:
: ) / (
DOI: 10.4197 / Eco. 26-2.1
٣
:
!
"#
–
–
)
/ /
/ / (
. ! ! "# $%
! & '* +,! '* -* ..! 0!
1.! 23.! 0! 4+ 0!
...
6, '*
7! !8! 9: 0 ., ; !<
:,!
3! #! 9,! =% >
0 .
3 47 !=! ? #:0! % @ @
:A! 9!A! = .
?! 0 '0#
B 0 '* ,! , CC0!
D=! 9 'B E+0! 'B 6,! !; +C: FB >:!
+,!
?! 0 :A! 9!A! '*
B : >CC0!
@ 93#! #G! G3! H!I ! 'B E+0! E4#
@0! JK=! L! G H-B% +,! B 0! !3 ! @ 3! L ?; @!A!
= !C D0 6KM!
?;: >G : :A! 9!A! D
0! 'B 0! G0 D0 .
٤ NG! % @ @:
) : ( 0! !3 !
D= !C D, 'B ! !! , P.* 6, 6KM!
4! 4B . D0 :A! 9!A!
) . Q (
! 'B ! !! , 6KM! 6,! B !3 9!A! D= 0 0! H!8! 'B GB D,
:A!
) . ( @ G,* . !; K! .
D= !C < , @#! @ 6KM! G3! ! !; >:A! 9!A!
, 4#! D3! L 'B
<! !; % .
!" # )
$% &
( '# ! '
# ! # '%* + &
,
-".# "/
(Light and Holland, 1998) 0& / !* *# '
1# 23 # ' $% $4# 5+&
$% #6 $67#6 $% $#
.
$# $9# !"#
$: ;/ !7#6 $%
</ $% 9# 4# $%
) Hammer and
Champy, 1993 (
. -=/ +# >/ 2*6
?+ @# A/ / 7
9# # 4# !" 5 ;# 4# $%
#
* .
!"## !*# 3B C %9 &
%* % &
'D # 0
/ + % 5#6 # E; # % % %#% 0= $C# %
!"# $#% $&'* +&* $&
: $,' $&
٥ ...
"#
F ! G9# 23 ?+% 7 / '
# .
# H%97 0 (E-management)
I# #
# # J $D 5/ $# ;# # "
# KK
+ 1 G;#
. # #6 23 !*
$ # C J# G # # $ L3 E;
(accessibility) # / ;#
. 0
J% $ # 0%
# #& !M </ %# , !M
# + # $% 0% NO96 )
5O (
D <
!# !&
(transaction) # + K+
P/ 0% </ K </ # $
(Dean, 2000, p.6) .
E; 0 3
L G;# 0&
# 1 :
/ R $% $# #6 / !; $ S S#
$ 3# $O $% $67#6
&
#
#
# .
R
@#
2% + # G9# +# 0% 1
KK .
I R G9# # $M 5T $+# 1*#
2% + #
7 7 KK
O9
# A 0% 1@# '
#+# $ .
R 0% 5= !+/ $7# S ?#C UM# S 0& !7#
2% + +# 5= G9# K $C
KK .
٦
!
>"; %M/ E; KV 0%
%M
# EO"
:
"! " # $ $+# 5=
$ E;
' K /
G9# + 5= # G9#
W#
" # $+# 5=
$ $ E;
' 0% M
G9# +# KK 2% + 5 # W+
" #
+# $+# M7;& 6 $3 $O# +# ! <4# ! ; :
M '# G9# K
WKK 2% + 5 0%
$ %
)
$ (
&'* +& * ,- %
# E# # " $/
3+ $4# 0& #
$; ! $ ; $%* A #+ $6;#
5 ; 0%
. <; = J 23 A/ C
0& *
T 9# $
C / # !%
$;#
# $ 9 $6+
; !" %# $
# (E-government)
C 7#C6 (digital economy)
+# /
# (E-commerce)
# (E-management)
>*
@# # $;%97 23 $ ! / $6;#
; 2#* & E; / % % 7 $
!"# $#% $&'* +&* $&
: $,' $&
٧ ...
! $6+ J C # #6 $;%97 L3 )
' XYZ[
/ Z]][
^ ' Z_]
.(
!"## !*# 3B C %9 &
% &
%*
: 'D # 0
/ + % 5#6 # E; # % % %#% 0= $C# %
"#
.
% $# 1# # K# # # $ $67#6 $
1%# G9# # U '$; $# 9 $ $6+
(software) $ # 1 23 '$67#6 $# '
$ $% 0& $%
. $6+ $#
# * $" 3 23 # $ #
.
<K ; $# !@;#
(mainframe) $# 0&
5O % !7#6 $C 0% 5= 7* ; , .
-;
$ 1%# % %
# 07C/ G;# V;# 9# $% 7#
. V#
@;# / !7#6 $% $# # # $ # $; ! G# G;# 0% # $% $ .
C $/ !"# !7#6 $% $#
0% # / E;
+ `6 $% 7# + !M # )
Attaran, 2003,
p.442 .(
# )
! (
(Business @ the Speed of Thought)
P#+ ! 3 (Bill Gates,1999)
$ 3& >/
$" #
٨ C = K
$ C P $# '+ 0%
K 0% $
$ a ' &
* ; K# 0& *#
0%
. $# $9# 7 UM# G !%; C
'J#+ '7#C6 0% $#6 7 !7#6 $%
'
! ; 0%
. + 3 9 # >/ 0& */ C
C + !7#6 $% $# # ...
