'Shi hdnh phdp. ludi
Sg S(326)
-2019
THUD HIEN QUYEN VA NGHfA VU CUA CHA ME DOI VOl CON SAU KHI CHA ME LY HON
• PGS.TS. N G U Y £ N TH! LAN*
Tdm tdt: Bdi viet de cgp den quyen vd nghia vu cda cha mp doi v&i con sau khi ly hon, tim hieu nhung vdn diphdt sinh irong qud trinh thuc hipn de dua ra gidi phdp nhdm ddm bdo thuc hipn quyin vd nghia vu ddi v&i con sau khi cha mp ly hon mat cdch tot nhdt.
Abstract: The paper is concerned with rights and duties of parents towards their children after divorce, problems arising out of implementation process in order ta propose solutions for ensuring performance of rights and duties of parents towards their chidren after divorce to the best..
1. Quydn va nghia v^ ciia cha mf ddi vdi con sau khi Iy hdn theo quy djnh cua phdp luSt Vift Nam
Ludt Hdn nhan va gia dinh ndm 2014 quy djnh vifc trdng nom, chdm sdc, nudi duang, giao due con sau khi ly hdn van thupc ve cd hai ben bd mg:
"Sau khi ly hdn, cha m? van cd quyen, nghia vy trdng nom, chdm sdc, nudi duang, gido dye con chua thanh nien, con da thdnh nien mat ndng luc hdnh vi dan sy hogc khdng cd khd ndng lao dpng vd khdng cd tai san de ty nudi minh theo quy dinh cua Lugt nay, Bp lugt Dan sy va cac lugt khac cd lien quan" (khodn 1 Dieu 81). Cy the bao gdm cac nghia vy va quydn chdm soc, nudi dudng con chua thanh nien, eon da thanh nien mdt ndng tyc hdnh vi dan sy hogc khdng cd khd ndng lao ddng vd khdng cd tat san de ty nudi minh (Didu 71); gido dye con, chdm lo va tao dieu kifn cho con hpc tdp;
t^o dieu kifn cho eon dupe sdng trong moi trudrng gia dinh ddm am, hod thudn; lam guang tdt eho con vd mpi mgt, phdi hpp chgt che vai nha trudiig, ca quan, td chue trong vifc giao dye con, hudng
dan con chpn nghe nghifp, tdn hpng quyen ehpn nghd, quyen tham gia boat ddng chinh trj, kinh tf, vdn hoa, xa hpi cda con (Dieu 72). Cha m^ la ngudi dai difn theo phdp luat cho con theo phap lugt, cha hogc m? cd quyen ty minh thyc hifn giao djch nham dap ung nhu cau thiet yeu cua eon theo quy djnh eua phdp ludt, ddi vdi giao djch lien quan den tai san la bdt ddng sdn, ddng sdn co ddng ky quyen sd hihi, quyen sfl dyng, tai sdn dua vao kinh doanh efla con chua thanh nien, con da thanh nien mat ndng lyc hanh vi dan sy phdi cd sy thda thu^n cua cha m? cho du hp da ly hdn, cha m? da ly hon van phdi chju trach nhifm lien ddi v6 vifc thyc hifn giao due lien quan ddn tdi san cua con theo quy djnh eua phdp ludt (Didu 73); phai bdi thudng thiet hgi do con chua thanh nien, con da thanh nien mat ndng lyc hanh vi dan sy gay ra (Didu 74);
cha m? ed thd la ngudi qudn ly tai sdn rieng ciia con khi con dudi 15 tudi (Dieu 76); cha me cd quyen dinh dogt tdi san rieng cua con vi Ipi ich cda con, neu con tu du 09 tudi h a len thi phdi xem xet nguyfn vpng cua con (Dieu 77)...
I Ddn chO & Phdp lu$t
* Dpi hpc Ludt Ha Npi^hi hdnh phdp. Iu4t 86 5 (326)-2019
Nhu vdy, vd ca bdn, khi cha m? ly hdn, quyen va nghia vu ddi vdi con cung khdng cd gi thay ddi.
