!"#$% #
&'&# (&$%&
)*
QUALITY OF WORK LIFE TOWARD ORGANIZATION COMMITMENT OF INDUSTRIAL ELECTRONICS EMPLOYEES AT NAVANAKORN
INDUSTRIAL ESTATE PATUM THANI
*&*B
' C)D )
EFG 2550
.. !"#$%&'
(()!"*'+,-"!. /*"#$%0102*345$
'*'+1(6!.1$'1'78% '%&("&4& 96$'
%1( ('*'+ &.'1'#$% &" ''!.4 &%(!& !" '$.!. 1($%
&('$'(&4 %'&(3'' $4&4 %'& %
&:!
!. %',!.'$%'964''''
&+ $'$5 1( &;4"!"#0,!.*. 1(%'&!
('$ !<# !"!.
: := "&!
:& 2551
: !"
#$# %"&#!%# ' ()
: )#)* %+%
: ",(
(-+! : .,. 2551
$$2(3#! 3 (3 '$ 1) %6+,783' 9"3 ! 2) %6+,78%(% ! :' 9(; # " 3) %6+,78#)!3 ! ,78" 398 9#2%(>%6+6%&" %3!":':(9%!
#2+?'9 "3 %@"+ # %+%A 9"3#(3#)*##)!%!#
" #(?' 1)
! 3'(" 2) (; # " '%, #2## ? !9 # (; # "' 9"3 3',78+
9 !9 #B#2 3)
#)! ! #B#2+3' 0.01
#B : , !, " #
$# %"&#!, # '()
#B : #B%(>8? (3 5 %6+ %(> # '%6+%!
Research Title : Quality of Work life toward Organization Commitment of Industrial Electronics Employees at Navanakorn Industrial Estate Patum Thani Name of Researcher : Thanasit Phoemphian
Name of Institution : Sripatum University Year of Publication : B. E. 2551
ABSTRACT
The Objective of this research were as followed : 1) To study the level of quality of work life ,organizational commitment 2) To compare the organizational commitment among employees factors are different. 3) To study the relations between quality of work life and organizational commitment of employees. The sample were used 398 employees. Data were collected by questionnaires. The data were analyzed by application program computer. Statistics use were : percentage, mean, standard deviation, Pearson4s product moment correlation coefficient.
The results of this research indicated that 1)The level of quality of work life and organizational commitment of employees were moderate. 2) The difference of sex, age and marital status had no different in the whole organizational commitment. On the other hand, the different of working duration and educational background had different in the whole organizational commitment. 3) The relation between quality of work life and organizational commitment was positively at the level of significant.
Keywords: Quality of work life, Organizational Commitment , Industrial Electronics Employees, Navanakorn Industrial Estate Patum Thani
Keywords : 789:;<=;<:>?@ABCD<E<8>F9GE AHIJ<K 5 :;< @LMN8OPQRSQ8T<COUQ@ABC:;<VQC=;<PH>7 :QC:WQ<XQWY@:HMN8F:8JLZW@V8H[
1
1
2 3
" 3
# 3
$%& 4
2
()*#+,%-). & 6
()*#01% 2 15
0&)*)*4 22
# (. 27
3
6) 30
-22 30
8*8 31
#41 33
41 33
&)*.-4. 35
4
041 38
5 !"# $# %!%
0( 45
0. 48
,0 50
4 53
" 56
$ ' 63
###&)*.-4.
#()* 70
1
!" #$$ !%&... 30 2 $+ , -$$ +.
/0 + .12... 35 3 $4 &5
( )
X + &57 (S.D.) $+$<0&#!... 37 4 $4 &5 ( X ) &57 (S.D.) $+$?@
$"2!... 38 5 &!&$4 &5$?@$" +... 39 6 &!&$4 &5$?@$"D
+... 39 7 &!&$4 &5$?@$"D
+/0... 40 8 &!&$4 &5$?@$"D
+... 41 9 &!&$+$4 &5$?@$"D
!&5&+E$@... 41 10 &!&$4 &5$?@$"D
+.12... 42 11 &!&$+$4 &5$?@$"D
!&5&.12+E$@... 42 12 $%"$<0&#!$?@$"
... 43 13 ? !7!... 44
1 Steers$$$$$$$$.. 19
1
!"#$%&
'"#$%() *"+" *),-%. &""""#$% "
/)" &&)"") *"0 /)"&. &")"
#$%)"1 12+!%&3/) "#$% &
"%)" ,-1 -3)!) *"0!4"&!*5 2540 1+*
%%:!,&" .&..&" %";4
!)*"2!*)&*""! .<- .,%")"&!*
=% /) 1 >;"./4$";"),+",-&*+ %%=%
"&,-%)"",-. %";4 *"2,-%#?#& $ +" 1 21&0,=%!*)1 "4.%#
%" = %=.@%!%"& . /)!))";"
),)"+4 *"2,-",&!**!)"@%!%") *".%=%&
0,-"!)""*". &*" &)!)""!-.& "
!)"& %#@%!%,-.%=%+" >;"1+*-".
",-..44"&))" )*),-%. - "=%;4
?1*.%=.+",,-""!*)1
%-)" ,-%*"/)"1!<- !.!4"14 !)".)" ) ) *") 4 /) "% !? & >;" ?/)*()" )..
"4,)" &-*" ;" -.. )" !)!)"#
-*41,-. & )",3,')" .
%-
-!.4 "&.2+%-!)" -".)" 1-..
+*)" & /) !,-") *".. ;"?..) +*
,)"&!*,3,')" "4-.)" ,3 ,
# /) ,-.) +*,)" 4 . .+%."*)"
%=.!*"A.,3 3* ,-2!)&")"!!)")"
&!)"!)")"",-!)")")" ("3, 2537:1 ) !)" )"), /),-+;*!)".**, '&(*-;")")" ?;",-3.%!..,"
3/)*..3.%!".. *).%=%)"" (%, 2545:
1)
Greeberg and Baron (1995: 647) 1**3.%!"*),-% 3 . .
3 1&* 2 !",%;"),," "+;2+!*))"
)!. " ,-22%!+";4 &%%=%2)")" 3* 21
<- )")" "4 '3.%!)"," ;"(%"..
-;" >;"))" Hackman and Sattle (1997: 9) .**/)+
?;" **), -/).3.%!".- 03* %;"), ,"&*"2!*)2+!*))" 1
4".4-0*#.. ,-") +*)" ,-.;4) +*
3.%!,")"&2+!*))" 2+% ;",;#3.%!
,"*.= 2+!*))" . ", & ,.2!*)2+
!*))" 1 >;"*),-% 3 !*)")"
!"#
1. /);#3.%!," &2+!*))" )"
"
2. /);#?;". . 2+!*))" )"" &!
*
3. /);#= -*"3.%!,"2+!*) )" )""
!"#
1. *)"".2!*)2+)""-/)1*
2. = )"3.%!," 2+!*))" )"
"(1,3%" -/)
!$ % !"#
1. ".. *&!!*" 2+!*))" &!!*"
1.1 "..&!!*" .2+!*))" &!!*"
1.2 "..) &!!*" .2+!*))" &!!*"
1.3 "..?&!!*".2+!*))" &!!*"
1.4 "..) "&!!*" .2+!*))" &!!*"
1.5 "..;#&!!*" .2+!*))" &!!*"
2. 3.%!,".= 2+!*))"
!"#
,% 4".4 (;#3.%!," &2+!*) )" )""@%!% )"*)!-3%4*)%0)% ,!%
)!- "-=.
3.,3,% ("@%!%*)!-3%4*
)%0)% ,!%)!- "-=. 80,000
!# &'
""#(
) - ?;" 5.%!@%% ?;"5^.!)? ,..#
)" 6 /),-%( 1 5 &*"(
1. ) !* 25 5 2. ) -*" 25 _ 30 5 3. ) * 30 5
? - ?;" .") +*,)"" &*"(
1. 1&* ". "1*1
2. 1&* "..?& ")"3.%!+**
3. - *" 1&* ". &!*& ) +*
) " - ?;" ."@%!%",)" %!4"&!*
"%@%!%",)" .4 1*?;" . @%!%"*)" )/
*) 5!0 &*"
1. ) "!* 5 5 2. ) "-*" 5-10 5 3. ) "* 10 5
;# - ?;" ;#)""&*"( 3 /) 1. !*%!.
2. %!.-/). * 3. +"*%!.
" - ?;" .") +*@%!%)")" >;") +*,*
)!-3%4*)%0)% ,!%)!-
)* '+!% - ?;" +;. " .,-"%
;"), &. *"2!*)%=%,")"" ) - 1*!)&.. ")& !%=
- "..) &*"%
- -&","
- ),'?)"!)"