G;#
-=/ G" '# K
'; >+/ C $9# 4# >/
>a C 7 ?+% >/ # 7# # / $ 0% #
V ' 7 K+ ;# !"# + C / 5 O $% $ + C 3 ^ M9 $6;% +#6 ! ' ';#
$3 $% 0% !7;% % / /
+#; 0&
. # 23 U#
5O J !# $ 3#
.
0& <D 5 # G9# J@# / 2*6 # ! 4#
M $ + 0& $
/ '$ + $O K+&
$9# 2%# ?+
0& <D
# $; $9# 2%# CO <3 %# +#& K
! .
$% $# G9# &
$67#6 )
>% G%9 /
# (
# + J/ 9& J= / + $
/ 0& !@;# 0& $ C <%# ! !@;#
# ! .
# / !*# >/ 9& 23 0& / + !
!"# $#% $&'* +&* $&
: $,' $&
٩ ...
;# / ! %# $% 5/ / K+& G9 .
a 23 0%
5 $67#6 $% $# G9# / ! 99# / # / $% & J/ 9& 9& # / ; >% G%9 Business Process Reengineering (BPR)
.
# % (enabling rule)
$ 23 / + >a
, %# / ^%#
D C 0& !;#
/ 2*6 & !O 23 % 5 "/ + $%
"; $# G9# =# / 23 $67#6 $%%
. 3 J9
$ $ $% +#& ;# 0& <D .
# / +
/ E; ; $ * # $% !;# % $+## J !# / + + 3 '5 J+# 0& <D#
(Ahadi, 2004, p.6) # %# # # &
0% 6% # ! ! !* 9& ;#
# 0% 6% # ; !b # ; ! # / + / '9% +
%# ; M $D + / '!b .
&
$% 9* ! @ c+d# 9*/ 1M # # ; ! + # ! A#
/ 'A/ + <3 <%# !7 0 K# 3
-M*
23 e ! & = +##6 1 !# 0& < !7 3 K+# ";
0% # % 2# 0#; $5+
A#
! $ $D A# 0% ! .
$ 3a
١٠ ! & 9*/ 9& <9# # % # -=/ a
! $5+& ;# <3 C 5=
9 N S4 #
) . ' XYZf
'
^ ZX .(
G9 S#
1D )
Z]]g ^ ^ ' :
Zf R Zh ( -
% 23 # F $#
: # 7
# !M # !O 19 $O ! !#
# 0% #6 `6 !7#6 !M A !M
* .
@#
5 # 9% # . # 1
! $% !# # T +& 5 3 N ! 5O A $ .
@#
# 1
J !* $O K+& $ 3# $T E;# !*# / 0%
# # G/ / $# 0& % I#;# 6 E; #&
-#& %
^# 1 # '
H7#
G O D D .
-=/ $@
. 9*/ J+ %
1/ 0& !7% '= $% $# J+ 0% #6 # 0% 5= $5+ 9# G # !%# + J 9 K+ & ! # $O % GC J K+
# ; .
, ; ;/ * A/ + )
Z]]i R Z]]h ^ ' Zg ( >.
3 # >/ A# %* + # 1#
;/ '/ 9 0& H%97
"
"
K+& 9* @
B + !O $O ! '+ 1 G;#
!"# $#% $&'* +&* $&
: $,' $&
١١ ...
" J9 7
"
# "
5 !+ 17# N >.
9*
!M # !O 9* 3 5/ # E; '! J9
%# # 9M .
-.#
# 1# J9# '# 0%
.
-#& 3# # # 9* !
#C 3& '$*
B !O ! K+& # F O 1#
'
# ! K+& # / ! a a # !M % # ## 23 '
$67#6 $* # !O ! K+& ;# # $# * # .
# F +# 7 &
9 #.#
$#
$%
$67#6 9 9## #
#
L3 # % G% #6 0% A L9# c; 6
# + .
. # 1@ E; a $# G 9&
5 # % $% $# 1# !O M
# , !7#6 9# $% G9# % $
-#& $5+&
$ # ;# + 1 23
%9 $%
.
A/ + `# # 1#
-M+&
.
F K# $ 0% M % ! $* $#
99#
B *% + $ 0% C >+#
* 1/ G;# !+/ ; .
a 1# 3 5=
#B K## # )
'+
XYZ_
/ Z]]Y
^ ^ ' :
XZf R XZi :(
١٢ ./
: & % &
: 3 G9 I# 6 /
$ 1 ;# -5 )
$ &
4#
( +## $ G >+#
% C % .
0 : ! $* $#F K# $ :
# # L3
H%97 #
) # .(
$ L3 ;##
K#
% :
/ R GM 2*#
(Hyperconnection) :
! ! 2*# 3
* $& # .
R 0% B !#
: ; !# $# E;
-5 ; $C * MK / %
A 19 .
C G ! $# / )
ZY / g ( </
) ZY (
)
g ( N / .
I R ! !#
: # ! $* $# / E;
J ; $C ! !# $&
+ MK / %
!7# %# ! * E;
-+ ; .
R M :
$67#6 $# J### # K &
%#
– # # M !7# %
= 6 # A C !& !+# '5
"/ 3.
) X_
(
"
. 0& 7& $C 1=/ 3.# # & !
B 19 !#
.!
R ; O ! :
# J * &
$ #
%7# # ; ##
B * .
a 3
; O ! & # !b ! .
a #
!"# $#% $&'* +&* $&
: $,' $&
١٣ ...
