BAB IV …
5.2 Saran
Dari penelitian yang sudah dilakukan oleh penulis, beberapa hal dari hasil penelitian dapat diimplemtasikan didunia nyata adalah :
1. Penggunaaan routing protocol AODV, OLSR, dan ZRP dapat digunakan untuk komunikasi di suatu tempat yang membutuhkan mobilitas sangat tinggi. Contohnya untuk komunikasi antar panitia sebuah konser.
2. Penggunaaan routing protocol AODV, OLSR, dan ZRP dapat digunakan untuk komunikasi mobil patrol polisi di suatu kota, sehingga komuniksi antar mobil patroli dapat menggunakan routing protocol ini.
67
DAFTAR PUSTAKA
1. Leonenta, Vincensius. Analisis Performansi Destination Sequenced Distance Vector(DSDV) dan Zone Routing Protocol (ZRP) Berbasis Algoritma Ant pada Jaringan Mobile Ad hoc. Institut Teknologi Telkom.
ANALISIS PERFORMANSI DESTINATION.pdf
2. Edward, Khristian. 2013. Perbandingan Performansi Protokol Dsdv Dan Olsr Pada Mobile Ad Hoc Network Dengan Simulator Ns 2, Tugas Akhir.
Yogyakarta: Fakultas Sains Dan Teknologi Universitas Sanata Dharma.
3. Mukti, Guido. 2012. Unjuk Kerja Protokol DSR Pada Mobile AD HOC Network Dengan Simulator NS 2, Tugas Akhir. Yogyakarta: Fakultas Sains Dan Teknologi Universitas Sanata Dharma.
4. Rasha T. K, Shwetha Vincent.2013. Efficient Routing Protocol For Mobile Ad Hoc Networks (MANET). Computer Science & Technology Department, Karunya University,Coimbatore.
5. Kambayashi , Yasushi .2013. A Review of Routing Protocols Based on Ant-Like Mobile Agents. Department of Computer and Information Engineering, Nippon Institute of Technology.
6. Sugianto, Dionisius Reinard .2013. Perbandingan Kecepatan Konvergensi Tabel Routing Protokol Dymo Dan Aodv Pada Mobile Ad Hoc Network Dengan Simulator Ns2. Tugas Akhir. Yogyakarta: Fakultas Sains Dan Teknologi Universitas Sanata Dharma.
7. I.S. Wardy.2007. Penggunaan Graf dalam Algoritma Semut untuk Melakukan Optimisasi. Institut Teknologi Bandung.
8. The Network Simulator – ns- 2. http://isi.edu/nsnam/ns/. (17 November 2013)
9. Sing, Valinetino Lord.2010. Evaluasi Performansi Olsr (Optimized Link State Routing) Pada Mobile Ad-Hoc Network. Institut Teknologi Bandung.
10. Arifin, M.Zen Samsono Hadi., Haryadi Amran., Nuansa Putra R.2011.
Analisis Performansi Routing AODV pada Jaringan VANet.Institut Teknologi Sepuluh Nopember.
11. Aprillando, A. 2007. Cara Kerja dan Kinerja Protokol Optimized Link State Routing (OLSR) pada Mobile Ad hoc network (MANET), Tugas Akhir. Jakarta: Fakultas Teknik Unika AtmaJaya.
12. Indarto, E. dan Andi, B.W. 2004. Mudah Membangun Simulasi dengan Network Simulator-2. Yogjakarta : Penerbit Andi.
13. Pujianto, Laurentius . 2014 . Analisis Convergence Time Protokol Routing Dsdv Menggunakan Simulator Ns 3. Tugas Akhir. Yogyakarta: Fakultas Sains Dan Teknologi Universitas Sanata Dharma.
14. Lungan, Richard. 2006. Aplikasi Statistika & Hitung Peluang. Yogyakarta : Graha Ilmu
15. Irianto, Agus. 2004. Statistik : Konsep Dasar Dan Aplikasinya. Jakarta : Kencana
16. Hardianto, RN. Tri. 2015. Analisis Unjuk Kerja Pengaruh Hit Ratio Pada Squid Proxy Terhadap Sumber Daya Komputer Server. Tugas Akhir.
Yogyakarta: Fakultas Sains Dan Teknologi Universitas Sanata Dharma.
