Motsi without whose moral and financial support I would not have been able to achieve my higher education; and. To all those friends, family and relatives who have been by my side during my time of need.
INTRODUCTION
Background
Khor ‘The WTO, The Post Doha Agenda and the Future of the Trade System’ (a Third World document on the WTO) (2002). The precautionary principle: a fundamental principle of law and policy for the protection of the global environment.
The aims of the thesis
Research Methodology
The following cases will also be used in relation to the impact of sanitary and phytosanitary measures; and technical standards and regulations and their relation to the precautionary principle;. Schwartz, UNU-IAS Report 'Trade Provision; The Precautionary Principle and the WHO.' (2005) United Nations University, Institute for Advanced Studies, 1-.
THE PRECAUTIONARY PRINCIPLE IN INTERNATIONAL TRADE
- Background
- Definition of the Precautionary principle
- Origins and History of the precautionary principle
- Scope of application of the precautionary principle
- The shifting of the burden of proof by the precautionary principle
- Elements of the Precautionary principle
- The implications of section 5.7 of the SPS Agreement on the precautionary principle
- The status of the precautionary principle in the WTO
- The EC Hormones dispute
- The legal status of the precautionary principle in international law
- Does the precautionary principle constitute a barrier to trade?
The emphasis will be on the two definitions of the principle given in the Mons Ministerial Declaration52 and the Rio Declaration53. It is important at this point to note the fundamental differences between these two definitions of the precautionary principle. Percival, “Who's Afraid of the Precautionary Principle?” (2005) Environmental LR, 23 no.1, University of Maryland Legal Studies Research Paper no.
Harmones, et al.; 'The Introduction of the Precautionary Principle in the 20th century: Late Lessons from Early Warnings' as quoted by R. There are also divergent views as some scholars attribute the principle to Hippocrates,87 who is considered the father of the precautionary principle. He is believed to have been the source of the precautionary principle during the Middle Ages.
As already mentioned, one of the significant consequences of the precautionary principle is the shifting of the burden of proof. In this dispute, the Panel expressed concern about the question regarding the precise definition and content of the precautionary principle. However, the Appellate Body declined to take a position on the status of the precautionary principle as a principle in customary international law.
However, there is no doubt about the status of the precautionary principle in international environmental law.
THE WORLD TRADE ORGANIZATION AGREEMENT ON SANITARY AND
- Background
- What is an SPS measure
- Ascertainment of the purpose or goal of SPS Measures from the definition
- Key provisions in the SPSAgreement
- Article 2 - Rights and Obligations of members
- Article 3 – Harmonization
- Article 4 - Equivalence
- Article 5 – Risk Assessment
- Article 10 –Special and differential treatment
- Disputes under the SPS Agreement
- EC Hormones dispute
- Japanese Varietals dispute
- The Australian Salmon dispute
- Impact of SPS measures on African agricultural products
- The efficacy of the SPS Agreement
- Special and differential treatment
- Provision of technical assistance
- Risk assessment and scientific justification
- Market access
The member countries in the negotiation phase of the SPS Agreement agreed to use the relevant international codes except in circumstances where they had nothing to do with human, animal and plant life or health. 207 Article 12, subsection 3, provides that the Committee shall maintain close contact with the relevant international organizations in the field of health and plant protection, in particular with the Codex Alimentarius Commission, the International Office of Epizootics and the Secretariat of the International Plant Protection Convention. The complainants alleged that the EU had violated Articles 3 and 5 of the SPS Agreement by banning certain meat and meat products that had been treated with certain growth-promoting hormones.224.
Furthermore, the panel considered whether there had been a breach of Article 2.2 of the agreement. The panel addressed the first definition of risk assessment in the first sentence of the definition.229. These are the negotiations that led to, among other things, the SPS and TBT agreement coming into place.
Khor, 'The WTO, The Post Doha Agenda and the Future of the Trade System' Third World Network (TWN) paper. This is a paper presented at the WTO, Post Doha Agenda and the Future of Trade. This is at the heart of the problem that developing countries face in implementing the WTO agreements.
The preamble of the SPS agreement stipulates that to the extent permitted to the members.
COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF ZIMBABWE AND SOUTH AFRICA ON COMPLIANCE
- The obligations of the member states under the SPS Agreement
- Provisions in the SPS Agreement for developing countries
- Overview of food safety and standards
- Roles and Responsibilities of Government Departments
- Legislation governing food control
- The role of Non-Governmental Organization (NGOs)
- The legal framework for food safety and standards in South Africa
- Overview of the food control regulation
- Roles and responsibilities of Government Departments
- Legislation governing food control
- The South African Bureau of Standards (SABS)
- Comparative analysis
- Membership in international standard setting bodies
- Participation in WTO SPS notifications
- Establishment of a national enquiry point
- Technical assistance
- Organization of the responsibility for food control
The focus here will be on comparing the level of compliance of South Africa and Zimbabwe with the SPS agreement. Zimbabwe is a member of the WTO and a signatory to its agreements and in particular the SPS Agreement. 370 Agenda item 8 paragraph 52 Report on the Implementation of National Action Plans to establish/strengthen the roles of the Codex contact points and the National Codex Committees in the region.
The Ministry of Health at national level assumes the role of the National Codex Contact Point. The main responsibility of the Ministry of Health is to provide support to local authorities. It is also responsible for providing services on behalf of the National Department of Health, such as import control.
