• Tidak ada hasil yang ditemukan

View of Effects of Estrogen Deprivation and Titanium Surfaces on Osteogenic Differentiation of Human Bone Marrow Stromal Cells, an in Vitro Study

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2023

Membagikan "View of Effects of Estrogen Deprivation and Titanium Surfaces on Osteogenic Differentiation of Human Bone Marrow Stromal Cells, an in Vitro Study"

Copied!
9
0
0

Teks penuh

(1)

ARSQ@BS

.AIDBSHUDR3GDRSTCX@HLDCSNHMUDRSHF@SDDEEDBSRNEDRSQNFDMCDEHBHDMBX@MCSHS@MHTL RTQE@BDRNMFQNVSG@MCNRSDNFDMHBCHEEDQDMSH@SHNMNEG!,2"R

,DSGNCR4MCDQ@VQHSSDMHMENQLDCBNMRDMSGTL@MANMDL@QQNVRSQNL@KBDKKRG!,2"R VDQDG@QUDRSDCBTKSTQDC@MCRDDCDCNMBDKKBTKSTQDOK@SDR@MCSHS@MHTLCHRJR2SQ@TL@MM2VHSYDQK@MC RLNNSG@MCR@MCAK@RSDC@BHCDSBGDC2+ SHS@MHTLRTQE@BDR3GDMBDKKRVDQDBTKSTQDCHMDRSQNFDM CDOQHUDC$#FQNVSGLDCHTLENQG@MCRTARDPTDMSKXHMBNMUDMSHNM@K%!2.2@MC$#NRSDNFDMHB

$#.2LDCH@ENQC@X$W@LHM@SHNMTMCDQRB@MMHMFDKDBSQNMLHBQNRBNOD2$,V@RODQENQLDC SN@RRDRRBDKKUH@AHKHSX@SS@BGLDMSLNQOGNKNFHDR@MCFQNVSG"DKKUH@AHKHSX@RR@XV@RBNMCTBSDCSN CDSDQLHMDBDKKFQNVSG KJ@KHMDOGNROG@S@RD@BSHUHSX@MCB@KBHTLBNMSDMSRKDUDKRVDQDLD@RTQDCSN DU@KT@SDNRSDNFDMHBCHEEDQDMSH@SHNMONSDMSH@KM,D@M±2#

1DRTKSR3HS@MHTLRTQE@BDLHBQNSNONFQ@OGHDR@MC$#BDKKBTKSTQDHMEKTDMBDCBDKKLNQOGNKNFX

@SS@BGLDMS@MCFQNVSG'TL@M!,2"RVDQDROHMCKDRG@ODCBDKKRNMBDKKBTKSTQDOK@SD@MCRLNNSG SHS@MHTLRTQE@BDRVGHKDNM2+ SHS@MHTLRTQE@BDBDKKRVDQDRSDKK@SDKHJDBDKKR$RSQNFDMCDOQHUDC BDKKBTKSTQDCDBQD@RDCBDKK@SS@BGLDMSFQNVSG@MCNRSDNFDMHBCHEEDQDMSH@SHNMONSDMSH@KNEG!,2"R KJ@KHMDOGNROG@S@RD@BSHUHSX@MCB@KBHTLBNMSDMSKDUDKRNM@KKRTQE@BDRHM$#.2VDQDL@QJDCKX@MC RHFMHEHB@MSKXKNVDQSG@M%!2.2LDCH@O/QNLNSHMFDEEDBSRNE2+ RTQE@BDNMNRSDNFDMHB CHEEDQDMSH@SHNM +/@BSHUHSX@MCB@KBHTLBNMSDMSRVDQDENTMCNMKXHM%!2.2MNS$#.2LDCH@

"NMBKTRHNMR$RSQNFDMCDOQHUDCBDKKBTKSTQDCDBQD@RDCBDKKFQNVSG@MCNRSDNFDMHB CHEEDQDMSH@SHNMNEG!,2"R 2+ RTQE@BDBNTKCMNSOQNLNSDNRSDNFDMHBCHEEDQDMSH@SHNMNEG!,2"R HM$#BNMCHSHNM3GTRLNCHEHB@SHNMNESHS@MHTLRTQE@BDLHBQNSNONFQ@OGX@KNMDLHFGSADHMRTEEHBHDMS SNDMG@MBDNRSDNHMSDFQ@SHNMNECDMS@KHLOK@MSHMNRSDNONQNSHBANMD

Key words:.RSDNONQNRHR2@MCAK@RSDC@MC@BHCDSBGDCSHS@MHTLRTQE@BD.RSDNAK@RSHBCHEEDQDMSH@SHNM

*Graduate Student, Department of Oral & Maxillofacial Surgery, Faculty of Dentistry, Prince of Songkla University, Hat Yai, Songkhla, Thailand

