review article

(1)

2022, Vol. 8 , No. 3 , 163-173

Https://doi.org/10.22059/jppolicy.2022.89549

This Work Is licensed under a CreativeCommons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International (CC BY-NC 4.0) R E V I E W A R T I C L E

Examining the Approaches &Performance of Housing Policies in the Islamic Republic of Iran

Samaneh Keshvardoost^1*, Atefeh Ahmadi Dahrshid²

1-Assistant Professor Education &Islamic Thought, University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran 2- Phd in Geography, University of Kurdistan, Sanandaj, Iran

Corresponding Author’s Email: [email protected]

Received: 22 June 2022 Accepted: 29 August 2022

A B S T R A C T

This article, using the method of document content analysis with a retrospective approach, aims to evaluate approaches

&performance in different periods to investigate the housing policies of the governments. The results of the present research show that the government's policy-making in the form of two general approaches of maximum intervention in the economy, including the quasi-socialist approach in the two periods of the first decade of the revolution &the Ahmadinejad government, led to the l&assignment &intervene polices. But the second approach in the form of market policies in the three governments of Rafsanjani, Khatami &Rouhani has led to the adoption of monitoring, support &empowerment policies.

Keywords:Housing Policy, Approach, Performance, Governments, Iran.

(2)

ﻪ4ﺎﻨ5ﺼ7 ﯽ9ﻮ;< یراﺬ>ﺘ8ﺎﯿ8

هرود ۸ هرﺎﻤD

،

۳ ﺰGHﺎﭘ

،

۱۴۰۱ تﺎﺤOP

.

۱۷۳ - ۱۶۳

Https://doi.org/10.22059/jppolicy.2022.89549

I7< $ FG 7 7 0 9 ( $ K =

4 1$ ") #

1

،*

/ 2 +$ / WZ 2

1 - .$

0 &

1

"./#

_

! "# $ A

A .

2 - )$

j9

! "# $

A $ )

AY/

.

&A! ], ! * :? @A,

[email protected]

:4 . $ J.

1 14010

J.

:O . 3 7 . 2 1401

< 0O

- & D 9?< &' % "#$% U B

?@ # & &@

+ ' $ .

?@ # &' 4 &K 0 & Q O F + # i &'$ , C '

&I "#$%

. + ?@ # 0 7 Y =K (

# # G9 &' " 9 T I &Š2 D + 4 $2 &' E I

+ # . &P = D + Q >

T + # # B ?< C &<

$4

9 + # | . &P D 4 C P ( + &< T Y 2 B + # E I S &' .+

.+ 9 B D C J

$ ! "

.

; W]

: 1 &' ' 5 5< % " ; );

R; % $

.

(3)

%' -) % 5< B) ?. 5 -)! 5 &R 5< P

@ ? , . ' )O '% %& 0 FR) < & F

‚ t & ' @ < - 4 ) ; A 4 :) -)C 5< ' F% Q .1; ' ! 1, & ]4 T > s , $

? , % < < - P4M FR) < & F @ ) . & 1; 5 -)! I ! G # k 2 lJ . ' ,

& M t I Q<

. ' ; v / ) , b$ ! T

Pourmohammadi &et al., 2012 (

4 ) 1 5< :* .

4 J ) %' \ )J

$ m & '% % $ % +. %' % " ; );

1 &' ) 1; ' $ Iran Islamic

Council Research Center, 2020 4 `# [ 2* .(

m & ' 5 &% 1 R; fR %' R; %

% " ; ); :)# 4 :) \ P& % +W & \r < 4 1 J P' 5< ) o [ 2@ %' O O $

1+O "# h);T % +W [ 2* &

)

s of

thplan 6

&

5th

the

; 2012 Urban Development,

&

Report of the Ministry of Roads

evaluation report of Mehr

; development in 2017, 2018 plan of

6th

Report of the performance of the

; 2016 - development 2006

Housing Project, (Maskan-e mehr), 2014

(

% " ; ); ) C . > G S ; $

31 &

43 & 5< ; ; W

1) v< & g {&

$ 1 &'

