IN THE SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL CASE NO.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL

In the petition of

BEINASH. JOSEPH LEON MECKLENBERG (PTY) LIMITED J B & L NOMINEES CC

In the matter between

ERNST & YOUNG

W1XLEY, THOMAS ALEXANDER

REYNOLDS, PHILIP WARDEL MOORREES

AA1 CASE NO

First Petitioner Second Petitioner Third Petitioner

First Respondent Second Respondent Third Respondent

SUPPORTING AFFIDAVIT

i, the undersigned,

PHILIP WARDEL MOORREES REYNOLDS,

do hereby make oath and say that

1 I am the third respondent. The facts contained herein are within my own knowledge and belief and both true and correct.

2 I have read the answering affidavit deposed to by Thomas Alexander Wixley and confirm the allegations therein insofar as they refer to me.

DEPONENT

THUS SIGNED AND SWORN TO at on this day of APRIL 1998, the deponent having sworn that he knows and understands the contents of this affidavit, that the oath which he takes is binding on his conscience and that the contents of this affidavit are both true and correct.

Before me,

Full Names (printed) Business Address:

Area:

Capacity:

98.261

COMMISSIONER OF OATHS

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL CASE NO.

in the petition between : BEINASH, JOSEPH LEON

MECKLENBERG [PTY] LIMITED J B & L NOMINEES CC

1st Petitioner 2nd Petitioner 3rd Petitioner In the matter between :

ERNST & YOUNG

WIXLEY, THOMAS ALEXANDER

REYNOLDS, PHILIP WARDEL MOORREES

1st Applicant / Respondent 2nd Applicant / Respondent 3rd Applicant / Respondent and

BEINASH, JOSEPH LEON

MECKLENBERG [PTY] LIMITED J B & L NOMINEES CC

1st Respondent / Appellant 2nd Respondent / Appellant 3rd Respondent / Appellant

REPLYING AFFIDAVIT

BE PLEASED TO TAKE NOTICE that the Petitioners' REPLYING AFFIDAVIT is herwith presented for service and filing.

SIGNED AT JOHANNESBURG ON 24 APRIL 1998.

MELAMED & HURWITZINCT Attorneys for Petitioner

70 Oxford Road, Riviera

P.O. Box 9000 JOHANNESBURG C/O ROSENDORFF & REITZ BARRY

1st Floor, President Building 119 St. Andrews Street BLOEMFONTEIN Ref.:CVR/DD/E55312 Tel.: [051]447-4342

Sup3/160 Page 2

TO : THE REGISTRAR OF THE ABOVE

HONOURABLE COURT BLOEMFONTEIN AND TO

WERKSMANS

Attorneys for Second Respondent West Wing, Werksmans Chambers 22 Girton Road, Parktown

P.O. Box 927 JOHANNESBURG Tel.: 488-0000

Fax.: 484-3100/3200 Ret: Mr. E. Levenstein

Received copy hereof on 1998

for: 2nd Respondent's Attorneys