- +""-/)"*
- %=%)""
- -*"3.%!"3.%!)/
- ( 3 !*)"
,- '( - ?;" +;,">;"&"?;":!%(-;"
. )""..!*))" /) ))" ,3?/))"
&!)"(3%)")"
.#+ /( "0/1
/),3(&",*"%3.%!," &(&-*")+,
",-".2+!*))" >;")*"2,-%-,)"
0 %";4
2
) #1
2+% 1&%&:#@... )"% /),3(&"
,;#% ".4
1. &%. 3.%!,"
2. &%. 2+!*))"
3. 2"% .. )"
!/ # )* '+!%
#)* '+!%
Walton (1978: 12) 1*?;"3.%!,"1* (#".
!))"!)"&?)" %#&"(
?!-/)" /)"")")" .,-"0 Bluestone (1977: 44) 1*?;"3.%!,"1* ("
.,-2+,3&""1;"),,"+";4 2*.
**,!%,&&1-)")" >;".2!*)3.%!
")" /)1- ?;""%-. # ,-.3=%1! ,?."%;4 /)*),-%"%=%2)"
)" 4".4 (d),-*A ,-3%)")" *),-3%-/)"
&""1;"),+";4 3* "" )"2%!e .;4 . % 2*) " )"," (!
Merton (1977: 55) 1*?;"3.%!,"1* (..-
")A /)".. % = "&" .
!?" /)%" ;"),)"" /)%=%
)"22%!&1 )) *"""*.*!*)"&?. )""
!% (2530: 15) 1*?;"3.%!,"1* 3.%!"..%g.
-. !%+% &*(# )" /)3.%!".1*?+) ). &?)"!)"/4$.". &"1,&!*
33 (2535: 38) 1*?;"3.%!,"1* )"
= -*""%"&))""-)4"%!%"#
(Human dimension) .%1%%!%%&#$%
(2535: 33-44) 1*?;"3.%!,"1* )"+" -/)
",." ;"?;".**)"" " &
&) ,,-.
!% (2540: 39-40) 1*?;"3.%!,"1* (%".
?"1) *"!0%=% ?"%22%!1 .)4"
*" &%!, >;"?/)( )0/) &),"(%".,- ."%;"),,"
3.%!," - ?;" +;)""..!*)"&
&)!*"A ," ,-"+;;"),&./)1
!))"!!)" &*"2!*)%=%)"" &%=%2)""
)* '+!%
House and Cummings (1985: 199-200) 1*?;")" ))"3.%!,
"1* ))"-*"? -/);"),,")"
%=%2)")" -/)). -;"3.%!"(2//)"
2 (Well-Being) ,")"2+@%!%" ,-".;"),,"4A )" ))"3.%!,") #!*"A 8 ".4
1. 1 2 3 !)&. !%=&. ") (Adequate and Fair Compensation) - ?;" 1 1 2!)&.. ") ))"!$."
-1 !$)"2+ .-/). . 1")/
2. ?.".?+#&) (Safe and Healthy Environment) - ?;" ."1@%!%",&).- ?."1**"2. !*) & 1*. ")!
3. )'.?)"2+@%!%" (Development of Human Capacities) - ?;" ".1,3#&?-- ".. ".2+@%!%".
(!)"!)"," ".1 )*.
4. - (Growth) - ?;" .2+@%!%".).-,)3.
&!&-*" .",)3.
5. = ,-* " (Social Integration) - ?;" .2+@%!%"(
. ))"2+*" .". )"(%! .))*)/4))
&*"& (-+*-* 2+@%!%"1 ) &.) @%= 2+)/
6. %-".(=&) (Constitutionalism) - ?;" . !%=,%-" .@%!%!*)) *"- .,%=%*
2+"3 )v")%-0)"" )")" .)&
!%=
7. )"3*".,3," &3*".12*.(
*! (The Total Life Space) - ?;" ..)"3*" "
3*"%3.%! * .)"",3*" &.
,-) .3*".1 . -..2%3)
8. +%,,)" (Organizational Pride) - ?;" +;)""..
+%,.1@%!%",)" ..3/). " &1+*)" ) 3 &
2%3)!*)"
Walton (1973: 12-16) 1*?;")" ))"3.%!,"1*
3.%!,&( (Humanisitic) &&))"!-/)"
/)"")")" .,-"2022%!)""&!%!)"
#$%.!))"!)"&-?)"," &-*
..3.%!"!)".)*"3.4!*"A , 8 (e !% ".4
1. 1*!)&.. ")& !%= (Adequate and Fair Compensation)
*!)&(%"-;".*")?;"3.%!,"1 /)".
!)""#$% &*""/),-1!))""#$% >;"!)".4 (%"(-.3.%!) +*) )"- ,*!)&
-!& ")",3%". . 2+)/,)""&. "4 e ,!%. *!)&.*"3.4* .3%%!"4%,/)"
1.1 . ") /) *!)&.1"4 . ")."3.%!
!!$)""
1.2 !%= >;"%= -*"*!)&.#"
%1. . *!)&.1")"!"..# A 2. ?"..) &*"% (Safe and Healthy Working Conditions) - ?;" 2+@%!%") +*,&)"*" &
%"&))"".<)")!%-! &1*%2. !*) 1-
!$.&*). "1>;"&).*"%&) >;"(
"
3. -&"," (Opportunity for continued Growth and Security) - ?;" ".2+@%!%1)- .2!*)"1 & ? )"!)",-1+&#,-* .&"-/)),/)!&-*"-..
+";4,#)"3.%!" .e %/)
3.1 .".' - ?;" 12%3) 1)- ";4 3.2 .&"- - ?;" .-".1!. + # /)",-..+";4
3.3 )0() )").",-
0,)" -/), ")3.)(. ))"2+*" 3%) -/)2+. )")/ A
3.4 " - ?;" .")"*"& 1.1 3.5 ),'?)"!)" (Opportunity for Developing and Using Human Capacity)
4. '?)" (Opportunity for Developing and Using Human Capacity) ,".4(,-0. ;# ) '"
&)3.)"(%"*")?;"3.%!"-;" >;",-
?-. ,3 ..) +*) *"!0..3/),!)"&/).-0,3
&1!))",+&%3.%!.-;"(2,- 0,3.%!
'?)".4 ?%/)"!*"A ".4
4.1 ()%-/)(!)"!)" - ?;" ) . 2+@%!%".)% ?" !)"
4.2 #.>>) (%) )"".2+@%!%"1,3 +3;4*.@%!% #"% ( .?,
"
4.3 +,-*&(%".*3 /) 1',-+- +. "&&"!*"A ,@%!% !)2.*%;4
&"4A /),-./)&"@%!%" &2.%;4) *"
?+!)"&(. )
4.4 %4"-)""(%?)"..
"2+@%!%"1',-.+3.@%!%"41 !)"
4!)%,3*@%!%1("*)""
4.5 "&2 /) ..?," !)""&2..,
@%!% %"
5. +""-/)"* (Social Integration) "
*(.2+@%!%"-0*!)".* ?@%!%",-201 . )&*/)" . >;"(. )"")")" =3!%
= -*",)" .2!*) ,">;"#"*.4
%
5.1 ()%)!% (%"* ;"?;"
#? )" 1*.)!%-/)1*;"?;")" & ;?/) /)"*!*?,"
5.2 1*.&*"34,)" -/)."
5.3 . &","* /) .+;*.
. &"1,"..*%1
5.4 .,* /) .#".3* -/)>;" . ,,#)" ,-") "
5.5 .+;*"*..,)" .
5.6 .!%!*)/),#d2 /) 3%,)" -/).
"&"%-0+;)"!) *"&%"!*)
6. %=%)"" (Employee Rights) - ?;" %-.,--./
"1.%=%,@%!%!)!.1)- &&")),%=%>;"&
-/)-&","* !)"1,%=%*! ( )" )-;")"*"3.43.%!" >;"?%1
6.1 )"!(<)")+)"! ,#
@%!%"2+%-)!)")+!*"A /)%" >;"2+@%!%0,-)+.
. )"@%!%".%=%.1*,-)+)/A .(*! ) >;"1*
. )"@%!%"
6.2 .)%,+ /) .%=%.+?;"@%!%"
#$%-/)")")" !*)2+%- *.2!*)%
.3))"!
6.3 .)(%?;"!)"#)
,/)")" . 2.;"1 *!)& &","
6.4 ,-!*)-. (# )"2+*"
7.-*"3.%!"3.%!)/ (Work and Total Life Space) /) . ,")"!)",-- &.3.%!)"!)"
) &%)/
8. ( 3 !*)" (Social Relevance of Work life) /) %
".%1,#.12%3)!*)" >;"*),-%%*
)""&)3.)"2+@%!% 3* +;)"*2+@%!%".+* )" )"!1.
**2%3)," /)" &)/ A
Desslesrs (1991: 471) 1*?;")" ))"3.%!," 1&*
/- *" &2"* &&2""2%! (
! &2"-*.4),",*)"
1. !%=&.-!2,@%!%!*)"
2. ,-)",,3+?1!0. & "(
!))"+;# ! .1,3+?..