% " ; ); x * T ) %' $ 1 &' O O $

O ' 5 &% A $ $

+ R; % %' 5< :* FM %& .1; , [ 2@ %' ' @

\; $' & )+ ,

T ' .% P% & 5< % 4 & 0 0 $ , $ ;&% 4 F 1 &' % " ; ); 4

R; % %' $

. 1; % 4 %' 1 ? < & 5< % 4 %' 1 &' % " ; ); bi :* .1; ' do y , 4& & 5< 1 )W F ))s g) * ? A : %' % +. $ T%' .1; , %' T % &' $

$'

)d % 4 %' 5< 1 )W F ; . + ='% "O

% +. '&%& & 1 : -! .

l &% -) 5< % 4 1 )W '& :$ . I ' .% 5< O Q<C ?) ' 1 1 )W :$ . &

) ' ' $ @ ‹% 5<

Ahmadi Daharshid, 2017: 157-169; Aghaei, 2017; Baradaran &et al., 2019

P i q 0 & (

1 &' 5< % " ; );

; % ) $ %' .' $ @ dƒ -) $ 5< ?5+ a!% F%& 0 & 1) $

)J 4 5 4 )

?5, . T 4 & \ %' P' $ &

%' % +. 5< % " ; ); 1)$

- % $

1; ); & % +. ' Q$ % & ' 2 W R.

1 &' $ ' ) b)$ ; , & 5< % " ; ); ;% ='' O

: C &

.1; %& 0 P' 5< 4 ) l -) ;% T l &% :)# $

# %& ; % %' )+)

% " ; ); p & ' 5 ' 5 &% i f C% C ‚ t 4 `# ' %' & @ ' # :$&m#

1 &' G $ 4 J %' $

.1; ' ;% % 5<

:$&m# h c 4 J %' . $

' # 5< ; ); ' 2 W ' \ ;% I Q c 1; ! O P % +. %' 5<

. @

\ / %' , ' ) O < 1; ' ' % W ;% '% % %' 5< $ !% % "O 1; ); FM .

.

O 5< % " ; ); . fR >& $' 4 ! O G ! b$ ! O ' ; % ; 1, Q . '

' ; 4 & ' . & 5< & ) 4 , M . & 1; +O \ 1 X. 4 '4 & ,

) 1; , T M' Q ]4% ,%

Hezarjaribi &Emami Ghafari, 2019

\ / %' .(

% " ; ); & 1 &' '

:$&m# % . 5 '- . R; fR 4 \ %' 5<

1; ); I ! G 1; 0 J 1 &' $

' ;% % $

1 &' ' 5 1;

) 1; ' % W '% % T p & $

Baradaran &et al., 2019

1; ); ;% & ?) .(

$

\ / P %' 5< ) o R.

, ' ) O < T %' . 1;

1; ); ) %' . 5< ) o g * $

b$ ! % a & P4M F W & B , 1 &' T %' . 4 ; ]&%

4 < % , 5< ' @ ) . ; .

?) < 5< ) o %' 1; .

)

Shekargazar &et al., 2014

.(

1; ); ) fR 4 `# %' 5< $

R;

' . ; , % fR 4 `# 5< ) o %' J 5< & J ) 4 1; ); ; ; ' 5 &% &'

(4)

ﻪ.ﺎﻨ0ﺼ2 ﯽ ﻮ3 یراﺬ ﺘ ﺎﯿ

هرود ۸ هرﺎﻤ7،

۳

، ﺰ:;ﺎﭘ ۱۴۰۱ .

تﺎﺤCD ۱۷۳ - ۱۶۳

1;

)

Alian &Ismailzadeh, 2015

.(

+$&m# p

• 5•< % 4 • & ' •2 W R•. ?• ) } Q %

& O •r $% •+.

