• Tidak ada hasil yang ditemukan

View of ผลของคลอเฮกซิดีนต่อการแสดงออกของยีนและการกระตุ้นการทำงานของเอนไซม์เอ็มเอ็มพี-2 ในเซลล์เอ็นยึดปริทันต์ของมนุษย์

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2023

Membagikan "View of ผลของคลอเฮกซิดีนต่อการแสดงออกของยีนและการกระตุ้นการทำงานของเอนไซม์เอ็มเอ็มพี-2 ในเซลล์เอ็นยึดปริทันต์ของมนุษย์"

Copied!
12
0
0

Teks penuh

(1)

ړx›|z“›ªœw€¡†¢Ù‡h›wŸ‘«˜†|››wx›|¢Ù«“ÝwŸ‘w‘݇¤iÙwŸ‘‰·Ÿ|ŸÙx›|

ª›Ù®€Ðª›±ª›±Ü¢­Ùª€““Ъ›±Ù£†Œ‘¡‰žÙ‡Ðx›|Ù¤—Ð

˜¡‘¡“žw—ØЇ¢‘؊ٟw¤“

‹‰zž†h›

ª›±ª›±Ü¢ªŒÒÙª›Ù®€Ð‡ž•™Ù£²|‰¢²¢‹‰‹Ÿ‰˜·ŸzžÖ­ÙwŸ‘‰·Ÿ“ŸªÙÞ³›ªÞ²›­Ù¬‘zŒ‘¡‰žÙ‡ÐwŸ‘w‘݇¤iÙwŸ‘‰·Ÿ|ŸÙ x›|ª›Ù®€Ðª›±ª›±Ü¢ªŒÒÙxž³Ù‡›Ù™Ù£²|‰¢²˜·ŸzžÖ­ÙwŸ‘z•‹z¤wŸ‘‰·Ÿ|ŸÙx›|ª›Ù®€ÐÙ¢³z“›ª›w€¡†¢ÙªŒÒ٘Ÿ‘˜·ŸzžÖ

‰¢²­i­ÙwŸ‘z•‹z¤wŸ‘ªw¡†z‘Ÿ‹}¤“¡Ù‰‘¢Ð«“Ý“†wŸ‘›žwª˜‹x›|ªÙÞ³›ªÞ²›­Ùh›|ŒŸw†i•z¤Ø˜‹ž‡¡­ÙwŸ‘‰·Ÿ“ŸªÞ³›

›hŸ|w•iŸ|x•Ÿ|‰ž³|«‹z‰¢ª‘¢«“ݪÞ³›‘Ÿz¤Ø˜‹ž‡¡­ÙwŸ‘z|›¥h­Ùh›|ŒŸwªŒÒÙª•“ŸÙŸÙ™“ž|­i«“ݐž|܋›¢w•hŸ

¢z•Ÿ˜ŸŸ‘ˆž‹ž³|wŸ‘‰·Ÿ|ŸÙx›|ª›Ù®€Ð­Ùw“¤hª›±ª›±Ü¢

•ž‡ˆ¤Œ‘ݘ|zÐ ªÜÞ²›–£w—ŸÚ“x›|z“›ªœw€¡†¢Ù‡h›wŸ‘«˜†|››wx›|¢Ù «“ÝwŸ‘w‘݇¤iÙwŸ‘‰·Ÿ|ŸÙx›|

ª›Ù®€Ðª›±ª›±Ü¢

•ž˜†¤›¤Œw‘ØЫ“Ý•¡Š¢wŸ‘ ª€““Ъ›±Ù£†Œ‘¡‰žÙ‡Ðx›|Ù¤—Ðˆ¥wª“¢³|­Ù˜ŽŸ•Ý‰¢²¢«“Ý®h¢z“›ªœw€¡†¢Ù‰¢²z•Ÿ

ªxixiهhŸ| ° ªŒÒÙª•“Ÿ ٟ‰¢ ™“ž|}Ÿwٞ³ÙªŒ“¢²ÙªŒÒٛŸ™Ÿ‘ª“¢³|ª€““Љ¢²¢€¢‘ž ‘i›“Ý ¬†¢™‘Þ›®h¢z›Ù ª›

ª“¢³|‡h›®Œ›¢w ž²•¬| –£w—Ÿz•ŸªŒÒÙÜ¡—‡h›ª€““Іi••¡Š¢ª›±‰¢‰¢ –£w—Ÿ‘݆ž‹wŸ‘«˜†|››wx›|¢Ùª›±ª›±Ü¢

ª›±ª›±Ü¢ «“݉¡ÜÐ †i••¡Š¢ª‘¢“®‰Ð›Ÿ‘Љ¢Ü¢€¢›Ÿ‘Ð «“Ý–£w—ŸwŸ‘w‘݇¤iÙwŸ‘‰·Ÿ|ŸÙx›|ª›Ù®€Ðª›±ª›±Ü¢

†i••¡Š¢®€¬w‘Ÿ`

ړwŸ‘‰†“›| z“›ªœw€¡†¢Ù‰¢²z•Ÿªxixiّi›“Ý «“Ý ¢z•ŸªŒÒÙÜ¡—‡h›ª€““Ð ¬†Ü‹•hŸ

¢zhŸª~“¢²‘i›“Ýz•Ÿ¢¢•¡‡x›|ª€““ЪŒÒّi›“Ý + «“Ý + ‡Ÿ“·Ÿ†ž‹ «‡hz“›ªœw€¡†¢Ù

‰¢²z•Ÿªxixiّi›“Ý }Ý®h¢z•ŸªŒÒÙÜ¡—‡h›ª€““Ð «“Ý­™iړ­ÙwŸ‘ž‹ž³|wŸ‘w‘݇¤iÙwŸ‘‰·Ÿ|ŸÙx›|

ª›±ª›±Ü¢ ­Ùª€““Ъ›±Ù£†Œ‘¡‰žÙ‡Ðx›|Ù¤—ÐªÞ²›ˆ¥wª™Ù¢²•Ù·Ÿ†i• z›Ù ª› ٛw}ŸwÙ¢³ž|܋•hŸz“›ªœw€¡†¢Ù®h¢

ړ‡h›Œ‘¡ŸØ¬Œ‘ª›±ª›±Ü¢ ‰¢²˜‘iŸ|››wŸÙ›wª€““Ð «“Ý®h¢Ú“‡h›‘݆ž‹wŸ‘

˜‘¤ŒÚ“ Ù·³ŸŸ‹i•ÙŒŸwz“›ªœw€¡†¢Ù­Ùz•Ÿªxixiه·²Ÿ ‘i›“Ý ®h¢z•ŸªŒÒÙÜ¡—‡h›ª€““Ъ›±Ù£†

Œ‘¡‰žÙ‡Ðx›|Ù¤—Ð «“ݘŸŸ‘ˆž‹ž³|wŸ‘w‘݇¤iÙwŸ‘‰·Ÿ|ŸÙx›|ª›Ù®€Ðª›±ª›±Ü¢ ®†i

z·Ÿ˜·ŸzžÖª›±ª›±Ü¢ z“›ªœw€¡†¢Ù ª€““Ъ›±Ù£†Œ‘¡‰žÙ‡Ðx›|Ù¤—Ð

›Ÿ}Ÿ‘ÐŽŸz•¡Ÿ¬›—„•¡‰ŸzØ݉žÙ‡«Ü‰–Ÿ˜‡‘Џ™Ÿ•¡‰Ÿ“ž–‘¢Ùz‘¡‰‘•¡¬‘ט¤x¤•¡‰«x•|z“›|ª‡ª™Ùޛªx‡•ž×ٟw‘¤|ª‰Ü™ŸÙz‘

10110

(2)

&GGFDU PG $IMPSIFYJEJOF PO ..1 &YQSFTTJPO BOE "DUJWBUJPO JO )VNBO1FSJPEPOUBM-JHBNFOU$FMMT

4JSJMVDL5JSBOBUIBOBHVM

Abstract

.BUSJY NFUBMMPQSPUFJOBTF PS ..1 JT POF PG LFZ FO[ZNFT JO QFSJPEPOUBM EFTUSVDUJPO JO QFSJPEPOUBM EJTFBTFT ..1 BDUJWBUJPO QSPDFTT JT DSVDJBM GPS DPOUSPMMJOH UIF PQUJNBM GVODUJPO PG UIJT FO[ZNF $IMPSIFYJEJOF JT UIF NPTU DPNNPOMZ QSFTDSJCFE BOUJTFQUJD NPVUISJOTF JO UIF EFOUBM ÇFME 5IF BEWBOUBHFT PG UIF DIMPSIFYJEJOF JODMVEF BOUJCBDUFSJBM BOE BOUJGVOHBM BDUJWJUJFT TVCTUBOUJWJUZ BOE BOUJDPMMBHFOPMZUJD BDUJWJUZ )PXFWFS FGGFDU PG DIMPSIFYJEJOF PO FYQSFTTJPO BOE BDUJWBUJPO PG ..1 CZ IVNBO QFSJPEPOUBM MJHBNFOU DFMMT )1%- JT OPU DMFBS

0bKFctJWF 5P JOWFTUJHBUF UIF FGGFDU PG DIMPSIFYJEJOF PO ..1 FYQSFTTJPO BOE BDUJWBUJPO JO )1%- DFMMT

.atFrJaMsaOE .FtIPEs )1%- DFMMT XFSF DVMUVSFE JO %.&. XJUIXJUIPVU WBSJPVT DPODFOUSBUJPO PG DIMPSIFYJEJOF GPS NJOVUF UIFO DPOUJOVF HSPXJOH JO %.&. XJUI TFSVN GPS IPVST $ZUPUPYJDJUZ XBT FWBMVBUFE VTJOH .55 BTTBZ ;ZNPHSBQIZ XBT VTFE UP WFSJGZ UIF ..1 BDUJWBUJPO 5IF FYQSFTTJPO PG ..1 ..1 5*.1 BOE ("1%) XBT EFUFSNJOFE VTJOH 35SFBMUJNF 1$3

3FsVMts BOE DIMPSIFYJEJOF EFDSFBTFE DFMM WJBCJMJUZ UP + BOE + SFTQFDUJWFMZ $IMPSIFYJEJOF BU XBT OPU UPYJD UP )1%- DFMMT BOE SFEVDFE ..1 BDUJWBUJPO XIFO JOEVDFE CZ $PO " $IMPSIFYJEJOF EJE OPU IBWF BOZ FGGFDU PO ..1 ..1 BOE 5*.1 FYQSFTTJPO

$POcMVsJPO $IMPSIFYJEJOF NPVUISJOTF JO MPX DPODFOUSBUJPO IBE OP DZUPUPYJD FGGFDU JO )1%- DFMMT #FTJEFT JU XBT BCMF UP JOIJCJU ..1 BDUJWBUJPO JO UIFTF DFMMT

,FZXPSET ..1 $IMPSIFYJEJOF )VNBO QFSJPEPOUBM MJHBNFOU DFMMT

-FDUVSFS%FQBSUNFOUPG4UPNBUPMPHZ'BDVMUZPG%FOUJTUSZ4SJOBLIBSJOXJSPU6OJWFSTJUZ4VLIVNWJU8BUUBOB

#BOHLPL5IBJMBOE10110

(3)