3. ,-!%!*)/)-*""d"&.*3/)?/)
4. ,-)".**,!%,,*.. )"")"!
5. ,-2!)&.. ")& !%=
6. &),".) &?+#
Shrovan (1989: 1-6) 1*?;")" ))"3.%!,"1 3
"4
1. '/)'4",%=.-/)%"!*"A ,).
*),-%3.%!".. &.',3.%!)" >;"
))"-)"%=%# 3 &&%3=%1! .,%g.)"&!*
2. .. !% /) & ),%g.)"(# 1
!))";"), &1 *)" (. ),? -/)(2+
.,)"2+)/ .,A 1 ))"* !.
!*))" 0?"1) *".%=% )(,-)" 1 22%!.%;4
3. @%!%( /) "(&) . 1!)",3) *") 8 3" ,"&!* *).@%!%=
2+*",."'3.%!)"&!* 4""",-
%%=%..)"1*?%;41 ?-@*)" 4A 1*.
. %=.@%!%,".)/4)) ?",-<- 1 "4
"../)2",&!* >;"!*)/)"1 "2", (.&!*
)" ,- 3*
Bruce and Blackburn (1992: 15-16) 1*?;")" ))"3.%!,
"1"!*)1.4
1. *!)&.(=&. ")
2. ".) &1*
3..),'? "..- &&"-
&",-*A ,"
4.-&" - ?;" ),'+ #&
? 4"+;?;"","
5.+" - ?;" .)1.@%= -*""&
2+%-
6.."",".%!" &.) -) *"*.
7..*" - ?;" ?,&*",-/)"*!&"1 ) *"-
8. )"" - ?;" +%,!*)".2%3)&!*)"
1* 3.%!,"4) %!%!*"A .3* %,- +;;"),-/)1*;"),," .&!*.+&,-
%!%&!*&!!*" %!%..!*)3.%!," 1&*
%!%*!)&.. ")& !%= %!%".) &*"%
%!%- %!%"," %!%)'?)"
!)" &%!%+""-/)"* ?;"%=%)""
-*"3.%!"&3.%!)/ 4")"= -*""
%"&))""&( 3 !*)" >;"(4"%!%"# (Human dimension) .%1%%!%)/A
.#+ !1 )* '+!%
Schuler et al. (1989: 492) 1*?;" 3 )"3.%!,"1".4 1.%;"),,"+" %"&",,-"
2.,-22%!%;4 ) *") .%)!"."
3.%=%,"%;4.".**&,";4 4.. )!%-!&0" >;"*"2?;"
4.1 !*# ?;"!*
4.2 )!&* 2!)&" %)"%* "
5. /- *)"". &?,. ".
;4 >;"(2+;,()")" &.**,".
%;4
6. )!-&/)".;4/)"*,,""
+;2+!*))" &)!. "
7. )!-&/)" "..
8. ,-"+;,";4 ,-".**,
!%,,-%=%)). " v"%-0)"" %=%)""
9. ,-%!$3.%!.. !!$() +*..
Greeberg and Baron (1995: 647) 1*?;" 3 )"3.%!,".
. 3 1&* 2 !",%;"),," "+;2+!*) )" &)!. " ,-22%!+";4 &%%=%2)")" 3*
21<- )")" .!?" 4" 3 %-&
"!)".**,-&2*&&24!)"1?+1@%!%) *"
+
).4 3.%!," "(*-;",')"
. %;4)"22%! &".. ",.**,
!%,,/)".. )""!))"!)" ;"),)"
" ,-".!4",,") *"!0. "4)" ;" -%=.
) *"( /)"",.&"+", ;"),&"2+, )" >;"( .%2@%!%")")" >;"0/)3.%!,"
Dessler (1991: 4) 1*?;" 3 )"3.%!," ,-
".+;..!*))" %"&", '=)" &%!%
&)
"4 2+% ? 3 )"%"3.%!,"1*
%"3.%!," *"2,-"%;"),,"
?"1) *"!0%=% .)4"*" &%!, >;"?/)*(
,& ) 0/),-%&),".. .
" %;"),," &,-%2+!*))" &+;*!(
*-;")")"
!/ # ,- '(
')" 4!)"",-".2+!*))" 2.
1 /) "!0,&).)%!/)",-0&
!!?" .!4"1 2+% 1- )"2+!*))" ..2+;#
1".4
# ,- '(
%3.,":!%)"* 2+!*))" )"3%, )" &")) :!%.) *")&!*)/)" 1*. ."
&*" ",,@%!%" /)0)")" %3.,
".41&*
Allen and Meyer ()"?;", )! 3 , 2529:35-36) 1*?;"2+!*))"
1 3 &% /)
1.&%!%.4)"*2+!*))" (+;)"
.+;*!(*-;")")" &,-- )"2+!*))" * 1) 3/)& )<- &*% )")" 2) !0)!0,.,3 ) *"
!0.."/))" 3) ?) *"&".#3%)")" 1 2. &%:!% &%.4)"2+!*))" ,+&
))":!% /).2+!*))" 0.&"+&:!%) *"
!*)/)"-/)""," 1* . &"." .
#3%1 1* 11- 0/)". . 21&2. .%;4 -%4")"3%-/)))1) *"??.& >;"2. .4%,#
!.%-/)2 3 .. 1 :#@..(&%.4 /) :#@. Side Beet )" Hawart S. Becker >;"1* %2+!*))" (2.. . 3"
4-* ?-)))" 1+. )1"
3. &%".. ?+!)"-/)$)""
&%.4)"2+!*))" *( ". &!0,.)%!,- )" >;"(2$)")" &" +;*/)(3%
))" 0!)".2+!*))" /)?+!)"&-.
2+!*))" 4(-.-/)=2+.3%!)".!*)@%!%-., )"
Kanter (1968: 499) 1*?;"2+!*))" 1* !0,)".
*"&".&*" (2+= ,".?)"-0?;"
?)&",!)"
Poter and Smith (1970 )"?;", Mowday et al., 1982: 27) 1*?;"2+!*) )" 1* (= .-. &*)"&!*(2+ )"
Sheldon (1971: 143) 1*?;"2+!*))" 1* !%-/)+;.
3%.!*))" >;". )# )")"
Steers (1977: 46) 1*?;"2+!*))" 1* +;)"".
&"!(-;". )" .*% ./3%)" )/ &!0,.
)%" &",/)@%!%")")"
Steers and Porte (1983: 442) 1*?;"2+!*))" * ?&*"
))( 2 &% /)
1. 2+":!% (;#2+!*))" .(:!%
,.!)"1(*-;")")" &2+!*))" ,$
(3%)")" /)1+*<- )")"
2. 2+":!% (;#2+!*))" .(:!%
,.1)" 3* 1?/)(2+) 1
*!)&+";".2+!*))" 1*!)". 2 3 .1)" ?
%4"1".)/01**.)" 1
. (2529: 99) 1*?;"2+!*))" 1* !%)"3%.(1 ,"!*))" +;2+!*))" .- .;>;"*2+"
-/)&*. "") +*,)" *4 1?;".3%.!0, . )"*)"!)" /)<- )")"
2+!*))" - ?;" +;,">;"&"?;":!%(
-;". )""..!*))" /) ))" ,3?/))"
&!)"(3%)")"
""# / ,- '(
Mowday et al. (1982: 28-35) 1*?;" .-2+!*))" ?
&*"1( 4 *
1. * (Personal Factors) -/)#*1&* ) ,@%!%",)" &"+",,:=%g .2"!*)2+!*))" */)
"..) * ,@%!%"* &.*% ,"*
2+!*))" * ).4,*"2+-%"0.&2+*"
2+3 *;#.2"!*)2+!*))" */) "..;#
!2+!*))" *"..;#+"
2. #)"&".. )" (Role-Related Characteristics) 1&* "
.. "..*3 &.))"!)" .= !"
2+!*))" */) ".".. .& ",&
,.. )"! .&..2+!*))" +"
3. #"")")" (Structural Characteristics) 1&* )"
)" ..&2 ) .**,%-" &.*()"
)" .= "2+!*))" */) )" .,-".*
*,!%, . )"0.2+!*))" +"
4. ," (Work Experience) 1&* !% ..!*)2+*", )" ;"2+,!"3 @%!%")"2+"3 +;*".
(%"..)%=%"2+!*))" */) "..
.,," 3* !%)"*,-+*/)*" +;*
)" 1-")"" +;*)" ?1",1 +;*
!)"!*))" " 0.2+!*))" +"
Streers (1977: 121-122) 1*?;" .-2+!*))" ) )" ) 3 )1&*
1. *)"" 1?;" ,",)" &
#!)")"" 3* &"+",,:=%g (Need for Achievement) (!