**Associate Professor, Department of Oral & Maxillofacial Surgery, Faculty of Dentistry ,Prince of Songkla University, Hat Yai, Songkhla, Thailand

***Associate Professor, Department of Orthopaedic Surgery & Physical Medicine, School of Medicine, Faculty of Medicine, Prince of Songkla University, Hat Yai, Songkhla, Thailand

$EEDBSRNE$RSQNFDM#DOQHU@SHNM@MC3HS@MHTL2TQE@BDRNM .RSDNFDMHB#HEEDQDMSH@SHNMNE'TL@M!NMD,@QQNV2SQNL@K

"DKKR@Min Vitro2STCX

"GNMSHBG@"GNNJH@QSRHQH /QHR@M@/QHO@SM@MNMS !NNMRHM3@MFSQ@JTKV@MHBG

/QDLIHS QONQML@DJKNMF

(2)

SWU Dent J. Vol.7 Suppl 2014

3GDBTQQDMSRSTCX@HLDCSNHMUDRSHF@SD DEEDBSRNE2+ SHS@MHTLRTQE@BDRNMFQNVSG@MC NRSDNFDMHBCHEEDQDMSH@SHNMNEG!,2"RHM$#BDKK BTKSTQD

,@SDQH@KR@MC,DSGNCR BDKKBTKSTQDLNCDK

!NMD L@QQNV BDKK BTKSTQD 4MCDQ ODQLHRRHNM EQNL @M $SGHB@K "NLLHSSDD NE 2NMFJK@M@F@QHMC 'NROHS@K @MC O@SHDMS VQHSSDM HMENQLDCBNMRDMSANMDL@QQNVV@RG@QUDRSDCEQNL GD@KSGXL@KDO@SHDMSRTMCDQFNHMFNQSGNO@DCHB RTQFDQX@FDÁXD@QR!NMDL@QQNVV@R BTKSTQDC@RCDRBQHADC:< SO@RR@FD%HF GTL@M ANMD L@QQNV RSQNL@K BDKKR G!,2"R EQNLO@SHDMSRVDQDONNK@MCDWO@MCDCENQ O@RR@FDRENQSGDDWODQHLDMS%HF!

"TKSTQD LDCHTLR &QNVSG LDCHTL BNLOQHRDCNE#,$,%EDS@KANUHMDRDQTL

%!2ODMHBHKKHMRSQDOSNLXBHM@MC ETMFHYNMD.RSDNFDMHB.2LDCHTLV@RFQNVSG LDCHTLRTOOKDLDMSDCVHSGL,@RBNQAHB@BHC L,ȕFKXBDQNOGNROG@SD @MC M, CDW@LDSG@RNMD %NQ DRSQNFDMCDOQHUDC $#

BTKSTQDLDCH@OGDMNKQDCEQDD#,$,%@MC BG@QBN@KRSQHOODC%!2VDQDTRDC@KKEQNL2HFL@

42 :<

"DKK RDDCHMF 3HS@MHTL CHRJR RLNNSG

@MC2+ SHS@MHTLRTQE@BDRRHYDWLLVDQD JHMCKX OQNUHCDC AX 2SQ@TL@MM 2SQ@TL@MM 2VHSYDQK@MC%HF"#$WO@MCDCG!,2"RHM

%!2FQNVSGLDCHTLVDQDRDDCDCNMBDKKBTKSTQD OK@SDR "NQMHMF 42 @MC RLNNSG @MC 2+

SHS@MHTL CHRJR "DKK RDDCHMF CDMRHSX ENQ BDKK FQNVSGRSTCXV@RWBDKKRBL@MCNRSDNFDMHB CHEEDQDMSH@SHNM RSTCX V@R W BDKKRBL (MSQNCTBSHNM

$RSQNFDMRTOONQSRBDKKFQNVSGCDBQD@RDR

@ONOSNRHR@MCOQNLNSDRNRSDNFDMHBCHEEDQDMSH@SHNM NEGTL@MANMDL@QQNVRSQNL@KBDKKRG!,2"R

@MCNRSDNAK@RSR:<$RSQNFDMCDOQHU@SHNM$#HM ONRSLDMNO@TR@KVNLDMB@TRDRHLA@K@MBDANMD QDLNCDKHMF:<QDRTKSHMFHMNRSDNONQNSHBANMDVHSG SGHMSQ@ADBTK@QANMD@MCONNQANMDLHBQN@QBGHSDBSTQD :< R@KNMFKHEDDWODBS@MBXHMBQD@RDRMTLADQR NE@FHMFONOTK@SHNM:<@GHFGDQMTLADQNEDKCDQKX HMBQD@RDRSGDCDL@MCENQCDMS@KHLOK@MSOK@BDLDMSR HMNRSDNONQNSHBANMD