Tuy nhien, do khi ly hdn, cha me cham dut hdn nhan, nen vifc thuc hifn quyen va nghia vu cua cac ben ddi vdi eon ciing dupe thyc hifn bdng each thuc khac so vdi khi hdn nhan cdn tdn tgi. De ddm bdo tdt nhdt quyen lpi cho dfla con sau khi cha m? ly hdn, Ludt Hdn nhdn vd gia dinh da quy djnh cy thd han vd quydn vd nghia vy cua cha m?
ddi vdi con chung, quyen va nghia vy ddi vdi nhau vi lpi ich eua dua con chung nhu sau:
Trude het, hp cd nghia vy tdn trpng quyen cua con dupe sdng chung vdi ngudi trye tiep nudi; cd nghia vy cap duang cho con. Do khi ly hdn, ngudi cha, m? khdng tryc tiep nudi eon dd bj tach khdi gia dinh, cd noi d khac, khdn^ sdng eung vdi dua con nfla nen phai thye hien nghia vy cap dydng.
Theo dinh ky hodc mpt Idn, hp phdi ddng gdp tien hoac tai sdn de nudi con. Sau khi ly hdn, ngudi khdng tryc tiep nudi eon ed quyen, nghia vu tham nom con ma khdng ai dupe can trd. Cha, m?
khdng trye tiep nudi con Iam dyng vifc thdm nom de can trd hodc gay anh hudng xau den vife trdng nom, ehdra sdc, nudi dudng, giao dye cdn thi ngudi tryc tiep nudi eon ed quyen yeu eau Tda an hgn ehe quyen thdm nom eon efla ngudi do. Khi ben cha, me khdng sdng eung vdfi con nfta, cd the theo thda thudn vdi ngudi true tiep nudi con, hp se thyc hifn quyen tham nom con theo djnh ky (Dieu 82).
Cha, mg tryc tiep nudi con cd quyen yeu cdu ngudi khong tiuc tiep nudi con thyc hifn cac nghia vy theo quy djnh cua phdp ludt; yeu eau ngudi khdng tryc tiep nudi con ciing cac thanh vien gia dinh tdn trpng quyen dupe nudi con ciia minh. Cha, m? tryc tidp nudi eon cung cac thanh vien gia dinh khdng dupe cdn trd ngudi khdng
true tidp nudi con trong viec tham nom, cham sdc, nudi dudng, gido dye eon. Quy dinh ndy nhdm dam bdo sy nghiem hie va tao dieu kifn tdt nhat cho cdc ben cha, me, thyc hifn quyen vd nghia vy cua minh ddi vdi con (Dieu 83).
vd thay ddi ngudi tryc tiep nudi con sau khi ly hon, trong trudng hpp cd yeu eau eua cha, me hodc ngudi than thich; ca quan qudn Iy nha nudc ve gia dinh; ca quan quan ly nha nudc ve tre em;
Hpi lien hifp phy nft, Tda an cd the quyet dinh vifc thay ddi ngudi tryc tiep nudi con. Vifc thay ddi ngudi tryc tiep nudi con dupe giai quyet khi cd mft hong cac edn cu sau: (i) Cha, m? cd thda thugn vd vife thay ddi ngudi true tidp nudi cdn phu hpp vdi lpi ich cua con; (ii) Ngudi tryc tiep nudi con khdng cdn du dieu kien tryc tiep trdng nom, cham sdc, nudi dudng, giao dye con; (iii) Vifc thay ddi ngudi tryc tiep nudi con phai xem xet nguyfn vpng efla con tfl du 07 hidi trd len; (iv) Trong trudng hpp xet thdy ea cha va me deu khdng du dieu kifn tryc tiep nudi con thi Tda an quyet djnh giao eon eho ngucri gidm hd theo quy djnh cua Bp luat Dan sy (Didu 84).
