\.
^m
Nguyen Van Hung va dong bon pham toi gi?
T
• Nguyen Thj H&ng ThiSy
ren co sd ket ludn dieu tra, ndi dung vy dn dugc the hien nhu sau:
"Do can tien an tieu, Nguyen Van Hung (sinh nam 1985) ban bgc vdi Cao Van Minh (sinh nam 1989), Hoang Van Tudn (sinh ndm 1994) vd ban gai ciia Tudn Id Nguyin Thu Ha (sinh nam 1999) tim edch chilm doat tien cua anh L6 Van Tdn. Ca bpn thdng nhdt dd Hd gia lam gai bdn ddm, dupe Himg gidi thieu rdi ddn Tan din dia diem mua ban ddm, sau dd bdo cho Minh, Tudn den bdt qua tang.
Khoang 17 gid 20 phiit ngay 20/9/2014, Himg ggi dien hen anh Tan din nha n ^ i Nang Hdng dl mua dam Hd vd bdo chi can dua cho Hd 100.000 ddng cdn tiln thue phdng thi Himg vd anh Tan chia ddi. Hiing thue phdng 205 eung Hd vd Tdn len phdng rdi nhdn tm cho Minh vd Tudn bilt. Tudn va Minh len phdng noi Hung, Tan va Ha dang nghi. Tai ddy, Tuan gia vd la anh trai ciia Hd di tim nhieu ngdy khdng gap vd lay dep trong
phdng nem vao mat ciia Hiing, ldy ghe inox dga ddnh anh Tdn nhung Hiing gid vd can nen Tudn khdng danh Tan. Sau dd, Tuan lien tuc hdi Tan "bdy giay mdy idm sao"
ep anh Tan dua tien cho bpn Tudn.
Dugc nha nghi can ngdn nen ca nhdm dua anh Tan den quan nude.
Ca hgn de Ha d lai va dua anh Tdn den bai dat trdng, yeu cau anh Tdn dua 10.000.000 ddng. Anh Tdn dua cho Tudn 200.000 dong nhung Tuan khdng chiu. Anh Tdn ndi:
"Tao khong sa chung mdy ddu ".
Tudn va Minh dpa se dua ra cdng an. Tuan bdt anh Tdn de lai chile xe may de hdm sau giai quylt. Do ngai phai ra cdng an nen anh Tan ddng y de CMIC xe mdy va vilt gidy lai.
Khoang 9 gid ngay 21/9/2014, Hung, Minh, Tudn ddn anh Tdn den mpt dja diem vdng. Anh Tdn dua cho Tudn 500.000 ddng dl xin Igi xe may nhung Tudn khdng dong y. Tai day, Hiing, Minh, Tudn tiep tyc de doa anh Tdn. Tuan dung ddy dien dai khodng 60 cm, dudng
kinh 0.5cm danh vdo vung dau vi ngudi anh Tdn ep anh Tan phai gpi difin v6 cho vg Id chi Le Thu Trang chudn bl 40.000.000 ddng nhung chi Trang khdng cd tiln dl n$p cho Tuan. Anh Tan da ggi di?n nhd ban la anh Biii The Nam vi Nguyen Vdn Quyet den giai quyet hd nhung khdng dugc n8n cac anh da din cdng an huy^n trinh bdo".
Nhdn dinh vl hanh vi ciia Himg, Minh, Tudn, Ha trong vii an tren, cd hai quan diem trai chieu nhau.
Quan diem thii nh^t cho rdng: Himg, Minh, Tuan, Ha deu pham tdi cuop tai sdn vi da co thoa thuan trudc, dung thii dogn dd dp anh Tdn vdo tinh thi kho xii, sau dd Tudn diing vu luc nhdm chilm dogt tiln ciia anh Tdn (40.000.000 ddng).
Quan dilm thii hai lai cho rdng: Hdnh vi ciia Hung, Minh, Tudn pham tpi cudp tdi sdn, con Hd CO dau hieu ciia tpi cudng dogt tdi sdn (khoan I Dieu 135);
L U A T s u V l f r NAM 1 s d SI THANG S-2016
tuy nhien day la tdi pham nghiem trgng. Ha dudi 16 mdi nen khdng phdi chiu trach nhiem hinh su.
Ve cd nhdn tdc gid cd quan diem nhu sau:
Hanh vi cua Himg, Minh, Tudn trong ngay 20/9/2014 chi cau thdnh tdi cuong dogt tai san. Bdi le, theo Dilu 135 Bg ludt Hinh sy ndm 1999 thi ddu hieu mat khdeh quan cua tdi Cuong dogt tdi san Id: de dpa dung vii lye hoac cd thii doan khdc nham chiem doat tdi sdn ciia ngudi khac. Trong trudng hgp ndy, cdc ddi tugng Hiing, Minh, Tuan, Ha dd diing thii doan ddi vdi anh Tdn, dy dd anh Tdn mua ddm vdi Ha, sau dd Tudn gid vo lam anh trai Hd den bat qua tang, rdi de dog diing vii lye ddi vdi anh Tdn nhdm yeu edu anh Tdn phai dua tien cho bpn chung. Tuy nhien, tai thdi diem nay anh Tan van ndi rdng khdng sg vi nghi rang Himg
Id ban minh. Nhung vi nggi phdi ra cong an gidi quydt nen da mien cudng dd lai xe may de hdm sau mang tiln din chupc. Vi vdy, hdnh vi ciia Hung, Minh, Tudn ehi cau thdnh tgi cuong dogt tai san.
Chi ddn hdm sau, ngay 21/9/2014, Hung, Mmh, Tudn ddn anh Tdn den dia diem vdng. Tai ddy. Hung, Minh, Tudn tilp tuc de dga anh Tan. Sau dd, Tudn dung day dien danh vdo ddu, vdo ngudi anh Tdn, anh Tdn mdi 1dm vdo tinh trgng khdng the chdng cu dugc, buOc phdi gpi dien ve cho vg de mang tien den, liic ndy hdnh vi eua Himg, Minh, Tudn mdi cdu thdnh tdi cudp tdi san (theo Dieu 133 Bg lugt Hinh su nam 1999, ddu Meu mgt khdch quan cua tdi cudp tdi san bao gdm mdt trong ba hanh vi sau: dung vii lye nham chiem doat tdi sdn; de doa diing vii luc ngay hie khac nhdm chiem doat tai san;
cd hanh vi khac lam ngudi cd tai
san 1dm vdo linh trgng khdng the chdng cu dugc nhdm cMem doat tdi sdn).
Ddi vdi hanh vi ciia Ha; Ha cd tham gia ban bae cimg Hung, Minh, Tudn tim edch chilm doat tien cua anh Tdn. Vao ngdy 20/9/2014, Hd dd gia lam gai bdn dam vd Cling tham gia vdi Hiing, Minh, Tudn nham tim each chiem doat tien ciia anh Tan. Vi vgy, hdnh vi cua Hd trong ngay 20/9/2014 ed ddu hieu ciia tgi cuong doat tdi sdn thudc khoan 1 Dilu 135 Bg Mat HiiUi sy nam 1999. Ddy la tgi pham nghiem trgng, Hd dudi 16 tudi nen khdng phdi chiu trach nMem hinh su. Ngdy 21/9/2014, Hd khdng ban bgc, cung khdng tham gia cung Himg, Minh, Tudn tim each chiem dogt tien cua anh Tan ndn Ha khdng phdi chiu trach | nMem hinh su ve tdi cudp tdi sdn •
Tdi ph^m ciro'p tdi san bj cdng an bdt qua tang Anh minh hga
LUAT SUVIET NAM I SO SI THANG S-2016