ 9/ / @ 7% ' H
# ,T F > ,C , W?L% ,
9%
6 /Z 5 A, *, QF
C W
Z *, QF 1
? 9#
!T<
9%
+<
5+
. ,#+
H 5V%
C
%> , +' i ,% *
=%
H +&%
5 B
M ,#+ G , +
9 8 9 % Z
=8 6 / / @ * ,
*
/ 4 Z @ .
W<,% G#
* / Z * : 6 G# 9 #
b +1"
9
O,#
U / G1"
. 9# ,#+ / / @ < 5 9 G
9- / S q 5 C
9 / +6 Z H4 ,<
":
+<
5+
. 9 : > >,% H "Y H ,#+
5 / +6 . H9 +< *
4> 5
* V <
b 9 / / , w O ) 8 45 6
V H b , @ l 9 / / @ *
=86 / 456 9 -,- e $#/ W * .
/ / @
=86 7 "V *
E 9 '() ,-
Y, ,K#+% T :C <
H5 9%
> 5+
4
=86 U ,#+
5 F 9 /,#/ { '()
5++<
.
#V%
* ,C / G=:% %
% , * C
9 # +% * L H* #E * ,8C *
,/ G 56 9%
KVI
* * / j >
,< 3 / ,N * / .
/ / @
=86
* H 5 S q 5C 9 5+O , w 4
5 B r Z 9#/
/ 5 5@
H
< / 9 M
7:' Z ? Z 9%
+<
5+
. ,#+
H ? Z . ,/ ,
9 % S q 5C , 5 /
=86 9/ / @ 7% '
* H 9 ?@ 3 a# 7a =%
9%
5C
? Z 9 % 4 < 5 + G ,
5++< A 5E %>
B 5 6 # ,- E p+O =+ 5 .
9 ,w@ =% O 9"% ' H
%>
3,#+<
A /,% * C H
45++< 5V% ,N 5+#
.
@ 9#E 9
9%
5
% / C
*
* N F 4 C 4 , < 0 1 9 # ,#+ * H
? Z
S
=86 9/ / @ 7% ' < 5 +< H5+<
" E e> %Z > < * C
*
* >
? %> / * / > / S,
* 9"%
G I : 9"":
9%
6 H 4> 5 O
9%
G 5
- A 5E C
5 W /
B
=86 9/ / @ > 96 S =+ G:2 *
W E,/ > ,#T / 9=
.
) 3 :&%
H
%> / , 5%
C
<,6 C ? H C
*5+: 6> '() < 5 5
< @ 9% 56 45 >
5 >
.
%> / I & D :L%
C
<,6 C ? H C
7 < ,
#E H5 , - ,E 9/ / @ },&% ? Z ,- , Ph T< 9' * #E 5E ! &M T< +%
9%
6 .
/ G=:%
Ja U
> tZ 9# ,#+ * #E 9/ / @ H
.:@
4 N F > = 6Z '() * Z
%> / 9# ,#+
C
<,6 C 56 9#&+Y * L * B
I @
@ '() "t =+
{ H N F * , 4
C
%> / G 9# ,#+ * C
<,6 C 9 %
6 B
< 9I
5+:6> 8 E * , 4> 5 O '() G < 5+# @ #% ? Z , 5%
/ . , N > #%
,#+
H
" E > 4 1#/
C
* 9 % Z
%> / 9 / / @ 7% ' G '() 3 a# * , Z
* D 8#%
/ B { / @ < 9 %>
H H , < ,K % '() 9 %
Z 5
%
* / F Z 5+<
4 ,T ~ I
* 5+< 4, S0 6 F
5 +< * Q-W% Z * C
G#6 AW"# % Z > 4 1#/ > / ?+F 4_ Q-
5+<
.
^ , / N 9 / / @ * C
e(
9%
+<
<,6 7S * , 5+
C
%> / H
< 5 ++< 9 / +6 { * C ? C
U |%
."J% . +%
H 5 #S A>` '() B
'() < * , , G > r +O
6 4 1#/ %,V%
H I & W %,E ]S > N 9/ / @ ^ ,/
C
9 E(S 9 E *
# , , H aJ+% ~(JY U
7:' 4 / *,# < S 9%
<
5+
. aJ+%
U 9 ":' 9 +& *,# < S
S , t aJ+% 9 E % 9E(
U 9 E, t 9 E(S , t 7:' 9+& 4 / B
aJ+% < 9I U
9":' i ,% 5 1/
9%
6
/ †( S q( S E q(S <
) H9 1383 : 171
.(
6 > 9=
4 C
=86 / / @ < 9
* 9% <
5 , H 4, ?