70
LAMPIRAN
1. Listing Program aodv.tcl / olsr.tcl / zrp.tcl
#define setting option
set val(chan) Channel/WirelessChannel ;# channel type set val(prop) Propagation/TwoRayGround ;#
radio-propagation model
set val(netif) Phy/WirelessPhy ;# network interface type
set val(mac) Mac/802_11 ;# MAC type
set val(ifq) Queue/DropTail/PriQueue ;# interface queue type
set val(ll) LL ;# link layer type set val(ant) Antenna/OmniAntenna ;# antenna model set val(ifqlen) 50 ;# max packet in ifq
set val(nn) 25 ;# number of mobilenodes
set val(rp) AODV/OLSR/ZRP ;# routing protocol
set val(x) 1000 ;# X
dimension of topography
set val(y) 1000 ;# Y dimension of
set val(cp)
"cmu-scen-gen/setdest/skenario/random/skenario_10"
set val(sc) "cmu-scen-gen/cbr-25-test.tcl"
### Setting The Simulator Objects
set ns_ [new Simulator]
Agent/OLSR set use_mac_ true #for OLSR
Agent/ZRP set radius_ 2 #for ZRP
#create the nam and trace file:
set tracefd [open data/random/aodv/aodv30.tr w]
$ns_ trace-all $tracefd
set namtrace [open data/random/aodv/aodv30.nam w]
$ns_ namtrace-all-wireless $namtrace $val(x) $val(y)
set topo [new Topography]
$topo load_flatgrid $val(x) $val(y) set god_ [create-god $val(nn)]
set chan_1_ [new $val(chan)]
# Defining Node Configuration
$ns_ node-config -adhocRouting $val(rp) \ -llType $val(ll) \
-macType $val(mac) \ -ifqType $val(ifq) \ -ifqLen $val(ifqlen) \ -antType $val(ant) \ -propType $val(prop) \ -phyType $val(netif) \ -topoInstance $topo \ -agentTrace ON \ -routerTrace ON \ -macTrace ON \ -movementTrace ON \ -channel $chan_1_
for {set i 0} {$i < $val(nn) } {incr i} { set node_($i) [$ns_ node]
$node_($i) random-motion 0 ;# disable random motion }
source $val(cp)
source $val(sc)
#
# create God
#
set god_ [create-god $val(nn)]
$ns_ at 0.0 "$node_(0) label node_(0)"
### PROCEDURE TO STOP
proc stop {} {
global ns_ tracefd $ns_ flush-trace close $tracefd
exec nam datacache.nam &
exit 0
}
puts "Starting Simulation..."
$ns_ at 10.0 "stop"
$ns_ run
2. Listing Program KonvergensiAODV.awk
BEGIN {
waktuAwal = 0 waktuAkhir = 0 idpkt= 0
} {
action = $1 timeAwal = $2 timeAkhir = $2
node = $3 mac = $4 id = $6
protocol = $7
if (action == "s" && node == "_0_" && mac == "AGT" &&
protocol == "cbr" ) { waktuAwal = timeAwal }
if(action == "s" && node == "_0_" && mac == "RTR" &&
protocol == "cbr" ) { waktuAkhir = timeAkhir }
} END {
print("Discovery Awal =", waktuAwal) print("Discovery Akhir =", waktuAkhir) print("Waktu Discovery =", waktuAkhir - waktuAwal)
}
3. Listing Program Hop.awk
BEGIN {
if (action == "r" && node == "_0_" && mac == "RTR" &&
protocol == "cbr" ) { idpkt = id
}
if (action == "f" && protocol == "cbr" && mac =="RTR" ) {
jmlforwading ++;
}
if(action == "r" && mac == "AGT" && id== idpkt &&
protocol == "cbr" )
print("Paket CBR telah sampai pada node =", nodeTujuan)
jmlhop = jmlforwading+1;
printf("Jumlah Lompatan = %d\n",jmlhop);
}
4. Contoh hasil trace file AODV
M 0.00000 0 (100.00, 500.00, 0.00), (252.24, 883.05), 0.08 M 0.00000 1 (200.00, 500.00, 0.00), (181.44, 25.88), 11.36 M 0.00000 2 (400.00, 500.00, 0.00), (911.98, 857.79), 12.43 M 0.00000 3 (600.00, 500.00, 0.00), (593.87, 585.14), 29.35 M 0.00000 4 (800.00, 500.00, 0.00), (834.19, 757.41), 11.01 M 0.00000 5 (150.00, 650.00, 0.00), (827.61, 718.34), 28.86 M 0.00000 6 (300.00, 650.00, 0.00), (717.64, 695.16), 29.00 M 0.00000 7 (500.00, 650.00, 0.00), (740.24, 362.82), 47.53 M 0.00000 8 (150.00, 350.00, 0.00), (811.84, 209.04), 11.23 M 0.00000 9 (300.00, 350.00, 0.00), (509.95, 931.00), 34.39 M 0.00000 10 (731.79, 130.10, 0.00), (760.55, 46.28), 12.95 M 0.00000 11 (576.75, 122.14, 0.00), (614.51, 654.66), 33.05 M 0.00000 12 (825.13, 568.81, 0.00), (825.29, 568.26), 0.94 M 0.00000 13 (866.97, 721.47, 0.00), (204.22, 238.08), 41.56 M 0.00000 14 (639.52, 653.54, 0.00), (639.61, 653.13), 0.21 M 0.00000 15 (279.31, 858.99, 0.00), (279.06, 858.45), 0.56 M 0.00000 16 (484.92, 840.23, 0.00), (484.48, 840.23), 0.61 M 0.00000 17 (77.23, 480.38, 0.00), (743.18, 179.54), 23.29 M 0.00000 18 (463.76, 65.27, 0.00), (160.47, 920.13), 24.37 M 0.00000 19 (6.94, 517.67, 0.00), (170.87, 560.08), 29.84 M 0.00000 20 (559.58, 924.75, 0.00), (114.22, 467.25), 14.16 M 0.00000 21 (723.02, 260.70, 0.00), (755.95, 703.68), 10.50 M 0.00000 22 (413.43, 359.50, 0.00), (769.93, 771.18), 33.67 M 0.00000 23 (830.38, 708.21, 0.00), (819.60, 936.02), 14.61 M 0.00000 24 (769.13, 274.80, 0.00), (923.62, 28.43), 21.99
