SKYLINE BUSINESS JOURNAL (SBJ) REVIEWER FORM

SKYLINE BUSINESS JOURNAL (SBJ) REVIEWER FORM

Manuscript title

Reviewer

 The reviewer’s identity remains anonymous to author/s



Rating

Please use the symbol

()

to indicate your preference (1 is the lowest and 5 is the highest)

Key Evaluation

Parameters 1 2 3 4 5

Uniqueness of the research

Relevance to the journal

Contribution to existing knowledge

Literature review Research design Data analysis Conclusions Managerial Significance Organization of the manuscript

Quality of the communication



Recommendations for Review

Please use the symbol

()

to indicate your preference Manuscript requires routine editing only

Manuscript requires minor revisions from author(s) Manuscript requires major revisions from author(s) Manuscript is un-publishable



Editorial Decision

Please use the symbol

()

to indicate your preference Accept

Accept after specified revision Reject



Comments and Suggestions for Authors