2. #)"">;"("."2%3)) +* 3* 2<))""
.)# )""&),.@%= 2+*" (!
3. " >;"(%".1&. + /)1", )" 3* +;)""..!*))" *3/)?/))")" &!%)"
*..!*))" (!
) 1 ..2!*)2+!*))" !&%)" Steers .: Steers (1977: 122)
Luthans (1992: 125) ** 2+!*))" ?+-
1. * 1&* ) ,",)" &.#%
)" +;-/) &%?;" ,-/) )
2. #)")" 3* ))&&#)"2+
- !)"
0
- "
"
- *3/)?/))")"
- !%)"*!*))"
- +;)""!*) )"
2)"2+
!*))"
2+
!*))"
#)""
- 2 ))""
- .)# )""
- ),.@%=
-
3. .1*,3*#)")" 3* "/))/A ..-"%"/)
&?)" 4) +*,0&A ./)1" 0,-.+;2+!
3) ,- '(
Cherrington (1989: 302) 1&*"2+!*))" ( 2 /)
1. 2+!*)/)" (Continuance Commitment) -/). *2+.%
% (Calculative Commitment) 0/) !0,)".") +*, )" 4A ""#$! .= ") +* 3* "3/)*
)" 4."%* ?+"* /)*"(%!* &*,*
2. 2++; (Affective Commitment) -/). * 2+
% = (Moral Commitment) ( ))" !*)*% &<- )")"
3* "+;2+% =)" &%;4 /)#)"
&+;.*,!)")"))"<- )")"
Poter and Smith (1970 )"?;", Mowday et l.,) 1&*"2+!*))"
?)=% #1( 3 )" ) /)
1. 3/)) *"&"& )!*)<- 4"*% !*))"
2. !0,.,3 ) *"!0"?/) 3 )"
)"
3. ?.") +*-/)#1>;"(3%)"
Steers (1977: 46) 1&*"2+!*))" ?&*"#)"
2+!*))" 1 3 /)
1. (3/)) *"&" & ),<- &*% )")"
2. !0,&,.,3 ) *"!0"? /) 3 )")"
3. ?) *"&".") +*(3%)")"
).4& Staw and Salancik (1977 )"?;", Mowday et al., 1982: 24-25) **
&%"& %2+)"% )" &%!% "*)&!!*"
/)
*%!% ";#2+:!% (Vehavioral Commitment) *",1.* :!%)"") *"1 ..*,-"2+!%) +*
)" /),0!.:!%&"))>;"2+ 4. !%)"
!)"!1 >;"(2!*):!%.%!, -" -/))*1*
:!%(!-!% >;"!%.2**)&0(!"
:!%)"
, !/" ,- '(
/)%2+!*))" & %2,"..!*))" 3*1.
%3- *1*1".4
Steers (1977: 54) 1**2+!*))" 4 *"2!*))!"
(Absenteeism) >;"2% !*"A * -3%)" .2+!*))"
+"&&)")!"!"
Greeberg and Baron (1995: 176) 1**2+!*))" * ..
2+!*))" &!!*" .&!!*",/)")"" >;"*.4
*"2,--0*2+!*))" .2!*):!%")" /)
1. ..2+!*))" ,+".&." &))
",!
2. 2+!*))" .= ,,.**,%
!*"A ,+" "4 ;"(.-"*..2+!*))" +" 4!0 ,*"() *".
3. ..2+,")" 4 " &1*%
. ",-*
. (2529: 97) 1**2+!*))" 1+*2.= .
%=%)")" ".4
1. "..+;2+) *"&%" .&..**,%)"
)" ) +*,+"
2. "..+;2+) *"+" .?) *"&. "") +*
)" !*)1 /)")")" ,-<- >;"!)"/),=
3. ".2+!*))" &/),= ,<- )")"
.2+) *"!*)" -0*"/)-">;"!? 3 )"
,-?;"<- 10
4. ".2+!*))" !0,.,3 ),"
,-)" &.2,-@%!%") +*,.-/))/
&%. 2+!*))" ".*&"! ;"1*
2+!*))" - ?;" !%,">;"&"?;"+;&:!% (-;"
. )""..!*))" >;"&",--0*.!0,, )*!)"(
*-;")")" &.!)".(3%)")" &).,3
?)"!)"/) 3 )")" &2+% -0*&%)" Steers (
&%.*,.;#*!) *"..) +* (&%.*2+!*) )" ) 3 4.2!*):!%"-/)1* 1&*
1. ))"
2. ,3?/))"
3. !)"(3%)")"
!"# #1
2+% 1"% .. )";#4".41".4 !"# #1 )* '+!%
Golembiewski and Sum (1990: 35-43) 1;#?;"3.%!," (QWL) ..2!*)'"&0*!) *" 231 /)%- 0 4 (QWL) 1&* 1) .)%,")"" 2) )"3*""2*) 3) -",2" & 4) ;"), ,"2;#* .)%,")"" &)"3*"
"2*).2) *"!*)'"&0,"
)"
Chaipol (1989) 1;#?;"3.%!,"* . . + )""3.%!,",%#)% %#. %#)"1 .@%!%",1 2;#* %#)%.3.%!".+"*
%#)"1 ,* *!)& %#1 .3.%!+"*%#.,
) 4" 3 * 1*.&!!*") *". "?%!%,) ,
" *,+)"2+")"1 ,."4" 3 * * ) ," .2!)&( ) .,3.%!
" . ") *"..= " 3/)3!% ;#&)
",%#4" 3 * &+,3.%!"
% (2538) 1;#3.%!," )") -% . 284 /)"/).,3,% (&)?.2+% 1";4)".#(
&/)!) * 3.%!")") -% . ) +*
,. &/)%&!** *!)&. !%=&. ") '
?)" ?)" -&","
+"" -*"3.%!" &. )"= "
*,-*) +* ,. -%"&).) &*"% * 1*.*"% &=+,)" *,-** 1*), %- e ,%2&!%!2@%!%")")
)#(2539)1;#3.%!,")"&"","")!- )%0)% : ;#. *%#%.& (1 ) """)% *
".3.%!"4",%!%&%!% *) ," ..2!*) 3.%!")"&"" /) = 2+"3 ,%!% *) !%=
&)," ..21&* = 2+"3 &
" ..2!*)3.%!",%!%.**,)"
1&* = 2+"3&) * ..2!*)3.%!",%!%
)"3.%! 1&* = 2+"3&) * ..2!*)3.%!"
,%!%)"3.%! 1&* = 2+"3
1 (2539) 1;#3.%!," #..!*) 3.%!," &:!%(3%..)")" )"3 :!%* 3:!% .3.%!,"
" .:!%(3%..)")" +" &* 3.%!,
" 1&2 3 - = ,-* "
%-".(=&) )"3*".12*).(*!.
= ":!%(3%..)")"
" (2541) 1;#3.%!")"3*"1vv< 2%!&-*"
1 *!) *".,3,;# /) 3*"1vv< "#& %/)"
225 /)"/).,3,0)+ 1&* &)?. #*
&)?3.%!,">;"&*"( 2 * 1&* &)?.,3&
Rating Scale )" Likert &&)? d /),-2+!)&"%-0*
3.%!,") +*," #*.= 3.%!
," &.) 3.%!,". /) !&-*"
," & "
: (2541) 1;#3.%!")""!)/)"%
%#%1 (-3) * "!)/)"%.3.%!
")""" !&-*" & ,@%!%" .2!*) 3.%!")""!)/)"% * ) ?)"
!&. 1%# 1*.2!*)3.%!")""!) /)"%
!"# #1 ,- '(
Hrebiniak and Alutto (1972) 1;#2+!*))" * )" %".
%"+",+">;"%"+",1&* "%/) % 2 3 !)&,+&!*"A ?;"
-,".?!))"!)"/4$)""1 ".
&.2+)" ;4
=. (2532: 146) 1;#2+!*))" : ;#2+%---
&2/. *)"/)>.! 1 * ) ;# )"".
2%3)#". .**,%- ),-,"
#)"".!%!*)= 2+)/ *3/)?/))")" %.
3) "1/)*"4"-.= 2+!*))"
% (2536: 96-97) 1;#= -*"2+!*))"
#* #)"" #)")" &#)"
")"2+%-,)" )3 *!) *"(2+%-%# 258
* #* #)"" #)")" &#)"
")"2+%-.= 2+!*))" !&.
2+. /) )"" +;*!. = 2+*"
.**,%-" +;& ", .",%# &
+;*. !%=,%.3) >;"4"-.4)=% &
2)"2+!*))" 1) 43.11
@ (2540: 62-64) 1;# ..2!*)2+!*))" )""
"3&"%33. ! %#+>.! 1 (-3) 235
*.**,%-" = 2+"3 &= /)
*".= 3%"2+!*))" */) "..**,
%-" &.= ..2+"3/)*".2+!*) )" +"
% (2542: 147-150) 1;#,/)" 3.%!,"2+
!*))" : ;##% ?"% *!) *" /) ",#
142 * ".2+!*))" ,+" ,0#**
) ;# .&!!*",-.2+!*))" &!!*" 3.%!