> 0#; * C 5K+ =#6 9*
6 0#; * ! C 5K+ % &
+ # & `O * % .
0& 0& 9# 0& 2* <D# $ L3 &
6 J ! !C # K L+# + #C + !# + & * J=#
. 6 !"#
+#
%# $ $CO !#
0% $# $
! B !7#6 .
# #
1M K+&
$# # !O $ 3# C # 99#
$%
$67#6 9 $% # '; !
$M %#
"D )
'5O '#* '
; $M K+/ ' (
J $CO 9# 1 23
A/ ; #M )
' XYZf
^ ' ZZ
.(
# !;# % 3.#
/ l ! '
G%# !
3# # $% 9*/ 0& % % $% 9* ! -#&
#& !M '
! $# & =# "
-#&
# MK J .
?=&
# !;# % /
JK# $C $% 7# & !O # > # <3 # $% $ $+#
$#
!7#6 $*
) '
XYZf / Z]]_
' ^ ZZZ .(
$* U 0&
+ % . # ! $%
$/ # !7#6 $% $#
9M 9/ !
# C $%
.
١٤ ! $ # 9# % & 'A/
>O 4# !* <3+ +## 4# % #9 ; M 9* < # ! %# %
+ ! C = # 9/ 4 23 '77#
# $C;#6 +## 6 # .
! $ >& I#;#
0& I C 3# ";
K+# C !
# $4#% 9 P G '! % ! 0% A+ <3 4#% & ' ; L3 0% $/9 . # G9# U CO a >%
9 $3 '#* #
% ?+ = 6
# / 6 G9# / '# G9# 9#
'! 9*/ $% 7# # $/ + # =
$#
$%
.
3+ &
;+ <+ 9*
. / +
0& !7% %* % !%; !O !* U# %* 7 ##
$C N. UM# !=/
. !; %; ! 4# G +#
</ ' :
$% 7# & U M 9 ! .
P 0% ! + a <3+ 4#
9 MK+ 4# # <3 # ;#
. 4# `6
* % ! ## 9 (Holistic Approach)
;#
# !* 4# !O !
$#
$%
# .
& # 9 & 0& N* I#; 3
+ ! 9*/ / $%% <3+ 7#
;# K
+ $
+ 5 3+
' %# ' '
!"# $#% $&'* +&* $&
: $,' $&
١٥ ...
N* I#;
% T !# U + 0%
(Human Resource Reengineering) .
0% K# 'U 3
N* ?+ ; ^ + 7# , a * $/ / 23 e$% $# # J 0#;
$#
$%% 7# # ! "/ JC $ $%
>+## % ! #;# # 9* $#
.
G9 . <3+ # & 0% K# '7#
O +##6 $% 7# & '! 3#
#6 !
, UM# 0& !7% # $% $# # 5 %* + $;# C ) .
' XYZf
/ Z]]_
' ^
^ : Z[i R ZY]
.(
+ + * A/ + )
XYZ_
/ Z]]Y ^ ' XZX ( 0&
# / C &
(Digital of E-Management)
K+& ! $* $# # 0% # # E;
& 1M )
-#& C ' '# '99#
( * 1M
) $ $+# $% 9# ' ' 'G# 'I#
9 # 2*#
.(
* J# 3 $ 3&
0% $;# $9 $* C * 0#;
$9# A# 0% / P < A#
9 9## %"## / $9# ' -+= $;
-7#
#5 % % K +#
.
& 5* ! !C `6/ # / ! 0= $C </ "/ !# ! $* $# 0% ## #%
0& 9# 5* 5& +# 0&
! P/ H7/ <3 ;
#%
– / G;# % " ! <
١٦ # "
. " G 3 H= # !*
/ . D=
H8!
! 9!A!
:A! 9!A!
-!
3#!
) :
(
% / 0 P >/ 7 3 3 + -#& / L3 # / #& !7#6 * 0% JC
'
# L3 # / ! # %9## &
/ 5/ %/
% #6 , / + '
E;# 9# ;# ";# # $# # ?%
# !/ 0& %;# % %# ! J+
.
$# $% * ##
(internet)
% JC # %4*
. #
! / %# A/ + !*#
$#
7 '
, $*# 9# '*
. #O K+ 7 !"# 6 /
C## " $%9# I#;# & ! <
# $D C 0% 1
L+#6 3 0& !;# # .
0% 3+ 6;# %# % # # % < # .
' % " % =/ 0
0% +& P# E; $ ; F % 7
.
9%# 'MK # %"# %# 7 m# / </
' ;
n# P 3/ ## # % $ ' ,
!"# $#% $&'* +&* $&
: $,' $&
١٧ ...
+ ^ N9 $D ; K+ CO .
a #
/ E; ; K+ 7 4# 0# # ;
K+ L3 5 % JC * 2 (Hoffman, 1999, p.3)
.
)
$ (
&'* +& * 12
#6 0% $ $C K 0& # 1#
% # # 1 $67#6 $
. # 3
5 K 0& = AD 1 # 1 $% # # $ & '9 3 # +# % $9# $67#6 #;# $%
.
##
!"
G9# 1/
% # )
' Z]]g
^ ^ ' :
[[
R [Y :(
X R !%; "; C $# # !* 9#
+#& 5 J # < ! 9# .* # / # 0% + !+ G% 1 $# J !
";
.
Z R ! $# 0% 5= 9C ; .
[ R $C ;7 $ $% #
C % A# J .
Y R 9# $B !O "#6 3+ <7#C6 o#6 ;#
# CO $3 $D
.
