NGHliN Ciru - TRAO o 6 i
MQT S6 BI$N PHAP TAO DONG Ll/C CHO CAN BO, CONG CHlfC CXP CO Sd TRONG QUA TRiNH THl/C THI C 6 N G VU
ThS. NGO THI KIM DUNG
1. Ddng lye thyc thi cdng vy d can bd, cdng cliflc (CBCC) dugc hilu Ik sy kbit khao vk ty nguyen cia CBCC nhim phat huy tfnh tfch eye vk hufimg cic nd Iyc cia ban thdn hg tdi thyc Men tdt myc tieu cia boat ddng cdng vy dl ra. Do vdy, khi cac CECC cd ddng co Ikm viec dflng ddn thi d hg cflng se xud't hien ddng lye 1km vide tfch eye vk se dat hieu sud't cao. Thyc t l cho thdy, d cdc t l chflc cd quan hknh chinh nhk nudc (HCNN), ddng Iyc tfch eye ttong thyc thi cdng vu d CBCC Ik ylu td quan trgng, quydt djnh sy tdn tai vk phit triln cia td chflc ttong xa hdi. d nhttng td chflc hknh chfnh mk ngudi Ianh dao bilt quan Idm din CBCC cfta mhih; bilt kMch le bg Ikm viec (tfle Ik bilt tao ddng lye 1km vide cho CBCC) thi ttong td chflc dd se cd dugc mdt ddi ngtt CBCC sd'ng hft minh vi id chiic, coi to chflc nbu gia dlnb cia minh vk coi cdng viec cia td chflc nhu cMnh edng viec cia minh, dilu nky se giup cho to chflc dl dkng dat dugc muc tieu da dkt ra vk tao duge nhilu co hdi bcm cho sy phdt triln Udp theo. Ngugc lai, ttong nhflng td chflc banh chfnh mk CSCC khdng duge quan tdm dflng mflc, tMlu ddng lyc tich eye 1km viec tU viee hokn thknh muc tieu cia td chflc khdng nhttng trd nen khd khdn hem mk cdn cd nguy cd din din sy suy Ihoai cia td chflc.
Ddng luc tich eye boat ddng cdng vu d cdc CBCC khdng ty nhiin cd d mdi ngudi mk nd duoc hlnh thknh tren co sd nlidn
thflc vk ndng Iyc boat ddng cdng vu cia bg. Nhdn thflc giflp CBCC xac djnh dugc muc tieu hknh ddng cia minh, ddng thdi giflp hg dilu chinh dugc banh vi cfta minh ttong qua ttlnh boat ddng thyc tiln dl dat dugc muc tieu xic djrih. CBCC ttong cde td chflc HCNN cM ed tbi tfch eye Ikm viec vk 1km viec cd hieu qui khi hg nhdn thflc vk Mlu ro dugc tfnh chdt, ndi dung, cdc ydu edu cua cdng viec dugc giao mdt cdch cd J thflc vk ty gide. Tft dd hg se cd J thflc phfll ddu, nd lyc vugt mgi khd khdn dl hokn thknh tdt nMdm vu dugc giao, ttdi lai, kM CBCC chua Mlu ddy dft nMem vu cia minh (nghla li chua Mlu dugc minh cin lam gl?) Ikm nbu thfi nko? tbi khd cd thi ndi ddn Meu qua viec thyc tM nMem vu d bg. Dilu nky cbo tiidy, ddng lyc tfch eye trong thyc thi cdng vu cia CBCC cung dugc bilu bifin d mflc dd hki ldng vdi edng viec, mflc dd bki ldng vdi thyc ticudc sdng mk cdng vile dem Iai cbo Iig. Trong boat ddng cdng vu, ddng lyc 1km vide d ngudi lao ddng ndi chung vk ddng lye thyc tM cdng vu d CBCC cdn dugc bilu Mfin ro nfit d thdi gian va mflc dd ty nguyfin tiiyc Mfin cde edng vific dugc giao. Dan eft nhu, nhitag CBCC cd ddng lyc tfch cue ddi vdi boat ddng cdng vu cia bin thdn vk xa hdi, tM hg thudng bilu bifin sy quan tdm din nghi ngMep vk cdng vific dugc giao d mflc dd cao tdp trang sflc lyc vko cdng viec vdi
• Hgc vl0n Hdnh chinh
TAP CHi OUAN LJ NHA NUdc - sd 194 (3-2012) 39
NGHlgN Cihj - TRAO DOI
Idng nhiet tinh vk sy say mfi xud't phdt ttt sflc hflt cia cdng vice, ludn thi Men ttdch nMem vdi cdng vific d i Ik nhttng viec don gian nhdt, hg khdng cd bilu bifin di mudn ve sdm hay pM hoki tbdi gian vko viec tan giu vdi ddng ngMdp vk sft dung intemet dl giSt tbdi gian... Ngoki ra, ddng lyc tfch eye trong cdng vific d CBCC edn bieu Men d cbd, hg Iudn cd J cM, ngM Iyc vugt khd trong edng viec, J cM Ikm viec cia hg cdn cd tde dgng tda sdng, lan trayin tdi cdc thknh vien khdc trong td chflc, 1km cho td ehfle cd them sflc manh.
