!"#$$%&
!'(: *+#, " 1 %+".$/
REVITALIZING THE OPEN SPACE IN PUBLIC HOUSING COMMUNITY A CASE OF NHADS BANGPLEE NEW TOWN, PHASE 1
!&G *H
%I!H IJ
KJL,JM+!"J'(
"MN,"! 2546
!"# $%&# '($)'"
*+,-../ # !*.01*# '($)' $./ 2#
3//2"$ ** 3. -*4!&# # '1
$ 51$ 4! !6 (!"# )782 2/ !%
.$#" #.(**## $.*$./ *1$*
## # '1 2'"#"#! # 2%*'/7&!%
,-.# /"!"# .'5 2,-.5 1$12. ,-.!#' .#' .$+* ,-...'
'.#"3 2*,-.2# $ $2..0/
' .,22'# ,-.4!!"# $%&# 1'$2 /" ')' 2'%#2'# 122#"+2*,-.# # ' *
# ' 2!9 1$$2+'4! 2 2/9% .$#"+ # # ' *!9'$'1$
&(2'.$2' 2+''$.$'# # ' '$,-.
!"# $%& #" 1$ )*3**% ..$ (# '($)' .$*!# 2/(2 )/7# 232'')'.
'2*,-.
'#" 22'$.# # ' '*:;<:(!"# $%&
)1''1$#'$2 &# 2'$)"3%*'=&1 '$23 2**4!# $ 3.2'"#"2#7&# 23
%*'>&?!&# @/ (0.$#"')/7
$1
&(2'
!"
#" #$! "#:
%&'()* 1 '&(,(-./ % % &'#" ! ( )*#"'$ (&'"' #& !#(+(,)-
)% %)#'*"!#.'/0! 1 !#$%#2345$%' #(+5$% ! 6&*
#1 #1 (' #1 )*&' 1'7#" !#'1'#8
9:,#$"*&'#" !( #"))#$"*
5'
(8)) 204 (8)) 50 1 B (8)) 50 1 '#@A-(8)) 40 1 B &'(8)) 40 1'
#@A- !6'#'#'*#$!/)) #(+(,)-!"&*
% )*1- .8- 5'#7 " "
/) ))#$&'/ 7(C11- 7 #,,' 5#'
#"' !6"& ( & "- % #(+' "
#))*1*#$!
" : 23425$% !*8)) !*
: ,#$"*5' ! 1 #"&"*)1
: F ,- &'/- /
"*: 7(C11- "' (
(G !55-: 5.. 2547
*
5$% !*8)) !* "$5$% ! !&1*# 6#5$!
)) #(+5$% ! !&' , )% % 17(-#5$! &' 8/5(C@" '*#), ,5 5 8-(C@" 4 (#.
* 5 8- 6&* 1) 1/55$% ! , 5 8-5J1 )5$% ! ' /55$% ! 2) 1# # &' 5 , 7/5 5"*&'- !# !&'5$% !*8 3) 1#)5J1&' ,5J1 &&&' 1) 5$% !*8
&*1*L &' 4) 1#)7 ,' 5 8-&*1*L ! * 6# (#.23425$% !*8 #$! )% %#(+ #)"
!)1*(C@""'1 "8 1 '#"- !
"'"' 6&* )&7 /- *# !#)'6(1&1*) 1 !#"- , #"-&' #"- 8(C@"&' 5 8- (C@"/5
' 5* #"1 @ !"5$% !*8&' $ (C@"
(8/5 "* !&'5$% ! #$!() !
#* !"*0! )&'6 % &"* !&'5$% !M
#$! 0 " ! 1'7 5 8-#)(7 /- !*'"#
)5$% !*8 !6*' #1- )5$% !#
@: 5$% !*8 " *6#
Research Topic: Revitalizing the Open Space in Public Housing Community A Case of NHAks Bangplee Newtown, Phase 1
Name of Researchers: Mr. Nattawut Usavagovitwong and Ms. Sukumaporn Jongpakdee Name of Institution: Faculty of Architecture, Sripatum University
Year of Publication: B.E. 2547
ABSTRACT
Open space in public housing community, which known as public recreation space is currently lack of any maintenance and service, and it becomes unhealthy and useless for the people in community. The main objectives of this research are to study, explore and explain the relationship structure of the problems existing in the study area in 4 perspectives those are 1) Physical aspect, by exploring the relationship between userks behavior and the physical conditions of area of study, 2) Finance and resources aspect, by investigating financial and resourcesk condition of related institutions and organizations, 3) Behavioral and social aspect, by exploring behavior of people in community, patterns of utilizing open space, and attitude of people to open space, and 4) Institutional aspect, by explaining the stakeholdersk relationship in various aspects in revitalizing open space issue. Because this research is regarded as interdisciplinary approach, so the methodology is itself requires the various and different analysis, for instance,
questionnaires and in-depth interview according to the type of data and information, which each perspective may require, and finally, analyzing and synthesizing to identify the whole picture of existing problemks structure.
The outcomes are that the key problems of failure in maintaining open space of the study area are the mismanagement of budgets, manpower, and resources in related institutions and organizations due to the mismatch between the size of population and resources, including the conflict between related public institutions because of overlapping and unclear of task forces, which remain the existing use much different from the previous masterplan of open space.
Keywords: Open space, Interdisciplinary approach, Stakeholder
1 .... 1
1.1 .. 1
1.2 !"# $!%&'()%*+!.. 3 1.3 -./"0123.. 4
1.4 )-123. 4
1.5 &-... 5
1.6 7123. 5
1.7 "(907+:7 .. 6 2 ;3<) ..
...
72.1 !%&+=>.... 7 2.2 ;3<7)!%&+=>)!%
9/9)%... 8
2.3 77 7!%&+=>.. 12 2.4 ;3<@AB@$ 21 2.5 ;3<!=0)9.. 25
3 =.... 30
3.1 )=.. 30
3.2 )D $.. 30
3.3 -") *.. 32
3.4 /". 33
4 )7!%&123)0 $!%&'9/9. 36 4.1 $!%&'()%*+ !.. 36
4.2 -)9 !. 43
4.3 -)9)13' ) !.. 54 4.4 -)9!;-... 59 4.5 7)D*!F!%&+=>... 67 5 )7-)9.)0.. 69 5.1 )1G-)=.... 69 5.2 )+9- ()%*+!.. 80
5.3 09/9... 81
5.4 )01-7 *9 !%&+=>H$ +:7 )*
+/-+I*"#/ 83 5.5 !=0)9H-+@AB@$!%&+=>... 87 5.6 /"-)9.. 91 6 /"H123 )... 101 6.1 )0/" !H123... 101
6.2 ) 104
6.3 + .... 111
>/.. 113
H .. 118 H . -+.*9 *. 119 H . 3>0H$ +) *@AB@$!%&+=>... 123
"-+H$ ... 137
J
-
3.1 -"*9 *)%%*9 *)D $ 32 4.1 "9*)-)1-)= )7%!;3 !.1. 2546.. 41 4.2 -"9+-)-" )7%!;3 !.1. 2546 42 4.3 $+1)>!%&123... 44 4.4 *9 7)>!%&+-H*9 7)7... 48 4.5 *9 7)>!%&+-)"K.. 48 4.6 - 7 !- :7 ""/.. 53
4.7 )1-)= 54
4.8 +)1-)=.. 55
4.9 7.7!)*7$!%&+=>
+) .. 58
4.10 3>7 9! H$ $+1*9/9. 60 4.11 3>!;- . H$ $+1*9/9.. 61 4.12 3>.%$+1H$ $+1*9/9. 62 4.13 3>7)%H$ $+1*9/9 63 4.14 3>*9 !%&+=> H$ $+1*9/9)*9
!%&+=> 63
4.15 .**9 !%& H$ $+1*9/9)*9 !%&+=>... 64 4.16 9+)*9 !%&+=> H$ $+1*9/9)*9 !%&+
=>... 64
4.17 !*H$ $+1*9/9 -+ ! !!%&+=> 65 4.18 )D)+)*7!%&+=>H$
$+1*9/9... 66
5.1 )01 !"=H*7 7$!%&+
=>)1G *7"L-. 75 5.2 ) 9+7$7 !%&))1G. 79 5.3 /" 7)D7 (H!F!%&H$ +) ... 84
9
-
5.4 /" 7)D7 - *"(90!%&H$ +) . 84 5.5 /" 7)D7 "#/"*!F!%&H$ +) ... 85 5.6 /" 7)D7 :*!F!%&H$ +) .. 86 5.7 3>!=0/+ *9/9 89 5.8 ")7D7 +)1G)G 91 5.9 )") :7 )" 7)72&*-+)%*@AB@$!%&
+=>..
95 5.10 )")"(90:7 "(90):"H$ +:7 )*-+
)%*@AB@$!%&+=>..
97 6.1 (1 !*/+)"K0)!%!F9/9 102
M
!"
2.1 Sherry ArnteinWs ladder of participation 17
3.1 ( 34
4.1 -&!%&123 37 4.2 !%&1233> !(7. 38 4.3 +9/9*!%&123.. 39 4.4 )- 7$!%&*()%*+ !+9
) 40
4.5 ! 1-2 !!%&(+)!%*"#/. 45 4.6 ! 3-8 !!%&(+)!%)%(.. 46 4.7 ! 9-14 //!%&(+)!%)!%
*&. 47
4.8 *9 !%&+)!%.. 50
5.1 +)1G-)=. 71
5.2 ( 7$7 )1G-)= 73 5.3 ( :">9/9. 81 5.4 !!=0+)1G/-... 91 5.5 !.>0 !=0H$ +:7 )) *@AB@$
!%&+=> 93
6.1 ! )& 1. 106 6.2 ! )& 2. 107 6.3 ! )& 3. 109 6.4 +%+*@AB@$!%&+=>. 110
1 1
1.1
!"#$%
"&& '( 2518 , % (,&. /0 1 3 .4.
2515-2519) 48& .9:9 4;' " ,&!,<=>%?
!&#&@ #"AB =C!& 1 , !"BD$ '
" "# B" ?#B =C &,! E, !,!