_ R ; MK $% $ S !O !4*# 1# !%#
%% J K+ # G $ .
f R # >.* ; D $& / 9# !=/ !7#
!=/ $ .
١٨ g R . D %# # &
K ; .
i R / 59& J 7 ! 9 3# 9 K#
#C .
h R
; 7 %7 7 $ J+#
.
X]
R 9 $ # G9 3# $C ^%#
.
XX R
%# $% # G >+/ !%#
.
XZ R
#
$% +# 1 .
X[
R 7 #% $% $ # .
G9 1=
1D )
Z]]g ^ ^ ' :
[Y R [_
( /
/ M A7C / # F :
X R $% ;#& !O 3# 5 % ;#
/ $ * 0% +# !O % !7; !# '
B E; !M !O + !C. % !7; & %
# .
Z R 0& ! 1% E; 1 !
$C ! > +# C </ % * <3
; > P # $9# # # H7. '> , ) 9 'N* '$ / ...
m .(
[ R $#+6 (Video Conferencing)
$
-4+ # .
Y R $% MK % +; 2 # # #
L3 % ^7 1 $ # 23 MK L3 ;
$%
.
!"# $#% $&'* +&* $&
: $,' $&
١٩ ...
_ R % $O $%# !7
23 + MK .
f R L3 # ; + !O + $O 5&
M A
)
; 9;
.(
g R E #; $% $ ; K#
; I / 9#;6 m #;6 !O 9 !
@;# 1 D E 9
.
i R % # / ;# >a 7 $
# # K ^ ;# !O ;# !O 7 % / 7 !"## # '$ L3 2%#
) ', Z]]i R
Z]]h
^ ' [h (:
R ; K I# 1# S .
R !## # G G9 N#
.
R +#
` I# >
%# 5O $, $+#;6 .
R # + K $+# + ;#
.
R C !# 9 O#
.
0 $ $;# 5+& 0& #
## / K EO" G;# >% ## <3 '7 !"
J#+ J $CO ;# '5O% ;#
2O ;7/ $"# 0% M K '!#
.
23 $ 5/ 0% ## $+ # "D#
2%# # # 9* 1M ! 0% ".# !O $
'7 $ '$+# 9# 9*/ 1M
'+ $%
٢٠ +# $O;# '.# '!# 'G# $%
) 5* $%9
J !7#
(
$% !# ;* ! $% 23 ' .
;# 0% # !# ! ; 3 P 5/ +
5 ## + #& / # G9 $ ! % .
-=/ # # a 23 0& =
-&
`6 J7# 7# $% # .
1# $ 5 1# S# `O=
I#&
& / $ / O
-7 `O # ## & 1#
E;# 9#
23 ' %# $O* ! 0% 5= >#+ $ -/ ## # / # 0%
7 G9# 0%
# $# ##
-+ P ; ! ".# $3 #
'
!M $# * G9 !## $ ! # E;
<3 '5 9=6 , #O# P 56D S## # $ $O* ! 0% 5=
* C G;# = 0& = '$ J %#
%# $O ! 3#
.
</ ; * (Hamid Ahadi, 2004, p. 6-7)
$# $M / 0&
% $ !* ## # $67#6 $%
:
X R C 9# $# $
.
Z R A !7#6 $# $*
.
[ R $% # !#
(EDI) .
Y R
$#6 * 0% # # $#
.
_ R (ERP)
.
f R
%# $; '9M # $#
.
!"# $#% $&'* +&* $&
: $,' $&
٢١ ...
L3 !V*# 6 -7; M
!; L3 !;# 6 $# 2%#
!%;# + 'S = !M $ / </ = ` +#;# # $ #
%9#
;# #% 9# >
# 5= 0% %= + + 7 7 'M/
#6 $% # 7 L*# 9& + ! #
"; # $+# # ; # #+ 7 .
$ # 0% KV C E; !# 3&
! ' $ 0% G9# 7#C 6 3 a '!
&
0% 23 '; / ^ N9 $# N/ 0% G9#
@; 6 / H% $/ 5 '$ / J%% +# $#
.
*# # $9# 1%# #6 $#
/ + ;# ' # % MO # 5
)
% (
+ MO / )
%#
( 5 5#O 23 '
$# 2%#
.
!V"# 6 + 7 %# $D a 9 3 "/ & ! '# $9# -5"#
>+# # $
7 0& ! !"## # "" $;#
0% %9 K# 23 '!7#6 $% $# # $9#
G;# ##+ M/ $+ $C# # %#
# 9#
. + >+#
9& ; # ; 7 $
$+% $7# # K ! , .
; $; 9# 0% $+ !# >%
$; / '$;# 2%# $".# J 5 !#
1%# 1# c; % #5 5#6 !+/ %
٢٢ '# !7#6 $%% "; $# $9#
5/ / $9# E;& # / 23 G9# ?+ !;
;#6 7 #5+& 1%# #%9 + !+# ! G
!M + 0& $O P# M 5=/ ^ , + $O .
)
$ ( '* +& * 33 4 5 6 &
`&
$% $# 7 ! +
7 $67#6 C
iXih / m#
Xh / f / XYZf % + !*# ; $+ >+# =
0% 1* ' 7 # $O#%
J G# KO 3# $%9# ;# # $O# 9 3#
$O# U $+ $% # $67#6 K #
# ! !D M=/ 'A ; !D M=/ 'A ; + $%
& ! ! !D ; + $% # !
# $O#
.