7 + y •, . $'

•$

5< 1 )W F ; %' ? ' •2 W •0 k •t •

) 1•; $% +. %'

Beltratti & Morana, 2010

\ / %' .(

) % 5 $ & & C 1; ); ) t P ) › / % (2017

4 %&' %' ;& $ & )C $% +. %' 5< % 4 $'4 & ' 2 W 2003

- 2012 ;%

T .1; , ' ; $

! O ) /@ )c & /@ O 1)› ? # ]&% 4 $'4 ' 2 W 1; ); ) t P 4 ! t A 1)› .

. +$&m# .'% ' ' & $ & )C % +. &' $ %' 5< \W &

y , & % @ % Q 5< 1 )W ) } Q %

% # 1; );

4 4 %' 1994

- 2013 , P -) % @ ; % ' •)0 ' @ ]&% 4 ' ; E& % +. %'

+ 1;

\ % @ % Q T )do ' ' 4 5< 1 )W # 1; ); y , )do . $' 1; ' Q % '

)

Robstad, 2018

.(

@ , # I k 8p

O ' 1 &' @ [ 2@ %' ‚ / $ % 4 %' $

) % 5< & ) 4 % ! t . g)t &'

& % 4 P i

Qt 5< & ) 4 % 4 %' 1 &' @ % ! t ) -) ) g)t Q . '

' T % ! t .1! O i %

q W& 4 ?QW . % 4 P i 2008

h c

&' 1 @' P 1; ); \ & , % 4 %' 1

& ' 5< & ) 4 T > P & ?W J %' % - %

P-) 5 . 4 = $ @ % 4 $

% 0 & 0

% ' 5 &% & ' . $% T ' ; q 5< & ) 4 ()2* %' T i '

) 4 % 4 4 ; $% $ .1; 5< &

' |; % 4 P-) 5 ' 2 W ?u < ' % 5< ?u < . ' Q) $ O ' = O ' q $ . \ &

u 1;' % . 4 1 &' @ ) $ .

Dejkam, 1994

. \ 1 &' @ \! ? %' .(

) 4 5< &

5 & , ~ J 1 % 1 %' & ) 4 / % . ; % %' % T , 1 &' 1;' %' .' )O %

' 2 W O ' O ' k $ & y q O ' %' .1; 5< % 4 , - %

1) \!

) 4 %' $

, "O % . 5<

) b <); "# €- 5< :* .' + ' 2 W 1 & - %

4 & '' O

k $ ) 1; ' 2 W & \; . $

Hyderabadi, 2001: 120

k& \ !% E u O ' .(

O ' .1;

& O 5< } $

) % W g)t %' -) T%' b.

)

. 1; ; ? , O ' .'

% Q :4

a ' . < % Q )< ; . - i %' 5< $

.' )O

.1; ) # % 5< $ J & T ?2J . ) % Q - ; F Qt 5< 1@ ; } J $ - . ) # 1 /

' 2 W h 5 h c ' 5 &% .'% ' % W O' \ - ). ' 2 W % ! t I ~ ! g)t &' ) J %' (W % 4 % . & 4 ; h; % " ; ); & \ & 1; T ?) 5 5 % 4 % . & 4 ; 1 %'

? 5 . T .' , ? * 1; 5

.) % F Rt ' & C M' ' 2 W %' % 1 &' 1 @' $

%& 0 (1; ~' G 5< & ) 4 '% %' F , )G % T T% . 1 &' O%- & 5C . ) &% 4 . '

T i 4 . . t 4 % 4 %' a ) ()2* ?J % $

' 5 &% & 1; A) . ' C% C %' $' ; )# % l

T f / ) 1; G 2@ & &' )c :* 4 ; $

Noormohammadi &et al., 2015: 344

1; ); .(

%' 5< $

J t % +. A P' !% : -! % i . 1 J . ,

W

; ;

% R;

% ' ' 5<

h;

% +W g * P'

% A < ' lJ

&

1 &'

% ' . ! \ \ ' JT 5< ) o > v< &

1 &' S ; .1;

), . % $ $ 1; ); x *

. ?J % % +. 5< ?5+ g * & # $

C 1) ! h c ! ) 1;'

Om & ?) ' ' ; 4 . % P 4 5< % 4 ' ! 2 $

a!% %' W % 4 % . & 4 ; IM \ )c & 0 ' :+. b. % 4 $ 0 & . 0 ) M Rt

(5)

>' \ P 4& & ' Q T :)# $

»

% 4 1<5,

« %' W ' 4 $% @ % $ . J %' > X .1; ?