Luat Hdn nhdn va gia dinh nam 2014 cung quy dinh difn nhftng ngudi dupe quyen yeu edu thay ddi ngudi tryc tiep nudi con kha rdng de kjp thai phat hifn quyen eua eon bj dnh hudng do ngudi true tidp nudi eon khdng edn du dieu kifn trye tiep nudi eon hogc cd tinh vi phgm quyen vd nghia vy cua cha me ddi vdi con.
2. Nhihig v^n de phat sinh trong qua trinh thuc hifn quyen va nghia vu cua cha mf doi v&i con sau khi cha m$ Iy hdn
Thu nhat, thvtc hipn quyen vd nghia vu doi v&i con ciia nguai true tiip nudi con
Cha hodc m? Id ngudi hyc tiep nudi eon se Id ngudi gdn bo mat thiet gdn gui vdi con ban, vi
Ddn chCi & Phdp lu^t I
Qhihdidiphdp ludi 86 5 (326)-2019
vgy, thudrng hp se la ngudi cham sdc, giao due con nhieu han so vdi ngudi khong tryc tiep nudi con.
Hp se mat nhieu thdi gian vd cdng sue ddi vdi dua tre vi vdy cd the anh hudng den thu nhdp vd khd ndng phat trien cua ca nhan. Tren thuc te, nguai cha hodc mg sau khi ly hdn thudng nhd dng ba cham sdc con hodc thue ngudi giup vifc cham sdc con hang ngay. dieu nay cd the dnh hudng ddn sy phat trien ve tdm ly vd sue khoe efla dua he khi thai gian gdn gui cha mg khdng nhidu va each gido dye cham sdc eua dng ba hay ngudi giup vife cd the khdng dung each. Vi vdy, hifn tupng tre bj trdm cam, sue khde bj dnh hudng la rdt ed thd xdy ra tren thyc te va rdt khd kidm soat.
Cha, me tryc tidp nudi con sau khi Iy hdn cd the xae lap quan hf hon nhdn vdi ngudi khac, do dd, vifc nudi duong con rieng se dupe chia se vdi ngudi chdng ho|c ngudi vp mdi. Ludt Hdn nhan va gia dinh nam 2014 quy dinh: "Cha dupng, mg k£ cd quydn va nghTa vy trong nom, nudi duSng, cham sdc, giao due con rieng eua ben kia cung song chung vai minh (heo quy dinh cua phap ludt"
(Dieu 79). Tuy nhien, do nhieu yeu td, khi cha, me tai hdn thi dua tre lgi khdng song chung nita md d vdi dng ba thi cha dupng, m? ke eung khong cd nghia vy ddi vdi con rieng cua chdng hogc vp minh. Dieu nay vd hinh ehung cd thd gdy khd khdn cho vifc nudi duang chain sdc, giao dye con ciia ngudi cha hogc ngudi mg tryc tidp nudi con.
Bdi vi, khi hp xac lap quan hf hdn nhan thi thu nhdp cua hp trong thdi ky hdn nhan mdi thupc tai sdn chung hpp nhdt vp chdng ndu vp chdng lya chpn chl dp tdi san theo lugt dinh. Trong khi dd, nghia vy nudi duang con rieng lgi thupc nghia vy rieng, ve nguyen tdc, ngudi dang tryc tiep nudi con rieng khdng dupe dung tai san chung dd thyc hifn nghia vu rieng tru khi ed thda thugn. Neu ho
E 9 Ddn chili & Phdp lu^t
khdng cd tdi sdn rieng thi vifc thyc hifn quyin va nghia vy ddi vai con rieng Id rat khd khdn. Giai phap cho trudfng hpp nay la hp phdi thda thugn vdi chdng hodc vp chia tdi sdn chung hong thdi ky hdn nhan hogc yeu can Tda an chia tai sdn chung trong thdi ky hdn nhan de lay phdn tdi san ciia minh nudi dudng chdm sdc con rieng. Neu hg khdng cdn du dieu kifn tryc tiep nudi con thi co the thay ddi ngudi nudi con nhdm ddm bao quyen vd lpi ich hap phap ciia dua con.