"F=AG "F=A &A4 & "G,!# ! " '= %8!#
E E,"? 9 / $% B 0 ,# (Over-spilled Town) B 0 $%,@"& #"AB 0 8!# @&F @ -! @ ; @FB $8!#!? &&
'!& !"# $%% 4,469 8( 2523 !&, @B">
:9!&A4 &B "
:9B " ! 9 B
" X #!.! G #!&!,. ,. ,=
# "##G "B!#&
"#"F=AG "F=A " && , $ ,&
:9! &"F=AG 8!# !& X& /#
"A=> , (Self-contained Town) D$!#,& (- B"4A&>) &A4 & &FB# ",B ","F=
"F=AG8!#' !& 0 /"A=>"@ = 25,000 , = 150,000 [1]
!&:B %0 , 1 D$8!#?"#&A4 & Site & Services [2]
?, 5,205 ,&"? .A#&8!##& = 3,000 ,& #b! 2 % B"- ",B","F=8!# "E"%.A# #&A4 &#, %( 2523 ",
& 2 8!#"#B"&A4 &", (?, 8,545 ,&)
& 3 ? !? 4$; !?,B /% !&
:B = 45,000 [3]
2
:B 0& 1 D$8!#!? "#. 8!#8,# "
:9 !"G,!# #&A"G!!G &"BG :9
"? 9"B!$E :9"G,!#&G "!& 1&&#
%,"F=!"!# . ! % ! G&0 ?#
4 &&A0 !"@ .& @$#, &
","F=",8,## #8#"&#,E ","F=! , !
!A ;&A"G8 &#& ?#!, #8#!& 1
!#,!G & %& 8"!, !"? B "? 9 8"@ &8!# ! ! &% "? !E 8,% %,"F=! B (Neighborhood Park) $ ,"? 9' .& #8#&>i B&&i "@ ,#B8!# 1B % j!
""#," F> B&&#,kX&$% "? 9&
,& &! '&A4 &B# $%
. 8!#,. #%" &,"?
. "? .A#4 &&A0 !&%,"F= (%" &,) %8!#@A?!#&A
", 4 & ","F=! E (Neighborhood Park) 8,##
B&&i !&","F=! ,%%= 5 8 1 B ;= ", %,B 2 B !&A%?. (. 1.1) #.A#8!# ##"&, D$
! => 0 %,!,. %,. & 1 2 ,,!& , (Decentralizing Activities) !&
!! G#" F> [4] "G:B % %! ,", 8!#@ABB #&> =&B =%
",98!#@A%#!!A ",&"G %&B ?# ! 4&G 8!A8 % #8#"&8!# =? ""#&4
# %" &,# %?b", G& X :9%?, "& 8"@#&>8!#, @B"> # 8!#&%? "&
BG-G"A?% .A#&A4 &8!#%&"A?%!& ?#
A! ,8"@&%?8!# <!Ab 4;&8B! ?# !:9
%?,:9"F="B
3
, %!% 8!#"!# E,%,"F=8!# &8,# "@
B 8"@#&>8!#& E, @B"> D$".B=G ,B!& 8!# :9!#"B &:9!# ! % , &%%$&&"?, # ,kopkA%,"F= # !&>
"A"B!B %!#,# < 4;'"
1.2 ! "#$%& ' ($)!*
"G,!# ,=% j!8!#@A?&& %!##
",!# ?#.A#B8"@ #8#&> .8!#&
" %& # !"G,!# ,#&".B=G,B ! % $ ,? &,kopkA"G,!#% j!%
#!!"FG %& !,8 F#%
B % ! % "Fq",B D$ ! =>,.
?!# !
:9"? 9 8!#:9 BB%#%.!8, .#%! % ! !&:B 8!# #8"###! E ( ;= 8#
,,) !&&A## % 8!#?#"G,!# "&,! E,
=&##. , 40 ! E8!# %##
",8!#%&A&%?!& ".#AB! %?8"8 ,&
8!#"!, ! "&",
" B$:9"? 9 E :9!# D# ,&
#!A%0 8!# 4? "F !&:B %
! ,D$ !&A, .! 8!#@A&#&# 4?
- "F ,& .!!A%! , "Fq!& 0
== 4? "F&A&? ! %%",% & 88!#
,-"#8 , 40 ##=",98 #8 :9i 40 E,,"? 9 !,, :9!#"F=AG
%' 8!# @ # :9%?, :9&Ab& ",= !"
% %! = B","F= 40 % 28 8 [5]
4
,% % j!"F=! ,, B kopkA # !#
&>!&"FG !&=@$,#B ,- 88!# 4;' ! %!& 40 B !@$
,& &!A ;%%'B "? 9 D$,@$8 3 4
?!
1.3 ,-./ 012
1.3.1 4$;"G#%,"F=?4$; &A:B
!r&# &,#
1.3.2 4$;< ,# 4,#.A#&A4 &
#%,"F= ,=?!%
1.3.3 ,&&!# !",!#!,"@!#
&,& &,#%
1.3.4 , >8#:9!&=,#B 4 &G ,& &,# ;=," F>B>,&
&,# "? 9
1.3.5 ".kopkA"G,!#%,"F=&" %&&,
1.4 (, 012
1.4.1 !#&G !&%?4$;&@$ % j!,B 4 &, %AG&% j! &
1 (Site & Services B#b!)
1.4.2 !#, 4> !& #4$;!# ! !&B@$
!!#i8%
!
!> 8!# 4? "F >B !B!& 4? "F
r&# &,#
1.4.3 !#< ,# 4B#,
5 1.5 %, 5 (
1.5.1 ,,= &,# !&B % !#i 8%
<;rkopkA"G,!#! B
<;r",, !& # !'B
<;r,."G,!#&G
<;r !> '>i &,#!#
=4$; 4 ;=%'# &
1.5.2. ?!4$;!4 & , !&B #!#4$; ;=
&G%4$; "G" ,?, B
<" F> #%4$; ,@$ ,G& 8!# - 4$; !!# ,& &,#
1.5.3. E,,#A !& 2 ;=
#A'GA #A EG"%4$; 8!# "
(Observation) #"@ (Structure Questionnaire) " G;=>
$ (In-dept Interview) " G;=>B (Focus Group Interview)
#AB&GA E,,#A " &,# 8!# .
&& / , %=,&# .!%
4$; .%4$; =4$; 4 1.5.4 , >#A
#A8!#" G;=> #, > = %' !&
4 & & & <;r=4$; "G=>
#A8!#"@#, >"@ 8!# <;r"B ,&
, >"@i 8!# 1& ,@
, !& #
1.6 " 5 012
1.6.1 4$; %% .A#, &=4$;, &&A#%
,& 8=4$;# & ?4$; $#4 &=4$;
- 4 %! ?#",8"!# "G" 4;' , /F%4$;
6
1.6.2 F.&>#@. #@$#A# E
1.6.3 & , E#A? ! . ,F E#A D$",8
"# ;= 1#B8!#& E
1.7 '7 5* 85"
1.7.1 #A"? 8!## !"kopkA
%,"F= ,=4$;
1.7.2 #A%'","? ?, &!#i 8!# !#.
!# !",!# 00
1.7.3 ,"? 4$;#:9!##% j!
&A4 & ' !$%&
[1] , by&. . ' ($)!* . ,-
!8&, 2535. # 1.
[2] ;=#&A4 &A$ !& # &%
"F=AG%'8,## 8!# "BG ",.A#&A4 & .A#A"#
#
[3] 4? "F. "#$%& (0 , ( 9. 2545. "@&"? (15 2546).
[4] ,by&. 2535. ##, # 4-7.
[5] 4? "F. . ! 5": '" $%& : (!($)!* - ., ! (0 , ( 9. 2545. "@&"? (15 2546) # 3-6.
7 2
2.1 !"#$%&'(
2.1.1
Tunnard "# Pushkarev [1] ,-./#01 2345 46 78#/9:/;7/ :< " .76=> 9/8#;:"#" 99=?/"#/@
9 /:/":=-9=-A"-#. :#-701//8BC37 D12 "#=EC4F34.C2345 46 07"/,-.
6=-
6=>"B#/"#02/8BC37 "996C99"#
/6#/G
6=>02. F345 4 6=>75-2 /20C- /7C 6=>0228H.345 4 9=/B6C2C 6CC3B./
6=>0262/DC"#/6=#2C /8#;:;. 029I/"#6=>
9;6625/;7 36 B45 49"B7, 26J62/.C 7134.22< ,-."/ 0 6. 6-K/6# L#L 6=>9;6:#-"
2.1.2 B C2
2 32B C 012 62//"#//8 345 46 3B 9# D12 #/@26C9,-./92-27/#:,=
-9#"/9. (Neighborhood Park) 6=>262 //"#/8T 2 62:2/ 12.5 , ;2C -/3 // 6-K/6#B26-K/6# 627/ /#5 8H.34.B#C /#5 /1 2"9/,=: :05=F8H. 34.3/#5 C5:< /
#/@3B.9;/"/=44 800-1000 D12 06-; 34.,-.
E-C/6-;6. 34.6#6-;, 6/; 5-10 02/ 34.H 34.
=7346#< [2]
-945 4 (Community Park) ,-."/27-3B. 3 45 4 E-C 62, :2/ 12.5 , E-C 2/8 "99 Passive Recreation
8
2 2 6-K/6# "# /GB96-K/E: 392 /"993B. " ##,B#8 B/CH3/#.45 4777-6=>#/@
64/K,-. "#734./96_/#:< 64 #C/ 6=>:. #/@
2"9973B.9;/"/=4/5/6_"#C7 / = 1,500 6 2 ;346=>"B#/_C":6CC6-C ": /8 8/34.
2-;=6A2-.C
2.2 )"#$%&'("#''!'*+*#
/9 ;-26/2C. B ;;#:/34.345 4 0
;7/6=>=6-K ,-.C.C 3 =6-KB#/< /K =/"/";-/CA
=/2";--./;7/ "# "#=/5-.C";--.b:;/
"#c
2.2.1 -./CA -"#H=
,-. _1/@01 FB -"#H=2/9#/@
/34.=EC4F "#. /7/7//6/: Jane Jacobs [3]
22 #/@"9"#C6=>22 /, =9 6K7 3/34.C
6eC :07C [4] ,-._1/@"#9 A/CA;2"-#.
E-C92 8#:b:;/ / /#5 E-C/ 7-.
;2 =g-#. 26/9 3 -. 763B. b:;/ / /#5 92 //
/ 7-.;2=g-#. , 6/9 3 -. "#/ - /.
2: H;2=g-#. 2CHB 1-3 6 /K763B.6/;-/ /#5 / //64/
:"B2:
CB2B/92CH_C ;;#3B.8H.
B, 34.=EC4F7/2< 7//_1/@ Alexander [5] 9 CBB2E#/92CH_C CHB/ , 6/; 200-250 6 : B CB3/6-;AC3 3
9 6=>67.
; #;; BC/H [6] ,-.3B. "//B-26234./,.
//"9922-, 3B.6/;- H.1/ m, 36=>67.n 673B.
, 3337-H"# "#2/K762 E #325-
2.2.2 -./;7/ "#
" ;--./"8"#//"992 /6=#2C"=#
,=7/-: / 7/6-; 26.//"992626=>F=/93 /6;2 3B./9 "#0=;/ //"996=>8H./B-/;7/ 92
< (Designerp s Oriented) D12=r7759,-.9/;H7F"#.=9 #. 6B#
//B-26=g-E#101 B#/B#C3/34.C"#
/;7/ B/CB12 m B#/B#C3/34.C"#/;7/ ;276=>2 3B.6/;-1 E-C1018H.34.C (Userps Oriented) 5/6_"#C3B. 06. 34.