"1t H C JS > * , C
4 8#6
* C
%> / H C ? C
<,6 C 3 /
% C
* / G =:% < /
/ '()
9 56 .
<,6 f6 F e C * 8E C
!"#$% * H
N F 4 C 9
@
9%
< 5 Z 9%
N F Z 4
C W:C * B5 %
- N F G < * 4
C 9 T 5 "a
9# ,#+
U%
,6 / q5C <
. 9 T <, 6 , 5% 9% F 5C $ < 9 <
5 F / G=:% H5+< 3 / Z 9&E 5 F org
4 8#6 com
H # ,- S A F )
5#/,1 ? Z * 8E * , l a# % .
5 1% 9 # ,#+ / / @ * , / G=:% < *,N W
56 H A,
Net Eraser W /
.
> 9=
A a%
* C / #1- / 9 %> / :
G 9" Y , <
7 "V < / G % ,
%> / ,- 9%
N F 5+
4 C 5 ++< 3, #+< 9@ S 9# ,#+ *
#S +6 H9 T ,:# % , w 7 I 9:
6 5 . e W- 9S,
= ,%Z < / Z > 9< C
W 5V#% * =:C
< I ,# / H^ "N O S j H
K 9 ?@ A K
/ 4 ,< L 3,#+<
. A K G
" 6 #S 45 % 1
9 % 6 *, - * ,
U :C
» F 9+1" :I =%
A C C, : 9= ,#=I *
« /
) H9 1383 : 174
.(
9 l K' lL G j6
.:@
'() * Z H
'() 7% 6 W % T< {
9%
6 .
@ % * + H9 +<
C
=%
9/ , ) 8 > 9- W lL 9%
5C B 9"< ) H + > 4 ,- G
* C
4 G#%
A / % 9 5
.
4 G#%
9= ,#=I 9Y t 9 ,N 6
* C H 4 8 >
4 C .:@ *
* Z / * , 456 ,K % 8S ‚ ,$#
]S, Y
4 1#/ 2
9%
+<
5 .
^n/
C 4 C 9% lC 5 W %Z
] l C 9 %
C
* , ? Z 3, #+< 4 1# / 5 +
7 "V /Z 9 '() ,- 5 6
) H•
1384 : 180
.(
* C> #% fC < ,#+ e,# -
+ %> „ W * C T<
U / @ +6 9/
,L+%
9%
6 . ,#+ 5 1% , <
e,# -
4 > * E * Q-W%
H Z
=%
> . ,/ : 9 "% , ,N > j O < * C T<
9+=6W% 9/ / @ , , 9% f W
5C
) H^ ,8IZ 1385 : 175
.(
HG +r:C 9% ,K
9% 9 ?@ +% … S < = ,%Z I 5/
5 H ,
… 1 *
% * +%
H 5 W 9/ / 9/ / @ / H9&E *> L% * 9+&
B
< 9' 2 %
I Z
= ,%
^F P >
U 11 ,8% #n/
Z ,< 9":'
.
4> ,%
4 W / W- <
T ) 8 #TF W % (
5 & G > < @ ?@
H 4
• S W- <
Z
= ,%
/ W- <
,N H 5 ,E GF _ 5X / H # "N * C T<
.
G +r:C H +% ?O 8P W<,%
U 9"Y H 9+&
Hcom
Hnet org
Hbiz
<,6 C
* Z 9 = ,%
/
+% 8P > #% < 9#<,6
infoU
%,/ ,#T H e
Z 9 = ,%
/ . +%
C
mill *
N#/ z#$% W gov
4 C
* +% = ,%Z 9% K
eduU
NT 9Y #S
4 C
* Z
= ,%
/ .
, G H Z
= ,%
9# ,#+ . +% , 5% G#6 #S H
Y, 9 S D( )
A : >
=86 . E U 9 ?@
. 3 N / * % ,#<
b 9 % 9 # ,#+ 9 / / @ ~(J Y 5 -
:
= ,%Z 9 C ,' ": > f F
> 5 5 6 < † 4
,#+
9 F † , ' A ,% $6
4 , H 5 ++< dQ @ ? Z > *,#T :6 ~(JY )
T 5 4 N 6 /
.(
4 6 G :C
# @,- N
,
?:@
* C H5 56 9N d(a O < • / * 6 * ,@
/ 456 .