> ; %' <) 2*, 5< @ 1385

4 :) 600 > ; %' & % -$

1390 4 :) 6 / 1 %' @ 5< J & ) )

1; , ' ' & % +. ?.

)

Population &housing census in 2006 &2011

.(

1 &' % rJ &% 4 & . 1 $

. b)i

@ F ) > 5 FR) < / .1; ) ? W . < % 4 `# F <;ƒ 4 % @ $

E& # & d $% % 4 ?)5+ 5< FR) < 4 $% 5$ % 4 5< & 5< ?X $

& b) < % "O d % , 5< % 4 %' 1 &' b) < )c

) &%

Gharakhani, 2014 (.

$.

a k " " # I

4 5 . $

1 &' ' 5 @ -) $' + % 5< :* %' $

l k $ "#

1 &' %' 5< $ * $

> t %' g T 4 P . $ ;% ' %' . 1; \; $

@ ' # $ .' ,

$.

+ # I L % & "

1QX F 5 4 5 4 J %' >&

, 5< 1@ ; $% )\ & 4 ))\ F%& 0 5<

&

5 h; ;&%

F B@ T 5 4 Ž% ! = , \; & / F )G 2@ & ) & , +

B@ A I ! G + B@ 4 5 .1; W +

4 :$ . $ ' 5 %' . ' 5< $ J &

-) 5< 4 ) ' & ) w $ . ' l ' \ 4 k $ , ) :)#

5< J &

T l -) & + , ) 74

'%&T G%' ) '' O

Pourmohammadi &et al., 2012: 39

; ) & %' .(

>

J & ' \ , ?) 5 & ' 5< $

167 . ' J & % -$

57 . l % k $ G%' 1; '

> ; %' .

P&' 137 >' \ . J & % -$

67 > ; %' .1; k $ G%' 1370

, %' , ) $ J & q

&

;&%

453 . ' J &% -$

143 4 1; G 2@ :* } : -! .1; ' l % k $ G%' ' 5

& O% . $ J & ' %' 1 &'

% .

17 %' 10

> ; %' .1; ' l % k $ G%' 1371

394

. , ) J & % -$

71 ) 1; ' l % k $ G%'

Azizi, 2004: 4

.(

>&

1 k $ T < & , ' 5< $ J & ' \ .

Source: (Program &Budget Organization, economic report of the housing sector, 1989-1993)

1. Market Failure

(6)

ﻪ.ﺎﻨ0ﺼ2 ﯽ ﻮ3 یراﺬ ﺘ ﺎﯿ

۳

، ﺰ:;ﺎﭘ ۱۴۰۱ .

تﺎﺤCD ۱۷۳ - ۱۶۳

>&

2 ' 5 .

< & , ' % . & O% . 5< $ k $ T

Source: (Program &Budget Organization, economic report of the housing sector, 1989-1993)

$.

+ # I L % ;

4 J %' $' Q . Q P&- \; P&' $˜@& 5<

• + >& $ >&

k $ B@ . & ). R. $ +

1; ); & ; ; $ . $

). k $ S ; .'4 ' # %' P&'

4 J ' ; P&' # 5< J & %' % @ b. ‡ J :4 % Q 5<

\; & ) 4 4 ) , bi

1 5; ?) 5 & 0 % 4 ; ' T l t 4 O

1 5; ; : O 5< Q ) b ; : -! $

O , %' \ $ 4 ; •%- $

1!