2,-. 36#2":/:/ -.C75-=F2, 6B / /":#C 0 /B-/34.C"#/;7/ ,-.B#/B#C36-C/n [7] 68H.7, 6.
,=34.=EC4F6C" 26=g-E#BCH [8]
2.2.3 -.b:;/ "#c
2.2.3.1 !"#"$ !"
7//_1/@ @F,9H#CF [9] ,-._1/@b:;/ /34.2 26=> ,-./#,. /_1/@=448H.34.
"#, ,-.34.627,-.901 :./2".7;45 4 E-C:"=2 8#:b:;/ /34.2 ,-."/
1. ", 6=>:"=2 8#: :.//34. 6_B;"#
6_4C :./"#, :./34.2":/:/ -./;7/ 6#
"#;2C -/
2. *" /#5 2-.9;BB34. ;-7:./22 2
"#;2C -/2 0=/9/;7/ "99//#/C 32
10
/#5 2=/94234./#/C 64 4 . " . 8H.=/94;
7 :./22 0:9 :./"99/8 BC37 /7/8H.D12 4D12 #/@" 7 6#:;-:/<
06.,=34.26=>7 //8H. -7/--.6#
3. '-) 6=>:"=26/2C/94
4. + =4/2 C5:/ C :./-.//8BC37 2":/:/,= 7/";- Gerhad Rosenberg 34.6=>T/;7 01 :./34.2 627/
$%&' C5= 0-9 =u :.//C /25- :./
5//9/#5 6262. 5.6C 2:./ =#-AC 71 :./2E# ;237 :26:. 64 626# =#-AC71:./
22CH3/#.9.-/3/95 7/8H.=/ 627/, 0,=34.2,-.
-.C:6
$%&&$()$%&* CB 10-19 =u :./2B9CH/
6=>/6=>/#5 64 226#H-5C/ 2/;7/ / L#L
$%&+,(-()$%&. C5CHB 20-50 =u 6=>C2 :./
H25- :./ 26_@T/;7 6=>2C 93 - 3C71:.BC,-.629 E-C34.6#3":#62B6#C4 J B#7/26#3B0H/34.,="#. 716=>46#2/#5 E/ 34.2 D12;7C :F /b:C4 [10] "# _/;v /,4C [11] :
#./#C 6=>C234.-3B2 ;2C -/
B#/B#C ":, :CH,/#9. 627/6=>C2 5A"K"
$%&,)&* C5 50 =u1,= 8H.HC5,-.9/=/=?3B..7/ 1/1/
":, 6C96B /7/C :./2-6#K/3#"/9. 25C/9 C6-C/ B#H/B# 62C ////"//#/C
/7//_1/@//7C: /#5 C5345 4 74C943B.
97:.7-;2C -/ C, "# /.C6C3- 62:9 :./2":/:/-.C
11
5. ')',. 6=>:"=2 F/94"#C,-. -9 /_1/@2:/ 8#3B.6/;- H. 6.37:#-7_:;:/34.2 62//8BC372":/:/
6. )/'0. 6=>:"=2 F//978H. 34.2 0.CH,/#7/9.B"B# B34.6#3/6-; / C 8#: 7H373B.6.,=34.=EC4F -.=; "# 023/34.
7. % 8#: :./,=34.2 6 2 6# /C 6=>
/6=g-E/3B.6/;-6#/27,=34.26=g-E# ,-. /C;21
8. )"#$ 2 -2 0978H.
34.C,-.E-C2, 6/;- "- 6 "-6=>=r77CB1223B.=44 , C/6.,=34.2
9. ')1)2 6=>=r77C2 8#: :./6.,=34.2646-C/
9;627-,. =#-AC7/AC 4:; "#AC7/2 5@CF.1 64
=#-AC7/ =#-AC7///4/ "# ;7J4
10. ).)3) "# B#/B#C3/;7/ 237 "22=9 6K7 :. B#/B#C/;7/ 2 0:9"/
5//#5 345 4 =r77CB1223B.=44- 373/34.2 627/- -1-H-/CA ,-."/ H= (Image) 2 - A"-#. 6=>69C96C9.C2 :#-701 - 23B.6/;- H.1/01//8
11. 0",!%' 9;62 #/@/;7/ E-C96=>2CH_C
"# B"H C :./=4427,=34.2H1
2.2.3.2 ) /) #$) .(0*11/$ 2%
7;F [12] ,-./_1/@ 9;;#23B. ;2"-#. 2 3B.95#B126.B, 6. /;7/ /=6A:< - 1. 4;-9."#;2"-#. 39"#45 4 E-C;2"-#. 2-
"#6B 63B.3":#9"#45 43727 /;7/ /:< /1
2. -9/_1/@=44
12
3. ;;#62 "#8H.45 4 6-C/9/6. / /#5 64 62 B629. ;;#3/4/7H 4;/3/#5 6. /;7/ /,-. //
4. T/6;
5. 62C -/"#8H./ 0,-.6=>;27H372 CB12 /7-B5=/F 626# 62C -/
/,.9 :./=44 5/6_"#C ;2 25-CB12 /;7/ / 627/6=>;22-1-H- 37 3B.6. /;7/ 6 B C [13] ,-.:.6/: 5@CF 7424 "#/:.3=9/F 23B "#:26:.CH6 - /"826/;-/8#-6=#2C/;7/ CH6 6=>:.
6. /Ex@=4 F-./;7/ /
.8;-#-=/3//"992B345 4 E//_C/K/6.,=,.322 8H. 3#/@ m"2n D12 28 /6=>//"9928;68;2-H6 ":/:B#/B#C (6J/C- A) ":3 6=>7; :.101 ":/:B#/B#C3"6_@T/;7"# [14]
=rB3B/2, 8H.6.,=34. 27/ , ,-.6=>
28H.6-;8 [15] "#6B:5B1223454, ,-.9 ;C /K 39 6=>2D12:C 0. CH#9:8H. [16]
/7/ 7//_1/@=5A [17] ,-.3B..6"3/82 ,.-.C 8H.CH_C3E/6 3B 9#2 1 3B6=>C 2 :./02/8"#///#/C 01-C 2CH 3/#.9.
2.3 ))')'"#$%&'(
=rB29,-.E-C2,=6/2C/9 /7-/2 /K /22 , ,-.9/6373 m.6K77; /K 93/-H"#2 /6=>
9= "/270H/:-/ 6 8#/9:4.C25-n [18]
2.3.1 -./6;
13
BC=/.0;2 7/9= BC/#6=>B#/ 3 2/7-6/K9C,-.62/c.0;2 CHC7/-"#;-6=>.C "2 0 =C5/:F34.626;2 C93B./9BC.0;2 ,-."/ [19]
//7C73B."/BC.0;2 (Administrative Autonomy)
/ 26/2C./9/6;BC4/-9.0;2 /#6#C m0ABC4/<n /# 39=6_B=6_,C6 BC4/.0;2 99B.227/- 01" .7 0A: /yB C ":
BC4//#C6=>8H.95 B.2 98;-49 :#-70167./.0;2 /K1:/9BC4//# 3B.BC4/.0;2 99.C3/
7-B"#7-/-./6;26/2C./9H=EA26 /-6;/
"#/95/@
/642 F-./6;BBCT (Intergovernmental Fiscal Relations)
7//_1/@ Keare [20] 9,-. /_1/@"#=C5/:F34.;/#/@-/#
E-C Musgrave (1983); Oates (1972); MaLure (1995); Bahl "# Linn (1992) "# Bird (1993) 05=6=>B#//2B9/642 F/6;BBC T3-9.0;2 ,-."/
- B.298;-49"#9= C7C7:.-#./969C9 4/2,=
- B#/6#2C , -#./C9"#C7C B3B.
.C25-
- B/6 2;5-E/"#. m9= "#C/26B#CHn 7:.0H/,-.9/6#2C.CCE=3 "#6=>99
/6;2 73/7-6/K9A@ (Increased Local Taxing Authority) /6;2 03/7-6/K9A@ C;23/6;2 C,-.3B."/
BC4/.0;23/c6 3-.:< /cA"-#.
/CA D12/6;2 C,-.3 0,-.B#/< 2 ; 6/K9A@E6"#6/K9 6C :< .0;2 E-C6JCC;2/6/K9A@E606=>C,-.B#/
/7/ Keare C957//7 Bahl "# Linn 3=u ._. 1992 2,-.77/6
14
:< 40 6 9 C,-.7//6/K9A@E6BC4/.0;2;-6=> 40%
C,-.B - C,/K: =rB293B/6/K9A@E6/K C,-.2 6/K9,-., -#.B, /9/67;6:;9E:/;7/ 6_@T/;726;2 17;
E-C6J3/#5 =6_/#c /6/K9A@2:2 / D12" .":=6_BT6 ;/
B/b@6/K=9=rB 7:.6;2 /7-6/K9C,-.7/ 6C "#A@/.6=>
/4-64C
C,/K: 01" BC4/.0;2 777-6/K9C,-.< /1 8H. 73/:-;37 "#EC9C/c.0;2 :#-70145 4 7, ,-.
6; /c26=g-E#345 4 "7176=>:. =/9/9=r77C 2< 623B.6/;-8#3=;9:;
/6;2 / A6/4 (Increased Private Sector Participation) /6=#2CBEC.CB.298;-497/BC4//# HBC4/
.0;27-7-6=>/6=#2C"=#2"#. ":2C;2/ /6=#2C7/
BC4/ HA6/4[21] " ;-,-.6;2 /"B#C"#,-.9/
957/T9#39/9;/-.H=EA9C6 D126-;
99 #4 6=>"99 m.-6=>67.6--6;/n (Build-Own-Operate: BOO) 69K-6K73BC6-C 6=> m.--6;/-EC.Cn (Build-Operate-Transfer:BOT) A6/46=>8H.#5."#-6;/,-.C6#B1271EC.C3B."/BC4/
C/0,? BTS 3/56L BH="992< /9;B7-/H=EA E-CA6/4 D12" ;-#/@ _/CA2 0 =C5/:F34./999 H=EA3"992,-.
!678: "' " :2%&0& #"0 (%&; - ( /)($&)= [22]
The Management Support to Town >PanchayatsG Project (MSTP), =6_6=#
/6B:5=/B1223B./c-.:<6 , 76=>99 H=EA"#/c -45 4 6=>,=C#4. B126/;-7/ BC4/
.0;2, 76C3//B-EC9C-./6;"#/9;BCF;-B;
C6=>; 6 Panchayats 2=6_6=#6=>:CB12 CC =9=5
=;;A3/7-/-./6;BC4/.0;2
15 1$H
BC4//#6=#, 07-9= 62/c6 3-.