s 0.000000000 _0_ AGT --- 0 cbr 512 [0 0 0 0] --- [0:0 14:0 32 0] [0] 0
r 0.000963333 _1_ MAC 0 AODV 48 [0 ffffffff 0 800] [0:255
r 0.004356020 _0_ MAC 0 AODV 48 [0 ffffffff 9 800] [9:255
s 0.007652485 _6_ MAC 0 AODV 106 [0 ffffffff 6 800] [6:255
r 0.011332480 _19_ RTR 0 AODV 48 [0 ffffffff 5 800] [5:255
r 0.013794076 _2_ RTR 0 AODV 48 [0 ffffffff 7 800] [7:255
r 0.019443932 _14_ MAC 0 AODV 48 [0 ffffffff 3 800] [3:255
r 0.023679336 _16_ MAC 0 AODV 48 [0 ffffffff f 800] [15:255
r 0.028891193 _6_ RTR --- 0 AODV 44 [13a 6 7 800] --- [14:255 0:255 29
r 0.033050360 _13_ MAC 0 AODV 48 [0 ffffffff 17 800] [23:255
r 0.043646636 _21_ MAC 0 AODV 48 [0 ffffffff a 800] [10:255
r 2.001248630 _5_ RTR 0 AODV 48 [0 ffffffff 0 800] [0:255
s 2.004984377 _1_ RTR 0 AODV 48 [0 ffffffff 0 800] [1:255
r 2.006962729 _5_ MAC 0 AODV 48 [0 ffffffff 1 800] [1:255
r 2.009064188 _1_ RTR 0 AODV 48 [0 ffffffff 11 800] [17:255
r 2.014824797 _15_ MAC --- 0 ARP 28 [0 ffffffff 5 806] --- [REQUEST 5/5
r 2.031609613 _22_ MAC 0 AODV 48 [0 ffffffff 2 800] [2:255
D 2.031610313 _14_ MAC COL 0 AODV 106 [0 ffffffff 10 800] [16:255 -1:255 27 0] [0x2 4 2 [14 0] [0 6]] (REQUEST)
r 2.033752408 _4_ MAC --- 0 ARP 28 [0 ffffffff 7 806] --- [REQUEST 7/7
s 2.046470434 _7_ MAC --- 0 RTS 44 [14ee e 7 0]
r 2.056716314 _2_ MAC --- 0 ARP 28 [0 ffffffff 9 806] --- [REQUEST 9/9
s 2.061011651 _0_ MAC --- 0 RTS 44 [52e 9 0 0]
s 2.064984419 _23_ MAC 0 AODV 106 [0 ffffffff 17 800] [23:255
5. Hasil Pengujian AODV Skenario 1
KETERANGAN AODV KETERANGAN AODV
1
discovery awal 0.000000000 16
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 2.039135334 discovery akhir 2.054185012 waktu discovery 2.039135334 waktu discovery 2.054185012 2
discovery awal 0.000000000 17
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 2.037174576 discovery akhir 2.059449721 waktu discovery 2.037174576 waktu discovery 2.059449721 3
discovery awal 0.000000000 18
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 2.049960296 discovery akhir 2.052924044 waktu discovery 2.049960296 waktu discovery 2.052924044 4
discovery awal 0.000000000 19
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 2.069216174 discovery akhir 2.054185133 waktu discovery 2.069216174 waktu discovery 2.054185133 5
discovery awal 0.000000000 20
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 2.051256716 discovery akhir 2.051105951 waktu discovery 2.051256716 waktu discovery 2.051105951 6 discovery awal 0.000000000 21 discovery awal 0.000000000
discovery akhir 2.044078452 discovery akhir 2.057090249 waktu discovery 2.044078452 waktu discovery 2.057090249 7
discovery awal 0.000000000 22
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 2.047280892 discovery akhir 2.038024866 waktu discovery 2.047280892 waktu discovery 2.038024866 8
discovery awal 0.000000000 23
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 2.056800776 discovery akhir 2.056835772 waktu discovery 2.056800776 waktu discovery 2.056835772 9
discovery awal 0.000000000 24
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 2.047029188 discovery akhir 2.046722106 waktu discovery 2.047029188 waktu discovery 2.046722106 10
discovery awal 0.000000000 25
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 2.050009066 discovery akhir 2.061203491 waktu discovery 2.050009066 waktu discovery 2.061203491 11
discovery awal 0.000000000 26
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 2.049688410 discovery akhir 2.058117419 waktu discovery 2.049688410 waktu discovery 2.058117419 12
discovery awal 0.000000000 27
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 2.052729161 discovery akhir 2.037256169 waktu discovery 0.000000000 waktu discovery 2.037256169 13
discovery awal 0.000000000 28
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 2.061261521 discovery akhir 2.051810878 waktu discovery 2.061261521 waktu discovery 2.051810878 14
discovery awal 0.000000000 29
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 2.017721340 discovery akhir 2.051336218 waktu discovery 2.017721340 waktu discovery 2.051336218 15
discovery awal 0.000000000 30
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 2.058878408 discovery akhir 2.049666242 waktu discovery 2.058878408 waktu discovery 2.049666242
6. Hasil Pengujian OLSR Skenario 1 discovery akhir 6.400200817 discovery akhir 6.213036757 waktu discovery 6.400200817 waktu discovery 6.213036757 2