h);T % +W A . % +. , lt %' F \/W a) & ' ; ! $

) \)Qt • ; 4 O ' h);T & "#

Azizi, 2004: 39

› . k $ & ( > ; 4 h) 5< 1@ ; P&'

1373 352 =

1374 330 = 1375 310 = 1376 291 = 1377 340 , lt %' 5< J & % -$

) '

Rahmani, 2005: 186

' 5 .(

. k $ + 5< :* %' P&'

> ; %' $' 1373

' \ 219 . , ) 5< J & % -$

64 G%'

> ; P&' > ; %' .1; ' . l % k $ 1374

226 & ' O — J J & % -$

77 l % k $ G%'

.1; ' > ; 1375 J & ' \ , — J 5< $

214 . 1; % -$

69 ' k $ h; G%'

> ; .1;

1376 212 & , ) J & % -$

64 > ; \ @T > ; %' & 1; ' . l % k $ G%' 1377

207 >' \ J & % -$

58 1; ' O — J k $ G%' k $ l G%' & ' 5 & k $ -) 4 >& .

+ % 5 . $'

k $ .1; ' 4T & 5< k $ , ) -) [ 2@ %' '

> ; %' 1375 . '

16 ? %' ' , ) F% G ) $ J & ?. G%' 8

G%'

> ; %' k $ ) w $ . , ) F% G 1376

1@ ; 52 / 4 bW% 5) J %' ' ' 4T F% G $ J & 4 G%'

? %' 70

) >& > ; ; %' . );% G%' 7

9 lQt 5) J%' ' F% G ) $ J & G%'

) 1Q<

13 18 > ; %' .' -)C bW% -) ) ?. 4 , 1 J 5< b ; . , G%' 74

)

> ; %' & , l b ; 4 76

b ; , 1 J & 5< 1@ ; Q< l P . T P ;&'

) ' , )\ k $ 4 :) ' 4T 5<

Azizi, 2004: 39-40

.(

>&

3 , ' 5 .

> ; > t %' 5< ) (@

\; P&' $

Source: Iran Statistical Center

(7)

$.

+ # I L % ;%

> ; 4 \; P ; $

1379 1383 ), %' ))s . ' O h 2 & &

+* - %

:* = +* ! &

b$'4 ?2! 5<

%' 5< :* . k $ .' ' [ 2 @ ' @ ' p # % \;

1@ ; ? , P ; 3114

> ; %' . k $ ' 5 ;% .1; ' 5< J & % -$

$ 1379 1383 +

1@ ; k $ $' 380

' 5 & 5< J & % -$

371

$ > ; %' J & % - 1390

'& J . ' 6

/ 97 G%'

4 •/; B; (@ , [ 2@ %' 1; ! O F% G @ . k $ l C O .1; ' k $ > ; %' .'% ' G ! k $ ' 5 1379

k $ 110

' 5 &

122 (@ , 4 @ .1; ' ' $

G ! k $ -) $ T%' b. 5<

'% ' ' 4 )

Report of The Parliment Research Center: Housing &Urban

Development Sector in the Third Development Plan &Budget Bill 2001, 2002: 5-8

5; ' \ , '&-! hQ; .(

%' 4& Fo)$ & , ;% )c > ;

1382 5; $ ; & 4 ; ; .' h 2 % ;% )c $

1; ); ' & 4 -$ & J $

% ' ]4% ,& ! b. ,% & ' ‹% 1 ' %' ) ! $

O 5< % 4 %' % k 2 ]4% O ' ; 1 %' & ' Q ]4% &

5< 5< ) : -! bc% & 1!

'& J 10 12 M ; T%' ) );% , % @

Hezarjaribi &Emami Ghafari, 2019: 104

%&' %' . % t .(

5< :* l &% $ , % ' , k t 4 b. ]& ! ?) ' b. ]& ! 4 , y , ?) ' b),

4 ; Q

) 4 & ) 4 : -! & % @ 1 % ?5, T )# & T # 4 ; • \ ' ' + % ' @ % @

)

Rahmani, 2005: 189

@ 5 FR) < u % ?QW &' \; P ; %' .(

€- P' ' . % '

1; );

G $ % ,

1!%

5 # T % . %' . P & } <W 1@ ' # ' .