C %# K ;7 >+# 7 23 5= 0%
fiZX m#
Zh / f / XYZf 0 $;# + ! )
+
# $O#
( +% !*# + C 7 C '
+% 23 # +% % !*# 23 # +% %
##+ !/ $ # # + _
/ h / XYZ_
G Xh
/ X]
/ Z]]Y .
-+# # G9# # C
$ 1%# 0%
2% + O9 23 $% $ K K
'K #
!"# $#% $&'* +&* $&
: $,' $&
٢٣ ...
G9#% 0 # $;# 'D% # JC# N#&
C 9# 7 $7 S + + 0& " K $
$ $ ;7 .
+ # $ U 9&
On Demand University Services
(ODUS) M 5=/ # # +# G9# 9# #
L3 >% '+ $M , %9 P#
! 0; E; ' %# + !*#
% < C + $M #
# >% ! > H >7 :
X R $ –
O9 .
Z R $ –
3#
.
[ R
$% %# D*
.
Y R $ –
% $ .
_ R # $%
– .
f R # $%
– O9 .
g R
% $%
.
i R 3#
.
h R + # .
+ 7# +% # )
#6 + (
$% #
# # !; 3# J#
5 # J +
9# #
>
! $; #6 $+#
, K / $ / $% / $ 5 + .
٢٤ !. 9# $+ 1%# $9# # 5= 0%
/ + % $M '& % O9 P# M 5=
$9# CO <3 $M EO" $+# NO9# 0% E; ^;
E; 3 5+& !O 23 # .
7 28 % ,9
; $# EO" a E; C E; 3# 9 9&
! =/
O9% A/ P# M 5 + ""
.
$#6 $ # ; ,
$
+# $ 7 , .
23 $#6 A#; G7 0% .# 0% E; ^; C = 0%
47 O9 P# M 5=/
KO $O# 5+& # E;
. $ $ 3. C
+; EO"
) X]
(
$ $#6 0% +F M ! #6 23 '
! %/ G9# 23 UM# 0& !@7# # C '#3 G7 $"
$"
p / (Chronbach Albha)
H= ' 23
C !+
) X .(
C !+ H=#
) X ( p $" ! / (Cronbach's
alpha) q% C E; $4# % G#6 A#; $" P '
) ],h][
( ' ) ],hXX ( ' ) ],ihi ( ' O9 'P# M 5=/ !
J# $" 0% ! ' ## 0% +
q% E; #3 G7 0% L"/ P <3 '$#6 ) ],h_]
( ' ) ],h_Y ( ' ) ],hYi ( # 0%
. #6 " 23 s C
$ 0% $#6 JK# E; C 0& A/
E; $ .
!"# $#% $&'* +&* $&
: $,' $&
٢٥ ...
) (.
:
!
" #$ % &' *$"
+ , %-/
.
!0 &1"2 3
45 /
' %
9!A! D= !C
:A!
,STU ,VS
,VVS ,UQ
,V ,US
Q B G0!
0! H!8! ' B ?! 0 ,U CC0!
,UT ,VQ
,UV ,V
,UQ
67 8 9
,U ,UT
,U ,UT
,VUV ,UV
6 4 ! % &9
/ @# J#+ +; $ E; >% !7; 5=
+ J#+ +;
) ZYX_]
( $9 EO" !"#
5=/
P# M 3
) Z[_]
( ' O9 3 #
)
Z],]]]
( '
3 )
Xi]]
( .
G ; O9# 5+& # E; EO" $9 +; ;#
EO" J#+ $9 9 ! )
gg ( +; # 23 '
A# ' ! < 1;6 P/ 0% % ) ],]_
.(
J#+ $9 9 ! +; ;# # 23 5=
% EO" E;
:
) Y_
( 'P# M 5=
) ZXi ( '3 O9%
) _i ( F .
# 17 * !O +# $#6 JK#
# $#6 0% !7;
:
٢٦ R ) Y]
( 7 # P# M 5=/ ;;
) ih t (
+;
.
R ) hY ( O9 ;;7 # )
Y[
t ( +;
.
R ) _g ( ;;7 #
) hi t ( +;
.
; 9* " < % = &6>
!%;# # # $5+ E; J#
E;% M7;
:
) (
% 6 "?> &
#;O7 # .#% #6 + E; C 6 # $#6 # # E; M7; !%;# $ !
C " 'KO 9* ##
K#
$4#
$#6 "
; 4#
` B
%% M7; K; U
#+6 (SPSS)
Statistical Package for Social Sciences '
$4# # # 23 9&
";
# :
# G9# K • '
$ 0% <#;
) X R X_
(
#6 .
% M • + 5 0
2%
M 5=/ ! KK
'P#
O9 + ' '
$ 0% <#;
) Xf R Z[
(
#6 .
)
<
( -9 % =9* &
$+# 7 $4#% 7 57; I# E; C 7 57; " E; $ # %# E; $4#
'$# ! 7 57; !* 3 3
!"# $#% $&'* +&* $&
: $,' $&
٢٧ ...
'H+ ; 9# 'M 1;6
1O#6 ! '<
`##*# !C P/ 0% ## <
-+# " / .
0& $ *# 3 ` H+ 9# $M
$ P 9&
(Likert Scale) 3 #
E;
% :
!,
;<
, W ,SU '* A!
) P= !! B (
,V W Q,TU '* A!
) D!% . (
Q, W ,U '* A!
) , (
, W ,U '* A!
) D!%
(
,Q W T, '* A!