.RSDNONQNRHRBNTKCADBNMRHCDQDC@R@

QHRJE@BSNQENQRTQUHU@KNECDMS@KHLOK@MS.RSDNONQNSHB ANMDCDLNMRSQ@SDRMDF@SHUDDEEDBSRNMNOSHL@K NRRSDNHMSDFQ@SHNM @MC HLOK@MS RS@AHKHSX HM NU@QHDBSNLHYDCQ@SR@MCQ@AAHSR:<!@RDCNM SGDQDONQSRSG@SSHS@MHTLRTQE@BDLHBQNSNONFQ@OGX QDFTK@SDRBDKKFQNVSG@MCCHEEDQDMSH@SHNM:<@MC R@MCAK@RSDC @MC @BHCDSBGDC 2+ SHS@MHTL RTQE@BDG@RADDMQDONQSDCSNDMG@MBDNRSDNAK@RSHB CHEEDQDMSH@SHNM:<@MCQDCTBDRGD@KHMFSHLDNESGD HLOK@MS:<2@MCAK@RSDC@MC@BHCDSBGDCSHS@MHTL RTQE@BDLHFGSAD@AKDSNDMG@MBDNRSDNHMSDFQ@SHNM NESHS@MHTLHLOK@MSHMNRSDNONQNSHBANMD 3NLHLHBDRSQNFDMCDOQHUDCBNMCHSHNMHM ONRSLDMNO@TRD B@RDR DRSQNFDM CDOQHUDC BDKK BTKSTQDB@MADDRS@AKHRGDCAXTSHKHYHMFBG@QBN@K RSQHOODCANUHMDRDQTL@MCOGDMNKQDCEQDDBTKSTQD LDCHTL SN QDLNUD DRSQNFDMHB @BSHUHSX NE EDS@K ANUHMDRDQTL@MCBDKKBTKSTQDLDCHTL/GDMNK QDCHMBDKKBTKSTQDLDCHTLHR@AKDSNRSHLTK@SD BDKKR FQNVSG @MC CHEEDQDMSH@SHNM QDOKHB@SHMF DRSQNFDMHBKHJD@BSHUHSXHMBDKKBTKSTQD:<"G@QBN@K RSQHOODCANUHMDRDQTLHRDRSQNFDM@MCKHOHCKHJD BNLONMDMSREQDDRDQTLSG@SHRTRDETKENQRSTCXHMF GNQLNMD@MCFQNVSGE@BSNQRQDRONMRDRHMBDKK

(3)

Figure 1. Demonstrating morphologies of hBMSCs (A) at primary, (B) 3rd passage, and scanning electron microscope images of (C) smooth and (D) sandblasted and acid-etched

(SLA) titanium surfaces. Insets represent (C) smooth and (D) SLA titanium disks.

HM $#FQNVSG LDCHTL ENQ GQ ESDQ SG@S BTKSTQDLDCHTLV@RBG@MFDCSNQDFTK@Q%!2@MC

$#FQNVSG LDCH@ ENQ BDKK FQNVSG @MC QDFTK@Q

%!2.2@MC$#NRSDNFDMHBLDCH@$#.2 ENQNRSDNFDMHBCHEEDQDMSH@SHNMRSTCHDRBNMRSHSTSHMF FQNTORNERSTCX:<

(MUDRSHF@SHNMR

"DKK@SS@BGLDMS@MCLNQOGNKNFXNARDQU@SHNMR Scanning electron microscope: "DKK LNQOGNKNFX @MC @SS@BGLDMS NM SHS@MHTL CHRJR VDQD@RRDRRDCNOSHB@KKXNMC@XR@MCTRHMF RB@MMHMF DKDBSQNM LHBQNRBNOD 2$, +5 )$.+)@O@M"DKKRVDQDEHWDCHMFKTS@Q@KCDGXCD

@MC ENQL@KCDGXCD CDGXCQ@SDC HM DSG@MNK RDQHDRNE@HQCQHDCFNKCROTSSDQBN@SDC

@MCHL@FDCMENQD@BGHMUDRSHF@SHNMSHLD:<

"DKKFQNVSG

Cell viability assay:"DKKUH@AHKHSXV@R LD@RTQDCSNQDOQDRDMSBDKKFQNVSG.MC@X BDKKRVDQDHMBTA@SDCHM"DKK3HSDQ® PTDNTR .MD2NKTSHNM"DKK/QNKHEDQ@SHNM RR@X/QNLDF@

42 HM OGDMNK QDC EQDD BTKSTQD LDCHTL VHSG

%!2ENQGQHM@GTLHCHEHDCHMBTA@SNQ@S º"VHSG".SGDMSGDENQL@Y@MCXDV@R PT@MSHEHDC@SML@ARNQA@MBDNMCTOKHB@SD R@LOKDR ,TKSHRJ@M &. 3GDQLN 2BHDMSHEHB