,L+F ]a ,#+
4
=" H ?@ *
Y S * , • ,JS * W
9/ / @ q 5C * , , G > 4 1#/ ,N 9# $6 lC
/ . G +O < * ,
=86 C 9 9%
6 5 H 9:
#S , 6 T< ,/ 5+
H S 9%
+<
5+
.
1. ECHELON 2. on line
, 9%(/ * ?:@
H
# C D 2 % ~, J% @ % ] ,6 R S
* H
^ ,/ q5C 9/ / @ * C
9% :6
":' D :L%
#S +6 9/ / @ 56
b 9# ,#+
Z "'
~,J% *5@ ) /
.
345 6 0 & %
{ ’ "S p+@ D E %> >
H - p+@ > * 45%Z @
/ 91"#$% 9% / <
, Z
†() 9%
6 : j # ,8 / p+@ H• E p+@
A / ‚ % p +@ '() p+@ H1
. d( a
/ # ,- Y 9% K % < 9 +< ,:# % H
+ , w > * 5
* C H
+ 4y
* C / 456 96 '() d(a ]8 ,% *
) H 5 +6 1385 : 318
.(
W Z , H
9 C T< ?% / / 7 a
% 5+
?:@
7= 6 C % , , 9%(/ * 5 5@ * C
9% , Ph p+@
Q- .
?@ * , l K' *5 5? C T < G < / Z , a#'
d,t 5 . 9 '() p+@
H •J+%
• J+% G WN @ 9 '() *, , q ,6 • E *> /
9&:@ * 9%
6 A : p+@ 9-y <
/ 9#&+Y ' .
>
,S b5/
l#
9 F
+ , w C
+ *
* C p+@ * H + 9I # L l< , Hj ,#=I ,= % >
* C 3 a# *
/ 456 4 1#/ 9% K q 5C * , '() . ,/
. ,T F H, N , N:T O , w C
*
9% K '() #S / 45%Z @ /
. p +@ 3 Y , w H
S 7 1V%
* C
d,t 9% K
<, 7=6
p+@ f fa ,#T @ * /
U |%
5 5@ 7= 6
/ #S / : p+@
.
%> / C .:@ *
?+F * Z U |%
N 8 #TF C
@ "@ 5 H9' * H
% / C
< 4 ) 8 * 9%
+<
5+
B
# / ? Z '()
@ % '() , a
7 "V * ,
9' 9# +% ,-
/ .
%> / G C
] ,6 / +#%
b5/
l = H
,N 56 9C5 %> / 4
5 B
":@ >
U
%> / G C
H
= ,%Z 9"% +% ^ _Z /
. :@ <
* Z
# ,- '() e> ,F 9 # ,#+ ) 8 > 456
T < 9 +1" 9 q5 C * C
45?', .
% / C .:@ *
^ _Z G * Z H
E, @
9 C q , &% 8S l K' * 5
) H{ 5 W Z 1383 : 253
.(
H 6 8E ,% /,? < 9 8' ,C C
@
* @ Z
=86 U ,#+ 9 ?@
9%
5 > ,F
% U" ,
*5&
H . +% G A : ',/
) lK+ %
9 ,#+
9%
6 5 . ,#+
r:C
„ S
%> / 9"% +% ^ _Z * C C
*
7:' T%
9%
+<
$/ * < 5 A, * W
5+# C S * V * W .
1. Cybernetics
F , < 9 '() p+@
U .:@
> '() { / , 7 :' , 1 H* Z U % / 4
5 5@
9) 8 ) ,#+
(
/ #/
H
*, - "@ G: 6 '() 5 / >
9 % 6
=86 U 9 '()
G:6 '() e ,- 5+ ,
7#$%
9%
6 ]" D 2 , 5 # H #
5+< 9C5 %, S * C , <,V ":' .
:C H # † 1 † ,' p+@ < )
, 3 8
* 7% < •,#T%
9C5 %, W< ,% G ":' >
H 9= #< ,#+ " /
/ 45%Z lC , .
D :L%
H 9%
&/ #6 5 1- U
' 2 % '() * + 9
* , * ,8C
6 9/,#/ 9/ , C T<
4 C
* 5 5@
/ 456 7 58 p+@
. b N 4, ?