discovery awal 0.000000000 17
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 6.062434979 discovery akhir 5.956967228 waktu discovery 6.062434979 waktu discovery 5.956967228 3
discovery awal 0.000000000 18
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 6.218070334 discovery akhir 6.313700870 waktu discovery 6.218070334 waktu discovery 6.313700870 4
discovery awal 0.000000000 19
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 6.400200817 discovery akhir 6.224036757 waktu discovery 6.400200817 waktu discovery 6.224036757 5
discovery awal 0.000000000 20
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 6.236238878 discovery akhir 6.185686005 waktu discovery 6.236238878 waktu discovery 6.185686005 6
discovery awal 0.000000000 21
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 6.163820023 discovery akhir 6.201536473 waktu discovery 6.163820023 waktu discovery 6.201536473 7
discovery awal 0.000000000 22
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 6.109942443 discovery akhir 6.415404284 waktu discovery 6.109942443 waktu discovery 6.415404284 8
discovery awal 0.000000000 23
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 6.230362754 discovery akhir 6.010088982 waktu discovery 6.230362754 waktu discovery 6.010088982 9
discovery awal 0.000000000 24
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 6.361441018 discovery akhir 6.109942443 waktu discovery 6.361441018 waktu discovery 6.109942443 10
discovery awal 0.000000000 25
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 6.230362754 discovery akhir 6.010644982 waktu discovery 6.230362754 waktu discovery 6.010644982 11
discovery awal 0.000000000 26
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 6.224026757 discovery akhir 6.010788982 waktu discovery 6.224026757 waktu discovery 6.010788982 12
discovery awal 0.000000000 27
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 6.386450738 discovery akhir 6.010147856 waktu discovery 6.386450738 waktu discovery 6.010147856
13
discovery awal 0.000000000 28
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 6.230362754 discovery akhir 6.415404284 waktu discovery 6.230362754 waktu discovery 6.415404284 14
discovery awal 0.000000000 29
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 6.230362754 discovery akhir 6.396854207 waktu discovery 6.230362754 waktu discovery 6.396854207 15
discovery awal 0.000000000 30
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 6.224036757 discovery akhir 6.384584507 waktu discovery 6.224036757 waktu discovery 6.384584507
7. Hasil Pengujian ZRP Skenario 1
KETERANGAN ZRP KETERANGAN ZRP
1
discovery awal 0.000000000 16
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 5.515545767 discovery akhir 5.685991025 waktu discovery 5.515545767 waktu discovery 5.685991025 2
discovery awal 0.000000000 17
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 5.722862527 discovery akhir 5.612185989 waktu discovery 5.722862527 waktu discovery 5.612185989 3
discovery awal 0.000000000 18
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 5.687322529 discovery akhir 5.928704563 waktu discovery 5.687322529 waktu discovery 5.928704563 4
discovery awal 0.000000000 19
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 5.267701057 discovery akhir 5.822505892 waktu discovery 5.267701057 waktu discovery 5.822505892 5
discovery awal 0.000000000 20
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 5.685602842 discovery akhir 5.945383968 waktu discovery 5.685602842 waktu discovery 5.945383968 6
discovery awal 0.000000000 21
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 5.462120290 discovery akhir 5.717480346 waktu discovery 5.462120290 waktu discovery 5.717480346 7
discovery awal 0.000000000 22
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 5.679363668 discovery akhir 5.515545767 waktu discovery 5.679363668 waktu discovery 5.515545767 8
discovery awal 0.000000000 23
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 5.376917952 discovery akhir 5.685602842 waktu discovery 5.376917952 waktu discovery 5.685602842
9
discovery awal 0.000000000 24
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 5.704034920 discovery akhir 5.634058728 waktu discovery 5.704034920 waktu discovery 5.634058728 10
discovery awal 0.000000000 25
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 5.838842688 discovery akhir 5.737540218 waktu discovery 5.838842688 waktu discovery 5.737540218 11