‹‰Ù·Ÿ

¬‘zŒ‘¡‰žÙ‡Ð QFSJPEPOUBM EJTFBTF ªŒÒÙ¬‘z‡¡†

ªÞ³›‰¢²¢wŸ‘›žwª˜‹ª‘Þ³›‘ž| ‰·Ÿ­™i¢wŸ‘‰·Ÿ“Ÿx›|›•ž•Ý

Œ‘¡‰žÙ‡Ð €£²|Ù·Ÿ®Œ˜¥hwŸ‘˜¥Öª˜¢qÙ®Œ­Ù‰¢²˜¤† w“®wwŸ‘ªw¡†

¬‘zªw¡†}ŸwwŸ‘‡›‹˜Ù›|x›|ª€““Э٪ÙÞ³›ªÞ²›Œ‘¡‰žÙ‡Ð

‡h›Œq}}žwh›¬‘zx›|ªÞ³›«‹z‰¢ª‘¢ ¬†ªÞ³›«‹z‰¢ª‘¢‰¢²ªŒÒÙ

˜Ÿª™‡¤˜·ŸzžÖx›|wŸ‘ªw¡†¬‘z ®†i«wh ܛ‘Ю¬‘¬«Ù˜ }¡|

}¡•Ÿ“¡˜ 1PSQIZSPNPOBTHJOHJWBMJT «‰ÙªÙ›ª‘““Ÿ

›‘ЀžªŠ¢ 5BOOFSFMMBGPSTZUIJB «“Ý «›ww‘¢ªw‡¡

«‹zª‡›‘Ð «›z‰¡¬Ùž€¢ª‡±¬z¡«‰Ù˜Ð "HHSFHBUJCBDUFS BDUJOPNZDFUFNDPNJUBOT <> w“®w˜·ŸzžÖ™Ù£²|®†i«wh wŸ‘˜‘iŸ|«“Ý™“ž²|ª›Ù®€Ð­Ùw“¤h ª‰‘¡w€Ðª‰ž“¬“¬Œ‡¡ªÙ˜

NBUSJY NFUBMMPQSPUFJOBTFT ™‘Þ› ª›±ª›±Ü¢ ..1T

¬†ª€““Э٪ÙÞ³›ªÞ²›Œ‘¡‰žÙ‡Ð ‰·Ÿ­™iªw¡†wŸ‘‰·Ÿ“ŸªÙÞ³›ªÞ²›

‹‘¡ª•Øٞ³Ù

ª›±ª›±Ü¢ ªŒÒÙw“¤hx›|ª›±Ù®€Ð‰¢²¢z•Ÿ˜ŸŸ‘ˆ­Ù wŸ‘h›‰·Ÿ“Ÿª‰‘¡w€Ðٛwª€““Ð FYUSBDFMMVMBS NBUSJY

®†i‰¤wÙ¡† ‘•‰ž³|z›““Ÿª}ÙÙ¡†‡hŸ| ° ª›±ª›±Ü¢ˆ¥w˜‘iŸ|

®†i}Ÿwª€““Й“ŸÙ¡† ®†i«wh ª€““И‘iŸ|ª˜iÙ­ ÇCSPCMBTUT Ù¡•¬‰‘Ì“ OFVUSPQIJM «z¬z‘Ÿ} NBDSPQIBHF ªz‘Ÿ‡¡

¬Ù®€‰Ð LFSBUJOPDZUF «“ݪ€““Ћ¤™“›†ª“Þ›† FOEPUIFMJBM DFMMT ªŒÒهiÙ ª›±ª›±Ü¢¢‹‰‹Ÿ‰˜·ŸzžÖ­Ùw‘Ý‹•ÙwŸ‘x›|

‘hŸ|wŸ‰¢²‡i›|¢wŸ‘h›˜“Ÿª‰‘¡w€Ðٛwª€““Љž³|­Ù˜ŽŸ•Ý

Œw‡¡ ªhÙ wŸ‘Üž×ٟx›|‡ž•›h›Ù wŸ‘ªw¡†™“›†ª“Þ›†­™h wŸ‘™Ÿx›|«Ú“ «“Ý­Ù˜ŽŸ•Ý‰¢²¢ÜŸŠ¡˜ŽŸÜ ªhÙ Ýª‘±|

xi››žwª˜‹‘¥Ÿ‡›†Ð ‘•‰ž³|¬‘zŒ‘¡‰žÙ‡Ð›žwª˜‹ wŸ‘z•‹z¤

wŸ‘‰·Ÿ|ŸÙx›|ª›Ù®€Ð­Ùw“¤hÙ¢³}£|¢z•Ÿ˜·ŸzžÖ›hŸ|¡²|‡h›

wŸ‘z|›¥hx›|ªÙÞ³›ªÞ²››hŸ|˜†¤“ UJTTVF IPNFPTUBTJT wŸ‘z•‹z¤‰·Ÿ®†i­Ù™“Ÿ‘݆ž‹‡ž³|«‡h‘݆ž‹wŸ‘«˜†|››w x›|¢Ù ‘݆ž‹wŸ‘w‘݇¤iÙwŸ‘‰·Ÿ|ŸÙ «“ÝwŸ‘ž‹ž³|wŸ‘

‰·Ÿ|ŸÙ†i•‡ž•ž‹ž³| JOIJCJUPST ª›±ª›±Ü¢ ‰¢²Ü‹•hŸ¢‹‰‹Ÿ‰

­ÙwŸ‘‰·Ÿ“ŸªÙÞ³›ªÞ²›Œ‘¡‰žÙ‡Ð®†i«wh ª›±ª›±Ü¢

«“Ý <> ª›±ª›±Ü¢ ªŒÒÙª›±Ù®€Ð­Ùw“¤hª›±

ª›±Ü¢ ‰¢²˜ŸŸ‘ˆh›‰·Ÿ“Ÿª‰‘¡w€Ðٛwª€““Й“ŸÙ¡†

‘•‰ž³| z›““Ÿª}Ù Ù¡†‰¢² «“Ý «“ݪŒÒÙª›Ù®€Ð‰¢²

‡i›|wŸ‘w‘Ý‹•ÙwŸ‘w‘݇¤iÙwŸ‘‰·Ÿ|ŸÙ‰¢²€ž‹€i›Ù‡hŸ|}Ÿw

ª›±ª›±Ü¢Ù¡†›Þ²Ù ° ¬†wŸ‘w‘݇¤iÙwŸ‘‰·Ÿ|ŸÙ}ݪw¡†x£³Ù

‹ÙÚ¡•ª€““Ð «“݇i›|›Ÿ–ž¬ª“w¤“x›| ª›±ª›±Ü¢ «“Ý

‰¡ÜÐ 5*.1 ‘h•†i• <> ¢‘Ÿ|ŸÙ܋wŸ‘ªÜ¡²x£³Ù x›|ª›±ª›±Ü¢ ¬†ª~ܟݭّ¥Œ‰¢²Ü‘i›‰·Ÿ|ŸÙ­Ù‘›¬‘z

Œ‘¡‰žÙ‡Ðx›|Ù¤—Ð <> «“Ý­Ù™Ù¥‰†“›|‰¢²ª™Ù¢²•Ù·Ÿ­™i ªw¡†¬‘zŒ‘¡‰žÙ‡Ð <>

z“›ªœw€¡†¢Ù DIMPSIFYJEJOF ªŒÒ٘Ÿ‘ÕhŸªÞ³›‰¢²

¢x›‹ªx‡­ÙwŸ‘‰·Ÿ“ŸªÞ³›w•iŸ| ˜ŸŸ‘ˆ‰·Ÿ“ŸªÞ³›®†i

‰ž³|«‹z‰¢ª‘¢w‘ž‹•w w‘ž“‹ ªÞ³›‘Ÿ «“Ý®•‘ž˜‹Ÿ|Ù¡†

<> ¬†w“®wwŸ‘››w’‰Š¡¶Ùž³Ùz“›ªœw€¡†¢Ù}Ý®Œ‰·Ÿ“Ÿ

Úٞ|ª€““Ðx›|ªÞ³› <> z“›ªœw€¡†¢Ùˆ¥wÙ·ŸŸ­i­Ù‰Ÿ|

‰žÙ‡w‘‘ªŒÒÙÙ·³ŸŸ‹i•ÙŒŸwÕhŸªÞ³› z•‹z¤wŸ‘ªw¡†z‘Ÿ‹

}¤“¡Ù‰‘¢Ð «“Ý“†wŸ‘›žwª˜‹x›|ªÙÞ³›ªÞ²›­Ùh›|ŒŸw <>

¬†‰ž²•®Œ­i‰¢²z•Ÿªxixiّi›“Ý ٛw}ŸwÙ¢³z“›ªœw

€¡†¢Ùž|¢z•Ÿ˜ŸŸ‘ˆ­ÙwŸ‘ªwŸÝ‡¡†wž‹ÜÞ³ÙÚ¡•qÙ «“Ý ªÙÞ³›ªÞ²›­Ùh›|ŒŸw ‰·Ÿ­™i˜ŸŸ‘ˆz|›¥h­Ùh›|ŒŸwªŒÒÙ

‘ݐݪ•“ŸÙŸÙ <> ¢wŸ‘–£w—ŸÜ‹•hŸ ˜ŸŸ‘ˆÜ‹

z“›ªœw€¡†¢Ù›¥h­ÙÙ·³Ÿ“ŸŽŸ™“ž|}Ÿw‰¢²›˜Ÿ‘“Ý“Ÿz“›

ªœw€¡†¢ÙªŒÒÙª•“Ÿ ٟ‰¢ ٟو£| ž²•¬| <>¬†wŸ‘

–£w—Ÿ™Ù£²| <> ­iz“›ªœw€¡†¢Ù ¡““¡w‘ž‡h›¡““¡“¡‡‘

ª‰¢‹ª‰hŸwž‹‘i›“Ý ™“ž|}Ÿw­™iÚ¥iˆ¥w‰†“›|›

˜Ÿ‘“Ý“Ÿz“›ªœw€¡†¢Ù «“݉·ŸwŸ‘‡‘•}˜›‹Œ‘¡ŸØz“›

ªœw€¡†¢Ù­ÙÙ·³Ÿ“Ÿ­Ùª•“Ÿ‡hŸ| ° ܋•hŸ ž²•¬|€£²|ªŒÒÙª•“Ÿ

ٟى¢²˜¤†‰¢²‰·ŸwŸ‘–£w—Ÿ ˜ŸŸ‘ˆ‡‘•}܋z“›ªœw€¡†¢Ù­Ù Ù·³Ÿ“Ÿ + ®¬z‘w‘ž‡h›¡““¡“¡‡‘ ª‰¢‹ª‰hŸwž‹

‘i›“Ý

z“›ªœw€¡†¢Ù ٛw}Ÿw¢’‰Š¡¶ÕhŸªÞ³›«“i• ž|܋

•hŸ˜ŸŸ‘ˆž‹ž³|wŸ‘‰·Ÿ|ŸÙx›|ª›Ù®€Ð­Ùw“¤hª›±ª›±Ü¢

®†i ¢wŸ‘–£w—Ÿ­Ù™“›†‰†“›| <> ¬†­iª›Ù®€Ð ª›±ª›±Ü¢ «“Ý ‰¢²ˆ¥w˜‘iŸ|Ÿ}Ÿwª€““Ðx›|Ù¤—Ð €£²|