:< 3B."/6_9#6 Panchayats ,-.C6C /7/6_9#6 Panchayats C0H/
B. -6;/-.;6423-< 7/73B.642,-.0. //H.C 6;,="#. 6_9#
7 04-34.3B.,-. C,/K: BC4//#/K:B/- 6_9#6 Panchayats :./;642C6-629/67;6:;9E:6 C -6K 7/2,-.9 4C6B#7/ E#/"# UNDP (United Nations for Development Program) 3=u ._. 2528 62.E/2/96_9#6 62
=9=5=;;A3/7-/-./6; E-C 75- 5B C62 /B-E/-.
/6;CC "#.99/7-//6;3B."/:6_9#
E/-/#B MSTP 6.B629 "#3B. H."/6_9#3/
;6BF0A/6;"#I//34.. H#62=9=5=;;8# ;/=6 ;8#
CC< ,-9/c 7/=6_6=#"#6_9#6 2< 33 6 E-C8#
/=6 ;,-.3B.. H# :T-./6;69:. D120H/"C// "#9756.6=>T . H#-94:; "#,-.9/= #8#3B 5/ 6 6- . H#0H/6/K9,.623B.BC 4/.0;2,=6=C96C9623B.901;_"#"E. /c :#-7 0 ,=6C96C/96 22 #.C#1/ /;6BF3#/@C 0-
=;;8#/7-/-./6;6 :< 2 m-25-n 626=>"B96 2< 3=;9:; /7/C 09/01 :./-./6;2 - 0 95#/3-.:< ,-.-.C
323-94:; BC4/6=#34.62 26=>62 ;6:F3/;6BF ": 3-9.0;2/#9, 6=>64 ".27;"#. 67./
.0;2 , 6C":,-.9/I/3B.;6BF"#6BF . H#-./6;6 B/C ,-.9/I/-./6. H#"#/2:A6 -9.0;2-.C D1275-0 ,-. /627/8#3B. 6/;-/6;2 /7-6/K9A@ /9934./yB C.0;2
"#/#-34.7C6_9##
6=#2C"=#64 3B.6/;- -5#/C926_9#7-6/K9,-./9 /95 34.7C ;26=>/;H7F3B.6BK BC4/-96_9# 06;2
=;;A3/7-C/AC3:.7/7-C,-.2 CH6-;
16 2.3.2 -./7-/9;BF/
"/7-/9;BF/7/T45 4 6=>";-2,-.9/_1/@C
"B#C Henry Sanoff ,-./#01""#=9/F3/=C5/:F34.";-3/
:< ,-.6=-:,= [23]
2.3.2.1 %I&J/)* (Community Building)
/cE-CT45 4 /6#K6BK45 46=>_HCF/#/c"#
/;7/ 3/HA"-#. :< AC345 4 3-9/"8"#/=;9:;
B/CB12/K /6;2 -93/6.,= 99345 4:/;7/ /c 3-< 2 8#E-C::345 426
/cE-CT45 46=>"/"99F E-C ;C_FCH2 345 4:.6=>8H./B-;_/c-.C:6"#345 4B.2 C,9. D12 4;/345 47.F/B091626C345 42 7 :/9"/c2 7/AT,-. D123B#C< /,-."-3B.6BK ;-;6;2 26/;-7//8#/-2 7/45 46 E/27=99 6K7 //7/20H/
8#/-1 7/AC/ B#///cE-CT45 4 -:,=
345 4:. 6/2C.3//B-6=?B C"#"3/
c
/B-;226=>CF;"#=rB45 43B."4- 3-245 4 07-/,-.
6;2 - 045 4E-C/c"#5 c"#.6C /909"#F/2< 345 4 /cE-CT45 46/;-13-9#"/9. 627/345 46 E/279=/6,-.9C "# 64237/ // "#345 467:.
6=>8H./B-:./3B.45 4:6=>C, /7/ 7//_1/@ John Kretzman
"# John McKnight 3=u ._.1993 2.E-C Sanoff ,-./#,. m/cE-CT45 4 :.6;2 2//B-CF;45 43B.,-.4-67 "#c9TCF;D12 CF;32 CHB#C-9"# ;:; ,-."/ =9/F"#- 03/7-/
345 4 4;-"#-5/;7345 4 D12;26B#6/2C.3/7-#-9 3//B-E//cn
2.3.2.2 $$/)" (Community Participation)
17
Sherry Arnstein,-.7--9/ E-C#-9 6. .3/ ,. 8 -9 7/.C,= / -A=/9 2.1
A=/9 2.1 Sherry Arnteinps ladder of citizen participation 2 : Nigel Taylor, 1998 [24]
/ =446=>/9/26/;-1E-C6/2C./9 /"#/6=#2C . H# #- -"C. "#95/"83-9:<62:9 :./
=44B45 43B. /25- 6=>/9/28 8/:-;37"999## (Top- down Approach) /9"99#H9 (Bottom-up Approach) 6.-.C/ Deshler "# Sock, 1985 ,-./B-#/@/ ,.6=> 2 =6A [25]
Citizen control
Delegated power Partnership
Placation Consultation
Informing Therapy
Manipulation 8
7 6 5 4 3 2
1
Degree of citizen power
Degree of tokenism
Nonparticipation
18
1. / "996C (Pseudo Participation) B C01/23B.8H. 6/2C.,-.9H.
. H# :#-701/=1/@B3-.:< ":, 73/:-;373-< 3 /;7/ BEC9C:< (6C96/9 2 1-4 3"8AH ; Arnstein)
2. / "99". (Genuine Participation) B C01/ 28H.26.
73/:-;37B ;-6BK8H. 8#:/:-;37:/;7/ "#
EC9C3-< 3-9B12BB - (6C96/92 5-8 3"8AH ; Arnstein)
" ;-E-C2,=/ =44B45 4 7,-.8#B
=;;A76=>:.1 38H.276=>:. / ,-.01-9 3- "#.7 ,-.C, /9/ 7;5-6 2, ":;2225-/K 7:.,=. /9/. 6. "K3B.45 4 (Community Building) 717 b;v8#
C".7; /7/ 4;-"#=6A/ =441CH/9=r77C
"-#. ":#0/F E-C Sanoff [26] ,-..01/"9-9/ 7/
/_1/@E-C Burns 3=u ._. 1979 ,. 4 :,-."/
1. -9 :B/H. (Awareness) D12=9/F 6=>6228H.26/2C./9 /9/ 7:. T"#6BK=rB3622 / ":
7 =rB":/:/
2. -9/9H. (Perception) 6=>-90- -9 1/ E-C6/2C./9 6.37 ;:;-. /CA 6_@T/;7 E-C8H. 76";-7/B#/B#C 5 D12. H#6B#76=>. H#62/"8:,=
3. -9/:-;37 (Decision Making) 6=>:2c7/T. H#2,-.7/ 2 :"/2/#,="#. 62 :-;373/"83/;7/ :< 3B.-#.
/9 ;-6BK2,-.9
4. -9/,==;9:; (Implementation) :6=>62225- E-C8H.
7:.6=>8H.-H"#623B."37/;7/ BEC9C2: ,-.0H/,==;9:;
7;
B9/_1/@3:=6_ E-CE//c26=g-E#"#
26/;-7/45 42 6 ;CF BT6 ;/ 7//;6BF/_1/@ 10 "B 9=6-K2 6/2C.2:.1013/c=9=52 T/HE-C45 42,-."/ 60A
19
45 4 /34.2-;2 CH6-; /6.0126=g-E# /;7/ 26/2C.E-C9
"B#6;53/H E/"#-93/ 45 4 6. "K45 4 6=>:.
!678: "')1;#"$$%I:#$) 2,0 (Bottom- up Approach)
Diamachi Fureai Park "6-] [27]
1$H
E//c 36: Showa 26 E/C =6_2=5 E-C6:
Showa :CH3C/#6 =4/_CCH= 100,000 6 6BK=r7759 /34.2626=>B96-K/ C, 6B 6C 3B.6-K/< 3 C34.226=> 27-0 0 6=>026# B9./K6#39. 7/2/#5 8H.=/6-K/< ,-. /=45 B /96 E-C .:/# / 4 . -:,=
1) 6-K/-2B9/;7/ /6#:<
2) 8H.=/:./02279=/9629.,-.E-C-/
3) 4;/345 4 :./B96-K/ 8H.=/ 4 "#8H.;/
4) 8H.=/"#67.B.2096#C6-K/:./ / "#:/#27 m.
n
.66B#,-.9/cE-C67.B.26 E/C "#8H.=/
E-C/#42 / / 18,000 6:C/6_ :6 E/C -.C6B:58# 6-K/<
7 026#/#"7.2 =#-AC
A6 ,-.5 :;.6B9E-C 3B.8H.45 46=>8H.7-B02 E-C /"7/"9990 3" 5 :< 64 0226B H="99 :#-701/;7/ AC3 E-C45 4,-. /=45 B /967.B.26 "#,-._1/@A0C
36 2< ,-. /=1/@8H.642C46/2C/9b:;/ /6#6-K/
"#3B.45 4,-. 3/9//"99 8H./"993B."3//.2 76=>B9 E-C101 :./45 46=>B#/ 627/45 46=>
8H.34.CB#/E/
20
$
6;2 7/7-=45 64;=;9:;/ E-C 8H.6. = 60 D12 018H.HC5"#8H.;/
/ 1 E-C"96=>/#5 3/c"99 :#-/-6#/5=/F 626# E-C 6/eF69:. -
- 226CB96-K/6#K/
- 2B96##H/9#
- 2B96-K/5/C - 2/826C99
- =#-ACE-C92626#":#4;- - 03B.8H.;/6.01,-.
- 03B.0C:F6.01E/,-.
B#7/" ;-3/.26/;-7/ :./45 4/K0H/,=
7-922/B- E-C345 4,-.6. 3/.
1))$$
- Community action planning - Focus groups
- Game simulation - Goal setting - Group interaction - Workshop
2.3.2.3 )1;0 ()= #"*
=5A [28] ,-._1/@01/9;B6B45 4-./-H"#45 4E/6B 45 4 6 3B 9#,./B. . 3B..6"-./7-F/AC345 4 /6B"B4:;D126-; 6=>67.26=g-E#2_1/@ , ,-. EC9C-./
c45 4":C3- F/AC345 471 /yB C9;;"#3B.73/
=;9:;B.2 E-C: ..9. /7-2-; 3B. ;:;95#B H9.7- 62 7
;:;9:;6B ;:;95#45-3/-H"#45 4"#/@CF/# 234.62
=EC4F / "#7-/6/2C/934.7C 6 2 7E-C49-./yB C-/#"#.
