Manuscript Review
for publication in the Scientific and analytical journal Qogam jane Dauir
Reg. No. Science field:
Article title:
No
. Evaluation criteria Yes No Note, recommendation
1 Article compliance 1.1 Journal profile
1.2 Correspondence of the article title to its content
Compliance of the abstract with the content of the article and keywords
1.3 Compliance with the design of scientific manuscripts
2 Relevance of the topic
2.1 Justification of the relevance of the issue 2.2 Sufficiency of reflection of the topic in
domestic and foreign publications 3 Scientific level of the article 3.1 The completeness of the topic
3.2 The correctness of setting goals and objectives
3.3 The validity of the applied research methods
3.4 The validity of the made conclusions and proposals
4 Scientific novelty
4.1 The authenticity of the obtained results 4.2 The presence of controversial provisions 5 Scientific presentation
5.1 Scientific nature of the language and the style of presentation
5.2 Content understandability 5.3 Correct terminology
5.4 Reasonableness of the volume of the article and its elements – figures, tables, list of sources
6 Article evaluation 6.1 Positive sides 6.2 Negative sides
6.3 Comments and suggestions
Recommendations for publication (highlight the necessary):
1. The article can be published without scientific editing.
2. The article can be published subject to corrections and additions without re-review 3. The article needs corrections, additions, and re-review
4. This article is not recommended for publication
Reviewer _________________________________________________
Academic degree, title _________________________________________________________
Position ___________________________________________________________________
Place of work _________________________________________________________________
Date:
