Tieu chllin qu6c te cua tap chf khoa hoc Ya viec ip dung tai Viet Nam
Kim Ngpc*
Tdm ^ Hi#n nay, oic tap cM khoa hpc xa hpi d Viet Nam dang ttag budc ddi mdi vi ning cap theo d6n chuin qudc te, cv> thl Ii theo tita chuin cic tap chf dupc xlp hang hdi Vito Thdng tin khoa hge My (BI) vi Co sd dtt lita (Scopus) cua Nhi xuit bto Elsevier Hi Lan.
Tdkhda: Tap chf khoa hpc; dta chuin quoc tl; ISI; Scopus.
l . M » d i D
ISI v i Scopus da xft chpn chit lupng cfla cic t a i dif t t t a flil gidi mdt cich khit khe v i kJ ludng d l dua vio co sd dft lito cfla hp. Den nay, danh sich ISI bap gdm liBtag 10.000 tB.p cU; Scopus bao gim 18.500 tap chf. Mic dd cd nhftng S kito dma thtog nhit, nhung ISI v i Scopus vto Ii mdt dxmg tit tt cich phto loji dupc a,to i ^ n vi sflr dvmg rdng rii khi bta luto vl
# i t lupng khoa hpc cfla cic cdng trinh nghita cdu. Cic tjp chi khoa hpc fliupc ISI Itilcapns l i nhftng tjp chf dupc cpng dtog
^Oa hpe quic t l cdng nhto. Lita Hpp Qabc, cic chfnh phd v i cic to chdc quoc t l ftudng sd dimg thing kd cto ISI trong quto if Vi hoach dinh cic chfnh sich khoa hpc, ky ttiniL Cic flidng kd v i dinh gii vl khoa ItJC, cdng ngjip v i kJ U,uat neu khdng flieo ISI dd bi licb so vdi U,dng kd quoc te. Bii vilt niy trtnh biy nhftng flta chuto qudc t l cto tap chf khoa hpc; th^c trjng ip dvmg efla cic IJP chf khoa hpc x i h§i Vilt Nam vi mdt s l kito nghj.
2. Tiln c h a i n qnic t l cda tjp chf khoa hpc
Cd nhieu flta chuto quic t l cda cic tjp chf khoa hpc, song tvtu dimg lji cd 5 tita chuan chd yiu sau diy.
TW- nhdt. vi the thuc xudt ban: - Tto tap chf cy fl,l, rd itog; - ngdn ngft ttie hito l i titog Anh (niu xuit bto bing ngdn ngft khic fld ttidng fln fliu vito bii vilt bao gom: tto tic gii, tdm tit, tfl: khda, tii li|u tn'ch din, ttiam khto cto bii viet tt,l hito bing titog Anh); - k J hjn xuit bta phii dtog tt,eo quy dinh cto tjp chf (01 tuan/ky, 01 tt,tag/ky, 03 tt,tog/ky, 06 fl,tag/kj...).
Thti hai, vi hlnh thtic trinh biy: - Bia tjp chf ghi id cic thdng tin vl s6, tjp, thtog, nim xuit bto, v l m i so chuto qudc te ISSN, ve ten, dia chi ca quan xuit bta tap chi; - khdng in qutag cio, toh khdng lita quan din ndi dung cic bii bio khoa hpc dtag dong tjp chi; - khdng ghi hpc him, hpc vi cto cac fliinh vien Hpi ding Biln
••' Phli giio su, Ueu Sl, Vipt Hka Hm Khoa h(pc xi hgi Vi?t Nam. DT: 0913513745.
Email: [email protected]
Tap chi Khoa hgc xa hpi Vi|t Nam, sd 8(105) - 2016 tap tjp chf v i cic tic gii; - kbdng ghi tin ngudi plwn bito khoa hpc (Referee) cto bii bio dupc ^ n g .
Thu ba, ve Hgi dong Bien tap: H^* dong Bien tap tjp chi gdm cic nhi khoa hpc Cd uy tin khoa hpc d trong nudc v i quic tl.
Trong dd, ft nhit hon 1/3 s l ttiinh vito Hdi dong Biln tjp tjp chf l i cic nhi khoa hpc cd uy tfn d qudc tl.