21
F/27-:1716=C9 6B 8H.7-/-H"#CF/#"#7-/6/2C/934.7C "#
623B./7-/45 4 =;;A /C;21 6; 3B.6/;-/ =44 3H=/ / 8H.CH_C 626=>:"8H.CH_C
/7/ C,-..5==rB3/c45 43B#C< -.6=>=rB26/;-7/
/- D127, C H.1/8H/B /345 4 D12B12 8H.2_CCH345 46=>"3E5:B/ 3E/"# 5=/94B C,-.C6-C 6#.C3//;7/ 3-< 345 4 /7/C, C /;7/
3/c45 4 // E-C8H.CH_C 6BK /7-/;7/ 6;2 :#-701
=rBB126/;-7//28H.CH_C6/;/12 , 9/y69C93/CH_C / D12 7 8#3B./34.26=g-E#26=>CH3=r7759 ,-. /#6 ;-;;CF;
/# E-C6.,=926=>:
2.4 '67863 (Concept of Revitalization) 2.4.1 B C"#7/-
B C/H -.C/3B#C-9 3 B C;7C 56.
/3B. 3/H3-9 m#"/9.n (Neighborhood) C,/K: 01" .7 /9";--./H# "#. /KC D9D.CH 627/63-9B12 m#"/9.n /K02CH_C D128H.26. CH //K627/02< 0 :9 :./ ,-. , 76=>629. E6C "#/;7/ 2<
32/ 5 B12 m#"/9.n /K 03/:9-.6_@T/;7,-. ,-."/
/cB; CF B/#E-C5=/K CC 27H m#"/9.n Zeilenbach [29] ,-.5=",.6=E-C TCH9";-" =/"/
,-."//H2 T2B (Individual-based Approaches) D12 56.-./=9=5 A45 4B9/CH_C6=>B#/ E-C3B. /902B#/@AH ;_:F 6=>62 =/2 ,-."//H2 T202 (Place-based Approaches) 56./H2101 6=>,=,-.6_@T/;76=>B#/ /HA45 46=>
62 D12";- B#//"#C#6C-:< -27/#:,=
2.4.2 HC/ 5@CF (Individual-based Approach)
• /c (Social Development)
22
6=>B123;2 /34.C"B#C25-3/H45 4 E-C/6;2 - 0F/7-/.0;2 , 76=>/#5 F/45 4 B/ B C/K /2BC4/ 5B C27CCT/c45 4E-C3B.45 46=>8H.-H"#
7-/6 64 /7-I/9 E/6; 6. "K45 43-.:< ,-."/
/I/4
• /c6_@T/;7E-C/./;7/
(Program-driven Economic Development)
,-."/ " ;-2T/H45 43B.=9 6K7 35/< -.
:.3B. /96_@T/;745 46=> E-C4/"#F/6/42, "
8#/, /9A5/;762=9=5/#,/3B.6/;-/;7/ 6_@T/;71345 4 E-C CC 277-2-;B022 0H/3B.6/;-/;7/ 6_@T/;71E-C 6=?B C3B.6/;-/.345 4E-C345 46 /7/C /6; E/62 /_1/@"#/I/4:< 626;2 E/3/.C,-. E-C6JB98H.2 C,-.
.C
• /CC:6_@T/;78F/5/;7 (Trickle-down Economic Growth)
/6B,=7//96#2 "#6_@T/;7345 47/2/# "#.
2 =6-K/B. 3-9 BA/K6=>;2276=>64/ :C64 //B-:
-/69C"#./B-.0;23B.6/;-6=> :/95:5/;7/K6=>/B12 /K /25/;7-3B2:CH3#"/45 4 ,-.=EC4F7/ :/6B#/K76/;-/8#;:
"#/9;EA26;2 /1 3B.6/;- 6=>,=,-.27 /7.345 46;2 /1 C,/K: 3CC;/7, 34;/2C2C/ -23=6_BT6 ;/6C34.
"#, =9 6K73/H45 4 "#.
2.4.3 H02 (Place-based Approach)
• Gentrification
7/- 2;C "#C 9C"B#C Gentrification /HA /CA26 3-9#"/9. E-C6.2/948H.2 C,-.=/#01
23
H D12 TCH9";-2/c-.5:B/ "#;4C/ 2:./T 2 /_1/@H B/#/CB12/K /6./H2236:C/.
(Central Business District: CBD) E-C/953B. /#56. 7/AC/ 623B.6/;- H#2-;"#B; CF345 42 CH6-; 6;2 H1 3B.6/;-;2C -/62 9/;7/ 6_@T/;72B#/B#C279/#5 2 CH3B D123B.2-;0H/34.
,-.C6:K 6 K-6:K BC /1627/2-;7H /1 ": .6C/K345 4 97C2CH:"#C.C/,= E-C6J8H.2 C,-..C 627/
B; CF2H16 3B. F345 42 CH6-; /6=#2C"=#
• Incumbent Upgrading
#/@#.C/9 Gentrification "::/:2 Gentrification 6./6.
6=#2C"=#A"-#. 7/95#AC/ 8/#5 Incumbent Upgrading 6./
HE-C_C345 4 Incumbent Upgrading T;-CH2//B-#/@
45 4:6 6=>45 48H.2 C,-.=/# B6=>45 4#-942 7/
_HCF/#6 (32 Gentrification /45 43B.6=>45 43#-942B12) E-C /#,/3/HCH2 F/45 4D12 :./27H45 4E-C101#/@
/CH F345 43B.6-; "::./=9=53B.45 4CH1 E-C /9 09.0;2:< 64 ;C#C EC9# E 626=>/-1-H-3B.6/;-/#5 8H.
C,-.=/# "#/;7/ 6_@T/;72< 64 /#57/345 4 6. CH _C/ /1
• Adaptive Re-Use
B C01/=9=5B02 2, /34.3B.6/;-=EC4F , 76=>
6_@T/;7B 3B.6/;-=EC4F3B E-C";-/K6B /9 Gentrification /K/6.
3B.6/;-/#57/AC/ ":CH3-926#K/"#6J677/ -/=96=#2C 0B027:.9H,=/9EC9C-.A@62//:5.3B.6/;- /#53B C,/K: ";-C, C=9 6K73//=96=#2C /34.345 48H.2 C,-..C
7/2/# "#.B - 3B.6/:,-. Individual-based Approaches
"E. 23B. /9 /#5 8H. C,-..C E-C=_7//6.01=rB"# 6=>,=,-.
6_@T/;73A B - 32 Place-based Approaches 3B. /9/c
24
6_@T/;7"#/#,/:#-45 4 ":- 37 :./8H. C,-..C -
;2276=>/K/8";-#/@6.-.C/
!678: ^_`^,* ) a "6(%J) [30]
/"8/c6 ;ED:. ,-.6=#2C";-3B E-CT9#6 ,-.6 E/1 7/ :./45 4:< 36 ;ED:. 6C345 4 3/"8 , 76=>:/=4;7F (Public Hearing) B / :"6.=45 //967.B.26 ":/6.,= -./7-6;5623B.
: :./345 4 C, 0,-. C,/K: 6 ;ED:.,-.;6;2 E/CC mE/H45 4n (Neighborhood Revitalization Program: NRP) 623B./H"#c45 46=>,=C =;;A E-C 0:9 :./45 4 /25-
$%=*"1; 4 "/) NRP 1. 6;2 - 03B.45 4
2. H=9=5/3B.9;/-.:<
3. 6;2 BBC3-96-C/
4. . m 6=>45 4n
/%)/) NRP
627/AC36 ;ED:. =/9,=-.C45 4-9#"/9.; 66 45 4 E-C7//762B :./45 469:. 93":#45 4 :./2
":/:B#/B#C BC298;-49E/,-.=6 ;"#"9=6A45 4 62 /H6 1 3B / E-C 0"9/#5 45 4: -9 :.//
H,-.6=> 3 #/@ -
1. Protection B 22 60CB.=9 6K7-.A"-#.
45 4CH"#. B:.//=9=56=#2C"=#, / 6=?B CB#/BC 298;-496=>/2-H"#3B.45 4A#/@-/#:,= E-C /45 46B#7 6=>/#5 2 C,-.=/#.H "#2 C,-.H
25
2. Revitalization B 22 "E. 2762 E # D12E-C /7CH3/#./9C 5:B/ E-C6=?B CB#/BC298;-49E/ CC/#562 /:5. :./45 4"#CC A"-#. 3B.C2C:,=
3. Redirection B22 62 0C-.C,-.345 4"# :./
T H E-C6=?B CB#/BC298;-49E/ / 6=#2C"=#A"-#. 3B B -"#CC -1-H-/#53B < 3B.6/;-1
E-CBC298;-49E/ ,-.7-9= 3/H3B.-#./9 :./26J677":#45 4 E-C3A ,-. /7-9= 3/
H 3-.:< 9 -. ,-."/ 1) =; 2CH_C 2) /c-.6_@T/;7 3)
"#02/8BC37 4) /c 5) /./#5 45 4/ _;#=
"#c- 6) =#-AC34;:"#CF; 7) E6C"#B. 5- 8) / "# 9) ;2"-#.
C,/K: 96C7/ NPR 3B.,-..6/:9=/237E-C5=C .C 3 =/ ,-."/ =/"/ :/9/7//c"8 H/7- 9= /-6;2DD #4.627//9/-/#:.//
345 4C:62 D127/29-6=?B C"#"89CC, ,-.
=;9:; =/2 -"C.B345 42 :./2, -#./9 EC9C6 "#=/5-.C "8 NPR ,-. /6.,=2-.2CH_C
E-C6J8H.6=>67.2CH_C"#67./;7/ ":C, ,-.3B. 6C: m8H.64n 3B.=rB9C, ,-.9/"/.,
2.5 "&J* (Concept of Power Structure)
76=>;22B#/6#2C,-.C/3/b@y/"8 =;9:; -64 2 Flyvjerg
"# Richardson [31] ,-./#,.C37
m6 034./"8E-C B#//"8C6=>E.C3-/K: ": ":
6, 0B#/6#2C F64;7 B6=> , CH, ,-. b@y/"8 , 0B#/6#2C -"C.,-. B/":/6CH."# /9 -"C."#7 6=>B#//3/9_Fb@y/"8 n
627//7-/6 , 73B. /9/c-.3-/K: ;2B1226.
6/2C."# ;;#:/;7/7-/"#/c /K F364;
26
E. B09/909 B09/995# "#B95#/995#
, //K.C H="99 F64;7 0;7: 5#/@"#B#//34.