%HMK@MCMLD@M±2#:<

.RSDNFDMHBCHEEDQDMSH@SHNM

For alkaline phosphatase (ALP) activity measurement:.MC@XBDKKRVDQDKXYDCHM 3QHSNM72HFL@42 @MC@LNTMSNESNS@K OQNSDHMBNMSDMSV@RLD@RTQDCTRHMF#"/QNSDHM

(4)

SWU Dent J. Vol.7 Suppl 2014

RR@X*HS!HN1@C42 ENKKNVHMFL@MTE@BSTQDQÄR HMRSQTBSHNM"DKKKXR@SDV@RHMBTA@SDCVHSG O@Q@MHSQNOGDMNKOGNROG@SDR2HFL@XHDKCHMF@

XDKKNVRTARSQ@SDNEOMHSQNOGDMNK"NKNQHMSDMRHSX V@R QD@C @S ML @ARNQA@MBD HM CTOKHB@SD ,TKSHRJ@M&.:<

For calcium content assay:"DKKODKKDSR EQNLBDKKKXR@SDRVDQDCDLHMDQ@KHYDCNUDQMHFGSHM ,'"+@S13SGDMKDUDKRNEB@KBHTLBNMSDMSR VDQDLD@RTQDCTRHMF"@KBHTL"NKNQHLDSQHB RR@X JHS !HNUHRHNM 42 ENKKNVHMF @ L@MTE@BSTQDQÄR HMRSQTBSHNM"NMBDMSQ@SHNMRNEOMHSQNOGDMNK@MC B@KBHTLBNMSDMSRVDQDDWSQ@ONK@SDCVHSGRS@MC@QC BTQUDR NE RDQH@K CHKTSHNMR NE OMHSQNOGDMNK @MC B@KBHTLRS@MC@QCQDRODBSHUDKXSGDMMNQL@KHYDC AXSGD@LNTMSNEOQNSDHMBNMSDMSRNESGDR@LD R@LOKDR @MC QDONQSDC @R M, OMHSQNOGDMNK LF OQNSDHM @MC MF B@KBHTLLF OQNSDHM M ,D@M±2#:<

#@S@@M@KXRHR

6GDMSGDC@S@VDQDMNQL@KKXCHRSQHATSDC NMDV@X@M@KXRHRNEU@QH@MBD -.5 V@RTRDC VHSGDHSGDQSGD3TJDX'2#NQ#TMMDSSD3LDSGNCR

@R @OOQNOQH@SD .SGDQVHRD SGD *QTRJ@K6@KKHR

@M@KXRHRVHSG,@MM6GHSMDXSDRSV@RODQENQLDC

@SO 1DRTKSR

"DKK RG@ODR @SS@BGLDMS @MC FQNVSG VDQD HMEKTDMBDCAXSHS@MHTLRTQE@BDLHBQNSNONFQ@OGX

@MCDRSQNFDMCDOQHUDCBNMCHSHNM

Scanning electron microscope images CDLNMRSQ@SDCCHEEDQDMSBDKKRG@ODRNMCHEEDQDMS SHS@MHTLRTQE@BDR@MC@KNVDQBDKKCDMRHSXHM$#

SG@M%!2.2BTKSTQDLDCH@O@QSHBTK@QKXNM2+

SHS@MHTLRTQE@BD%HF #.MRLNNSGRTQE@BD G!,2"RROQD@CNTS@MCENQLHMFBDKKRGDDSBNUDQHMF SGDRTARSQ@SDRTQE@BD%HF !VGHKDNM2+

BDKKRRSQDSBGDCBDKKANCX@BQNRRQNTFGRTQE@BDR AX DWSDMCHMF RL@KK BXSNOK@RLHB OQNBDRRDR SN

@SS@BG NM ONQNTR RTQE@BD BQD@SHMF HMSDQBDKKTK@Q MDSVNQJ%HF"#+NVDQBDKKCDMRHSXNM RLNNSG@MC2+ RTQE@BDRHM$#.2%HF!#

SG@M %!2.2 LDCH@ %HF " RTFFDRSDC HMGHAHSNQXDEEDBSRNE$#BDKKBTKSTQDNMBDKKFQNVSG

"DKKRGDDSR@MCCDMRHSXVDQDSGHMMDQNMRLNNSG

@MCKNVDQNM2+ SHS@MHTLRTQE@BDRQDRODBSHUDKX HM$#.2%HF!#SG@M%!2.2%HF "