›¥h­Ù‘¥Œ®hܑi›‰·Ÿ|ŸÙ JOBDUJWF GPSN Ÿw‘݇¤iÙwŸ‘‰·Ÿ|ŸÙ

†i•wŸ‘‹hwž‹˜Ÿ‘“Ý“Ÿ QBNJOPQIFOZMNFSDVSJD BDFUBUF "1." «“i•Ù·Ÿ®Œ‹h­Ù˜Ÿ‘“Ý“Ÿ‰¢²¢z“›

ªœw€¡†¢Ù ‰¢²z•ŸªxixiهhŸ| ° «“ݪ‡¡˜Ÿ‘‡ž³|‡iÙx›|ª›Ù®€Ð

«‡h“ÝÙ¡†ªÜÞ²›‰†˜›‹Ú“x›|z“›ªœ€¡†¢Ù‡h›wŸ‘‰·Ÿ|ŸÙx›|

(4)

ª›Ù®€Ð‰ž³|˜Ÿ ܋•hŸz“›ªœw€¡†¢Ù˜ŸŸ‘ˆž‹ž³|wŸ‘‰·Ÿ|ŸÙ

x›|ª›±ª›±Ü¢ «“Ý ‰¢²z•Ÿªxixiّi›“Ý «“Ý ‡Ÿ“·Ÿ†ž‹ †i•z•Ÿ˜ŸŸ‘ˆ­ÙwŸ‘«h|

}ž‹¬ª“w¤“‰¢²¢Œ‘Ý}¤‹•w DBUJPODIFMBUJOH NFDIBOJTN wŸ‘‰·Ÿ|ŸÙx›|ª›±Ù®€Ðª›±ª›±Ü¢‡i›|›Ÿ–ž®››Ù‰¢²¢Œ‘Ý}¤

‹•w DBUJPO ®†i«wh ®›››Ù˜ž|wݘ¢ ;O+ «“Ý ®›››Ù

«z“ª€¢ $B+ ‰·Ÿ­™iªÞ²›ˆ¥w†£|®›››Ùª™“hŸÙ¢³››w®ŒwŸ‘

‰·Ÿ|ŸÙ}£|ˆ¥wž‹ž³|

ž|®h¢wŸ‘–£w—ŸÚ“x›|z“›ªœw€¡†¢Ù‡h›ª€““Ъ›±Ù

£†Œ‘¡‰žÙ‡Ðx›|Ù¤—Ð­Ù†iŸÙx›|wŸ‘w‘݇¤iÙwŸ‘‰·Ÿ|ŸÙ x›|ª›Ù®€Ðª›±ª›±Ü¢ }£|ªŒÒى¢²ÙhŸ˜Ù­}•hŸ­Ù‘݆ž‹z•Ÿ

ªxixiى¢²®h¢z•ŸªŒÒÙÜ¡—‡h›ª€““Ðٞ³Ùz“›ªœw€¡†¢Ù}ݏ¢

’‰Š¡¶­†‡h›ª›Ù®€Ðª›±ª›±Ü¢

wŸ‘–£w—ŸÙ¢³¢•ž‡ˆ¤Œ‘ݘ|zЪÜÞ²›–£w—Ÿz•Ÿ˜ŸŸ‘ˆx›|

z“›ªœw€¡†¢Ù­Ù‘݆ž‹z•Ÿªxixiى¢²®h¢z•ŸªŒÒÙÜ¡—‡h›ª€““Ð ª›±Ù£†Œ‘¡‰žÙ‡Ðx›|Ù¤—Ð ­Ù†iŸÙwŸ‘«˜†|››wx›|¢Ù«“Ý wŸ‘w‘݇¤iÙwŸ‘‰·Ÿ|ŸÙx›|ª›Ù®€Ðª›±ª›±Ü¢

•ž˜†¤›¤Œw‘ØЫ“Ý•¡Š¢wŸ‘

wŸ‘ª“¢³|ª€““Ъ›±Ù£†Œ‘¡‰žÙ‡Ð

ª€““Ъ›±Ù£†Œ‘¡‰žÙ‡Ð ®†iŸ}Ÿwz“ž|ª€““Ѐ£²|ªŒÒÙ ª€““Љ¢²ªw±‹­Ù®Ù¬‡‘ª}Ùª™“• ‰¢²ŽŸz•¡Ÿ¬›—„•¡‰Ÿ zØÝ

‰žÙ‡«Ü‰–Ÿ˜‡‘Ð ™Ÿ•¡‰Ÿ“ž–‘¢Ùz‘¡‰‘•¡¬‘× ªŒÒÙ ª€““Љ¢²‰·ŸwŸ‘ª‡‘¢«“ݪܟݪ“¢³|‡Ÿ•¡Š¢x›|˜¡‘¡“žw—ØÐ

‡¢‘؊ٟw¤“«“ÝzØÝ <> ¬†¢•¡Š¢wŸ‘¬†h›†ž|Ù¢³ qى¢²®†i

‘ž‹wŸ‘ˆ›Ù}ŸwÚ¥iŒd•z“¡Ù¡w‰žÙ‡w‘‘zØ݉žÙ‡«Ü‰–Ÿ˜‡‘Ð

¬†®†i‘ž‹z•Ÿ¡Ù›}ŸwÚ¥iŒd• qÙ}݇i›|›¥h­Ù˜ŽŸÜ‰¢²†¢

Œ‘Ÿ–}ŸwwŸ‘‡¡†ªÞ³›¬†®h¢‘›Ú¤ ™‘Þ›ªŒÒÙ¬‘zŒ‘¡‰žÙ‡Ð

«“݉·ŸwŸ‘ˆ›ÙªÜÞ²›•ž‡ˆ¤Œ‘ݘ|zЭÙwŸ‘}ž†qٙ‘Þ›wŸ‘

ÚhŸqÙz¤† Ù·Ÿqى¢²®†iŸ“iŸ|­™i˜Ý›Ÿ††i•˜Ÿ‘“Ý“Ÿ

›˜ª‡‹žª›‘Ð QIPTQIBUF CVGGFS TPMVUJPO 1#4

­i­‹¢†Œ“›†ªÞ³› CMBEF OP x¥†ªÙÞ³›ªÞ²›Œ‘¡‰žÙ‡Ð‹Ù Ú¡•‘ŸwqÙ ‹‘¡ª•Øw“Ÿ|x›|‘ŸwqÙ ¬†™hŸ|}Ÿw˜h•Ù z›qÙ «“ÝŒ“Ÿ‘ŸwqٛhŸ|Ùi› ¡““¡ª‡‘ ‡ž†ªÙÞ³›ªÞ²›

‰¢²®†iªŒÒÙ¡³Ùxٟ†Œ‘ݏŸØ Y ¡““¡ª‡‘ «“Ý•Ÿ|“|‹Ù }ŸÙªÜŸÝª“¢³|ª€““Ð ­i›Ÿ™Ÿ‘ª“¢³|ª€““ÐÙ¡††¢ª›±›¢ª›±

%.&. %VMCFDDPkT NPEJÇFE FBHMF NFEJVN ‰¢²ª‡¡€¢‘ž

‘i›“Ý «›“w“¥‡Ÿ¢Ù -HMVUBNJOF z•ŸªxixiÙ

¡““¡¬“Ÿ‘Ð ªÜÙÙ¡€¢“¡Ù 1FOJDJMMJO ¥Ù¡‡‡h›¡““¡“¡‡‘

˜ª‡‘Œ¬‡ž€¡Ù 4USFQUPNZDJO ®¬z‘w‘ž‡h›¡““¡“¡‡‘

«›¬ª‰›‘¡€¡Ù ‹¢ "NQIPUFSJDJO # ®¬z‘w‘ž‡h›

¡““¡“¡‡‘ ­Ù‡¥iª“¢³|ª€““Љ¢²¢zŸ‘Ћ›Ù®†››w®€†Ð ‘i›“Ý ›¤Ø™Ž¥¡ ›|–Ÿª€“ª€¢˜ ªŒ“¢²Ù›Ÿ™Ÿ‘ª“¢³|ª€““Ð

˜žŒ†Ÿ™Ð“Ý z‘ž³| Œ‘ݏŸØ •žÙ }ݏ¢ª€““Ðzދz“ŸÙ

››wŸ}Ÿw¡³ÙªÙÞ³› ª“¢³|‡h›}Ùª€““Ъܡ²}·ŸÙ•Ù¬‡ª‡±}ŸÙ ª“¢³|ª€““Ð}£|‰·ŸwŸ‘ˆhŸª€““Г|}ŸÙª“¢³|­™h ªŒÒÙª€““Ð

‘¤hى¢² ª“¢³|‡h›®Œ†i•›Ÿ™Ÿ‘ª“¢³|ª€““ÐÙ¡†ª†¡ ªÞ²›ª€““Ð ª}‘¡Öª‡±}ŸÙª“¢³|ª€““Ð ‰·ŸwŸ‘ˆhŸª€““Г|}ŸÙª“¢³|ª€““Ð

­™h ­Ù›ž‡‘Ÿ˜h•Ù™Ù£²|‡h›˜Ÿ ª€““Љ¢²­i­ÙwŸ‘‰†“›|ªŒÒÙ ª€““Б¤hى¢² ˆ£|

wŸ‘‰†˜›‹z•ŸªŒÒÙÜ¡—‡h›ª€““Іi••¡Š¢ª›±‰¢‰¢ .55 assay)

ª€““Ъ›±Ù£†Œ‘¡‰žÙ‡Ðˆ¥wÙ·Ÿ“|­Ù}ŸÙª“¢³|ª€““Ð

«‹‹ ™“¤ /VOD %FONBSL ‰¢²z•Ÿ™ÙŸ«Ùhٙ“¤

“Ý ª€““Ð ªŒÒÙª•“Ÿ ž²•¬| }Ÿwٞ³Ù›Ÿ™Ÿ‘ª“¢³|

ª€““Ј¥wªŒ“¢²ÙªŒÒٛŸ™Ÿ‘ª“¢³|ª€““ÐÙ¡††¢ª›±›¢ª›±‰¢²¢

Œ‘¡ŸØ€¢‘ž“†“|ªŒÒÙ ‘i›“Ý «“Ý­Ù˜ŽŸ•Ý‰¢²¢«“Ý

®h¢z“›ªœw€¡†¢Ù†i•z•ŸªxixiهhŸ| ° $ ‹‘¡—ž‰

¬›˜ˆ ›¡Ùª‡›‘Ð «“‹‹›‘Ÿ‰›‘¢˜Ð }·Ÿwž† ®†i«wh z•ŸªxixiÙ

‘i›“Ý «“Ý“†“|h•|“Ý ª‰hŸ }و£|z•ŸªxixiÙ ªŒÒÙª•“Ÿ ٟ‰¢ ™“ž|}Ÿwٞ³ÙªŒ“¢²ÙªŒÒٛŸ™Ÿ‘

ª“¢³|ª€““ÐÙ¡††¢ª›±›¢ª›±‰¢²¢€¢‘ž ‘i›“Ý ª“¢³|ª€““Ð

‡h›®ŒªŒÒÙª•“Ÿ ž²•¬| ›Ÿ™Ÿ‘ª“¢³|ª€““Ð}݈¥wªŒ“¢²Ù ªŒÒٛŸ™Ÿ‘ª“¢³|ª€““ÐÙ¡†®h¢€¢‘ž «“ݏ¢˜Ÿ‘ª›±‰¢‰¢

.55 z•ŸªxixiÙ ¡““¡w‘ž‡h›¡““¡“¡‡‘ ª“¢³|‡h›ªŒÒÙ ª•“Ÿ ٟ‰¢ ™“ž|}Ÿwٞ³Ù‰·ŸwŸ‘“Ý“ŸÚ“£w›‘ЏŸ€ŸÙ GPSNB[BO †i•®†ªŠ¡“€ž“¬®€†ÐŒ‘¡Ÿ‡‘ ®¬z‘“¡‡‘

‡h›™“¤ ›hŸÙzhŸwŸ‘†¥†w“ÞÙ«˜|‰¢²z•ŸŸ•z“Þ²Ù ٟ¬Ù ª‡‘ †i•ªz‘Þ²›|•ž†wŸ‘†¥†w“ÞÙ«˜|x›|˜Ÿ‘“Ý“Ÿ­Ù®¬z‘

ªÜ“‰ #JPDISPN "TZT 67.