7/6=> 5 /#5 ,-.-:,=
E.7"998H/-B68-K7/E-C95#6-C E.7"998H/-B68-K7/E-C/#5 E.7"99B5;C
E.7"99B#/B#C E.745 42, =/
Charles M. Bonjeans "# David M. Olsen .E-C BC-;5 [32] ,-./#01#/@
E.745 4 #/@ 4 =/2 8#://B-#/@E.44 345 4
/) -H 49 (Legitimacy) D12 0-H,-.7/-9/2=44C 9 ) -H 6BK,-.C4-67 (Visibility) 44D120:"B3/6
"# D12977, =/C4-67/K,-. B7/#,-. 8H.3 45 47 CH 3 / ,-."/ /26BK,-.C4-67 (Visible Leader) D12=44 C 9"#6=> 8H.:-;376#/3B.6=>8H. //B12 8H.2CH69B#
(Concealed Leader) 6=>8H.28H.:-;C 96=>8H.":=442,=, 3B.
/C 96=>8H. /5-.C,-."/ 8H.#/@F (Symbolic Leader) D12
=442,=C 96=>8H. ":8H.:-;, ,-.:-;373B.6=>8H. - /_1/@E.77:. 6.37 B C"##/@73
=6-K-.C 627/7, 3462 7: B.26CC6-C ) -H96:;;# (Scope of Influence) 8H.":#"#":#/#5 2
7":/:/ 64 32B12< B=6-KB12< 95#B/#5 B12 7 32/2776=>//#5 B12 6=>:.
) -H 6=>B126-C/8H. (Cohesiveness) -H#/@E.7 /#5 8H. 6/A,B
'+1
7/2,-./# "#.B - 7 05=/9_F 6227 /B- :"=B99:,=,-.-:,=
27
1. -./CA2 ,-."/ -2 :"B2:D12 8#:=; 26.
34.2 A/CA2 9HF B5-E / .C6C3- "# 6. .3/"-6: 6=>67.
2. -.b:;/ /34.2 ,-."/ 6_ 4D12 8#:6#3/6. 34.2 C5 -9 =#-AC "#;2-1-H-3B.6. 34.2 :#-701 -9 37 /;7/ 2:62/9/6. 34.2
3. -./7-/45 4"#BC26/2C. ,-."/
3.1 BC4/.0;2 (6_9#:9#96"# /6B 6 3B 9#)
:"=3/=6 ;- 03/9;B7-/26=g-E#
6_9#"#/6BL ,-."/
- EC9C"#"8/-H"#26=g-E#
- /7-9= 3/-H"#26=g-E#
- E./9;B 7:/# 01 - 03
/9;B7-/2 - .7/-23/-H"#2 3.2 F/45 4 ,-."/ / /45 4 8 45 4
- -9 6. "K3/ :/45 4 :/;7/ /c :<
- -9/ 45 4 :/;7/ /c
- - 03/7-/-H"#=EC4F345 4
- 0AC/2F/45 40
)=
[1] Tunnard, C. and Pushkarev, B. Man-Made America: Chaos or Control: An Inquiry into Selected Problem of Design in the Urbanized Landscape. Connecticut: Yale University Press, 1963. .E-C A;_/-;v ,I. '"`"#$%&'(!'*+*
#: '(,. #%. ;C;F=;/8A"#6 B9e;:
75G#/F B;C#C =u/_1/@ 2542 B. 30
28
[2] _F,9H#CF. ')a'&'(')*+* ')a!'#%
')#: '(,.b#'#*+' !)*+'. ;C;F=;/
8A"#6 B9e;: 096EE#C7 6/#.67.5B#-/9 =u /_1/@ 2538B. 19-23.
[3] Jacobs, J. The Death and Life of Great American Cities. London: Random House, 1961.
p. 115
[4] 6eC :07C. m"//"99A"-#. 2345 4 623B.6/;-/
/#5 8H.CH_C: /_1/@E- ;6C =BC-n. !: ''*' (01ea'',a'J !,1': 18:130. 2544.
[5] Alexander, C. et .al. A Pattern Language: Town Building Construction. New York: Oxford University Press, 1977. p. 305-309.
[6] ; #;;v BC/H. "a''+J2") 3g"a'' "#' b. ; F23. /56L: /; F75G#/F B;C#C, 2535 B. 293.
[7] Jacobs, J. op.cit. 1961:162 [8] Ibid. p. 100
[9] _F,9H#CF, ."#., 2538:16
[10] :F /b:C4. ',."#')!&'(/'+"!' /%'b#. ;C;F=; B9e;: A;486 9e;:;C#C 75G#/F B;C#C =u/_1/@ 2526.
[11] _/-;v /,4C. "a''!'/*"#$!% 22 ' !%
!"#'"b%!%/a'+"!'. C/;7Cb:;/ 5@CF/9 // A;4//"99"#845 46 B;C#C_;#=/, 2529.
[12] 7;F :F. '*+*. /56L: O.S. Printing House, 2528. .E-C =_;;
5/3. "#$"#''b33%,2/(a'*+)", ') '3/'+"h: ')/!-a'-'/*. ;C;F=;/8 6 "#A B9e;: 096EE#C7 6/#.67.5B#-/9 =u/_1/@
2545, B. 11-12.
[13] 6 B C. !')&'(0"b%!%/. /56L: E
; F/@;C, 2527.
29 [14] Jacobs, J. op.cit .1961: 111
[15] Ibid. p.117 [16] Ibid. p.104
[17] =5A ,/;5F. ''!'!*+*)')3*+*'!!%*a:
'(,. !*+*#/!%". ;C;F=;6Bc_:F B9e;:
75G #/F B;C#C =u/_1/@ 2536
[18] Heckscher, A. mThe Management of Open Spaces: Who runs them and with what aims?n.
In L. Taylor. (ed.). Urban Open Spaces. New York: The Cooper-Hewitt Museum, The Smithsonian Institutionps National Museum of Design, 1979. p. 10
[19] Johnson, R. and McCullough, J. mUrban Local Government Financen. In Royston A.C.
Brockman and Allen Williams (eds.) Urban Infrastructure Finance. Manila: Asian Development Bank, 1996. p. 235-271.
[20] Keare, D. mResource Mobilization and Financial Managementn. In Royston A.C. Brockman and Allen Williams (eds.) Urban Infrastructure Finance. Manila: Asian Development Bank, 1996. p. 91-92.
[21] B CA6/4 8H.;7C, ,-.B C 016JBC5/;72"B 8#/, 6B/": ,=01F/45 4.0;2 B;:;95#.0;2-.C [22] Johnson, R. and McCullough, J. op.cit. 1996: 262-263
[23] Sanoff, H. Community Participation Methods in Design and Planning. Singapore: John Wiley & Sons, 2000. p. 6-8.
[24] Taylor, N. Urban Planning Theory since 1945. London: Sage, 1998. p. 89 [25] Sanoff. H. op.cit. 2000: 9
[26] Ibid. p. 10-11.
[27] Ibid. p. 269-274
[28] =5A ,/;5F, ."#., 2536: 190
[29] Zeilenbach, S. The Art of Revitalization: Improving Condition in Distressed Inner-city Neighborhoods. New York: Garland, 2000. p. 23-32.
[30] Martin, J.A. and Pentel, P.R. mWhat the Neighbors Want: The Neighborhood Revitalization Programps First Decaden. Journal of American Planning Association. 68(4): 435-449.
Autumn, 2002
30
[31] Flyvbjerg, B. and Richardson, T. ‘Planning and Foucault’. in Allmendinger, P. and Tewdwr-Jones, M. (eds.). Planning Futures: New Directions for Planning Theory.
London: Routledge, 2002. p. 62.
[32] BC-;5 5:0=. '+102J'a%3%')*+*): '(,.
*+*!'0'a.) an#. ;C;F/8A"#6 B9e;:
096EE#C7 6/#.67.5B#-/9 =u/_1/@ 2545, B. 13.
30 3
3.1
!"#$%&%&
' ' ( "%( )* +*,- + '&
.*/'#&0 '!&$11 2&30!!4& 5!4&1 3)*#&0%&%& 6$%4$% 65 , 0 $1,"#&00%-1*3%& 2$1!4&1 3++$"' (!4"&30!!4&) 59'#:&!4&
$!+ (0%-#&0+0%-13)*+6;
3.2
#"&309"!4& 2 &30 5#
3.2.1 !4&()4
!4& 5 9"!4&)+ %!4&10 - +. 6#!4&
',9"5'
) +6 #&0 9"!4& )* !* 5#
00 ! '& .*!-0"'? *" "
#''"#:$1 5#:5$'#
!) +'3- 9"!4& +' (Observation) 2' 5#
+'*/'$1* +' )* *+#:
+*,-$'? ' ) +)3-
#""2+ +)3- 2'09 0+)3-$%:4 .4+)3-5#&&% $1"9"!4&12" - 5#+)3- % $0"'? ! "&'6"& #&0
%0 11"*& :4611#'&011 [1] '
#""52+ 0"
31
- + +' +$%;+ "$11
*"02";% " 5*4)%&9"!4&
#""+". #&0 :4611#'&011
- + &&9 5#+ #""5 "
& '? $11 1 &( 11 &
*- &:4+4 ' ) 9"#""+".
9" 6#""+". %!&' #"" 6 $1
%&+'! Yamane !!01 6 5,000 % 6' 370 % $0"&& &0 5 #&00"
+6; .05 [2] 2$1,+'#"" Accidental Samplings 5 +.0 &''&30 )4+'-5+6+ [3]
3.2.2 !4& ')4
!4& 5 + 59""5#& !%1-
#&0 !'? 5$* #% %
32
3.3 !!
' 3.1 '# $1$ #&0 $1$9"!4&
'#
Literature Review Questionnai res Observation Structure Interview Key Informants Focus Group
* – – 1* – 5 – +.)* ( ! +.)*."#&0
&30 )*!11 1. $1 $e "
2. &30 +*,-"
3. 0""+,342)
X X X
X X
X X X
+.)* + 1. 5 2. 1*
3. 00& 4$11 4. &30"
5. .(
'$$1* +,30
1. **$ '+)** +,30
2. '$1* !$11
3. 0"+6'+6;!*
+,30
4. 0"'$+$*h
* +,30
*/'$1* +,30
X X X X X
X X X X X
X
X
X X X X X
X X X X
33 ' 3.1 (')
1. "&'6"&"+,
2"#&0#:*h*
!+. ( 1. +"03 2. "% "03
!+.
1. 2+--% ":1"
2. '6& %
3. 0+ ,)*#&00+ ,:&
!+.$0+0%
%!(#&0-11 2.+6%011"*&
2"#&0#: * 3.11
0"+!11
!+.$&
1. 0"$%$*h*
2. !+.!:4611
!+.$
X X X X
X X X
X
X X X X X
X X X X
X X X
X
X
X X X
! "#$%&
&30+*,-0%%!(
&30+*,-0%%("11 1. +.%011 "11
2. "&"11
&30+*,-0%$11
X
X X
X
X X
X
X X X X
$#$ &'
&:&021-
,*&!2"+,30
X X
X X
X
3.4 #$
# ,9"!4& !' '& .&0'!!4&
6 #&009 +.+#&0" $)*5()*0" 3.1)
34
0+ ,)*#&0!