TTui- tu, ve n$i dung Ithoa hoc ciia tgp chi:
- Tjp chl khoa hpc dtog tii cic bii bio khoa hpc cto cic nhi khoa hpc d trong nudc vi qudc tl; - tjp chf khoa hpc phii cd eo chl phta bito (peer review) bii bio Cdiy Ii tita chuin quan tipng nhit khdng ttil Uiieu dupc cho mdt tjp chf khoa hpc; mli bii bto cd It nhit hai nhi khoa hpc cd uy tfn phta bito theo nguyta tic kfn; - dung Iupng bii bio: tli da khdng qui 9.000 tu; - bii bio khoa hpc phai kem flieo cic thdng fln vl: tta bii bio vdi khotog 15 - 18 tft (mdt so tap cht yta cau tli da 25 tft), ve tic gii, ve dia chi thu tfn cfla tic gia d l ngudi dpc cd flil lita h | dupc, v l tdm tit vdi khotag 200 - 250 tft, ve tu khda vdi khotog 3 - 5 tft, (nhftng tft ngft chtnh the hito ndi dung bii vilt vi cd svr hito dito fl-ong phin tdm tit), vl mi s l phta loji chuyto nginh cto bii bio, ngiy tda sojn nhto dupc bai bio, ngiy phin bito dtah gii v i sfta chfta, ngiy bii bio dupc duy|t dtag, v i trfch din (rd rtag vi tim dupc trdn h | thing ca sd dft lilu cda ISI; Scopus); - bii bio khoa hpc gom cic phto chu yiu: gidi tt,i|u (khdng qui 800 tft, vta dl nghita cftu Ii ^ phuong phip nghito cfa vta d l nhu tt,e nao), kit qui vi thao Into: (nghita cfa ttm dupc kit qui gi, cic kit qui flm dupc cd Jr nghTa gl) ket Inin vi di nghi, tii lipu tham khao.
72
TM BiBi, vi WebiHe t<?> c*fr Tjp ^ Idioa hpc cd website ritag hojc he t h ^ S t i ^ tuyin (Online submission s y s t e ^ * ttimg qnto \S xuit b t o tjp (if; cto flitog fln ttn w ^ s i t e dupc cjp nh|t giong nhu b ^
in cto tjp chf giiy. _*
3 . Ap dfng Uto d i n l n q u i c t l d cto t j p c h { l d i a a h p c x a K $ i t f l V ! | t N a m '*"•
Tf^lh' din n g i y 21 tlitog '3 i i i i 2016 Vipt Nam cd 356 tjp chf khoa hpc dupe dua vio danh myc tjp chf tfnh diim cda Hdi ding Chfte danh giio su Nhi nudc (HDCDGSNN). Trong so dd, chi cd ffl^
tjp cht Advances in Natural Sciences:
Nanoscience and Nanotechnolpgy (ANSN) cfla Vi|n H t a ISm Khoa hpc vi Cdng n g h | Vi|t Nam (VHLKH&CNVTO dupc vio dtah sich SCBE culi nim 2 0 1 9 - hai tjp chf Vietnam Joumal'' M Mathematics cfla Hdi Toin hpC'Vi|tNaS v i Acta Mafliematica Vietnamica^ cfli VHLKH&CNVN dupc vio danh sich Scopus. .,, „,.i.4i
Nhtt viy, flong sd 356 tjp cttifi9 t ^ Vilt Nam chi cd ba tjp chf lllioa l p 6 c ^ ngh| nam trong danh-sich K I v i Scoptt chilm khoing 0,84%; khdng cd- tjp ' i ^ ; khoa hpc, x i hdi n i o cto Vilt Nam n i « trong ISI v i Scopus. Trong. khi d d f * * qudc gia ASEAN khic nhu lMa]fte«dl cd 48 tjp cht, Thii L t a cd 21 ,t j p c h i d i r t ' xep vio Scopus. , '^ t
Cic tap cht khoa hpc x i bdi cto> V0 Nam m|lc d i d i cd nhieu ab hfe Mi taJS ntog cip v l c i toit lupng, flii flnic j4,Mtai thftc trtnh biy, nhmig, cho din nay vi|c„%
dvmg cic tita chuto quic t l cto t^l cl^
khoa hpc flong h | ttiing B I v i Scopuavfe
cM khotog cieh'lM Mit' So vdi eto tito chuto qudc tl tito diy, ate%, iM khoahde xa hdi cto Vict Nam chi d ^ ung dupc tat it
# f t chi: Kit qua khao sit tt,^ tl IOO tap phf khoahpc xa hdi cto Vi^ Nam {troag d^ cfc ca sd gito djic dji hoc, cac Bd ban l i n h , Hpc vicn Chmh tri quoc gia H i Chi l f c * <?« 66 tfl, chf khi^ hpc; Vito Hto lam
^ » , h p c x i hdi Vift Njm cd 34 tjp chi) qi
^ i n l ^ s a u :
:: nirOiit, v i thl thdc trtnh bay:
* ' f ^ n ^ t t d hi|n chd yiu bing d&,g Vi|L
© f i t s x a f khoa hpc xi hdi bing fling Anh, pm: Vieinam Banking Review; Viediamese studies; Viefliam S o c ^ Sdences Review;
Vttdijiy^ Sodo-Bconomic Development
^ j e w ; ^%l^am Economic Review;
I%ilosophical review. Phin lto tg, chf khoa hpc xa hdi d Vi|t Nam xua bto khdng dtog ky
, Thi Am, v l Wnh ttiuc flinh biy:
Tta mdt s l Up chf chua id dia chi co qsan khoa hpc chfl qnto, tto dtog Anh cto t|P eht chua chfnh xic. Hi|n tji cd 13 tjp Chf tttag to (cdng cd tto li Tjp chf khoa M cto 13 CO sd giio dvic dji hpc, bao
#8iT Tiudng Dji hpc Su phjm Hi Ndi; Dji hdc Quic gia Hi Npi; Trudng Dai hpc Su
^ Tp. Hd Chf Mnh; Dji hpc Hul;
Ttudng Dji hpc Md Tp. Hi Chf Minh;
• ^ Dji hpc Md Hi Ndi; Tnrdng Dai hpc Mtog Dftc; Trudng Dji hpc Cta Tho;
IWmg Dji hpc Su phjm Hi Npi 2; Tradng ' Bji hpc Vinh; Trudng Dji hpc Tay
Nguyta; Ttudng Dji hpe Hi Tinh. Thirc lijng trta tit khd di phto bi|t khi tmy cip Wn internet Nhiin flidng 1| qudc tl khac
--- Kim Ngpc Ve Unh flmc cfag chua dupc ban bito tip cfc ls> chf khoa hpc nghita cfa ^ dnng.
Tji Vito m n lim Khoa hpc xa hpi Viet Nam: 100% tjp chf cd chi s l BSN, tto co quan xuit bto cu flil ro rtag; 03 tjp chf khdng ghi hpc him, hpc vi cto Hdi ddng Bito tjp (chilm 1,7%, gdm Tjp chf Khta cd hpc; Tjp chf Nhto luc khoa hpc x i hpi;
Tjp chf N ^ t a cfa An Dd v i Chau A);
phto ldn Up chf khdng in qutag cao.
Thuba.vk^ chfc Hdi ddng Bito t ^ : Cd 02 Up du' td chfa Hpi ddng Bita t|p Up chf flia, flta chuta qudc tl. Hpi ddng Bito tjp gdm cfc nhi khoa hpc cd uy tfn d trong nudc v i qudc tl (chiim 1/3 sd tt,inh vito): Tjp chf Kinh ti v i Phit trito - Trudng Dji hpc Kinh ti qudc dto; Chuyin san Kinh tl v i Kinh doanh - Trudng Dji hpc Kinh te, Dji hpc (Judc gia Hi Npi.
Trong khi dd, Ui Vito Hto lam Khoa hpc x i hdi Vi|t Nam, 100% Hdi ddng Bito tjp cic Up chf khoa hpc li cac nhi khoa hpc trong nudc.