Trong trudng hop thay ddi ngudi nudi con ma dfla con dupe giao cho ngudi giam hd thi phap luat Vift Nam chua quy djnh cu the quyen va nghia vy ciia eha mg doi vdi con. Theo quan diim efla tac gia, phap ludt can quy djnh cy the rdng, cha mg phdi co nghia vy cap dudng cho con. Tren thyc te, nhieu trudng hpp, do hoan canh ma cha mg khdng the de dua con sdng ehung vdi minh dupe nhung van cd thd qua lgi dd cham sdc coil, thi khdng nen ddt ra vdn dd thay ddi ngudi nudi con, giao eon eho ngudi giam hp khi dua tfe khong bj dnh hudng den quyen va lpi ich. Dik nay se ddm bao ban quyen va nghia vy efla eha me nhu quyen dgi difn, quyen quan ly tai san eua con, quyen djnh dogt tai san efla con, bdi thudng thift hgi do con gay ra.
Mpt van de nua ddt ra la tren thyc td, cha, m?
la ngudi tryc tiep nudi con cd hanh vi can trd vifc thdm nom con cua cha, me khdng tryc tiep nudi con, cua ngudi thdn thieh cua dua tre nhu nguoi cha vd gia dinh nguai cha can trd ngudi m? vd gia dinh ngudi mg tham nom, chdm soc con. Dieu nay lam dnh hudng rat ldu den tdm ly cua dfla tre va quyen Ipi ich hpp phap cua nhung ngudi cd quyen va lpi ieh lien quan. "Vife ngan can quyen tham nom con doi vdi nguoi khdng trye tidp nudi duong vd hinh chung da vi phgm quyen cua tre
^hi hdnh phdp. ludt 86 5 (326)-2019
em..."'. phap lugt Vift Nam coi day la hanh vi bao lyc gia dinh^. Tuy nhien, vifc chung minh hen thyc te Id rat kho khan vi ngudi tryc tiep nudi con ludn vien ra nhieu ly do dd tu chdi vifc tham nom cua ngudi cdn lgi va gia dinh cua hp. Theo quan diem cua tdc gid, ngudi bj ngan can vifc tham nom con cdn luu gift nhftng chflng cu cdn thiet de bao vf quyen efla minh khi ben true tidp nudi eon tidp tye cd hanh vi ngdn cdn dd dd yeu edu hp phai thyc hien nghiem tuc nghia vy lugt dinh, hoac yeu cdu ca quan nhd nudc cd tham quyen can thifp kjp thdi.
Thu hai, thirc hien quyen vd nghia vu doi v&l con cda nguai khong true tiip nudi con
Mpt trong cac quyen quan trpng nhat cua ngudi khong tryc tiep nydi con la quyen cap dudng. Muc cap duSng va phuang thflc cap dudng thudng xac dinh dya tren sy thda thydn can cu vdo thu nhgp, kha ndng thyc te eua ngudi cd nghia vy cap dudng va nhu can thiet yeu eua ngudi dupe cap duong, neu khdng thda thudn dupe thi yeu cdu Toa an gidi quyet^. Tren thyc te, khi ben cha, mg khdng tryc tiep nudi con cd thu nhap dn djnh vd nghiem tiic thyc hifn thi quyen va lpi ieh eua dfla con sg dupe dam bdo. Ndu ngudi cha, me khdng thye hifn nghia vu cap dudng cho con thi ed the cudng che thi hanh nhu khau trfl vao thu nhdp cua ngudi dd*. Tuy nhien, dieu nay vap phai mpt mdu thuan la neu ben cha, m? phdi cdp dudng cho con da tai hdn thi thu nhgp eua hp se thupc tai sdn chung cua vp chdng, trong khi dd, nghia vy cdp duong la nghia vy rieng nen vifc khdu tru vao thu nhdp vd hinh chung la da Idy tdi sdn chung de thyc hifn nghia vy rieng, tfl dd ngudi vg hodc ngudi chdng cua hp hi dnh hudng ddn quyen lpi. Ben cgnh do, Nghj djnh sd 62/2015/ND -CP ngay I8/7/20I5 cua Chinh phu