The National Plant Protection Organization of the South African Department of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries.” Import control is carried out by the Provincial Ministries of Health on behalf of the National Ministry. This law provides for the approval, by the Ministry of Health, of the source of food for consumption in ports, airports, on ships and on aircraft, as well as for its inspection.
427 Agenda Item 8, Paragraph 52 Report on the Implementation of National Action Plans to Establish/Strengthen the Role of Codex Contact Points and National Codex Committees in the Region.
CONCLUSIONS
Overview
If developed countries themselves cannot fully meet such a criterion, very little can be said about developing countries. In this regard, it is safe to conclude that the SPS Agreement has set standards that are much higher and beyond the reach of most in developing countries, which in turn hinders international trade. Several years have passed since the Uruguay Round; there have been no significant changes in market access for developing countries in the developed countries as promised.443 As if this were not enough, there are increased demands on the developing countries to liberalize their markets to the benefit of developed countries, while the developed countries is closed.444.
The multilateral trading system and especially within this context the Agreement on Sanitary and Phytosanitary Measures has not brought any significant benefits to developing countries in general.445 The Agreement does not take into account the special and different needs of developing countries, which are at the heart of the founding values of the WTO. Khor Third World Network Paper "The WTO, post-Doha and the future of the trading system" (2002). In terms of environmental safety standards, the application of the precautionary principle without clear and appropriate outlines will prove to be very problematic.
This is also the problem that developing countries face when they are confronted with highly industrialized nations, especially where the imported products present themselves as competition for the domestic products. The financial burden of proving that such products are environmentally safe is too high and is far beyond the reach of most developing countries.
Recommendations
According to Kogan because of the over-regulation of its industries and because they are lagging behind, the European Union has responded especially to America by imposing increasingly restrictive regional and global environmental standards.447 One of the most controversial issues here is because it does not there is appropriate guidance for the implementation of such environmental standards in an international. Agreement.451 According to Khor, most of these agreements were negotiated before the majority of developing countries where part of the WTO and as such did not represent their collective interests.452 The Doha round of trade negotiations introduced developing countries as members of the WTO a chance to renegotiate some of the terms of the agreements on an equal footing.453 However, the fact that the round of negotiations has been deadlocked for so many years and the way developing countries are treated in the negotiations leaves much to be desired. desired.454 Other authors cite the problems of transparency in the negotiation processes and the lack of negotiating power that weighed heavily on the developing countries.455 However, the handling of these issues at the Doha ministerial conference has left the developing countries in despair. The failure to adequately address the interests of developing countries in this round of negotiations has undermined confidence in the WTO's multilateral trading system.
The Doha Agreement also attempted to decide on the inclusion of the trade-environmental debate in the scope of the WTO. The precautionary principle is included in some WTO decisions and as such the issue was raised in this round of trade negotiations. While most developing countries have expressed concern about bringing the trade and environment debate into the WTO framework, as it clearly does not deal with the trade-related issues it already faces, more industrialized and powerful countries than The idea that if the issue were to be included in the WTO, it might create the possibility of an agreement in which trade and the environment would be discussed.
However, he remains skeptical that, even if such an agreement exists, it will resolve the implementation issues that are at the heart of the controversy surrounding existing WTO agreements. Not only should we be inspired by regional agreements with countries in Africa, but we should also agree abroad with more influential countries, such as those in the European Union or the United States of America, which are the main source of foreign currency in developing countries.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Humphrey 'The impact of private food safety standards on the food chain and on public standard setting processes', (2009) Paper prepared for FAO/WHO, ALINORM 09/32/9D-Part II, May Review of case studies and evaluations of Sanitary and Phytosanitary Capacity: Kenya, Tanzania and Uganda. Sewaden 'Saving two in a billion: quantifying the trade effect on European food safety standards on African exports.'(2001) African Exports Food Policy, 26, Issue Development Research Group DECRG www.elsevier.com/locate/foodpolaccessed on 02 November 2012 Gupta 'Capacity Building and Technical Assistance - New Approaches and Building Alliances?'(2002)FAO/WHO Global Forum of Food Safety Regulators Marrakesh, Morocco, 28-30 January 2002.
Jacques DIOUF opening address for FAO/WHO, FAO/WHO Global Forum on Food Safety Regulations (2002) Global Forum of Food Safety Regulators, Morocco 28-30 available http://www.fao.org/docrep/meeting/004/y3680e / Y3680E04.htmaccessed 16 May 2012. FAO/WHO (2002) Global Forum of Food Safety Regulators, Country Paper proposed by Zimbabwe GF/CRD Marrakech, Morocco 28-30. January. FAO/WHO (2005) Regional Conference on Food Security for Africa, Ensuring Food Security for Africa, Ensuring Food Security and Qualitative SME Food Enterprises as Prepared by Zimbabwe, Harare, 3-6. October.
Mandour Gabr 'Improving efficiency and transparency in food systems - Sharing experiences' (2002) FAO/WHO Global Forum of Food Safety Regulators Marrakesh, Morocco 28-30 January. Policy Guidelines: National Food Safety and Official Food Recalls South African Department of Health, (2004) http://www.ehrn.co.za/download/reg_meattrans.pdf accessed 12 May 2012.