* ,
% '() * + >
C T < 9% K * C , #S / Z <, 9% K 9' H
S, * > • > ,2 3 /
B
< * ) ,#+
U |%
=8 6 U l K'
D() 9 / H l?% D 2 % 9 '() . / j
* ,8C
@ 56 / 4 .
I 6 b F , T<
U ' :L%
%> / > * C
9Y S 9#I * C ?
f$ 3 &
C
!"#$% ~ J/
/ #/
.
%> / G O,- C
A , % * , ? Z I & D 2 % C ?
#S +6 456 / H :C @ *> L% * M , Ph
* C 5:' b Z H , #:<
@ B45 6
f$ < / Z ,% G 7 I
$ * C H
8+@
U 5 { V% 9 + '
% 5 +
* M '
5 *,C u 5 ,E 9% :' ,K+% < 5
H
*> L% * M = Z 3
% 5 +
=8 6 U
# Z 5 %(/ +% / l?% @ < / 5 98 '
V% % H /
45 {
9:
6 . { / G , H
=86
=8 6 A / % * U
9 ?@
C5Y < @ ,#+
7 < , / H WC 7 #% ,N 5 = * * C
9%
> T< * @ % > / 4
C 9 :"' H9#&+Y H* L H9I % H* #E - - *
9% K# H9# +% H9' H9TC yF A L 9 % 9#6 5? H
, - .
] V% ,#+ C %
Z > ,Ph#% * ,8C H
-
#6 9+% 5 5? L " E < / * H
A WI
* C R S
> S b
M#E 9"% +%
9%
+<
5 . ,K+% G >
H z$T%
9%
6 T < 9"% +% <
*> L% * M +% ,#+
H 5 6 9& / I a% G < 6 5C S 8|% 9N#/ F
> 9N#/ F G 9N NO b
9# +%
)
* = ,S Hl ,
9 / / @ ":' (
> H b
9/ / -
> 9N+C, b
9% K - 6 G 8 9/ , ' M 5 9' .
% H 9S,
I * C =C 56 9 ,&% *
% , 5% ?@ % <
*> L% * M 9"% + , K
9%
/ 5 .
=+ * , •
*> L% * M 9"% +% , 5%
H 45 + Z 3 ] , 6 5
4 -Z H
* C, w#%
,P Q- Z 9"% +% * V%
5+# C < - H
‚ ,$# / •
9 E 96> A K d O O ,<
H C ,8C l /, 9 ,&% !T <
C =C
S ,F . , { / G H , > * C =C
* , h
*> L% * M +% G % 9% Y
6 :
1 . 9% ,K > T< 9"Y 5 5? 5/
U 9 # +% :#1- 5a H ,#+
b G
/ 45 5F .
#%
h N#/ , 5% 4 N 1/
4 C
&/ i ,% * U
5 '() * +
,K G# ,- A WI
* C
*> L% * M +%
H 8/
* > 9@ S 9 "S 91+% &8 L
6 45 / . G , + H
&/
U ,< ‹ VI 4 ,:C 5 '() * + A WI
* C
* M +%
, - Y *> L%
.
2 .
{ '() > u 1 +% a
% / C / H C ? 9 ) 8 *
%>
C H
- C
< l?% *
* V
%5S
5 I S 9% :' 9 /
B 3( S -,C , >
A L G# ,-
% h
%> / G % C
H /Z / G=:%
* C ,8@
*, QF 9F
56 #6
.
3 .
< L Z>
5 5?
C /Z
*> L% * C ',/
9 % , w 3 V
5 H / A>`
* C ? ? Z , 5% 9I #%
H q J& >
/ +% *, QF
% %> / H % , GŠ:J%
h
%
5+6 S,
.
4 .
?@ % *> L% * M 9"% +% , 5% 5+ , 5 5?
* C
*5 + , H Z
Z 5 8 / 56 3 F
# ,< 9a"
B ,% G H
7 := ~( Y
I / , C U A K
.% @ +%
# ] ,6 @ *> L% * M C
* 9% * ,2 5+<
.
5 .
> ,#+
@
?
>Z
* C
/ i 8 9Y S 9 5% *
: j >
H /
=%
W G > 4 1#/ s /
* , , C
= ,S H N
, 9 "% , 9 "% , ,N >
,N * / > @
H
% , < @ =% G
U 4> 8%
5 5?