(5)

wŸ‘w‘݇¤iÙª€““Ъ›±Ù£†Œ‘¡‰žÙ‡Ð†i•z“›ªœw€¡†¢Ù«“Ý z›ÙzŸÙŸ•Ÿ“¡Ùª›

ª€““Ъ›±Ù£†Œ‘¡‰žÙ‡Ðˆ¥wÙ·Ÿ“|­Ù}ŸÙª“¢³|ª€““Ы‹‹

™“¤ /VOD %FONBSL ‰¢²z•Ÿ™ÙŸ«Ùhٙ“¤“Ý ª€““Ð ªŒÒÙª•“Ÿ ž²•¬| }Ÿwٞ³Ù›Ÿ™Ÿ‘ª€““Ъ›±Ù£†

Œ‘¡‰žÙ‡Ðˆ¥wªŒ“¢²Ù›Ÿ™Ÿ‘ª“¢³|ª€““ЪŒÒÙÙ¡††¢ª›±›¢ª›±‰¢²ª‡¡

€¢‘ž ‘i›“Ý «“Ý­™i›¥h­Ù˜ŽŸ•Ý‰¢²¢«“Ý®h¢z“›ªœw€¡†¢Ù z•ŸªxixiهhŸ| ° ªŒÒÙª•“Ÿ ٟ‰¢ ™“ž|}Ÿwٞ³Ù‰·ŸwŸ‘

ªŒ“¢²Ù›Ÿ™Ÿ‘ª“¢³|ª€““Л¢wz‘ž³| †i• †¢ª›±›¢ª›± ‰¢²ª‡¡€¢‘ž

‘i›“Ý ¢™‘Þ›®h¢ z›ÙzŸÙŸ•Ÿ“¡Ù ª› $PODBOBWBMJO "

†i•z•Ÿ›Ù¤ªz‘ŸÝ™Ð}Ÿw –‰Ü†‘Œ‘ݘ¡‰Š¡¶ Ž•˜žÙ‡Ð zØÝ

‰žÙ‡«Ü‰–Ÿ˜‡‘Ð }¤šŸ“|w‘ØЏ™Ÿ•¡‰Ÿ“ž z•ŸªxixiÙ ®¬z‘w‘ž‡h›¡““¡“¡‡‘ ª“¢³|ª€““Їh›®ŒªŒÒÙª•“Ÿ

ž²•¬| ªÞ²›z‘‹ª•“Ÿªw±‹›Ÿ™Ÿ‘ª“¢³|ª€““ЪÜÞ²›®Œ•¡ªz‘ŸÝ™Ð

Œ‘¡ŸØª›Ù®€Ðª›±ª›±Ü¢ †i••¡Š¢®€¬w‘Ÿ` ˜h•Ùª€““Ð

‰·ŸwŸ‘˜wž†›Ÿ‘Ъ›±Ùª›ªÜÞ²›•¡ªz‘ŸÝ™Ð‡h›®Œ

wŸ‘•¡ªz‘ŸÝ™Ðª›Ù®€Ðª›±ª›±Ü¢†i••¡Š¢®€¬w‘Ÿ`

;yNPHraQIy)

›Ÿ™Ÿ‘ª“¢³|ª€““Ð}ŸwwŸ‘‰†“›|}݈¥wÙ·ŸŸ•¡ªz‘ŸÝ™Ð

™Ÿª›Ù®€Ðª›±ª›±Ü¢ †i••¡Š¢®€¬w‘Ÿ` ;ZNPHSBQIZ

€£²|¢•¡Š¢wŸ‘¬†h›zޛ ›Ÿ™Ÿ‘ª“¢³|ª€““Ð}݈¥wژwž‹

«€ªŒÌ“‹žª›‘Ð TBNQMF CVGGFS «“i•Ù·Ÿ®Œ«w†i•

®eŸ HFM FMFDUSPQIPSFTJT ­Ùª}“‰¢²¢z•ŸªxixiÙx›|

›z‘¡“ŸŸ†Ð‘i›“Ý «“ݪ}“Ÿ‡¡Ù HFMBUJO z•Ÿ

ªxixiÙ ‘i›“Ý

ªÞ²›‰·ŸwŸ‘«w¬Œ‘‡¢Ù†i•®eŸ«“i• ª}“}݈¥w“iŸ|

†i•˜Ÿ‘“Ý“Ÿ 5SJUPO9 z•ŸªxixiÙ ‘i›“Ý }·ŸÙ•Ù ‘›‹ ‘›‹“Ý ٟ‰¢ wh›ÙÙ·Ÿ®Œ‹h­Ù˜Ÿ‘“Ý“Ÿ

EFWFMPQJOH CVGGFS . /B$M N. $B$M

N.

5SJT)$M Q) #SJK ‘i›“Ý ªŒÒÙª•“Ÿ zÞÙ ‰¢²

›¤Ø™Ž¥¡ ›|–Ÿª€“ª€¢˜ }Ÿwٞ³Ùi›ª}“†i•˜Ÿ‘“Ý“Ÿ

#SJMMJBOU #MVF 3 4JHNB z•Ÿªxixiّi›“Ý

­Ù˜Ÿ‘“Ý“Ÿª‰¡“«›“w›œ›“Ð ‘i›“Ý «“Ýw‘†

›Ý€¢‡¡† ‘i›“Ý ªŒÒÙª•“Ÿ ž²•¬| “iŸ|˜¢˜h•Ùªw¡Ù››w

†i•˜Ÿ‘“Ý“Ÿª‰¡“«›“w›œ›“Ð ‘i›“Ý «“Ýw‘†›Ý€¢‡¡w

‘i›“Ý ‹‘¡ª•Ø‰¢²¢ª›Ù®€Ðª›±ª›±Ü¢ }݌‘Ÿw‚ªŒÒÙ

«ˆ‹­˜‹Ù«ÚhÙª}“˜¢Ù·³Ÿª|¡Ù

˜Ÿ‘˜wž†›Ÿ‘Ъ›±Ùª›«“Ý–£w—Ÿ‘݆ž‹wŸ‘«˜†|››wx›|¢Ù

˜wž†›Ÿ‘Ъ›±Ùª› }Ÿwª€““Ъ›±Ù£†Œ‘¡‰žÙ‡Ð†i• 53*

3FBHFOU 4JHNB 64" ‡Ÿ•¡Š¢‰¢²‹‘¡—ž‰Ú¥iړ¡‡«ÙÝÙ·Ÿ

«“ÝÙ·Ÿ®Œ˜ž|ªz‘ŸÝ™Ð D%/" SFWFSTF USBOTDSJQUJPO †i•

*.130.** 3FWFSTF 5SBOTDSJQUJPO TZTUFN 1SPNFHB 64" ‡Ÿ•¡Š¢‰¢²‹‘¡—ž‰Ú¥iړ¡‡«ÙÝÙ·Ÿ }Ÿwٞ³ÙÙ·Ÿ D%/" ‰¢²

®†i®Œ•¡ªz‘ŸÝ™Ð†i••¡Š¢ ª‘¢“®‰ÐÜ¢€¢›Ÿ‘Ð †i• -JHIU$ZDMFS 4:#3 (SFFO * .BTUFS ‹Ùªz‘Þ²›| -JHIU$ZDMFS

** 3PDIF 64" ‡Ÿ•¡Š¢‰¢²‹‘¡—ž‰Ú¥iړ¡‡«ÙÝÙ·Ÿ

¢Ù‰¢²‰·ŸwŸ‘–£w—Ÿ®†i«wh ª›±ª›±Ü¢ ..1 ª›±ª›±Ü¢ ..1 «“Ý ‰¡ÜÐ 5*.1 «“Ý ("1%)

..1 GPSXBSE k $""(""(5"5(($55$5($$ k SFWFSTF k ($"$$$55(""(""(5"($5 k ..1 GPSXBSE k $"5$($5($$"5($"(""(5 k

SFWFSTF k (5$"5"5$((($"($"$ k 5*.1 GPSXBSE k ((""(5("$5$5(("""$("$"55 k

SFWFSTF k $5$("5(5$("("""$5$$5($55( k ("1%) GPSXBSE k 5(""((5$("(5$""$(("5 k

SFWFSTF k 5$"$"$$$"5("$(""$"5(( k

wŸ‘•¡ªz‘ŸÝ™Ðxi›¥“

ړwŸ‘‰†“›|«˜†|­Ù‘¥Œx›| zhŸª~“¢² + zhŸª‹¢²|

ª‹ÙŸ‡‘„ŸÙ •¡ªz‘ŸÝ™Ðz•Ÿ«‡w‡hŸ|‰Ÿ|˜ˆ¡‡¡¬†­i•¡Š¢

‰†˜›‹wŸ‘«Œ‘Œ‘•Ù‰Ÿ|ª†¢• 0OFXBZ "/07" ‰¢²

‘݆ž‹z•ŸªÞ²›ž²Ù‘i›“Ý Q ¬†¬Œ‘«w‘˜ˆ¡‡¡

ª›˜Ü¢ª›˜ª›˜ 4144

(6)

‘¥Œ‰¢² w‘Ÿ«˜†|ړwŸ‘‰†˜›‹z•ŸªŒÒÙÜ¡—‡h›ª€““Ðx›|z“›ªœw€¡†¢Ù‰¢²z•ŸªxixiهhŸ| ° ¬†wŸ‘•¡ªz‘ŸÝ™Ð†i••¡Š¢ª›±‰¢‰¢

.55BTTBZª€““Ъ›±Ù£†Œ‘¡‰žÙ‡Ðˆ¥wª“¢³|­Ù˜ŽŸ•Ý‰¢²¢«“Ý®h¢z“›ªœw€¡†¢Ù†i•z•ŸªxixiهhŸ|°ªŒÒÙª•“ŸÙŸ‰¢™“ž|}Ÿwٞ³Ù ªŒ“¢²ÙªŒÒٛŸ™Ÿ‘ª“¢³|ª€““Љ¢²¢€¢‘ž‘i›“ݪ“¢³|ª€““Їh›®ŒªŒÒÙª•“Ÿž²•¬|xi›¥“«˜†|›¥h­Ù‘¥ŒzhŸª~“¢²+zhŸª‹¢²|ª‹Ù