quy dinh chi tiet vd thi hanh mpt sd dieu cua Ludt Thi hdnh an dan sy da quy djnh neu la ngudi cd nghia vy c6 tai sdn chung vdi ngudi khac, thi chap hdnh vien se thdng bdo de hp ty thu xep Idy phdn tai sdn cua minh thyc hifn nghia vy, neu hp khdng chia tdi san sau mpt khoang thdi gian nhdt djnh thi chap hanh vien cd quyen xfl iy tdi san de thi hanh an ddi vdi ngudi cd nghia vu cap duong ma trdn trdnh nghia vy dd^. Vifc quy djnh ndy rd rang da ddm bdo tdt nhdt quyen cho dua con, nhung ciing tuang ty nhu tren da phdn tich, vifc chap hanh vien xu ly tdi sdn chung ciia vp ehdng la khdng ddm bdo nguyen tdc chung ve ehia tai san ehung cua vp chdng theo quy djnh efla Lugt Hdn nhan vd gia dinh ndm 2014, dieu nay cd the se dnh hudng den quyen va lpi ieh hpp phap cua ngudi vp hodc ngudi chdng cdn lai. Neu khi tai hdn, hp thuc hifn chd dp tai san theo thda thudn va thda thuan rieng bift vd tai sdn thi ciing khdng the vdn dyng Ludt Thi hanh an ddn sy nhu da neu tren dupe, bdi vi, gifta hp va ngucri va hodc ngudi chdng mdi khdng tdn tai tai san ehung, nhu tdc gia Bui Minh Hdng da vidt: "Che dp tai san rieng bift xdc djnh vp chdng khdng cd tdi san chung. Chi cd sy tdn tai cua hai khdi tai sdn rieng eua moi ben... Che dp tdi sdn rieng bift tt-ao cho vp, ehdng kha nang ty chii rdt cap v6 tdi sdn..., tuy nhien, che dp tach bift tdi san cung bdc Id nhieu hgn ehe. Nd bj danh gid la
"ich ky nhat" vi thue chdt dd la ca ehe bdo toan tai san cua ca nhdn..."^. Neu ngudi phai cap duong cho con, sau khi tai hdn d nha npi trp, khdng ed thu nhap se anh hudng rat Idn den quyen va Igi ich hpp phdp efla con, vifc cudng che thi hanh Id khdng hifu qud. Nhieu ngudi la lao ddng tu do, thdt nghifp, chd d khdng on djnh nhu lao dpng di cu thi vifc hp trdn tranh nghia vy cap duang se khd cd thd ap dung che tai ddi vdi hp cung nhu
Ddn chCi & Phdp lu^t O
^hi hdnh phdp. ludt 86 5 (326)-2019
bupc hp thyc hifn nghia vy cdp duang cho con.
Dac bift khi cung mdt lue hp phdi edp dudng cho nhieu ngudi, eac con, bd mg, anh chj em thi vifc sdp xdp uu tien ai hudc va mflc cap dudng dupe tinh nhu thd nao thi thyc tien thi hanh cdn gap vudng mdc, khd giai quyet. Hifn nay, trong eac gia dinh Vift Nam, cac ba m? sau khi ly hon la ngudi tryc tiep nudi con thudng phdi nudi con mpt minh. ngudi cha sau khi Iy hdn la ngudi khdng tryc tiep nudi con, sau dd tai hdn thi van cd tinh trgng trdn tranh nghia vy cap dudng cho con hodc do hp khdng ed thu nhdp nen khdng cdn kha ndng cap dudng nua. Trong trudng hpp nay, vifc dp dyng che tai ddi vdi hp ciing khdng giai quyet dupe van de, khdng dam bao dupe quyen vd lai ich eua dua eon.