Ngoki ra, nhttng ddc dilm vl sinh IJ, gidi tfnh, tudi tae, nhdn ehing hge hay vdh dc tdn giao... cung Ik nhitag yfiu td chi quan cd anh hudng dfin ddng CO, thdi dd thuc tM cdng vu d ngudi CBCC. Ching ban, gifii tfnh nam vk ntt cd nhttng khde biet nhd't dinh. Nam gidi thudng thi Mfin sy canh ttanh, nang ddng, thfch tlm tdi, sing tao vk cd thi lyc tdt ttong cdng viec nbung lai hay ciu tiia, ndng vdi vk thilu kien trl. Hong kM dd, ntt gifii thudng cin than, edn cu, chju khd, cd sflc chiu dyng cao nhung lai dl an phdn. C^fnh sy klidc biet nky tdc ddng den ddng lyc 1km vide cia bg vk tao ra sy khdc biet ttong ddng lyc thyc tM cdng vu d CBCC trong cic co quan HCNN Men nay.
Do ddc ttung cia nin HCNN, cia boat ddng cdng vu ndn ddng lyc thyc tM cdng vu d CBCX! cdn chju tae ddng bdi nhilu ylu td khach quan kiiie ntta nbu: dac ttung cia td chflc, vfli dl bd tri nhdn sy ttong td chflc, phong each Ikm viec cia nhk Ianh dao bay dilu kien 1km viec thyc t l cia ca niikn... Vf du, cac td chflc, co quan HCNN mang tfnh tiifl bdc chdt ehe vk boat ddng thdng sudt tft cdc co quan trang uong din dja phucmg ma ttong dd, cdp dudi phuc tung cdp trfin, nhdn cM thj, menh lenh va sy kilm tta thudng xuyfin cia cd'p ttfin nfin cdng chflc hknh chfnh chju nhilu sy rkng budc cflng nhic hon cde nhdn vien 1km vific ttong cdc td ehfle tu nhdn, thfim vko
do, ndu viec phdn quyln cho CBCC khfing dugc thyc Men tdt cd thi ddn dSn viec CBCC khdng phdt huy dugc kha nang sang tao, khdng chi ddng ttong cdng vific cua minh.
Ddng lyc thyc tM cdng vu d CBCX: dugc cMa ikm ba loai Ik: ddng lyc tri tue - tinh thdn; ddng lye i J tudng - tinh cam vk ddng lyc kinti td - vat chdt. Chi thi: ddng lyc tri tue - tinh thdn ik nhttng kfch thfch gkn li^n vdi viec thoi man nhu cdu khai sdng nhttng lgi fcli nhan thflc, dd chi'nh la sy khoi ddy tinh thdn sang tao dl tao ra nhitag tti thIii:
mdi, tidn bd vk httu fch, phyc vy cbo hoat ddng cdng vu ngky mdt tdt ban. Ddng lyc IJ tudng - tinii cam la nhttng thue diytfiib tfch eye cia CBCC gdn liln vfii cac sic thii tinh ciim nbu tdm trang thoii mil hay khdng thoai mdi; tinh cim yeu thuang, cdm gidn hay sy hdn thi vk cao ban ntta Ik IJ tudng cd nhdn... Ddng Iyc kinh te - vdt chdt Ik nhttng kfch tMch Iifin quan din vific thoi man nhu cdu ddi sdng vdt chdt cia ngudi CBCC, nd khdng chi bao gdm nhu cdu an, d hay mde... cia ngudi CBCC ma cdn bao gdm ca nhttng phuang tidn, trang thilt bj cho cac qua ttlnh boat ddng sing tao cia hg. Viec liilu rd cac Ioai eldng Iuc xudt Men d CBCC se giflp cdc nhk quan IJ cdng cd nhflng nhdn dinh, phdn tfch dl tim ra nhttng Men piiap tdc ddng phi hgp nbkm tao ddng lyc cho CBCC trong qui trinh thyc tbi cdng vu, gdp phdn ndng cao chdt Iugng boat ddng cdng vu hidn nay.