+.$
- ( - - 0+
4#""+*,-16 - 0%%(
- ("11 - 0%$11 ,*& ! ) - &:&021- - ,*&!2"+,30
!4&*(11
* 4&
'#"&
*/'
' - **$
- ' - 0"+6 - +
)*
+)*e "
- +)*#&
- +,342) - $1 - &30
'#+."
"& %0i -11
+.)* + - 1*
- 5 - .(
- 00&4 - &30"
2"#&0
#:$
*
- 0"+!11 - 0"&
- 0"+.$
( -+
- *--1*- - +)*(
- +)*. 4
0""+*,-
0%- +0%-
!+
!+#0$jklj4* +,30$11
' )*-! 6 2+
'(
)*0" 3.1: 2+"
35
$(
[1] )+ +.2+*4":4611 5 11 $! 9 5+.!.:4611 5 8 11 "554 "*&
0 6
[2] Yamane, Taro. Statistics- An Introductory Analysis. Tokyo: John Weatherhill, 1970. p.580- 581.
[3] &&30%!&'% $9"!4&)+
5+.9"!4&5'%&+' )4+'-*$%0 +6+ ""54 %"95$% '
36 4
!"#$#
4.1 !"'""() "
)
! " #$ %&
"'(" 22-23 +- , -./0 (2 4.1) ,%' +0 /5
""- %% '678"--20 /
! "-678"- '02 ' 9:8'", - /:!0!0 /;&:9%&2% /+%&6%:$
'-/"9'%'/ ,' /<(&28 =,: %
% , /'/<( ("!%5 :/2%
6$7!0!;&:%=,::%2% ' 1 ,%
#$-,: (Neighborhood Park) #$=,:9,=':;!:
," %&"'(!0! ' :,:;&:%&
6%!0!-9' 5,025 ' ,%7( '/92%
!0! %& !0! ,%'=',%'-"M7N5 +/%
(/% A, B C) ,/,2 4.2 ) /22&"6/ 5
!0! ' 1 #$6$7 %&2%
,% ( 7.15 " ",:% 74.50 6 9/<,&, ,%/'M , 9'+- , ( 1 ,","!", Marine Clay #$9:/+&!<5=,:%!", - %& 9 7( #$ /WM9' -9 ,%X %%"Y,&Z ,"+0% +$ %% - 9'/&+$ 20
# "
37 2 4.1 6$7
: Z\% ! ", 2540
) /2/
'%%': :"-,,&
,:'% 3 '%/9M =,: 6 9/<
/9 !0! "0 / 6=% ,% '%
: , =
6$7
38
2 4.2 6$7 7( %2,%
6$7%&',&6 9/< #$=,:%8 - /02"/<6 9^ .6.2543 ,%6_' ( 9.3 " %=a,!0!"'(6$72% :6 9/< , 8 !0! ,:'%
+/% A +/% B
+/% C
+2%
)"* ()
%&6% (!0!)
"0 / -"M7N5
39 1) !0! 201
2) !0! 202 3) !0! 203 4) !0! 204
5) !0! 40 ' "-"M7N5 6) !0! 40 ' +/% B
7) !0! 50 ' "-"M7N5 8) !0! 50 ' +/%b B
2 4.3 !0!6$7 : Z\% ! ", 2540
-6$7%%%&2% :,&/9 !0! #$
'%%%$ ! " ,%:/9 !0!
,&, 4,469 = ,%X /'c
!0!:' ,%- ,&/'-,!0! 907/<(&2 /<(&
d 2%_ -, 6$:' a=,:9- : '
;",!,::6,& ,%( /9 !0!9:,&
!0! 50 B
!0! 40 B
!0! 50 "_
!0! 40 "_
!0! 204
!0! 201
!0! 203
!0! 202
40
/' ' 2 -,"/'M% _ (-%,9"c=, /'_' 1 =,:c,:')
/'"0 / #$==,::%':,% "-,,d -+=,:''%':,%:-/'#$
9"0 / 6%%&2% ' 1 ( 6$7) ,%'/<5,/+/0;2&" ,2 4.4
2 4.4 :,&'%!
%':
/9 !0!
"0 /-
6 9
/<
_ ' 1 _
' 2
,&,:"
-,%&6%
'/<58
96%%& '%:
,& 907 /<(&2 /<(&
41 ) !
6 9/< ! -9' 14,761 % 6!% -9' 7,139 6M" -9' 7,622 ;&:/"<" -9' 10,254 -9' 7,222 ' ' ! 1,538 / .. !6$7X 8 !0!
%7N5 ( 13,277 -/+-::6(,6) , '6 9/< !Z ( 150,000-180,000 ,% !/'M
!0! 0;&:%=,::%#$0 / -9' 143 2%"0 /
4.1 -9' ! 6 9/< ,Y72 .6. 2546 -9' !
.6. 6!% 6M" ' -9';&:
/"<"
-9' '
! X%
' 2545 7,141 4,628 11,769 10,328 7,175 1.64 2546 7,139 7,622 14,761 10,254 7,222 2.04 : %7N 6 9/<
- 4.1 / ' -9' !6M""$%= "
,%"- 4,628 ^ .6. 2545 7,622 ^ .6. 2546 #$-%+$%:%
-9'$6M":6$7 ( ,%' a/ !,%'' -9' !X% ' ^ .6. 2545 ^ .6. 2546 1.64 2.04 ' ' 9, #$/"!/9M%$' 7( ' !6$7 &'':% :/ $a ( -9' !"$ '=%-9' !/"<"
= / ::a' !/'M6%%&"$==,:
!%&6% ,," 6$7%+' %:%
:6%9%&!' % '$:'-$%:%=6%%&%+' ==,:
%:%/9 ':
6 9/< //'Md 9 67 - :M#$/'%& ! "
42
9/<#$%&2% ! "
,% !/'M66%%& +$:% 92 4.2 -9' ! ,Y72 .6. 2546 9, 9 & -9'
'
:%
' ,
-9' !
:%
! , 1
2
967 - :M 9/<
1 1 3 15 16 17
299 3,661
194 1,311 1,626 131
4.14 50.69
2.69 18.15 22.51 1.81
1,284 6,628 368 2,093 4,350 38
8.70 44.90
2.49 14.18 29.47 0.26 ' 7,222 100 14,761 100 : %7N 6 9/<
-) /2678"-
!':!0! /'M:% 49 - !0 / ,%=,:-: 9 N% :% 20 &-:"7! ! :%:% 12.7 8'"/"- :! (:% 5 /9/+9 /'M:% 53 - %& :% 43 - %& #$
/'M- 90 / -%%&/ZWf+ g , ( 1,007 (/90 /-',: 2540) ,%- !:',"
( 15 g 30 - a'!':/'M% 678"- 2 (Formal Sector) a/'9"$"/ (Informal
Sector) ! -9 : =,: %a/;: 5=#5-: a+%
'' ,/, ,, "'(: (6 9/<; :&
'=6 9/< 2545)
43 X) /<(&2 /<(&
//
6+/% + A #$+:- _ ,%+! '+/% g , +/%75 + /00'" #$%&,:"6 :_ /'+/%!0!+ /' +/pW5 "/' !% ", 0/'
=ppq
=ppq%&';",!=ppq' /0 ,% 6_ /+%%=ppq' 1
%&';",! ' //0 /'"- ,6 9/< -9' 239 % "(!:
9 230 .. /'
//
- =7(%5
=7(%5%&';",!/9=7(%5 //< //
6=%
- 65
65%&';",!/9"65 565 6=% ';",!"7 !% !0/%65 3
6$7(6$7 ( '"-%=,:-96$7 4 " "6$7 :'"-%0 '/9M; prsp&'/<( #$=,:
$ / /0,:% (#$- '+$ = 5) ,%% %,:& '" 5 9, , =
4.2 .#" /
4.2.1 !:,"
"'(6$7%& %&6% ;'/0
44
^ 2544 !0!;&:%=,::%%&6%8 2 6$7 ,:'%%&6%-9' 5,205 '% ,/, 4.3 #$'/<(
%&"'(6$7 #$W--0%!:,"2%!0!
% ,%:+' :Z,!0!,:%&"+/% B #$+/%
=,:+&+ &/:("!%5 /' ("!%5#$/:,% ! "("!% ,!0!+&+
%!:,"%&6%/& 2 ' :,:%&6%
=:9"0 /
%: "% 67'/,0/: -,+ :% ,--
!: %!5X /'0 /'!:/,a : #$
/':%
4.3 %&6%"'(6$7
01 () )
:+'!,%' 1,260
:+'/! 1,902
:Z,!,%' 832
:Z,/! 768
," 110
("!%5/! 133
("!%5/! 200
5,205 : " 1 Z\% ! "
4.2.2 /2 ,!0!W--0
W--06$7+&": (2 2,7,8) -0,/ ! '!0!- ",00;&:%&6%!0! ":% (2 9-11) W--0/'=,:/:: : :%/0 /' :;&:%&6%!0! #$/'M !Z-00
45
,'9:",WM,:d ! WM9 %9 /% (2 1,6,12)
1
2
2 4.5 2 1-2 /2W--0
46
3 4
5 6
7 8 2 4.6 2 3-8 /2/
47
9 10
11 12
13 14
2 4.7 2 9-14 00--:% % %9
48
WM/2%2/ -"% "( 9:
!0!=/+!:'=,:
-/2!:'/<( W--0 =,:%=-;!:,"
,"= ,%!:,"," _ ';=':' +0 /5!:/'/<(
, ':;%- ( W--0!:,"7( #$/+
-9=,:/ 4.3 4.4 =
4.4 !:,""'('" ;!:,","
(# (....) (5)) (%)
% -,+#$-,: 15,675 9.80 22.12 ("!%5 :6% 18,730 11.71 26.43 /'/<( 36,450 22.78 51.44 ' 70,855 44.28 100.00 : Z\% ! ", 2540
,%' 44.28 = ( 70,855
4.5 !:,""'('" '-"
(# (....) (5)) (%)
%, /+ -,+-,: 18,455 11.53 26.05 ("!%5 :6% 18,730 11.71 26.43
/,a t 3830 2.39 5.41
-,+;&:%&6%!0! 2240 1.40 3.16
":: 7920 4.95 11.18 /'/<( (=%&/2,) 19680 12.30 27.78 ' 70,855 44.28 100.00 : /9'-
,%' 44.28 = ( 70,855
-,+'%$",$ (2 3-5) / 0/9M $ ; 30 ^:'==,: %-,+=':/'%&6%
Site& Service -!:+% 5 30 ^:' %= /' Site& Service a
49
/'%&6% /0%=,::% -+$W--0 /2678"- /
%= %'+% 59:'/'$+&0-,+ %=a -,+ "=,:% !0! %-
!:/% (==,:) ,%/'-,+- a'/<( ",+
#%," ,%!0!/'=,: "!'',,Z+ a -/'$ ,%X %%" '%& ' !0! 50 ' B !0! 50 '"_ =,:+&00 "-:%,a ,%7(
/:!'' ! "% "%:' ,& 11 (2 4.7) : #$,M/0, / 0/'$-/2',:/
-,,& ! "8 -: '%
;",!,&' - %:%:,&:6 =/+,&7 :%&/2,=,: -!:-%,&7/& ;!"MWM 9' -9 9:!:-%,& 907/&%"$
%=a %/' !!!0!:0/2 9% ,%"- : #$!: -90'
" %5 !'%a0' -/9'-' "- :
(2 4.4) - ' '!0! 50 ' B !0! 50 '"_
/'' '!0! 40 'B !0! 40 '" /,a "- ; =,: &,0% , :
50
2 4.8 "-!:'
4.2.3 '/<5 '%26 "!:'/<(
0(7( %2'/<( ; 6 "!: ,% ,:'% ' /9M%:% 7 =,:
,' :!:
8'!0! , ': (Neighborhood Park) -6$7 Tunnard Pushkarev ','',==' 12.5 = ! 1,000 ==' 20 ! ( '+&
9,-;," , ( 5.54 = /9 2 !0! ,%, ' ( 22 = #$ !,!0!-9' 17,461 /,/':" 2 ! #$/+'=,:' '/<( !0!