) X D!%
(
@ &A % &B -9 =9*
# E; $ $ $ S ;# 0& E; !7#
7 57;
` 23
C/ !+%
) Z ( ' ) [ ( ' ) Y ( ' ) _ ( 23 '
% : )
= ( . 67 " , >
: 4/7 3 !0 &1"2 8
?@
3 !0 &1"2
67 " %
Y 4
@ % ) T ( XB
QT
Q @ ) T ( @ % '*
) T ( XB
@ ) T ( XB M:Z
T
Q
%
$
Y 4
;#%
Q
Q
Q
? ;#%
QS,T
B# ;#%
S Q,T
٢٨
% ,A -
Y 4
@ % ) (
!#
QT
Q
Q @ ) ( @ % '*
) Q (
# S
Q,T
@ ) Q ( @ % '*
) (
#
QT
Q
@ ) ( M:Z #
S,T
B
C !+ H=#
) (
% :
` P# M 5=/ E; $ JK# / •
%
M / 0& * )
[_
( C/ 0&
! )
Y_
( - K;#
) Y]
t ( M % '
) Y_
( - ".
) [_
t ( -/ '
M
/ !C ) [_
( - ) Z_
t ( E; $ +& 9 .
` P# M 5=/ E; $ JK# / •
#%
% # 0% %7; / 0& *#
K; 3#/
) YZ,_
t ( / # 0% %7; " ' 3#
) []
t ( -/ '
0% %7;
# 2* 3#/
) Zg,_
t ( E; $ +& 9 .
` P# M 5=/ E; $ JK# / •
$M
! !+
M / 0& *#
) X]
( !C/ 0&
) Z]
(
M / )
YZ,_
t ( % ' !C/ #M !
) X]
(
$ '
) Z]
( !C/ 0&
) []
( )
Z_
t ( -/ 'O
M
) []
( ".
) g,_
t ( E; $ +&
.
!"# $#% $&'* +&* $&
: $,' $&
٢٩ ...
) C ( . 4/7 67 " , >
!?
45$
.
% !?
t
4
@ % ) Q ( B
Q @ ) Q ( @ % '*
) ( B Q
@ ) ( XB M:Z
Q
B
DE FF
C !+ H=#
) [ ( E; $ JK# / O9
M / 0& *# $M ; )
Z]
( !C/ 0&
) []
(
/ M )
ff t ( M % )
[]
( - ".
) [[
t ( -/ '
!C/ M )
Z]
( )
X t ( +& 9
E; $ .
) E ( . 4/7 67 " , >
G !?
.
% !?
t
4
@ % ) T ( B
S,Q
Q @ ) T ( @ % '*
) T ( B T
Q, Q
@ ) T ( XB M:Z Q
,T
B
HI FF
C !+ H=#
) Y ( E; $ JK# /
!C/ M / 0& *# $M ; )
[_
( M /
) g],Z t ( M % )
[_
( !C/ 0&
) Y_
(
) Zf,[
t ( -/ '
M )
Y_
( - ".
) [,_
t ( 9
E; $ +&
.
٣٠ ) H ( . 0J 4/7 67 " , >
$ .
%
$ 0J
t
4
B% [ L:! @ '
T
V,V
Q L:!
Q
Q, Q
=#! ! % 0! M!
QV
U,
B
HI FF W
C !+ H=#
) _ ( E; $ JK# /
; !D " + 0% %7; / 0& *# %
/
K; 9# % )
Yh,X t ( + 0% %7; " '
P )
YZ,X t ( -/ '
+ 0%/ !D 0% %7;
P )
i,i t ( E; $ +& 9 .
C D4 6*
!
E; !#
% 7 57; % ! "; $4#
K
G9#
# '
2% + 5 0% M
KK
M 5=/
P#
' O9 + ' E; '
/ $+ !C/ $+ 0%/ 0% $K; # $4#
23 `
! H= " 'E; $ $+#6
$+#6 L+#6 4#
+F 23 E; $
"; %M .
) C ( D4 6*
"! " #
0% ! "; !D ^ :
12 3 , 4 % &- %6 =8 +& *
E&'* +& * 12 6 +&? =8 &'*
!"# $#% $&'* +&* $&
: $,' $&
٣١ ...
+ =##
$ $ $+# ;# ! "; !D
P# M 5=/ ! EO" E;
O9 +
; 4#
# G9# K 23 '+
C/ !+ >;=
) f ( ' ) g ( ' ) i (
% 23 :
) K ( . L8 , &7
!0 &1"' /
3 .
% '
/
/7 M N7<
N5-< O O
4
* ! K0! C
, ,ST T,Q
Q CA! B#
, ,T T,T
Q
! 9!
,QT , ,VQ
K0! CA ! 4#
, ,SSV S,V
S
T ! J= ! D,
GK! @:! ! ,
,SU V,
V
P= 0 @ -%
K0! C*
,T X ,S ,U
S X K0! C* @ % 4
,T ,V U,V
V @ ! '* !=-.! B ,QV 0!
,VSS Q,U
Q
U
! B8! @ M:! H<*
, ,SU ,
T
0! 0 .
&
:A! 9!A!
,VV ,UUQ QT,TS
T
B8! =#
,T ,V Q,
# B8! C* 3: \3 Q , 0
,S ,V
:A! 9!A! = 2- =#
,QT ,V U,S
U
0! @% @ 9: D, , #!