Thtitu, venpi dung khoa hpc cto tjp chf:
TJP cht dtag tai bii bio khoa hpc phin Idn li oia cic nhi khoa hpc flong nudc. Rat ft Up chl dtag tai bii cto cic hpc gii nudc ngoai (nin cd dtag, chu yiu d ravic ttidng fln khoa hpc).
Thdng fln, kit ciu bii vilt cto cic tap chf khoa hpc xa hdi d Vi|t Nam vl co bin chua tuto ttiu ttieo ttidng 1| qudc tl. Cic Up cht ttiupc cic CO sd giao diic dai hpc da ghi dd cac dft lito bii vilt, gdm torn lit, lic khoa vi kit cau bii gdm 4 mvic chtnh theo thdng I? quto tl. Cd 4 Up chl ghi ttidng tin ngiy nhta bai, chinh sfta bai va ngiy dtag bii
Tap chi Khoa hpc xi hpi Vi|t Nam, sl 8(105) - 2016
i
(gdm: Tjp chf Kinh tl vi Phit biin - Trutog Dji hpc Kinh tl qudc din; Chuyto san Kinh te va Kinh doanh - Trudng Dji hpc Kinh tl, Dji hpc (Judc gia Hi Ndi; Tjp cht Khoa hpc Dji hpc Hui; Tjp chf Phit trito vi hdi nhjp, Trudng Bji hpc Kinh ti - Tii chfnh). Han hit cic 1^) chf khoa hpc cto cic Bd ban nginh khdng ghi tdm tit, tft khda vi khdng kit ciu bai vilt gdm 4 phin ttieo ttidng Ie qudc tl. Tji Vito Hta lim Khoa hpc xa hpi Vilt Nam, chi cd 13 Up chf cd tdm tat btag fling Vi|t vi tttog Anh, hoic chi cd tttog Anh, chilm 46%; 10 Up chf cd (* Uida, chilm 35,7%; 7 up chf cd Idi md diu, kit luto. chilm 25%; 01 Up chf ghi ngiy nhto bii, chhih sfta vi ngiy ffing bii, chiem 0,3% (Tjp chf Tim 1^ hpc).
Nhik Up chf khoa hpc xi hji cto Vi|t Nam khtog cd co chi phto bito khoa hpc bii bio. Diy li diim khic bi|t Ito nhit gifta Up chf khoa hpc xi hpi cto Vipt Nam vdi cie tjp cht khoa hpc qudc ti. Khi tic gii gdi bii din, mdt vii ngudi trong Hdi dong Biln tjp xem qua vi quyit djiih ding hay khdng. Chfag nhftng dtag bii mi cdn phai tta nhuto bdt cho tic gii. Cd 15 do cich lim nhu ttii nto dji da sd nhftng bii bio fl-en eic tjp chf niy cd chit lupng khoa hpc tit fliip. Cd tit nhieu l5i vi sai sdt co bin trong nhftng bii bio.
Cich trtnh biy hit sftc so sii vi tdy ti|n, lim cho ngudi dpc thiy hlnh nhu tic gia khdng tdn ttpng dpc gii.
Ngnyin nhto cto flivrc fl-jng trto cd nhiiu, song, cd hai nguyta nhto cin Iuu tim: Otu nhil, Vi|t Nam chua cd khung khd quy dinh chung vl flil thuc xuit bto, hinh ttiftc trtnh biy npi dung bii bio cho cic Up
dtog tjp chf hjn hpp. ,, , J .. i,i#' Vito Ichdng ffip ftig'^ipiti "nhiing"^
chnto qudc tl cto tjp chf khoa hpCi ^ M ^ F li tilu chf td chfa Hdi ddng Bito tjp vi # chl [dita bito bii bio & ^ i i flrfch t d l ^ ^ tji sao nhftng cdng tAh khoa hpd % g ^ ^ tjp toi khoa hdd xS h$i cto Vi^ 1 ^ ' khdng cd nhilu ngirdi dpc, ngay ci n h i ^ ngudi trong gidi khoa hpc tti h$i d i ^ S j dpc visd ttfch din,^pigft,hoj(; ., , . , ' " *
Diy ctog cMnh li nhttag fliich flifejto nhit cho cic Up chf khoa hpc xi hiJi VSfe Nam trong hdi nhjp ttdu chuin qttfe^., 4 ,
4.M$tsdldlnn|^ '-"v Di xiy dvmg ljp chf khoa hpp xl hii cfl^
Vi|t Nam ttieo fliu chuin qudc tl, c ^ 'flivffi
hito mdt sd vi|c sau: -.--••^
Thu nhit, xiy dvmg 10 trtnh vi cd ,t»pi^
tim xiy dvmg fludc mdt sd tjp chf tost) chuin qudc tl, bit diu tft vi|c ntog cao diif luprng ndi dung bii vilt. 1
reii- hai, td chfa Hdi ddng Bita tjp thed' ttiu chuto qudc ti, xiy dvmg quy chl vi Mnh phf hojt dtog cda Hdi ddng Biln tjp.