2. Qua trao ddi, phdng vfli ddi vdi 180 CBCC cdp CO sd thudc cdc Gnh vyc khac nhau d dja bkn thknh phd Ha Ndi vl dfing lye thyc tM t;dng vu eia ddi ngtt nky cho thdy, cd tdi 30% CBCC khdiig bki ldng vdi cdng viec Men tai cia mlnb, 33% gitt J kiln trang ldp vk 37% hki ldng. Kit qui nky cho thiy tJ le CSCC khdng hki Idng vdi nMem vu, edng viec dugc giao Ik rdt ding phai luu tdm. Ty 16 nky eho thdy tfin tai nhttng bit cdp ttong quan IJ nhk nudc 6 cic td chflc, cd quan, sy tMfiu ddng lyc 1km
40 TAP CHi OUAN LY NHA NUdC - sd 194 (3-2012)
NGHliN Ciru - TRAO OOI vific cia CBCC la nhdn td lam cho Mdu
sudt cdng vide eia t l chflc khdng dap flng dugc cic yfiu cdu dat ra cia xa hdi vk sy rdi bd cia mdt sd CBCC khi hg cd co hdi.
Vdi cdu hoi, trong dilu kien lam viec hien nay, dng/bk cd mudn chuyin sang Iam viec tai cd quan, td chflc khic khdng?
CJiung tdi tbu dugc mdt kft qui bit ngd, dd la, ty le CBCC mudn rdi bd co quan HCNN chiim ty le rfl cao (chilm 43,5%), nhitag ngudi khdng mudn rdi bd chidm tJ le tuong ty (chidm 43,5%), cd 13% CBCC gitt J kiln trung ldp. Nhttng ngudi cd J kie'n trung ldp diu giii thfch ring mudn ra ngoki 1km kiii ed co hdi vdi mong mudn tbu nhdp cao ban, nhung vin mudn 1km viec d CO quan HCM^ vi cdng viec dn djnh.
Trong sd nhttng CBCC mudn chuyin cdng vific Men tai trong co quan HCNN sang 1km vific d cac td chflc klidc thi trlnh dd dai hgc chilm 75%, trinh dd cao ding trd xudng chilm 25%, dilu nky dang Ik mdt bdo ddng vl sy "ciiiy mdu chit xam"
d trong cdc co quan HC!NN, ddy ro rkng Ik vd'n dl mk cac nhk quin IJ cdn phii ddc biet ehfl tdm vi co quan hknh cbfnh khong cdn Ik noi dknh cbo nhttng ngudi cd tki ma trd thknh noi trfl ngu cia nhilu lao ddng vdi trinh dd khdng cao. Mflc dd quan tdm dfin nghi nghiep vk cdng vifie dang dim nhiem d CBCC cflng thdy xufl bifin nhilu vdn dl bd't cdp: ed tdi 31% sd CBCC dugc khio sat khdng hilu ro vl cdng vide minh lam. Hg khdng hilu rd dugc ehfle trdch nhifim vu cia cdng viec, cac dilu kien, tieu chuin kill thyc hien cdng viec cung nhu phuong thflc thyc liifin cdng viec vk chflc Irach quyln ban cia bin thdn ddi cdng viee de'n ddu... Vdn cdn 53,6% CBCC dknh thdi gian ngoki cdng viec d co quan dl 1km them ede edng viec khic nhdm kiem thfim thu nhap; 27,4% CBCC dknh tbdi ^ian cho viec nglii ngoi sau gid 1km vific dl tii sin xudt sflc lao ddng do khdng cd vifie gl 1km Ihem vk chi cd 20% CBCC dknh thdi gian dl tu bgc vk theo ede ldp hgc ndng cao
trinh do chuyen mdn. Dilu nky Ik mdt can cfl 1J giii vfi nhitag phkn nkn tft pMa ngudi ddn ddi vdi cac hoat ddng cdng vu cia cac td chflc HCNN bifin nay
Kft qua nghien cflu tren cdn bilu hifin mdt thyc te Ik: trong hoat ddng cdng vu thudng ngky, chi cd 18% CBCC kbing djnh hg cd sy tfch eye vk rd't tfch eye dd'i vdi boat ddng cdng vy do bg dim nhidm.