," .= "2+!*))" &/)%-
??) -+ %%=. Stepwise * . )"&( 3 !*)" +
"" ("*) -&"," ) .)*
2+!*))" )""#%-% ?"%
(2542: 103-104) 1;#,/)"+3.%!"
2+!*))" )""%#1%4 )%. (1 ) 329
* "..) ) " &&.2+!*))" +"*"
..) ) ) ") & & "* "..3.%!".(%"&
-"+".2+!*))" +"*"..3.%!"4".(%"&
-"! "..3.%!".(%"&.-"!*") . 2+!*))" +"*"..3.%!".-0%"&-"!*)
3 (2543: 144) 1;#,/)" )" &2+)" )"
"%# %)! (1 ) 166 1**". )
;# ?" )!"%/) &-* "."&!!*".
2+!*))" !*" ,".&!!*".2+!*) )" !*"
!&% :#@. "% .. )" !))+/4$)"
%#.,3/);# 2+% 1()&%,% 4".4 /) 1. 3.%!," ) 8 1&*
1.1 1*!)&.. ")& !%=
1.2 "..) &*"%
1.3 -&","
1.4 ),'?)"!)"
1.5 +""-/)"*
1.6 %=%)""
1.7 -*"3.%!"3.%!)/
1.8 ( 3 !*)"
2. 2+!*))" ) 3 1&*
2.1 ))"
2.2 ,3?/))"
2.3 !)"(3%)")"
!/% !"#
!&)% !&!
!?" )"% .doc
*
-
- )
- ?
- ) "
- ;#
3.%!,"
- 1*!)&.. ")
& !%=
- "..)
&*"%
- -&",
"
- ),'?
)"!)"
- +""-/)
"*
- %=%)""
- -*"3.%!"
2+!*))"
- ))"
- ,3?
/))"
- !)"(
3%)")"
3
#!5 !"#
% 4".4( (Survey Research) /);#?;"3.%!,
"..2!*)2+)")" )"".%. %! &
!*" A &-*"-;" >;".4!)%"% ".4 + (#(
3.,3,"% 4".4 /) "@%!%.@%!%") +*,*
)!-)%0)% ,!%)!- "-=. 23 %#
" 71,000 *!) *".,3 398 &,3%=.*!) *"&
")% ,3+!/)!$)" Taro Yamane ()"?;", %" )", 2544: 14) 3/) 0.95 */) 0.05 ".4
+! n = N 1+ N(e)2
n = *!) *"
N = 34"-
e = /). )1 (0.05)
&*+! n = 71,000 = 398 1+ 71,000(0.05)2
+!"!1*!) *",&!*%# " ). !!". 1
1 *!) *""@%!%)"*)!-3%4*
)%0)% ,!%)!- "-=.
/ #+6!3 "
'
(
#(
1 %# )0).>. % )%0)% (1 ) 3,000 17
2 %# %4 )%0)% (1 ) 2,000 11
3 %# 1 &! 1vv< 3,000 17
4 %# %>;% (1 ) 1,000 6
5 %# 1> )%+ (1 ) 2,400 13
6 %# %0 (1 ) 4,000 22
7 %# v+%!;(1 ) 6,000 34
8 %# !>+3%! )%0% ) (1 ) 3,000 17 9 %# .>. &+&v)%" (1 ) 2,000 11
10 %# ! )%!. (1 ) 4,000 22
11 %# >% (1 ) 1,200 8
12 %# 1> .&) >.(1 ) 4,500 25 13 %# % 3% ". (1 ) 3,000 17
14 %# .>... 5,000 28
15 %# v+%+ (1 ) 6,500 36
16 %# ). >%!0 )%0)% (1 ) 3,000 17 17 %# )0).>. )%v). (1 ) 2,000 11 18 %# - )%!% >%)!) (1 ) 2,400 13 19 %# - )) )%0)% (1 ) 3,000 17
20 %# .. (1 ) 4,000 22
21 %# >% .vd) 3 (1 ) 1,000 6
22 %# )0!! (1 ) 1,000 6
23 %# % %%!(1 ) 4,000 22
71,000 398
66%+1% !"#
/)"/),0)+,% 4".4 2+% 1"&)?;4
&% :#. &2"% .. )" >;"&)? 3 * /)
*. 1 &)?)+. #*)"" 1&* )
? ) " &;# 5 )
*. 2 &)?. 3.%!,"(&)?.2+%
";4 &% :#.)" Richard E. Walton &2"% .. )"
,3!**)" Likert >;"#)")?) ).(3%"
&3%",-!),#%* 5 .e ,-& /)&
- )"&)? 1&* -0 ) *" %" -0 1*&*, 1*-0 1*-0 ) *" %" 29 ) )
1. 1*!)&.. ")& !%=
2. ?"..) &*"%
3. -&","
4. ),'?)"
5. +""-/)"*
6. %=%)""
7. -*"3.%!"3.%!)/
8. ( 3 !*)"
*. 3 (&)?. 2+!*))" (&)?.4.2+%
";4)" &% :#.)" Steers &2"% .. )" ,3!
**)" Likert >;"#)")?) ).(3%"&
3%",-!),#%* 5 .e ,-& /)&- )"&)? 1&* -0 ) *" %" -0 1*&*, 1*-0 1*-0 ) *"
%" 19 ) )
1. ))"
2. ,3?/))"
3. !)"(3%)")"
1-
0)+ ,3&)? (Questionnaire ) 398 3 *"
&)?"1#. 1 " ,&!*%#,*)!-3%4*
)%0)% ,!% )!- "-=. !%!*)*"-"
1*) &-""!)&)?. ) & ,- &!*%#
*" "2+%
! 1-
)+.1!)&)?%- ,3&)%!) 0+ /)-*?%!%&%- )+ ".4
!&)?&,-&
1. + &?+!)")"&)?
2. &)?3.%!," (!** (Rating Scale) !&!)" Likert &*")&!*)( 5 /) -0 ) *" %" -0 1*&*, 1*-0 & 1*-0 ) *" %"
e ,-&
,-&&*"))(& -)?3%" &)?3%"
".4
- )?3%" (Positive) &)"!) ".4 -0 ) *" %" 5 &
-0 4 &
1*&*, 3 &
1*-0 2 &
1*-0 ) *" %" 1 &
- )?3%" (Negative) &)"!) ".4 1*-0 ) *" %" 5 &
1*-0 4 &
1*&*, 3 &
-0 2 &
-0 ) *" %" 1 &
&- &
2+% &*"3.%!,"( 3 1&* 3.%!,
"! 3.%!,"" &3.%!,"+"
>;"13*"&+! ".4
3*"& = &+" _ &!
-% 4".413*"&* 5-1
3 = 1.33
%- "*,-?-3*"&)"&!*3.%!,
"1".4
& 1.00 _ 2.33 - ?;" .3.%!,",!
& 2.34 _ 3.67 - ?;" .3.%!,","
& 3.68 _ 5.00 - ?;" .3.%!,",+"
3. &)?2+!*))" (!** (Rating Scale)
!&!)" Likert &*")&!*)( 5 /) -0 ) *" %"
-0 1*&*, 1*-0 & 1*-0 ) *" %"
)<% %1
,-&&*"))(,-& -)?3%" &)?3%"
".4
- )?3%" (Positive) &)"!) ".4 -0 ) *" %" 5 &
-0 4 &
1*&*, 3 &
1*-0 2 &
1*-0 ) *" %" 1 &
- )?3%" (Negative) &)"!) ".4 1*-0 ) *" %" 5 &
1*-0 4 &
1*&*, 3 &
-0 2 &
-0 ) *" %" 1 &
#
2+% &*"2+!*))" ( 3 1&* 2+!*))"
! 2+!*))" " &2+!*))" +" >;"1 3*"&+! ".4
3*"& = &+" _ &!
-% 4".413*"&* 5-1
3 = 1.33
%- "*,-?-3*"&)"&!*2+!*))"
1".4
& 1.00 _ 2.33 - ?;" .2+!*))" ,!
& 2.34 _ 3.67 - ?;" .2+!*))" ,"
& 3.68 _ 5.00 - ?;" .2+!*))" ,+"
!!%+1% !"#
1. ?%!%%- 3%" ( Descriptive Analytical Statistics) ,3
#)")+.0*3.;# 1&*
- *) (Percentage) ,3,%- )+1 - *. (Mean) ,3,&- )")+!*" A - *. "!$ (Standard Deviation) &"#
)")+
2. ?%!%%- 3%") ( Inferential Analysis Statistics) 1&*
- )&!!*")"*. %! ?%!% t-Test ,3, )&!!*"-*"*. )"!&)% 2 *
- %- &". (One - Way ANOVA ) ,3, )&!!*"-*"*. )"!&)%* 2 *
- -= . (Pearson Product Moment Correlation) ;#
= )"!&.()%!*)
-* "?%!%.,3,%- 4".4-. 0.05
4
, ! 1-
2+% 1)2%- )+( 3 *1&*
( 1 2%- )+ *)""
( 2 2%- 3.%!," 2+!*))" )"
"
( 3 2%- )+/))!%$%
( 1 , ! 1-""#('
2 &) )" *)"" &!
