tourism in rural areas, by synthesizing strategic planning models and artificial neural network
Maryam Ghasemi
Assistant Prof. of Geography and Rural Planning, Ferdowsi University of Mashhad, Iran
Hadis Kamranifar
M.Sc Student of Geography and Rural Planning, Ferdowsi University of Mashhad, Iran
Salman Hayati
Young Researchers and Elite Club, Lamerd Branch, Islamic Azad University, Lamerd, Iran
Received: 26/5/2015 Accepted: 6/10/2015
Extended Abstract
Introduction
World tourism organization estimates that tourism industry, as the most important industry in 2020, with an overall income of 2 trillion dollars and 1.561 billion travelers, has the first role in development of economics of countries. So this industry is a good opportunity for developing countries like Iran, which has rich cultural and wilderness attractions. Because of growing tourist with cultural targets in world , and Iran's rank in cultural heritage attractions (10th in world), a special attention is needed to cultural tourism and abilities spread in villages, a scientific understanding of facilities and limits, opportunities and its threats is also vital. Many villages posses rich and unique cultural background and valuable historical monuments, each of which contain a part of historical identity of this land.
Unfortunately despite of this richness and diversity, this type of tourism has not grown enough in our villages. Villages of The city of Binaloud being adjacent to Mashhad metropolis (24 km) on one hand, and on the other hand because of its intact nature, accept lots of eco-tourists each year. To develop cultural tourism in potential villages, the need for using scientific strategies to reconstruct and develop cultural tourism is raising. The aim of this study is to identify and chose best strategies in developing cultural tourism in potential villages in the city of Binaloud, and to provide a base for planning and developing cultural tourism in rural areas.
Following questions are proposed to achieve this goal: 1- What kind of strategy is effective for cultural tourism in current situation; this strategy shall prevent threats and then utilize good points and opportunities, and meanwhile resolve our weaknesses? 2- What are the best strategies for reaction to current conditions of rural cultural tourism in the city of Binaloud?
Methodology
The research method and type are descriptive-analytic and practical-developmental,
Responsibility Author: Email : [email protected]
respectively. Data collection has been carried out by documental and field methods.
First, weaknesses, strengths and opportunities and threats in developing cultural tourism were identified by wide documental studies. Then primary surveys were proposed to some of experts and village chiefs to ask for important internal or external factors which can be strengths, weaknesses, opportunities or threats for the development of cultural tourism, Then necessary adjustments were done based on theoretical literature and extraction of common points. Final factors as most limiting or helping ones in improvement and continuity of development of cultural tourism in rural areas under study - were distributed among 40 responsible officials and experts in Cultural Heritage, crafts and tourism Organization of the city of Binaloud and also 10 village chiefs those have enough potential in their villages to give their views. After conduction and correction of strategies, they scored the strategies from 0 to 20, based on respondent's answers. A combination of strategic planning models and artificial neural networks was utilized to analyze the data and to present strategies for developing cultural tourism in villages.
Results
First step in strategic analysis is to identify key strategic factors in relation to the problem under investigation. Overall, 13 strengths and 13 weaknesses were identified in internal factors, and 8 opportunity plus 5 threats were recognized among external ones, and must-do strategies were conducted based on these points.
Then its elements were laid-out in the combined model of strategic planning and artificial neural network SWOT-ANN, and a first model was created. The aim of this model is to select the best strategy, and because of its good ability in modeling, the ANN method was used to analyze an prioritize the strategies of the research.
After creating the network and calculating based on the mentioned pattern, 10 prior strategies were found. Based on normalized points, those belonging to conservative strategy, defensive strategy, offensive strategy and competitive strategy gained 0.5431, 0.2842, 0.1727 and 0.1256 points, respectively. Based on these points it can be said that conservative strategy shall get more attention and priority because it has the highest score.