C , 5 %
>Z 5 5? *> L% * M +%
* C +% G %h ? 9 5% * ,L+%
6 . l :
*> /
4> G H 8+@ , C , < ‹ VI / 6 U
* M +% , 5 % Z
,@ i ,% G E G 5 *> L%
l
/ * ,2 *
.
7+
8 &
9,
: ( (
1 . 8IZ
5 H^ ,
) 1385 (.
5 W- 4 '() , ' > * .
U:@, 9"' 9"'
* Z . ,?
: 5=TC yF T#
b
* ,8C &I J%
.
2 . H >Z ) 1379 (.
A / ?@ 9"% +%
. U:@, 5=TC yF b
* ,8C &I J%
. ,?
: 5=TC yF T#
b
&I J%
* ,8C .
3 . A H +6Z G 5I ) 1382 (.
9N+C, 9/ / +% ,#+
. ,?
: A % 4 NT ) 8 p +C, &I J% W<,%
† Y ) D (.
4 .
’ ,< H{ 5 W Z )
1383 (.
9"% 9+%
. U:@,
* 5 L%5 / .
,?
:
5=T T#
b A % 5:V%
,E ) D (.
5 . p ,< H 5 +6 )
1385 (.
,Y &% ?@ ,8C +%
. U:@, 5Y *,N ' ,8<
. ,?
: 5=TC yF T#
b
&I J%
* ,8C .
6 . A " H9 ) 1383 (.
=86 9/ / @
* : '() 9 ?@ 5 5?
. U:@, 5=T 9TC yF &%
b A % 5 :V%
,E ) D (.
,?
:
5=T T#
b A % 5:V%
,E ) D (.
7 . 2 5:V% Hj @ )
1381 (.
%5a%
‚ 9"% +% *y ,#/ , * .
. : C C C ,8C .
‚ 1 . ,?
: :aI p+C, .
8 . 5 &/ H9 <0 )
1383 (.
»
*> L% t , @
«.
% +"
U
@ &I J%
. e 6 .
9 . 3 F H>,@
) 1384 (.
3,#+< 3 >
: ,E 9 ?@ +%
21 . U:@, 5:V%, % 9@
91/
. , ? : 5=T C yF T # b
* ,8C &I J%
.
10 . G H9 )
1380 (.
» 9% :' +%
H fI O 9"% +%
9 , * C
«.
,T U ,8C . e 20 : 45 - 5 .
11 . 9 J"/
5: H y ) 1386 (.
» / / '() * + , <
«.
b W@
9/
b
*, #<
. 5=T b A "' † a
/ ,? 4 NT 9/
.
12 . 5 1/ Ž <
) 1386 (.
*> L% * M +%
. U:@,
* $# ,wY .
“ 2 . ,?
: 5=TC yF b
* ,8C &I J%
.
13 . { 8' H9-,- )
1385 (.
» C ,#+
«.
% +"
U 9"% &I J%
. { 7 . e :1 69 - 53 .
14 . , H35 % )
1377 (.
,?O b 9 "% +% , w#%
. U :@, 5=T C yF b
* , 8C &I J%
. , ? : 5=T C yF T # b
* ,8C &I J%
.
15 . , N ?@ H9+ &%
) 1384 (.
»
> L% C :
,#+ 9# C , Ph
«.
% +"
U 9"% &I J%
. { 6 . e 4 : 123 - 107 .
16 . 5 : H ` % )
1371 (.
,@
G I '() 9"":
. U:@, 4 S,=6 ^ .
,?
: V &I J% W<,%
/ a a
C .
17 . 9"/ H•
) 1384 (.
9 '() ` a% ' :L%
- 9# +%
. U:@, 5=T 9T C yF &%
b ,E 5 :V% A % )
D (.
‚ 4 .
,?
:
5=T T#
b A % 5:V%
,E ) D .(
( 0 ,
18. Eriksson, Johan (2006). "The Information Revolution, Security , and International Relations: (IR) relevant Theory?". International Political Science Review. Vol. 27. No. 3:
221-244.
19. Nye, Joseph S. (2001). "soft power and conflict management in the information age".
Turbulent peace, challenge of managing international conflicts. united states institute of peace press. chapter 22.
20. The Canadian center for Intelligence and security studies (Carleton University) (2006). "A framework for understanding terrorist use of the Internet". Vol. 2006-2.