,'/+!:
!0! , ': (Neighborhood Park) =,:
, !:"
-9' ! /'/<( , ': - ''( 2 ,%6$7 Tunnard Pushkarev ' ':"=,:
( 800-1,000 ' ( /2W--0;&:!:,'%& ( 150
51
' '%$,/+' :!:
!=,: :/ %&' 0, !:!:-$-9':%' 8-9' !,'- :!:: #$- 2"% = 5
, &
-''( 2 ,%6$7(% '&
/ :",Y "'0 ='7( %' ( ,''- z,:' 3 ,: ', '': 3 '/&/"&/:,% /'/2W--0'
&,"/,/',:': ,:%' 1:5 '': '/&
/"&/:,% 1:1 '% =z,:' /+'=,:' & 7( '/<( !0! ={0(7(
%2,d ",Y "'0 9 ' :!:
-''( 2 ,%6$7 Tinnard Pushkarev ' % / , ':'- !0! % ,"
( 3-5 200-250 /'/2W--0'=,:9,:%&
2%,%/'$!0! ,% % -: +$'=" 250 -'=,:' % '%&6%'/<( 0(7( :
",!: %!5-
,'&:/$-:
'/<( ='9:",'&:/$'=-:
- 9:=,&-/ /'/2W--0%& -'=,:'=", '&:/$-: ;&:%&6%%&!0! ,%',-/2'/
",$ =,: WM'/ ': : 7( "-",$
,%9,"-/9'/<( , - :9,
"-",$:'% /+ /;&::!:/%=,:06 '% ' ,:'%' +0 /5 /'/2"-",$W--0 '"-",$%&%-9, -=9,7( "-- ",$%
52
='- ,:'% -, % 0(5/ ! : __ ,%X 0;&:/&%0 ,a ={'- /+9"-,d =,:%'/<( !0!
4.2.4 :/0 2"%;6$7" "%2
'/<( !0! '%
:-9,:!0!:!: %!5%&% +$:', 9 - ' /,:' W--% =,: :-9,,:& ,%
&=:",'09"- :-9,,:7( "- =9,
"-!:/% ,-+$'=",7( '-:!0! ,%, ,&7,%!0! 5 /' :0prsp&' /<( #$/''/<( - :0- /' :
!0! /+9,=,:,%%%- /2W--0 8 '/<( /!0! 8 ,& 4.6
%!: %!5," -/2/%= aW--%$
9:",%!:'/<( %=':!0! ,%X
%/'-,+ -==,:';'%=':
': - / 0$a !0! %=':/9 0;&:%&6%%=,::%#$=- !:+/'0 :a--":'0
=,: ! 8 $-9#+% 5/'0 ",' :!:
-,+ -",%!:,"/'$'/<( ,-+$ "
:% #$",'-,+-9'':% 30 %=':
/'/<( ," ;
53 4.6 ' :,:%2 :=,:0
': 8[1] /2W--0 /''=,:0
, =" 12.5 = 5.54=
(,' 2 !0!)
= , !
:"
800-1,000 ' =" 150 ' [1] /+' :=,:,:' :/ ' !!:!::%' , - 8
, & ='7( %'
'': '/&/"
&/:,%%& ' 1-3 ',:z,:' 3 ,:
'0"-
7( %' ,% /' ':: %' = 1:5
'': '/&/"&/:
,% ( 1
' =z,:
'
, &' = :",Y "'0 9"-
9 !:'," 3-5 % - +$
!0! =" 200- 250
% -!0!+$' % =" 250 ' /,:' 9
'-: =':&:/$' =-: =",'&:/$-: ,%0=,:-/2%- 2/ ,,&-/!0! =,:
WM% 9/% :
/"/:'&:/$-::",$
!0!
7( "- '9$+$'%!:/% , +$;&:!:/%06 '% ' ,:'%
-0, /5=
"-",$ :% -'W--0 = 0(5-,/+:","- ,%W--0 %' "-",$ ",-,'
%%!0!
-,:",'% ,%:9, 7( !::!,-$
: -/9'-( '"-% ,"+0% 2546
54
6$7" ",:%2 5 $- 9':-:-9,!:
/2%& '==,:prsp&'/<(
!0! %$%&W--%% ,%- =,:2"% = 4.3 .#"!0 " *
4.3.1 /2(5,:" %'%%':
,&'/<(
6 9/<
6 9/< '%';",!,% ,&/2 , ' 1 ' 2 /' ,%% ( 30-40 : ^ ,%%=,:/'M-a27 d ! 27 27q%
#$",%=,: ( 25.6-29.3 : ^ -%=,:- <%
%=,:-/"%5 ! ,% %=,:a, a,d ,%%^ .6. 2544 (%^ .6. 2545 ,/, 4.7
4.7 %6 9/<
* *0"
89 2544
8:
89 2545
8:
89 2546
%=,:27 25,628,383.76 27,725,000 29,300,000
%=,:"!27
1. <% d 1,508,083.35 1,495,700 1,953,000 2. %=,:-%5/"
,% ! , 2,242,346.29 2,372,000 1,897,000 3. %=,:a, a, 1,211,251.50 50,000 152,800
"=,:d -
"!'% 3,248,750 10,158,638.78 3,397,200 **"< 33,838,814.90 41,801,338.78 36,700,000 : 6 9/< 2546
55
6!:-% %^ ,9"/9M =,: -: ", ' ( 8-10 : ^ !:/% '/,0 ( 15- 17 : ^ #$+=,:
'%-%/0,6 /<(&2 ( 1.5-2.4 : ^ 02(5 ," /"/: ( 5-5.5 : ^ ,%/, 4.8
4.8 %-%6 9/<
0) 0) 0"
89 2544
8:
89 2545
8:
89 2546
1. %-%_ 1,520,701.86 1,849,283 1,928,251 2. ',", -: -9 4,208,692.22 5,821,560 5,502,960 3. ',-:!'' 3,620,596.03 4,682,350 4,964,400 4. ', !:/% '/,0 14,768,016.99 14,655,720 16,961,880 5. ',/<(&2 1,410,618.43 2,354,800 2,252,000 6. ',"0,0 400,000 25,000 70,000
7. %-% - - -
8. ',02(5 ,"
/"/:
5,664,850 12,329,256 5,008,600
0) *"< 31,593,475.53 41,717,969 36,688,091 : 6 9/< 2546
- 4.3 4.4 - a=,:' !:-%,:!0! #$%&/' ',/<(&2 % (:% 5.6 -6.1 (%-%, 6_ ,%!:-%6_ =,:+&!:=,:%-% -9 =,: !:/%
'/,0 ", -: -9 ,% (,:/<(&2/'- +&!:=
,&7'/ ,!0! "(% ' " --9' ! Z02"2 9: :a% % (W--0a 4 /,5 #$' -"'- a ( 2-3 /,5) -!:-%/& $ =,: -:
9+ : 0+ -+!90,=,:%
-",9'#9#0^ 9 !90,-
+0 /":,M!:/:'/':/&"0 / /'9:
56
+%0!:/ ( "0 /==,:!'%0,0!:-%/' %,
/+'=,:'6_ = (-,/!0!
,:'%/ 0/9M%:% 2 6 :!: (:=WM /<(&2,' =,: ##;"'+ 7'/ ,!0!
! "
! " ,"';",!,&
2%-, 6 9/<$ :,&:a 6_
/' _ 9:%-,/%&6%:;&: :%&_ (%
' 2 /'' 1 ! "=,:,9"-,/=
,:')
5!0!
5!0!c/2',:!0! =,: 0(
!0! #$==,: (//0-'%,d c!0! =9- -,/<(&22%!0! -,9-:6_ ,%6- _0,0"/'!:-%"-c'=!0! ! ,&
( !0! %9 #$a-9':% ( 200 #% (-/+!0!) "!0!- =,:- -
%%!'!0!-,"-ad :%d
/' (!0!=,:-6 =,:-0
&: &: 1 : #$"&:/:! =-9!:"- prsp&/2'/<( =,: -c/'=/+
/:%=,::/&0=,: -% (/<(/0: /.
(///<( /0!0!) #$,:/<(/06-,//9 /02 ,%: !0! 7,500 ^
d
'%-- 9:'/<( /2,$ ,$
=,: 5-,9/% ; 6$7,%: ' 6_=,: / : 5-,9/%:,& ,:9,9/%!0! -6a'"
96_ - -,=,: -/'$'/<( /'%'
57
&!0! :,&9/%5-,9/% -$- ;:/2
%2 &9!0!/2,$ +$:'5-,9/%- ==,: ( 0,0:6,% a
4.3.2 '" 56%2 '==,:-,"prsp&' /<(
-:&,:" %'%%':prsp&/2',:
'/<( ,' /+9'" 5 ",'/+%
%&=,: ,=,:--=': 4.9 ,%'%==,::%':,&
'/<( ,:'%'% 5/9M%:% 2 '%
=,: 6 9/< 5!0! ,%- 9'" 5 6%2W--0 '%/ ",'/+,:" % , '==,:'%/- ::WM'/<(