Conclusion
Because of more complicated effects impose by local conditions, shallow and one- dimensional determinations are not beneficial for solving multi-dimensional and complicated problems any more. Managers should facilitate themselves with efficient tools to overcome this environment a face the problems. Systematic or holistic approach can help managers and planners greatly to understand and solve the problems better. That is why SWOT technique with such approach is used in this study and respective strategies are presented; but SWOT is not able to rank the strategies; so different prioritizing methods should be used to achieve this goal.
Artificial neural network (ANN) method is one of the most important methods for prioritizing which has been used in the world. Because lateral relations - in addition to longitudinal ones - are present between SWOT's four factors, i.e. strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats in SWOT analysis, ANN is one of the best ways to prioritize SWOT strategies, and it makes possible to set relations between all levels of a model and to compare them toward each other. Investigations show that conservative strategies has gained overall score of 0.5431 and after them defensive strategy with overall score of 0.2842 was chosen as second strategy.
Choosing conservative and defensive strategies in cultural tourism conditions of the villages of the city of Binaloud will show the best performance, and competitive and
offensive strategies can be used after current situation has improved in the areas under study.
Keywords: artificial neural network, the city of Binaloud, cultural tourism, strategic planning, village.
References
Afkhami, B., 2007, An Introduction to the Relation between Archeology and Cultural Tourism, Ilam publishing.
ATLAS, 2009, ATLAS Cultural Tourism Research Project, http://www.tramresearch.com/atlas/presentation.htm.
Bhardwaj, Shruti, 2015, Cultural Heritage Tourism and Development in Punjab, Asian Journal of Research in Social Sciences and Humanities, Vol. 5, Issue: 3, PP. 158-181.
Carvalho, M.S.; Lima, J.; Kastenholz, E., 2014, Cultural Creativity- that Opportunity for Rural Destinations?, Journal PASOS: Revista de Turismoy Patrimonio Cultural, Vol. 12, No. 3, PP. 635-648.
Cultural Heritage, Handcrafts and Tourism Organization (CHHTO), 2009, The Document of Reconstruction and Operation of Historical and Cultural Places, Ali Asghar Parhizgar, CHHTO publishing.
Das Beejata, Acharjee Shukla, 2013, Problems and Prospects of Cultural Tourism: A case study of Assam India, International Journal of Physical and Social Sciences, 3(4), PP. 455-462.
Eftekhari, Abdorreza Roknodin, Davoud Mahdavi, 2006, Solutions for Development of Rural Tourism with the Aid of SWOT: Lavasan Kouchak, Quarterly Journal of human sciences teacher, Vol. 10, No. 2, PP. 1-30.
Faaroughi, F., 2012, Codification of Criteria of Urban Design with Culture- based Reconstruction Approach in Order to Grow Cultural Tourism in Historical Areas (Case study: A part of historical area of Sanandaj), Master, Tarbiat Modarres university.
Gaifang Liua, Joseph S. Chenb, 2014, A Dynamic Model for Managing Cultural Tourism, Asia Pacific Journal of Tourism Research, Published online: 04 Apr.
Ghasemi Khouzani, M., 2011, Tourism as a System: Case study: Mashhad, Journal of geography and regional development, No. 17, Fall and Winter.
Ghasemi Khouzani, M., 2008, The Structure and Application of Cultural- religious Tourism and its Management in Mashhad Metropolitan, Ph.D.
Thesis, Shahid Beheshti University.
Hadighe Javani, M., Safarzadeh, M. & Naser Alavi, S., 2010, Study of a Model to Prioritize Pedestrian Immunization based on Artificial Neural Networks, Quarterly Journal of Traffic Management Studies, 16, PP. 39-54.
Hayati, Zohair; Marjan Sadeghi Mojarad & Nima Jafari, 2010, Discovering the Paths of Electronic Information by Using Dependence Rules Algorithm in Data Mining; Case study of the website of the library of the UTS
university, Australia, Quarterly Journal of librarianship and information, 1, PP. 169-251.