,U Q,
@ !! B3! @ C D, T E!=8! E ,T
,UU QQ,VS
% /
,Q ,S V,T
٣٢ C !+ H=#
) f ( E; $ $+# / 5=/
P# M -+# $/ C
- 0% ; G9# K
# C ; 9# 23 '
) Y,Zf ( ! 1O#
C <
) i,f_
t ( + / $ "/ C ' 0%
##
: + '
$O K+& C 'K+
'
`9 - $O K+& !=/
' " 54&
C ! 23 '
1O# $O )
XY,iZ t ( ' ) X_,X_
t ( ' ) X_,ZY t ( '
) Xf,]h t ( ' ) Xf,XX t (
# 0%
.
C !+ H=#
) f ( -=/
0% $K; # $ !C/ /
E; $ P# M 5=/
9=6 ' 0&
!#
+ # K G; '
1%# !7# !
19 $7 +# 6 ' $% / + G; '
# # J !#
< 1O#6 $O $ C '
$ L3 )
Z],Yh t ( ' ) ZZ,ig t ( ' ) ZY,][
t ( ' ) Z_,_g t ( 0%
##
. C !+ H=#
) g ( O9 E; $ $+# /
4# 0% # ; - -+# $/ C G9# K
# C ; 9# 23 '
) Y,[i ( C < 1O# !
) XX,ii t ( $ "/ C ' ## 0% + /
: 54&
9# '- $O K+& !C/ + 'C ! "
K+& C '+% ! K+& %# S# '!
1O# $O 23 '$O )
XZ,Z]
t ( ' ) XY,YZ t ( '
) X_,hg t ( ' ) Xf,hg t ( ' ) Xg,gX t
( # 0%
. !C/ / -=/ H=#
E; $ 0% $K; # $ :
' +
$O $ C '# J !# # $7 +# 6
!"# $#% $&'* +&* $&
: $,' $&
٣٣ ...
$ L3 < 1O#6 )
ZZ,h[
t ( ' ) Z[,[i t ( 0%
##
.
) I ( . 8 , &7
/
45$
.
% '
/
/7 M N7<
N5-< O O 4
K0! C* ! ,
,SS S,S T
Q CA! B#
, ,VS U,QU S
! 9!
, ,UT QQ,U
K0! CA ! 4#
, ,SV V,
T ! J= ! D,
GK! @:! ! ,Q
,U QQ,TQ Q
P= 0 K0! C* @ -%
X ,
,V U,T V
S
* @ % 4 X K0! C
,V
,ST ,Q Q
V @ ! '* !=-.! B ,T 0!
,VU V,
U
! B8! @ M:! H<*
,SQ ,TS Q,Q
& 0! 0 . :A! 9!A!
, ,UV Q,V
B8! =#
,S ,S T,US
Q
# B8! C* 3: \3 , 0
,STS ,US
:A! 9!A! = 2- =#
,S ,VVV Q,QU
0! @% @ 9: D, , #!
,U Q,Q U
T
@ !! B3! @ C D,
=8! E ,Q E!
,UQ QQ,
% /
,V ,TQ ,VV
٣٤
&'* +& * 12 3 6
D& * D
) P ( . 8 , &7
/
.
% '
/
/7 M
<
N7 N5-< O
O
4
K0! C* ! ,T
,SU ,T
Q CA! B#
,T ,V V,U
S
! 9!
,Q ,SV ,S
Q
K0! CA ! 4#
,QV ,V U,
U
T ! J= ! D,
! GK! @:!
,Q ,SS V,
T
P= 0 K0! C* @ -%
X ,Q
,SV V,
S X K0! C* @ % 4
, ,STV S,
V @ ! '* !=-.! B ,S 0!
,VSU Q,
U
! B8! @ M:! H<*
,
,VQ V,
& 0! 0 .
:A! 9!A!
,Q ,UT Q,S
B8! =#
, ,VT Q,Q
Q # B8! C* 3: \3 ,QT 0
,VSQ Q,TQ
Q
9!A! = 2- =#
:A!
, ,V U,TU
V
0! @% @ 9: D, ,V #!
,UU Q,ST
T @ !! B3! @ C D,
E!=8! E ,T
,UU Q,
T
% /
E,=K F,EI F,D
!"# $#% $&'* +&* $&
: $,' $&
٣٥ ...
C !+ H=#
) i ( E; $ $+# /
+# $/ C -
- 4# 0% ; G9# K
# C ; 9# 23 '
) Y,Zf ( C < 1O# !
) X],hX t ( 0% + / $ "/ C ' ##
: C
+ '$O K+&
+ ' K+& !C/
- $O
'
`9
- $O K+& !=/
%9 G;# '
MO $C 1O# $O 23 '
) Xf,_[
t ( '
) Xf,gY t (' ) Xg,]]
t ( ' ) Xi,X[
t ( ' ) Xi,[f t ( # 0%
. H=#
-=/
$K; # $ !C/ / 0%
E; $ :
G;
+ $% / !# # $7 +# 6 '
1%# !7# !# K G; ' # J $ L3 < 1O#6 $O $ C ' 19 ) ZX,g_
t ( ' ) Z[,g[
t ( ' ) ZY,YY t ( ## 0%
.
) C ( D4 6*
" # :
0% " "; !D ^ :
"
, = ! G4 4 % &- %6 =8 E6 &'* +& * 12 6 33 4 5 6
+ =##
" "; !D $ $ $+# ;#
P# M 5=/ ! EO" E;
O9 +
2% + 5 0% M ;
G9# +# KK
C/ !+ >;= 23 '+ # )
h ( ' ) X]
( '
) XX (
% 23 :
٣٦ 33 4 5 6 , = ! G4 .