Cd 52'% CBCC cim nlidn ring hg Ikm vice vdi thai dd blnh thudng, khdng tfch cue cung khdng chin nin khi thyc Mfin cdng viec. CM tdi 30% CBCC khang dinh hg khdng ydu thfch cdng viec, lam vile theo kilu dugc chang hay chd chi vi trich nMem ma thdi...
Nhttng biiu Men thidu ddng luc tfch eye trong cdng vific d CBCC cd nhilu nguyin nhdn khac nhau gdy ra nhu cdng tic bd trf nhdn sy ttong cdc td chflc chua hgp 1 J, chd do luong, thudng ttong bfi thdng HCNN chua tao dugc ddng Iyc 1km vide tfch cue d CBCC hay ngudi lanh dao trong cic td chflc chua bie't edeh khfch le, ddng vien cdng chflc 1km vide...
Rd rkng, kft qua nghien cuu d tren da cbo thdy mdt bflc tranh tokn canh vl nhttng bat cap trong ddng lyc tbi cdng vu d cdc CBCC ttong cdc td chflc HCHN hiln nay De tao ddng lyc thyc thi cdng vu cho CBCC thi cdn pbai thdy rd nhttng nguydn nhdn inh hudng de'n ddng luc 1km viec d CBCC.
3. Nguyen nhdn ddu tien, sdu xa din din sy thifiu ddng Iyc trong boat ddng cdng vu d CBC(I! bidn nay chfnh la do tdc ddng cia sy nhdn tliflc va dinh hudng ve nghi nghifip d cac CBCC. Trong sd J kien cia 180 CBCC vl IJ do khien cdng chflc chgn lam vific tai ca quan HCNN hien nay thi cd tdi si,4'% CBCC cho ring, hg Ikm viec ttong cic td chflc HCNN Ik do cdng viec dn dinh, 24,2% cho ring, nghi nghiep cia hg do cba me vk gia dinh dinh hudng.
CM cd 24,4% CBCC Iya chgn cdng vific Ik do nghi nghiep phi hgp vdi ban thin.
TAP CHi QUAN i f NHA NUdC - sd 194 (3-2012) 41
NGHIEN Cim - TRAO OOI
Nhitag sd Geu nay da phdn nao giai thfch cho su thidu ddng luc lam vice d CBCC, cung nbu nhitag bat cdp vd hifiu sudt cdng vific trong cac td chflc HCNN bifin nay.
Nguyen nhdn thfl hai tac ddng Idn ddn ddng lye trong boat ddng cdng vu d CBCC Ik ning luc, nghiep vu cua ddi ngu nay cdn ban cbd. Kft qua khio sat cho thay, cd 62,5% CBCC cd ttinh do dai hoc, 25%
CBCC cd trinh dd trang cdp, cao ddng vk vin cdn 12,5% cM cd trinh dd THPT. Khio sal vl thuc te Mlu cdng viec dang dam nhiem cia CBCC, chflng tdi cung tbu dugc kel qui cd tdi 37% khflng thyc sy bilu rd vfi cdng viec cia minh vk phdn Idn cdng chflc dugc iidi diu 1km quen vdi cflng viec theo kilu ty hgc, ngudi ttudc hgc ngudi sau, cfl lam mfli thdi gian se quen...
Nguyen nhdn thfl ba tac dflng den dgng lye Ifch cue cia CBCC trong boat ddng thyc thi cdng vu cbfnh la vdn dl tdm trang ca nhdn. Tdm trang ca nhdn xud't hien do sy tac ddng cia nhilu ydu td chi quan vk khach quan khac nhau. Nhttng ydu td chu quan tao nfin tdm trang cia mfli ca nhdn cd Ihl ke de'n dd Ik cdc vd'n dl vl tudi tie, gidi H'nh, sd thfch cia ca nhdn... Nhttng ngudi tre tudi (dudi 30 tudi) thudng rit quan tam din luong cao, d hg thudng nang ddng, sang tao vk bam hgc bdi. Hg thfch su mao hilm vk ua di chuyin nhung thie'u sy dilm ITnh, hay sdc ndi..., chi'nh difiu nky anh hudng ldn dfn ddng lyc lam viec cia hg.