J 1@ ; $

& O 5<

$

b.

b 4 5 . , ‚ / T%' 4& . 0 =' ) 4 % 4 ? . 4 ;' 4T \; P ; $' 5 &%

% )<

%' 5< k% \ 1 )W G ? % T & % ' T $ R.

$ , . '

>&

4 .

> ; t % +. ?. , lt %' 5< $ J & ) :)# & ) $

88 - 1379

$.

+ # I L % ; i[

> ; %' \; P% C W

$ 1384 1388 . ' O h 2 & &

1) \!

5< :* $

; P 5 b <); '& 1 J '% 4 @ %' & G 2@ :* 1 & % "O 1 &' : & ' )O

& O & m & % +W 5< ) o 4 1 J & ?) < '& :* %' ) 1; T%' b. $

Tavaklinia &Zarghami,

2017: 58-59

\ / .(

+ %' 1 &' ' 5 ]% -O a ‚ t h 2 & ) 4 J %' b 1 &' . $'

; :* %' .1; ' 5 ? 5< ' 2 W 4 J %' P% C W ; 4 , a0& F - 5<

% "O

; f" 1 % ' @ ]R 1 &' C $ -) % @

% G % @ % "O & FR5+ ?) ' 1; ' ' F

(8)

ﻪ.ﺎﻨ0ﺼ2 ﯽ ﻮ3 یراﺬ ﺘ ﺎﯿ

۳

، ﺰ:;ﺎﭘ ۱۴۰۱ .

تﺎﺤCD ۱۷۳ - ۱۶۳

5< )@ 4 1 J :* %' 1 &' ' 5 .1; ' 5 h<. 4 J %' ) ! @ ; 4 FR5+ @ -) ) T) W 4 J %' b$ & (4 ; 5< )@ ' ) ' 4 J %' b$ -) 4 ; ) $ ; W

0 &

FR) < '- % . % / ? , 5 FR) < :* %' .1; ' f / P% C W l / ( 5<

) 1; , ' P% C l / QW ? W ' 5 1 &' -) } <W 1@ ' #4 ' . 5 # &

Report of The Parliment

Research Center, 2010 .(

@ 4%

(@ , 4 J %' $ + 5<

> ; %' % +. •/; %' 5< ) $' 1389

1206 1Q< . ' 5< J &% -$

) P% C 780 -) ( J & % -$

65 , ' ,% G%'

%' 5< :* › . k $ 4 @ .1;

? W 4 >& %' \; P% C iJR

. ,

Development Plan, Economic Report of 2012, 2019, p. 805) source: (Report on the Performance of the Law of the 4th

$.

L % 2/ + # I

P% C k $ 4 % )< . T%' 4 \; b # . , ? & ' W P

P &' & 5< — J T%' b. % +W 5< ) o \ 5< a ‚ t ) )# k $ 5< :* %' 1; ); ) $ $ ' % 4 b)i 1; ); & 5< $

:$ . & + T $ / $

%' 4 % '% @

) , ' k $ h; 5<

Hezarjaribi &Emami Ghafari, 2019: 111

) )# ; % %' ) w $ .(

' 4 5< :* %' T k $ 167

173 1! . ' 5 &% % '%

.1; ! O i %' ' ; ! $

(9)

>&

6

b # ' 5 .

5< 4 J %' \;

Source: Report of the performance of the fifth plan of development 2017

(@ , ' 5 ;%

> ; t @ ; & 5< :* ) . $

+ $

(@ , = $' › . $

) # ' 5 ;&% & , 5< ) , ) :)# k $ 1Q<

(@ , &

$ ) /; ). $

) :)# P W% 4 ' 5 J & $ 4 B; & J & $ %' % @ b. J &

, ' , ) (@ , .