3GDHMGHAHSNQXDEEDBSRNE$#BDKKBTKSTQDNMBDKK FQNVSGV@RVNQRDMNMSGD2+ RTQE@BDHM$#.2

%HF#

(MGHAHSNQXDEEDBSRNE$#BDKKBTKSTQDNM BDKKFQNVSGV@RETQSGDQGHFGKHFGSDCAXBDKKUH@AHKHSX

@RR@X(SV@RBKD@QKXRGNVMSG@SFQNVSGNEBDKKR NM@KKRTQE@BDRHM$#FQNVSGV@RRHFMHEHB@MSKXKNVDQ SG@M %!2FQNVSG LDCH@ O 3GD GHFGDRS KDUDK NE BDKK FQNVSG V@R ENTMCNMBDKK BTKSTQD OK@SD HM %!2@MC $#FQNVSG LDCH@ O

$EEDBSR NE BDKK BTKSTQD RTQE@BD RTARSQ@SDR VDQD FQD@SDQCHRSHMBSHM$#SG@M%!2FQNVSGLDCH@(M

%!2FQNVSGLDCHTLFQNVSGNEBDKKRNMRLNNSG

@MC2+ SHS@MHTLRTQE@BDRV@RMNSRHFMHEHB@MSKX CHEEDQDMS O ATS HM $#FQNVSG LDCHTL FQNVSGNEBDKKRNM2+ RTQE@BDV@RRHFMHEHB@MSKX KNVDQSG@MRLNNSGRTQE@BDO%HF

$RSQNFDMCDOQHUDC BDKK BTKSTQD CDBQD@RDC NRSDNFDMHBCHEEDQDMSH@SHNMNEG!,2"R@MC DMG@MBHMFDEEDBSNE2+ NMSGDCHEEDQDMSH@SHNM HM$#BDKKBTKSTQDV@RMNSENTMC

(5)

Figure 3. Demonstrating cell growth derived from cell viability assay of hBMSCson day 21, on cell culture plate (Pl) and smooth (SM) and sandblasted and acid-etched (SLA) titanium

surfaces in conventional (FBS) and estrogen-deprived (ED) growth media. Symbols + represents significantly lower than cell culture plate, *, significantly lower than FBS-OS on the

same cell culture substrates, and significantly lower than other surfaces in ED-OS and FBS-OS media, at p<0.05 (n=4, Mean±SD).

Figure 2. Scanning electron microscope images of hBMSCs on smooth and SLA titanium surfaces on day 7 (A&B) on smooth and (C&D) sandblasted and acid-etched (SLA) titanium

surfaces, (A&C) in conventional (FBS-OS) and (B&D) estrogen-deprived osteogenic media (ED-OS). Inset images on C and D exhibit cell attachment on the SLA titanium surface.

(6)

SWU Dent J. Vol.7 Suppl 2014 KJ@KHMDOGNROG@S@RD +/@BSHUHSX@MC

B@KBHTLBNMSDMSKDUDKRNEG!,2"RNM@KKRTQE@BDR HM$#.2VDQDRHFMHEHB@MSKXKNVDQSG@M%!2.2 LDCH@O%HF ! KJ@KHMDOGNROG@S@RD

@BSHUHSXNM2+ HM%!2.2SDMCDCSNADGHFGDQ SG@MSGD@BSHUHSHDRBDKKBTKSTQDOK@SDR@MCRLNNSG SHS@MHTLRTQE@BDO3GDKNVDRS +/@BSHUHSX V@RENTMCNM2+ HM$#.2LDCHTLO

%HF

3GD GHFGDRS KDUDK NE B@KBHTL BNMSDMS V@RENTMCNM2+ SHS@MHTLRTQE@BDHM%!2.2

@MCSGDKNVDRSKDUDKV@RNMBDKKBTKSTQDOK@SDHM

$#.2LDCH@O+DUDKRNEB@KBHTLBNMSDMSR NMBDKKBTKSTQDOK@SD@MCRLNNSGSHS@MHTLRTQE@BD HM %!2.2 VDQD MNS CHEEDQDMS O ATS RHFMHEHB@MSKXKNVDQSG@MSGDKDUDKNM2+ SHS@MHTL RTQE@BDO(M$#.2LDCHTLB@KBHTLKDUDKR NMRLNNSG@MC2+ RTQE@BDRVDQDMNSRHFMHEHB@MSKX CHEEDQDMS O ATS VDQD RHFMHEHB@MSKX GHFGDQ SG@M SGD @BSHUHSX NM BDKK BTKSTQD OK@SD O

%HF!