) ? ) " &;#
(n = 398)
""#( " () 1#
3 168 42.2
-%" 230 57.8
)
!* 25 5 107 26.9
25-30 5 184 46.2
* 30 5 107 26.9
2 (()
(n = 398)
""#( " () 1#
?
220 55.3 172 43.2
- *" 6 1.5
) "
!* 5 5 230 57.8
5 _ 10 5 100 25.1
* 10 5 68 17.1
;#
) * .6 41 10.3
.6 -/) 3. 143 35.9
. 111 27.9
%!. 99 24.9
+"*%!. 4 1.0
398 100
!". 2 *)"".(*!) *",;# 398 1"!*)1.4
* ",)" (-%" 230 %() 57.8 &(
3 168 %() 42.2
) * ",)" .) -*" 25-30 5 184 %() 46.2 .) !* 25 5 107 %() 26.9 .) * 30 5 107 %() 26.9
? * ",)" .?( 220 %(
) 55.3 )"".? 172 %() 43.2 &.?(
- *" 6 %() 1.5
) " * ",)" .) " !* 5 5 230 %() 57.8 )"".) "-*" 5 _ 10 5 100 %() 25.1 &.) "
* 10 5 68 %() 17.1
;# * ",)" .;#.6 -/) 3. 143 %() 35.9 )""/) . 111 %() 27.9 %
!. 99 %() 24.9 ) * .6 41 %() 10.3 &
.;#+"*%!. 4 %() 1.0
( 2 , ! /)* '+!% ,- '( ' 3 *.
( )
X &*. "!$ (S.D.) )"&3.%!,"
3.%!," X S.D.
)* '+!% ./#
1*!)&.. ")& !%=
?"..) &*"%
-&","
),'?)"!)"
+""-/)"*
%=%)""
-*"3.%!"3.%!)/
( 3 !*)"
3.20 2.82 3.47 3.15 3.07 3.33 3.19 3.24 3.53
0.41 0.87 0.65 0.59 0.66 0.68 0.67 0.63 0.89
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
!". 3 * ",)" .3.%!," ) +*,
" .*. * 3.20 *. "!$* 0.41 &/)%
. "1-) * ( 3 !*)" ) +*," .
*. * 3.53 *. "!$* 0.89 ?"..
) &*"%) +*," .*. * 3.47 *. "
!$* 0.65 +""-/)"* ) +*,"
.*. * 3.33 *. "!$* 0.68 -*"3.%!"
3.%!)/) +*," .*. * 3.24 *. "!$*
0.63 %=%)"") +*," .*. * 3.19 *. "
!$* 0.67 -&",") +*," .
*. * 3.15 *. "!$* 0.59 ),'?)"
!)") +*," .*. * 3.07 *. "!$* 0.66 &
1*!)&.. ")& !%=) +*," .*. * 2.82
*. "!$* 0.87
4 *. ( X ) *. "!$ (S.D.) )"&2+!*))" )"
"%#
3.%!," X S.D.
,- '( ./#
))"
,3?/))"
!)"(3%)")"
3.34 3.35 3.61 3.05
0.50 0.62 0.66 0.62
"
"
"
!". 4 * ",)" .2+!*))" ) +*,
" .*. * 3.34 *. "!$* 0.50 &/)%
* ,3?/))" ) +*," .*. * 3.61 * . "!$* 0.66 ))" ) +*," .*. *
3.35 *. "!$* 0.62 &!)"(3%)")" ) +*,
".*. * 3.05 *. "!$* 0.62 ( 3 , ! 1-'6/!$ !"#
!$ 1 ".. *&!!*" .2+!*))"
&!!*"
!%$. 1.1 "..&!!*".2+!*))" &!!*"
5 . . *. 2+!*))" )"" &!
n X S.D. t p
2+!*))"
3 -%"
168 230
3.36 3.32
0.48 0.52
0.86 0.389
!". 5 . . *. 2+!*))" )""&
! 1**"..&!!*" .2+!*))" 4" &!!*"
) *". "?%!%
!%$. 1.2 "..) &!!*" .2+!*))" &!!*"
6 . . *. 2+!*))" )"" &!)
!& X S.D. F p
2+!*))"
!* 25 5 25 _ 30 5
* 30 5
3.33 3.28 3.43
0.57 0.51 0.39
2.89 0.056
!". 6 . . *. 2+!*))" )""&!) 1*
*"..) &!!*" .2+!*))" &!!*" ) *".
"?%!%
!%$. 1.3 "..?&!!*" .2+!*))"
&!!*"
7 . . *. 2+!*))" )"" &!
?
!& X S.D. F p
2+!*))"
- *"
3.39 3.27 3.36
0.48 0.52 0.35
2.41 0.09
!". 7 . . *. 2+!*))" )""&!
? 1**"..?.&!!*" .2+!*))"
&!!*") *". "?%!%
!%$. 1.4 "..) "&!!*" .2+!*))" &!!*"
8 . . *. 2+!*))" )"" &!)
"
!& X S.D. F p
2+!*))"
!* 5 5 5 _ 10 5
* 10 5
3.34 3.24 3.45
0.53 0.49 0.37
3.469 0.032*
* . "?%!% . 0.05
!". 8 . . *. 2+!*))" )""&
!) " *"..) "&!!*" .2+!*))" &!!*") *".
"?%!%
/))/). . *. 2+( +* %=. Scheffe 2 . . &""!". 9
9 . . &!!*"*. )"2+!*))" )"".
.) "&!!*"( +*
*. !& X 1 2 3
1 !* 5 5 3.34 - 0.25 0.31
2 5-10 5 3.24 - 0.034*
3 * 10 5 3.45
* . "?%!% . 0.05
!". 9 * "..) " 5-10 5 .2+!*))"
&!!*""..) " * 10 5 ) *". "?%!%. 0.05 *
"..) " !* 5 5 .2+!*))" 1*&!!*""..) " 5- 10 5 &*"..) " !* 5 5 .2+!*))" 1*&!!*"
"..) "* 10 5
!%$. 1.5 "..;#&!!*" .2+!*))"
&!!*"
10 . . *. 2+!*))" )"" &!
;#
!& X S.D. F p
2+!*))"
) * .6 .6 -/) 3.
. %!.
+"*%!.
3.30 3.41 3.21 3.40 3.02
0.50 0.48 0.53 0.47 0.36
3.45 0.009*
* . "?%!% . 0.05
!". 10 . . *. 2+!*))" )""&
!;# *"..;#&!!*" .2+!*))"
&!!*") *". "?%!
/))/). . *. 2+!*))" )""( +*
%=. Scheffe 2. . &""!". 11
11 . . &!!*"*. )"2+!*))" )"
"..;#&!!*"( +*
*. ;# X 1 2 3 4 5
1 ) * .6 3.30 - 0.79 0.92 0.86 0.89 2 .6 -/) 3. 3.41 - 0.041* 1.00 0.67
3 . 3.21 - 0.10 0.96
4 %!. 3.40 - 0.69
5 +"*%
!.
3.02
* . "?%!% . 0.05
!". 11 *"..;# .6 -/) 3. .2+!*) )" &!!*"";# . ) *". "?%!%. 0.05 *
"..;# ) * .6 .2+!*))" 1*&!!*"".
.;# .6 -/) 3., ., %!. & +"*%!. *"..
;# .6 -/) 3. .2+!*))" 1*&!!*""..
;# %!. &+"*%!. *"..;# . . 2+1*&!!*"" %!. &"..;# +"*
%!. *"%!. .2+1*&!!*""
;# +"*%!.
!%$. 2 3.%!,".= 2+!*))"
12 *-= -*"3.%!,"2+!*))" )"
"
2+!*))"
r 3.%!,"
"?%!% (P)
0.497 0.000**
** . "?%!%. 0.01
!". 12 *-= -*"3.%!,"2+!*) )" )""* 3.%!")"".= "
2+!*))" ) *". "?%!%
13 2)!%$"%
!%$"% (1!
!%$%
1*(1!
!%$%
!$ 1 ".. *
&!!*" 2+!*))" &!!*"
-
- )
- ?
- ) "
- ;#
!$ 2 3.%!,"
.= 2+!*))"
5
*! #, 1
, !"#
;#% /)" 3.%!,"!*)2+!*))" )"" .