> ; %' , 5<

1395 % +. ' 2 W b. J ' .%

49 ) 1; , ' k $ 1Q< l G%'

Report of

the performance of the fifth plan of development, volume 2, 2017: 55

.(

$.

+ # I L % 2 (

' 5 &%

& 1; ' . ))s % 0 1; ); % 0 1; ); 4 b+, % C %' % 1 & b+,

; :1; ' ' % W 0 % 1! .

5; . ; ' ; ! $

& @ , *) ' @ $

& O & $ b. $

' [ 2@ %' . T%' 78

W g 5 % 1 &' \; b+,

& 1 l ; % %'

h);T % +W 4 1 J :, # B< & "#

) & J ' $ h);T :$ . & ) +)# &

1Q< $

& J t 4 ) 5< ' 5< :* %' ' k $ . P W ! $ ?) P4M $

4 T . k $ . 1; ( J & 5< ) 77000

> ; %' J &

1395 96000 > ; %' J &

1400 .1;

(10)

ﻪ.ﺎﻨ0ﺼ2 ﯽ ﻮ3 یراﺬ ﺘ ﺎﯿ

۳

، ﺰ:;ﺎﭘ ۱۴۰۱ .

تﺎﺤCD ۱۷۳ - ۱۶۳ >&

7 . œ . k $ 4 J %' b+,

5<

Source: The Document of Sixth Development Plan, 2015: 237

' 5 4 @ 0 J > J %' @T > ; ?) ' b+, ' 5 p ' Q S ;' %' $

- , i ]% -O @T S ; }

> ; 1396 - (@ , 4 @ p G%' G 4 ) 5< ' $

1! . ; [ 2@ %' .1; ' O l &% 4 .1; S ) %' , ! 4 1 &' ' 5 &% ' ; ! $

' ; 5 FR) < / 8

1! . ; G%'

%' ! 4 ' ; ' & ' ; ! $ ; -. 1* #

& $

; ,

& @ 5< 1 &' ' 5 &% .1; ! O % W % . % ;' %' $ > ; %' .1; b5 4 `# ~& G ‚ t = $

1396 4 :) ~& G % T S ; 220

-) C 5 . ' . 4 `# & ' ; ‚ t 4 % @ % -$

hQ; ~& G A$' 1)\0& ' Q

\ ) # $ A$' +) ~& G .1; > ƒ; ' ,

% \ B; $

u % FR) < % . +W 1 %' . ! O k $ ) $'

Tavaklinia &Zarghami, 2017: 73

.(

>&

8 .

> ; t %' \; b+, ' 5 $

1397 - 1396

Source: Report of the performance of the fifth plan of development in 2017-2018: 333

(11)

References:

1- Aghaei, Parviz (2017), Evaluation of urban housing policies in the Islamic Republic of Iran, Tehran: Public Policy Studies Network [in Persian].

2- Ahmadi Daharshid, Atefeh (2017), Explanation of the Economic Developments of Sanandaj Urban Area, PhD Thesis, Department of Human Geography, Khorazmi University of Tehran [in Persian].

3- Azizi, Mehdi (2004), evaluation of housing &urban development performance in the first plan, 1994, website of the Ministry of Roads

&Urban Development [in Persian].

4- Baradaran, Morad; Ghafari Gholamreza, Rabiei, Ali &Zahedi Mazandarani, Mohammad Javad (2019), Government &housing policy in Iran after the Islamic revolution", Welfare &Social Development Planning Quarterly, Volume 10, Number 38, pp. 179-218 [in Persian].

5- Beltratti, A., & Morana, C. (2010). International house prices &macroeconomic fluctuations. Journal of Banking & Finance, 34(3), 533- 545.

6- Chow, S. C., Cunado, J., Gupta, R., & Wong, W. K. (2018). Causal relationships between economic policy uncertainty &housing market returns in China &India: Evidence from linear &nonlinear panel &time series models. Studies in Nonlinear Dynamics & Econometrics, 22(2).