Figure 4. Demonstrating osteogenic differentiation markers of hBMSCs, (A) alkaline phosphatase activity and (B) calcium contents on cell culture plate (Pl) and smooth (SM) and

sandblasted and acid-etched (SLA) titanium surfaces in conventional (FBS-OS) and estrogen-deprived osteogenic media (ED-OS) on day 21. Symbols *represents significantly

(7)

#HRBTRRHNM

3NDKTBHC@SDDEEDBSRNEDRSQNFDMCDEHBHDMBX NMNRSDNHMSDFQ@SHNMNECDMS@KHLOK@MSSGDBTQQDMS RSTCX HMUDRSHF@SDC FQNVSG @MC NRSDNFDMHB CHEEDQDMSH@SHNMNEG!,2"RNMSHS@MHTLRTQE@BDRHM

@KNMFSDQL$#BDKKBTKSTQD CUDQRDDEEDBSRNE

$#NMFQNVSG@MCNRSDNFDMHBCHEEDQDMSH@SHNMNE G!,2"RENTMCHMSGDBTQQDMSRSTCXDLOG@RHYDC HLONQS@MSQNKDRNEDRSQNFDMNMFQNVSG@MCNRSDNFDMHB CHEEDQDMSH@SHNMNEG!,2"R@MCNRSDNAK@RSR:<@MC GHFGKHFGSDCCDSDQHNQ@SHMFDEEDBSRNEONRSLDMNO@TR@K DRSQNFDMCDEHBHDMBXNMNRSDNFDMDRHRNENRSDNONQNSHB ANMD:<

#HEEDQDMBDR NE BDKK LNQOGNKNFX @MC FQNVSG NM RLNNSG @MC 2+ SHS@MHTL RTQE@BDR

%HF@MCSGDGHFGDQKDUDKRNENRSDNAK@RSHB CHEEDQDMSH@SHNMHM%!2.2SG@M$#.2LDCH@NE G!,2"R%HFRTOONQSOQDUHNTRQDONQSR:<

SG@SSHS@MHTLRTQE@BDLHBQNSNONFQ@OGXHMEKTDMBD BDKK AHNKNFHB@K QDRONMRDR :< @MC DRSQNFDM HR DRRDMSH@K SN BDKK FQNVSG @MC NRDNFDMHB CHEEDQDMSH@SHNM:<

RBDKK@SS@BGLDMSSNSGD$",OQNUHCHMF DWSDQM@KRHFM@KRQDFTK@SDRFQNVSG@MCRTQUHU@KNE G!,2"R:<@CDBQD@RHMFNE$",RXMSGDRHR O@QSHBTK@QKXBNKK@FDMSXOD(HM$#BNMCHSHNM:<

LHFGS AD @M TMCDQKHMD B@TRD SG@S @KSDQDC BDKKRTARSQ@SD HMSDQ@BSHNM @MC SGTR BDKK FQNVSG

@MCCHEEDQDMSH@SHNM M@RRTLOSHNMV@RRTOONQSDC AXSGDBTQQDMSEHMCHMFRSG@S2+ SHS@MHTLRTQE@BD HM$#.2LDCHTLBNTKCMNSDMG@MBDNRSDNFDMHB CHEEDQDMSH@SHNM NE G!,2"R (M BNMSQ@RS SGD RTOONQSHMF NE NRSDNFDMHB CHEEDQDMSH@SHNM V@R ENTMCNM2+ RTQE@BDHM%!2.2%HF@MC OQNLNSHMF DEEDBSR NE 2+ SHS@MHTL RTQE@BD NM

NRSDNFDMHB CHEEDQDMSH@SHNM NE NRSDNAK@RSR @MC G!,2"RHMQDFTK@QNRSDNFDMHBLDCHTLG@RADDM QDONQSDC:<

3@JDMSNFDSGDQSGDEHMCHMFRRTOONQSDC GXONSGDRDRSG@S$#BNMCHSHNMCDBQD@RDCFQNVSG

@MCNRSDNFDMHBCHEEDQDMSH@SHNMNEG!,2"RATSHM BNMSQ@RS2+ SHS@MHTLRTQE@BDBNTKCMNSOQNLNSD NRSDNFDMHBCHEEDQDMSH@SHNMNEG!,2"RHMDRSQNFDM CDOQHUDC BNMCHSHNM 3GTR SHS@MHTL RTQE@BD LNCHEHB@SHNM @KNMD LHFGS AD HMRTEEHBHDMS SN DMG@MBD NRSDNHMSDFQ@SHNM NE CDMS@K HLOK@MS HM NRSDNONQNSHBANMD

BJMNVKDCFDLDMSR

TSGNQRVNTKCKHJDSNSG@MJ2SQ@TL@MM 6@KCDMATQF 2VHSYDQK@MC ENQ JHMCKX OQNUHCHMF SHS@MHTLCHRJR,R2TOO@K@J#@LRQHRTJENQGDQ SDBGMHB@K @RRHRS@MBD @MC "3$" /24 ENQ E@BHKHS@SHMFSGDRSTCX3GDRSTCXV@RRTOONQSDC AX 3G@HK@MC 1DRD@QBG %TMC 12 QONQML@DJKNMF