discovery awal 0.000000000 26
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 5.722862527 discovery akhir 5.465043772 waktu discovery 5.722862527 waktu discovery 5.465043772 12
discovery awal 0.000000000 27
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 5.277010570 discovery akhir 5.553972948 waktu discovery 5.277010570 waktu discovery 5.553972948 13
discovery awal 0.000000000 28
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 5.722862527 discovery akhir 5.759889709 waktu discovery 5.722862527 waktu discovery 5.759889709 14
discovery awal 0.000000000 29
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 5.359590932 discovery akhir 5.601269162 waktu discovery 5.359590932 waktu discovery 5.601269162 15
discovery awal 0.000000000 30
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 5.808303837 discovery akhir 5.536036569 waktu discovery 5.808303837 waktu discovery 5.536036569
8. Hasil Pengujian AODV Skenario 2
KETERANGAN AODV KETERANGAN AODV
1
discovery awal 0.000000000 16
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 2.013885000 discovery akhir 2.024769470 waktu discovery 2.013885000 waktu discovery 2.024769470 2
discovery awal 0.000000000 17
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 2.024010114 discovery akhir 2.036278672 waktu discovery 2.024010114 waktu discovery 2.036278672 3
discovery awal 0.000000000 18
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 2.026209201 discovery akhir 2.024769470 waktu discovery 2.026209201 waktu discovery 2.024769470 4
discovery awal 0.000000000 19
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 2.049428915 discovery akhir 2.024667736 waktu discovery 2.049428915 waktu discovery 2.024667736
5
discovery awal 0.000000000 20
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 2.032184070 discovery akhir 2.031472131 waktu discovery 2.032184070 waktu discovery 2.031472131 6
discovery awal 0.000000000 21
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 2.025741039 discovery akhir 2.022575033 waktu discovery 2.025741039 waktu discovery 2.022575033 7
discovery awal 0.000000000 22
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 2.021212245 discovery akhir 2.023714766 waktu discovery 2.021212245 waktu discovery 2.023714766 8
discovery awal 0.000000000 23
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 2.035738272 discovery akhir 2.024985860 waktu discovery 2.035738272 waktu discovery 2.024985860 9
discovery awal 0.000000000 24
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 2.021212245 discovery akhir 2.059432129 waktu discovery 2.021212245 waktu discovery 2.059432129 10
discovery awal 0.000000000 25
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 2.032958040 discovery akhir 2.022575033 waktu discovery 2.032958040 waktu discovery 2.022575033 11
discovery awal 0.000000000 26
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 2.039492252 discovery akhir 2.040584369 waktu discovery 2.039492252 waktu discovery 2.040584369 12
discovery awal 0.000000000 27
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 2.018898875 discovery akhir 2.024769470 waktu discovery 2.018898875 waktu discovery 2.024769470 13
discovery awal 0.000000000 28
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 2.022367693 discovery akhir 2.040584369 waktu discovery 2.022367693 waktu discovery 2.040584369 14
discovery awal 0.000000000 29
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 2.022492522 discovery akhir 2.023714766 waktu discovery 2.022492522 waktu discovery 2.023714766 15
discovery awal 0.000000000 30
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 2.043275503 discovery akhir 2.024985864 waktu discovery 2.043275503 waktu discovery 2.024985864
9. Hasil Pengujian OLSR Skenario 2 discovery akhir 6.350048345 discovery akhir 6.079399836 waktu discovery 6.350048345 waktu discovery 6.079399836 2
discovery awal 0.000000000 17
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 6.236238878 discovery akhir 6.338940734 waktu discovery 6.236238878 waktu discovery 6.338940734 3
discovery awal 0.000000000 18
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 6.415404284 discovery akhir 5.980424863 waktu discovery 6.415404284 waktu discovery 5.980424863 4
discovery awal 0.000000000 19
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 6.335443558 discovery akhir 6.202024836 waktu discovery 6.335443558 waktu discovery 6.202024836 5