Ngugc vdi nhttng ngudi tre tudi, nhttng ngudi lao ddng Iren 50 tudi thudng cd tdm Iy thfch nhttng cdng viec thu vj. Tuy nhien, d hg Ihudng ft sang tao, bay bao thi nhung lai giau kinh nghiem, dilm tinh vk than Irgng trong viee giii quyft cac cdng vile.
Ngoai nhitag yeu tfl' chi quan cdn cd nhilu ye'u td khich quan khae nhau tde ddng den Irang thai tdm IJ cia cac ca nhdn ttong hoal ddng thyc tM cdng vu nbu: mdi trudng Ikm viec, ca sd vdt chdt, tinh ttang kinh t l - xa hdi, phong cdch Ikm viec cia nhk Ianh dao...
d CBCX thudng xud't Men hai Ioai tdn trang Ikra viec phd bidn Ik tdm ttang lam viec tieh cue dn dinh vk tdm ttang lam viet tieu eye kiidng dii djnh. Nhilu CBCC lii frong cdc td chflc HCNN hien nay thudnj xudt bieri tdm frang Ikm vific klidng ^ djnh do mflc lucmg cdng chflc edn thd'p so vdi mat bing xa hdi.
Chfnh vl vdy, nguydn nhdn thfl tu IJ, dilu kien 1km vific khdng tdt se cin trddfii tinh tfch cue cia CBCC frong boat dflng thyc thi cdng vu. Ca sd vdt chd't, ky ihuai bao gdm: nhk xudng, thilt bi van phfing, mdy mde... cd tic ddng ldn dia ddng Iuc 1km viec d cdc CBCC. Nhttng CO quan, l6 chflc cd CO sd lam viec tdt se tao cho cfing chflc tinh thdn, thii dfi Ikrii vide tdt vi ngugc Iai.
Nguyen nhdn thfl ndm, vd'n dl tuyin dung vk bd tri skp xip nhin sy trong tl chflc cd tac ddng ddn ddng Iyc ikm vific I CBCC. Ddng Iyc tfch eye hay kh6ng tfch eye trong qua trlnh thyc thi cdng vu 6 CBCC chju tac ddng rk't idn d tfnh phi hmi bay khdng pbi hgp vl nang Iyc ma ml!
CBCC dam nhifim trdn thyc tl. Nhilu nghien cflu cbo thdy, trinh dd cia nhan vien hay eia eac CBCC cao hon nhilu so vdi cdng vific hg nkm gitt se din tdi vi4c nhdn vidn, edng chflc nhanh chdng rai vko trang thai nbkm chdn vk thifiu ddng CO lam vide. Ngugc lai, trinh dd cia nhdn vien, cia CBCC thdp hon yeu cdu cdng vific se lam cho hg khd khdn trong giii quylt cic cdng vific cu thi. Tinh trang nky Ikp di ISp Iai hang ngky se 1km cho ngudi lao dfing roi vko tinh ttang met mdi, chin nan va khdng cd ddng co 1km viec ntta.
Nguyen nhdn thfl siu, tifiu chf ddnh gii CBCC chua rd rkng, cic Men phdp thi dua khen thudng d cac td chflc cd quan cfin nhilu bfl cdp tae ddng ddn ddng luc Iam viec d CBCC. Thyc li cho thdy, dinh gii cung nhu khen thudng hay kJ ludt CBCC se Gen quan ddn lgi fch cia hg nhii: dl bat, ndng luong hay sy thoi man'cde nhu ciil
42 I*P CHi OUAN I* NHA NUdc - sd 194 (3-50121
NGHI£N ciru - TRAO DOI thyc t l cua mdi cd nhdn. C»ng tac danh
gid, khen thudng, ky ludt d cac td chflc, co quan dim bio dugc tinli khich quan, cdng bdng va chfnh xdc tren co sd nhttng tieu chi rd rkng se Ik mdt nhdn td tao nen tfnh tich eye Ikm vide d cac nhdn vien vk CBCC. Mat khdc, sy dinh gia khdng chfnh xic, thieu khdeh quan, tMlu cdng bdng hay cd tinh trang cko bang trong cdng tac danh gid... se gdy tdm IJ chdn nan vk tMdu ddng lyc ticb eye 1km vide d hg, ddy cung Ik nguyen nhdn cia sy kem bifiu qui ttong hoat ddng cdng vu d cdc CBCC.