Ÿ‡‘„ŸÙ «˜†|z•Ÿ«‡w‡hŸ|›hŸ|¢Ùž˜·ŸzžÖ}Ÿww“¤hz•‹z¤Q

'JH$FMMWJBCJMJUZPG)1%-DFMMTJOWBSJPVTDPODFOUSBUJPOPGDIMPSIFYJEJOFNFBTVSFECZUIF.55BTTBZT )1%-DFMMTXFSFUSFBUFEXJUIWBSJPVTDPODFOUSBUJPOPGDIMPSIFYJEJOFGPSNJOVUFUIFODPOUJOVFHSPXJOHJO

%.&.XJUITFSVNGPSIPVST5SFBUNFOUTTJHOJÇDBOUMZEJGGFSFOUGSPNUIFVOUSFBUFEDPOUSPMBUQ BSFQSFTFOUFEBT

ړwŸ‘‰†“›|

wŸ‘‰†˜›‹z•ŸªŒÒÙÜ¡—x›|z“›ªœw€¡†¢Ù‡h›ª€““Ъ›±Ù£†

Œ‘¡‰žÙ‡Ðx›|Ù¤—Ð ‘¥Œ‰¢²

z“›ªœw€¡†¢Ù‰¢²z•Ÿªxixiّi›“Ý «“Ý

¢zhŸª~“¢²‘i›“Ýz•Ÿ¢¢•¡‡x›|ª€““ЪŒÒÙ ‘i›“Ý +

«“Ý + ‡Ÿ“·Ÿ†ž‹ €£²|‡·²Ÿw•hŸw“¤hz•‹z¤ ‘i›“Ý

›hŸ|¢Ùž˜·ŸzžÖ‰Ÿ|˜ˆ¡‡¡ Q «˜†|ˆ£|z•Ÿ

ªŒÒÙÜ¡—‡h›ª€““Ð ­ÙxØ݉¢²w“¤hz“›ªœw€¡†¢Ù‰¢²z•ŸªxixiÙ

‡·²Ÿ“|Ÿ ‘i›“Ý «“Ý ¢zhŸ

ª~“¢²‘i›“Ýz•Ÿ¢¢•¡‡x›|ª€““ЪŒÒّi›“Ý + + «“Ý + ‡Ÿ“·Ÿ†ž‹ €£²|®h«‡w‡hŸ|}Ÿw w“¤hz•‹z¤ Q

(7)

ړx›|z“›ªœw€¡†¢Ù‡h›Œ‘¡ŸØª›Ù®€Ðª›±ª›±Ü¢

‘¥Œ‰¢²

ŽŸÜ®€¬w‘Ÿ`«˜†|«ˆ‹­˜x›|ª›Ù®€Ðª›±ª›±Ü¢ €£²|

‹h|‹›wˆ£|Œ‘¡ŸØª›Ù®€Ðª›±ª›±Ü¢ ­Ù‘¥Œ›¡Ù«›z‰¢

JOBDUJWF ™‘Þ›¬Œ‘ª›±ª›±Ü¢ QSP..1 ‰¢²¢xٟ†

w¡¬“†ž“‡žÙ ‹Ùª}“›z‘¡“ŸŸ†Ð ‘i›“Ý ‰¢²¢ª}“Ÿ‡¡Ù

›¥h ‘i›“Ý ®h܋z•Ÿ«‡w‡hŸ|x›|Œ‘¡ŸØª›Ù®€Ðª›±

ª›±Ü¢ ‘Ý™•hŸ|w“¤hz•‹z¤ $ «“Ýw“¤hz“›ªœw€¡†¢Ù z•Ÿªxixiّi›“Ý «“Ý

ړx›|z“›ªœw€¡†¢Ù‡h›wŸ‘w‘݇¤iÙwŸ‘‰·Ÿ|ŸÙx›|ª›Ù®€Ð ª›±ª›±Ü¢ ‘¥Œ‰¢²

«ˆ‹­˜‹ÙŽŸÜª}“®€¬w‘Ÿ`«˜†|Œ‘¡ŸØª›Ù®€Ð ª›±ª›±Ü¢ ‰¢²ˆ¥wª™Ù¢²•Ù·Ÿ†i• z›Ùª› $PO " ­Ù‘¥Œ

›¡Ù«›z‰¢ «“Ý‘¥Œ«›z‰¢ «ˆ‹­˜‰¢²¢xٟ† «“Ý w¡¬“†ž“‡žÙ ‡Ÿ“·Ÿ†ž‹ ܋•hŸw“¤hz“›ªœw€¡†¢Ùz•Ÿ

ªxixiّi›“Ý ¢«ˆ‹­˜x›|ª›Ù®€Ðª›±ª›±Ü¢

­Ù‘¥Œ«›z‰¢ “†“|›hŸ|ž†ª}Ù

‘¥Œ‰¢² ړx›|z“›ªœw€¡†¢Ù‡h›Œ‘¡ŸØª›Ù®€Ðª›±ª›±Ü¢ ..1 ª€““Ъ›±Ù£†Œ‘¡‰žÙ‡Ðˆ¥wª“¢³|­Ù˜ŽŸ•Ý‰¢²¢«“Ý®h¢

z“›ªœw€¡†¢Ù†i•z•ŸªxixiهhŸ|°ªŒÒÙª•“ŸÙŸ‰¢™“ž|}Ÿwٞ³ÙªŒ“¢²ÙªŒÒٛŸ™Ÿ‘ª“¢³|ª€““Љ¢²¢€¢‘ž‘i›“ݪ“¢³|ª€““Ð

‡h›®ŒªŒÒÙª•“Ÿž²•¬|ªw±‹›Ÿ™Ÿ‘ª“¢³|ª€““Љ¢²®†iŸ•¡ªz‘ŸÝ™Ð†i••¡Š¢®€¬w‘Ÿ`

'JH &GGFDU PG DIMPSIFYJEJOF PO ..1 MFWFM PG )1%- DFMMT )1%- DFMMT XFSF USFBUFE XJUI WBSJPVT DPODFOUSBUJPOPGDIMPSIFYJEJOFGPSNJOVUFUIFODPOUJOVFHSPXJOHJO%.&.XJUITFSVNGPSIPVST 5IFNFEJVNXFSFIBSWFTUFEGPSHFMBUJO[ZNPHSBQIZ

‘¥Œ‰¢² ړx›|z“›ªœw€¡†¢Ù‡h›wŸ‘ž‹ž³|wŸ‘w‘݇¤iÙwŸ‘‰·Ÿ|ŸÙx›|ª›Ù®€Ðª›±ª›±Ü¢ ..1 ª€““Ъ›±Ù£†Œ‘¡‰žÙ‡Ðˆ¥wª“¢³|

­Ù˜ŽŸ•Ý‰¢²¢«“Ý®h¢z“›ªœw€¡†¢Ù †i•z•ŸªxixiهhŸ| ° ªŒÒÙª•“Ÿ ٟ‰¢ ™“ž|}Ÿwٞ³ÙªŒ“¢²ÙªŒÒٛŸ™Ÿ‘ª“¢³|ª€““Љ¢²¢€¢‘ž

‘i›“Ý ‰¢²¢ z›Ù ª› z•ŸªxixiÙ ®¬z‘w‘ž‡h›¡““¡“¡‡‘ ª“¢³|ª€““Їh›®ŒªŒÒÙª•“Ÿ ž²•¬|ªw±‹›Ÿ™Ÿ‘ª“¢³|ª€““Ð

‰¢²®†iŸ•¡ªz‘ŸÝ™Ð†i••¡Š¢®€¬w‘Ÿ`

'JH&GGFDUPGDIMPSIFYJEJOFPO..1BDUJWBUJPO PG)1%- DFMMT )1%- DFMMT XFSF USFBUFE XJUIWBSJPVT DPODFOUSBUJPOPGDIMPSIFYJEJOFGPSNJOVUFUIFODPOUJOVFHSPXJOHJO%.&.XJUITFSVNBOE HNMPG$PO"

GPSIPVST5IFNFEJVNXFSFIBSWFTUFEGPSHFMBUJO[ZNPHSBQIZ D L%B

$IMPSIFYJEJOF

D L%B

$IMPSIFYJEJOF

(8)

‘¥Œ‰¢²Ú“x›|z“›ªœw€¡†¢Ù‡h›wŸ‘«˜†|››wx›|ª›±ª›±Ü¢ª›±ª›±Ü¢«“݉¡ÜÐ ..1..15*.1ª€““Ð ª›±Ù£†Œ‘¡‰žÙ‡Ðˆ¥wª“¢³|­Ù˜ŽŸ•Ý‰¢²¢«“Ý®h¢z“›ªœw€¡†¢Ù $)9†i•z•ŸªxixiÙ ‘i›“݇hŸ|°ªŒÒÙª•“ŸÙŸ‰¢™“ž|}Ÿw ٞ³ÙªŒ“¢²ÙªŒÒٛŸ™Ÿ‘ª“¢³|ª€““Љ¢²¢€¢‘ž ‘i›“Ý ª“¢³|ª€““Їh›®ŒªŒÒÙª•“Ÿ ž²•¬|˜wž†›Ÿ‘Ъ›±Ùª›Ÿ•¡ªz‘ŸÝ™Ð†i••¡Š¢›Ÿ‘Љ¢

ª‘¢“®‰ÐÜ¢€¢›Ÿ‘Ð w“¤hz•‹z¤®h®†i˜žÚž˜z“›ªœw€¡†¢Ù

'JH&GGFDUPGDIMPSIFYJEJOFPO..1..1BOE5*.1FYQSFTTJPOPG)1%-DFMMT)1%-DFMMTXFSF USFBUFEXJUIWBSJPVTDPODFOUSBUJPOPGDIMPSIFYJEJOFGPSNJOVUFUIFODPOUJOVFHSPXJOHJO%.&.XJUI TFSVNGPSIPVST5IFN3/"XFSFFYUSBDUFEGPSSFBMUJNF351$3

ړx›|z“›ªœw€¡†¢Ù‡h›wŸ‘«˜†|››wx›|¢Ùª›±ª›±Ü¢

ª›±ª›±Ü¢ «“݉¡ÜÐ ‘¥Œ‰¢²

ړª‘¢“®‰Ð ›Ÿ‘Љ¢Ü¢€¢›Ÿ‘Ð «˜†|‘݆ž‹wŸ‘«˜†|

››wx›|¢Ùª›±ª›±Ü¢ ª›±ª›±Ü¢ «“݉¡ÜÐ ®h܋

z•Ÿ«‡w‡hŸ|›hŸ|¢Ùž˜·ŸzžÖ‰Ÿ|˜ˆ¡‡¡ Q ‘Ý™•hŸ|

ª€““ЭÙw“¤hz•‹z¤ «“ݪ€““ЭÙw“¤h‰¢²˜žÚž˜z“›ªœw€¡†¢Ù z•Ÿªxixiّi›“Ý «“Ý

(9)

‹‰•¡}Ÿ‘ØÐ

ª›±Ù£†Œ‘¡‰žÙ‡ÐªŒÒÙªÙÞ³›ªÞ²›‰¢²‰·Ÿ™ÙiŸ‰¢²£†qÙwž‹w‘݆¥w xŸw‘‘®w‘ ª€““Ъ›±Ù£†Œ‘¡‰žÙ‡ÐªŒÒÙª€““И‘iŸ|ª˜iÙ­ ‰¢²ªŒÒÙ