1DEDQDMBDR

#@MF9"U@M!DYNNHIDM1+*@QODQHDM , /@O@ONTKNR 2$ +NVHJ "6 $WONRTQD NE

*2BDKKRSNDRSQNFDMDMG@MBDRNRSDNFDMDRHR

@MC HMGHAHSR @CHONFDMDRHR ) !NMD ,HMDQ 1DR

0HT 6 MCDQRDM 3$ !NKKDQRKDU ) ,@MCQTO2 AC@KK@G!,*@RRDL,/@SHDMSR VHSGGHFGANMDL@RROGDMNSXODDWGHAHSDMG@MBDC NRSDNAK@RS CHEEDQDMSH@SHNM @MC HMGHAHSHNM NE

@CHONFDMDRHR NE GTL@M LDRDMBGXL@K RSDL BDKKR)!NMD,HMDQ1DR

(8)

SWU Dent J. Vol.7 Suppl 2014

!QHFGSNM"3'TMS1,$@QKX GHRSNKNFHB@K @MC TKSQ@RSQTBSTQ@K BG@MFDR HM LDCTKK@QXEQ@BSTQDB@KKTR)!NMD)NHMS2TQF L

6HDMDQ),3HKKX)/NOTK@SHNM@FDHMF HM SGD 4MHSDC 2S@SDR NE LDQHB@ HLOKHB@SHNMR ENQOTAKHBOQNFQ@LLDR(MS)$OHCDLHNK

!DOOT**HCN'6@S@YT 3DQ@NJ@*

,@SRTTQ@,/DQH(LOK@MS!NMD#DMRHSXHM 2DMHKD .RSDNONQNRHR"G@MFDR EQNL (LOK@MS /K@BDLDMS SN .RRDNHMSDFQ@SHNM "KHM (LOK@MS

#DMS1DK@S1DR

!NQR@QH5%HMH,&H@U@QDRH&1HLNMCHMH + "GHDR@ 1 "GHTRNKH + DS @K 2@MCAK@RSDC SHS@MHTL NRSDNHMSDFQ@SHNM HM XNTMF @FDC @MC NU@QHDBSNLHYDCRGDDO(MS) QSHE.QF@MR

"@QU@KGN","@QU@KGN+%"NRS@+) 2@ ,) %HFTDHQDCN "1 YDUDCN 2 3HS@MHTL HLOK@MSR@QDLNU@KSNQPTDRSTCXHMNRSDNODMHB Q@AAHSR(MCH@M)#DMS1DR MRDKLD*!HFDQDKKD,3NONFQ@OGX DEEDBSR NE OTQD SHS@MHTL RTARSQ@SDR NM GTL@M NRSDNAK@RS KNMFSDQL @CGDRHNM BS@ !HNL@SDQ

*HDRVDSSDQ*2BGV@QSY9'TLLDQS 36 "NBGQ@M #+ 2HLORNM ) #D@M ## DS @K 2TQE@BDQNTFGMDRRLNCTK@SDRSGDKNB@KOQNCTBSHNM NEFQNVSGE@BSNQR@MCBXSNJHMDRAXNRSDNAK@RSKHJD ,&BDKKR)!HNLDC,@SDQ1DR 1NBBTYYN,6HKRNM3 OQNRODBSHUD RSTCXDU@KT@SHMF@OQNSNBNKENQVDDJRÄKN@CHMF NE2+ HLOK@MSRHMSGDONRSDQHNQL@WHKK@NMDXD@Q

QDRTKSR"KHM.Q@K(LOK@MSR1DR

!DQSGNHR 8 *@SYDMDKKDMANFDM )

*@SYDMDKKDMANFDM!2/GDMNKQDCHMSHRRTDBTKSTQD LDCH@HR@VD@JDRSQNFDMHLOKHB@SHNMRBNMBDQMHMF SGDRSTCXNEDRSQNFDMQDRONMRHUDBDKKRHMBTKSTQD /QNB-@SK B@C2BH42

@JU@@F 4S@@JDQ$3GNQRDM3

+D@ . +@GNNSH ' &QNVSG BNMSQNK NE GTL@M L@LL@QXB@MBDQBDKKR,"%BDKKRHMBTKSTQD DEEDBSNEDRSQ@CHNK@MCFQNVSGE@BSNQRHMRDQTL BNMS@HMHMFLDCHTL"@MBDQ1DR

/TBBHMDKKH ), .LTQ@ 3' 2SQDFD

#6 )DEEQDX )) /@QSQHCFD -" RDQTL E@BSNQ OQNLNSDRBNKK@FDM@RDRXMSGDRHRAX@MNRSDNAK@RSHB BDKKKHMD)"DKK/GXRHNK 8NG@X # 9G@MF ) 3GQ@HKJHKK *, QSGTQ ), 0T@QKDR +# 1NKD NE RDQTL HM SGD CDUDKNOLDMS@KDWOQDRRHNMNE@KJ@KHMDOGNROG@S@RD HM,"3$NRSDNAK@RSR)"DKK/GXRHNK