4. Dl khuyin khfch, tao ddng lyc tfeh eye ttong thyc thi cdng vu d CBCC trong eic td chflc HCNN bidn nay, cdn thyc Men tdt mdt sd giii phip sau ddy:
Mdt Id, lanh dao cic co quan cdng quyln cin quan tdm din vide ndng cao nhdn thflc cho CBCC vl boat ddng cdng vu mk hg dang dim nbiem dl giflp hg cd nhitag djnh hudng dflng ddn vl nghi nghiep, tao duoc ddng co, thii dd dflng ddn d hg khi thuc bidn cac nhiem vu dugc giao.
C^c td chflc, CO quan hknli chinb ben canh viec td chflc cic ldp dko tao ky ndng cho CBCC dl ndng cao nang cao ndiig lyc thyc tbi cdng vy cia hg tbi cdn pbii chfl J md cic ldp gido due vl dao dflc vk phdp ludt cho CBCC cia minh, cd nbu vdy mdi giflp cho ddi ngu nky cd tinh thdn, ttiii dd dflng din dd'i vdi boat ddng cdng vu vk tao cho bin thdn cd ddng luc lam viec tdt, ddp flng dugc cdc yeu cdu ddt ra cho boat d6ng cdng vu bidn nay.
Hai Id, Nhk nufiic cin quan tdm, ning cao dilu kien sdng cho CBCC; cd ehl dd luong vk cic chl dd dai ngd hgp IJ cbo CBCC dl giflp hg cd sy ydn tdm trong cdng viec vk tao dugc dgng lyc tfch cue Ikm vific trong cic hoat ddng cdng vu cia bin thdn.
Ba Id, di thoa man nhu cdu dugc tdn trgng, dugc dinh gii vk dugc khang djnb minh trong cdng vide, trong td chflc cia ngudi CBCC tbi trang cic td chflc, co quan cdn phai cd co chl, cM'nh sdeh khen nggi.
tdn vinh vk nhdn rdng nhitag kit qui dat duge cua CBCC mdt each ro rang; cic nhk lanh dao ttong cic td chflc, co quan cin phii quan tdm ddn viec tap ra nhitag co hdi dl phdt friln thd manh cd nhdn cia tttng ngudi ttong td chflc de qua dd, giflp bg phdt huy het cdc tilm nang, cd hdi vk long nMet tlnb cia ban thdn cho cdng viec, hokn thknh tflt cdc nhiem vu dugc giao.
Bdn Id, sy tuong quan nhdn su ttong td chflc cd tdc ddng ldn ddn tinh thdn, thii dd cung nbu cdc hknh vi edng vu cia CBCC.
Thyc td cho thdy, sy sip xdp nhan sy dat din mflc dd dung hgp cao se la co sd tao nen ddng lyc tfch eye 1km viec d cdc CB(X. VI vdy, ede nhk lanh dao, quan IJ edng cdn dac bift quan tdm ddn cdng tie tuyin dung cdn bd vk bd tti sip xip CBCC trong cic td chflc, co quan cua minh; dam bio dugc sy hgp IJ, ligp tinh d titag bd phin cttng nhu tokn co quan, Ikm cho ddi ngu CBCC cd sy hang hai nhiet tinh trong cdng vific, ddng thdi dem Iai nhttng thknh cdng cho td chflc.
Ndm Id, cac CO quan cdng quyln, cic td chflc, cic nhk quan IJ cdn phii quan tdm ddn cdng vide xdy dyng mdi tradng lam viec Iknh manh, thudn lgi vdi ddy d i ttang thift bj ky thuat cdn thilt dip flng dugc cic yeu ciu cia cdng viec cho ddi ngu CBCC.
Cy thi, cic phdng 1km vific phii di rdng, trong cdc phdng 1km viec cdn trang bi ddy d i cdc mdy mde cdn thift nbu miy tfnh, may dilu hok nhift d6...; mdi td chflc, co quan cin cd nhttng quy chl van boa cdng sd hgp IJ, tao dugc tmh thin dokn kft tuong, thdn tuong ii gifip dd ldn nhau gitta cic thknh vidn ttong td chflc dl qua dd cdc CBCC dugc hok minh vko biu khdng khf ttong Iknh cia td chflc, lam niy sinh nhilu cim sue tfch cue trong c6ng viec de dem lai sy thknh cdng cbo ban thdn vk xa hdi, ddng gdp sflc minh vko cdng cudc xdy dung vk phit triln nin cdng vu cia nudc nhkQ
TAP CHi QUAN I Y NHA NUdC - sd 194 (3-2012) 43