Ddi vdi quyen thdm nom, cham sdc con thi ngudi cha hogc ngudi me khdng hyc tiep nudi con sc thyc hifn theo thda thudn vdi ngudi tryc tiep nudi con, khdng dupe ty y thyc hifn quyen nay.
Tren thyc te, nhieu trudng hpp ngudi cha hoac nguoi me da ty y ddn eon d nha tre ho|ie trudng hpe ma khdng bdo va thoa thugn vdi ngudi cdn lgi dan den nhihig xung dpt nhat djnh trong gia dinh.
Tuy nhien; theo phap luat Vift Nam hifn nay khdng cd che tdi cy the cho trudng hpp nay. Theo quan diem ciia tac gid cdn quy djnh che tai cy thd nghiem khac cho dii vifc ty y mang con di khdng vi myc dich vy lpi hay myc dich gi khae. Ngoai ra, ngudi khdng tryc tiep nudi con van phai thyc hifn eac quyen va nghTa vy khac ddi vol eon eung vdi ngudi tryc tidp nudi con nhu quyen dgi difn eho con, nghia vy boi thudng thift hai do con gdy ra theo quy djnh cua phap lugt. Tren thye te, nhidu eha mg eho ring minh khdng phai trdch nhifm gi doi vdi dua tre do minh khdng sdng cung con, ma
ngudi tryc tiep nudi con phai ehju, trach nhifm.
Day la sai 1dm trong vife nhin nhgn van de. Diia tre Id con chung, vife cham sdc, nudi duang giao dye con la ti'deh nhifm cua hai ben eha mg, ngudi khdng tryc tiep nudi con chi la khdng thuc hifn viec cham sdc, gido dye thuong xuyen hon so vdi nguoi tryc tiep nudi con thoi.
Ben canh do, tren thye td, ngudi khdng tnrc tidp nudi eon khi phdt hifn ngudi tryc tiep nuoi con da trdn tranh nghia vy nudi dudng cham soc eon thi hp cd quyen yeu cdu ngudi kia thyc hifn hogc cd the yen cdu ngudi kia phdi cap dudng cho con hodc ed the ydu cdu thay ddi ngudi nudi con.
Nhung vifc thu thap chung cu trong hirdng hgp nay Id rdt khd khan. Nhieu truong hpp dfla he dli bj dnh hudng nghiem trpng den sue khoe, tinh thdn thi mdi cd du ca sa de yeu cdu giai quyet.
Nen chdng cdn cd quy dinh ve tham kham dinh ky cho dua con de kjp thai phdt hifn nhung dau hifu bdt thudng de xfl ly nhanh gpn, ddm bdo quyen va lpi ich cho con.
Trong qua trinh cdp duong, neu hp roi vao tinh trgng co khd khdn ve kinh te thi ed the xin tam ngimg nghia vy cap dudng, nhung phap lugt Vift Nam khdng quy djnh ve thdi ban tgm ngflng, do dd, dd xac djnh khi ndo het thai gian tgm ngflng la rat khd khan, tao didu kifn thugn Ipi cho hp trSn trdnh nghia vy cap dudng mpt each hpp phap.
Theo tac gid, vife xem xet vdn dd tam ngflng thyc hifn nghia vy cdp du5ng phai hdt sue ein trpng va hgn che tdi da. Vifc tam ngimg thyc hifn nghia vu cap duong chi dupe dp dung cho phuang thuc cap du&ng djnh ky, do dd, sau khi hdt thdi gian t?m ngimg thi ngudi dd s6 cap duong tiep ma khdng phdi bu Igi tai san trong suot thdi gian tgm ngimg.