!?" /);#3.%!," &2+!*))"
;#. . 3.%!,"2+!*))" &!#*
).4 ;#= -*"3.%!,"&2+!*))"
,;#% 4".4 2+% 1,3*3 .("@%!%.
@%!%") +*,*)!-)%0)% ,!%)!- "-
=. 23 %# " 71,000 &*!) *" 1*
!) *" 398 &,3&)?(/)"/),0)+ 4 )+12 ,3)%!) &0+ 2% ?1".4
""#(
*)"*!) *",% 4".41&* * "*,-*
(-%" 230 %() 57.8 .) -*" 25 - 30 5 184 %(
) 46.2 .? 220 %() 55.3 .) "!* 5 5 230 %() 57.8 &.;#.6 -/) 3. 143 %(
) 35.9
/)* '+!%
".3.%!" ) +*," ( X = 3.20)
&/)%,&!*?. "1-) 1".4 ( 3 !*)
" ) +*,"( X = 3.53) ?"..) &*"%
) +*," ( X = 3.47) +""-/)"*) +*
," ( X = 3.33) -*"3.%!"3.%!)/ ) +*,
" ( X =3.24) %=%)"") +*," ( X =3.19) -&
"," ) +*," ( X =3.15) ),'?)"
!)" ) +*," ( X = 3.07) & 1*!)&.. ")& !%= ) +*
," ( X = 2.82) / ,- '(
& ".2+!*))" ," ( X =3.34)
&%,&!*?. "1-) 1".4
,3?/))" *".2+!*))" ) +*,
" ( X = 3.61) ))" * ".2+!*))" ) +*,
" ( X = 3.35) &!)"(3%)")" * ".
2+!*))" ) +*," ( X = 3.05) , /!$
%- . . &!!*"-*" !*" A /) 2@%!%"
)"" >;". 4"- 3 !%$ *
!$ 1 ".. *&!!*" 2+!*))" &!!*"
.3.%!".&!!*" &*"(!%$ *) 5 ".4
!%$. 1.1 !&)%/)" * 1*(!!%$%
!%$. 1.2 !&)%/)".) * 1*(!!%$%
!%$. 1.3 !&)%/)"? * 1*(!!%$%
!%$. 1.4 !&)%/)") " * (!!%$%
!%$. 1.5 !&)%/)";# * (!!%$%
!$ 2 3.%! 3.%!,".= 2+!*) )" 2% 4".4 * 3.%!".=
2+!*))" ) *". "?%!%. 0.01 *! #,
;#% /)" 3.%!,)" !*)2+)" )"" 2+% ) ))% . 2% ".4
/). . *. 2+!*))" )"",*)!-3%4*
)%0)% ,!%)!- "-=. ! * 1&*
) ? ) " &;# ?)=% 21".4 '&
2)!%$* )"".&!!*" .2+!*))"
1*&!!*" ) *". "?%!%
/)%- 2+!*))" . . * "..
&!!*".2+!*))" 1*&!!*" 4".4)(*"4"-%"&
3 ) *".+;+%,,)" -/) .%!*" A .1-/) ,-".*",,3?..) +*) *"!0. /),-%-, -."&,"1 0,- ),?)" *.
)"*4(-%"-/)3 ;",-"4"-%"&3 "!0
?)"! >;"))""% )" % (2546) 1;#2+!*) )" )""@%!%,"")!-).&/)" ,!
%)!--/) *1*.&!!*")"2+!*))" )""4"
(3 &-%"
#
2)!%$* ) )"".&!!*" 1*.2,-2+
!*))" )""&!!*" ) *". "?%!%
/)%- 2+!*))" . . ) )"" *
"..) &!!*" .2+!*))" 1*&!!*" )/)" *"
-*.41*")" -;" 1?;"&"@%!%")")"
&<- ,%")")" .1+*0,
";"?*?,-)" 1) *"!0. /)*),-% 3 &*
)" ) *"+" "4 "1*%+;/)-* " ;"") +*
)" !*)1, ";",-2+!*))" >;"))"
"% )" . (2550) 1;#= 3.%!,"2+!*) )" )""@%!%,""2%! !,1 *1*.
&!!*")"2+!*))" )""..) &!!*"
* '
2)!%$* ?)"".&!!*" 1*.2 ,-2+!*))" &!!*" ) *". "?%!%
/)%- 2+!*))" . . ?)""
* "..?&!!*" .2+!*))" 1*&!!*" */)
"..)&.!)" ",)3.&1*!)",-)" !)"
" ,-!)"&) 1/) ).4#$%
%",-.&!*""& -/)).!-/)..!)")2+)/&"
:!%.2+!*))" +";4 ) *" %"?) *"&", )<- &*% )")" &!0,.* ) *"
/) 3 )")" *. "1*1 0.!)".?&
," &/).2"&1 ))" 0,-%
+%,,!)"&*,-)" % ;"1**"..?
&!!*" .2+!*))" &!!*"
#
2)!%$* ) ")"".&!!*" .2,- 2+!*))" .&!!*" ) *". "?%!%
/)%- 2+)"" ".) ".2+!*) )" +"*"..) ") >;"))"2"% )" Mowday & Lyman (1982) 1** ,@%!%",)" .2"!*)2+)"
*/) "..) "* ,@%!%"* & .*% ,"
* 2+!*))" * ))""% )" =' (2543) 1;#
2+!*))" ;#."%# 2%!e &*)" 2;#
* ,".2!*)2+!*))" )"" >;""..)
"."= */)*"&2+"3 ,-.2+
!*))" +" 1*) 1%!&!&"",-*,)" )/
/ &C 3
2)!%$* ;#)"".&!!*" .2,- 2+!*))" .&!!*" ) *". "?%!%
/)%- 2+)"" "..;#+".
2+!*))" ) .-"!*)%".1)" *)"+" &/)1*
(1!.!)"-"10%2%-" ,-.2+!*))" ) >;"
))""% )" = (2541 >;"1;#?;"2+!*))" )"",
""2%!4) 2;#"** "..;#!*".
2+!*))" &!!*"
/). . = -*" 3.%!,"2+!*) )" )"" * 3.%!," )"".=
"2+!*))" )"" ) *". "?%!% >;"-
* ?".3.%!,"+" 2+!*))" 0+" /)"
3.%!," ?) +*,.+""0+;.2+!*))" +"!1
,-"1*!)". "-/)))&!*?)"3.%!,
") +*,!0,-"+;1*;"), 1*%2+!*))" >;"
))"2% )" % (2542) &2"% )" (2550) * 3.%!4" 8 /) 1*!)&.. ")& !%=
?"..) &*"% -&",
" ),'?)"!)" +""-/)"
* %=%)"" -*"3.%!"3.%!)/ &
( 3 !*)" 4".4 /)")" )!*" A )"3.%!,"
4" 8 .*"2&,-"%2+!*))" &0)"
)"
1
1" , !"#
2% * 3.%!," & .=
2+!*))" ) *". "?%!% >;"2% .1.-- ;".
))&-2.1% /),-".2+!*))" ;4".4 1. 1*!)&.. ")& !%= )" *
*!)&!?,3,--!&-*" (Performance Pay) /),-))"
?)"" >;"!)",3&%2..!3.4) *"3 Key Performance Indicators (KPI) &&"2%,-" /)"+?;"*"&
*"%)"" >;"(d4 %,-%)!%!*)")*"2,-"%
2+!*))"
2. ?"..) &*"% : ! 5)"%#4 %#;"?;"%"!*)/)"!&
3* ?..-))" /)%"..&*"
!.))"& ?;""" ?.")
%#!*" A *"%"+-.,?."
3. -&"," : %#,3%=./),4""!"&
")),-"?;"%!%!, )3. (Career Development in Practical) /),-"+;?;",,.")" 4"+&".
,-"+;*. &1)"@%!%",-.)/ ,3%=.-. "
(Job Rotation)
4. ),'?)"!)" : ,-* "!*" A )"%#
-+&,-&!*-* ".3-* ") *") /)4" /)d),-
",!*" A 1*&"%-0 )4" "-&).%;4 4".4/),-"&!*1.)!)"&)-,-2+%-1
&&1 ,"2+%-0?")!*" A /),-"1 '+&+.13* &-)"!1)."-;"
5. +""-/)"* : )" *"%%
*)"",-;4 /),-",)" .+;(-;". (.
. %"*)&")),+)"*= ,!*""- /)-*) -),-".+;(). "(+&(.*
"
6. %=%)"" : )" *"%,-",?;"%=%*
(/)"?)?+"# ),+)"% =)")"
/),-"+;?;"1%=%*)")" .4
7. -*"3.%!"3.%!)/ : )" ,-
" ,-"?@%!%"1) *"!0?&%2"
2" 1*/)"&- "(0&-.. ".,-
"!)""*" "*?/)(*!)""