discovery awal 0.000000000 20
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 6.403455233 discovery akhir 6.236238878 waktu discovery 6.403455233 waktu discovery 6.236238878 6
discovery awal 0.000000000 21
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 6.062434979 discovery akhir 6.236238878 waktu discovery 6.062434979 waktu discovery 6.236238878 7
discovery awal 0.000000000 22
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 6.045453454 discovery akhir 6.415404284 waktu discovery 6.045453454 waktu discovery 6.415404284 8
discovery awal 0.000000000 23
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 5.828139266 discovery akhir 5.980424863 waktu discovery 5.828139266 waktu discovery 5.980424863 9
discovery awal 0.000000000 24
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 6.326083376 discovery akhir 6.400200817 waktu discovery 6.326083376 waktu discovery 6.400200817 10
discovery awal 0.000000000 25
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 5.911182654 discovery akhir 6.390200817 waktu discovery 5.911182654 waktu discovery 6.390200817 11
discovery awal 0.000000000 26
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 5.902167625 discovery akhir 6.390200817 waktu discovery 5.902167625 waktu discovery 6.390200817 12
discovery awal 0.000000000 27
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 6.338940734 discovery akhir 6.332202148 waktu discovery 6.338940734 waktu discovery 6.332202148
13
discovery awal 0.000000000 28
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 6.314343332 discovery akhir 6.327502148 waktu discovery 6.314343332 waktu discovery 6.327502148 14
discovery awal 0.000000000 29
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 6.294338743 discovery akhir 6.336377349 waktu discovery 6.294338743 waktu discovery 6.336377349 15
discovery awal 0.000000000 30
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 6.079399836 discovery akhir 6.363950454 waktu discovery 6.079399836 waktu discovery 6.363950454
10. Hasil Pengujian ZRP Skenario 2
KETERANGAN ZRP KETERANGAN ZRP
1
discovery awal 0.000000000 16
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 5.406629141 discovery akhir 5.689845868 waktu discovery 5.406629141 waktu discovery 5.689845868 2
discovery awal 0.000000000 17
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 5.819260821 discovery akhir 5.602062670 waktu discovery 5.819260821 waktu discovery 5.602062670 3
discovery awal 0.000000000 18
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 5.763796903 discovery akhir 5.268511554 waktu discovery 5.763796903 waktu discovery 5.268511554 4
discovery awal 0.000000000 19
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 5.184330000 discovery akhir 5.840024103 waktu discovery 5.184330000 waktu discovery 5.840024103 5
discovery awal 0.000000000 20
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 5.376836703 discovery akhir 5.662174534 waktu discovery 5.376836703 waktu discovery 5.662174534 6
discovery awal 0.000000000 21
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 5.526410496 discovery akhir 5.461841237 waktu discovery 5.526410496 waktu discovery 5.461841237 7
discovery awal 0.000000000 22
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 5.390549841 discovery akhir 5.718549190 waktu discovery 5.390549841 waktu discovery 5.718549190 8
discovery awal 0.000000000 23
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 5.393957841 discovery akhir 5.198682947 waktu discovery 5.393957841 waktu discovery 5.198682947
9
discovery awal 0.000000000 24
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 5.240909124 discovery akhir 5.817375887 waktu discovery 5.240909124 waktu discovery 5.817375887 10
discovery awal 0.000000000 25
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 5.434787899 discovery akhir 5.660674716 waktu discovery 5.434787899 waktu discovery 5.660674716 11
discovery awal 0.000000000 26
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 5.581746110 discovery akhir 5.660674716 waktu discovery 5.581746110 waktu discovery 5.660674716 12
discovery awal 0.000000000 27
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 5.683440498 discovery akhir 5.795867269 waktu discovery 5.683440498 waktu discovery 5.795867269 13
discovery awal 0.000000000 28