Heidari, Majid, Asna Ashari, Hamid, Parsaei, Saeid, & Parvaresh, Saeed, 2014, Using the Analytic Network Process (ANP) in a SWOT Analysis for the Development of Tourism Destination; Case study: KISH Island, International Journal of Management (IJM), 5(6), PP. 21-31.
Hennessey, Sean, Yun, Dongkoo & MacDonald, Roberta Marion, 2014, Segmenting and Profiling the Cultural Tourism Market for an Island Destination, International Journal of Management and Marketing Research, 7(1), PP. 15-28.
Holden, A., 2007, Environment and Tourism, Routledge.
http://whc.unesco.org/en/list/
Jafarnejad Chaghooshi, Ahmad, Fathi, Mohammad Reza, Omidian, Asie & Karimi Zarchi, Mohammad, 2011, Integration of FPM, Fuzzy AHP and ANP Methods in Formulation of Software Industry Strategy (Case study:
System Group Company), Australian Journal of Basic and Applied Sciences, 5(9), PP. 1232-1247.
Jamshidi, S., 2013, Reconstruction of Izad Khaast Caravanserai in Line with the Organizing Historical Buildings in Izad Khaast Plain with Cultural Tourism Approach, Master thesis, Shahid Beheshti University.
Jarkko Saarinen, Naomi Moswete, Masego J. Monare, 2014, Cultural Tourism:
New Opportunities for diversifying the tourism industry in Botswana, Bulletin of Geography. Socio-economic Series, 26(26), PP. 7-18.
Jati, Handaru, 2010, Analysis of Green Computing Strategy in University:
Analytic Network Process (ANP) Approach, The First International Conference on Green Computing, Lumbung Pustaka University Nigeria Yogyakarta.
Kajanus, Miika, Kangas, Jyrki and Kurttila, Mikko, 2004, The Use of Value Focused Thinking and the A SWOT Hybrid Method in Tourism Management, Tourism management, 25(4), PP. 499 506.
Kasimoglu, Murat, Aydin, Handan, 2012, Strategies for Tourism Industry- Micro and Macro Perspectives, Chapter 10: The Role and Importance of Cultural Tourism in Modern Tourism Industry.
Kaspar, C., 1986, Die Fremdenverkehrslehre im Grundriß (= St. Galler Beiträge zum Fremdenverkehr und zur Verkehrswissenschaft, Reihe Fremdenverkehr 1), 3. Auflage, Bern.
Khanzadi, Mostafa, Dabirian, Shahin & Taheriattar, Reza, 2012, Using Hybrid Method for Strategic Planning of Construction Contractor Companies, Journal of American Science, 8 (1), PP. 513-524.
Khalil Eraghi, Mansour and Elham Nobahar, 2011, Predicting House Prices in the of Tabriz: Hedonic price models application and artificial neural network, Quarterly Journal of economic politics and researches, No. 60, PP. 113-138.
Kiya, S.M., 2010, Neural networks in MATLAB, Kiyan rayaneh sabz publication
services cooperative company, Third edition, Tehran, No. of pages 232.
Maleki, M.H., Mohaghar, F. & Karimi Dastjerdi, D., 2010, Conduction and Evaluation of Organizational Strategies with the Help of SWOT Models and Analysis of Network Process of ANP, Organizational culture management magazine, 8th year, 21, PP. 159-176.
María Cristina Otero Gómez, Wilson Giraldo Pérez, 2015, Cultural Tourism in Villavicencio Colombia, Tourism in Latin America, PP. 105-125.
Mazloum, B.Z., Mikaeli Tabrizi A.R. & Salman Mahini, A.R., 2014, Promotion of Evaluation of Effects of Development by the Theory of Dempster-Shafer (Case study: Binaloud city Khorasan Razavi), Quarterly journal of environmentology, 40(3), PP. 621-630.