8. ( 3 !*)" : )" .%!*" A ..#( 3
!*)"4""!"&")) )&%!*" A ,-" /)(
!,-"%+%,.1*")" .4 1'6 !"#(0
1. );#?;"!&)/ A .*.22+!*))" )"
"1;4 1&* !% )" :!%" 2+)"
)" 3/)),!)" %-& " (!
2. ;#. . -*"*3..!&-*"".&!!*"*
3.;# 3* "%- /)2. . *))"-/)
&!!*") *"1
3. ,% 4"!*)1 ;#3.%!,",*=%!*" A /)2;#.1. . *))"-/)&!!*") *"1-*"=%&!*
)
)
%3. 2540. ..2!*)2+!*))" )"""3&
"%33.! %#+>.! 1 (-3). % %= % -e%! %3%!% )!-&)" e%!%
-% =! .
33 )%. 2535. 'D! % . "-: + /)%".
!% 3:=%g. 2530. !&:!%! .,')" . , ))3%3 ')" -* . 4, - 226. .: "%
-% ==%3.
% %%+. 2542. E3.%!,"2+!*))" : ;#.
#%-% ?"%. % %= %-e%! %!%
)!-&)" e%!% -% =! .
=. .==%!. 2532. 2+!*))" : ;#.2+%---
&2/. *)"/)>.! 1 . % %= %-e%! %!%
)!-&)" e%!% -% =! .
)#%#$ . 2550. )")" 3.%!,"&
2+!*))" )""@%!% : ;#. "")!- 2%! "? ! ,!%)!-.. % %= %-e%!
%!% )!- e%!% -% .)=..
: .. . 2541. ;#3.%!")""!)/)"% %#
%1 (-3). % %= %-e%! %!%
)!-&)" e%!% -% #!! .
1 %"-3. 2539. ;##..!*)3.%!,"&
:!%(3%..)")" : ;#.3:!%.
% %= %-e%! %!% )!-&)" e%!%
-% =! .
) %!!%.=. 2538. ..)%=%!*)2+)"+"!*))" ;#
.)!-%") , < &, %#$ . % %= % -e%! %!% )!-&)" e%!%
-% =! .
"3 3) +*. 2537. "-%"% . "-. % ). ! . -%!"# . 2542. 3.%!,"2+!*))" )""
%#1%4 )%. (1 ) . % %= %-e%!
%!% )!- e%!% -% #!! .
. - . 2529. !!5!, . % 4".2. "-.
% ). ! .
% ". 2546. 3.%!,"2+!*))" )""
@%!%,")!-). &/)" ,!)!-
-/). % %= %-e%! %!% )!-&)"
e%!% -% .)".
3 )"1+ . 2543. )" &2+!*))" . % %= % -e%! %!% )!- e%!% -% #!! .
% )*)&. 2538. 3.%!,")") -% ..
% %= %-e%! %!% e%!% " -% .
% % . 2545. = -*"3.%!," 2+!*) )" &2@%!%")"","")!-)%0)% .
% %= %-e%! %!% )!-&)" e%!%
-% #!! .
. =.+. 2550. 3.%!,"&2+!*))" )""
@%!%,"" !,1 . % %= %-e%!
%!% )!- e%!% -% .) -".
!% ")). 2540. 1 )* '+!/% . Productivity World. 2 (-
%"- 2540): 39-40.
%. 2537. 'F . % 4". 3. "- : + %%3 , -% -)1 .
" !d!. 2541. 3.%!")"3*"1vv< 2%!&-*"
1 . % %= %-e%! %!% )!-&)" e%!
% -% #!! .
= @%. 2541. = -*";"),,"&2+!*) )" )""""2%!4). % %= %-e%!
%!% )!- e%!% -% #!! .
% ' . 2536. E= -*"2!*))" #*
#" #)" &#)" ")"
2+%-,)" )3. % %= %-e%! %!% )!- e%!% -% #!! .
)# "%. 2539. 3.%!")"&"")!-).0)% : ;#
.*%# %%& (1 ) """)%. % %= % -e%! %!% )!- e%!% -% #!! . Bluestone, I. 1997. Organization Citizenship Behavior Among Hospital Employees: A
Multidimensional Analysis Involving Job Satisfaction and Organization
Commitment. Hospital and Health Service administration. 42 (summer 1997) : 221- 262.
Bruce, W.M. and J.W.Blackburn. 1992. Balancing Job Satisfaction & Performance: A Guide for Human Resource Profesionals. Westprt: Quorum Books.
Chaipol, H. 1989. A Comparative Study of Thai Middle Managersl Perception of their Quality of Worklife in America-Owned and Thai Owned Companys Operating in Thailand. USA: United State International University.
Cherington, J.D. 1989. Organizational Behavior: The management of Individual and Organization Performance. Boston: Allyn and Barcon Inc.
Dressler, G. 1991. Personal Human Resource Management. 5th ed. New Jersey: Prentice- Hall Inc.
Golembiewski, R.T. and B. Sun. 1990. EQWL Improves Worksite Quality: Success rate in a Targe Pool of Studys. Human Resource Development Quarterly. 1 (Spring 1990): 35- 43.
Greeberg,J. and R.B. Baron. 1995. Behavior in Organization. 5th ed. New Jersey. Prentice- Hall Inc.
Herbiniak,L. and J. Alutto. 1972. Personal and Roll-Related Factors in The Development of Organizationl Commitment. Administrative Science Quarterly. 17 (December 1972):
555-572.
Huse, E.F. and T.G. Cummings. 1985. Organizational Development and Change. 3 rded.
Minnesota: West Publishing.
Kanter, R.M. 1968. Commitment and Social Organization: A Study of Commitment Mechanism in Utopian communities. American Sociological Review. 33 (August 1986): 499-517.
Luthans, F. 1992. Organizational Behavior. 6th ed. Singapore: Mcgraw-Hill Company.
Merton, H.C. 1997. A Look at Factors Affecting the Quality of Worklife. Monthly Labour Review. 10 (October 1977): 64.
Mowday, R.T., L.W.Porter and R.M.Steerr. 1982. Employee-Organization Linkages: The Psychology Commitment, Absenteeism and Turnover. New York: Academic Press.
Schuler, R.S., N.J. Beutell and S.A. Youngblood. 1989. Effective Personal Management. 3rd ed. Minnesota: Nest Publishing Company.
Sheldon, M. 1971. An Empirical Analysis of Organizational Identification. Academy of Management Journal. 14 (March 1971): 149-226.
Shrovan, D.J. 1989. Quality of Work Life : perspectives for business. Massachusetts : . The public sector.
Walton, R.E. 1973. Quality of Worklife: What is It? Sloan Management Review. 15 (Fall 1973): 11-12.
Steer, R.M. 1977. Organizational Effectiveness: A Behavioral View. Satana, Monica, California: Goodyear Publishing Company.
Steer, R.M. and L.W. Porter. 1983. Motivation and Work Behavior. 3rd ed. New York:
Mcgraw-Hill Inc.
* ,
%+1% !"#
6
)* '+!% ,- '( ' % ( +!y(
!z ! %! "/5 1 #1)"2+!)&)?
3.4&" /)"- √ ", [ ] -/)!%)",3*)"*"!(%"
)"*
1.
[ ] 3 [ ] -%"
2. ) ... 5 .../)...
3. ?
[ ] [ ] [ ] - *"
4. ) ", ... 5 ... /) ...
5. ;#4+" ...
2 &)?. 3.%!,"
+y" %)&!*)!*)1.4**-0 -/)1* ,,
&/)"- √ ",3*)"*"-").!"%-0)"
* (!)))
%-0
) )? -0
) *" %"
-0 1*&*, 1*-0
1*-0 ) *"
%"
1 *!)&.1.. ")
*,3* ,3.%!
2 *;"),*!)&.1
"
3 %#.* *!)&..
!%=
4 *!)&.11**
*)"*..,-%#
5 *),.%#,-.!
5"
6 *),#
) ,%#
7 ?.")"*1*-,- .2. !*)
8 %#."&2. <)"
%!%!*" A /)<)") )""
9 ".*2%3)1*1,-*
1+,-* A
10 *1),,3+
?,@%!%") *"!0.
%-0
) )? -0
) *" %"
-0 1*&*, 1*-0
1*-0 ) *"
%"
11 *+;**1",%#.
"
12 *3/)*?-, )3..
) +*,
13 *.),&"5/)&1 -..>>)1. ""
14 %#d),-*
",-*,3,"1 15 *?&1-1) *"
-1 !)"
16 *) 4".* 1)%,
".2%3)1 !)"
17 *1),"&2"
*2+%-
18 )" )"*,-
"*
19 3%,)" .3* -/)>;"
&
20 "*,-*;"?;"
)"*-
21 *?+* /)"*!.1*. )"
"--"
22 /)*",-%=%*
>;"&
23 %#d),-")" 1 /)1*1(=