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 5.413144915 discovery akhir 5.617052704 waktu discovery 5.413144915 waktu discovery 5.617052704 14
discovery awal 0.000000000 29
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 5.769095515 discovery akhir 5.589547727 waktu discovery 5.769095515 waktu discovery 5.589547727 15
discovery awal 0.000000000 30
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 5.803648699 discovery akhir 5.727488717 waktu discovery 5.803648699 waktu discovery 5.727488717
11. Hasil Pengujian AODV Skenario 3
KETERANGAN AODV KETERANGAN AODV
1
discovery awal 0.000000000 16
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 2.046020997 discovery akhir 2.047530648 waktu discovery 2.046020997 waktu discovery 2.047530648 2
discovery awal 0.000000000 17
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 2.049296797 discovery akhir 2.047530648 waktu discovery 2.049296797 waktu discovery 2.047530648 3
discovery awal 0.000000000 18
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 2.051979606 discovery akhir 2.045916133 waktu discovery 2.051979606 waktu discovery 2.045916133 4
discovery awal 0.000000000 19
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 2.046555916 discovery akhir 2.047530619 waktu discovery 2.046555916 waktu discovery 2.047530619 5 discovery awal 0.000000000
20 discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 2.051550977 discovery akhir 2.051664267
waktu discovery 2.051550977 waktu discovery 2.051664267 6
discovery awal 0.000000000 21
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 2.047398959 discovery akhir 2.051461588 waktu discovery 2.047398959 waktu discovery 2.051461588 7
discovery awal 0.000000000 22
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 2.042456880 discovery akhir 2.046471193 waktu discovery 2.042456880 waktu discovery 2.046471193 8
discovery awal 0.000000000 23
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 2.047772219 discovery akhir 2.049122429 waktu discovery 2.047772219 waktu discovery 2.049122429 9
discovery awal 0.000000000 24
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 2.045428591 discovery akhir 2.049122429 waktu discovery 2.045428591 waktu discovery 2.049122429 10
discovery awal 0.000000000 25
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 2.042456879 discovery akhir 2.047426694 waktu discovery 2.042456879 waktu discovery 2.047426694 11
discovery awal 0.000000000 26
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 2.050940537 discovery akhir 2.043524890 waktu discovery 2.050940537 waktu discovery 2.043524890 12
discovery awal 0.000000000 27
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 2.045428591 discovery akhir 2.044470409 waktu discovery 2.045428591 waktu discovery 2.044470409 13
discovery awal 0.000000000 28
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 2.043508090 discovery akhir 2.045404624 waktu discovery 2.043508090 waktu discovery 2.045404624 14
discovery awal 0.000000000 29
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 2.048222659 discovery akhir 2.050833151 waktu discovery 2.048222659 waktu discovery 2.050833151 15
discovery awal 0.000000000 30
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 2.015975221 discovery akhir 2.051664043 waktu discovery 2.015975221 waktu discovery 2.051664043
12. Hasil Pengujian OLSR Skenario 3 discovery akhir 6.415404284 discovery akhir 6.139783221 waktu discovery 6.415404284 waktu discovery 6.139783221 2
discovery awal 0.000000000 17
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 6.031224287 discovery akhir 6.139783221 waktu discovery 6.031224287 waktu discovery 6.139783221 3
discovery awal 0.000000000 18
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 5.980422863 discovery akhir 6.235344278 waktu discovery 5.980422863 waktu discovery 6.235344278 4
discovery awal 0.000000000 19
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 6.407504284 discovery akhir 6.415404284 waktu discovery 6.407504284 waktu discovery 6.415404284 5
discovery awal 0.000000000 20
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 6.314404284 discovery akhir 6.236238878 waktu discovery 6.314404284 waktu discovery 6.236238878 6
discovery awal 0.000000000 21
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 6.406434625 discovery akhir 6.400200817 waktu discovery 6.406434625 waktu discovery 6.400200817 7
discovery awal 0.000000000 22