˜h•ÙŒ‘Ýw›‹­ÙªÙÞ³›ªÞ²›Œ‘¡‰žÙ‡Ð ¢™ÙiŸ‰¢²‘žw—Ÿ˜†¤“wŸ‘

‰·Ÿ|ŸÙx›|ª›±Ù£†Œ‘¡‰žÙ‡Ð ¢z•Ÿ˜ŸŸ‘ˆ­ÙwŸ‘ªŒ“¢²Ù

®ŒªŒÒÙª€““И‘iŸ|ªÙÞ³›ªÞ²›«x±|x›|›•ž•ÝŒ‘¡‰žÙ‡Ð ®†i«wh ª€““И‘iŸ|ªz“Þ›‹‘ŸwqÙ DFNFOUPCMBTU «“ݪ€““И‘iŸ|

w‘݆¥w PTUFPCMBTU <> wŸ‘–£w—ŸÙ¢³­iª€““Ъ›±Ù£†

Œ‘¡‰žÙ‡Ð ªÙÞ²›|}ŸwªŒÒÙª€““Љ¢²¢‹‰‹Ÿ‰¬†‡‘|‰ž³|­Ù˜ŽŸ•Ý

‰¢²ªw¡†wŸ‘‰·Ÿ“Ÿ «“ݪw¡†wŸ‘€h›«€ªÙÞ³›ªÞ²›­Ù¬‘z

Œ‘¡‰žÙ‡Ð ªÞ²›ªw¡†wŸ‘‰·Ÿ“Ÿx›|›•ž•ÝŒ‘¡‰žÙ‡Ð ‰·Ÿ­™iªw¡†

‘h›|“£wŒ‘¡‰žÙ‡Ð€£²|Œwz“¤†i•ª€““Ћ¤Ú¡•ªÜ¢|®hw¢²ž³Ù «“Ý

~¢wxŸ†®†i|hŸ ‰ž³|}ŸwwŸ‘­™iwŸ‘‘žw—Ÿ¬‘zŒ‘¡‰žÙ‡Ð¬†

‰žÙ‡«Ü‰Ð ™‘Þ›wŸ‘‹Ÿ†ª}±‹}ŸwwŸ‘«Œ‘|qÙ ™‘Þ›wŸ‘‹†

ªz¢³• }£|ªŒÒÙh›|‰Ÿ|™Ù£²|‰¢²ª€““Ъ›±Ù£†Œ‘¡‰žÙ‡Ð}ݘžÚž˜wž‹

˜Ÿ‘ŽŸÙ›w ‘•‰ž³|Ù·³ŸŸ‹i•ÙŒŸw™‘Þ›Ù·³ŸŸ‰¢²‰žÙ‡«Ü‰Ð

­i~¢†“iŸ|­Ù‘h›|ª™|ޛw®†i

wŸ‘–£w—ŸÙ¢³­iz“›ªœw€¡†¢Ù‰¢²›¥h­Ù‘¥Œx›|Ù·³ŸŸ‹i•ÙŒŸw z•Ÿªxixiّi›“Ý ‰¢²ˆ¥w­i›¥h›hŸ|«Ü‘h™“Ÿ­Ù

‰Ÿ|‰žÙ‡w‘‘ ¬†ªŒÒÙÙ·³ŸŸ‹i•ÙŒŸw‰¢²‰žÙ‡«Ü‰Ð}hŸ

­™izÙ®xi¬‘zŒ‘¡‰žÙ‡ÐÙ·Ÿw“ž‹®Œ­i‰¢²‹iŸÙ «“ݪŒÒÙz“›ªœw

€¡†¢Ù‰¢²‰žÙ‡«Ü‰Ð­i­ÙwŸ‘~¢†“iŸ|‘h›|“£wŒ‘¡‰žÙ‡Ð‘Ý™•hŸ|

­™iwŸ‘‘žw—Ÿ¬‘zŒ‘¡‰žÙ‡Ð z“›ªœw€¡†¢Ù­Ù‘݆ž‹z•ŸªxixiÙ

‰¢²˜¥|‰¢²­i­Ù‰Ÿ|‰žÙ‡w‘‘Ùž³Ù ¤h|™•ž|ړ­ÙwŸ‘ÕhŸªÞ³› «“Ý

“†wŸ‘ªw¡†z‘Ÿ‹}¤“¡Ù‰‘¢Ð <> «‡h­Ùz•ŸªxixiÙٞ³Ù܋

•hŸªŒÒÙÜ¡—‡h›ª€““Й“ŸÙ¡† <> z•ŸªŒÒÙÜ¡—‡h›

ª€““Ðx›|z“›ªœw€¡†¢Ùٞ³Ùx£³Ù›¥hwž‹‘ݐݪ•“Ÿ‰¢²˜žÚž˜«“Ý

˜h•ÙŒ‘Ýw›‹x›|˜Ÿ‘‰¢²­i­ÙwŸ‘‰·Ÿ“Ý“Ÿ <> ªhÙª†¢•

wž‹wŸ‘–£w—ŸÙ¢³ ܋•hŸz“›ªœw€¡†¢Ù¢z•ŸªŒÒÙÜ¡—‡h›ª€““Ð ª›±Ù£†Œ‘¡‰žÙ‡Ð ‰¢²z•Ÿªxixiّi›“Ý «“Ý z“›ªœw€¡†¢Ùž|¢z¤Ø˜‹ž‡¡‰¢²†¢ ˜ŸŸ‘ˆ¢’‰Š¡¶z|›¥h

­Ùh›|ŒŸw®†iªŒÒÙª•“ŸÙŸÙ™“ž|}Ÿw­i›‹i•ÙŒŸw ªÙÞ²›|}Ÿw z¤Ø˜‹ž‡¡x›|˜Ÿ‘‰¢²ªŒÒÙ¬ª“w¤“‰¢²¢Œ‘Ý}¤‹•w ˜ŸŸ‘ˆªwŸÝ

‡¡†wž‹ ¡•€¡Ù NVDJO €£²|ªŒÒÙ¬Œ‘‡¢Ù­ÙÙ·³Ÿ“Ÿ‰¢²~Ÿ‹›¥h

‹ÙªÙÞ³›ªÞ²›h›|ŒŸw«“ݍqÙ <> «“ݐž|ˆ¥w†¥†€ž‹‹ÙÚ¡•

qÙ ªŒÒÙړ“†wŸ‘wh›‡ž•x›|«‹z‰¢ª‘¢­Ùh›|ŒŸw ­ÙwŸ‘

–£w—ŸÙ¢³­™iª€““ИžÚž˜z“›ªœw€¡†¢ÙªŒÒÙª•“Ÿ ٟ‰¢ ª‰¢‹

®†iwž‹wŸ‘­iz“›ªœw€¡†¢ÙªŒÒÙÙ·³ŸŸ‹i•ÙŒŸw­Ù¢•¡‡Œ‘Ý}·Ÿ•žÙ

‘•ˆ£|wŸ‘­iªŒÒÙÙ·³ŸŸ~¢†“iŸ|­Ù‘h›|“£wŒ‘¡‰žÙ‡Ð­Ù‘Ý™•hŸ|

wŸ‘‘žw—Ÿ¬‘zŒ‘¡‰žÙ‡Ð ¢wŸ‘–£w—ŸÜ‹•hŸz“›ªœw€¡†¢Ù‰¢²­i

›‹i•ÙŒŸw ˜ŸŸ‘ˆz|›¥h­Ùh›|ŒŸw®†iٟو£| ž²•¬|

<> ¬†z•ŸªxixiÙ}ݓ†“|‡Ÿª•“Ÿ ܋•hŸ ž²•¬|

ŽŸ™“ž|wŸ‘›‹i•ÙŒŸw†i•˜Ÿ‘“Ý“Ÿz“›ªœw€¡†¢Ùz•Ÿ

ªxixiÙ ¡““¡w‘ž‡h›¡““¡“¡‡‘ ª‰¢‹ª‰hŸwž‹‘i›“Ý

˜ŸŸ‘ˆ‡‘•}܋z“›ªœw€¡†¢Ù­ÙÙ·³Ÿ“Ÿ‰¢²z•ŸªxixiÙ +®¬z‘w‘ž‡h›¡““¡“¡‡‘ ª‰¢‹ª‰hŸwž‹‘i›“Ý

€£²|­w“iªz¢|wž‹z•ŸªxixiÙx›|z“›ªœw€¡†¢Ù‰¢²

­i­ÙwŸ‘–£w—Ÿ­Ùz‘ž³|Ù¢³

ª›±ª›±Ü¢ ªŒÒÙª›Ù®€Ð‰¢²ˆ¥w˜‘iŸ|®†i}Ÿwª€““Ð

™“ŸÙ¡† ªhÙ ª€““И‘iŸ|ª˜iÙ­ ª€““Ћ¤™“›†ª“Þ›†

«z¬z‘Ÿ} ªŒÒهiÙ ª›±ª›±Ü¢ }݈¥w˜‘iŸ|«“Ý™“ž²|››w

ŸÙ›wª€““Эّ¥Œ‰¢²ž|®hܑi›‰·Ÿ|ŸÙ ™‘Þ›ª‘¢w•hŸ ¬Œ‘ª›±

ª›±Ü¢ ­Ù˜h•Ùx›|wŸ‘w‘݇¤iÙwŸ‘‰·Ÿ|ŸÙ ª›±ª›±Ü¢ ªŒÒÙ ª›Ù®€Ð‰¢²‡i›|wŸ‘w‘Ý‹•ÙwŸ‘w‘݇¤iÙwŸ‘‰·Ÿ|ŸÙ‰¢²€ž‹€i›Ù

‡hŸ|}Ÿwª›±ª›±Ü¢›Þ²Ù ° ¬†‡i›|›Ÿ–ž¬ª“w¤“x›| ª›±ª›±

Ü¢ ™‘Þ›ª›±‰¢ª›±ª›±Ü¢ «“݉¡ÜÐ ‘h•†i• <>

¬†ª›±ª›±Ü¢ €£²|ªŒÒÙª›Ù®€Ð‹ÙÚ¡•ª€““Ð}Ý}ž‹¬ª“w¤“

‰¡ÜÐ ®•i«“݉·Ÿ™ÙiŸ‰¢²‘h•wžÙ­ÙwŸ‘}ž‹¬ª“w¤“x›|¬Œ‘

ª›±ª›±Ü¢ }Ÿwٞ³Ùª›±ª›±Ü¢ ‰¢²›¥hxiŸ|ªz¢|}݉·Ÿ™ÙiŸ‰¢²

‡ž†˜h•Ù ¬Œ‘¬†ªÙ x›|¬Œ‘ª›±ª›±Ü¢ ®†iªŒÒÙ«›z‰¢

ª›±ª›±Ü¢ <> wŸ‘w‘݇¤iÙwŸ‘‰·Ÿ|ŸÙx›|ª›Ù®€Ðª›±ª›±

Ü¢ }£|x£³Ù›¥hwž‹wŸ‘¢›¥h›hŸ|ªÜ¢|ܛ «“Ý­Ù˜ž†˜h•Ù‰¢² ª™ŸÝ˜ x›|ª›Ù®€Ðª›±ª›±Ü¢ «“݉¡ÜÐ wŸ‘ž‹ž³|wŸ‘

w‘݇¤iÙwŸ‘‰·Ÿ|ŸÙx›|ª›Ù®€Ðª›±ª›±Ü¢ }£|‰·Ÿ®†i¬†wŸ‘

ž‹ž³|wŸ‘‰·Ÿ|ŸÙx›|ª›±ª›±Ü¢ ™‘Þ›“†}·ŸÙ•Ùx›|ª›±

ª›±Ü¢ «“Ý™‘Þ›ªÜ¡²}·ŸÙ•Ù‰¡ÜÐ

­ÙwŸ‘–£w—ŸÙ¢³®†i­i z›ÙzŸÙŸ•Ÿ“¡Ù ª› ™‘Þ› z›Ù ª›

$PODBOBWBMJO " PS $PO " ­ÙwŸ‘}·Ÿ“›|˜ŽŸ•Ý‰¢²¢

wŸ‘w‘݇¤iÙwŸ‘‰·Ÿ|ŸÙx›|ª›Ù®€Ð ª›±ª›±Ü¢ ¬†ª“¢³|

ª€““Э٘ŽŸ•Ý‰¢²¢z›Ù ª› ŽŸ™“ž|}Ÿwª€““ИžÚž˜z“›ªœw€¡

†¢ÙªŒÒÙª•“Ÿ ٟ‰¢ ªÜÞ²›ª“¢²|ړ‰Ÿ|ªz¢‰¢²›Ÿ}}ݪw¡†x£³Ù x›|z“›ªœw€¡†¢Ù«“Ýz›Ù ª› ¢‘Ÿ|ŸÙ•hŸ z›Ù ª›­™iړ