Hifn nay, co tnrong hpp sau khi ly hdn mot vai
I Ddn ChO & Phdp lu^t
^^Utdnh phdp. ludt 86 5 (326) - 2019
nam, cac ben cha mg cd thd Id ngudi tryc tiep nudi Van de nay phdp lugt Vift Nam chua cd quy djnh con hole ngudi khdng tryc tidp nudi con phat hifn cy the. Theo quan didm eua tac gid, khi Tda an da ra dfla tre khdng phai con ciia minh va da cd don ra phan quyet rdng gifta hp khdng tdn tgi quan hf kifn de xdc djnh lgi quan hf cha con hoac me con. cha con hodc me con thi ed nghia coi nhu chua Ve thu tyc xac djnh lgi quan hf cha con hoac mp timg tdn tgi mdi quan hf dd ngay hr khi dua he con chung tdi khdng ban nhidu d ddy, nhung ndu dupe sinh ra. Tuy nhien, xudt phat tu lpi ich cua Tda an da ra phdn quyet giiia hp khdng tdn tgi dfla tre thi khdng nen dgt ra vdn dd hdi td ddi lai quan hf cha con va mp con thi vifc edp dudng va khodn tdi sdn da nuoi du5ng hay cdp duong cho nudi du5ng da thyc hifn trong sudt qua h-inh tu dua ti:e ma hp chi khdng phai thuc hien nghia vu trudc khi cd phan quyet eua Tod an se dupe xu ly dd ke ti!r thdi didm phan quydt cua Tda dn cd hifu nhu the nao? Lifu nguai cd ldi cd phai chju trach lue phap ludt rdng giua cac ben khdng tdn tgi quan nhifm vd hoan tra lai cho ben edn lai hay khdng? hf cha con hoac me con •
/. Xem Nguyen Thi Hanh, Vipc dp dung vd thuc hipn cdc quy dinh ve quyin vd nghia vg ciia cha mp doi vdi con khi ly hon, Tgp chi Khoa hpc, Vien Dgi hpc Md Hd Ngi, sd 44 - thdng 6/2018.
2. Ngan cdn vipc thuc hiin quyen, nghia vg trong quan hp gia dinh giua ong. bd vd chdu; giua cha. mp vd con;
giira vg vd chong; giua anh, chi, em vdi nhau (diim d khodn I Diiu 2 Lugt Phong, chdng bgo l^c gia dinh nan 2007).
3. Dieu 116 Ludt Hon nhdn vd gia dinh ndm 2014.
4. Diiu 78 Ludt Thi hdnh dn ddn su ndm 2014.
5. Bieu 24 Nghi dinh so 62/2015/ND~CP
6. Xem Bill Minh Hong, Ap dgng chi dp ldi sdn va chong theo thoa thudn, Tgp chi Khoa hpc, Viin Dgi hoc Ma Hd Npi. sd 44 - thdng 6/2018.
Quy che phap ly ve thanh vien...
(Tiep theo trang 41)trong cac don vj Ivrc lirgmg vu trang nhan dan. dyng nhan dan voi tir each la thanh vien doi voi doi (iii) Bo quy djnh cam tham gia vao Quy tin hrong la nguoi dang trong thori gian chap hanh quyet dung nhan dan voi tu each la thanh vien doi voi doi djnh dua vao co so giao due, co sd chiia b?nh • tuong la nguoi da bj ket an tir tQi ph?m nghiem
hpng tro len ma chua duijrc xoa an tich. Bo sung , g,j„ ^, j.i,g„g ,^ j ^ ' 04/201S/TT-NHNN.
quy dinh c4m d6i voi doi hrong la nguoi dang bj 2. Khoin I Biiu 31, Thdng iitsd 04/20l5rrT-NHNN.
cam hanh nghe kinh doanh, dam nhi?m chuc v\i 3, Biim c khoan I Biiu 31 ndng tit so 04/20IS/TT- ho^c lam mgt cong vi?c nhat djnh lien quan den NHNN.
kinh doanh theo quyet djnh cua Toa an. 4. Biim c khoin I Biiu 31 Thdng ttr sd 04/20IS/TT- (iv) B6 sung quy djnh cam tham gia vao Qu^ tin WMW.