7- Comprehensive housing plan, executive-strategic document (2006), Ministry of Housing &Urban Development [in Persian].

8- Dejkam, Laleh (1994), Government &housing problem, collection of papers of Iran Housing Development Seminar, Ministry of Housing

&Urban Development, first volume, first edition, Tehran [in Persian].

9- Document of the Sixth Plan of Economic, Social &Cultural Development of the Islamic Republic of Iran (2016-2020), 2015, Tehran:

Country Management &Planning Organization [in Persian].

10- Ghanbari, Abolfazl &Zaheri, Mohammad (2010), evaluation of macro housing policies in the plans of pre &after the Islamic Revolution of Iran, Housing &Rural Environment, No. 132, pp. 77-90 [in Persian].

11- Gharakhani, Masoumeh. (2014), black box of comprehensive housing plan, economic special issue of Sharq newspaper, December 2014, Available online at: http://sharghdaily.ir/Vijeh// [in Persian].

12- Hezarjaribi, Jafar, Emami Ghafari, Zeinab (2019), review of evolutions in housing welfare policies in Iran (9179-2013), Quarterly of Social Development &Welfare Planning, No. 38, pp. 76-119 [in Persian].

13- Iran Statistical Center, Population &Housing Census, 2006 &2011 [in Persian].

14- Noormohammadi, Mehdi, Meshkini, Abolfazl, Ruknuddin Eftekhari, Abdolreza, Sarrafi Mozafar (2015), Institutional Approach in Urban LandManagement, Tehran, Arad Ketab Publications, p. 346 [in Persian].

15- Pourmohammadi, Mohammad Reza, Sadr Mousavi, Mirsattar, Abedini, Asghar (2012), analysis of housing policies of the government with an emphasis on socio-economic &cultural development programs, Urban Studies, No. 3, pp. 43-34 [in Persian].

16- Program &Budget Organization (2000), Law of the Third Plan of Economic, Social &Cultural Development of the Islamic Republic of Iran, Tehran: Program &Budget Organization [in Persian].

17- Rahmani, Teymur, Esfahani, Pouria (2015), an analysis of the effect of supply &demandfactors on housing prices in Iran, Quarterly Journal of Housing Economics, No. 55, p. 11 [in Persian].

18- Rahpo Sakht-e Sharestan Consulting Engineers (2014), evaluation report of Mehr Housing Project, (Maskan-e mehr) Ministry of Housing

&Urban Development, Office of Planning &Housing Economics [in Persian].

19- Report of the Ministry of Roads &Urban Development, 2012 [in Persian].

20- Report of the performance of the fifth plan of economic, social &cultural development of the Islamic Republic of Iran in 2016, third volume of Sectoral area, 2017, Tehran: Publications of the country's program &budget organization, center of documents &publications [in Persian].

21- Report of the performance of the Law of the Sixth Plan of Economic, Social &Cultural Development of the Islamic Republic of Iran in 2017, 2018, Tehran: Publications of the country's program &budget organization, center of documents &publications [in Persian].

22- Report of the revision studies of the comprehensive housing plan (2015), Ministry of Roads &Urban Development, National Land&Housing Organization, Bureau of Macroeconomics [in Persian].

23- Robstad, Ø. (2018). House prices, credit &the effect of monetary policy in Norway: evidence from structural VAR models. Empirical Economics, 54(2), 461-483.

24- Shir, Ahad (2005), 15-year performance of the housing sector in the first, second &third plans of Iran's economic development after the revolution (1989-1993), Political &Economic Information Journal, No. 217 &218, pp. 184- 189 [in Persian].

25- Tavaklinia, Jamile, Zarghami, Saeed (2017), pathology of the fifth &sixth national programs of economic, social &cultural development of the country in the field of housing for low-income urban groups, studies of urban structure &function, number 16, pp. 47-82 [in Persian].

26- The Central Bank of the Islamic Republic of Iran (2001), summary of economic developments from 2001 to 2016, Department of Economic Surveys, Tehran, Iran [in Persian].