*QDARA@BG/'*TYMDSRNU2

2@SNLTQ@*$LLNMR151NVD#61NADX/&

!NMDENQL@SHNMHMUHUNBNLO@QHRNMNENRSDNFDMDRHR AX SQ@MROK@MSDC LNTRD @MC GTL@M L@QQNV RSQNL@KEHAQNAK@RSR3Q@MROK@MS@SHNM

2KNNSVDF,"2VNKHM#-DSDKDMANR )"(R@JRRNM.&.GKRRNM"$RSQNFDMDMG@MBDR FQNVSGGNQLNMDQDBDOSNQDWOQDRRHNM@MCFQNVSG

(9)

GNQLNMD@BSHNMHMQ@SNRSDNR@QBNL@BDKKR@MC GTL@MNRSDNAK@RSKHJDBDKKR)$MCNBQHMNK

QONQML@DJKNMF/ J@Q@V@SBG@Q@MFTQ@

!/QHO@SM@MNMS/%@BSNQRHMEKTDMBHMFDEEDBSRNE RODBHEHB".7HMGHAHSNQ-2 (#RNMFQNVSG@MC CHEEDQDMSH@SHNMNELNTRDNRSDNAK@RSRNMSHS@MHTL RTQE@BDR(MS).Q@K,@WHKKNE@B(LOK@MSR

QONQML@DJKNMF/2TV@SVHQNSD- /QHO@SM@MNMS/.TMFAGN*&QNVSG@MCCHEEDQDMSH@SHNM NELNTRDNRSDNAK@RSRNMBGHSNR@MBNKK@FDMRONMFDR (MS).Q@K,@WHKKNE@B2TQF 3NQFDQRNM#)!DKK2XDQ2$'NQLNMD QDOK@BDLDMSSGDQ@OX@MCOQDUDMSHNMNEMNMUDQSDAQ@K EQ@BSTQDR@LDS@@M@KXRHRNEQ@MCNLHYDCSQH@KR ) ,

!NX@M!#!@SYDQ1*HDRVDSSDQ*

+HT8"NBGQ@M#+2YLTBJKDQ,NMBKDQ2DS@K 3HS@MHTLRTQE@BDQNTFGMDRR@KSDQRQDRONMRHUDMDRR NE,&NRSDNAK@RSKHJDBDKKRSN@KOG@.'

#)!HNLDC,@SDQ1DR 2BGV@QSY9+NGL@MM"'.DEHMFDQ )!NMDV@KC+%#D@M##!NX@M!#(LOK@MS RTQE@BD BG@Q@BSDQHRSHBR LNCTK@SD CHEEDQDMSH@SHNM ADG@UHNQNEBDKKRHMSGDNRSDNAK@RSHBKHMD@FD CU

#DMS1DR

!NVDQR*3*DKKDQ)"1@MCNKOG!

6HBJ#&,HBG@DKR",.OSHLHY@SHNMNERTQE@BD LHBQNLNQOGNKNFX ENQ DMG@MBDC NRSDNAK@RS QDRONMRDRHMUHSQN(MS).Q@K,@WHKKNE@B(LOK@MSR

#H2HKUHN+)@LDRNM)&@LHD9

&H@MMNTCHR/53RHQHCHR$(MUHSQNDU@KT@SHNMNE SGDCHQDBSDEEDBSNEDRSQ@CHNKNMGTL@MNRSDNAK@RSR '.! @MC GTL@M LDRDMBGXL@K RSDL BDKKR G,2"R(MITQX2TOOK2 &Q@RRH@M 1"NKNEE)+!QTFFD)2

$WSQ@BDKKTK@QL@SQHWQDFTK@SHNMNELDS@ANKHRL@MC HLOKHB@SHNMRENQSTLNQHFDMDRHR"NKC2OQHMF'@QA 2XLO0T@MS!HNK

RGBQNES&2 RGVNQSG))/NSDMSH@K QNKDNEDRSQNFDMRHMVNTMCGD@KHMF L)

"KHM#DQL@SNK

"NQQDRONMCHMF@TSGNQ

RRNB/QNE/QDLIHS QONQML@DJKNMF

#DO@QSLDMSNE.Q@K@MC,@WHKKNE@BH@K2TQFDQX

%@BTKSXNE#DMSHRSQX/QHMBDNE2NMFJK@4MHUDQRHSX '@S8@H2.-&*'+

/GNMD%@W ,NAHKD/GNMD

$L@HKOQ@LDIHCFL@HKBNL

Referensi

Dokumen terkait

BEST strategy is consisting of four stages of learning that is Brainstorming, Exploring, Sharing, and transferring knowledge all stages are really effective to develop