(10)

­ÙwŸ‘ªÜ¡²Œ‘¡ŸØª›±ª›±Ü¢ ­Ùª€““Й“ŸÙ¡† <>

wŸ‘‰¢²z›Ù ª› ˜ŸŸ‘ˆª™Ù¢²•Ù·Ÿ­™iªw¡†«›z‰¢ª›±ª›±Ü¢

ªÜ¡²Ÿwx£³Ù}£|ªw¡†®†i}ŸwwŸ‘ªÜ¡²}·ŸÙ•Ùx›| ª›±ª›±Ü¢

<> ­ÙwŸ‘–£w—ŸÙ¢³Ü‹•hŸz“›ªœw€¡†¢Ù‰¢²z•Ÿªxixiّi›

“Ý €£²|ªŒÒّ݆ž‹‰¢²®hªŒÒÙÜ¡—‡h›ª€““ИŸŸ‘ˆž‹ž³|

wŸ‘w‘݇¤iÙwŸ‘‰·Ÿ|ŸÙx›|ª›Ù®€Ðª›±ª›±Ü¢ ­Ùª€““Ð ª›±Ù£†Œ‘¡‰žÙ‡Ðx›|Ù¤—Ð‰¢²ˆ¥wª™Ù¢²•Ù·Ÿ†i• z›Ù ª› ®†i

­ÙwŸ‘–£w—ŸÙ¢³w±Ü‹•hŸz“›ªœw€¡†¢Ù ®h¢Ú“‡h›

Œ‘¡ŸØx›|ª›±ª›±Ü¢ ‰¢²ˆ¥w˜‘iŸ|››wŸÙ›wª€““Ъ›±Ù£†

Œ‘¡‰žÙ‡Ð €£²|˜›†z“i›|wž‹Ú“wŸ‘«˜†|››wx›|¢Ù‰¢²Ü‹•hŸwŸ‘

«˜†|››wx›|¢Ùª›±ª›±Ü¢ ®hªŒ“¢²Ù«Œ“| ٛw}ŸwÙ¢³ wŸ‘«˜†|››wx›|¢Ùª›±ª›±Ü¢ «“݉¡ÜÐ w±®h܋wŸ‘

ªŒ“¢²Ù«Œ“|ªhÙª†¢•wžÙ †ž|ٞ³ÙwŸ‘‰¢²z“›ªœw€¡†¢Ù˜ŸŸ‘ˆ

ž‹ž³|wŸ‘w‘݇¤iÙwŸ‘‰·Ÿ|ŸÙx›|ª›Ù®€Ðª›±ª›±Ü¢ }£|ÙhŸ

}ݪw¡†}Ÿww“®w‰¢²z“›ªœw€¡†¢Ù˜ŸŸ‘ˆž‹ž³|wŸ‘‰·Ÿ|ŸÙ x›|ª›Ù®€Ð­Ùw“¤hª›±ª›±Ü¢ †i•z¤Ø˜‹ž‡¡z¢ª“ž²Ù €£²|­Ù w‘Ý‹•ÙwŸ‘w‘݇¤iÙª›±ª›±Ü¢ ٞ³Ù‡i›|›Ÿ–žwŸ‘‰·Ÿ|ŸÙ x›| ª›Ù®€Ðª›±ª›±Ü¢ wŸ‘‰¢²ª›Ù®€Ðª›±ª›±Ü¢ ®h

˜ŸŸ‘ˆ‰·Ÿ|ŸÙ®†i }£|®hªw¡†wŸ‘w‘݇¤iÙwŸ‘‰·Ÿ|ŸÙx›|ª›±

ª›±Ü¢ z•Ÿ˜ŸŸ‘ˆx›|z“›ªœw€¡†¢Ù­ÙwŸ‘ž‹ž³|wŸ‘

‰·Ÿ|ŸÙx›|ª›±Ù®€Ðª›±ª›±Ü¢«‡h“ÝÙ¡†Ùž³Ù®hª‰hŸwžÙ <>

›Ÿ}ªÙÞ²›|}Ÿw¬z‘|˜‘iŸ|˜Ÿ¡‡¡x›|ª›±ª›±Ü¢ «‡h“ÝÙ¡†

¢z•Ÿ«‡w‡hŸ|wžÙ Œ‘¡ŸØz“›ªœw€¡†¢Ù‰¢²­i­ÙwŸ‘ž‹ž³|

}£|®hª‰hŸwžÙ ‡Ÿ‘Ÿ|ŸÙwŸ‘–£w—Ÿ­Ù™“›†‰†“›|‰¢²Ü‹

•hŸz“›ªœw€¡†¢Ù‰¢²z•Ÿªxixiّi›“Ý «“Ý

˜ŸŸ‘ˆž‹ž³|wŸ‘‰·Ÿ|ŸÙx›|ª›±ª›±Ü¢ «“Ý ‡Ÿ“·Ÿ†ž‹ †i•x‹•ÙwŸ‘z¢ª“ž²Ù

ړx›|z“›ªœw€¡†¢Ù‰¢²˜ŸŸ‘ˆž‹ž³|wŸ‘w‘݇¤iÙwŸ‘

‰·Ÿ|ŸÙx›|ª›Ù®€Ðª›±ª›±Ü¢ ­ÙwŸ‘–£w—ŸÙ¢³˜h•Ù™Ù£²|ÙhŸ

}ݪw¡†}Ÿw¬ª“w¤“x›|z“›ªœw€¡†¢Ù‰¢²ªwŸÝ›¥h­Ù™“¤x›|

}ŸÙª“¢³|ª€““Ð ‰¢²ž|z|¢’‰Š¡¶›¥h™“ž|}ŸwÙ·Ÿz“›ªœw€¡†¢Ù‰¢²

˜žÚž˜ª€““ЪŒÒÙª•“Ÿ ٟ‰¢››w®Œ«“i• €£²|Œ‘¡ŸØz“›

ªœw€¡†¢Ù‰¢²z|›¥h›Ÿ}«‡w‡hŸ|}Ÿw˜ŽŸ•Ý}‘¡|­Ùh›|ŒŸw }£|

ªŒÒى¢²ÙhŸ˜Ù­}­ÙwŸ‘–£w—Ÿ‡h›®Œ•hŸ ˜ŽŸ•Ý­Ùh›|ŒŸw}‘¡|

ٞ³Ùz“›ªœw€¡†¢Ù}ݏ¢z•Ÿ˜ŸŸ‘ˆ­ÙwŸ‘ž‹ž³|wŸ‘w‘݇¤iÙ wŸ‘‰·Ÿ|ŸÙx›|ª›Ù®€Ðª›±ª›±Ü¢ ®†i†¢ªÜ¢|­†

‹‰˜‘¤Œ

Ù·³ŸŸ‹i•ÙŒŸwz“›ªœw€¡†¢ÙªŒÒÙÙ·³ŸŸ‹i•ÙŒŸw

Ÿ‡‘„ŸÙ (PME TUBOEBSE ˜·Ÿ™‘ž‹wŸ‘ž³‹ž³|wŸ‘ªw¡†

z‘Ÿ‹}¤“¡Ù‰‘¢Ð«“Ý“†wŸ‘›žwª˜‹x›|ª™|ޛw­ÙÚ¥iŒd•¬‘z

Œ‘¡‰žÙ‡Ð›žwª˜‹ ­Ùz•Ÿªxixiى¢²˜¥|z“›ªœw€¡†¢Ù­™iړ†¢­Ù wŸ‘ÕhŸªÞ³›‘Ÿ«“Ý«‹z‰¢ª‘¢ «‡h܋•hŸªŒÒÙÜ¡—‡h›ª€““Ð ™“ž|

›‹i•ÙŒŸw܋•hŸz“›ªœw€¡†¢Ù˜ŸŸ‘ˆ¢’‰Š¡¶z|›¥h­Ùh›|

ŒŸw®†iªŒÒÙª•“ŸÙŸÙ †i•z•Ÿªxixiى¢²zh› ° “†“| ­Ù z•Ÿªxixiى¢²‡·²ŸªhÙ­ÙwŸ‘–£w—ŸÙ¢³ z“›ªœw€¡†¢Ù}Ý®hªŒÒÙ Ü¡—‡h›ª€““Ð «“ݐž|¢Ú“­ÙwŸ‘ž‹ž³|wŸ‘w‘݇¤iÙwŸ‘‰·Ÿ|ŸÙ x›|ª›Ù®€Ðª›±ª›±Ü¢ ›¢w†i•

w¡‡‡¡w‘‘Œ‘ÝwŸ–

|ŸÙ•¡}žÙ¢³ ®†i‘ž‹ª|¡Ù‰¤Ù˜Ùž‹˜Ù¤ÙwŸ‘•¡}ž}Ÿwª|¡Ù‘Ÿ®†i zØ݉žÙ‡«Ü‰–Ÿ˜‡‘Ð ™Ÿ•¡‰Ÿ“ž–‘¢Ùz‘¡Ù‰‘•¡¬‘×

Œ‘Ý}·ŸŒ` ˜žÖ֟ª“x‰¢²

ª›w˜Ÿ‘›iŸ|›¡|

$POTFOTVT SFQPSU 1FSJPEPOUBM EJTFBTFT QBUIPHFOFTJT BOE NJDSPCJBM GBDUPST "OO 1FSJPEPOUPM

*OHNBO 5 4PSTB 5 -JOEZ 0 ,PTLJ ) ,POUUJOFO :5 .VMUJQMF GPSNT PG HFMBUJOBTFTUZQF

*7 DPMMBHFOBTFT JO TBMJWB BOE HJOHJWBM DSFWJDVMBS ÈVJE PG QFSJPEPOUJUJT QBUJFOUT + $MJO 1FSJPEPOUPM

"JCB 5 "LFOP / ,BXBOF 5 0LBNPUP ) )PSJVDIJ / .BUSJY NFUBMMPQSPUFJOBTFT BOE BOE 5*.1 N3/" MFWFMT JO OPSNBM BOE EJTFBTFE IVNBO HJOHJWBF &VS + 0SBM 4DJ

,VCPUB 5 /PNVSB 5 5BLBIBTIJ 5 )BSB , &YQSFTTJPO PG N3/" GPS NBUSJY NFUBMMPQSP UFJOBTFT BOE UJTTVF JOIJCJUPST PG NFUBMMPQSPUFJOBTFT JO QFSJPEPOUJUJT BGGFDUFE IVNBO HJOHJWBM UJTTVF

"SDI 0SBM #JPM

(11)

5FSWBIBSUJBMB 5 1JSJMB & $FQPOJT " .BJTJ 1 4BMP 5 5VUFS ( FU BM 5IF JO WJWP FYQSFTTJPO PG UIF DPMMBHFOPMZUJD NBUSJY NFUBMMPQSPUFJOBTFT ..1 BOE BOE NBUSJMZTJO ..1 JO BEVMU BOE MPDBMJ[FE KVWFOJMF QFSJPEPOUJUJT + %FOU 3FT

%BIBO . /BXSPDLJ # &MLBJN 3 4PFMM .