Moghadam, M., 2009, Evaluation of Changing the Application of Land in Programming City Transportations with the Aid of Artificial Neural Networks (Case study: Zanjan city), Meshkini, Abolfazl, University of Zanjan.
Momeni, M., 2007, Discussion in Urbanity and the Geography of Spare Times and Tourism in: Development of urbanity and tourism industry in Iran (from concept to solutions), Bahman Kargar, Geographical organization of armed forces.
Monavvarian, A., Fathi, M.R., Omidian, A. & Karimi Zarchi, M., 2011, Creating Learning University through Integration of ANP and SWOT with fuzzy AHP Methodology (Case of University of Tehran), 7(10), PP. 23-35.
Mousavi, M. and Bagheri Kashkooli, A., 2013, Cultural Tourism (Nature and Concepts), Arad ketab publishing.
Nakhayi Kmalabadi, I., Amirabadi, M. & Mohammadipour, H., 2010, Selection of the Optimum Strategy based on SWOT Analysis and Analysis of Network Process (ANP) Method (Case study: Arak petrochemical company), Quarterly journal of industrial management of the faculty of human sciences of the Azad university of Sanandaj, 5th year, 11, PP. 21-34.
Ontario Cultural and Heritage Tourism Product Research Paper, 2009, Prenter for Ontario, 70 P.
Pourahmad, A., Hoseini, A., Arouji, Alizadeh, H.M., 2013, The Priority of Evaluating the Strategies for Cultural Tourism Development in Alamout Region in Qazvin, Human geography studies (geographical studies), Autumn, 45(3), PP. 1-17.
Rahnamayi, Mohammad Taghi; Ahmad Pourahmad & Yousef Eshraghi, 2011, Evaluation of City Development in Maragheh with the Aid of the Combined Method of SWOT-ANP, Quarterly Journal of Geography and Development, Sistan and Balouchestan University, 24, PP. 77-100.
Shah Amiri, S.R., Monajjemi S.A.H. & Nemat Bakhsh, N., 2007, Evaluation of Online Systems with Artificial Neural Networks, Scientific - Specialized quarterly Journal of electrical engineering of Majlesi, 3, PP. 55-62.
Shahnoushi, Naser; Mitra Zhale Rajabi; Ali Firouz Zare and Abas Ghaffari, 2013, Identification of Effective Factors in Producing Bread Wastes and
Differences between Bakeries with use of Distinction Analysis and the Artificial Neural Network which is base on it (Case study of the city of Mashhad), Quarterly journal of agriculture economics, 3, PP. 101-132.
Sehat, Saeed & Isa Parizadi, 2009, Using the Process of Network Analysis in Analyzing Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities and Threats (Case study of Iran Insurance joint-stock company), Industrial management magazine, Vol. 1, No. 2, PP. 105-120.
Statistical centre of Iran, 2011 (1390) Iranian Population and Housing Census.
Stebbins, R.A., 1996, Cultural Tourism as Serious Leisure, Annals of Tourism Research, V. 23, No. 4, PP. 948-950.
Steeb, Willi, Hanse, 2005, The Nonlinear Workbook, Third Edition, Johannesburg: World Scientific Publishing Co., PP. 644.
Thirachaya Maneenetr, Thanh Ha Tran, 2014, Developing Cultural Tourism in Border Province: A Case Study on Bueng Kan Province, Thailand, Mediterranean Journal of Social Sciences, Vol. 5, No. 23, PP. 55-62.
Timothy, Dallen J., 2011, Cultural Heritage and Tourism, Channel View Publications.
Wineaster Andersona, 2014, Cultural Tourism and Poverty Alleviation in Rural Kilimanjaro, Tanzania, Journal of Tourism and Cultural Change, Published online: 17 Jul 2014.
Xu, Honggang, Zhouyuan, Tang, Sisi, Ni, 2014, The Impact of Cultural Tourism on the Innovation of Ethnic Handicraft Production in Dali, China, Asia Pacific World, Volume 5, Number 2, Autumn, PP. 82-100.