Thu ba, xiy dimg quy ttinh flip nhto bii viit, phta bito, biln t|p, xuit bin, phiji htah, dilu quta trpng li cic t^) chf ch^ 1 tt-png yta dn phto bito khoa hpc thJ!
nghiem hic (cd ttil dtrong hojc ngoii nis^
mpt cich phd hpp) di ntog cao chit lupajg 1 khoa hpc cto bii bto. ,Y | Thi tu, xiy dvmg mdt ca sd dft Uto cfla^ J qudc gia, li|t kl tit ci nhfing bii bio khga hpc da cdng bd trto cfc tjp difldioalipexS' I hdicflaVi|tNamttirnhfagn!mdiu(h|j[i< :
Kim Ngpc
XX. hay Ul jm chf flii kJ XDC (nto cd) din nay ph»c vy cho nghita cuu, flf ch din.
5.Ke(lDjn
^ Vijt Nam dang hdi nhjp qudc ti sin ipng, ttong dd cd cfc Up chf khoa hpc xi hdi cto Vidt Nam. Cfc t«, chf khoa hpc xi hdi cto Vict Nam Midng fl,i dfag ngoii qo? djo hdi nhjp cfc tita diuta qudc tl cto t«) chf khoa hpc. Nta khdng cd svr chuto bj, khtog cd dinh hudng ttii khdng bao gid xty dvmg dupc nhftng up chf cto chung ta theo chuin qudc te.
Til Hin tham khio
Ul BSiHSng a n t e danb giio SI nhi midc (2016), Cdiig van ^ 37/HBCDCSmi ve Ku cdu vi
< * i tvng Utoa lvc vi Ihi lhic dang bM mmg ale mp dtt Um, hfc a„gc M, Sim, ngiy 4 thing 4.
(21 H S dSng Oifc danh giio sii nhi nudc (2016), T/^Htuht'dngiinxllcdnstAgnialliludmin cUh danh gida sa, phd gidc sn „dm 2016, Nxb Bich khoa. H i N$i.
13] Tlin V5n Nhrag (2016). " M ^ vii thSng tin v i m i so drain iinoc te cho tap chf v i sich. vS sn phin l o j i ! « , dn-khoa hoc v i cich ttinh biy mdl bii Mo nong i ^ dii khoa hoc", Tdi lieu '"^S dan xil cdng nh&i 1,1 liiu chdn chuc
^•n* Sido so. phd gido su ndm 2016. Nxb Bich Una, H i Noi.
[41 E"«=«G>fidd,t3Blion Indexes for Sdeoce: A New ISnieiision in Docomeilation ihongh Associaiion of Ideas", & w i « ; 122(3159). lass.
[5| Adkr. i . E»jiig, J , Taylor, ,>, "aution Analysis^, StadstioalScicna:. 24(1X 1-14,20O9.
[61 l'llp*»ww.ykhoaiieLcon,*inhIuanAignyenvant a a n m i 229_ngnyenvanlnan-
nguyendinhngnyen^chadnong-nckh- vietnamJam
P I hnp://science.diomsonrenteis.com/cgi- bui/jiiilst/jlsnbcalg.cgi?PC=K (8) http://sciinagojr.com 191 hnpy/www.scopus.cam
[101 l«lp://»w«..vass.gov.vn/noidong/anphain/Usts /ThamKhaoTapClin'ievUWail.aspj