#PMDBUP#FMMFNJO "- #JSFNCBVU 1 FU BM &YQSFTTJPO PG NBUSJY NFUBMMPQSPUFJOBTFT JO IFBMUI BOE EJTFBTFE IVNBO HJOHJWBM + $MJO 1FSJPEPOUPM

&KFJM "- *HPOEKP5DIFO 4 (IPNSBTTFOJ 4 1FMMBU # (PEFBV ( (PHMZ # &YQSFTTJPO PG NBUSJY NFUBMMPQSPUFJOBTFT ..1T BOE UJTTVF JOIJCJUPST PG NFUBMMPQSPUFJOBTFT 5*.1T JO IFBMUIZ BOE EJTFBTFE IVNBO HJOHJWB + 1FSJPEPOUPM

4NJUI 1$ .VOP[ 7$ $PMMBEPT - 0ZBS[VO

"% *O TJUV EFUFDUJPO PG NBUSJY NFUBMMPQSPUFJOBTF ..1 JO HJOHJWBM FQJUIFMJVN JO IVNBO QFSJPEPOUBM EJTFBTF + 1FSJPEPOUBM 3FT

4USPOHJO ": $PMMJFS * #BOOJEPW ( .BSNFS #- (SBOU (" (PMECFSH (* .FDIBOJTN PG DFMM TVSGBDF BDUJWBUJPO PG L%B UZQF *7 DPMMBHFOBTF *TPMBUJPO PG UIF BDUJWBUFE GPSN PG UIF NFNCSBOF NFUBMMPQSPUFBTF + #JPM $IFN

-JN ,4 ,BN 1$ $IMPSIFYJEJOF 1IBSNBDPMPHZ BOE DMJOJDBM BQQMJDBUJPOT "OBFTUI

*OUFOTJWF $BSF o

,VZZBLBOPOE 5 2VFTOFM -# 5IF NFDIBOJTN PG BDUJPO PG DIMPSIFYJEJOF '&.4 .JDSPCJPM -FUU o o

#BSSFUU#FF , /FXCPVMU - &EXBSET 4 5IF NFNCSBOF EFTUBCJMJ[JOH BDUJPO PG UIF BOUJCBDUFSJBM BHFOU DIMPSIFYJEJOF '&.4 .JDSPCJPMPHZ -FUUFST o o

- F ) 4DIJPUU $3 5IF FGGFDU PG N P V U I S J O T F T B O E U P Q J D B M B Q Q M J D B U J P O P G DIMPSIFYJEJOF PO UIF EFWFMPQNFOU PG EFOUBM QMBRVF BOE HJOHJWJUJT JO NBO + 1FSJPEPOUBM 3FT

,PSPTUPGG +. 8BOH +' 4BSNFOU %1 4UFXBSU +$ 'FMENBO 34 #JMMJOHT 1$ "OBMZTJT PG JO TJUV QSPUFBTF BDUJWJUZ JO DISPOJD BEVMU QFSJPEPOUJUJT QBUJFOUT FYQSFTTJPO PG BDUJWBUFE ..1 BOE B L%B TFSJOF QSPUFBTF + 1FSJPEPOUPM

"DIPOH 3 /JTIJNVSB * 3BNBDIBOESBO ) )PXFMM 5) 'JPSFMMJOJ +1 ,BSJNCVY /:

.FNCSBOF UZQF .5 o NBUSJY NFUBMMPQSPUFJO BTF ..1 BOE ..1 FYQSFTTJPO JO MJHBUVSFJO EVDFE QFSJPEPOUJUJT JO UIF SBU + 1FSJPEPOUPM

(FOESPO 3 (SFOJFS % 4PSTB 5 .BZSBOE % *OIJCJUJPO PG UIF BDUJWJUJFT PG NBUSJY NFUBMMPQSPUFJOBTFT BOE CZ DIMPSIFYJEJOF

$MJO %JBHO -BC *NNVOPM

#POFTWPMM 1 0SBM QIBSNBDPMPHZ PG DIMPSIFYJEJOF + $MJO 1FSJPEPOUPM

3¿MMB ( -öF ) 4DIJPUU $3 5IF BèOJUZ PG DIMPSIFYJEJOF GPS IZESPYZBQBUJUF BOE TBMJWBSZ NVDJOT + 1FSJPEPOUBM 3FT

$IFO : 8POH 38 4FOFWJSBUOF $+

)BHH 6 .D(SBUI $ 4BNBSBOBZBLF -1 $PNQBS JTPO PG UIF BOUJNJDSPCJBM BDUJWJUZ PG -JTUFSJOF BOE

$PSTPEZM PO PSUIPEPOUJD CSBDLFUT JO WJUSP "N + 0SUIPE %FOUPGBDJBM 0SUIPQ

(SFFOTUFJO ( #FSNBO $ +BèO 3

$IMPSIFYJEJOF "O BEKVODU UP QFSJPEPOUBM UIFSBQZ + 1FSJPEPOUPM

(12)

4BODIF[ *3 /VTCBVN ,& 4XBJN 4'

)BMF "4 )FOEFSTPO 3" .D(VJSF +" $IMPSIFYJEJOF EJBDFUBUF BOE QPWJEPOF JPEJOF DZUPUPYJDJUZ UP DBOJOF FNCSZPOJD ÇCSPCMBTUT BOE 4UBQIZMPDPDDVT BVSFVT 7FU TVSH

5BUOBMM '. -FJHI *. (JCTPO +3

$PNQBSBUJWF TUVEZ PG BOUJTFQUJD UPYJDJUZ PO CBTBM LFSBUJOPDZUFT USBOTGPSNFE IVNBO LFSBUJOPDZUFT BOE ÇCSPCMBTUT 4LJO 1IBSNBDPM

1VDIFS ++ %BOJFM +$ 5IF FGGFDU PG DIMPSIFYJEJOF EJHMVDPOBUF PO IVNBO ÇCSPCMBTUT JO WJUSP + 1FSJPEPOUPM

.JSIBEJ ) "[BS .3 "CCBT[BEFHBO "

(FSBNJ[BEFI # 5PSBCJ 4 3BITB[ . $ZUPUPYJDJUZ PG DIMPSIFYJEJOF oIZESPHFO QFSPYJEF DPNCJOBUJPO JO EJGGFSFOU DPODFOUSBUJPOT PO DVMUVSFE IVNBO QFSJPEPOUBM MJHBNFOU ÇCSPCMBTUT %FOU 3FT + *TGBIBO

#BCJDI ) 8V[CVSHFS #+ 3VCJO :- 4JOFOTLZ .$ #MBV - "O JO WJUSP TUVEZ PO UIF DZUPUPYJDJUZ PG DIMPSIFYJEJOF EJHMVDPOBUF UP IVNBO HJOHJWBM DFMMT $FMM #JPM 5PYJDPM

:V . 4BUP ) 4FJLJ . 5IPNQTPO

&8 $PNQMFY SFHVMBUJPO PG NFNCSBOFUZQF NBUSJY NFUBMMPQSPUFJOBTF FYQSFTTJPO BOE NBUSJY NFUBMMPQSPUFJOBTF BDUJWBUJPO CZ DPODBOBWBMJO "

JO .%".# IVNBO CSFBTU DBODFS DFMMT

$BODFS 3FT

5IFSFU / -FIUJ , .VTTP 0 $MFNFOU # ..1 BDUJWBUJPO CZ DPMMBHFO * BOE DPODBOBWBMJO

" JO DVMUVSFE IVNBO IFQBUJD TUFMMBUF DFMMT )FQBUPMPHZ

5 J S B O B U I B O B H V M 4 1 B U U B N B Q V O :POHDIBJUSBLVM 5 1BWBTBOU 1 6QSFHVMBUJPO PG .5..1 JO 1%- DFMMT CZ CBDUFSJBM TVQFSOBUBOU + %FOU "TTPD 5IBJ

.VTUFBUB '. 1BXMJT[ZO + "TTBZ PG TUBCJMJUZ GSFF BOE UPUBM DPODFOUSBUJPO PG DIMPSIFYJEJOF JO TBMJWB CZ TPMJE QIBTF NJDSPFYUSBDUJPO + 1IBSN

#JPNFE "OBM "QS 5TVDIJZB ) .JZB[BLJ 5 0INPUP 4 )JHIQFSGPSNBODF MJRVJE DISPNBUPHSBQIJD BOBMZTJT PG DIMPSIFYJEJOF JO TBMJWB BGUFS NPVUISJOTJOH $BSJFT 3FT

1BWBTBOU 1 :POHDIBJUSBLVM 5 #JPMPHZ PG QFSJPEPOUBM MJHBNFOU DFMMT #BOHLPL .JTUFS,PQZ 5IBJMBOE $P -UE Q

‡¡†‡h›‹‰z•Ÿ

›‰Üֆ‘ ˜¡‘¡“žw—ØÐ ‡¢‘؊ٟw¤“

ŽŸz•¡Ÿ¬›—„•¡‰Ÿ zØ݉žÙ‡«Ü‰–Ÿ˜‡‘Ð

™Ÿ•¡‰Ÿ“ž–‘¢Ùz‘¡‰‘•¡¬‘×

˜¤x¤•¡‰ «x•|z“›|ª‡ª™Ùޛ

ªx‡•ž×ٟ w‰

¬‰‘–žÜ‰Ð ‡h›

}†™Ÿ›¡ª“±w‰‘›Ù¡w˜Ð TJSJMVL!TXVBDUI

$PrrFsQPOEJOH aVtIPr

%S 4JSJMVDL 5JSBOBUIBOBHVM

%FQBSUNFOU PG 4UPNBUPMPHZ 'BDVMUZ PG %FOUJTUSZ 4SJOBLIBSJOXJSPU 6OJWFSTJUZ

4VLIVNWJU 8BUUBOB #BOHLPL 5IBJMBOE 5FM FYU

&NBJM TJSJMVL!TXVBDUI

Referensi

Dokumen terkait

8% SIMILARITY INDEX 5% INTERNET SOURCES 4% PUBLICATIONS 4% STUDENT PAPERS 1 2% 2 1% 3 1% 4 1% 5 1% 6 1% 2023_AACL_BIOFLUX.pdf ORIGINALITY REPORT PRIMARY SOURCES Submitted

5% SIMILARITY INDEX 4% INTERNET SOURCES 4% PUBLICATIONS 3% STUDENT PAPERS 1 1% 2 1% 3 1% 4 1% 5 1% 6 1% Exclude quotes On Exclude matches < 1% Assessing the Governance Modes