=84 %6/
H&
.
C !+ H=#
) h ( 5=/ E; $ $+# /
4# 0% # ; - -+# $/ C P# M 0% M
5 K 2% +
C ; 9# 23 'K )
Y,Z_
(
C < 1O# ! )
XY,f]
t ( / $ "/ C '
## 0% + :
H# / # G9# / */
'K# 5 0% # # !M $= " J/ $6+
G9# 1=
J# & '+ C 0& -+ - #
$ # $O K+& # 9 G9#
G9# / */ '#& + 0& !;# >+# G;# 0%
9# & '+% 5 0% -+& P # G
1O# $O 23 '+& !* M/ 0% P + # )
X_,h]
t ( ' ) Xg,fY t ( ' ) Xg,gX t ( ' ) Xi,Y]
t ( '
) Xi,hX t ( # 0%
. 0% $K; # $ !C/ / -=/ H=#
E; $ :
G9# &
#
!* K # <%# 9 # J <K# + J# %9## + # G9# +# & 'S% # J 0% # 9 !;# & '9# $6+
# K + L3 < 1O# $O 23 ' $7
$ )
Xh,[[
t ( ' ) Xh,f]
t ( ' ) ZX,XY t ( ## 0%
.
33 4 5 6 , = ! G4
<J2 %6/ . .
!"# $#% $&'* +&* $&
: $,' $&
٣٧ ...
) D ( . 8 , &7 % &' *$" !
' / !0 &1"
3 .
% '
/
/7 M N7<
N5-< O O 4
:A! 9!A! D= @*
. &#! J= 0 4=
. ,Q
,VQ U,
S
S 9!A! = D= &#! @*
* :A!
K0! C
F D, 'B B## ! :* 0 '* ,!
. ,S
,SS S,S
V 0 :A! 9!A! D= @*
* : G!% 'B L:0 ,Q .
,V V,U
T
U X0 :A! 9!A! D= E-
!
X
! 0! '*
, . ,S S,
Q
Q 9!A! D= B#! @*
& 1C!! B 0 :A!
@C! @ 93 1! =! !#!
\0 B : .
,T ,SV U,
Q :A! 9!A! = ,! @*
0! : & 'B B#
0! 3! C:
. ,QV
,UT Q,
V
QQ :A! 9!A! D= @% 0%
@ M: &#% . ]3 @% @:
'B B# ! G!! -A!
C! H!8!
. ,QS
,SU T,U
Q :A! 9!A! D= @% 0%
X* L:0
0 0! H!8! 'B , .
,SU V,
% /
E,=H F,K=
E,KF
٣٨ ) F ( . 8 , &7 % &' *$" !
#$
"
.
% '
/
/7 M N7<
N5-< O O 4
:A! 9!A! D= @*
0 . &#! J=
4=
. ,T
,S T,S
T
S 9!A! = D= &#! @*
K0! C* :A!
F D, 'B B## ! :* 0 '* ,!
. ,TT
, ,T
Q
V 0 :A! 9!A! D= @*
'B L:0
* : G!%
, . ,V V,UT
S
U X0 :A! 9!A! D= E-
!
X
! 0! '*
, . , ,Q
Q :A! 9!A! D= B#! @*
=! !#! & 1C!! B 0 B : @C! @ 93 1!
\0 . ,
,V QT,Q
V
Q :A! 9!A! = ,! @*
C: 0! : & 'B B#
0! 3!
. ,
,STQ ,T
@: :A! 9!A! D= @% 0%
@ M: &#% . ]3 @%
H!8! 'B B# ! G!! -A!
C!
. ,TQ
,V T,
Q :A! 9!A! D= @% 0%
X* L:0
0 0! H!8! 'B ,T .
,U ,Q
% /
E,EP F,H=
,H
C !+ H=#
) X]
( E; $ $+# / O9
-+# $/ C
- ;
# 4# 0%
5 0% M
!"# $#% $&'* +&* $&
: $,' $&
٣٩ ...
2% +
KK C ; 9# 23 ' )
Y,Yi ( 1O# !
<
C ) XX,_X t ( / $ "/ C ' 0% +
##
: # G9# 1=
- -+
+ C 0&
& '
J#
$ # $O K+& # 9 G9#
G;# 0%
#& + 0& !;# >+#
G9# / */ '
#
& P -+
+% 5 0%
G9# / */ '
" J/ $6+ H# / # # !M $=
K# 5 0% # + # G9# +# & '
%9##
9# $6+ J#
1O# $O 23 '
) X[,Zf t ( ' ) X[,_Y t ( ' ) XY,Z[
t ( ' ) X_,X[
t ( ' ) X_,gf t ( # 0%
.
H=#
-=/
!C/ / ;
$K E; $ 0%
: &
# J <K# + # G9#
# <%# 9 S% # !* K
' 1O# ! 23
L L3 <
) Z_,[Z t (.
6 , = ! G4 33 4 5
. %6/
D& * D 6 .
C !+ H=#
) XX ( E; $ $+# /
4# 0% # ; - -+# $/ C 0% M
5 C ; 9# 23 'KK 2% +
) Y,Zi (
C < 1O# ! )
XZ,Yi t ( / $ "/ C '
## 0% + :
H# / # G9# / */
& 'K# 5 0% # # !M $= " J/ $6+
+& # 9 G9# J#
$ # $O K
G9# +# & '#& + 0& !;# >+# G;# 0%