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 6.364785363 discovery akhir 6.403472819 waktu discovery 6.364785363 waktu discovery 6.403472819 8
discovery awal 0.000000000 23
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 6.417338459 discovery akhir 6.400422211 waktu discovery 6.417338459 waktu discovery 6.400422211 9
discovery awal 0.000000000 24
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 6.417988459 discovery akhir 6.391634366 waktu discovery 6.417988459 waktu discovery 6.391634366 10
discovery awal 0.000000000 25
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 6.387356759 discovery akhir 6.403235452 waktu discovery 6.387356759 waktu discovery 6.403235452 11
discovery awal 0.000000000 26
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 6.406787669 discovery akhir 6.409436171 waktu discovery 6.406787669 waktu discovery 6.409436171 12
discovery awal 0.000000000 27
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 6.415443131 discovery akhir 6.406811772 waktu discovery 6.415443131 waktu discovery 6.406811772
13
discovery awal 0.000000000 28
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 6.412342687 discovery akhir 6.123456773 waktu discovery 6.412342687 waktu discovery 6.123456773 14
discovery awal 0.000000000 29
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 6.236238878 discovery akhir 6.123444753 waktu discovery 6.236238878 waktu discovery 6.123444753 15
discovery awal 0.000000000 30
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 6.216238878 discovery akhir 6.230291012 waktu discovery 6.216238878 waktu discovery 6.230291012
13. Hasil Pengujian ZRP Skenario 3
KETERANGAN ZRP KETERANGAN ZRP
1
discovery awal 0.000000000 16
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 5.611608613 discovery akhir 5.667560252 waktu discovery 5.611608613 waktu discovery 5.667560252 2
discovery awal 0.000000000 17
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 5.783563820 discovery akhir 5.473334367 waktu discovery 5.783563820 waktu discovery 5.473334367 3
discovery awal 0.000000000 18
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 5.533101864 discovery akhir 5.347582568 waktu discovery 5.533101864 waktu discovery 5.347582568 4
discovery awal 0.000000000 19
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 5.772636409 discovery akhir 5.384727646 waktu discovery 5.772636409 waktu discovery 5.384727646 5
discovery awal 0.000000000 20
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 5.533101864 discovery akhir 5.384727646 waktu discovery 5.533101864 waktu discovery 5.384727646 6
discovery awal 0.000000000 21
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 5.533901864 discovery akhir 5.966500614 waktu discovery 5.533901864 waktu discovery 5.966500614 7
discovery awal 0.000000000 22
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 5.532654723 discovery akhir 5.520309329 waktu discovery 5.532654723 waktu discovery 5.520309329 8
discovery awal 0.000000000 23
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 5.347582568 discovery akhir 5.810074715 waktu discovery 5.347582568 waktu discovery 5.810074715
9
discovery awal 0.000000000 24
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 5.788731417 discovery akhir 5.250314051 waktu discovery 5.788731417 waktu discovery 5.250314051 10
discovery awal 0.000000000 25
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 5.702613794 discovery akhir 5.191267909 waktu discovery 5.702613794 waktu discovery 5.191267909 11
discovery awal 0.000000000 26
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 5.475825553 discovery akhir 5.191423432 waktu discovery 5.475825553 waktu discovery 5.191423432 12
discovery awal 0.000000000 27
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 5.785465098 discovery akhir 5.520465233 waktu discovery 5.785465098 waktu discovery 5.520465233 13
discovery awal 0.000000000 28
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 5.618628467 discovery akhir 5.520572231 waktu discovery 5.618628467 waktu discovery 5.520572231 14
discovery awal 0.000000000 29
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 5.825609018 discovery akhir 5.391393028 waktu discovery 5.825609018 waktu discovery 5.391393028 15
discovery awal 0.000000000 30
discovery awal 0.000000000 discovery akhir 5.919652255 discovery akhir 5.853186620 waktu discovery 5.919652255 waktu discovery 5.853186620